ML20246D232
| ML20246D232 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Clinton  |
| Issue date: | 08/18/1989 |
| From: | Knop R NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | Hall D ILLINOIS POWER CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8908250298 | |
| Download: ML20246D232 (12) | |
See also: IR 05000461/1989018
Text
. _ - -
OLO
<
.
,
..
.
.' M
'
AUG 181999
Docket No. 50-461
-Illinois Power Company
ATTH: Mr. D. P. Hall
Senior Vice President
Clinton Power Station
Mail Code V-275
P. O. Box 678
Clinton, IL 61727
Gentlemen:
When Region III forwarded NRC Inspection Report No. 50-461/89018(DRP) to
you via a July 25, 1989 letter Addendum 1 was inadvertently omitted. We-
hereby forward Addendum 1 for your information.
In accordance with 10 CFR 2.790 of the Commission's regulations, a copy of
this letter and the enclosure will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room.
We regret any inconvenience caused by the omission and we will gladly
entertain any questions concerning this matter.
Sincerely,
ORhCINAL SIGNED BY R. W. DeFAYErrE
1
R. C. Knop, Chief
Reactor Projects Branch 3
Enclosure: As stated
cc w/ enclosure:
J. S. Perry, Assistant Vice President
R. D. Freeman, Manager, Nuclear Station
Engineering Department
DCD/DCB (RIDS)
Licensing Fee Management Branch
Resident Inspector, RIII
Richard Hubbard
J. W. McCaffrey, Chief, Public Utilities Division
L
H. S. Taylor, Quality Assurance
eco
Division, Sargent & Lundy Engineers
1
58'
David Rosenblatt, Governor's
!
Rg
Office of Consumer Services
so
Sheldon Zabel, Esquire,
om
Schiff, Hardin, & Waite
y
L. Larson, Project Manager,
oo
General Electric Company
@"
Chairman of DeWitt County
Ig(j\\
gg
Illinois Department of Nuclear Safety
oso
D. Schopfer, Project Manager,
- 'U
Sar nt & Lundy Engineers
RIII
RIII
RIII
[
i'
? " ?--
'W
""
'
iu
g,,,.
.
,
,
.
.
1: .
e
C_s -Os
l
.
'
E N 70 RC E V E s
~~
C0 s TE R E N C E
i
e L s E ' L,
'989
Jiscussion
o= ac: ions re a:ec
- o
_eac
Rocia~: ion Voni:orinc Sys:em
Encineer's
.
ns:ruc?: ion
- o Suaorcina:es
- o Jevia:e
rocec ures
(Re=:
"ro m
inois
J
3
ower
O.
Re aor:
N o. 3-86-008).
__
--
,
_ _ .
-
__ _
'
,-
.
..
p
.
.,
C _INTON
I
i
ENFORCEMENT CONFERENCE
.
-
l
JU 4E
14, .1989
Opening Remarks
R. Knop, Br. Chief,
DRP-
I
NRC Presentation
M. Ring, Sec. Chief,
_icense Pr:esentadion
L Power Representative
'
Closing Remarks
C. Paperiello, Deputy
j
'
i
l .
l.
i
i
l
i
_
-
+
.
. -
..
(
.
CLINT04
1
ENFORCEMENT CONFERENCE D SCUSSION
ISSUES
a.
What management action was initiated once
'IP management was informed that the lead
Radiation Monitoring Systems (RMS) engineer
had instructed subordinates to intentionally
~
deviate from
lP procedures?
l
l
l
-
- -
_
,
[1.p..-
- .
,
z
i
,4
.,
C_ s- O s
Es 70RCEV Eb
C0h 7ERENCE
JISCUSS Os
SSL ES
,
3. .
W,a: ac: ions were
- a<en acains:
-: , e
RVS engineer, anc w,y?
eac
c.
Was monacemen:'s resaonse
- o
- le
eac
RVS encineer's in:en~:iona
cisrec arc 'or
3rocec ures
a 3 3ro aria :e?-
W1y or W1y no:?
..
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ .
. . _ _ . _
_._________.._____.__.____.__.________.m___..____________._
___
__
_ - --
15:[.
.
..
CLINTON
ENFORCEMENT CONFERENCE DISCUSSION
ISSUES
cd.
Why -did the lead -RMS engineer's intentional disregard .
for IP procedures entitle him to continued employment
at Clinton Power Station until December 1988?
Did his
duties involve safety-related activities?
If yes, was
there any indication that he intentionally violated or
- he intentionally caused to be violated any safety-
related practices or procedures?
If yes, explain the
potential impact that these events had on the safe
operation of Clinton Power Station.
.
___--u_._-----
_--------_--w----
---__. - - - - - - -_-- _ _ _- . - - -- - - _ - - . _ _
E
R
UD
E
E
S
C
C
T
O
L
N
U
E
S
R
E
E
E
R
TA
F
N
L
9
N
O
O
8
I
O
T
V
9
I
C
A
1
G
O
,
T
4
I
T
T
1
N
S
N
E
O
e
E
V
n
I
M
N
T
u
E
C
J
I
F
U
C
O
R
R
T
E
S
O
C
N
F
I
I
F
N
F
D
E
O
E
G
.
v
S
N
D
N
E
E
O
D
S
N
U
E
E
P
O
A
B
E
T
G
D
O
N
T
S
I
T
T
O
N
I
S
M
N
A
I
E
A
C
&
V
E
D
I
N
M
I
T
D
N
E
H
E
.
