Discusses Deficiencies & Inadequacies in SER (NUREG-0793). Unresolved Safety Issues,Dewatering,Environ Degradation & Psychological Stress Upon Public Not Adequately AddressedML20054L994 |
Person / Time |
---|
Site: |
Midland |
---|
Issue date: |
07/08/1982 |
---|
From: |
Marshall W MAPLETON INTERVENORS |
---|
To: |
Hood D NRC |
---|
References |
---|
RTR-NUREG-0793, RTR-NUREG-793 NUDOCS 8207090135 |
Download: ML20054L994 (7) |
|
|
---|
Category:CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS
MONTHYEARML20137N1591997-03-31031 March 1997 Informs That Licensee Facility Scheduled to Administer NRC GFE on 970409.Sonalsts,Inc Authorized Under Contract to Support NRC Administration of GFE Activities ML20058M0361993-04-12012 April 1993 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents.Forwards Records in App L Which Are Being Withheld Partially for Listed Reasons,(Ref FOIA Exemptions 5) ML20248D6521989-07-20020 July 1989 Forwards Response to Util Re Bills D0184 & D0185 for Plant OL Application Review Costs by Various Program Ofcs Through June 1984 ML20245D9621989-04-28028 April 1989 Forwards Addl Info Re Bunker Ramo Instrumentation Penetration Modules,Per 890131 Request.Util Believes That Modules Environmentally Qualified in Accordance w/10CFR50.49 & NUREG-0588,Category II ML20205C3521988-09-23023 September 1988 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Plant. Forwards App D Documents.App D Documents Also Available in PDR ML20155A7001988-06-0202 June 1988 Informs That Const on Conversion of Plant to gas-fired Facility Began on 880404 ML20155A7401988-05-18018 May 1988 FOIA Request for Documents on 850731 & 870312 Meetings Re Plant.Document Re 840314 Meeting Previously Obtained & Therefore Excluded from Request ML20237B4361987-12-14014 December 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents.App B Document, Board Notification 84-024,encl & Also Available in PDR ML20236X6141987-12-0808 December 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request All Documents.No Addl Records Subj to Request Located ML20236U2571987-11-0505 November 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Ball Type Main Steam Isolation Valves Used at Facilities ML20235B3081987-09-21021 September 1987 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents,Including AEC to ACRS Forwarding Safety Evaluation Re Zimmer.App a Documents Cannot Be Located.App B Documents in Pdr.App C & D Documents Withheld (Ref 10CFR2.790) ML20235M4251987-07-13013 July 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Acrs. Forwards Documents for Categories One & Three of FOIA Request.Review of 21 Addl ACRS Documents Continuing ML20235K1731987-07-0909 July 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Info Re Certain Contracts Awarded by NRC for Reporting Svcs.Forwards App a & B Documents.Documents Also Available in PDR ML20234F0911987-06-26026 June 1987 Responds to Appeal Re Denial of FOIA Request for Documents. Forwards Document 5 in App F.Portions of Document 5 Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 6 & 7).Other Requested Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20215K1981987-06-19019 June 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Allegations Concerning Plant.Forwards App G & H Documents.Documents Also Available in Pdr.App H Documents Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20213F9351987-05-0808 May 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request.Forwards App F Document & Weld Allegations.App G Documents Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20206H4951987-04-13013 April 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Bechtel Employment Discrimination.Forwards App E Documents.App D Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20235G2321987-04-0101 April 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Forged NDE Inspectors Certification Supplied by Barclay Intl for Use at Quad Cities Nuclear Station & Stated Investigations at Plants ML20211A9531987-02-13013 February 1987 Advises That Financial Info Submitted for 1987 in Util Satisfies Requirements of 10CFR140.21 That Each Licensee Maintain Guarantee of Payment of Deferred Premiums for Operating Reactors Over 100 Mwe ML20212M7651987-01-16016 January 1987 Informs That Due to Demands on Staff,Nrc Will Respond by 870430 to 850607 Request for Review of Invoices D0184 & D0185 Re OL Application Review Costs Through 840623 ML20207C0151986-12-19019 December 1986 Forwards Notice of Withdrawal of Application for OLs & Termination of Proceeding,Per Util 860711 Request & ASLB 861217 Memorandum & Order Granting Motion ML20207C1191986-12-18018 December 1986 Forwards Order Terminating CPPR-81 & CPPR-82 Based on Fact That Const of Facility Ceased,Units Inoperable & Site Environmentally Stable,Per Util 860701 Request to Withdraw Application to Amend CPs ML20215B9641986-12-0505 December 1986 Notifies Util of 870204-05 Early Emergency Responders Workshop in Chicago,Il to Discuss Lessons Learned & Current Problems in Coordination & Integration of Emergency Response Efforts.Meeting Agenda & Preregistration Form Encl ML20214Q0911986-11-24024 November 1986 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Ofc of Inspector & Auditor Investigations.Forwards App B Documents. Documents Also Available in