ML20210S473: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot insert)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 1: Line 1:
#REDIRECT [[IR 05000445/1986006]]
{{Adams
| number = ML20210S473
| issue date = 02/10/1987
| title = Ack Receipt of 861009,31 & s Informing NRC of Steps Taken to Correct Violations Noted in Insp Repts 50-445/86-06 & 50-446/86-04
| author name = Johnson E
| author affiliation = NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
| addressee name = Counsil W
| addressee affiliation = TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
| docket = 05000445, 05000446
| license number =
| contact person =
| document report number = NUDOCS 8702170638
| title reference date = 01-22-1987
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, NRC TO UTILITY, OUTGOING CORRESPONDENCE
| page count = 2
}}
See also: [[see also::IR 05000445/1986006]]
 
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:- __ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
    -
  ,
      In Reply Refer To:'                                            FEB I O INT
      Dockets: 50-445/86-06
                  50-446/86-04
      Texas Utilities Generating Company
      ATTN: Mr. W. G. Counsil
              Executive Vice President
      400 North Olive L.B. 81
      Dallas, Texas          75201
      Gentlemen:
            Thank you for your letters of October 9,1986, October 31, 1986, and
      January 22, 1987, in response to our letters and Notice of Violation dated
      August 26, 1986, ar.d December 30, 1986. We have reviewed your reply and find
      it responsive to the concerns raised in our Notice of Violation. We will
      review the implementation of your corrective actions during a future
      inspection to determine that full compliance has been achieved and will be
      maintained.
                                                                            Sincerely,
<
                                                                                svaal signed By
                                                                                  /Tl HHf
                                                                            E. H. Johnson, Director
                                                                            Division of Reactor Safety
                                                                              and Projects
      cc:
      Texas Utilities Electric Company
      ATTN:    G. S. Keeley, Manager
                Licensing
      Skyway Tower
      400 North Olive Street
      Lock Box 81
      Dallas, Texas          75201
      RIV:CPRTh                                CPRT              .5F        '
      PCWagner:gb                                IBarnes
                                              2. /1 /87
                                                                              /"DRP
                                                                                EHJohnson
      2./$ /87                                                                  1/y/87
            l$P!888! 8?88;go                                                                          / {' D
                                                            PDR                                            \
 
  '
.
    = Texas Utilities Generating              2
      Company
    Juanita Ellis
    President - CASE
    1426 South Polk Street
    Dallas, Texas    75224
    Renea Hicks
    Assistant Attorney General
    Environmental Protection Division
    P. O. Box 12548
    Austin, Texas    78711-2548
    Administrative Judge Peter Bloch
    U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission
    Washington, D.C.      20555
    Elizabeth B. Jahrson
    Administrative Judge
    Oak Ridge National Laboratory
    P. O. Box X, Building 3500
    Oak Ridge, Tennessee    37830
    Dr. Kenneth A. McCollom
    1107 West Knapp                                    ,
    Stillwater, Oklahoma    74075
    Dr. Walter H. Jordan
    881 Outer Drive
    Oak Ridge Tennessee      37830
    Anthony Roisman, Esq.
    Executive Director
    Trial Lawyers for Public Justice
    2000 P. Street, N.W. Suite 611
    Washington, D.C.    20036
    Texas Radiation Control Program Director
    bec to DMB (IE01)
    bec distrib. by RIV:
    *RPB                          * MIS System
    *RRI-0PS                      *RSTS Operator
    *RRI-CONST                    *R&SPB
    *T. F. Westerman, RSB          DRSP
      V. Noonan, NRR                R. Martin, RA
      L. Chandler, OGC              *RSB
    *RIV File                      J. Taylor, IE
    *D. Weiss, RM/ALF              J. Conklin, IE
    *I. Barnes, CPTG              * Project Inspector
    *R. Hall                      P. Wagner
    *w/766
 
