ML20153G777

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Opposes Licensing of Plant & Urges Negative Vote.Paper Entitled, Infant Mortality Changes Following TMI Accident Encl
ML20153G777
Person / Time
Site: Diablo Canyon  Pacific Gas & Electric icon.png
Issue date: 01/12/1984
From: Andersen A, Andersen D
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To: Gilinsky V
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
Shared Package
ML20151Y970 List: ... further results
References
FOIA-87-444 NUDOCS 8805120012
Download: ML20153G777 (4)
v • d • e


Text

-

_ g h

(

% kn @asne an6Mde 1155 South Dora Street, Uklah, California 95482 (707)462 5648 Jan. 12, 1984 [

e m .n. .e aa.e a aa <s.a .as VictorCplinsky c=.m, ,. aa < ca co. c/o Nuclear Regulatory Cor:anission Docketing and Servicing Department Washington D.C. 20555 W cam D. good For so-. of ws #t 6e

. .a no. cr oeco p4u u nt. n en.

en re em .,arcirs. ..in e,...i.e Re: licensin8 of Diablo Canyon

.o..etw,a evioams re m m n. nuclear power plant

'*"^*""

sst for hwm or.c. Dt meora of p.t.

Dear Mr. Calinsky

.oan o'n bCS:nND .4*tm. .stm , wit 48 mv en e. e... r.g ni te u. 6e.,v,. On Friday, January 13, there will be rituals re e. uset of repo+ni u yo.

re i u. is % u ,. re,,c en re held in San 1,uis Obispo, Ukiah, and =any other places in von re one,t. rec.ni .itorie.

artra .c<i.. California all expressing the hope and the prayer that

.No i [2[v,*.*[. 'e'*"-,' "[j you will envision accurately the ettects of a decision not r o Ei tI.Ne *NI. .*[/l ,' to license operation of the Diablo Canjon nuclear power No co c en.oe t a,. r., .e eir.i, c...r e, w or po... re to, r. Plant and the ef fects if the plant is licensed, s us.<u cm pe... er+ st so . v. no exei e.t mai., r., This letter has much the sa=e purpose. We hope you re ie rs.cr.s er re , i:,: . .no re err.: .. ' e s t , .. . t r..,

will teel, in very personal ways, the ef f ects of a decision me.. v :0.c' n '*

..-in eo i s.c,e-+

... , .- . . : i.e i v e mr.

one way or another.

o, n ie .e. : rs.r g r. , un , ..

c.. . . . . . . , ..en e .. . c . . We realize that you f ace genuine dile::ast for instance,

".'de *aI N c*.'i I c m# 2iki tha t there are sincere individuals in govern =ent and private a: o-or,s.cn cars" T*. crcen tensii,as o cr. e. . industry who have worked for years to get the plant to its e .. .s cr oe . cupa. .. v i ncre cori .e t e ut. i poo, ac peo r. present state for who= a negative vote would see:n a personal Tn s i .ar e. ,ro c.t c.o rr.-rt 9, NGee mom-govra-. toi or:sm.

tragedy and that energy sources other t.han fossil fuels must inse v -.v,; e -n st re.. be found. However, to us the hazards et nuclear radiation is's .-e n a:i . io"o. ;

, . c c . . .. r .. r n . , ,a .. .

com em+, te s 'vos D, a ; cts: a s are so great that, it there were no other argt=ents against m es e;::: es:n . sc* e n e s:te t u n et r ,e c r r e v r e.

the plant, they would be sutticient. Therefore, in this to", t . ece eme. :c a ;e o letter we concentrate on them.

coni ca res:t, n . c c a. .

ta.-.c era re nv.e r e m... It you were to vote for licensing, you would be adcing to m e.e . ~. . . i Tr. er ec. coris te t . esi c the unsolved problea et how to cope with the radioactive waste a[. t$[ [: .[e[.-s .'e n . ' . and you would be approving et a nuclear reactor in an area IE,')2 *!*.Y.((. l r'c[i ccj' j , very likely to oe struck vy su eartn%2ae.

Y.7;*.[ Y,, *'.',"s5.,e*I

. [.s '. We all know that radioactive c.atertals do get back into

.:.: io use r . ns-e. rir a s.

the environ =ent with present methods et waste storage, tha t w e c..e . .: . m,- r. cre c,.i io gera cataanim sag 'com.

there is a danger et this happening every time they are trans.