PDR ML20214A0761986-11-14014 November 1986 Forwards Insp & Evaluation of Plant for Adequacy of Stabilization Plan,Documenting 861015-16 Site Insp & Review & Insp of Site Stabilization Rept.Environ Stabilization Satisfactory ML20215N0241986-10-28028 October 1986 Forwards Order from DOE Economic Regulatory Admininstration Granting Exemption from Prohibitions of Power Plant & Industrial Fuel Act of 1978 & Puc of Mi Opinion & Order Granting Relief from Commission 850329 Rate Order ML20215M8851986-10-28028 October 1986 Forwards Insp Repts 50-329/86-01 & 50-330/86-01 on 861015-16.No Violations Identified ML20211B5401986-10-0909 October 1986 Further Response to FOIA Request for Eight Categories of Documents Re Ee Kent Allegations Concerning Facilities. Forwards Documents Listed in App K ML20210S9971986-10-0202 October 1986 Requests Change in Facility Svc List Address to Ref Address. Related Correspondence ML20210S4131986-09-26026 September 1986 Further Response to FOIA Request for 16 Categories of Records Re Facilities.Forwards App D & E Documents.Documents Also Available in PDR ML20214T7431986-09-24024 September 1986 Forwards Form 8-K Filed W/Securities & Exchange Commission. Util Believes Info Presented Bears No Issues Currently Before Aslb.Related Correspondence ML20214N4541986-09-0808 September 1986 Provides List of Activities Re Remedial Soils Work Being Modified Pending Final Disposition of Issues Described in Util 860701 & Counsel s Withdrawing Request for CP Extension.W/Svc List.Related Correspondence ML20209E6621986-09-0505 September 1986 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order.Documents Listed on App Available in PDR IA-86-235, Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order.Documents Listed on App Available in PDR1986-09-0505 September 1986 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order.Documents Listed on App Available in PDR ML20212K9061986-08-21021 August 1986 Forwards Request for Addl Info Re Environ Review of Util 860711 Request to Withdraw Applications for OL by 860828 ML20206M8311986-08-15015 August 1986 Forwards Util Response to ASLB 860716 Order.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20212J1391986-07-25025 July 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for June 1986.Listed Nonconformance Repts & Addl Documents Closed During June Encl ML20207D7261986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Aslab Jurisdiction.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20202F9581986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Util Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Appeal Board Jurisdiction,For Filing.W/O Encl ML20203B2351986-07-10010 July 1986 Informs That Review of 820622 Application to Receive Unirradiated Nuclear Fuel Assemblies Terminated,Per .Fission Chambers Should Be Disposed of & Licenses SNM-1904 & SNM-1905 Terminated,Per 10CFR70.38(b) ML20206T2401986-07-0101 July 1986 Advises That Since Facility Formally Abandoned as Nuclear Facility,Util Will Not Reply to Generic Ltr 86-05 Re TMI Action Item II.K.3.5 ML20202B1091986-07-0101 July 1986 Forwards Evaluation of 13 Specific Recommendations Contained in BNL Rept of Review of Surveillance & Maint Program,In Response to CE Norelius 860506 Request ML20206T4321986-07-0101 July 1986 Withdraws Application for Ols.Facility Will Be Converted to combined-cycle gas-fired Plant.Abandonment Actions & Equipment Sales Will Provide Assurance That Plant Cannot Be Used as Nuclear Facility ML20199J9181986-06-30030 June 1986 Submits ALAB-106 Quarterly Rept 51.No New Individuals Assigned quality-related Duties.Const Shut Down Since 840716 & No Const Activities Projected for Jul-Sept 1986 ML20211L0361986-06-25025 June 1986 Forwards Bechtel & B&W Nonconformance Repts for May 1986,per Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 ML20198E9051986-05-25025 May 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Apr 1986,including Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Equality Audit Finding,B&W Repts of Nonconformance & Audit Finding Repts. Only Nonconformance Repts Encl ML20205P9331986-05-23023 May 1986 Responds to Generic Ltr 86-10, Implementation of Fire Protection Requirements. Project in Surveillance & Maint Mode.Generic Ltr & FSAR Update Will Be Reviewed When Project Restarted ML20203Q2891986-05-0606 May 1986 Forwards BNL Technical Rept, Surveillance & Maint..., Based on NRC 851014-18 Insp.No Violations Noted.Items Identified Could Have Impact on Later Project Restart. Evaluation of Rept Recommendations Requested within 60 Days ML20203N3901986-05-0101 May 1986 Forwards Rev 2 to Tdi Owners Group App Ii:Generic Maint Matrix & Justifications. Rev Approved by Tdi Owners Group & Tdi ML20205N5861986-04-29029 April 1986 Forwards Corrected Page 1 to JW Cook to H Berkow Re Pipe Whip Restraint Design.Last Line Inadvertently Eliminated When Ltr Originally Issued 1997-03-31
[Table view] Category:INCOMING CORRESPONDENCE