-
    ;
,
!                                                                                                    Leg # TXX-6213
                                                                                                    File # 10130
                                                                                                            IR 86-06
*                          TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY                                              IR 86-04
                            SKYWAY TOWER . 489 NORTH OLIVE STREET. LB. 88 . DALLAS, TEXAS 7M01
                                                      January 22, 1987                                                  ~~~- '
                                                                                                                  ; g:-
                                                                                                f; {h,:.i.W:
                                                                                                        fg g..' ~.
                                                                                                                p ' --  .;
  %?&^*.L #.U E                                                                                ;        # ? 6198'l
          Mr. Eric H. Johnson, Director                                                          I. , _
          Division of Reactor Safety and Projects
          U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission                                                  L-
          611 Ryan Plaza Drive, Suite 1000
          Arlington, TX 76011
          SUBJECT:      COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION (CPSES)
                          DOCKET NOS. 50-445 AND 50-446
                          INSPECTION REPORT NOS.: 50-445/86-06 AND 50-445/86-04
                          SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE FOR INFORMATION TO NRC
                          NOTICE OF VIOLATION (N0V) ITEM A(2)
          REF:    1. TUGC0 Letter TXX-5037 from W. G. Counsil to E. H. Johnson
                      dated October 9, 1986.
                  2. TUGC0 Letter TXX-6071 from W. G. Counsil to E. H. Johnson
                      dated October 31, 1986.
          Dear Mr. Johnson:
          We have reviewed your letter dated December 30, 1986, requesting additional
            information to our responses referenced above regarding NOV 445/8604-V-02
            (Item A(2)). We hereby respond to the request for supplemental information in
          the attachment to this letter.
                                                                                    Very truly yours,
                                                                                  h                      th  b
                                                                                    W. G.      ouns 1
                                                                              By: [,              .            /
                                                                                    G. S. Keeley
                                                                                                          W/y
                                                                                    Manager, Nuclear ticensing
          RSB/amb:lw
          Attachment
          c - NRC Region IV (0 + 1 copy)
                Director, Inspection and Enforcement (15 copies)
                U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
                Washington, D. C. 20555
                                                                                      4
                Mr. V. S. Noonan
                Mr. D. L. Kelley
                      '
                                      a vunsuov er nus cruurua mcmc corunn                                b          '
pv    ms                                                                      -Ywe% +,                            '
 
                                                                                              -. .
    .
      .;
    .
  .      Attachment to TXX-6213'
        January 22,--1986
        Page 1 of 2
  *
                                        NOTICE OF VIOLATION
                                      ITEM A(2) 446/8604-V-02
                                SUPPLEMENTAL REQUEST FOR INFORMATION
        In your response to Item A(2), you mention that problems related to the
        overflowing of electrical cable from the cable trays that were identified by
        the NRC inspector had been previously identified by applicant personnel and
        were in the process of being reworked. Accordingly, you did not agree that
        the NRC identified condition was a violation and, therefore, did not provide
        the information required by the NOV.
        Based on our review of the information provided in your response and
        additional information provided by members of your staff, we cannot agree that
        the cited condition had been, or necessarily would have been, identified as a
        result of the rework that had been undertaken. While we agree that many of
        the same cables were involved in both the NRC identified condition of
        overflowing cable tray siderails and the rework being conducted, we disagree              ;
        that the NRC identified problem would necessarily have been resolved by
        pulling the cables back to remove interlacing and then reinstalling these
        cables in the same size cable tray.      In addition, the NRC inspector did not
        identify any QC hold tags (indicating an identified problem) during the NRC
        inspection.
                                SUPPLEMENTAL RESPG : TO ITEM A(2)
        As a result of discussions with the NRC Resident Inspector and our review of
        this violation, we have determined that a revision to our response is
        required. The revised response below will provide the supplemental
        information requested.
        1.  Reason for Violation
f            We admit the violation, and the requested information follows.
              The deficiences noted in this violation involving unacceptable cable
              installation'were the result of corrective actions in progress per
              NCR E-85-101983 and inadequacies in the cited TUGC0 Inspection Instruction
              QI-QP-11.3-26 and B&R Construction Procedure EEI-7. Specifically,
              criteria governing the installation and inspection of electrical cable
              were found insufficient to prevent the improper cable installation
              identified in the NOV.
        2.  Corrective Steos Taken
              A request for engineering clarification (RFIC E-11180) was initiated on
              March 4,1986 requesting engineering to evaluate cable tray nodes
              T240SF001, 02, 03, 04, and 05 for siderails and to document installation
l
              problems encountered during cable rework associated with NCR E-85-101983.
i            A design change (DCA #24,289) was issued on April 4, 1986, to replace the
'
              12" tray nodes with 18" width trays to correct the stated cable overfill
              and irregular routing problems. Construction Deficiency Report CDR-87-801
              was issued on January 19, 1987 to identify the need for reinspection of
              existing cable installations for cable overfill conditions. If the
              disposition of the CDR indicates that corrective action is required, a CAR
;            will be generated,
k                                                                                        _ - .
 
