ML21070A431
| ML21070A431 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 03/11/2021 |
| From: | Annette Vietti-Cook NRC/SECY |
| To: | US Federal Judiciary, Court of Appeals, for the District of Columbia Circuit |
| References | |
| 1889444, 21-1037, 21-1084 | |
| Download: ML21070A431 (49) | |
Text
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 1 of 49 IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT STATE OF NEW YORK , )
Petitioner, )
)
- v. ) No. 21-1037, consolidated with
) Nos. 21-1080, 21-1084 UNITED STATES NUCLEAR )
REGULATORY COMMISSION and )
the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, )
Respondents. )
CERTIFIED INDEX OF THE RECORD I hereby certify that the documents listed on the attached index constitute the record for Order CLI-21-01 issued by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) on January 15, 2021; and the NRCs Orders, issued on November 23, 2020, (a) approving transfer of the NRC licenses for the Indian Point Nuclear Generating Station; and (b) granting Holtec Decommissioning International, LLCs request for exemption from certain NRC regulations pertaining to the use of the Indian Point Nuclear Generating Stations nuclear decommissioning trust funds.
Respectfully Submitted, Annette Digitally signed by Annette L.
L. Vietti- Vietti-Cook Date:
Cook 2021.03.11 10:12:19 -05'00' Annette L. Vietti-Cook Secretary of the Commission Dated at Rockville, Maryland this 11th day of March 2021
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 2 of 49 CERTIFIED INDEX OF THE RECORD FOR INDIAN POINT NUC. GEN. STATION, UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI (NRC Docket Nos.50-003, 247, 286-LT, 72-051-LT)
STATE OF NEW YORK v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER Post Shutdown Decommissioning Activities Report 1 including Site-Specific Decommissioning Cost Estimate for 12/19/2019 ML19354A698 Indian Point Nuclear Generating Units 1, 2, and 3 Indian Point Nuclear Generating Units 1, 2 and 3 -
Supplement to Application for Order Consenting to 2 01/17/2020 ML20017A290 Transfers of Control of Licenses and Approving Conforming License Amendments 85 FR 3947; Consideration of Approval of Transfer of Control of 3 01/23/2020 January 23, Licenses and Conforming Amendments 2020 Petition by Safe Energy Rights Group, Inc. (SEnRG) and 4 02/11/2020 ML20042C984 Request for Hearing Petition of the State of New York for Leave to Intervene 5 02/12/2020 ML20043E118 and for a Hearing Declaration of Warren K. Brewer in Support of New York 6 02/12/2020 ML20043E121 Petition Declaration of Daniel J. Evans in Support of New York 7 02/12/2020 ML20043E122 Petition Declaration of George W. Heitzman in Support of New 8 02/05/2020 ML20043E123 York Petition Declaration of Alyse L. Peterson in Support of New York 9 02/10/2020 ML20043E125 Petition Declaration of Timothy B. Rice in Support of New York 10 02/12/2020 ML20043E126 Petition Page 1 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 3 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER Declaration of Chiara Trabucchi in Support of New York 11 02/12/2020 ML20043E128 Petition Petition by the Town of Cortlandt, Village of Buchanan, 12 and Hendrick Hudson School District's for Leave to 02/12/2020 ML20043F054 Intervene and Hearing Request 13 Petition of Riverkeeper, Inc. to Intervene and for a Hearing 02/12/2020 ML20043F530 HDI Request for Exemptions from 10 CFR 50.82(a)(8)(i)(A) and 10 CFR 50.75(h)(1)(iv), attached to 14 02/12/2020 ML20043C539 Letter from Andrea L. Sterdis, HDI, to NRC Document Control Desk Memorandum to Petitioners Regarding Commissioner Jeff 15 02/18/2020 ML20049A104 Baran Site Visit.
Letters from Secretary Annette Vietti-Cook to Senators 16 Schumer and Gillibrand and Representatives Lowey, 02/18/2020 ML20049H336 Engel and Maloney Letter from NRC Secretary to Alden Wolfe, Chairman of 17 02/20/2020 ML20054B993 the Rockland County New York Legislature, et al Letter from NRC Secretary to Benjamin Boykin, Chairman 18 of the Westchester County New York Board of Legislators, 02/26/2020 ML20057F128 et al Letter from NRC Secretary to Assemblywoman Sandy 19 02/28/2020 ML20059N684 Galef of the New York State 95th Assembly District Order (Denying Improper Requests for Adjudicatory 20 03/05/2020 ML20065M353 Hearing)
Notices of Appearance for Peter LeJeune, Alan Lovett, 21 Jason Tompkins and William Gill, IV on behalf of Holtec 03/09/2020 ML20069G163 International.
Page 2 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 4 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER Notices of Appearance of William Glew, Jr., Susan Raimo, 22 John Matthews, Paul Bessette on behalf of Entergy 03/09/2020 ML20069G709 Nuclear Operations.
Applicants' Answer Opposing Petition for Leave to 23 Intervene and Hearing Request Filed by the State of New 03/09/2020 ML20069K756 York Applicants' Answer Opposing Petition for Leave to Intervene and Hearing Request Filed by the Town of 24 03/09/2020 ML20069K761 Cortlandt Village of Buchanan and Hendrick Hudson School District Applicants' Answer Opposing Safe Energy Rights Group 25 03/09/2020 ML20069K765 Letter Requesting a Hearing Applicants' Answer Opposing Riverkeeper Inc.'s Petition to 26 03/09/2020 ML20069L613 Intervene and for a Hearing Notices of Appearance for Joshua M. Tallent, Lisa M.
27 Burianek, and Channing Wistar-Jones on behalf of the 03/11/2020 ML20071D721 State of New York Unopposed Motion of the State of New York for an 28 03/11/2020 ML20071D839 Enlargement of Time to File Its Reply Notices of Appearance of Daniel Riesel and Phillip Dane 29 Warren on behalf of the Town of Cortlandt, Village of 03/11/2020 ML20071J931 Buchanan, Hendrick Hudson School District Unopposed Motion of the Town of Cortlandt, Village of 30 Buchanan and Hendrick Hudson School District for an 03/11/2020 ML20071J972 Enlargement of Time to File its Reply.