MONTHYEARML20245D9621989-04-28028 April 1989 Forwards Addl Info Re Bunker Ramo Instrumentation Penetration Modules,Per 890131 Request.Util Believes That Modules Environmentally Qualified in Accordance w/10CFR50.49 & NUREG-0588,Category II ML20155A7001988-06-0202 June 1988 Informs That Const on Conversion of Plant to gas-fired Facility Began on 880404 ML20155A7401988-05-18018 May 1988 FOIA Request for Documents on 850731 & 870312 Meetings Re Plant.Document Re 840314 Meeting Previously Obtained & Therefore Excluded from Request ML20236U2571987-11-0505 November 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Ball Type Main Steam Isolation Valves Used at Facilities ML20216E4721987-05-28028 May 1987 Part 21 Rept 140 Re Potential Defect in Air Pressure Regulators Mfg by Bellofram.Dripwell Gasket May Fail Due to Mismachining of Gasket Seating Surface Causing Loss of Control Air & Starting Air Pressure ML20235G2321987-04-0101 April 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Forged NDE Inspectors Certification Supplied by Barclay Intl for Use at Quad Cities Nuclear Station & Stated Investigations at Plants ML20215N0241986-10-28028 October 1986 Forwards Order from DOE Economic Regulatory Admininstration Granting Exemption from Prohibitions of Power Plant & Industrial Fuel Act of 1978 & Puc of Mi Opinion & Order Granting Relief from Commission 850329 Rate Order ML20210S9971986-10-0202 October 1986 Requests Change in Facility Svc List Address to Ref Address. Related Correspondence ML20214T7431986-09-24024 September 1986 Forwards Form 8-K Filed W/Securities & Exchange Commission. Util Believes Info Presented Bears No Issues Currently Before Aslb.Related Correspondence ML20214N4541986-09-0808 September 1986 Provides List of Activities Re Remedial Soils Work Being Modified Pending Final Disposition of Issues Described in Util 860701 & Counsel s Withdrawing Request for CP Extension.W/Svc List.Related Correspondence ML20206M8311986-08-15015 August 1986 Forwards Util Response to ASLB 860716 Order.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20212J1391986-07-25025 July 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for June 1986.Listed Nonconformance Repts & Addl Documents Closed During June Encl ML20207D7261986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Aslab Jurisdiction.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20202F9581986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Util Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Appeal Board Jurisdiction,For Filing.W/O Encl ML20206T4321986-07-0101 July 1986 Withdraws Application for Ols.Facility Will Be Converted to combined-cycle gas-fired Plant.Abandonment Actions & Equipment Sales Will Provide Assurance That Plant Cannot Be Used as Nuclear Facility ML20202B1091986-07-0101 July 1986 Forwards Evaluation of 13 Specific Recommendations Contained in BNL Rept of Review of Surveillance & Maint Program,In Response to CE Norelius 860506 Request ML20206T2401986-07-0101 July 1986 Advises That Since Facility Formally Abandoned as Nuclear Facility,Util Will Not Reply to Generic Ltr 86-05 Re TMI Action Item II.K.3.5 ML20199J9181986-06-30030 June 1986 Submits ALAB-106 Quarterly Rept 51.No New Individuals Assigned quality-related Duties.Const Shut Down Since 840716 & No Const Activities Projected for Jul-Sept 1986 ML20211L0361986-06-25025 June 1986 Forwards Bechtel & B&W Nonconformance Repts for May 1986,per Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 ML20198E9051986-05-25025 May 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Apr 1986,including Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Equality Audit Finding,B&W Repts of Nonconformance & Audit Finding Repts. Only Nonconformance Repts Encl ML20205P9331986-05-23023 May 1986 Responds to Generic Ltr 86-10, Implementation of Fire Protection Requirements. Project in Surveillance & Maint Mode.Generic Ltr & FSAR Update Will Be Reviewed When Project Restarted ML20203N3901986-05-0101 May 1986 Forwards Rev 2 to Tdi Owners Group App Ii:Generic Maint Matrix & Justifications. Rev Approved by Tdi Owners Group & Tdi ML20205N5861986-04-29029 April 1986 Forwards Corrected Page 1 to JW Cook to H Berkow Re Pipe Whip Restraint Design.Last Line Inadvertently Eliminated When Ltr Originally Issued ML20197F8331986-04-28028 April 1986 Advises That Response to Generic Ltr 86-04 Re Engineering Expertise on Shift Inapproriate at Present Because Midland Not Currently Under Const.Commitment to Provide Info Will Be Added to Commitment Tracking Sys ML20210L2351986-04-25025 April 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Mar 1986,including Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts & Quality Audit Findings ML20203K8531986-04-23023 April 1986 Responds to NRC Re Allegation Concerning Adequacy of Pipe Whip Restraint Design.Project Records Placed in Storage & Personnel Performing Work Dispersed.Specific Design Approach Would Require Check of Records at Bechtel ML20203P1661986-04-21021 April 1986 Discusses 860407 Study Considering Options for Facility. Options Range from Abandonment of Facility to Completion as Nuclear Plant.Conversion of Plant to Combined Cycle gas-fired Plant Chosen as Most Favorable Option ML20209E6531986-03-28028 March 1986 FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order ML20140F8781986-03-25025 March 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Feb 1986,including Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts & Quality Audit Findings ML20154H9651986-02-25025 February 1986 Forwards Nonconformance Repts Written or Closed During Jan 1986,per Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 