ML20206H558
| ML20206H558 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse  |
| Issue date: | 10/04/1988 |
| From: | Koester A FULLER & HENRY |
| To: | Grimsley D NRC |
| References | |
| FOIA-88-516 NUDOCS 8811230231 | |
| Download: ML20206H558 (3) | |
Text
._-.
a, y
FUI.LER & HENRY ATTQMfYS AT LAW DONALD M MAWLDel THOMA$ M CBC$GS ONS SLACAf t. If7M FLOOR DSCUvA M J054PH F9613 A &TLS
- 8E I I"
I "A88 fle0MAlb OA1ATMPt2 CDAJC) 4 0 NOAF Ns P O' tot 3044 SL'8 A litAIMA inA C SLACE JAM 85 T SOUTMAAD.
ITIPHIM is MOSIBA DmD R SAMSC8 CAWT w wtLEDison JoHw a Mc(ApTwT THOMAS S LOEMSA TOLtDO. OM80 8283 MAnTuo o ConJCo tunesA a pe=1TT axxAnossAnna yMis w AsHnsw PtOCT A WM1Pft3 g
CMA8tas R LASCM JR WR11AM L PAT 9880 pgg) 3g? 3500 exAntENs8 TAYtom TR40l LANCR JR ALAN C 90TD JOHN j 1sentoso
,lyh e0 cons vn a m asa inoiso ****
]Dg8y p
{#,'"
"Dg I
omo A Ccu
- 0nd w namT m o0ccano uAYww.
trrvan a ruTN twts a foss ctsNw L aAMoo CtA)# 8 Call 911PHEMi ffOPOAD MA8Y ANw WHIPPLA*
FRSD 8 PL W 41904 tuli kAT A FAAAIS (419) 247-2589
.aLIO ngesrfTte es atrier,am October 4, 1988 DllEDOM 0F lliFORMATl01 ACT REQUEST D -11~3/Q b #d / O -M -gp Hr. Donnie Grimsley Director of the Division of Rulec and Records U.S. hPC Washington, D.C.
20555 e
Dear Mr. Gri.msley:
Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, I respect-fully request the following NRC records:
i 1.
List of concerns written by Commissioner Victor Gilinsky ret plant site visit of October 5, 1983 at Davis-Besse Nuclear Plant.
2.
Write-ups performed by Mr. Shafer and his staf f i
on the following Gilinsky conceinst 1, 3, 5, 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15.
Mr. Shafer may also have prepared written comments for items 7, 9 and 10.
If he did so, these comments are needed as well.
3.
Write-ups prepared by the NRR on the following Gilinsky concerns:
2, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10.
Requests 2 and 3 are reflected in the highlighted paragraph of the attached list of "notes and action items" re This may Toledo Edison Company Regulatory Improvement Program.
be of some assistance with the search for these two requests, a
i 8911230231 001004 PDR FOIA KDESTER88-516 PDR
. - ~ -
s FULLun Ac HENRY touco, omo Mr. Donnie Grimsley October 4, 1988 Page 2 4.
Compilation of graphs which indicate the hours of inspection by the NRC per facility for all the nuclear plant facilities in the United States.
Such data is needed for the years 1981 through 1986.
If the above documents cannot be located in the national office, they may be located in the regional office for Region III.
If this is the case, please forward my request to Region III.
I agree to pay search and reproduction fees of up to
$25.00.
If costs are expected to exceed $25.00, please contact me for authorization before proceeding.
If you have any questions regarding this request, please contact me.
In the event any of the records are denied, information regarding agency appeal procedures is expected.
Thank you for your assistance with this matter.
Very truly yours,
/
.M4 4%
- nne_Y, r
/
AYK/kmb I
2397-11 xc Thomas S. Zaremth, Esq.
Sue A. Sikkema, Esq.
attachment
____-.-__----------------------__-----------------------------A
f TOLED0 E.DISON CCKPANY RECUL A!0M !O kOVD2NT PROGMM (Notes and Action items) 1.
TEco has agreed to develop a Regulatory Improvement Program (RIP).
Mr. Shafer and his people vill aset with TEco before the end of November to work out the first draft of this RIP.
2.
The first higher management level meeting on the RIP will be the first or second week in January. 1984 After this teating, the licensee vill formally submit the RIP to the NRC.
3.
Mr. Davis and Mr. Stolz vill converse by telephone on November 7. 1983 to discuss the strategy regarding info n ing Connissioner Gilinsky of the proposed actions for upgrading TEco's performance at Davis-Eesse.
