Letter Sequence Other |
|---|
|
Initiation
- Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request, Request
- Acceptance...
- Supplement, Supplement
Results
Other: 05000206/LER-1981-013, Forwards LER 81-013/99X-0.Detailed Event Analysis Submitted, 05000206/LER-1981-013-99, /99X-0:on 810618,power Operated Relief Valve Controller Opened Twice During Normal Pressure Transient Following Reactor Trip.Caused by Setting Time Constant to Off to Satisfy NUREG-0737,Item II.K.3.9, L-81-029, Forwards Proposed Licensing Exam Schedule for 1981-82 for Reactor & Senior Operator Candidates,Per 810807 Request, L-82-002, Informs That Necessary Procedures Per NUREG-0737,Item I.A.1.3 Re Use of Overtime Required by Generic Ltr 82-12 Will Be Implemented by 821001.Tech Spec Will Not Be Submitted for Review Pending Receipt of Model Tech Specs, ML13308A671, ML13308B064, ML13308B821, ML13308B925, ML13310A775, ML13310A777, ML13310A778, ML13310A826, ML13310A828, ML13310A923, ML13310A926, ML13310B078, ML13310B081, ML13310B120, ML13310B280, ML13310B546, ML13310B619, ML13311B030, ML13316B714, ML13317A133, ML13317A134, ML13317A166, ML13317A190, ML13317A263, ML13317A267, ML13317A289, ML13317A367, ML13317A369, ML13317A377, ML13317A391, ML13317A427, ML13317A450, ML13317A454, ML13317A468, ML13317A478, ML13317A479, ML13317A484, ML13317A488, ML13317A490, ML13317A507, ML13317A512, ML13317A519, ML13317A553, ML13317A567, ML13317A581, ML13317A616... further results
|
MONTHYEARML13333A4221979-10-22022 October 1979
Forwards Responses to NRC post-TMI Requirements Re Design & Analysis,Operations,Rcs High Point Vents,Emergency Preparedness & Instrumentation to Monitor Containment Conditions
Project stage: Other
ML13303A7381979-10-30030 October 1979
Summary of 790927 Meeting W/Utils in San Clemente,Ca Re Emergency Plan Review
Project stage: Request
ML13322A6191979-11-15015 November 1979
Summary of 791108 Telcon W/Util Re Unacceptable Schedule for Implementing Lessons Learned Task Force Items
Project stage: Other
ML13333A4571979-12-14014 December 1979
Forwards Revisions to Util 790913 Commitments Re Compliance w/short-term TMI Lessons Learned Task Force Requirements Per NUREG-0578
Project stage: Other
IR 05000206/19790161980-01-0404 January 1980
IE Insp Rept 50-206/79-16 on 791101-02 & 26.No Noncompliance Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Scope & Methods of Field Insp for IE Bulletin 79-14,repair of Shorted Electrical Buswork & Licensee Design Change Proposal
Project stage: Request
ML13311B0301980-01-21021 January 1980
Discusses Response to NRC 800102 Order to Show Cause Re Implementation of NUREG-0578 Category a Requirements.Will Continue Operation Until 800315.Shutdown on 800131 Would Severely Impact Power Reliability in Pacific Northwest
Project stage: Other
ML13333A4781980-01-23023 January 1980
Advises That Responses to NRC Requesting Info Re Small Break LOCA Guidelines Will Be Submitted by 800228. Bulletin Response Will Be Sent by 800228
Project stage: Other
ML13333A4811980-01-24024 January 1980
Forwards Corrected Page 3 of App 10 to Enclosure a of Re Power Reliability Info.Omitted Info Sent to R Weiner of DOE on 800118
Project stage: Other
ML13333A4831980-01-29029 January 1980
Confirms 800124 & 25 Telcons Re Facility 800126 Shutdown for Implementation of Lessons Learned Task Force Category a short-term Requirements Re Reopening of Containment Isolation Valves
Project stage: Other
ML13308B0641980-01-30030 January 1980
Concludes That Inadequate Justification Exists to Extend Util 800131 Deadline to 800315 for Response to 800102 Order to Show Cause Why All Category a Lessons Learned Requirements Should Not Be Implemented
Project stage: Other
ML19290E8091980-02-0101 February 1980
Denies Request for Shutdown Extension Until 800315 to Complete Category a Requirements W/Available Equipment. Reopening of Containment Isolation Valves Until Further Mods Completed Acceptable