ML20154D3581986-02-24024 February 1986 Confirms Items Agreed Upon in 860219 Telcon Re soil-related Issues.Util Will Discontinue Monitoring Dike Groundwater Wells During Shutdown & Site Maint.Authorization Given to Seal Weeping Wall Crack ML20198H2401986-01-24024 January 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Dec 1985,including Bechtel Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts & Quality Audit Findings ML20136F4771985-12-31031 December 1985 Forwards PNL-5718, Review of Tdi Diesel Generator Owners Group Engine Requalification Program,Final Rept, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20138Q5531985-12-31031 December 1985 Submits ALAB-106 Quarterly Rept 50.No New Individuals Assigned quality-related Duties Since 850930 Rept & No Const Activities Projected for Jan-Mar 1986 ML20136C5711985-12-20020 December 1985 Forwards Monthly Rept for Nov 1985,including Bechtel Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts,Quality Audit Findings,B&W Repts of Nonconformity & Util Nonconformance Repts,Per ALAB-106 ML20138Q3871985-12-13013 December 1985 Ack Receipt of 851115 IE Bulletin 85-003, Motor-Operated Valve Common Mode Failures During Plant Transients Due to Improper Switch Settings. Valve Operability Program & Rept Scheduled to Be Completed Prior to OL Issuance ML20137Z1481985-11-27027 November 1985 Advises That Response to 851029 IE Bulletin 85-001, Steam Binding of Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps, Inappropriate at Present Since Plant in Surveillance & Maint Status.Schedule for Response Will Be Provided When Status Changes ML20137F2541985-11-25025 November 1985 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Oct 1985,including Bechtel Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts & Quality Audit Findings,Per 730323 Order ALAB-106 & Amend 1 to Cp.Svc List Encl ML20138J4431985-10-25025 October 1985 Forwards Monthly Rept for Sept 1985,per Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 & Amend 1 to Cp,Including Bechtel Nonconformance Rept,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts, Quality Audit Findings & B&W Repts of Nonconformity ML20138D0031985-10-14014 October 1985 Informs That Util Will Submit Schedule for Meeting Requirements of 10CFR50.62(d) Per Generic Ltr 85-06 Re QA Guidance for ATWS nonsafety-related Equipment When & If Project Reactivated ML20133F7581985-10-0808 October 1985 Informs of Plans to Physically Disable Equipment Installed in & About Evaporator Bldg to Serve Process Steam to Dow Chemical Co,Per 850925 Resolution.Equipment & Structures Abandoned Are non-Q.Related Correspondence ML20137Y7921985-09-30030 September 1985 Submits Quarterly Rept 49,per ALAB-106.No New Individuals Assigned to quality-related Duties.Const at Plant Shut Down on 840716.No Const Projected for Fourth Quarter 1985.Next Quarterly Rept Will Be Submitted by End of Dec 1985 ML20133A3141985-09-27027 September 1985 Forwards Review of Section 4.7 of Technical Evaluation Rept PNL-5600, Review of Resolution of Known Problems in Engine Components for Tdi Emergency Diesel Generators, Reflecting Views Re Crankshafts for 16-cylinder Engines ML20133H1261985-09-25025 September 1985 Forwards Bechtel Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts & Quality Audit Findings Written or Closed During Aug 1985,per Condition of Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 ML20138S0731985-09-17017 September 1985 Advises That Addl Excavation Between Tank Farm & Auxiliary Bldg Will Be Conducted Per NRC 850826 Authorization. Excavation Needed to Provide Supplemental Cathodic Protection.Svc List Encl.Related Correspondence ML20133H8841985-09-16016 September 1985 Discusses Ee Kent Allegations Re Plant,Per Encl . Decision Reflected in NRC Should Be Reconsidered. B Garde & T Devine of Gap Unwilling to Testify for Kent.Kent & Counsel Unable to Produce Expert Witnesses ML20140G8331985-08-23023 August 1985 FOIA Request for ACRS Documents Re Facility ML20137F7061985-08-12012 August 1985 Forwards Listed Documents Written or Closed During Jul 1985, in Accordance w/730323 Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 & Amend 1 to Cp.Only Nonconformance Repts Encl ML20133L8331985-08-0909 August 1985 Forwards Attachment 1 to Revised Exhibit D of Revised Compliance Filing & Application for Authorization to Issue Securities.Plan Is Requirement of Agreements W/Banks to Restructure Outstanding Debt.Related Correspondence ML20132B1841985-07-19019 July 1985 Forwards Monthly Repts for May & June 1985 Per Condition of 730323 Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 & Amend 1 to Cp.Related Correspondence 1989-04-28
[Table view] Category:PUBLIC ENTITY/CITIZEN/ORGANIZATION/MEDIA TO NRC