Notice of Appearance of Todd D. Ommen on behalf of 31 03/12/2020 ML20072K218 Riverkeeper Unopposed Motion of Riverkeeper, Inc. for an 32 03/12/2020 ML20072K286 Enlargement of Time to File Its Reply.
Page 3 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 5 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 33 Order (Granting Motions for Extension of Time) 03/12/2020 ML20072N979 Town of Cortlandt, Village of Buchanan, and Hendrick Hudson School District's Reply Memorandum in Further 34 03/20/2020 ML20080K697 Support of Petition for Leave to Intervene and Hearing Request Attachment A to Town of Cortlandt, et al, 03/20/2020 35 Reply Memorandum in Support of Petition for Leave to 11/21/2019 ML20080K700 Intervene and Hearing Request.
Petitioner Riverkeeper, Inc.'s Reply Memorandum in 36 03/23/2020 ML20083G736 Further Support of Petition to Intervene and for a Hearing.
Reply in Support of the State of New York's Petition for 37 03/23/2020 ML20083K846 Leave to Intervene and for a Hearing New York State Motion for Leave to Amend Contentions 38 03/24/2020 ML20084Q191 NY-2 and NY-3.
Supplemental Declaration of Chiara Trabucchi in Support 39 of New York State Motion to Amend Contentions NY-2 and 03/24/2020 ML20084Q197 NY-3.
Big Rock Point; Indian Point Units 1, 2, and 3; and 40 Palisades - Decommissioning Funding Status Report per 03/26/2020 ML20086Q904 10 CFR 50.75(f)(1) and 10 CFR 50.82(a)(8)(v).
Applicants' Answer to the State of New York's Motion for 41 04/20/2020 ML20111A329 Leave to Amend Contentions NY-2 and NY-3 Reply in Support of New York State's Motion for Leave to 42 04/27/2020 ML20118D012 Amend Contentions NY-2 and NY-3 Page 4 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 6 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER Holtec Decommissioning International, LLC - Responses to NRC Requests for Additional Information (RAI) Re the 43 08/07/2020 ML20220A666 Request for Indian Point Nuclear Generating Station Units 1, 2 & 3 State of New York's Supplemental Comments in 44 Opposition to Holtec's February 12, 2020 Request for 10/07/2020 ML20281A635 Exemptions.
Notice of Withdrawal of John E. Matthews on behalf of 45 10/09/2020 ML20283A406 Entergy Nuclear Operations Motion of Riverkeeper, Inc. to Supplement the Basis of Its 46 10/20/2020 ML20294A326 Contention With New Evidence not Previsously Available Resubmission of Motion of Riverkeeper, Inc. to 47 Supplement the Basis for Its Contention with New 10/20/2020 ML20296A283 Evidence not Previously Available (technical correction)
Letter from NRC Secretary to Indian Point License 48 10/27/2020 ML20301A383 Transfer Matter Parties 49 Letter from NRC Secretary to Senator Schumer, et al 10/28/2020 ML20302A336 Motion of Riverkeeper, Inc. for Full Adjudication of Its 50 Pending Contention Prior to Any Decision by NRC on the 11/06/2020 ML20311A660 License Transfer Declaration of David Lochbaum in Support of Riverkeeper's Motion for Full Adjudication of Its Pending 51 11/06/2020 ML20311A661 Contention Prior to Any Decision by NRC on the License Transfer.
85 FR 71664; Environmental Assessment and Finding of No Significant 52 11/10/2020 November 10, Impact 2020 Page 5 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 7 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER Applicants' Answer Opposing Riverkeeper's Motion to 53 11/12/2020 ML20317A296 Supplement the Basis of Its Contention Applicants' Answer Opposing Riverkeeper's November 6, 54 11/12/2020 ML20317A329 2020 Motion Notification re Notification of Significant Licensing Action 55 11/16/2020 ML20321A227 (NSLA)
Notification of Significant Licensing Action - Proposed 56 Issuance of an Order Approving a License Transfer 11/16/2020 ML20321A228 Application For Which A Hearing Has Been Requested Letter from the NRC Executive Director for Operations to 57 Senators Schumer and Gillibrand, and Representatives 11/20/2020 ML20325A224 Lowey, Engel, and Maloney Notice of Appearance for Jeremy L. Wachutka on behalf 58 11/23/2020 ML20328A222 of NRC Staff Approval of Exemption Request, Letter from Richard V.