Project stage: Other
ML13333A4981980-02-0808 February 1980
Submits Addl Info Re Commitment Schedule for short-term Lessons Learned Task Force Requirements.Circuitry to Close Auxiliary Feedwater Motor Operated Discharge Valve Will Be Installed During Apr 1980 Refueling Outage
Project stage: Other
ML13333A5031980-02-13013 February 1980
Forwards Justification for RCS Subcooling Setpoint,In Response to NRC 791227 Request.Addl Info Will Be Forwarded in Response to IE Bulletin 79-27 by 800228
Project stage: Other
ML13316B7141980-03-0707 March 1980
Advises NRC of Delay in Responding to Item 4 of as Part of Response to IE Bulletin 79-27.Submittal Rescheduled from 800228 to 800701
Project stage: Other
ML13330A0251980-03-25025 March 1980
Forwards Addl Info for Implementation of TMI short-term Lessons Learned Task Force Requirements.Describes Mods to Backup Nitrogen Pneumatic Supply & Valve Position Indication.Drawing Available in Central Files Only
Project stage: Other
ML13330A0271980-03-28028 March 1980
Responds to NRC 800117 Request for Review of Draft Evaluation of SEP Topic XV-20, Radiological Consequences of Fuel Damaging Accidents,(Inside & Outside Containment). Review Confirms Facts as Correct
Project stage: Request
ML13330A0321980-04-11011 April 1980
Confirms 800410 Telcons W/Regulatory Personnel Re Implementation of Several Category a TMI Lessons Learned Task Force Requirements Described in
Project stage: Other
IR 05000206/19800041980-04-11011 April 1980
IE Insp Rept 50-206/80-04 on 800128-0229.Noncompliance Noted:Failure to Rept Reactor Protection Sys Setpoints Less Conservative than Those Established by Tech Specs & Use of Nonstandard Fitting
Project stage: Request
ML13331B3711980-05-0707 May 1980
Ro:On 800506,during Refueling Operations,After Lowering of Reactor Internal Instrumentation Package,Incore Instrumentation Package for Thimble Location D-7 Found Bent Outward.Caused by No Provision for Thimble Passage to Core
Project stage: Request
ML13330A0521980-05-22022 May 1980
Discusses Open Items Re Implementation of Category a Lessons Learned Task Force Requirements Per NRC 800502 Request.Open Items Involve Instrumentation for Inadequate Core Cooling, post-accident Sampling & Reactor Cooling Sys Venting
Project stage: Other
ML13330A0621980-06-13013 June 1980
Discusses Completed Review of NRC Forwarding Five Addl Items Resulting from post-TMI Reviews.Forwards Commitments to Meet Implementation Requirements for Items 1-5
Project stage: Other
ML13319A2131980-07-0909 July 1980
Forwards Post-Accident Sampling Sys,Capabilities & Description, & Drawings,In Response to Open Item Identified in NRC Re Implementation of TMI Lessons Learned Requirements.Drawings Available in Central Files Only
Project stage: Other
IR 05000206/19800201980-07-0909 July 1980
IE Insp Rept 50-206/80-20 on 800616-19.No Noncompliance Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Major Maint,Major Surveillance, IE Bulletin & Circular Followup & Independent Insp Effort
Project stage: Request
ML13322A7711980-07-0909 July 1980
Post-Accident Sampling Sys,Capabilities & Description
Project stage: Other
ML13302A4691980-09-12012 September 1980
Forwards Amend 20 to Fsar.Amend Contains Responses to NUREG- 0660 & NUREG-0694, TMI-Related Requirements for New Ols
Project stage: Request
ML13322A9461980-09-12012 September 1980
Notifies That Actions Required in NRC Re License Amend Application Concerning Implementation of TMI Lessons Learned Requirements Cannot Be Accomplished by 800912. License Amend Application Will Be Submitted by 810116
Project stage: Other
ML13330A1321980-10-0909 October 1980
Notifies That Date for Submittal of Info Re Design Details for Reactor Coolant Vents & Addl Info for Main Steam Line Piping Integrity Evaluation Will Be Submitted 801101 & 1201,respectively
