ML20206E751

Partial Response to FOIA Request for Plant Info.Documents Listed in App Q Totally Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)

ML20206E751
Person / Time
Site:	Pilgrim
Issue date:	11/10/1988
From:	Grimsley D NRC
To:	Johnson G SWIDLER & BERLIN
References
FOIA-88-198 NUDOCS 8811180184
Download: ML20206E751 (3)

Text

-- - -

w s ,o e.w %o e- - ,

I e

60. CE3DOCO 006m0000 < Sxxuxw '

e F0!A-88-198 e'"..* % e' eiseocni I s

'f RESPONSE TO FRt(DOM CF 'I

' E ** d '" '

INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST {s\

\j I

• et.e smitt.7mTmeee_.1~0 NQM jggg i

- l

.e u s,..

l

_ Georg- E. Johnson. Esquire ___ _ _

50/293 PAtt 8. 94 COA 06 RILI AStO CA 40f 40C Af tD (See saeceev 6esosi he ege ee esce*Je ei tst to re gowest ke,e besa bee +et Ne ese*eret egear, weres tw4.ect to te seewest beve toen hete'ee ASMC,'ete's Abect te Pe 0+ees Pet e o seatfes in aseea&B e", epostv e,edot.e les pwtet es4*ctue. erig gegeng e e4 %4C PJang Doc,* eat Boese

,1717 M Street. 4 W , W eeheig*em. DC a pac, mea e,4.c,,e e4 'eust *-t e o me. tees se a ee4. _, _ _,_ _ e.s e g .4m e,e-et.e 's, eau ces.c.e, re ie,,eg e ce ge em em.t 1 mew 1517 at tw % w , Wn'estea DC. e e 'ones w a ee we to a vate. es ree. eve. **+e s' **, ste" e we teet *ese e eeeeie 4s p.tet recettee the acr$tte*e e4 **'t** ed 'p*e 8*e0(48' 61 thei e*w of'e*8 to ecs ett

• ev 'eer^eae sta**=e** e14 one seveg .1 ee %eg Pwe e as.weas meeg 1717 as $weet %W W es>cyeen OC . p 4 4eae. ww .

we tea 90iawse*

a mee.e eq %,ee, me.,

4ackeed e Neametca en hee ,0= me, opeia -cose to eM ee the es to 443v g ee(sees swed e we hec Pwene Des, meat floods 9717 M $teset h W , W eeNegten. M Ay, tecess mAem;t to ee 'eSest Fe eNtones Amt 8@@detetda tes'ge ter (epe p Pe reseees PevWed Gad pe,* eat poteepes to meted e pq sepowe'emis encten Raceres eJett to t** %est **.e tete 'edeae4 te erewe* Feseer ege*evim' 'r re=ee are 8*eci 'esseree te vee ,

.ee.e,s.Ce. .etoee.e- ,ew o me,et. ,to.e

e. e 4,. .e4 _ __

j P ART te A-4%fchWafl0% Wif MMELD tmCM PVOL'C OISCLOS84 -

! Ceted e******ma e N tee.ested '90F00 e tem ur'e**4 Fem Swtae 6%W pv'eveat to P4 $0'A ene*$teme eset'tes e e94 9er es 'tetere Setet e Poi W, tot- l e

mese e. C. re o ag ,,ee.es porterss e ce evmees 4e tw era, seg e ** ecees e tem e e%4 e o tog eeoe e.eem 4 pwees essasen ne serv g e v.e haC Pwt4 Dw a 9 neem,1717 m si.eet. % W . Wumeg+en DC, e e 'em w^e+ the FF A r,*ee es *ee.ece reae l Cews 8911180184 881110 POR FOIA

@ NCON96-198 PDR l

s Y-poieon n ovw?. un e== =_.jf suLd i

j 442c ,os v ...

.e

e (a  !

Pet 039044 to leepostesAttoes ACT nes#0este ac:A evowetet 88-198 oat: 0W -i 8 PA..t C $- AP,LICL448 poi &'[ElMPrlO8 4 f nw 4.

,,eew t.ad ct for to the theru.on e.av.e.et t to thv.teiow e.ure.4 pursu.nt e th.

to 6 .ncio V S C. ateetoAcc .ndns.c O

to Cf A 9 Sm of NmC megut. ton..

