ML20236L907

Forwards Comments on Util 861202 Proposed Amend to Plant Physical Security Plan for Response within 30 Days.Addl Info & Revs Required Prior to NRC Approval

ML20236L907
Person / Time
Site:	Big Rock Point File:Consumers Energy icon.png
Issue date:	11/05/1987
From:	Hall J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Berry K CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
References
TAC-65250, NUDOCS 8711110113
Download: ML20236L907 (4)

Text

s c = -

m .

.m I '

{'

4 '

e .j

.;- y .

j a s 5- , -

o '

r, lijf , Qt; -

fe; 1 , ,

d

~

hDocketNo250155'  ! 2 n y , , ,.

L ,, < E -kj

, ng ,

)-

\

T?lr. !Ke'nneth W. Berry, Director g' y> < v u q h n Nuc1'are Licensing- '

..-1 F '

, .~ Consumers 1 Power Companyl T f H "i 1945. West Parnall= toad,  ;.

' ~,- ,

O,<

jJacksonfhichiganf49201' -

' l j

b

Dear Mr:

Bhrry:' '

U

=1 H'

. ,,-N

SUBJECT:

IMISCELLANE0US' AMENDMENTS / SEARCH. REQUIREMENTS

)

> o 1 BIG: ROCK' POINT 1PL' ANT (TAC #65250) ' j '

']

a Thisisltosacknowledge~r'eceipt'oftheConsumers' Power.CompanyLletter, Sated 4 December 2, 1986a which transmi.tted a proposed. amendment:to;the, Big Rock' Point M Plant PhysicalsSecurity' Plan,(in responsetto the Miscellaneous Amendments ,

.,? and: Search Requirements.- 1 o '

y ,

m.

~

The submitted document 'hasib ieh reviewed 'ahd we.have~ determined that additional e ,

<information1and' revisions ltoithelplan~are required prior to ourTapproval.' The enclosed; comments (are based'upon" pertinent'NRC regulations.and published guida~nce' i

, describing methods,iacceptable"to. the' NRC staff,?f.or implementing: specific. parts-  ;

, Lof those' regulation's'

~

' i

. t.

f f 5 1 ,. , . '3 JIt is requested'that you provide your response i to these comments'within-30' days' s

from receipt of this-letter  ;; .

3 ., u n ' '

iThe reporting.and/or record keeping requirem'ents' contained:.in this letter , 4 affect: fewer than ten: respondents; therefore, OMB; clearance is not required

.under P.L.m 96-511. ,

'Should you hav'e any questions'concerning the enclosed comments , please' contact

.the' reviewer, Robert Skeltonl at (301)'492-4533.

g, -

I ,

Sincerely, , q n(

r ,

y ,- 1 y gg . .  % q

Jam s R. Hall, Project Manager

> Pr h%N p

$N!55 PDR Qi/oectDirectorateIII-1 ision of Reactor Projects III, IV,.V and,Special Projects

.j Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

a

Enclosure:

DISTRIBUTION W/ ENCLOSURES: e

Physical' Security Plan Comments- RSGB rf Sec rf d.

RSkelton "

CBuracker (2) .

cc w/ enclosure: . Region III RIngram See.next,page JRHall. Docket File 50-155 o *' < Case File NRC PDR RErickson wo/ enc 1 Local PDR-LBush wo/en'cl PStarcher , 4

-(*SeePreviqQspageforconcurrencAl l 0FC : R$GB g: L @ :R$G :PD III-1  :

..pp y..__

._____.______ . g, uf:. _RSGB _______

PD IIIp_1____.___7 ____:_

. __ _ _". _ _9 S_0$_$____.__S'________!____ _S.___jRIngra,m ,,,,!,J,H,a; ,,,,, ,,

,,,,,,,,,,,i, ,

hf DATEL /87L i-/ /87 f/j/87- 28/7/87 [h/M/87 $6/,/87 $I / blS7 L

p b L__ .

m

't: i

! 4 x, . ,

iDocket=No. 50-155 Mr. Kenneth W.' Berry,- Director'

. Nuclear =ticensing Consumers Power Company 1945 West Parnall Road-

'Jr.ckson Michigan 49201 x

SUBJECT:

MISCELLANE0US AMENDMENfS/ SEARCH REQUIREMENTS H BIG ROCK POINT PLANT (TAC #65250)

This is to acknowledge receipt of the Corisumers Power Company letter, dated October 2, 1986, which transmitted a proposed amendment to the Big Rock Point Plant Physical Security Plan, in response to the Miscellaneous Amendments and Search Requirements.

The submitted document has been reviewed and we have determined that additional

'* formation and revisions to the plan are required prior to our approval. The eclosed comments are based upon pertinent NRC regulations and published guidance describing methods, acceptable to the NRC staff, for implementing specific parts of those regulations.