59 Guzman, NRC, to Andrea L Sterdis, Holtec 11/23/2020 ML20309A577 Decommissioning International, LLC Indian Point Nuclear Generating Unit Nos. 1, 2, and 3 -
Letter with Order Approving the Transfer of IPEC Facility 60 Licenses to Holtec International, Owner, and Holtec 11/23/2020 ML20297A321 Decommissioning International, LLC, Operator (EPID L-2019-LLM-0003)
Indian Point Nuclear Generating Unit Nos. 1, 2, and 3 -
Enclosure 1, Order Approving Transfer of Facility 61 Operating Licenses to Holtec International, Owner, and 11/23/2020 ML20297A325 Holtec Decommissioning International, LLC, Operator (EPID L-2019-LLM-0003)
Page 6 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 8 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER Indian Point Nuclear Generating Unit Nos. 1, 2, and 3 -
Enclosure 2, Draft Conforming Amendments for Transfer 62 of Facility Operating Licenses to Holtec International, 11/23/2020 ML20297A326 Owner, and Holtec Decommissioning International, LLC, Operator (EPID L-2019-LLM-0003)
Indian Point Nuclear Generating Unit Nos. 1, 2, and 3 -
Enclosure 3, Safety Evaluation for Transfer of Renewed 63 Facility Operating Licenses to Holtec International, Owner, 11/23/2020 ML20297A333 and Holtec Decommissioning International, LLC, Operator (EPID L-2019-LLM-0003) 64 Commission Notification Regarding Issuance of Order 11/23/2020 ML20328A223 Letter from NRC Secretary to New York State Department 65 of Public Service Deputy General Counsel John Sipos and 11/25/2020 ML20330A254 Assistant Counsel Ryan Coyne 66 Commission Memorandum and Order (CLI-21-01). 01/15/2021 ML21015A201 67 Comment from Joel Gingold 01/31/2020 ML20050N670 Comment from Joseph Hochreiter on behalf of Hendrick 68 02/07/2020 ML20063L685 Hudson School District 69 Comment from Bruce Rosen 02/10/2020 ML20054B444 Comment from Assemblyman Thomas Abinanti on behalf 70 02/10/2020 ML20063L683 of the 92nd District of New York Page 7 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 9 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 71 Comment from Brian Fitzpatrick 02/11/2020 ML20044G103 72 Comment from Courtney Williams 02/11/2020 ML20052E506 73 Comment from Sally Gellert 02/11/2020 ML20054B411 74 Comment from Courtney Williams 02/11/2020 ML20054B449 75 Comment from Darrell Corti 02/12/2020 ML20044G097 76 Comment from J Best 02/12/2020 ML20044G098 77 Comment from Lynn Mastroddi 02/12/2020 ML20044G100 78 Comment from Anonymous 02/12/2020 ML20054B442 79 Comment from Anonymous 02/12/2020 ML20054B443 80 Comment from Cora Impenna 02/12/2020 ML20054B448 81 Comment from Daniel Frome 02/12/2020 ML20054B451 Page 8 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 10 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 82 Comment from James Phelan 02/12/2020 ML20054B454 83 Comment from Mariella Vargas 02/12/2020 ML20057F699 84 Comment from Anonymous 02/12/2020 ML20057F705 85 Comment from Courtney Nandagiri 02/12/2020 ML20057F708 86 Comment from Robert May 02/13/2020 ML20044G101 87 Comment from Robyn Ruina 02/13/2020 ML20044G102 88 Comment from Dylan Basescu 02/13/2020 ML20050L281 89 Comment from Jennifer Horowitz 02/13/2020 ML20054B457 90 Comment from Polly Bijur 02/13/2020 ML20054B470 91 Comment from Mary Grenough 02/13/2020 ML20058E948 92 Comment from Michelle Babian 02/13/2020 ML20058E950 Page 9 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 11 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 93 Comment from Mitchell Miller 02/13/2020 ML20058E951 94 Comment from Molly Mosher 02/13/2020 ML20058E954 95 Comment from Monika Half 02/13/2020 ML20058E956 96 Comment from Nell Cox 02/13/2020 ML20058E957 97 Comment from Pamela Hudson 02/13/2020 ML20058E960 98 Comment from Patricia Young 02/13/2020 ML20058E961 99 Comment from Robert Puca 02/13/2020 ML20058E963 100 Comment from Robin Meadows 02/13/2020 ML20058E965 101 Comment from Russ Demarest 02/13/2020 ML20058E967 102 Comment from Stan Jacobs 02/13/2020 ML20058E969 103 Comment from Susan Hayward 02/13/2020 ML20058E971 Page 10 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 12 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 104 Comment from Ted Sabety 02/13/2020 ML20058E972 105 Comment from Theresa Kardos 02/13/2020 ML20058E973 106 Comment from Wendy Fast 02/13/2020 ML20058E974 107 Comment from Adele Pascucci 02/13/2020 ML20058E976 108 Comment from Allan Goldhammer 02/13/2020 ML20058E978 109 Comment from Bob Stein 02/13/2020 ML20058E980 110 Comment from Candance Balmer 02/13/2020 ML20058E981 111 Comment from Carl Grimm 02/13/2020 ML20058E985 112 Comment from Carol Milano 02/13/2020 ML20058E989 113 Comment from Carol Seaver 02/13/2020 ML20058E990 114 Comment from Cathy Carnevale 02/13/2020 ML20058E992 Page 11 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 13 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 115 Comment from Christopher Esposito 02/13/2020 ML20058E993 116 Comment from Cristina Ramos-Payne 02/13/2020 ML20058E995 117 Comment from Deidre Moderacki 02/13/2020 ML20058E996 118 Comment from Edward Brody 02/13/2020 ML20058E998 119 Comment from Frances and Gregory Jacobson 02/13/2020 ML20058E999 120 Comment from Fred Robin 02/13/2020 ML20058F002 121 Comment from Grace Gordon 02/13/2020 ML20058F004 122 Comment from James Desmond 02/13/2020 ML20058F006 123 Comment from James Mulder 02/13/2020 ML20058F007 124 Comment from Jill McManus 