,,i,,,....e.,,'.,,;..... ported, and that there could be cassive contamination f ro weie e cc+s:.mc. m form +g e

. o,, . . . ,,, ,, c . ,, : .o. r . n r a an earthquake or irom teactor f ailure.

a g ea #*. , e s* ea. c<va ast om em r e t-a.n o.i .cy c.u.w n ..

We know tha t th e e t t e c t s o f ra d ia t ion on hte.a n s a re 8905120012 000418 -

PDR FOIA HAMLIN87-444 PDR

  • I s .

g canc'er including leukemia, birth def ects of all kinds including mental retardation, f and death.

You hold the awesome power of deciding whether to increase or, decrease these sangers.

Please imagane the results of your decision in personal terms. Vould you offer one of your own children or grandchildren to become a leukemia victim or to be born mentally retarded? Then realize that it you vote to increase the hazards of nuclear radiation, you are deciding that some people, who care as much as you do, will suf fer these unnecessary tragedies.

To turn to the hopetul visi.on--if you say "no" to the license then, first, money that would have gone to Diablo can go to wind; solar, and other saf e renew-able energy projects and to energy conservation, and, secondly, people throughout California and the world will feel a great sense of gratitude and relief that this threat et nuclear radiation has been lessened, and third and most important, indi-viduals in the future will be whole and healthy because et your decision. Whe ther they will realize their debt to you, who can sayt We feel sure that God will know--

and you will know.

Sincerely.

M.~ J.~, M. 3 : V( dhea, Dorothy Norvell Andersen M/W Alfred T. Andersen s ,w

f. S. We're enclosing an article with which you may or c.ay not be f amiliar, a i

su:: nary of Dr. Ernest Sternglass' paper "Infant Mortality Changes Following the Three Mile Island Accident". It is one of c.any sources which have convinced,us of the seriousness of radiation hasards f ro= nuclear power plants.

3 i

I i

1 l

1 J

]

)

-I i

\ . o *

  • I J

i V

P i

73l fi Ut*">,e.

  • ( L S C L *t f f *. 7 . l Ae:1 dent 'ut TM,.'a t:1l e ILland Last Tridcy r:arked the .first c.:iniverthry of the accident at l Three ::ile Island. One year later, the 03:I contcinment 1s '

still filled with radioactive wator rir.d pases. Hetropolitan i Edison, the plant oviner, nas propocod "cacanup" procedures ,

which amount to little more then relec:ing the trapped wastes  :

, into the environnon'.. Rocently the .?C has succosted that  !

they may permit thuce releaser veithout waiting for cc=;1etion '

of an environmenu.1 impcet statec.ent. >:ot surprisin517, <

these plans have been angrily :riticized by area residents.

Tne recent anniversary and 1.,r.cndin ne . reltcsca ma'te thic i s cond .::e to revits the hnnr. ht.elLn effects of tnn 9:1 accident. The Keccny Cotu ission cuggested that there were  ;

n; immediate huath effects cttributchle to the radioactive '

raioc:es lact etring. T; icy concluded that the accident-rcleto; increast in latca+. tancero veoul be undetectab2.c and t h:.t paveholo.i:a1 3  !.treca s ens workers ar.d thoce livinc in the area tac the on.y uignifice.nt effect.

/ A recent study by Dr. Ernrist J. fatern;16:,s of the University i

of Pitt:. burgh Schoe.' of !!edicine calls this con:lusien cer.:. l ion ly into qun tion. Storngines focute: his cttention en  :

irif t.nt nortolity rr. cord: collceted fr ,e aroc hospitals cnd '

tc th_euU

, . . '; .m::en

_a__ < v . ..t .hly . , . 'h.e...l

'itatistien..

.w.,"f.c &..,c c N n...... i~M-*12 m_.

.r , - . . . . ,,  ; r,. .4 .