It is requested that you provide'your response to these comments within 30 days from re eipt of.this letter, h e reporting and/or re' cord keeping requirements contained in this letter

.at fect fewer than ten respondents; therefore,.0MB clearance is not required under P.L.96-511.

Should.you have any questions concerning the enclosed' comments,-please contact the reviewer, Robert Skelton, at (301) 492-4533.

Si.ncerel';

y l

James R. Hall, Project Manager Project Directorate III-1 Division of Reactor Projects III, IV, V and Special Projects Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulativn

Enclosure:

DISTRIBUTION W/ ENCLOSURES:

Physical Security Plan Comments RSGB rf Sec rf RSkelton CBuracker (2)

.cc w/ enclosure: Region III RIngram See next page JRHall Docket File 50-155 Case File NRC PDR RErickson wo/ encl Local POR LBusn wo/ encl PStarcher 0FC : R$GB :RSGB .

RSGB :RSGB :PD.III.1 :PD III_1 :

. . . . . . . . . . . . ."2. 9. . _"..S  ! _. . ."I_______. . . S_IS_"___ ..I".9 ram JHa1l DATE.$/../07 $/#/ k87 $ / /87 $ / /87 $ / /87 $ / /87 $

e

g' ' '

t l

. .y .' ,

,m i-l 1

-i DocketTNo~.50-155.

. ENCLOSURE'

. COMMENTS ON ' PHYSICAL SECURITY PLAN CHMGES (MISCELLANE0US AMENDMENTS AND SEARCH' REQUIREMENTS)

BIG ROCK POINT: NUCLEAR PLANT -  ;

-State that' vital. area access . controls will not be dropped for life threatening.

. situations-not involving public health and safety. Reference 10.CFR 50.54(x) 1 and.-(y) and Generic Letter 87-08 (Q&A #3), i Revise the commitment in Section 3.2.L 5.6 that if. security' force members leave the protected area to perform of Ticial duties subsequent-to their initial entry and search, they will be. searched prior to re-entry into the protected area.if they have not been under direct observation or accompanied by another -

member of the security' force. Reference 10 CFR 73.55(d)(1) and Generic

Letter 87-08 (Q&A #11). y Provide a' statement that only bona fide Federal, State, and .localolaw enforcement personnel on of ficial' duty are exempt from the required equipment H

- searches 'upon entry to .the protected area. Reference'10 CFR.73.55(d)(1). l Revise the commitment'in Section 5.2.1.4'to ensure. prompt access to vital'.

equipment to accommodate,the potential need for rapid. ingress or egress of xe - , individuals during emergency conditions or situations. Indicate how this prompt access will be ensured (e.g.,'by issuing override keys to appropriate operators and. security force members at the start of each' shift, or by other j acceptable means). Delete the. reference to procedures'and place the necessary 1

'information in the security plan. Reference 10 CFR.73.55(d)(7)(ii) and Generic .I Letter 87-08'(Q&A #6).

Revise the commitment in Section 14.1.1 to periodically (annually) review l physical security and contingency plans and procedures to indicate potential j

' impact on plant and personnel safety Delete the' reference to (i 1 3) from 1

the commitment. Reference 10 CFR 73.55 (d)(7)(ii)(B) and Regulatory Guide j 5.05. j i

Provide a specific commitment that the secondary power supply systems for both the' alarm annunciator equipment and non portable communications aquipment shall be located within a vital area. Reference 10 CFR 73.55(e)(1) and Generic Letter 87-08 (Q&A #16).

~

Indicate what specific components of the secondary power supply system will j be' protected as vital. Reference 10 CFR 73.55(e)(1) and Generic Letter 87-08 I L (Q&A #18). '

j i

T E . _. o

i

., i di .

'.o Mr. Kenneth W. Berry Consumers Power Company Big Rock Point Plant 3 cc: Mr. Thomas A. - McNish, Secretary s Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49201 ,

Judd L. Bacon, Esquire Consumers Power Company ,

212 West Michigan Avenue j Jackson, Michigan 49201

)

Big Rock Point Plant 1 ATTN: Mr. Thomas W. Elward '

Plant Manager 10269 U.S. 31 North Charlevoix, Michigan 49720 4

Mr. Bud Heeres  !

County Commissioner  !

303 Sheridan i Charlevoix, Michigan 49720 Office'of the Governor l Room 1 - Capitol Building Lansing, Michigan 48913 l

Regional Administrator, Region III U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission J 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 Nuclear Facilities and Environmental Monitoring Section Office Division of Radiological Health '

P. O. Box 30035 Lansing, Michigan 48909 i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Resident Inspector Office *

' Big Rock Point Plant 10253 U.S. 31 North . .

Charlevoix, Michigan 49720 l 1

l l

l l

1 i

l

- - . _ _ - _ _