02/13/2020 ML20058F008 125 Comment from Kathie Mock 02/13/2020 ML20058F009 Page 12 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 14 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 126 Comment from Liz Wassell 02/13/2020 ML20058F010 127 Comment from Maria Ragucci 02/13/2020 ML20058F012 128 Comment from Marion Lakatos 02/13/2020 ML20058F014 129 Comment from Gerald Ravnitzky 02/14/2020 ML20052E411 130 Comment from Jay Forbes 02/14/2020 ML20054A031 131 Comment from Fred Polvere 02/14/2020 ML20054B453 132 Comment from Robert May 02/14/2020 ML20054B473 133 Comment from Norman Rosenberg 02/14/2020 ML20058G750 134 Comment from Philip Viola 02/14/2020 ML20058G751 135 Comment from Robin Alpern 02/14/2020 ML20058G752 136 Comment from Robin Knauth 02/14/2020 ML20058G753 Page 13 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 15 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 137 Comment from Susan Schwarz 02/14/2020 ML20058G755 138 Comment from Tracey Jordan 02/14/2020 ML20058G757 139 Comment from Amy Anderson 02/14/2020 ML20058G759 140 Comment from Charles Zekus 02/14/2020 ML20058G761 141 Comment from Daniel White 02/14/2020 ML20058G763 142 Comment from Gail Hovey 02/14/2020 ML20058G764 143 Comment from Gail Moran 02/14/2020 ML20058G765 144 Comment from Jean Naples 02/14/2020 ML20058G766 145 Comment from Jerold Huebner 02/14/2020 ML20058G767 146 Comment from Joan Gussow 02/14/2020 ML20058G768 147 Comment from K.P. Muller 02/14/2020 ML20058G769 Page 14 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 16 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 148 Comment from Katherine Desmond 02/14/2020 ML20058G770 149 Comment from Linda and Larry Queipo 02/14/2020 ML20058G774 150 Comment from Lisa Harrison 02/14/2020 ML20058G776 151 Comment from Lucile Hamlin 02/14/2020 ML20058G780 152 Comment from Lynn Bowdery 02/14/2020 ML20058G781 153 Comment from Naomi Woodard 02/14/2020 ML20058G783 154 Comment from Elizabeth Peterson 02/14/2020 ML20072M657 155 Comment from Susan Van Dolsen 02/15/2020 ML20054A030 156 Comment from Edith Kantrowitz 02/15/2020 ML20054B452 157 Comment from Judith Canepa 02/15/2020 ML20054B461 158 Comment from Leslie English 02/15/2020 ML20058H117 Page 15 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 17 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 159 Comment from Martin Lupowitz 02/15/2020 ML20058H118 160 Comment from Cherie Raglin 02/16/2020 ML20050M260 161 Comment from Sheryl Lerner 02/16/2020 ML20050M883 162 Comment from John Cavuoto 02/16/2020 ML20054B458 163 Comment from Peter Arno 02/16/2020 ML20054B467 164 Comment from Iris Arno 02/16/2020 ML20058H106 165 Comment from Vincent Ferri 02/16/2020 ML20058H124 166 Comment from Doretta Cornell 02/16/2020 ML20058H136 167 Comment from Elaine Weir 02/16/2020 ML20058H138 168 Comment from Linda DeStefano 02/17/2020 ML20050M905 169 Comment from Felicia Tavares 02/17/2020 ML20050N390 Page 16 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 18 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 170 Comment from Joan Gussow 02/17/2020 ML20052E413 171 Comment from Sally Jones 02/17/2020 ML20054B416 172 Comment from Susan Van Dolsen 02/17/2020 ML20054B437 173 Comment from Suzannah Glidden 02/17/2020 ML20054B438 174 Comment from Victor Tiship 02/17/2020 ML20054B440 175 Comment from Bryan Dunlap 02/17/2020 ML20054B446 176 Comment from Jean Fallon 02/17/2020 ML20054B455 177 Comment from Kelly Lundeen 02/17/2020 ML20054B464 178 Comment from Peter Gollon 02/17/2020 ML20054B469 179 Comment from Lance Haug 02/17/2020 ML20058H111 180 Comment from Wendy Whetsel 02/17/2020 ML20066G809 Page 17 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 19 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 181 Comment from Paul Corell 02/17/2020 ML20066G811 182 Comment from Alice Slater 02/17/2020 ML20066G814 183 Comment from Julie Woodward 02/17/2020 ML20066G816 184 Comment from Nivo Rovedo 02/17/2020 ML20066G818 185 Comment from Judy Allen 02/17/2020 ML20066G820 186 Comment from Alex Stavis 02/17/2020 ML20066G821 187 Comment from Pat Schories 02/18/2020 ML20052E405 188 Comment from Janine Melillo 02/18/2020 ML20054A026 189 Comment from Susan Montemorano 02/18/2020 ML20054A027 190 Comment from Tom Siracuse 02/18/2020 ML20054A028 191 Comment from Thomas Siracuse 02/18/2020 ML20054A029 Page 18 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 20 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 192 Comment from Anne Carter 02/18/2020 ML20054B441 193 Comment from Martha Saxton 02/18/2020 ML20054B466 194 Comment from Richard Fennelly 02/18/2020 ML20054B472 195 Comment from Michael Hamilton 02/18/2020 ML20058H119 196 Comment from Harvey Weiss 02/18/2020 ML20058H139 197 Comment from Vicki McFadyen 02/18/2020 ML20063L711 198 Comment from Ramona Harragin 02/18/2020 ML20063L712 199 Comment from Catherine Skopic 02/19/2020 ML20052E408 200 Comment from Catherine Skopic 02/19/2020 ML20054B447 201 Comment from Dale Saltzman 02/19/2020 ML20054B450 202 Comment from Nancy Brown 02/19/2020 ML20058H121 Page 19 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 21 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 203 Comment from Alisa Eilenberg 02/19/2020 ML20058H125 204 Comment from Andy Stein 02/19/2020 ML20066G822 205 Comment from John Reynolds 02/19/2020 ML20066G824 206 Comment from Donna Knipp 02/19/2020 ML20066G826 