IR 05000461/1989018

Forwards Addendum 1 to NRC Forwarding Insp Rept 50-461/89-18,consisting of Viewgraphs from 890614 Enforcement Conference Re Actions Taken Against Lead Radiation Monitoring Sys Engineer

ML20246D232
Person / Time
Site:	Clinton
Issue date:	08/18/1989
From:	Knop R NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
To:	Hall D ILLINOIS POWER CO.
References
NUDOCS 8908250298
Download: ML20246D232 (12)

Text

. _ - -

<

, . OLO

.

..

'

.' M AUG 181999 Docket No. 50-461-Illinois Power Company ATTH: Mr. D. P. Hall Senior Vice President Clinton Power Station Mail Code V-275 P. O. Box 678 Clinton, IL 61727 Gentlemen:

When Region III forwarded NRC Inspection Report No. 50-461/89018(DRP) to you via a July 25, 1989 letter Addendum 1 was inadvertently omitted. We-hereby forward Addendum 1 for your informatio In accordance with 10 CFR 2.790 of the Commission's regulations, a copy of this letter and the enclosure will be placed in the NRC Public Document Roo We regret any inconvenience caused by the omission and we will gladly entertain any questions concerning this matte

Sincerely, ORhCINAL SIGNED BY R. W. DeFAYErrE 1 R. C. Knop, Chief Reactor Projects Branch 3 Enclosure: As stated cc w/ enclosure:

J. S. Perry, Assistant Vice President R. D. Freeman, Manager, Nuclear Station Engineering Department DCD/DCB (RIDS)

Licensing Fee Management Branch Resident Inspector, RIII

Richard Hubbard J. W. McCaffrey, Chief, Public Utilities Division L H. S. Taylor, Quality Assurance eco Division, Sargent & Lundy Engineers 1 58' David Rosenblatt, Governor's  !

Rg Office of Consumer Services so Sheldon Zabel, Esquire, om Schiff, Hardin, & Waite y L. Larson, Project Manager, oo General Electric Company

@" Chairman of DeWitt County gg Illinois Department of Nuclear Safety oso

• 'U D. Schopfer, Project Manager, Ig(j\

Sar nt & Lundy Engineers i'

RIII RIII RIII [

'

? " ?-- "" 'W

iu

,

, g,,,. .

. .

1: .

e C_s -Os l

.

'

~~

i E N 70 RC E V E s C0 s TE R E N C E eL s E ' L, '989 Jiscussion o= ac: ions re a:ec :o _eac Rocia~: ion Voni:orinc Sys:em Encineer's

.

ns:ruc?: ion :o Suaorcina:es :o Jevia:e J

"ro m inois ower 3 rocec ures (Re=: Re aor: N ).

__ --

, _ _ . - __ _

'

,- *

. ..

p .

.,

I C _INTON

i ENFORCEMENT CONFERENCE

.

-

l JU 4E 14, .1989 Opening Remarks : R. Knop, Br. Chief, DRP-I NRC Presentation : M. Ring, Sec. Chief, DRP

_icense Pr:esentadion : L Power Representative

'

'

Closing Remarks : C. Paperiello, Deputy RA j i

l . i i

l i

_

-

+ .. . .-

( .

1 CLINT04 ENFORCEMENT CONFERENCE D SCUSSION ISSUES a. What management action was initiated once

'IP management was informed that the lead Radiation Monitoring Systems (RMS) engineer had instructed subordinates to intentionally

~

deviate from lP procedures?

l l

l

- - - _

,

[1.p..- ,

.

z

,4 i .,

C_ s- O s Es 70RCEV Eb C0h 7ERENCE JISCUSS Os SSL ES

,

3. . W,a: ac: ions were :a<en acains: -: , e eac RVS engineer, anc w,y? Was monacemen:'s resaonse :o :le eac RVS encineer's in:en~:iona cisrec arc 'or 3rocec ures a 3 3ro aria :e?-

W1y or W1y no:?

..

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ . . . _ _ . _ _._________.._____.__.____.__.________.m___..___________ ___

__ _ - --

15:[.

.

..

CLINTON ENFORCEMENT CONFERENCE DISCUSSION ISSUES c Why -did the lead -RMS engineer's intentional disregard .

for IP procedures entitle him to continued employment at Clinton Power Station until December 1988? Did his duties involve safety-related activities? If yes, was there any indication that he intentionally violated or

he intentionally caused to be violated any safety-related practices or procedures? If yes, explain the potential impact that these events had on the safe operation of Clinton Power Station.

.

