IR 05000293/1987030: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot insert)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Adams
{{Adams
| number = ML20151C674
| number = ML20237J247
| issue date = 03/30/1988
| issue date = 08/19/1987
| title = Partially Withheld Enforcement Conference Insp Rept 50-293/87-30 on 870909 (Ref 10CFR73.21).Major Areas Discussed:Status of Security Program & Allegations Re Deficiencies in Security Program
| title = Forwards Physical Security Insp Rept 50-293/87-30 on 870713-17.Violations Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Security Program & Alleged Deficiencies & Degradation of Vital Area Barrier.W/O Rept
| author name = Keimig R, Lancaster W, Smith G
| author name = Martin T
| author affiliation = NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
| author affiliation = NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
| addressee name =  
| addressee name = Bird R
| addressee affiliation =  
| addressee affiliation = BOSTON EDISON CO.
| docket = 05000293
| docket = 05000293
| license number =  
| license number =  
| contact person =  
| contact person =  
| document report number = 50-293-87-30-EC, NUDOCS 8804130129
| document report number = EA-87-164, NUDOCS 8708260080
| package number = ML20151C662
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, NRC TO UTILITY, OUTGOING CORRESPONDENCE
| document type = INSPECTION REPORT, NRC-GENERATED, TEXT-INSPECTION & AUDIT & I&E CIRCULARS
| page count = 3
| page count = 4
}}
}}


Line 19: Line 18:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:. _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
{{#Wiki_filter:_ _
' gr n Er c rt: '..
'
gwi)
, .
f$ d - ~.
ossicum oaIGIEL cerBifiedBY2  AUG 111987 Docket.N License No. DPR-35 EA 87-164 Boston Edison Company ATTN: Mr. Ralph G. Bird Senior Vice President - Nuclear 800 Boylston Street Boston, MA 02199 Gentlemen:
      . . . _. u MAQg%  (nrhMP[$ Y_b (cm.muma    (Dma U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
Subject: Special Physical Security Inspection No. 50-293/87-30 This letter refers to the special physical security inspection conducted by Messrs. G. C. Smith, R. J. Bailey and W. K. Lancaster of this office on July 13 - 17, 1987, of activities authorized by NRC License No. DPR-35 and to the discussions of our findings held by Mr. Smith with yourself and nembers of your staff at the conclusion of the inspection. This letter also refers to the telephone discussion between Mr. R. Ledgett of your staff and Mr. J. Wiggins of this office on August 14, 198 The purpose of this inspection was to review (1) the status of your security program, (2) allegations relative to deficiencies in your security program, and (3) the circumstances that resulted in the degradation of a vital area barrier. The inspection consisted of selective examinations of procedures and representative records, interviews with personnel, and observations by the inspector The enclosed inspection report identifies two apparent violations of NRC requirements concerning failure to ensure the integrity of a vital area barrier. We are concerned about these apparent violations because they indicate a serious degradation in the implementation of your NRC-approved security plan. As discussed during the telephone conversation between Mr. Ledgett and Mr. Wiggins, the apparent violations will be discussed at an Enforcement Conference at our office in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania at 1:00 p.m. on September 9, 1987. We understand that you will attend this meeting with members of your staff. You should be prepared to discuss the causal factors which led to the apparent violations, as well as the corrective measures you have taken or plan to take to prevent recurrence. In addition, you should be prepared to discuss the event involving the loss of vital area keys that occurred on August 3, 1987. Our decision concerning enforcement action for these matters will be communicated to you by separate correspondence following this conferenc I 0FFICIAL RECORD COPY kbD  [
- __
"
  - -
      & IEM >