207 Comment from John Dunn 02/20/2020 ML20052E400 208 Comment from Jordan Dale 02/20/2020 ML20052E402 209 Comment from Laura Lynch 02/20/2020 ML20052E404 210 Comment from Arelene Novich 02/20/2020 ML20052E407 211 Comment from Don Hawkins 02/20/2020 ML20052E410 212 Comment from Robert Emerick 02/20/2020 ML20054A032 213 Comment from John Sullivan 02/20/2020 ML20054B460 Page 20 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 22 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 214 Comment from Judy Jacobs 02/20/2020 ML20054B462 215 Comment from S. Anspach 02/20/2020 ML20054B475 216 Comment from Jan Boudart 02/20/2020 ML20058H108 217 Comment from Russell Faller 02/20/2020 ML20058H122 218 Comment from Kara Uleman 02/20/2020 ML20062G094 219 Comment from Susan Spieler 02/20/2020 ML20066G807 220 Comment from Nydia Leaf, et al 02/20/2020 ML20066G828 221 Comment from Iris Arno 02/21/2020 ML20052E559 222 Comment from Jacquelyn Dreshler 02/21/2020 ML20052E560 223 Comment from Lynda Scneekloth 02/21/2020 ML20052E561 224 Comment from Erin Macchiaroli 02/21/2020 ML20052E609 Page 21 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 23 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 225 Comment from Robert Conticchio 02/21/2020 ML20055G106 226 Comment from Sally Gellert 02/21/2020 ML20055G109 227 Comment from Jeff Tyler 02/21/2020 ML20055G120 228 Comment from Mai Jacobs 02/21/2020 ML20055G125 229 Comment from Jackson Gillman 02/21/2020 ML20058H107 230 Comment from Jane Alcorn 02/21/2020 ML20058H109 231 Comment from Nancy Boyd 02/21/2020 ML20058H120 232 Comment from Bella Kosmacher 02/21/2020 ML20058H130 233 Comment from Naomi Schechter 02/21/2020 ML20062G058 234 Comment from Philip Van Itallie 02/21/2020 ML20062G061 235 Comment from Robert May 02/21/2020 ML20062G063 Page 22 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 24 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 236 Comment from Robin Wald 02/21/2020 ML20062G065 237 Comment from Amy Anderson 02/21/2020 ML20062G070 238 Comment from Amy Benesch 02/21/2020 ML20062G071 239 Comment from Andrea Bunch 02/21/2020 ML20062G073 240 Comment from Art Shervs 02/21/2020 ML20062G077 241 Comment from Arthur Greenberg 02/21/2020 ML20062G080 242 Comment from Benny Cipriano 02/21/2020 ML20062G081 243 Comment from Corinne Kelly 02/21/2020 ML20062G083 244 Comment from Dorothea Halliday 02/21/2020 ML20062G086 245 Comment from Frank Stoppenbach 02/21/2020 ML20062G087 246 Comment from Heidi Hutner 02/21/2020 ML20062G091 Page 23 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 25 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 247 Comment from Jamie Levato 02/21/2020 ML20062G093 248 Comment from Krystal Ford 02/21/2020 ML20062G096 249 Comment from Lori Gross 02/21/2020 ML20062G098 250 Comment from Henry Kelly 02/21/2020 ML20063L684 251 Comment from Michele Reed 02/22/2020 ML20055G101 252 Comment from Peggy Kurtz 02/22/2020 ML20055G102 253 Comment from Peter Guerrero 02/22/2020 ML20055G105 254 Comment from Robert Petrie 02/22/2020 ML20055G108 255 Comment from Carla Johnson 02/22/2020 ML20055G114 256 Comment from Chris Owens 02/22/2020 ML20055G115 257 Comment from Anne Symmes 02/22/2020 ML20058H127 Page 24 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 26 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 258 Comment from Arthur Lubow 02/22/2020 ML20058H128 259 Comment from Bente Strong 02/22/2020 ML20058H134 260 Comment from Scott Gassman 02/22/2020 ML20062G068 261 Comment from Bruce Esrig 02/22/2020 ML20062G082 262 Comment from Anne Scheinberg 02/22/2020 ML20064C570 263 Comment from Bradley Kerr 02/22/2020 ML20064C571 264 Comment from Denise Marinaccio 02/22/2020 ML20064C572 265 Comment from Dillon Reilly 02/22/2020 ML20064C574 266 Comment from Kathleen Quinn 02/22/2020 ML20064C576 267 Comment from Laura Lamash 02/22/2020 ML20064C579 268 Comment from Lori Morris 02/22/2020 ML20064C580 Page 25 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 27 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 269 Comment from Marina Gutierrez 02/22/2020 ML20064C582 270 Comment from James Sheehan 02/22/2020 ML20064D046 271 Comment from Kathleen Sweeney 02/22/2020 ML20064D049 272 Comment from Mary and Robert Reader 02/22/2020 ML20064D050 273 Comment from Mary Florin-McBride 02/22/2020 ML20064D054 274 Comment from Michael Massagli 02/22/2020 ML20064D056 275 Comment from Michael Piper 02/22/2020 ML20064D058 276 Comment from Michele Wagner-Nebbia 02/22/2020 ML20064D061 277 Comment from Nancy Gillespie 02/22/2020 ML20064D064 278 Comment from Nathaniel Lange 02/22/2020 ML20064D067 279 Comment from Raphael Kosek 02/22/2020 ML20064D068 Page 26 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 28 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 280 Comment from Amy Trompetter 02/22/2020 ML20064D069 281 Comment from Stephen Bangert 02/22/2020 ML20064D072 282 Comment from Dale Saltzman 02/22/2020 ML20064D074 283 Comment from Douglas Wehrle 02/22/2020 ML20064D077 284 Comment from Kristin Brown 02/22/2020 ML20064D079 285 Comment from Alan Levin 02/22/2020 ML20064D082 286 Comment from Cate Woodruff 02/22/2020 ML20064D083 287 Comment from Jordan Abbott 02/22/2020 ML20064D085 288 Comment from Katharine Plummer 02/22/2020 ML20064D089 289 Comment from Kathleen Thomas 02/22/2020 ML20064D092 290 Comment from Kevin Kilner 02/22/2020 ML20064D094 