Project stage: Other
ML13330A1351980-10-15015 October 1980
Provides Plans,Schedules & Commitments to Meet Interim Criteria for Shift Staffing & Administrative Controls,In Response to NRC 800731 Request.Full Compliance W/Criteria Will Be Achieved No Later than 820701
Project stage: Other
ML13316A5161980-10-31031 October 1980
Environ Qualification of Electrical Equipment
Project stage: Request
ML13330A1581980-12-23023 December 1980
Advises That Response to NRC Requesting Confirmation for Implementation Dates of TMI-related Items Will Be Submitted by 810105
Project stage: Other
ML13308B8211980-12-30030 December 1980
Submits Addl Info Re Description of Shift Technical Advisor Training Program & Plans for Requalification Training Per 791031 Request
Project stage: Other
ML13330A1661981-01-0707 January 1981
Notifies That License Amend Application to Incorporate Applicable Tech Specs for Implementing TMI-2 Lessons Learned Category a Items Will Be Submitted by 810401
Project stage: Request
ML13308A6711981-01-13013 January 1981
Advises That Licensee Inadvertently Omitted Info from Re Plans for Implementation of Action Item II.K.3.25 in NUREG-0737 Re Effect of Loss of Ac Power on Pump Seals. Evaluation Will Be Submitted by 820101
Project stage: Other
ML13330A1911981-01-14014 January 1981
Informs That Radiochemical & Chemical Analysis Mods Promised in Util No Longer Necessary.Due to Other TMI Recommendations,Samples Can Be Analyzed Outside Lab.Cart Mounted Iodine Sampler W/Single Channel Analyzer to Be Used
Project stage: Other
ML14135A0051981-01-23023 January 1981
High Radiation Sampling Station General Piping Arrangement Plan
Project stage: Other
ML13330A1931981-02-0202 February 1981
Forwards Application for Amend 96 of License DPR-13
Project stage: Request
IR 05000206/19810041981-02-25025 February 1981
IE Insp Rept 50-206/81-04 on 801229-810130.No Noncompliance Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Followup on Systematic Appraisal of Licensee Performance & Allegation by Contractor Employee
Project stage: Request
ML13330A2411981-03-0606 March 1981
Responds to IE Bulletin 80-04, Analysis of PWR Main Steam Line Break W/Continued Feedwater Addition. Auxiliary Feedwater Sys Automatic Initiation Will Occur on Low Steam Generator Level W/Setpoint at 5% of Narrow Range Instrument
Project stage: Other
ML13330A2661981-03-17017 March 1981
Forwards Listing Containing Brief Description of Design Changes Completed During 1980 Per 10CFR50.59b & Rept on Challenges to Relief & Safety Valves Per NUREG-0578
Project stage: Other
ML13330A2671981-03-18018 March 1981
Advises That post-accident Sampling Sys,Described in Licensee ,Will Not Include Capability to Perform Chloride Analysis,Per NUREG-0737 & NUREG-0578.Chloride Analyses Using Dilute Samples Are Inaccurate
Project stage: Other
ML13330A2911981-04-13013 April 1981
Responds to NRC 801031 Request for Clarification of NUREG-0737 Requirements & Confirmation of Implementation Date.Rept by NUS Corp, Control Room Habitability Evaluation San Onofre Generating Station,Unit 1 Encl
Project stage: Request
ML13302B0341981-04-13013 April 1981
Summary of 810310 Meeting W/Utils in Bethesda,Md Re Explosion Hazards.Attendance List & Applicant Handouts Encl
Project stage: Request
ML13331A0741981-04-17017 April 1981
Requests That NRC Finish Review of Util Compliance W/Ie Bulletin 79-06C, Nuclear Incident at TMI - Suppl. Review Completion Needed for Util to Complete Design Change to Assure Automatic Tripping of Reactor Coolant Pumps
Project stage: Other
ML13330A2991981-04-20020 April 1981
Forwards Response to NUREG-0737,Item II.K.3.17 Re ECCS Equipment Outages.Also Forwards Analysis of Probability of Toxic Gas Hazard for San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station as Result of Truck Accidents Near Plant