  *
    ; 4
  .      Attachment to TXX-6213
        January 22, 1986
        Page 2 of 2
  '
        3.  Action to Prevent Recurrence
              Inspection Instruction QI-QP-11.3-26 and Construction Procedure EEI-7 have
              been revised to address the specific requirements of the electrical
              erection specification in the areas identified in the NOV. An additional
              inspection attribute has been incorporated into the inspection instruction
              prohibiting cables from extending above the top of cable tray siderails
              except where entering and exiting the cable tray.
        4.  Date of Como11ance
              Implementation of design change DCA-24,289 and associated cable rework is
              scheduled to be completed by July 1,1987. A change notice (DCN #5) was
              issued against the Installation Procedure EEI-7 on October 31, 1986.
              Revision 31 of Inspection Instruction QI-QP-11.3-26 is scheduled to be
              issued by January 31, 1987, upon completion of requisite training. If
              required, appropriate corrective action to disposition CDR-87-801 will be
              completed by July 1,1987.
l
l
l
l
l
l
}}

Latest revision as of 06:19, 19 December 2021

Ack Receipt of 861009,31 & s Informing NRC of Steps Taken to Correct Violations Noted in Insp Repts 50-445/86-06 & 50-446/86-04
ML20210S473
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 02/10/1987
From: Johnson E
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
To: Counsil W
TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
References
NUDOCS 8702170638
Download: ML20210S473 (2)
v • d • e


See also: IR 05000445/1986006

Text

- __ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

-

,

In Reply Refer To:' FEB I O INT

Dockets: 50-445/86-06

50-446/86-04

Texas Utilities Generating Company

ATTN: Mr. W. G. Counsil

Executive Vice President

400 North Olive L.B. 81

Dallas, Texas 75201

Gentlemen:

Thank you for your letters of October 9,1986, October 31, 1986, and

January 22, 1987, in response to our letters and Notice of Violation dated

August 26, 1986, ar.d December 30, 1986. We have reviewed your reply and find

it responsive to the concerns raised in our Notice of Violation. We will

review the implementation of your corrective actions during a future

inspection to determine that full compliance has been achieved and will be

maintained.

Sincerely,

<

svaal signed By

/Tl HHf

E. H. Johnson, Director

Division of Reactor Safety

and Projects

cc:

Texas Utilities Electric Company

ATTN: G. S. Keeley, Manager

Licensing

Skyway Tower

400 North Olive Street

Lock Box 81

Dallas, Texas 75201

RIV:CPRTh CPRT .5F '

PCWagner:gb IBarnes

2. /1 /87

/"DRP

EHJohnson

2./$ /87 1/y/87

l$P!888! 8?88;go / {' D

PDR \

'

.

= Texas Utilities Generating 2

Company

Juanita Ellis

President - CASE

1426 South Polk Street

Dallas, Texas 75224

Renea Hicks

Assistant Attorney General

Environmental Protection Division

P. O. Box 12548

Austin, Texas 78711-2548

Administrative Judge Peter Bloch

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission

Washington, D.C. 20555

Elizabeth B. Jahrson

Administrative Judge

Oak Ridge National Laboratory

P. O. Box X, Building 3500

Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830

Dr. Kenneth A. McCollom

1107 West Knapp ,

Stillwater, Oklahoma 74075

Dr. Walter H. Jordan

881 Outer Drive

Oak Ridge Tennessee 37830

Anthony Roisman, Esq.

Executive Director

Trial Lawyers for Public Justice

2000 P. Street, N.W. Suite 611

Washington, D.C. 20036

Texas Radiation Control Program Director

bec to DMB (IE01)

bec distrib. by RIV:

  • RPB * MIS System
  • RRI-0PS *RSTS Operator
  • RRI-CONST *R&SPB
  • T. F. Westerman, RSB DRSP

V. Noonan, NRR R. Martin, RA

L. Chandler, OGC *RSB

  • RIV File J. Taylor, IE
  • D. Weiss, RM/ALF J. Conklin, IE
  • I. Barnes, CPTG * Project Inspector
  • R. Hall P. Wagner
  • w/766

-

,

! Leg # TXX-6213

File # 10130

IR 86-06

  • TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY IR 86-04

SKYWAY TOWER . 489 NORTH OLIVE STREET. LB. 88 . DALLAS, TEXAS 7M01

January 22, 1987 ~~~- '

g
-

f; {h,:.i.W:

fg g..' ~.

p ' -- .;

%?&^*.L #.U E  ; # ? 6198'l

Mr. Eric H. Johnson, Director I. , _

Division of Reactor Safety and Projects

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission L-

611 Ryan Plaza Drive, Suite 1000

Arlington, TX 76011

SUBJECT: COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION (CPSES)

DOCKET NOS. 50-445 AND 50-446

INSPECTION REPORT NOS.: 50-445/86-06 AND 50-445/86-04

SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE FOR INFORMATION TO NRC

NOTICE OF VIOLATION (N0V) ITEM A(2)

REF: 1. TUGC0 Letter TXX-5037 from W. G. Counsil to E. H. Johnson

dated October 9, 1986.

