IR 05000369/1988010

Insp Repts 50-369/88-10 & 50-370/88-10 on 880329-0401.No Violations or Deviations Noted.Major Areas Inspected: Snubber Surveillance Program & Followup on Licensee Identified Item (LER)

ML20151V389
Person / Time
Site:	Mcguire, McGuire
Issue date:	04/20/1988
From:	Jape F, Lenahan J NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
To:
Shared Package
ML20151V385	List: IR 05000369/1988010 ML20151V381
References
50-369-88-10, 50-370-88-10, NUDOCS 8805030047
Download: ML20151V389 (4)

Text

_ _ _ _ .

-

,f .

9 pe %q L y*~ t UNITE 3 STATES i: j j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o,

t RE0 ION ll 9 101 MARIETTA ST., g ,,,, ATLANTA. GEORGIA 30323 Report Nos.: 50-369/88-10 and 50-370/88-10 Licensee: Duke Power Company A22 South Church Street Charlotte, NC 28242-

.

Docket Nos.: 50-369 and 50-370 License Nes.: NPF-9 and NPF-17 Facility Name: McGuire 1 and 2 Inspection Conducted: March 29 - April 1,1988 Inspector: >. b - 4 4 - 2 C) - 86 p J. J. Lenalan Date Signed

.- : Approved by: Ab )( 2d F. Jape, Sectio M hief Date Signed

'

(/ /

Engineering Branch Division of Reactor Safety SUMMARY Scope: This routine, unannounced inspection involved the eas of the snubber surveillance program and follow-up on a licensee identified item (LER).

Results: In the areas inspected, no violations or deviations were identified, i

8805030047 880421 pDR ADOCK0500g0?

n , = ._ - . . _ _ _ _ _ . _ . .-

' '

g yI a fj. , _ , ,

"

. -

g- +

gm

?

'

f' r  ;

REPORT DETAILS

.c

-

'

I Persons Contacted:

Licensee Employees t

• N. Atherton, Compliance Specialist

• T. M. Cook,' Snubber Engineer '

R. Fulbright, Maintenance Specialist

• B. Hamilton, Superintendent of Technical Services ,

• T. C. McConnel Station Manager

• R. W. Rider, Maintenance Engineer i B. T. Scott, Maintenance Specialists

• R. Sharpe, Compliance Engineer J. Snyder, Performance Engineer  ;

i NRC Resident inspectors- 4 W. Orders Senior Resident inspector

• D Nelson, Resident Intpector  ;

• Attended exit interview j Exit Interview )

'

The inspection scope 'and findings were sunenarized on April-1,1988, with those persons indicated in Paragraph 1 above. The inspector described the ,

areas inspected and discussed in detail the inspection finding No :'

dissenting comments were received from the license The licensee did not identify as proprietary any of the materials provided g to or reviewed by the inspector during this intpection, j

,

Licensee Action on Previous Enforcement Matters i This subject was not Jddressed in the inspectio l t Unresolved Items Unresolved items were not identified during this inspectio : Snubber Surveillance Program - Units 1 & 2 (70370)

.  !

The inspector examined procedures and quality records related to the i snubber surveillance program and inspected selected snubben on [

safety-related piping systems. Acceptance criteria utilized by the ;

inspector, are specified in Technical Specification 3/4. j i I I;

I [

!  !

F

_________________________ -__ _ _ _ _-

a .. .,

,

,. .

..

. Review of Snubber Surveillance Procedures The inspector examined the following procedures which control snubber surveillance activitie (1)- Procedure Number PT/0/A/4200/06 Inservice Visual Inspection of Safety-Related Snubbers (2) Procedure Number MP/0/A/7650/50, Operability Testing of Hydraulic Snubbers (3)- Procedure Number MP/0/A/7650/51, Hydraulic Snubber Removal and Replacement (4) Procedure Number MP/0/A/7650/62, Removal, Replacement and

.

Operational Inspection of PSA Mechanical Snubbers (5) Procedure Number MP/0/A/7700/01, Functional Testing of Mechanical Snubbers Inspection of Snubbers The inspector performed a visual inspection of approximately 200 hydraulic and mechanical snubbers installed on systems located in the Unit 2 "exterior doghouse", the roof of the Unit 2 diesel generator building, and the Units 1 and 2 auxiliary buildings. Snubbers examined included those installed on portions of the auxiliary feedwater main system, feedwater, component cooling, residual heat removal and nuclear service water systems. During the walkdown inspection, the inspector verified that the snubbers were not damaged, that ottachment to the supporting structure and piping was secure, and for hydraulic snubbers, that the fluid level in the reservoirs was acceptable and that fluid was not leaking from the snubbe No discrepancies were noted during the walkdown, Review of Quality Records The inspector reviewed quality records documenting surveillance of Units 1 and 2 snubbers. Records examined were as follows:

(1) Results of visual inspection of Unit 1 accessible and inaccessible snubbers performed in August - September 1987 (2) Results of visus 1 inspection of Unit 2 inaccessible snubbers performed in May - June 1987 (3) Results of functional testing perfonned as Unit 1 snubbers in September 1987 and on Unit 2 snubbers in May - June 1987 (4) Results of freedom of motor testing performed on Unit I snubbers in September 1987 and on Unit 2 snubbers in May 1987

. _ - _ _

. . ,

,

.

. .

-

Within the area inspected, no violations or deviations were identifie . Review of Licensee Event Reports - Unit 2 (Closea) LER 370-87-008, Four snubbers were not included on the periodic list due to a defective procedure. On June 24. 1987, licensee maintenance

.

personnel discovered that two snubbers on the Unit 2 Reactor Coolant System had been deleted from the visual inspector. checklis+.. Further review of the snubber inspection checklist disclosed that two additional snubbers had also been deleted. These snubbers had not been inspected -

'

since January 19, 198 In order to resolve this problem, visual ins,1ection and functional operability (stroke) tests were performed on the four snubbers in question. The inspection and test results showed that the snubbers were operable. The Unit 2 master snubber inspector list was updated and corrected. The inspector examined the test results and verified that the snubbers had been operable and reviewed the master snubber inspection lists and verified that the list had been correcte The licensee reviewed the Unit 1 master snubber inspection list and verified that a similar problem did not occur with the Unit 1 inspection progra The licensee has purchased a proprietar monitor the snubber inspector checklist (database)y computer for both Units.program The to licensee is in the process of training maintenance personnel to utilize this program. Use of the computerized snubber database program will be implemented in May 1987. LER 370-87-008 is close Within the areas inspected, no violatioa or deviations were identifie !

,

h