Page 27 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 29 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 291 Comment from Robert Morrow 02/22/2020 ML20064D097 292 Comment from William Messmer 02/22/2020 ML20064D098 293 Comment from Ann Sarrantonio 02/22/2020 ML20064D102 294 Comment from Bernard Nemes 02/22/2020 ML20064D104 295 Comment from Gary Schoenberger 02/22/2020 ML20064D106 296 Comment from Anonymous 02/22/2020 ML20066H359 297 Comment from Anonymous 02/22/2020 ML20066H361 298 Comment from Misha Fredericks 02/22/2020 ML20066H378 299 Comment from Paola Betchart 02/22/2020 ML20066H379 300 Comment from Sarah Eggleston 02/23/2020 ML20055G111 301 Comment from Anna Markowitz 02/23/2020 ML20055G112 Page 28 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 30 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 302 Comment from Daniel Lucas 02/23/2020 ML20055G117 303 Comment from Dolores Jones 02/23/2020 ML20055G118 304 Comment from Janelle Peotter 02/23/2020 ML20055G119 305 Comment from Liam Henrie 02/23/2020 ML20055G122 306 Comment from Noah Kimerling 02/23/2020 ML20057F701 307 Comment from Caryl Kottmann 02/23/2020 ML20057F707 308 Comment from Daniel Levy 02/23/2020 ML20057F710 309 Comment from Ervine Kimerling 02/23/2020 ML20057F713 310 Comment from Paula Zimmerman-Taylor 02/23/2020 ML20066H352 311 Comment from Robert Powell 02/23/2020 ML20066H353 312 Comment from Vincent Ferri 02/23/2020 ML20066H356 Page 29 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 31 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 313 Comment from Anthony Maresco 02/23/2020 ML20066H362 314 Comment from Carol Schrager 02/23/2020 ML20066H364 315 Comment from David Johnson 02/23/2020 ML20066H365 316 Comment from Deborah Dougherty 02/23/2020 ML20066H366 317 Comment from Dennis Phayre 02/23/2020 ML20066H367 318 Comment from Eric Wolf 02/23/2020 ML20066H368 319 Comment from Greg Lubow 02/23/2020 ML20066H369 320 Comment from Jeanne Casatelli 02/23/2020 ML20066H370 321 Comment from Leigh Hill 02/23/2020 ML20066H374 322 Comment from Mark Bierman 02/23/2020 ML20066H376 323 Comment from Marnie Scheinberg 02/23/2020 ML20066H377 Page 30 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 32 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 324 Comment from Ling Tsou 02/24/2020 ML20055G123 325 Comment from Laura Seitz 02/24/2020 ML20057F696 326 Comment from Puja Thomson 02/24/2020 ML20057F702 327 Comment from Rita DeMaria 02/24/2020 ML20057F703 328 Comment from Anne Bassen 02/24/2020 ML20057F704 329 Comment from Camala Projansky 02/24/2020 ML20057F706 330 Comment from Sheila Geist 02/24/2020 ML20066G808 331 Comment from Sonia Hairabedian 02/24/2020 ML20066H354 332 Comment from Sean Brennan 02/24/2020 ML20069F156 333 Comment from Jon Fein 02/24/2020 ML20069F157 334 Comment from Anonymous 02/24/2020 ML20069F160 Page 31 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 33 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 335 Comment from Anthony Nigro 02/24/2020 ML20069F163 336 Comment from Lisa Breznak 02/24/2020 ML20069F165 337 Comment from Laurie Bleich 02/24/2020 ML20069F167 338 Comment from Jay Kosack 02/25/2020 ML20057F694 339 Comment from Margaret Fort 02/25/2020 ML20057F697 340 Comment from Anonymous 02/25/2020 ML20069F169 341 Comment from Anonymous 02/25/2020 ML20069F171 342 Comment from Deborah Tompkins 02/26/2020 ML20057F712 343 Comment from Joel Gingold 02/26/2020 ML20069F172 344 Comment from Sharon Radulov 02/26/2020 ML20069F176 345 Comment from Kathy Flaherty 02/27/2020 ML20058H110 Page 32 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 34 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 346 Comment from Laurel Becker 02/27/2020 ML20058H114 347 Comment from Richard DeCrosta 02/27/2020 ML20069F175 348 Comment from Patricia Matteson 02/28/2020 ML20069F181 349 Comment from Sarah Underhill 02/28/2020 ML20069F183 350 Comment from Andi Weiss Bartczak 02/28/2020 ML20069F185 351 Comment from Elizabeth Marrapodi 02/28/2020 ML20087L849 352 Comment from Daria Greggs 02/28/2020 ML20087L851 353 Comment from Michael Green 02/29/2020 ML20069F188 354 Comment from Iris Arno 02/29/2020 ML20069F190 355 Comment from Christine Dakin 02/29/2020 ML20069F193 356 Comment from Kathie Talbot 02/29/2020 ML20069F194 Page 33 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 35 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 357 Comment from Philip Ratcliff 03/01/2020 ML20069F197 358 Comment from Anna Paritsky 03/01/2020 ML20069F200 359 Comment from David LeVine 03/02/2020 ML20069F202 360 Comment from Susan Schwarz 03/02/2020 ML20069F204 361 Comment from Carl Arnold 03/03/2020 ML20069F206 362 Comment from Wendy Fast 03/03/2020 ML20069F207 363 Comment from Walter Terrell 03/03/2020 ML20069F210 364 Comment from Donna Knipp 03/03/2020 ML20069F213 365 Comment from Anonymous 03/03/2020 ML20069F215 366 Comment from Norman Ross 03/03/2020 ML20069F218 367 Comment from Meredith Priestley 03/03/2020 ML20069F220 Page 34 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 36 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 368 Comment from Kira Peterson 03/04/2020 ML20069F121 369 Comment from Judith Fletcher 03/04/2020 ML20069F224 370 Comment from Natalie Polvere 03/04/2020 ML20069F227 371 Comment from Holly Malekian 03/04/2020 ML20069F229 372 Comment from Pat Townsend 03/05/2020 ML20069F123 