%, , . ., - n ,w4

. e. 3. . ~ _.m

, . - .'..,p..,...,r,.

s . . t. .

i

/The cu cr is norm:Oly n .,crie : of leu infan mortclity due  !

to lov er rish of pneun0nia anu influen a. In the Lutter of 1979 hocrever, the infant .ortality rcto in Pennsylvcnic rose l

fron a level of 10.:. par thour.s..d in :::::h to a peck of lo.5 I in Jul;. In Au uct, mortalit;. levels returr.ed to c nere ty;-  !

1:al level of 3 per thoucanu. Tci re;r::ents a rise fre: '

141 te P.71 dea *h. -cm c.n th 1,: :cu. :::::h r .: ,

  • uiv-- carres-p'he 4 pr:bs. bili *y thatonding thi tois enaincre purely se of note than live statistical stor.dard fluctue.: iondeviations.

is euca less than 1 in 1000, s

v' *;u rin g t ..'e s ce. : period, infant .ortr?.ity in tnc U.S. as a

hele continue:. to decline. heucs to tr.e : utn and cast of 7?:I, not :in thc .ota of the radioactiv a cca .lume, nico.c::-
cricnced r.o increm
0n in infer. destat.- itern 10:s esti:.:-

stos that during tM pt.riod of ':sy th*:agh July iM9, 332 "ex ct:" dockh: ,ccured in ?cnn:Giv L i t. , *cie, Cnd I.c7 York (cr 427 fru Mri'l to Vuly). ho C100 predict 3 inCroates in

  • hc ratoc of liuh: min and childcoed : sneers within the next dCcadC, . * *c ' d *bc * * "tM " t 4 ' * ** 't - :. * * * */ ; t , " t '"^ %
  • r .%

I. E *  %(* ,.- .

b p g) (lj ,

  • g g
  • 9 ' ) ( g, f
  • 9, .O g pe.* .c t:1 L *, j i O Y 0 r & 4.L L '. : . er T. * . T '. .l f: : r *. A L n00100n;,
: , .t.1.f . D -LO T C h G..

".'.t t r.

  • ?*Dt 00. ir :. l t e. ~. t.: :. U _

L .: .  :. r O u -

r r.n .' , v e r '. a e m. : t N tv *s Y.ar*- .n

m

_. .. . ~

9 4

Sternglass' conclusions cro no't withou t preaedont, cad cre in the rates of infant mortality were ot:ervea>igila supnorted by previous scientific Ltudit;.

Tc.,r,increates tacting at-co. spheric nucicar wc:pon tcetc in the fifties and cixtios.

Theco effects were not inmodiately recognized beccuse the.

radiation doce: were then thought to be too snall to cause damage. "cre rocent studius on the correl: tion between in-f ant nortality and X-ray expo ure durinc pregnancy have fur-ther demonstrcted the extrono sensitivity of the ceveloping fetus to low level radiction. The fetal thyroid. .>here rad-ioactive Iodine-131 cencentrates, is critical to develop ent and =aturation during tne finc1 montns of pregnancy. Thus the fetal thyroics of infants born between April and July ,

would have be m cetive end very sensitive to radiation at the 3 0, / 9 tiro of ..thew.TMI accident. Habies born af ter July or

< 3

.w . . o y c ., -..... . 4 . . , . w...s s . .. .< .e. y. .3 u. . . h.e.,,,

.s. ..

u. .w

...e .<.e

.... of .,, ....

accident -- her.ce the charp drop in cortality during August.

v Ster V: . 0 ran

-lacs rees en further tn cint c" t tht: for e ach in f ar.t h , r . * *. b v rcre--t'v't" n a .n -n e eu r wre: 1ere.er ne;cce, seri u sl . 0 *. r' u a t o c i tr ,

r- ci:1' lenaire to -ent al

..s . .~ .

4__

. - ... ... g. . _ . . . . . . , ....u

.. . .. , ,, m e

.. o .-

fantc and young

.w.,..,,,4.,. ..u. . .,...

peepic

<, u , s criectcc cay reach well into the ..

oo.e 4. n , . n v ,J . . . r. e c .,.e e C u,3 3 , ..2. .a .

tne 'T.I releacts v;cre c;all -o eenco... .. . .

ciall;. in co.s.pc.rtsen to

..a

.. .. .e u..s-..w.... vo .c o. . a. #y. -

. <..'.' c C U '. e .". &.h.*. ."'. . ' .' . ' . . 3 . . ~. t.

e .uc... c ...o......