==REGION I==
r .
Report N /87-30 Docket No. 50-293-License No. DPR-35 Licensee: Boston Edison Company 2 O raintree hit) Office Park Braintree, Massachusetts 02184 Facility Name: Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station Meeting At: N3C Region I, King of Prussia, Pennsylvania Meeting Date: jeyembbr9,J987 Prepared by:
        '
      *
.         l t .
      .AM b YCanc ster, Physical Security 7 - 3 - t 6r date Insketo I AA i
l
s    i/J, s G. C.~ Smith, Safeguards Specialist  ' date Approved by:  [cp  _f.Ja-ps Keimig'TfiTe afeguards Section, date
        )
    [
Boston Edison Company 2 Certain paragraphs in the enclosed inspection report contain details of your security program that have been determined to be exempt from public disclosure in accordance with 10 CFR 73.21 (Safeguards Information). Therefore, the paragraphs so identified in the inspection report will not be placed in the NRC Public Document Room and will receive limited distribution. This letter and the remainder of the inspection report will be placeo in the Public Docu-ment Room, in accordance with 10 CFR 2.790(a).
i veeting Summary: An Enforcement Conference was held at NRC Region I, King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, on September 9, 1987, to discuss the findings of a Special Inspection, No. 87-30. The special inspection concerned the status of the security program, allegations relative to deficiencies in the security program, and the circumstar:es that resulted in the degradati n of a vital area barrier. The loss of Protected Area (PA) and Vital Area (VA) keys, guard
.
j force response to PA and VA alarms, repetitive security concerns and security organization supervisory training were also discusse The meeting was attended by NRC and licensee management and lasted approximately three hour .
8804130129 880405 PDR ADOCK 05000293 O  DCD


_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _
Sincerely,
.
!
..
Original Signed Ey:
'
Ju anH.Joyner Thomas T. Martin, Director Division of Radiation Safety and Safeguards Enclosure: NRC Region I Inspection Report No. 50-293/87-30 (Contains Safeguards Information (SGI) in Paragraphs 2 and 3)
o
cc w/enci (w/o SGI):
.
K. P. Roberts, Nuclear Operations Manager Paul Levy, Chairman, Department of Public Utilities Chairman, Board of Selectmen J. D. Keyes, Boston Edison Regulatory Affairs and Programs E. D. Robinson, Nuclear Information Manager R. N. Swanson, Nuclear Engineering Department Manager Clay Higgins, Security Group Leader (receives Safeguards Information)
Details Participants Boston Edison Company R. Bird, Senior Vice President, Nuclear R. Ledgett, Executive Assistant to the Vice President, Nuclear K. Roberts, Nuclear Operations Manager R. Grazio, Field Engineering Section Manager C. Higgins, Security Section Manager G. Edgar, Licensing Counsel Nuclear Regulatory Comm.ission J. Allan, Deputy Regional Administrator L. Bettenhausen, Chief, Reactor Projects Brarch 1 J. Wiggins, Chief, Projects Section IB T. Martin, Director, Division of Radiation Safety and Safeguards J. Joyner, Chief, Nuclear Materials Safety and Safeguards Branch 0. Gromley, Project Engineer D. Holody, Enforcement Specialist J. Gutierrez, Regional Counsel J. Lyash, Resident Inspector W. Kushner, Safeguards Scientist G. Smith, Safeguards !pecialist W. Lancaster, Physical Security Inspector Security Concerns At the start of the conference, Mr. Martin summarized Region I's understanding of the circumstances relative to the licensee's identification of a degraded vital area barrier, which led to NRC Special Inspection No. 50-293/87-30 on July 13-17, 193 The inspection was conducted to review the licensee's actions af ter finding an opening in the VA barrier and to determine the validity of allegations made to the NRC concerning the licensee's security program. The results of that Special Inspection were as follows: the licensee's program to upgrade the security program is on schedule; two instances of failure to maintain the integrity of a VA barrier were identi-fied; one of the allegations reviewed resulted in identification of one of the two VA barrier failures; and, the other allegations were not substantiate Mr. Martin expressed concern about the recurrence of VA barrier violations, the quality of work being performed on VA barriers, the licensee's under-standing of the purpose of the security program, and the response to PA and VA alarms by the security forc _ - _ ____ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
The Honorable E. J. Markey Plymouth Civil Defense Director Senator Edward P. Kirby The Honorable Peter V. Forman Sharon Pollard, Secretary of Energy Resources Rachel Shimshak, MASSPIRG Public Document Room (PDR)
  '
Local Public Document Room (LPDR)
-
Nuclear Safety Information Center (NSIC)
. .
NRCResidentInspector(w/SGI)
4 .      d
Commonwealth of Massachusetts (2)
*
bec w/enci (w/o SGI):
Region I Docket Room (with concurrences)
Management Assistar t, DRMA (w/o encl)
Section Chief, DRP R. Wessman, PM, NRR D. Holody, RI J. Lieberman, OE J. Goldberg, OGC Robert J. Bores, RI
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - - _ _ _ - - - -


