ML20210L365

Requests That Congressman Feighan 860414 Petition to Participate in Proceeding Be Treated as Limited Appearance Statement & Not as Petition to Intervene Per 10CFR2.714(d). Related Correspondence

ML20210L365
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	04/25/1986
From:	Silberg J SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE, TOLEDO EDISON CO.
To:	Hoyt H Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
CON-#286-953 ML, TAC-60875, NUDOCS 8604290309
Download: ML20210L365 (3)

Text

f Oh0 &

Ov

1. $^/3 SEATED CONNESNM a[

SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A pamTNt=Sw*, w CLuOeNo amortSSCNAL ComeOmateONS *p 1800 M STnctt, N. w, h WASHINGTON, D. C. 20036 (*g /%

mansSay O ports. 84 "^ ** DA 8 at mRNNETM J wautas ase Damvb ANNg i. A8ecta SY iuam? L. povTedaN, e c. 5 SCO CuSN.PC m, s e - Oawso L awmENCE waug n ' mwik+* O. pO mit a L t omt p o ports pC E 5. sY N'S 'C. TELECOpite NN PNL 4 TL wtmYr /

O p

1. dh ["'

• M N

• t 'sCp C. (204 822 ce9 & 822 8899 $ e"a Na r{ O . gjy[^ , Qg",7 ,9 u veneOvwy .O.amLON C. aearsa s F. Tm*v.E SN!aZ. Man t N DOLANO* C S s'eOO.es vnasN - ,

v JI 8 F"E V * ' m asept (M A'8e GEOmog u mOctes, JR.. p.C. o J.e *tL mou=S.

FRE D a, ggrygg, p C. y") pgp, jf'CTOm*A s e, P

• E mapsFAs CO TMon445 h

I "g'* * ,O"MC.CDENN'[LL O L 1*m"uc e".""L'u'A ":? L"*pC.

d!"',"lM *k petPN. o r* tc <20e e22 072 naL A a ^ **;"

mkveN N'c" L" Stet A. NsCoeOLSON. Ja, e C. akey M GLag _

,,$,;,,ad g;_ .l.',pm.g ,g g ,JR.

,,,, a s, vkNM**,'A MAetsN O.maa P C- TwOne A S M *seCommeece A SaksDLEn E Sut SpmAOur TELEn Ju.o'TM QfgE g',pgg,Hgg,H,j mAm h !IS mOSSOTTL SC, GEC#GEV ALLg ee, se P C.

Du **eC[Ev $4 gLstantTM ne st NOLEv0N 4 e o ,E

. g at g

WilmE #7 WA SMsteGTON H 89 2693 (SMAWL AW WSM) twowag g c poc,g g, gg w : w p m a,.e er=a Gw=w- e..Lc S-.-A w:,m mm,:ama .A,s.. g:e=u ,* aw-~

r:m:S.m.n:

a,*g[,Nk8p'c C

pc evp:w tS GO vimGINia orreCE

= E.: .m o r m rm

• auk S *st a Cei, maa'me. '

d$,'.g'gOLag{m,o e

.=rm g

Mo*h O** E L DON J. w E iS E'L, p 'C. j *["fg", S"^g y# y ,"*" 6 sos Fames Caf D87 De'vE wNob N Yvg *$* gi eu#GM U*

v e ENna T, C. p ,Tg " AQ'* j Q MCLEAN, ve#GINea 22:02 't e't Ow ee " a "M d

e Nt e :. hvSat. ... namO T = mette : ar.::ac. :d""iank.==.e awnrx:r'.-

C C

"".O'"?S'h1 OSH*C mLES a t"eImeos. p C.

81S ? n 'if.t'2"' da "

1. 1. 7^ Erwtet

rla'.^.o* m's ,'O".?a S",C2ve N tNCN ho*[a N fai"."Y !. "Jt?s 1,s.e.