F
S
C
L
D
I
5
A
N
E
B
E
8
S
A
T
A
T
N
A
I
9
D
C
G
O
I
1
N
N
N
T
l
I
A
H
T
S
l
N
Y
N
C
C
E
A
E
N
O
E
U
U
C
M
T
R
Q
N
A
S
N
I
E
T
U
P
V
S
S
R
GO
I
T
N
R
NI
M
R 5
E
I
E 8
NA
I
O
A G
D S
G
WA
P 9
I
E
C
U 1
E
E E
E
O
M
S
M
R
L
L
I
L
N U
L
L E
R
N
E L
Y
R A
E D
A
A V
I
E
B R
D E
F
E T
F E
I
W
D
H
RC
O
CA
E
T
A
E O
O
E
I
T
E R
Y
T T
O
NP
T
CL
I
P
A
I
S
GH
E NA
L
I
R U
I
I
I
T C
V T
NT
B
I
P Q
O
S A
R S
E A
ID
L
E R
N
E
E
E B
E O
E
V
F
T U
H
R
T O
I
I
I
L
N O
N S
TV
C
S F
I
I
L
-
-
e
I
.
-
TOO
OTT
N
W
TS
D NN
E
E A
I
E
D
IV
L
T
I
E
N
B
S N C
I
I
R
O
A
W
N
Y H
N
E
N C
9
A
O
V A E
I
8
G
S
E
9
E
A
R D T
L
E
1
9
L
R
D H E
N
T
8
A
E
A R
Y
9
R
E C
E
N
T
E
SE U
1
A
N
A
W
NN R
OI T
I
I
P
T
5
G S
I
P
M
N
8
TNN
I
A
9
AE
I
O
Y
T
G E R
1
B
C
S
THO
I
N
B
N
I
R
U
S
S
E
TE E
E
G
N
V
AR R
W
A
T
O
HUU
N
I
O
T
D D
I
O
D
N
T
M
E E
E
C
E CC
P
O T
W
D
A
OO
R A
I
S
E
D
D
F
R R
I
ITP P
I
V
E
E
E
O
E
N
C
M
C A
E E
N
R
N
R
N T TT
I
I
L
E
E
F
E S A
A
U
D
N
D B
L L
L
OO
S
I
I
V
O
VU
I
S
I
I
E
C
E SV
V
I
e
.
-
B
X
N
I
O
DN
E
.
N
P
U
P
S
F
N
A
E
O
T
,
T
A
0
I
C
U
5
U
Q
R
E
R
E
F
C
T
D
C
S
A
N
N
0
S
I
1
A
D
E
E
D
R
R
C
G
L
U
E
S
O
I
E
I
F
L
F
S
I
L
A
S
N
G
E
N
A
I
G
W
S
N
R
E
U
O
I
I
L
C
S
D
S
L
N
E
E
O
A
T
Y
F
P
/
C
E
N
O
T
T
R
O
R
O
C
T
P
I
E
T
N
S
A
F
C
D
D
R
F
I
A
A
D
E
O
I
B
I
S
P
R
L
S
M
N
A
A
N
A
W
C
O
I
Y
C
D
C
I
I
R
D
I
T
N
A
O
A
E
H
H
L
I
F
C
R
A
E
O
E
O
T
N
P
I
S
V
-
-
-
O
O
N
N
.
.
-
-
S S
I
U O
S
ON
I
I
R L
E
E L
Y
I
S
O
E
A T
HS
S N
E
S
R
R
I
Y
N
S E
E
E C
V O
O
R
L
N
O
P
U
I
O
T
D
C
E C
E E
A
R
-
R
OO
U
T
U
C
R
S
N
S
A O
E
P
M
I
I
T
E N
N
F D
MI
O
A
ON
N
R
M
A
E
V
I
R
D
V
N
M
R N
E
E
I
A
SC
M
NN
N
A
R
E C
E
N
R
T C
M
A
G
G
R N Y
X
E
L
O
S O N
E S
A
O
T
P
R
IDC A
T
E
P
I
L Y P
NH
V
R
S
I
AR M
E T
T
A
Y
U
E
K L
C
C
L
NOO
L
E
C
I
OTC
TI
O
X
U
A
T
R
P
E
N
L
E
-
-
-
N U
AN
E GW
H
I
T
-
E O
O
.
_
N
P T
.
I
I
.
-
D
R
E
G
E
T
N
I
E C
Y
N U
L
IGR
R
N T
N
E
E
E S
O
D
N
~
N
T
N
~T
l
A
E
N
U
I
L W
N
H R
L
I
E
U
O
T O
C
H
S
T S
T
T
A
A E
A
S
RN
E
H R
R
T U S
R
S
E
E
E
S
E D
R
G
R
NO
S
A
TE U
N
D
N
W
AC D
O
D
D
O
5
T O E
L
A
L
I
U
8
N R C
I
9
A
O
O
O
O
P
S
TE R
N
T
W
U
1
L
E
N
TS
'
N
BA
E
R
E
C
UL
N
I
N
N
SO T
A
K
E
A
A
MN
O
O
I
D
T
TVL
E
E
I
C
T
O OI
T
O
V
S
C
C
N TV
C
O
O
L
N
R
A
D
T
TO
A
V
T
F
I
I
N
DNT
P
NC
N
C
E
M
E
E
I
WT S
A
l
M
S
DL
E N N
Y
L
E
E
E
A
T
A
V
TN
I
I
G
V
I
A
E YC
E
U
I
N
R NI
F
S
D
A N
A
N
L
E
AI
I
A
9
H
S
V
E
U
CD
M
8 DC
T
I
9 AE
O
D
S
X
N
S
E
P
HT
N
E
1
I
I
I
.
.
.