2. TUGC0 Letter TXX-6071 from W. G. Counsil to E. H. Johnson

dated October 31, 1986.

Dear Mr. Johnson:

We have reviewed your letter dated December 30, 1986, requesting additional

information to our responses referenced above regarding NOV 445/8604-V-02

(Item A(2)). We hereby respond to the request for supplemental information in

the attachment to this letter.

Very truly yours,

h th b

W. G. ouns 1

By: [, . /

G. S. Keeley

W/y

Manager, Nuclear ticensing

RSB/amb:lw

Attachment

c - NRC Region IV (0 + 1 copy)

Director, Inspection and Enforcement (15 copies)

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Washington, D. C. 20555

4

Mr. V. S. Noonan

Mr. D. L. Kelley

'

a vunsuov er nus cruurua mcmc corunn b '

pv ms -Ywe% +, '

-. .

.

.;

.

. Attachment to TXX-6213'

January 22,--1986

Page 1 of 2

NOTICE OF VIOLATION

ITEM A(2) 446/8604-V-02

SUPPLEMENTAL REQUEST FOR INFORMATION

In your response to Item A(2), you mention that problems related to the

overflowing of electrical cable from the cable trays that were identified by

the NRC inspector had been previously identified by applicant personnel and

were in the process of being reworked. Accordingly, you did not agree that

the NRC identified condition was a violation and, therefore, did not provide

the information required by the NOV.

Based on our review of the information provided in your response and

additional information provided by members of your staff, we cannot agree that

the cited condition had been, or necessarily would have been, identified as a

result of the rework that had been undertaken. While we agree that many of

the same cables were involved in both the NRC identified condition of

overflowing cable tray siderails and the rework being conducted, we disagree  ;

that the NRC identified problem would necessarily have been resolved by

pulling the cables back to remove interlacing and then reinstalling these

cables in the same size cable tray. In addition, the NRC inspector did not

identify any QC hold tags (indicating an identified problem) during the NRC

inspection.

SUPPLEMENTAL RESPG : TO ITEM A(2)

As a result of discussions with the NRC Resident Inspector and our review of

this violation, we have determined that a revision to our response is

required. The revised response below will provide the supplemental

information requested.

1. Reason for Violation

f We admit the violation, and the requested information follows.

The deficiences noted in this violation involving unacceptable cable

installation'were the result of corrective actions in progress per

NCR E-85-101983 and inadequacies in the cited TUGC0 Inspection Instruction

QI-QP-11.3-26 and B&R Construction Procedure EEI-7. Specifically,

criteria governing the installation and inspection of electrical cable

were found insufficient to prevent the improper cable installation

identified in the NOV.

2. Corrective Steos Taken

A request for engineering clarification (RFIC E-11180) was initiated on

March 4,1986 requesting engineering to evaluate cable tray nodes

T240SF001, 02, 03, 04, and 05 for siderails and to document installation

l

problems encountered during cable rework associated with NCR E-85-101983.

i A design change (DCA #24,289) was issued on April 4, 1986, to replace the

'

12" tray nodes with 18" width trays to correct the stated cable overfill

and irregular routing problems. Construction Deficiency Report CDR-87-801

was issued on January 19, 1987 to identify the need for reinspection of

existing cable installations for cable overfill conditions. If the

disposition of the CDR indicates that corrective action is required, a CAR

will be generated,

k _ - .

4

. Attachment to TXX-6213

January 22, 1986

Page 2 of 2

'

3. Action to Prevent Recurrence

Inspection Instruction QI-QP-11.3-26 and Construction Procedure EEI-7 have

been revised to address the specific requirements of the electrical

erection specification in the areas identified in the NOV. An additional

inspection attribute has been incorporated into the inspection instruction

prohibiting cables from extending above the top of cable tray siderails

except where entering and exiting the cable tray.

4. Date of Como11ance

Implementation of design change DCA-24,289 and associated cable rework is

scheduled to be completed by July 1,1987. A change notice (DCN #5) was

issued against the Installation Procedure EEI-7 on October 31, 1986.

Revision 31 of Inspection Instruction QI-QP-11.3-26 is scheduled to be

issued by January 31, 1987, upon completion of requisite training. If

required, appropriate corrective action to disposition CDR-87-801 will be

completed by July 1,1987.

l

l

l

l

l

l

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20210S473&oldid=3383830"