ML20210N720

Notifies That Util Has No Objections to Treating Hl Waldorf as Limited Appearance Statement Only.Ltr Does Not Meet Requirements for Participation as Party to Proceeding

ML20210N720
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	04/29/1986
From:	Silberg J SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE, TOLEDO EDISON CO.
To:	Hoyt H Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
CON-#286-019, CON-#286-19 ML, TAC-60875, NUDOCS 8605050235
Download: ML20210N720 (2)

Text

y

?

SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTs & TROWBRIDGE a *amTNE *sme imCLuo*NG peoFEssioNak Compomatioms 1800 M ET.N W.

waSHINGT fkD36 eausaw STEVEN u LuCas. a C.

(200 db TMowas C mLL L ova %E CME E m E sur spanout u

struanTo. epo.TTs. pC oav'o w mustastEiN.

• C ooa=E seuCEr miE CME L.N.n pTTwam,pc. wiCMaE6m waooEN e ucELvt wavias r. Ynavitso osa2. p C T E LE Co** * **LpH a. TavloM, g g ALAN o WassEmwaN

.r Emat vE pMEN o CMapNoFF. *#C.

o. poTTs. c v'CTo=*a J pEmmehs, o C E " J-p***Lup o Jo o hE'LL * .

• C- p 22 22 ti99 a M "ah**M E"'=E'"L Est a*aaN "oo' tee n? wasMiwoTow naoTMEa w O a TewoT ,aJavw'em MamoN. m p Cc saw"N Ma E mmTiEN.

• C. .

osT*, a saNo'L E e soNA TM AN T. Ca'*N

• JEFFE.nv.av. Lv astoN. p C.

pC- p. .*39 Ju.CMA a o a sa-p wuokas c -uE.of a~saaCMEa G,Ecaot u moGE#s.Je PC JAC. E a**a='* 'MoMas E C-oC E =. Ja a.C M * -o Jo .M mp a~oE.

E C pc MA - M GLassp.toEL

E*E,u .'s;0".ac .a,... c;VJfWa o,a e -uCE w. CMu-Cmu, 6 e LE ut a. NicMobsoN. Ja.. p C.

=,*n y,cg.a-C- ace.22on ,

"Ea Ev' =

m.7,N o. .au. p C.

E.G. # c

,,,,,,,%c,,,,,-

g

((Qt OCxt M

0"J cq,ooy .

p.uL 3 E

.T. p.o s"o' '.'."N paut a oau.C M.a.*E.,

u su,o'v .M,u'.E Eso E man J .,a.,E o a.a Most .a.

0,,, ,, ,,, 7 n. E 2 ,,; . paub EY o MuTCmNos.

J.av..E a s.L nossoTT.,pe, a.au uonat v auta. Ja . p C. c,,,,,u,,,,,o,,,,,

oay,o ,'gC

,,4.,,

A Cast.E W

,,,4.

~

.E ~ot uN a. .LE STANLEY M Sano

.YE sEFF most ANNea%q,GaN gangana3 su.ttsvase EL KE ggg g g g gggwgwg LESL setM apetEL p NaY.b.NLv WESsTIM. P CauoE~.5#EEo.JW,DC.

ggg,Lgg g ggqv ,,g g - T av.IE M.s t o sost~ E. E~oau uC . p om .N. s. ET- . omvaN~.

r.aNEsTe.La E.s e .

• C. sp t.,a,u,,p,,J .a.a.o.a.a.

SoNNtE s GoTTut a VET y,,,.. a o,,,C E is raped CREo47 o"ivE sTE ~E N = MrMa~N pautLa M ahoE4soM -o.NE Ma#'t pKCMT 48 ALE mahoEM o Yoedas2C2um somn es hassimas tu' CARL.ETON TMon s JoNEp s.

as a. SaETER, g P C. MowanoM sMAFFE# man E ma G asEn.

oEBomaM e saustm MCLE AN. veRCfN.A 22to2 (aumENCE w C EN T. e e. =C = .,4.yfa's.E"o no m .oTsoo gay,n, ,g,o.,E,,~ ,, s , , ,c, .. e,.g,M,Cggg;;

su a,, e Lo,,o s,,, E, ..

.otvt.

TMo c..s-EuLuta.MA

• C. Jo ... so . ... _ ,,,,,E v ***CMaEL C woe TE.LL van o. auLaCE. 9,C. GEonGE o.a.mL,h p oahe*E LahoE m somn J waNotEn

• somn ENGEL. p C. saCm a o .r. omasaLameGMT. Ja, .* TE LECop+E a p pontag SCOTT E. a u s ut c ,n,,n,,av....