The licensee stated that the 22" pipe penetration point going from the PA into the VA had been created when contractor personnel removed a blank flange without the licensee's authorization. The licensee further stated that the consequences of this event to the health and safety of the public were minimal because the plant was not operating at the time of the event and there was no vital equipment inside the area. As a result of this incident, BECO management has taken the following actions to prevent a reoccurrence: retraining of. supervision that reemphasizes the importance of VA barriers; procedural changes concerning work controls; and counsel-ling of the supervisors involved in the inciden The licensee stated that on July 8,1987, a VA door deficiency had been discovered that would have permitted unauthorized access into a V The licensee further stated that the unit was defueled at the time of discovery, therefore, the consequences of this event to the health and safety of the public was minimal. ' The licensee noted that a contributing cause to this violation was insufficient follow-up on suggestions given to a 1985 con-tractor review of Heating Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) security issues. As a result of the incident, the licensee stated that a VA door survey would be conducted and would address the adequacy of all VA door The results of this study will be provided to the NRC upon completio The licensee stated that on August 3, 1987, a contract security officer had misplaced a set of PA and VA key The security officer, his super-visor and the licensee's shif t supervisor failed to implement security contingency procedures immediately upon notification of the event. Com-pensatory security measures were implemented and the missing keys were found on August 4, 1987. The licensee stated that when BECO management discovered the loss of the keys, searches were conducted of both PA and VA areas and the computerized alarm histories for these areas were analyzed to ensure that no unauthorized access had been made. The licensee stated that there was minimal impact on the health and safety of the public because no penetrations to the PA and VA's had occurred. The licensee stated that they have retrained all security personnel to ensure that the correct actions are taken when either PA or VA keys are los The licensee also stated that the three above mentioned events (VA pipe penetration, VA door deficiency, loss of keys) were isolated cases of security events and were not indicative of a programmatic breakdown. The licensee feels that its security program is effectiv The licensee also provided a handout (see Attachment 1) detailing each event, the ca se of the event, the consequences of the event, and the corrective actions taken to prevent reoccurrenc ____.____________m__
    . _ . _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - . _ _ _ _ _ , ,
$
,
  $
.. .
:
s(, ,
ATTACHMENT 1 ATTACHMENT 1 TO THIS REPORT CONTAINS SAFEGUARDS INFORMATION AND IS BEING WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE
  >
  ,
      (
Boston Edison Company-  3
.,
bec w/ enc 1 (w/o'SGI):-
Region.I-DocketRoom'(withconcurrences)
ManagementAssistant,~DRMA(w/oenc1)
Section Chief, DRP
        ,
i R. Wessman, PM, NRR
.D. Holody, RI
  .
J.'Lieberman, OE
'J. Goldberg, 0GC Robert J. Bores, RI      .I
        !
a i
        . l l
l
  'Ng 1:DRSS  RI: DRSS RI:DRSS fa :DRSS Smith /mk/mlb/ms Kei nig Joyner F Martin 8/16/87  8/ff/87 8/jq/87 8/l'/87 l
OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
__ _ _ _ _ _-__ -
}}
}}

Latest revision as of 22:55, 16 December 2021

Forwards Physical Security Insp Rept 50-293/87-30 on 870713-17.Violations Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Security Program & Alleged Deficiencies & Degradation of Vital Area Barrier.W/O Rept
ML20237J247
Person / Time
Site: Pilgrim
Issue date: 08/19/1987
From: Martin T
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
To: Bird R
BOSTON EDISON CO.
References
EA-87-164, NUDOCS 8708260080
Download: ML20237J247 (3)


Text

_ _

'

, .

ossicum oaIGIEL cerBifiedBY2 AUG 111987 Docket.N License No. DPR-35 EA 87-164 Boston Edison Company ATTN: Mr. Ralph G. Bird Senior Vice President - Nuclear 800 Boylston Street Boston, MA 02199 Gentlemen:

Subject: Special Physical Security Inspection No. 50-293/87-30 This letter refers to the special physical security inspection conducted by Messrs. G. C. Smith, R. J. Bailey and W. K. Lancaster of this office on July 13 - 17, 1987, of activities authorized by NRC License No. DPR-35 and to the discussions of our findings held by Mr. Smith with yourself and nembers of your staff at the conclusion of the inspection. This letter also refers to the telephone discussion between Mr. R. Ledgett of your staff and Mr. J. Wiggins of this office on August 14, 198 The purpose of this inspection was to review (1) the status of your security program, (2) allegations relative to deficiencies in your security program, and (3) the circumstances that resulted in the degradation of a vital area barrier. The inspection consisted of selective examinations of procedures and representative records, interviews with personnel, and observations by the inspector The enclosed inspection report identifies two apparent violations of NRC requirements concerning failure to ensure the integrity of a vital area barrier. We are concerned about these apparent violations because they indicate a serious degradation in the implementation of your NRC-approved security plan. As discussed during the telephone conversation between Mr. Ledgett and Mr. Wiggins, the apparent violations will be discussed at an Enforcement Conference at our office in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania at 1:00 p.m. on September 9, 1987. We understand that you will attend this meeting with members of your staff. You should be prepared to discuss the causal factors which led to the apparent violations, as well as the corrective measures you have taken or plan to take to prevent recurrence. In addition, you should be prepared to discuss the event involving the loss of vital area keys that occurred on August 3, 1987. Our decision concerning enforcement action for these matters will be communicated to you by separate correspondence following this conferenc I 0FFICIAL RECORD COPY kbD [

- __

"

- -

& IEM >

r .

'

. l t .

l

)

Boston Edison Company 2 Certain paragraphs in the enclosed inspection report contain details of your security program that have been determined to be exempt from public disclosure in accordance with 10 CFR 73.21 (Safeguards Information). Therefore, the paragraphs so identified in the inspection report will not be placed in the NRC Public Document Room and will receive limited distribution. This letter and the remainder of the inspection report will be placeo in the Public Docu-ment Room, in accordance with 10 CFR 2.790(a).

Sincerely,

!

Original Signed Ey:

Ju anH.Joyner Thomas T. Martin, Director Division of Radiation Safety and Safeguards Enclosure: NRC Region I Inspection Report No. 50-293/87-30 (Contains Safeguards Information (SGI) in Paragraphs 2 and 3)

cc w/enci (w/o SGI):

K. P. Roberts, Nuclear Operations Manager Paul Levy, Chairman, Department of Public Utilities Chairman, Board of Selectmen J. D. Keyes, Boston Edison Regulatory Affairs and Programs E. D. Robinson, Nuclear Information Manager R. N. Swanson, Nuclear Engineering Department Manager Clay Higgins, Security Group Leader (receives Safeguards Information)

The Honorable E. J. Markey Plymouth Civil Defense Director Senator Edward P. Kirby The Honorable Peter V. Forman Sharon Pollard, Secretary of Energy Resources Rachel Shimshak, MASSPIRG Public Document Room (PDR)

Local Public Document Room (LPDR)

Nuclear Safety Information Center (NSIC)

NRCResidentInspector(w/SGI)

Commonwealth of Massachusetts (2)

bec w/enci (w/o SGI):

Region I Docket Room (with concurrences)

Management Assistar t, DRMA (w/o encl)

Section Chief, DRP R. Wessman, PM, NRR D. Holody, RI J. Lieberman, OE J. Goldberg, OGC Robert J. Bores, RI

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - - _ _ _ - - - -

. _ . _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - . _ _ _ _ _ , ,

,

.. .

s(, ,

>

,

(

Boston Edison Company- 3

.,

bec w/ enc 1 (w/o'SGI):-

Region.I-DocketRoom'(withconcurrences)

ManagementAssistant,~DRMA(w/oenc1)

Section Chief, DRP

,

i R. Wessman, PM, NRR

.D. Holody, RI

.

J.'Lieberman, OE

'J. Goldberg, 0GC Robert J. Bores, RI .I

!

a i

. l l

l

'Ng 1:DRSS RI: DRSS RI:DRSS fa :DRSS Smith /mk/mlb/ms Kei nig Joyner F Martin 8/16/87 8/ff/87 8/jq/87 8/l'/87 l

OFFICIAL RECORD COPY

__ _ _ _ _ _-__ -