MONTHYEARML20210S9971986-10-0202 October 1986 Requests Change in Facility Svc List Address to Ref Address. Related Correspondence ML20211E3271984-10-0101 October 1984 FOIA Request for All Documentation,Including Notes,Ltrs, Memoranda,Computer Printouts & Data Compilations Re Board Notification 84-149 Concerning Investigation Repts on Comanche Peak ML20101U5541984-06-15015 June 1984 FOIA Request for All Agency Records Generated in Connection W/Dg Eisenhut 840524 Request for Addl Info Re Structural Adequacy of Plant Diesel Generator Bldg ML20112E4681984-05-22022 May 1984 FOIA Request for Documents Re Meetings Between Members of Nrr,J Kane,H Singh,F Rinaldi & Others Re Resolution of Diesel Generator Bldg & Implementation of Recommendations or Conclusions from Brookhaven 831021 Rept ML20084K8631984-05-11011 May 1984 Forwards Intervenor B Stamiris Second Supplemental Proposed Finding & Conclusions of Law Re QA & Mgt Attitude Issues & cross-reference to Previously Filed Proposed Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law ML20084Q3491984-05-10010 May 1984 Requests That J Keppler Respond to Listed Issues Re Evaluation of Facility Completion.Caseload Forecast Panel Evaluation of Plant,Taking Into Account Issues Discussed, Also Requested ML20084L6261984-05-10010 May 1984 Questions J Keppler Statement That Util Projected Schedule for Finishing Unit 2 by Dec 1986 Attainable & No Caseload Forecast Panel Evaluation Planned.Objective Caseload Forecast Panel Evaluation Requested ML20090K6941984-05-0202 May 1984 Expresses Belief That Intervenors Govt Accountability Project,Lone Tree Council & M Sinclair Represent Small Minority of Community Persons Not Wanting Plants Completed & Operating.Majority of People in Favor of Facility Operation ML20112D2991984-05-0202 May 1984 FOIA Request for Documents Re Insp of Auxiliary Bldg ML20084N3611984-05-0101 May 1984 Presents Differing View from M Sinclair Re Safety Concerns. Closing of Plant Would Result in 5,000 Lost Jobs & Create far-reaching Economic Hardship Throughout Community ML20090K7211984-04-30030 April 1984 Expresses Belief That Intervenors Govt Accountability Project,Lone Tree Council,M Sinclair & B Stamaris Represent Minority of Community Persons Not Wanting Plants Completed & Operating.Majority in Favor of Operation ML20084K6471984-04-30030 April 1984 Contends That Govt Accountability Project,Lone Tree Council, M Sinclair & Representatives of B Stamiris Do Not Represent Majority of Midland County Population ML20084M6381984-04-30030 April 1984 Contends That Intervenors Govt Accountability Project,Lone Tree Council,B Stamaris & M Sinclair Do Not Represent Midland County Community,As Intervenors Claim ML20090K7121984-04-30030 April 1984 Expresses Belief That Govt Accountability Project,Lone Tree Council,M Sinclair & Representatives of B Stamaris Do Not Represent Majority of Midland,Mi as Claimed ML20084K3711984-04-30030 April 1984 Contends That Govt Accountability Project,Lone Tree Council, M Sinclair & Representative of B Stamiris Do Not Represent Majority of Midland County Population ML20100F5011984-03-0606 March 1984 Supplemental FOIA Request for Four Categories of Documents, Including Trip Repts to Region III or Facility & Vaugh Index ML20087P0531984-01-30030 January 1984 Discusses Encl Newspaper Article Re QA Problems at Facility. Increase in Number of Inspectors at Plant Requested ML20080T6271984-01-17017 January 1984 Appeals Denial of FOIA Request for T Novak Notes Generated by or During Visit to Glen Ellyn,Il to Discuss Ofc of Special Cases Findings Re Facilities from Sept 1982 to Dec 1983 ML20083N2151984-01-0909 January 1984 FOIA Request for Documents Generated by Kane or Singh for Evaluation of BNL Rept Re Diesel Generator Bldg at Facility ML20084S1421984-01-0909 January 1984 FOIA Request for Documents Re Executive Notice 83-69 on Facilities ML20079Q6931983-12-30030 December 1983 Requests Cessation of Radioactive Matls Discharge Into Tittabawassee River.Synergistic Effect W/Radioactivity Increases Cancer Possibility ML20082N9291983-12-0505 December 1983 Forwards Stamiris Exhibit 140,consisting of Applicant Responses to Stamiris Interrogatories 14,28,31 & 19(a). Applicant Two Sets of Supplementary Responses Should Be Filed W/Aslb.Svc List Encl ML20086Q4011983-11-26026 November 1983 FOIA Request for Agency Records & Info Generated in Connection W/Or as Result of T Novak Visit to Region III Ofc to Discuss Ofc of Special Cases Findings on Facilities from Sept 1982 - Dec 1983 ML20080B2781983-11-26026 November 1983 FOIA Request for Records Generated in Connection W/Ta Rehm to Bp Garde Re Midland Caseload Forecast Panel ML20086Q2611983-11-26026 November 1983 FOIA Request for Documents Re 831025 Meeting Between Util & NRC Concerning Mgt Audit & Associated 10CFR2.206 Request ML20078R5091983-10-31031 October 1983 Commends Util Efforts to Develop Employee Assistance Program to Deal W/Employee Substance Abuse Problems.Pressure Should Be Placed on Remaining Contractors & Subcontractors to Develop Similar Programs ML20080S7061983-10-13013 October 1983 Expresses Concern Re Discrepancies in Const Completion Schedule.Public Meeting Warranted in Light of Varying Completion Dates ML20086J3781983-09-28028 September 1983 FOIA Request for IE 800103 Rept Re Review of Matl False Statement at Facilities,Associated & Supporting Records to Rept & Repts Prepared in Response ML20080J5801983-08-19019 August 1983 Requests Answer to Question Raised During 830811 Public Meeting by B Stamiris Re NRR Review of Const Completion Plan & Individuals Consulted.Appointment of Independent Geotechnical Consultant to Review Work Suggested ML20078K8791983-08-10010 August 1983 Appeals Denial of FOIA Request for Documents Re Caseload Forecast Panel 830419 Meeting on Plant Const.Denial Effectively Denied Bulk of Documents Requested ML20077J4501983-08-0808 August 1983 Requests Names of Review Team