ML20210K742

Requests That Councilman Kay 860210 Intervening Statement Be Treated as Limited Appearance Statement.Requirements to Become Intervening Party Not Met.Mayfield Heights,Oh,Too Far to Confer Standing.Related Correspondence

ML20210K742
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	04/25/1986
From:	Silberg J SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE, TOLEDO EDISON CO.
To:	Hoyt H Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
CON-#286-937 ML, TAC-60875, NUDOCS 8604290038
Download: ML20210K742 (2)

Text

r V

g EM!& ma%,%A -

SHAW, PrTTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PamTNEnSMin sNCLuosNG PROrESScNAL CO=pomarcNS 1800 M STREET. N. W.

WASHINGTON. O. C 20036 E ekT ase, p C. e O C kie e O yo wmEN E M$Lgge p th o mOkt g m E EN pO TT S P C. " ma S C. TELEcoptEm vEN p ?L E ME m$r$

LLdh"g^"rwYd ** L kI pc (202) 822 tC99 & 822 u99 EYt7,,*a o [mErfo *g'T,g y 4 gypSN 6 v. Tie.OTMy M[NLON PC Matias F."Tmav E SNiaz. P C. MAmtE N DOLANQ* SO*Dosh TmalN ViCTomeA J *E nnm S. p C. ~

TMCM A S C. MeLL JE F FREV w m AMpE LMA86 GEORGE M mOGE r$. JR P C.

FRED A LITTLE, P C jky $ gpST: sh.YC -* mamFan c0 h,y ,*pg' D ADDEN E YO LE*

1. "2Ew"E'u'kt".b,,C.

LE Star A. NaCs.0LSO*e. J R . P C.

a 31"'Ml.12^

e aEn +4.

ne~~

\poEG* EC-GL A SAS M_ Mecogweg.L m 22 072 n n-;^,,t,,Oa. Ja.

M ANN AM E. M trE3ERMAN

"' ,"'Ca

• L T N #8

'='o"

• MAmTrN O amaL P C. TMoon.v Juo8?M A S A 8m OL E R 90 S""'OV f.'m!*!?f.'"m&SS8vvi. = C, Ofd*F" ".C"'E"v"j m " "c ,,"<,*oo j,iy,;,

^,o 1'*f0o 'wilfr"h."4 J

G.OmGEy Aut os y m. # C E Ls SA B E TM M PENoLE*CN W WASM 89 2es3 ($MawLaw wSM) tMoM AS E C#OC mER JR

"."'eIhIEI'p" 'JE E o' sa..

• C.

hugSy e a's ]EL

• FEY'9,"L"O0 Nv &

CaeLE 'SM*wL Aw~

".U,'v",d .'$ ""p *m*O..N . .

• s%'L R E #?r'II4 miCM4 40 s A S [ set n v* CT' sm C. P. MA

"[**'N

, S[M"OmE'W' f, c FS GO g VemGesetA OFFsCE b*g, I g'*p Cu NO[ahs Ot yg t]OTA oha ga 3 ,

See E L DO ** J. W E I S E L

• C. [g"[ **gI"[U M N ISOI ,A RM CREO8' OWIVE WE NN L'N A Wo.e s T E 1 SURGM h M NM A t?. p C. S ,#"-

gg Ny h MCLEmN. v6MGINia 22'02 g N[,i' OMS"O " A " J , "y,"',88

" ui.'s o ifLfC'I's"C

" *~ 3aut ';'. 4.g'",,9;a* . ... Po 20* o '** L'ftr.*Ei. :"SE Li".

"?ls.,",tla.*uit ^J1.,

e "3JM.S'k. " cS m. . C.- 81?"#1 C,'i""O'?"' da ** -

"^r.'I.^o"."a v'O"'?S"EC2= f.8?Am. Moon .

C RLE S S E MNIN. p C. A Thd E W S UWE NCE W OM E'% N!S m A"3 .It'

• ? ,""!sp*N"Nh'."# $;'SE L" A:@ .'?a'a

~

UL'".* t'8?JEC. he'd .'."e".'!: SE ..

JAa.E S 3. MA M Len. P C. DELaSSA A. miOGW AT JE F FRET R. S8evDE N8 W SAN C. LONG SY ME E78 FREO OmaSNER

• suo* aos=ceo e r e JOMN F DEALT * * *ca**"s #

• v mosse.4 meCManO S. SEatTT Montm7 E. CONas CoueSEL s

.- - s ...TE . S o.mt C, . L No .E R April 25, 1986 -

fes~ 822-1063 w<?

V

&g g1 f b

j Ng'i Helen Hoyt, Esquire Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing -

5 /

Board Panel /

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory /

Commission s. __

Washington, D.C. 20555 In the Matter of Toledo Edison Company, et al.

(Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, Unit No. 1)

Docket No. 50-346-ML

Dear Judge Hoyt:

Toledo Edison Company has received an " intervening state-ment by Councilman Al Kay" of Mayfield Heights, Ohio, consist-ing of a resolution (No. 1986-12) passed by the City of Mayfield Heights on February 10, 1986.

Toledo Edison Company does not object to this resolution being received as a limited appearance statement. However, to the extent that Mr. Kay seeks to participate as a party, Toledo Edison respectfully submits that he has not met the require-ments established to become an intervening party. Mayfield f

o -

so 3

1

)

A -

SHAW, PITTM AN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE A PARThERSM'8 8NCLUDIhG PmOFES5*ONAL CO8PORATtONS Helen Hoyt, Esquire Administrative Judge April 25, 1986 Page 2 Heights is on the eastern outskirts of Cleveland and is approx-imately 80 miles from the Davis-Besse site. This distance is too far to confer standing even in an reactor operating license proceeding. See Tennessee Valley Authority (Watts Bar Nuclear Plant, Units 1 and 2), ALAB-413, 5 N.R.C. 1418, 1421 n.4 (1977); Philadelphia Electric Co. (Limerick Generating Station, Units 1 & 2), LBP-82-43A, 15 N.R.C. 1423, 1433 (1982). It is therefore certainly too far to confer standing in a materials licensing proceeding. See Rockwell International (Energy Sys-tems Group Special Nuclear Materials License No. SNM-21),

CLI-83-15, 17 N.R.C. 1001, 1005 (1983) (greater proximity should be required in a materials licensing proceeding); Boston Edison Co. (Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station), LBP-85-24, 22 N.R.C. 97, 99 (1985) (residence 43 miles from a facility held too far to confer standing in a proceeding addressing spent fuel storage).

Furthermore, the resolution does not identify with specif-icity alleged deficiencies in any of Licensee's reports describing and evaluating the disposal of very low level radio-active waste. It provides no' citations, no detailed discus-sion, and no supporting data, materials, or references. The resolution therefore fails to comport with the instructions in your March 10, 1986 Memorandum and Order.

Accordingly, Toledo Edison respectfully submits that the intervening statement of Mr. Kay should be treated as a limited appearance statement.

inperely,

\ / v J Ey Silberg, P.C.

D id R. Lewis .

Counsel for The Toledo Edison Company et al.

cc: Docketing & Service Branch Charles A. Barth, Esquire Mr. Al Kay

?-

vr-- ,v r---,,e .--~w-,,-,-r---v- ,.,---.-----,--.e.-,a-v , -,v-,,,,-----mv,,,-,<--.-,,-,e-,-,,-wn, --