Project stage: Other
ML13317A6101981-05-0707 May 1981
Forwards Addl Info Re SEP Topic XV-16, Radiological Consequences of Failure of Small Lines Carrying Primary Coolant Outside Containment, Per 801215 & 810319 Requests
Project stage: Request
ML13317A6161981-05-12012 May 1981
Advises That TMI Action Plan Item II.K.3.9 Was Not Completed by 810101.Facility Has Been Shut Down Since Apr 1980.Item Will Be Completed Prior to Restart.Also Lists Completion Schedules for Items II.D.3,II.E.4.2.,II.G.1 & III.D.3.3
Project stage: Other
ML13317A6271981-06-0808 June 1981
Submits Results of Evaluation of Containment post-accident Pressure Reanalysis on Operational Limits,In Response to TMI Action Plan Item II.E.4.2(5).Peak post-accident Pressure & Temp in 770119 Analysis Is Still Applicable
Project stage: Other
ML20196A6141981-06-15015 June 1981
IE Review & Evaluation of Licensee Implementation of TMI Action Plan Requirement 1.C.5, `Procedures for Feedback of Operating Experience to Plant Staff
Project stage: Other
ML20196A6061981-06-15015 June 1981
IE Review & Evaluation of Licensee Conformance W/Tmi Action Plan Requirements 1.A.1.3, `Shift Manning Part 1,Limit Overtime
Project stage: Other
ML13317A6371981-06-17017 June 1981
Advises That Effluent Monitoring Sys,Per NUREG-0737,Item II.F.1 Will Not Be Completed Prior to Startup,As Remote Readout Gm Detector Has Been Removed.Interim Requirements of NUREG-0578 Will Be Met Per
Project stage: Other
1980-04-11
[Table View] |
Text
Southern California Edison. Company P. 0. BOX 800 2244 WALNUT GROVE AVENUE ROSEMEAD. CALIFORNIA 91770 K. P. BASKIN TELEPHONE MANAGER OF NUCLEAR ENGINEERING, July 1 (213) 572-1401 SAFETY, AND LICENSING Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention: D. M. Crutchfield, Chief Operating Reactors Branch No. 5 Division of Licensing U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Gentlemen:
Subject:
Docket No. 50-206 PORV Block Valve Adequacy Report San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station Unit 1
References:
- 1. Letter, K. P. Baskin, SCE, to D. M. Crutchfield, NRC, NUREG-0737, Item II.D.1 - Performance Testing of PWR Relief and Safety Valves, December 2, 1982
- 2.
Letter, K. P. Baskin, SCE, to D. M. Crutchfield, NRC, Implementation of TMI Action Plan Requirements, May 12, 1981 Reference 1 provided you with the PWR Safety and Relief Valve Adequacy Report for San Onofre Unit 1. The letter indicated that the report provided justification of the existing valve and piping configuration at San Onofre Unit I when the required modifications are completed. Reference 1 also indicated that due to a design difference between the San Onofre Unit 1 PORV block valves and the block valve tested at Marshall Steam Station, we would develop a plant specific justification for the block valves.
We indicated that the plant specific justification would include valve specific analyses, to be performed by the valve manufacturer Anchor/Darling. The PORV Block Valve Report was scheduled in Reference 1 to be submitted by June 1, 1983.
This commitment was confirmed by your Order Confirming Commitments dated March 14, 1983. As discussed in Reference 2, we interpret the completion dates contained in the Order Confirming Commitments to require the item to be completed by the specified date or the station shutdown until completion of the item, unless otherwise authorized by the NRC.
As you know, San Onofre Unit 1 was shutdown prior to June 1, 1983 and will remain shutdown until completion of the work related to the adequacy of the PORV block valves.
The information obtained to date, and the expected compl6tion dates of our work related to the adequacy of the PORV block valves are provided below.
8307250450 830713 PDR ADOCK 05000206 P
PDR1
Mr. D.