Members,Methodology & Plans for Public Participation Re Review of R Landsman Concerns Over Structural Adequacy of Diesel Generator Bldg ML20078G9471983-08-0808 August 1983 FOIA Request for All Records on re-review of Structural Adequacy of Diesel Generator Bldg Subsequent to May Testimony of R Landsman in ASLB Proceedings ML20082G3931983-08-0505 August 1983 FOIA Request for Records on 830615 Briefing of Commissioners Re Facilities ML20078K1741983-08-0505 August 1983 FOIA Request for Documents Submitted by Util for Consideration of Candidate Companies or Methodologies to Perform Const Implementation Overview of Const Completion Plan ML20078K8921983-07-11011 July 1983 FOIA Request for Documents Re Caseload Forecast Panel 830419 Meeting on Plant Const ML20077F3151983-06-22022 June 1983 Forwards Govt Accountability Project (Gap) Rept of Gap Investigation Into Region V/Nrr Effort on Former Bechtel Employee Allegations Re Welding Practices ML20071P8951983-06-0101 June 1983 Requests Info Re Total Number of Wells & Amount of Electricity Required to Operate Wells for Dewatering ML20024B0931983-05-31031 May 1983 Ack Receipt of Response Re Independent Audit of Facility. Truly Independent Audit Should Include Full Scope Overview of Completed Const Done by Third Party Rather than Util ML20076B0961983-05-16016 May 1983 FOIA Request for Matls Re Release of Draft Insp Rept to Util from Region III Dealing W/Startup Test Program for Facilities ML20023C5171983-04-21021 April 1983 Requests Assurance of Independent Agent to Perform Facility Audits,Per NRC 830419 Reinsp Order ML20069L1531983-04-19019 April 1983 Responds to Informal Discovery Questions Re Insp Repts, Deviation Repts,Attachment 10 Repts & Return Options in QA Sys.Containment Chipping Incident Was First Identified as Noncompliance by Region III During Oct-Nov Team Insp ML20090F1921983-04-18018 April 1983 Discusses Subcontractor Employee Concerns Re Unqualified Personnel at Plant Site in Jobs of Critical Importance to Safety,Poor Installation & Lack of Worker Qualification on Zack Design.Investigation Requested ML20024D7271983-04-0505 April 1983 FOIA Request for Documents Re Incineration of Radioactive Matls by Dow Chemical Co at Facilities ML20072S6431983-03-30030 March 1983 Supports Halting of Nuclear Legacy & Opposes Plant Opening Until Permanant Nuclear Waste Storage Method Devised ML20072M3921983-03-29029 March 1983 Requests to Make Limited Appearance Statement at 830329 OL Hearing ML20072M5911983-03-25025 March 1983 Supports OL Issuance ML20072M6371983-03-25025 March 1983 Voices Support for Startup of Facility ML20073E3811983-03-25025 March 1983 Expresses Outrage That Confirmed Items,Indicated in Tera Corp Re Independent Design Verification of HVAC Equipment Directly Affecting Control Room,Not Reported to Nrc.Details Should Be Provided to NRC & CPC at Same Time ML20072H6481983-03-25025 March 1983 Requests to Testify at 830329 Hearings ML20072T3481983-03-25025 March 1983 Ack Receipt of Re Tera Corp QA & Engineering Plans for Independent Design & Const Verification Program. HVAC Sys Adequacy Determination Methodology Requested.Info Distribution Requirements Should Be Clarified 1986-10-02
[Table view] |
Text
'
l Wendell H. Marshall MAPLETON INTERVENERS Route 10 Midland, MI 48640 July 8,1982 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555
Subject:
Deficiencies and Inadequacies found in Safety Evaluation Report (NUREG-0793) prepared by Nuclear Regulatory Commission related to the operation of Midland Nuclear Plant Units 1 & 2 Dockets Nos. 50-329 and 50-330.
Gentlemen:
This is the second report prepared by the staff of the Mapleton Interveners on the above SER. As a result of our study of the SER (Sec. 3.7.1 thru 15.5) we have come to the following conclusions.
- 1. SER has a tolerant attitude toward applicant.
- 2. NRC is reluctant to order Consumers Power Co. (CPC) to meet regulatory requirements.
- 3. Variances and exemptions granted to CPC which may affect the public health.
- 4. The many unresolved safety issues which affect the public health and safety.
- 5. No recommendation for permanent radiation monitoring equipment for installation in Midland and nearby communities.
- 6. The apparent staff desire to license the operation regardless of the public . 'th and safety.
- 7. No requirement for additional insurance which is available. (See NUREG-0891).
- 8. NRC unable to understand that people want protection against radiation rather than a license for the plant.
- 9. Glossing over the seriousness of the soil's problem which endangers the public health &
safety.
- 10. Nothing in SER about the dumping of heat, ammonia and radioactivity into the Tittabawassee River.
- 11. Permitting the discharge of gaseous radioactivity to the atmosphere including radioactive Iodine.
- 12. NRC Staff appears to find itself under intense pressure to compromise on the public health and safety in order to conclude that Midland Nuclear Plant can be operated without resolution of unresolved safety issues and other items peculiar to B & W plants and TMI.
- 13. Failure to consider synergistic effects of pollutants from CPC and Dow Chemical Co.,
discharged to the River and to the atmosphere.
8207090135 820708 PDR ADOCK 05000329 PDR E
I l
' 14. Failure to insist that cooling towers be utilized.