373 Comment from Tracy Feldman 03/05/2020 ML20069F124 374 Comment from Linda Silversmith 03/05/2020 ML20069F128 375 Comment from Mark Grenard 03/05/2020 ML20069F131 376 Comment from Francisco Velez 03/05/2020 ML20069F134 377 Comment from Anonymous 03/05/2020 ML20069F138 378 Comment from Virginia Davis 03/05/2020 ML20069F139 Page 35 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 37 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 379 Comment from Virginia Davis 03/05/2020 ML20069F140 380 Comment from Don Smith 03/05/2020 ML20069F144 381 Comment from Melissa Frazier 03/05/2020 ML20069F147 382 Comment from Anonymous 03/05/2020 ML20069F148 383 Comment from Susi Cummings 03/05/2020 ML20069G695 384 Comment from Gabrielle Swanberg 03/06/2020 ML20069F129 385 Comment from Elizabeth Butler 03/06/2020 ML20069F151 386 Comment from Patrick Bosold 03/06/2020 ML20069F153 387 Comment from Paul Correll 03/06/2020 ML20069G698 388 Comment from Janice Rusche 03/06/2020 ML20073G970 389 Comment from John Ewing 03/06/2020 ML20073G971 Page 36 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 38 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 390 Comment from Eugene Hamond 03/06/2020 ML20086J783 391 Comment from Charlene Woodcock 03/07/2020 ML20073H003 392 Comment from Gian Ascione 03/08/2020 ML20073G967 393 Comment from Diane von Roesgen 03/10/2020 ML20073G964 394 Comment from Kate Mitchell 03/11/2020 ML20073G976 395 Comment from Katherine Becker 03/11/2020 ML20073G979 396 Comment from Marshall Kitchell 03/11/2020 ML20073G984 397 Comment from Abby Newton 03/11/2020 ML20073G988 398 Comment from Adam Scheneider 03/11/2020 ML20073G990 399 Comment from Anonymous 03/11/2020 ML20073G997 400 Comment from Ed Miller 03/12/2020 ML20073G966 Page 37 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 39 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 401 Comment from Julie ONeill 03/12/2020 ML20073G974 402 Comment from Nancy Bernstein 03/12/2020 ML20073G986 403 Comment from Alice Slater 03/12/2020 ML20073G993 404 Comment from Allan Fujita 03/12/2020 ML20073G995 405 Comment from Carol Shore 03/12/2020 ML20073H000 406 Comment from Dassi Citron 03/12/2020 ML20073H005 407 Comment from Marjory Donn 03/13/2020 ML20073G981 408 Comment from Skip Short 03/13/2020 ML20084M929 409 Comment from Jane Wong 03/15/2020 ML20084M927 410 Comment from Alma Rodriguez 03/15/2020 ML20084M928 411 Comment from M Kosstrin 03/15/2020 ML20084M935 Page 38 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 40 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 412 Comment from Philip Ratcliff 03/16/2020 ML20084M922 Comment from Barbara Warren on behalf of Citizen's 413 03/16/2020 ML20084M933 Environmental Coalition 414 Comment from Gail Moran 03/17/2020 ML20084M924 415 Comment from Jennifer Horowitz 03/19/2020 ML20084M923 416 Comment from Paula Moats 03/21/2020 ML20086N076 417 Comment from Ellen Weininger 03/24/2020 ML20085H149 418 Comment from Robert DiFrancesco 03/24/2020 ML20086N077 419 Comment from Holly Malekian 03/24/2020 ML20086N101 420 Comment from Karl Brabenec 03/24/2020 ML20086N108 421 Comment from Beverly Dyckman 03/25/2020 ML20085J346 422 Comment from Laura Seitz 03/25/2020 ML20085J347 Page 39 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 41 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 423 Comment from Tina Volz-Bongar 03/25/2020 ML20085J348 424 Comment from Bruce Campbell 03/25/2020 ML20085J349 425 Comment from Craig Wilson 03/25/2020 ML20085J350 426 Comment from Eileen Manhood-Jose 03/25/2020 ML20085J351 427 Comment from Judy Allen 03/25/2020 ML20086J784 428 Comment from Michael Lee 03/25/2020 ML20086K719 429 Comment from Victoria Leung 03/25/2020 ML20086K721 430 Comment from Laura Seitz 03/25/2020 ML20086N062 431 Comment from Manna Jo Greene 03/25/2020 ML20086N065 432 Comment from Manna Jo Greene 03/25/2020 ML20086N067 433 Comment from Nicola Coddington 03/25/2020 ML20086N070 Page 40 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 42 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 434 Comment from Noel Kropf 03/25/2020 ML20086N072 435 Comment from Sally Jane Gellert 03/25/2020 ML20086N080 436 Comment from Stephen VanderMerwe 03/25/2020 ML20086N083 437 Comment from Al Samuels 03/25/2020 ML20086N086 438 Comment from Amy Allen 03/25/2020 ML20086N091 439 Comment from Anonymous 03/25/2020 ML20086N092 440 Comment from Deborah Milone 03/25/2020 ML20086N095 441 Comment from Eric Eller 03/25/2020 ML20086N098 442 Comment from Gail Payne 03/25/2020 ML20086N100 443 Comment from John Ravitz 03/25/2020 ML20086N104 444 Comment from Kevin Byrne 03/25/2020 ML20086N963 Page 41 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 43 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 36 Form Comments from Residents Living in Close 445 Proximity to Indian Point regarding the Indian Point 03/31/2020 ML20091J918 License Transfer Application (NRC-2020-0021).
417 Form Comments from Riverkeeper Constituents to 446 Reject Holtec's PSDAR regarding the Indian Point License 03/31/2020 ML20091J919 Transfer Application (NRC-2020-0021) 8 Form Comments from Citizens Opposing the Indian 447 Point License Transfer Application (NRC-2020-0021) - 03/31/2020 ML20091L448 (Version 2).
190 Form Comments from Citizens Opposing the Indian 448 04/01/2020 ML20092G718 Point License Transfer Application (NRC-2020-0021).