July 13, 1983 The Anchor/Darling contribution to the subject report is complete as of May 6, 1983. The Anchor/Darling portion of the effort yielded conclusive evidence that the block valves will perform the intended blocking function in the event of a post-accident stuck-open PORV scenario. The review and subsequent draft of a Westinghouse "PORV Block Valve Adequacy Report for San Onofre Unit 1" is currently scheduled to be completed by October 1, 1983, assuming successful verification of the items to follow.
The San Onofre Unit 1 block valve design, with the exception of the actuator, is comparable to the valve design used during the Marshall testing as shown in Table 1 (enclosed). The required opening and closing thrusts of the San Onofre Unit 1 block valve were derived from the test values adjusted for the differences in valve size and differential pressure. The calculated opening thrust is the maximum thrust required to unseat the valve based on the design differential pressure. The calculated closing thrust is the thrust necessary to seat the valve which is also based on the design differential pressure.
The actuator used to operate the San Onofre Unit 1 block valve is a pneumatic diaphragm actuator utilizing an internal, coil spring to provide the open force and pneumatic pressure the closing force. The available actuator opening force is based upon the spring rate and initial compression of the coil spring. The actuator closing force is based upon the air pressure supplied to the actuator. The actuator supplied with the San Onofre Unit 1 block valve is adequate to open and close the valve. The spring used in the actuator should have a spring rate of 1020 lbs. per inch and an initial compression of 2 inches. Since the actuator manufacturer supplies four (4) different spring sizes with this actuator, the spring size used in the San Onofre Unit 1 valve will be verified. The minimum supply air pressure to provide the required actuator closing force is 85 psig and this will be verified at San Onofre Unit 1.
The seating surfaces of the EPRI test valve were badly galled after the cycle testing and exhibited high seat leakage but, the leakage was not quantified.
We are attempting to define the precise impact this seat leakage will have on the function of this valve and will provide a more detailed description in the adequacy report. Additionally, the bonnet bolting needs to be verified to be torqued to 640 ft.-lbs. in order to prevent possible joint separation and external leakage during the anticipated valve loading.
A structural analysis of the valve shows stresses at critical sections which are below the allowable stresses (90% of yield strength),
except for the body-bonnet flange. Certain stresses in the flanges are approximately 5 percent greater than the yield strength of the flange material at the design temperature (6800F).
Although the stresses are above the yield strength, they are below the allowable stress limit permitted by ASME Section III, Division 1, paragraph NC-3647 which is the method that was used to determine the stresses.
Mr. D.
July 13, 1983 Based upon the above discussion, we will have to verify some Anchor/Darling assumptions and incorporate all of the information into a Westinghouse prepared San Onofre Unit 1 Block Valve Adequacy Report. As previously mentioned, this effort is scheduled to be complete, and will be submitted to you on or before October 1, 1983. We will advise you if there are any changes to this schedule.
If you have any questions regarding this issue for San Onofre Unit 1, please let me know.
Very truly yours, Enclosure
TABLE I Comparison of EPRI Test Valve and SCE Block Valve EPRI SCE BLOCK PARAMETER TEST VALVE VALVE Valve Description 3"-1540# Gate 2"-1500# Gate Drawing No.
93-15268 10529 Operating/Design Conditions Pressure (psig) 2405 2485 Temperature (oF) 650 680 Differential Press. (psi) 2405 2485 Flow Rate (lb/hr) 176,000 Material Body SA351-CF8M A351-CF8M Seat Surface Stellite No. 6 Stellite No. 6 Packing Crane 187-I Crane 187-I Valve Design Mean Seat Dia/Area (in/in 2) 2-7/8/6.49 1-7/8/2.76 Stem Dia/Area (in/in 2) 1-1/4/1.23 3/4 /.442 Stroke (in) 3-1/2 2-1/2 Packing Rings 4 Rings-Double 12 Rings Required Open Force (lb.)
Seat Load 6458 2838 Stem Unbalance (2958)
(1098)
Packing Drag 3000 1800 Total Open Force (lb.)
.6500 3540 Required Close Force (lb.)
Seat Load 8442 3714 Stem Unbalance 2958 1098 Packing Drag 3000 1800 Total Close Force (lb.)
14400 6612