- 15. Failure to include decomissioning plans for Units 1 & 2 and the costs thereof. ,
Herewith some items from the SER 3.7.1 Supplement to SER will be issued on Seismic Category Structures - 1 i 3.7.2 Seismic analysis will be discussed in supplement to SER 3.7.3 Seismic sub systems analysis evaluation of safe shut down of plant will be issued in a supplement to the SER - Also Seismic Analysis of buried pipes to be issued by staff supplement to SER 3.8.2 A confirmatory item. How can staff state they have reasonable assurance that requirements will be met?
3.8.1 Resolution of open items on containment will satisfy requirements of GDC 2, 416 and 50 i 3.8.2 Use of masonry walls in seismic category I structures is not in the intent of public health and safety the staff has reasonable assurance that this confirmatory item. De resolution of this.
- 3. Open items related evaluation of masonry walls. Masonry walls are not allowed in California quake areas.
3.8.3 Related eroding of concrete due to extensive soil settlement is an open safety item 3.8.4 Foundation support problems are not resolved and constitute a safety problem which i has not been resolved. De epoxying of all significant cracks (presumably in cement) does not add to integrity of the structures.
3.8.4 "De applicant's intent to comply with established criteria, codes, standards and r specifications acceptable to staff was not carried out because of sinking buildings, soil !
problems, dewatering to prevent liquification and present remedial action and this violation does not constitute an acceptable basics for satisfying requirements of GDC 2 and 4 i
3.9.2.3 CPC is not performing a plant-specific analysis of either Units 1 or 2 reactor !
internals for combined safe shut down. Since Midland 1 and 2 are similar to TMI 1 and 2, the CPC should use this as a baseline instead of using Davis-Besse as a baseline. CPC is ,
to submit the results of the analysis by April of 1983. His is a safety related item. De staff will report on resolutions of the issues in a supplement to the SER. Will major pipe [
breaks withstand LOCC conditions.
3.9.3 Buried water piping exposed to large soil settlement will be removed by staff and [
constitutes an open safety item - review will be reported in supplement to the SER. All !
large diameter pipe will be removed, replaced and reburied. Re-analysis of the results will be done by staff and remains an open item affecting the public health and safety. Item 5 of 3.9.3.2 concerning removal and releading of buried pipe less than 26" in diameter will be conducted in a supplement to the SER. [
j 3.9.3.3 Failure of reactor hold down studs analysis will be reported in supplement to the !
SER since it is a safety item.
i
[
___ .__ . . . ~ , _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
3.9.6 ASME code requires testing in accordance with Sec. XI of ASME Code as required by 10 CFR 50.55a(g). Since this is a safety item affecting the public health and safety the variance granted by NRC to CPC is a violation of NRC regulations and in view of the Besse-Davis and TMI accidents should be withdrawn.
3.10 Re-evaluation of Seismic Equipment is an open item affecting public health and safety. Audit of equipment is an open item and will be reported in a supplement to SER 3.11 Environmental qualification of mechanical and electrical equipment has not been
- qualified and staff has been unable to evaluate CPC's EQ program. His is an open item t that will be included in a supplement to the SER 4.2.3.1 IIold down spring integrity is questioned due to experience of spring failures at other B & W plants 4.2.3.2 Fuel rods mechanical fracturing is an unresolved open item. A report will be in supplement to this SER 4.4.4.1 Cone cooling instrumentation is inadequate and does not meet items IIF.2 of N UREG-0737. Ris is a safety item and affects public health and safety and the license cannot be granted i 4.4.4.1 LPMS should be evaluated for conformance with Regulating Guide 1.133 4.4.5 Operation with less than 4 pumps is a safety related item and CPC should consider 7 l the safety implication; of a 2 or 3 pump operation.
5.2.4.1 Evaluation of PSI (Preservice inspection) to be presented in a Supp to the SER.
l 5.2.4.3 (Page 5-14) A confirmatory issue effecting the public health and safety.
5.3.1.2 Par III P. 4 of Appendix G requirs testing personnel "shall be qualified and shall be able to perform tests according to written procedures". The exemption or variance for waiving this requirement certainly lessens the integrity of the tuting procedures and many impacts on safety.
Par III C.2 Appendix G was not complied with and there is no justification for giving variances or exceptions to regulatory procedures since the public health and safety is insured.
Requirements of Par IVB of Appendix G is exempted by variance granted NRC to CPC.
l 5.3.1.3 Exceptions or variances to Par II.B and Par 11 C.1 and therefore the CPC surveillance program is not in compliance with Appendix H/10CFR/50.
De granting of exemptions or variance to Par HI B.4, III C.2, IV A.1, IV A3, IV B of Appendix G and Par II B and II C of Appendix H will result in environmental impacts and will effect the public's health and safety. De mies and regulations must be enforced in behalf of the problem even if it imposes more work on the applicant CPC.
1 5.3.3 Par III B.4 Appendix G unqualified personnel to conduct tests - why?
Par III C.2 Appendix G the failure of applicant to prepare metallurgical test samples from j
exces production forging material. No variance is justified - remember TMI.
l i
P 5.4.2.2.3 How can Applicant meet Regulatory Guide 1.83 NUREG-OLD3 when only part of the requirements are met. 1 5.4.3.1 An open item on nozzle cooling at other B & W plants including Midland. ,.
5.4.4.1 ne staff is to report the applicants performance of required tests and analysis in ,
a supp to this SER. In spite of noted deficiencies in design of the DHR the staff concludes DHR System complete; with SRP Sec 5.4.7 and is acceptable. What a stretch of ;
imagination.