449 Comment from Clare Francis 04/12/2020 ML20113F021 Comment from Armand Sabitoni on behalf of Laborers' 450 Int'l. Union of North America (LiUNA) New England 04/24/2020 ML20188A345 Regional Office 451 Comment from Dale Saltzman 04/27/2020 ML20119A091 452 Comment from Roy Volpe 04/28/2020 ML20119B075 453 Comment from Paul and Dorothy Nierman 04/28/2020 ML20126G349 454 Comment from Mia Azcue 10/19/2020 ML20304A072 455 Comment from Nivo Rovedo 10/19/2020 ML20304A074 Page 42 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 44 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 456 Comment from Nora Gaines 10/19/2020 ML20304A075 457 Comment from Pamela Brandt 10/19/2020 ML20304A076 458 Comment from Pamela Hudson 10/19/2020 ML20304A077 459 Comment from Steven David 10/19/2020 ML20304A079 460 Comment from Alisa Eilenberg 10/19/2020 ML20304A083 461 Comment from Alix Keast 10/19/2020 ML20304A084 462 Comment from Allan Goldhammer 10/19/2020 ML20304A085 463 Comment from Allison Schubert 10/19/2020 ML20304A086 464 Comment from Andrew Stein 10/19/2020 ML20304A087 465 Comment from Andy Lukas 10/19/2020 ML20304A088 466 Comment from Barbara Lalicki 10/19/2020 ML20304A089 Page 43 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 45 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 467 Comment from Carol Greenstreet 10/19/2020 ML20304A093 468 Comment from Cary Kittner 10/19/2020 ML20304A095 469 Comment from Deidre Moderacki 10/19/2020 ML20304A098 470 Comment from Elizabeth Lynch 10/19/2020 ML20304A101 471 Comment from Elsa Leviseur 10/19/2020 ML20304A102 472 Comment from Frances Jacobson 10/19/2020 ML20304A103 473 Comment from Hilary Vidalakis 10/19/2020 ML20304A106 474 Comment from J Patricia Connolly 10/19/2020 ML20304A107 475 Comment from Jean McAvoy 10/19/2020 ML20304A108 476 Comment from Jean Naples 10/19/2020 ML20304A109 477 Comment from Briana Rose 10/19/2020 ML20308A765 Page 44 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 46 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 478 Comment from Margaret Teahan 10/19/2020 ML20308A766 479 Comment from Beverly Simone 10/19/2020 ML20308A767 329 Form Comments from Riverkeeper Constituents to 480 10/19/2020 ML20309A853 Commissioner Hanson 481 Comment from Nancy Houghton Brown 10/20/2020 ML20304A073 482 Comment from Stephen Mantor 10/20/2020 ML20304A078 483 Comment from Susan Schwarz 10/20/2020 ML20304A080 484 Comment from Terry Meyers 10/20/2020 ML20304A081 485 Comment from Wendy Alberg 10/20/2020 ML20304A082 486 Comment from Barbara Warren 10/20/2020 ML20304A090 487 Comment from Carol Milano 10/20/2020 ML20304A094 Page 45 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 47 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 488 Comment from Courtney Nandagiri 10/20/2020 ML20304A096 489 Comment from M. Doretta Cornell 10/20/2020 ML20304A099 490 Comment from Francis Breen 10/20/2020 ML20304A104 491 Comment from Gale Pisha 10/20/2020 ML20304A105 492 Comment from Joan Schildwachter 10/20/2020 ML20304A111 493 Comment from K. Muller 10/20/2020 ML20304A114 494 Comment from Kate D 10/20/2020 ML20304A115 495 Comment from Kevin Cawley 10/20/2020 ML20304A116 496 Comment from Mary Mallonee 10/21/2020 ML20304A071 497 Comment from Louise Golub 10/22/2020 ML20304A068 498 Comment from Marie Inserra 10/22/2020 ML20304A070 Page 46 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 48 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER 499 Comment from Linda Brunner 10/23/2020 ML20304A067 500 Comment from Deborah Brown 10/23/2020 ML20304A097 501 Comment from Jeff Wanshel 10/23/2020 ML20304A110 502 Comment from John Sullivan 10/23/2020 ML20304A112 503 Comment from Jude Jussim 10/23/2020 ML20304A113 504 Comment from Eileen Leonard 10/25/2020 ML20304A100 505 Comment from Margaret Sikora 10/26/2020 ML20304A069 506 Comment from Beverly Harris 10/28/2020 ML20304A091 Herschel Specter, President, Micro-Utilities, Inc, Email Re:
The Transfer of Licenses from Entergy to Holtec 507 10/29/2020 ML20303A335 Decommissioning International (HDI) for Any of the Three Indian Point Nuclear Facilities, IP1, IP2, and IP3 Decommissioning Indian Point One Report, by Herschel 508 Specter, President, Micro-Utilities, Inc., October 2020 10/29/2020 ML20303A337 (Attachment to 10/29/20 Email)
Page 47 of 48
USCA Case #21-1037 Document #1889444 Filed: 03/11/2021 Page 49 of 49 INDIAN POINT NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 1, 2, 3, ISFSI STATE OF NY v US NRC US COURT OF APPEALS CASE NO. Case Nos. 21-1037, 21-1080, 21-1084 (consolidated)
RECORD DOCUMENT DOCUMENT ACCESSION ID DESCRIPTION DATE NUMBER Decommissioning IP2 and IP3 Report, by Herschel 509 Specter, President, Micro-Utilities, Inc., October 2020 10/29/2020 ML20303A338 (Attachment to 10/29/20 Email) 510 Comment from Freya Goldstein 11/05/2020 ML20322A144 511 Comment from Eileen Bartley 11/05/2020 ML20322A145 Letter from A. Peterson (NYSERDA) to R. Guzman (NRC),
512 New York State Comments re: Indian Point 11/10/2020 ML20316A008 Decommissioning Trust Fund Exemption Request 3 Form Comments from Riverkeeper Constituents to 513 11/16/2020 ML20324A638 Commissioner Hanson 2 Form Comments from Riverkeeper Constituents to 514 12/03/2020 ML20338A389 Commissioner Hanson 515 Comment from Deborah Gordon-Brown 12/03/2020 ML20338A390 5 Form Comments from Riverkeeper Constituents to 516 12/25/2020 ML20364A034 Commissioner Hanson Page 48 of 48