4 Mr. Shafer and his staff vill perfors brief write-ups on the folicving Commissioner C111nsky concerns:
1, 3. 5. 11. 12. 13. 14. and 15. NRA vill prepare writeups on items 2, 4, 6. 7. 8. 9. and 10.
Mr. Shafer may also prepare written cescents for items 7. 9. and 10.
nose short write-ups will be prepared by November 9.1983 so that we may f ax then to NR.R for their review before they are used as a basis for discussion with Cosmissioner Gilinsky. Likewise NRA vill provide their write-ups to R1!!
for our review.
5.
It is our goal to develop a RIP which can be accomplished in no more than a two year period.
ne RIP will identify areas which need improvement and vill identify the necessary actions in each area to bring about this improve =ent.
ne actions will have scheduled dates associated with them.
We vill meet with the licensee at least bi-monthly to discuss the
.prostess being made in ejch area.
The !!P will be a living dacument.
- which vill be revised as appropriate if there are significant changes *cr schedule slippages.
6.
Mr. Shafer should take the lead, utilizing the knevledge and judgements of other NRC people as appropriate, to develop what our position vill be regarding the amount of time a Vice-President and a Plant Manager should be involved in activities which de not directly support the operation of the reactor facility.
7.
Mr. Shafer will resolve with NU the adequacy of the location of the SR0s at Davis-lesse with respect to the new rule requirement which will be effective on January 1. 1984 Based on consents made at the Novester 4 aseting it appears that the licensee believes he has the Resident Inspector's agreement with the licensee's position on this matter.
ne tatter needs to be pursued with NRA since the licensee's position may not be consistent with NRC requirements.
y 7--
we. o-o
.t
,o a r c ee.....
i., '..' a. ;/,.*
ve. e ot e...,.. i.
e6:6 e a v.. s. : i :. :,
o...*
November 7, 1983 MEMORANDLt TOR:
Vayne Shafer Chief. Projec:s tranch 2 Tit 0M A. Eert Davis. Deputy Ketter.a1 Mz2nistrator SUlJECT:
TOLOO EDISON C0KFANT R.CCVLATORY !P2ROVEXINT PROGRAM 3ased on our seeting with Toledc F.dison Company on November 4.1983, and our discussions with John T. Stels and Al DeAgatto of h1LA. I have developed the enclosed list of notes and action items which ! believe represent our agreements with TECo and NKA.
Please review these items and let me know if you disagree with any of then, or if you believe additional items should be included.
May I have yo,ur response by November 14, 1983 please.
d A. lett Davis Deputy Regicaal Administrator
Enclosure:
As stated cc w/enclosoie:
C. E. Norelius R. L. Spessard fVjiG^tWJ5T Y
=
s*
e FULLER & HENRY ATTORM8YS AT LAW posIAla M MAWEDel TwoMAS W CeonG4 ONS SEAC Af t. IFTW Pt005 68098A E PMAPW DINNE A LYM ne At p reAJose i mAna Josonstow twoenAst oaurupts caAso i v As woastin
,,,o,,
sJeA staam4 unac sAct JAases t soi,9mAno.
sittwee a woessa MA TVI O AAAAC TWlassa & Dewfft
}AM W SA
,.m. -
-.S m,,,,.,,,,,,,,,,,,,
um wman,m cw ntsate TAvtos AtAne novo Jones I wcutamo M ALA) W Tt 9,
macoasa ines 34, s
]O m,
D,A '
g g
o.m A cou pese w maten e occaAio narwoe.
STmpe f I&#T9t SDU188 M G&Dne L BAH 00 CtAAS5 CA85 STtPMcMJsfuPOAD KatY AMM wMirtu' reso, tuna inwiimii art A,anass (419) 247-2589
..uo u rm. -w October 4, 1988 MED0!.I 0F INFOUf Anoy ACT REQUEST ND ~ll ~ 3/ G
'd / O -n -jp Mr. Donnie Grimsley Director of the Division of Rules and Records U.S. NRC Washington, D.C.
20555 i
Dear Mr. Grimsley:
Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, I respect-fully request the following NRC records:
1.
List of concerns written by Commissioner "',ctor Gilinsky re: plant site visit of October *, 1983 ac. Davis-Besse Nuclear Plant.
2.
Write-ups performed by Mr. d;.sfer and his staf f on the following Gilinsky concerns:
1, 3, 5, 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15.
Mr. Shafer may also have prepared written comments for items 7, 9 and 10.
If he did so, these commente are needed as well.
3.
Write-ups prepared by the NRR on the following Gilinsky concerns:
2, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10.