~
5.4.6 An open item on the vessel head vent.
5.5.6 A confirmatory item important to the plant safety and the public health.
6.1.1.3.2 Applicant has not completed the procedure for relating radioactive isotopes to estimated ???? damage and has not complied with regulatory requirements, therefore, license cannot be granted.
l 6.2.1.2 Staff will report in Supp to the SER on applicant's submission of loads and moments within the steam generator.
6.2.4.4 Delenis screen acceptability will be reported in a supp to this SER.
I 6.2.6 De steff to evaluate the applicant's justification for not tating valves in a supp to this report. The applicant has not included the information on the leakage in the offsite dose.
6.3.5 In item 2."--verified by analysis based on built-in curves rather than by test". It is our contention that operating tests affords a more realistic data - especially since the health and welfare and safety are concerned.
6.4 Page 6-36. If the control room at Midland is the same as TMI then it appears that the control room does not meet the requirements of NUREG-0737 items #0.3.4 and GDC 19.
6.5.1.2 How can the staff state with such certainty that the system decontamination efficiencies are 99% for iodine and 99% for particulates following a partulated DDA.
l 6.6.1 ne uncompleted evaluation of the PSI program will be in a supp to this SER.
6.6.3 A supp to this SER on the evaluation of compliance with 10CFR50.55a(b). The staff
! considers PSI to be a confirmatory issue based on CPC's submittal for all variance requirements. In view of TMI how can HRS give variances specially since it concerns the public health and safety. It appears that NRC, in this SER, is speeding up the licensing process without regard to safety or the public health, 7.1.3.1 Dere are 9 confirmatory items which the staff states will not be addressed in this SER unless. unanticipated problems; arise - TMI notwithstanding. ,
) 7.2.3 E onomics is the basis for the design of Midlarxl integrated control system. A l turbine trip should trip the reactor, however, the excuse is used that this safety feature will be eliminated since the plant furnishes steam to Dow Chemical - are economics more important than safety;, evidently in NRC's rush to license they forego safety and the l public's health. As a suggestion why not have CPC generate steam with gas which is I available at the plant site in event of a turbine-reactor trip. How can staff find that non-conformance by CPC to safety-grade requirements is acceptable?
l
, . 2 9.1.2.1 The spent fuel storage facility provides for this storage of 1049 fuel assemblies rpproximating 5% full core loads. When the spent fuel storage is filled with spent fuel will !
the plant close? s Why does not the SER spell out actions taken when spent fuel pool is filled with spent fuel. l 9.4.2 The spent fuel pools ventilation system limits radioactive releases to atmosphere.
Why not prevent the radioactive releases to atmosphere.
9.4.3 The system is designed, according to SER, to control release of radioactive effluents to the environment during normal plant operations. What is the control in release of radioactivity under design basis accidents? How is the public health and safety protected?
10.3.2 Continuity of steam to Dow is given priority over electric power generators. It seems that the electric rate payer is forced to pay to subsidize Dow Chemical Company.
11.3.1 'Ihe gaseous waste management system allows the discharge of radioactive gases to the environment during normal operations.
(1) Why dischange any radioactivity to environment?
(2) When plant is not operating normally, or during an accident, are radioactive gases contained?
(3) Will discharges be simiiar to TMI?
(4) Why discharge ventilation exhaust air from turbine building and main condenser air ejector exhaust directly to atmosphere without processing thru a high efficiency air filter.
(5) What right does NRC and CPC have to impose annual doses to the public. The discharge of radioactive iodine is a criminal act perpetrated against the public health and safety. <
11.5.2 105 UCi/cc Value (2) the staff credits DILUTION. Since when does dilution become a solution to pollution.
15.5 How was determination made that the LPS after 8 hours9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br /> is neglible?
In conclusion, it is our opinion that the SER does not address itself adequately to the serious aspects of the radiologocal, UNRESOLVED safety issues, dewatering, ENVIRONMENTAL DEGRADATION, and the stress upon the public due to fear of radiation and possible TMI type of accident.
t A recent discussion by U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia requires HRC to consider public fear as a type of pollution. Environmental law protects mental health.
In Midland; there is fear of radiation from the nuclear plant and fear of a TMI type of accident. "Ihis fear is a psychology stress on the residents, especially in view of the fact that the plant is in the city of Midland, i
L
0 We at the Mapleton Interveners request information as h<>w NRC could possibly give a license to CPS when there are so many unresolved safety issues and statements to the fact that these will be reported in another document.
Yours tmly,
, f( 'bf Wendell H. Marshall cc: Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board C. Bechhoefer, ASLB F. P. Cowan, ASLB R. J. Cook, Midland Resident Inspector R. S. Decket, ASLB Steve J. Gadler, P.E.
J. Harbour, ASLB D. S. Hood, NRC J. D. Kane, NRC F. J. Kelley, Esq.
W. D. Paton, Esq, (NRC)
B. Stamiris Mary Sinclair NRC Document Room Michael Miller
\'
i We dell 11. Marshall 4 r. . , s
. _ _ - - N ,::: };
jff
., - % (
MA LETON INTERVENORS .
RI 1 10 M dland, Michigan 48640 T
% PM 81c
,.~ %vy
" ~
2C y
i
/c e
.7, , , . _ , -
i I i D. S. Hood . .
5.-
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 0
t .
b 6
1 l I
-- - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ . .-<
l