^ "

F 0,i',*"!# #.e" N af." p*c' DSEL"A"::'n '.^4'47, "'''' th"J"a *e. t'arJrc. $Yi* f a.NYsNaaYne*

• "J";!:

• Sem.

Jaset S s. Namekspe, p C. DE LISSA A. N'DG*av -

sE FFRET m Sasvoa m* SUSAN C. LONGStattto FmtOORASNE=

• aso' ases**ve e as e c JO***e F. DE ALv' '******'Em*w'*****

m.C-Amo S ...TTT moete? E. CON *e counsel

. met a S .et c7 ..at No .a a April 25, 1986 822-1063 Helen F. Hoyt, Esquire Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 In the Matter of Toledo Edison Company, et al.

- (Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, Unit No. 1)

Docket No. 50-346-ML

Dear Judge Hoyt:

The Toledo Edison Company et al. has received a service copy of a " Petition to Participate," filed in this oroceeding on April 14, 1986, by Congressman Edward F. Feighan. This pe-tition does not indicate how Congressman Feighan wishes to par-ticipate -- whether he wants to be made a party or whether he simply wishes to express his views in a limited appearance statement. From the tenor of the petition, Toledo Edison 8604290309 860425 PDR ADOCK 05000346 g PDR

~

\ O

?.

'/

4 SH Aw, PITTM AN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A pamThERSMi* peCLucaseG P#0FESSIONAL CORPORATCgg Helen F. Hoyt, Esquire Administrative Judge April 25, 1986 Page 2 infers the latter. Indeed, Congressman Feighan makes no at-tempt to identify particular deficiencies in Toledo Edison's reports describing and evaluating the burial of very low level waste at the Davis-Besse site; nor does he provide. citation, detailed discussion, data, materials, and references, as your March 10, 1986 Memorandum and Order required of persons who wished to become full parties. Toledo Edison therefore submits that Congressman Feichan's Petition should be treated as a limited appearance statement.

To the extent that Congressman Feighan's submittal might be construed a petition for leave to intervene as a party, Toledo Edison would object. As stated in the Commission's February 20 Order and your March 10 Order, a petitioner's standing to participate as a party in this proceeding is gov-erned by existing Commission precedents under 10 C.F.R. 5 2.714(d). Congressman Feighan has not demonstrated that he meets these standards. He has not alleged injury in fact to himself or residence in close oroximity to the Davis-Besse site.

Nor can he derive standing from his constituents. The 19th Congressional District, which Congressman Feighan repre-sents, comprises suburbs around Cleveland, the near is over fifty-five miles from the Davis-Besse site.ypt ofThis which distance is too far for any of his constituents to have-stand-ing in their own right, and hence Cong havestandingastheirrepresentativegyssmanFeighancannot 1/ Congressman Feighan incorrectly states that the eastern portion of the 19th District lies approximately 30 miles south-west of the Davis-Besse plant. This description apparently re-fers to the Perry Nuclear Power Plant, rather than the Davis-Besse facility.

2/ Although Congressman Feighan has not requested participa-tion under 10 C.F.R. S 2.715(c), Toledo Edison would note that it is unavailable to congressmen. General Electric Co. (GE Test Reactor, Vallecitos Nuclear Center), LBP-79-28, 10 N.R.C.

578, 582 (1979).

~lI SH AW, PlTTM AN, PoTTS & TROWBRIDGE A panyggR$mp (PeCLUDigo PeOFESS'ONAL COR*OR AT'OesS Helen F. Hoyt, Esquire Administrative Judge April 25, 1986 Page 3 For these reasons, Toledo Edison respectfully submits that Congressman Feighan's Detition should be treated as a limited appearance statement. Toledo Edison has no objection to its being so treated.

erely, 7

\ - , L

• a'y E. Silberg, P.C.

id . Lewis Counsel for The Toledo Edison Company et al.

Enclosure cc: Docketing & Service Branch Charles A. Barth, Esquire The Honorable Edward F. Feighan

.