Requests 1 and 3 are reflected in the highlighted paragraph of the attached list of "notes and action items" re:
This may Toledo Edison Company Regulatory Improvement Program.
be of some assistance with the search for these two requests.
MWVHb 3))o
~)
FULLER & HENRY f
TOLEDO, OH10 Mr. Donnie Grimsley October 4, 1988 Page 2
}
4.
Compilation of graphs which indicate the hours of inspection by the NRC per facility for all the nuclear plant facilities in che United States.
Such data is needed for the years 1981 through 1986.
=
If the above documents cannet be located in the natiit:al of fice, they may be located in the regional office for Region III.
If this is the case, please forward my request to Region III.
I agree to pay search and reproduction fees of up to L
$25.00.
If costs are expected to exceed $25.00, please contact me for authorization before proceeding.
If you hat 3 any questions regarding this request, please contact me.
In the event any of the records are denied, information regarding agency appeal procedures is expected.
Thsnk you for your assistance with this matter.
Very truly yours, n n'e as AYK!arb 23'<? 11 xc:
Thomas L.
Zaremba, Esq.
Sue A. Sikkuma, Esq.
attachment a
K E
t-rL l
j
y TOLEDO EDISON COMPANT REGUI.ATOF.Y IO ROVD'. INT PROGRAM (Notes and Action Items) 1.
TEco has.: greed to develop a Regulatory Improvement Program (RIP).
Mr. Shafer and his people vill meet with TECo before the end of November to work out the first draft of this RIP.
2.
The first higher management level meeting on the RIP vill be the first or second week in January, 1984.
Aftar this meeting, the licensee vill formally subcit the RIP to the NRC.
3.
Mr. Davis and Mr. Stolz vill converse by celephone on November 7, 1983 to discuss the strategy regarding informing Commissioner GiLinsky of the proposed actions for upgrading TEco's perf ormance at Davis-Besse.
4 Mr. Shafer aM his staff vill perform brief write-ups on the follovf reg Consissioner Gilinsky concerns:
1, 3, 5, 11, 12, 13, 14, and 15. 1.XA vill prepar? vriteups on items 2, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10.
Mr. Shafer may also prepare written comments for items 7, 9, and 10.
These short vrice-ups will be prepared by November 9.1983 so that we may f ax them to NRA for their review before they are used as a basis for discussion with Coenissioner Gilinsky.
1.ikewise NRA vill provide their write-ups to RIII for our review.
5.
It is our goal to develop a RIP whieb can be accomplished in no more than a two year period.
The RIP vill identify areas which need improvement and vill identify the necessary actions in each area to bring about this improvement.
The actions vill have scheduled dates associated with the=.
We vill meet with the licensee at least bi-monthly to discuss the progress being made in ejch area.
The RIP will be a living document,
'hanges'or' f'
'which vill be revised as appropriate if there are significant c
schedule slippages.
l 6.
Mr. Shafer should take he lead, utilizing the knowledge and judgements of other NRC people as appropriate, to develop what our position vill be regarding the amount of time a Vice-President and a Plant Manager should be involved in activities which de not directly support the operation of the reactor facility.
7.
Mr. Shafer vill resolve with NRA the adequacy of the location of the SRos at Davis-Besse with respect to the new rule requirement which will be effective on January 1, 1984 Based on comments made at the November 4 meeting, it appesrs that the licensee believes he has the Resident Inspector's agrewment with the licensee's position on this matter.
The matter needs to be pursued with NRA since the licensee's position may not be consistent with NRC requirements.
\\
1
s t u..:, -
l *,
t et csc. a.
s-
.s J
,8* H O!'.4 s* t '.. t.
t,,..-,f; m. m..,, s,.
- c., :,
November 7, 1983 2.0RANDD' TOR: Vayne Shafer, Chief, Projects Iranch 2 TROM:
A. Bert Davis, Deputy Kegior.al Ad:inistrator
SUBJECT:
TOLEDO EDISON COMPANT RIGULATORY IYJROVDENT PROGRAM Based on our meeting with Toledo Edison Company on November 4, 1983, and our discussions vith John F. Stolz and Al DeAgazio of NRR, I have developed the enclosed list of notes and action items which I believe represent our agreements with TEco and NRA.
Please review these items and let me know if you disagree with any o' them, or if you believe additional items should be included.
May I have yo,ur response by November 14, 1983 please.
dB a
A. Bert Davis Deputy Regio'eal Administrator Enclosure As stated cc v/enclosor'e:
C. E. Norelius R. L. Spessard l
l l
A t
I
- _ -. -- - -=-
-.