, ..< . e.m.... 2. t. .' . . . .' n . *. e .

e .e ... .. ,. . .3 ;. . ,

~e.u,e..

... . .,.. c e. . . e

.o..o .. . . . .c.<

..a n..,4ue ,,.e ..

. .. .... .. .. .na,.. ey n the .low-level y-.

o .c ...q.4 radiati, n ,. 3. onf U. released n C . 4. . C n by nuclear power =lon+ p s as a '

a .< . n ... .u., , . . . .. . .t u, a ,u, scu, e.v. e c .- +. s ' .r i . . u*.*."

s <

..". . ' c. * .. u-- " . .e s .s.* . ". .a. .". w

. s..e .

u,J 4..% . . .n.o l a . e s. .< . .~.<.<. ,v . . a . .- # " '

, . . . , ,.e. . e.. .r. .e .

. . e , 1 oAn .: o..t . . . . a t..a. c ,: , , 4c . . . . a.'o c . s . .

was decreasing ct a rate ccupr:ble to the rest of the United .. . . . . . . . ..v..4.... .

Statec,

a. .

eu.e.e .

until. Co1970,

.. .e, . .when m.... L b ,, , t , 0 the .:illstone nu c1:ar plant was 0;ened

< , e ., u. . . . . < . . , c . . u o .-. e . .e. a , a .. '

i The plant has resulcrly relected severs 1'nillion curies of .. \

rad'.ation

.e.u s.i. per.u.....

..... < ("ecr cince beir; pu,t on-line.

,.. Mearwe.ile, phede w.....ua.

. .~.

. ..c. . . , e e .

.. u.e m

..m..,... . . . .u..s.-

c.a

. e .,a.4 .,. ,. 4 . e u. a. ,..

u......

. . . j..tv . , . .

u. 3 y. . .ta u. .t g e, ....s.a

,.. ., g v - .J 9.<..,

... .7. . ... ., e.. ... .. au , . : . e. .C...,.. s.

u ..q . . . . . . . . . . ~ ..,. 3

.c ,. e . . c . ,..

,. .....,G.,., .u

u. .. wya . 5. . 4 t : 3 s . . .cu .. n ......u

. . . . a. .; ..u.c . . , . . .

. ,. .. e. 3 a. n c ,,w'y,

.e c , c free about 18 to 9 3 per 1000 , live ..a.

.<,,, .u. c . n c u o ., e v

. . t. .. . t a c. ..e 1.trs.

. . e . . , . . a. . . . . ,

Furthernore. por,

.. .n ~ . . - .a

. . ,.e Island

.a..<.,.. . .correep;r.d

. . .- c i c w .~ .- ^ extrtnely '. .. '. m- c ' < $ ell .vitn '.h: vrr ains c.ounts of c..aCu, ..,e o..C . . d. u, .'.v....

..c'...c........ c...~

.sn t'.e . . . . . .

. . . . .r.

. . .v..... < , ....

. .. 5< .

e

(. ., u. . . ; C .a. n . . <<.. . n. o ......; a. .. < . . . t o. ., e w L. e .r s.e

, w ev, .. . . . . . L. a .R s v. e . C w.

.s. " . * . *. . .

arcou further fic.a the plant. .

....s ..

((,o,,, < ,

.. , . . . a .,.i. . . . .~. ...

.s ,e.

,. .n... . .n . ea .... s,. .. . . . . pa c. . , . n . ....u...

e.... -

n.o . .r 3 .< t y cilo'..i).J tac Three "lle Asiand ,.ccicent", T r c Co n'. e: at Cnan[-cs the th 'llorld CenGrecs of ',.n' inters and '

C

,q . h .v,. C , /, * .u Onr*

2.e/ , I m, . V .

r)V .* '"i c l f . Tw..."**I..

. p e. ..r .u*. U . .

  • J C 4t'.t!L Oin
  • ' ' - - * * *c *r-705-AviV 0 1 0L/,

M O) .~ ir Ca'.0, ! *.e nlo i;.Th , C A , i ,'. . '

(i//Sk 49 7-75fy[.12 2- 2 7 59

- - - - - - - - - - -

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20153G777&oldid=2957916"