EN s rrom em T g L,L,Ta .,sM,E,~m miff a, E C.

-oT.eao.was atCas est. P C , s.E.T E M.L aM. Mo.CoGaMA vE s.' A N, t u, E ,,,

E TE coMN Davio M sam 4 JahET C MECa*

CMamLES S. TE nem'N. p C. oELissa a. m.iooway -

C 30*o084 T# aim osaht MoNTLLom wmiGMT**

Eseg MuTTLES.pC. eauTMaN sEFFmEv w man.pfLMAN MENoma A. GALLaGME R**

(T. rpm. mop N SnowN. P C.

WuNT. m E NNLa Davio E Tse.JmENCE Meut R* FREo omasNER oomoTMV a SCMLOTM' JAMES 5 MaMu9.. p C, FRE oE 4rCE L KLE tN JoMM F.otaL,. mENNETH a Gauo pavio m LEwes hahCv C. W AGNE R RANoAL 3 MELL p C. steven p wiTL E M a paYmiCM LElGMToM IH N'CMano C. oomeaLogoN" O. scott CustEn. Ja esCMano J pammiano m*CMamo s. etaTTv #E CARNE ao=E =7 E. w N J.EEvFF..RE

. FLv Y.o .S E RM AN moSE o.E.7 m? E. oZ.aM.L.E.W.

Ns. p e A C. E LL.E

.A it N .A.

F RE oE L .

ooLa~o oto.oEr.T.o....ooE o. LLv M4 .E a . .. e ~oo E.s*

• &#'*****D*v'**'***

COum sE 6

. .. E . 3 o,.E CT o,a k ~ u..E .

April 29, 1986 822-1063 Helen Hoyt, Esquire Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 In the Matter of Toledo Edison Company, et al.

(Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, Unit No. 1)

Docket No. 50-346-ML

Dear Judge Hoyt:

On April 10, 1986, Helen L. Waldorf wrote to you on behalf of the Lake Erie Basin Committee of the League of Women Voters.

In her letter Ms. Waldorf proposed to make a statement during the hearisq on the disposal of very low level radiation waste at the Davis-Besse site.

Toledo Edison Company has no objection to treating Ms.

Waldorf's April 10, 1986 letter as a limited appearance state-ment. However, to the extent that Ms. Waldorf seeks to partic-ipate as a party, it does not meet the requirements which have been established. The March 10, 1986 Memorandum and Order 8605050235 ADOCK 0500 060429 6 PDR O

MO S

. .- _ - = . - . - _ - . .- .. -

~

f i

SH AW, PITTM AN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE Helen Hoyt, Esquire Administrative Judge April 29, 1986 ,

Page 2 stated that a determination whether a petitioner has standing to participate as a party will be governed by existing Commis-sion precedent under 10 C.F.R. S 2.714(d). Neither Ms. Waldorf nor the Lake Erie Basin Committee meet these standards.

Ms. Waldorf's letter indicates that Ms. Waldorf resides in Painesville, Ohio. Painesvilie is approximately 100 miles from the Davis-Besse site. This distance is too far to confer standing even in a reactor licensing proceeding. See Tennessee Valley Authority (Watts Bar Nuclear Plant, Units 1 and 2),

ALAB-413, 5 N.R.C. 1418, 1421 n.4 (1977); Philadelphia Electric I Co. (Limerick Generating Station, Units 1 & 2), LBP-82-43A, 15 N.R.C. 1423, 1433 (1982). It is therefore certainly too far to confer standing in a materials licensing proceeding. See l Rockwell International (Energy Systems Group Special Nuclear Materials License No. SNM-21), CLI-83-15, 17 N.R.C. 1001, 1005 (1983) (greater proximity should be required in a materials 11 ..

censing proceeding); Boston Edison Co. (Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station), LBP-85-24, 22 N.R.C. 97, 99 (1985) (residence 43 miles from a facility held too far to confer standing in a pro-

! caeding addressing spent fuel storage). Ms. Waldorf's letter identifies no other Committee members who might have standing.

l With respect to the Committee itself, Ms. Waldorf states,

~

"[t]he Committee as such has no personal, financial, or prop-erty interest in this proceeding."

For these reasons, Toledo Edison respectfully submits that l

Ms. Waldorf's letter should only be accepted as a limited ap-pearance statement.

Sfnerely,

/ % ,UL @t{

Jay E. Silberg, P.C.

Da d R. 4 Lewis i-i Counsel for The Toledo Edison Company, et al.

{

cc: Docketing & Service Branch Charles A. Barth, Esquire Ms. Helen L. Waldorf i

. - . - . . - - , .