___--u_._----- ------------_--------_--w---- ---__. - - - - - - -_-- _ _ _- . - - -- - - _ - - . _ _

E R

U D

E E S C C T L O N U R E S P R E E E R T F N A L 9 N O I O 8 O T A

I V 9 C G O

,

T I

T T 4

N S N E E O e V I n

M N T u E

I C J F U C O R R E T

O S C N F I F

I N F D E O E G

E L

L A

.

v

N D N E E O D S I N U T E P E A E O B T

G D S O I

N T T T I O N S M N A I

E T

E A D C &

V E I T

I D N M N E H E D

I F S C L B E

.

5 A N E S A T A T 8 I N A 9 D C G O R 1 N I

N N I T

BS A H I

T l

l T S A N Y N C C E E N O E U U C M A

I T N R Q N S T U E P I V GO S S R NI T N R DU M R 5 E 8 I

NA I E ES O P 9 I AG DS G WA E C U S

M LE E E I

R E

L O M L

R N E L N U L L E Y I R A E D A E B R D E F A VI W E F E RC E T D

E H OT E O O CA O T O T SI A E R Y I

T T P

I A WT E N NP I

T I CL AA S GH A GE L I

T C I

NT I

B R U I

V T P Q O S A E E R S E A L

I D

N E B E E E R I V F T U H O R TO NS I I L

L NO I

-

I TV-C S F I

• * e * *

.

-

TOO OTT N

W D NN TS E I E A I

E D T V N L

S N C I

E B I I

O A W Y H N R I N E T NC 9 A O I 8 G S V E A E 9 E A R D T L E AD 1 9 L R D H E 8 A E N T Y 9 E R A R EC N 1 T E SE U A N A W NN R P

I P T I

OIGTS I

M I N A

8 TNN AE I O Y 9 C B T S

1 GER I

N B N THO R I A U S

I ST E TESS E E G S V AR R N N HUU W A T O I D O I T D D O E N T C M E E P

W D A OT E CC S E I

I D D R A OO F I R R I

V E E TP P O E C M E N E E N R N R C A I

E I

N T TT L U E

D F E S A A L S I N

O D B OO I

L L I

S V VU I I I E C E SV V

• * * e

.

-

B X

N I O D I

T N C E P

.

N S

U P F

N E A

O T

,

I T A 0 C U 5 U Q R E R E F C T S

D A C N N I S

1 A D E D E

R R C

I G

E L

E I

U S O F

I L L F S A S N

N A I G E S N R G

I W

O E

I I

T U S L C S D L N E E O A T C

Y F P E

/

N O T T O

R C

O R E

I T N S T P F A C D I

D R F A A P

I D E B I

O S M S

N R

A L

A N W C I

A I

D C O

Y C R I

I T

T I

N D E H A

H O A F C I

R L A E O E O T N P I S - - -

V O O N N

• *

.

.

-

-

S S I U O S ON R I

R L I

A E L E S

I Y

O E A T HS S N TE S I R R Y E N S E E O E R C VO L I

U O N O P T D SM C E C E E A CF R R -

OO U T C R S U N E

I P SI AO M T F D E N N A ON MI O R

M D A E N I V

V R E N M R N AR I

SC S E A GE NN N T M A

R E C EO E N R G R N Y TC X

M E

A L

G O

O SON I

E S T A

P R R DC A NH I

T E V

P L Y P S R P E T I

A AR M K L Y T U E NOO AL C

I C L C

OTC TI T L

O E

X U T LA R I

P E N E SS NU AN

- - -

- E GW T H I

O

_ N RPE O .

I P T I

.

• *

.

-

R E G E T N I

E C Y N U I L E GR N R E

L N T O D N B E NS T N l

~T

~

A E I N U N H R I

L E LW U

O T O C H ST S T EO A T S T E A E A S RN R H R S R S TE T U E E E OR S E D R S A R G NO N

TE U N D W AC D O D D TOE L I

O 5 L A U I

8 NR P C O O S 9 A O O T

U 1 TE R N W L STP E N

'

TS N BA E C I UL E R A K N E

N N O

SO TA I

D A MN O TVL T E E

I C T O C O N TV OI T V L

S N C R

A C O O OI D TO A F T

I I

V T N DNT P N C NC E E M E WT S I

l S A M E N N Y DL E I I A L E E G V I T A V TN A E YC E U I

S AO N R A NIN F A D I N E L

A 9 H S V E U AI M 8 DC I D T S CD 9 AE O N X SD P

I 1 HT N I E S I E

• * * * * *

.

.

.