_ .. t, ag *,th8.id in in .nt,e, o, in p.,1 uno., rotA i E )

i

i. m we .emw . p , ew.e i. t.x,*. o. irmsuvero ii }

2. ?>. %h.se W,m..on i.9 .on.8v t. ib. e m.i s.so,e.t evt .ne e.c.s ,, .f NmC itatUpt10N 2)

. ra. w w m . w ...,wt ,*. w ,..,uv. . nituverm>>

t s,. a teia s .e

. a ., Au <a p* ~ .xw. e . .mw oc. e.~ . . miu oc. i.: u s c siet ze. j

/, S.C.or.147 8 e. As.pu. 4,wrgy A."t .%86 p.Ntet. e. decio S .i Omet.w' S.'.9,.a W ,w.t.a142 y 5 C filh_

t a tm. w.e w,~m . . m. .. . rw +w ~ u. . % .,* ., ~ ,. -.i mu. itu vetm ei l

% .,~ .n mt..ne w eie.e.wi+~~ f

~ + ~ _ ..._~~_,_,..c,,.. l N w- .. .#, .e. < a > .m.ac. se . i, e n. w , io c,a a m #

• , .. , .w. w. ., e , *~- t s..m = +~,~

m . e.,,* n.%.

c. uw.e m..

ee, . e., c.

. = e. .

ec.. . . . . ou n ~ e- ..~.w.w  ;

,i.m ~. f .e.v .. - . e e. n .,. .c ...s n t. . e c. .. ,

~ innwu9o. r XX {

7 i

s. m ~ . ,~ a.... ,w m .x w .t. .< w .. w si4.. , c e . e r .e,innver a e,

(

t. w .w - e wm ,w .ww .. +- - .e. . e. e. - m.w auv.tm n j

.,e. e .a

. .a u - .n. ,. .

o w. --. . -

, ., , =.e e m. a.- ,.

uuto,w.,  ;

, *. . i . u .a r mw s . v.~.. :% . . .--.e.

- i

o. w .. a . m e.., ..ew ae ,e .n,inun o.wea w - - .., ,e ~. , .a .~, , u . w . e < e. ~ e. ~ , , 4 u vev o: ton Paal." c- Wfi 3.9t"c15s

= ,.w = e . e ... c .~.

r s . ,ecense aw .. t ~ .s ~ -.,~ -. ~ s.. ~,,,,.

w e.% -

c. e. c... .

. eti.e a v.5 .~+ c.n ,t w . ~ ~

,,i. ~ ,. . i n .~i.g. =. v4 == c~.

~ .e *. ., e. . cw. . j c4E3"bs p.ctai titta c4eict asc5Es~ciiXo'~ ' ArnT41iT4iEA6 i

! 7egional A&Iinistrator.

Appendix Q

_ ri"' *" 'p i Millh m T. RWisell Region _!  ;

1 4

1

}

l 1

I P Anf a p- AeptAt AIGHTS f __

Tee o.nw t., ..ch o.6,vig omc I hfes e P.4 la C m.. t. .ccuw to th. Asu re. 0%.I cer.t>f.s cton. Any such .co.1 must te e ff

{ ,,w. x e . o , .c e w. r.wn Ac s e.eioth.t u s.wwt.w o.wt. e. cween. e th. t. m ~a w mt., .m- t = u.a of th. C.rc*w .e.cn. U S. Nwo r Aep.to,y Comen on, W..hinf e

Jc th. tai..a Acc covna *** f nSe.

OiA Owret.,)

son. p

• • c .4** #8 i'.9 8 U S. NUCtt AR REGULATORY COMMilllON 4

< om FOlA RESPONSE CONTINUATION l

o Re: FO!Ao 88-198 ___

APPEN01X _Q __

RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHEL0 _

NUMBER, DATE DESCRIRTION & EXEMPTION (All records v;tthheld - Exemption 5)

1. Undated Ptigrim Background - EP !ssues (6 Pages)

2. L'ada t.ed Ptigrim Information (1 Page) 3, 6/23/87 FEFA Submittal Punch'ist (3 Pages) 4, 7/10/87 J. Schumacher: E. Thomas, RAC Memo

Subject:

RAC Review of Region I FEMA Self-Initiated Review of NRC Ptigria NP5 EPZ (2 Pages) 5, 7/24/87

" " " " Memo

Subject:

RAC Reviec of Revision 5 of the FEMA Self-Initiated Review of P119-tm NPS EPZ (2 Pages)

6. 12/31/87 F. Kantor, NRR, R. Bellamy, Questions and Answers NRC Region I, NRC (9 Pages)

7. 12/31/87 W. Lazarut, F. Kantor, NRR Questions and Answers Region I NRC in preparation for 1/7/88 Ptigrim Hearing (4 Pages)

8. 1/5/88 F. Kantor, NRR, W. Lazarus, Wessean Ptigrim Questions and l NRC Region I, NRC Answers (12 Pages) l 9. 3/18/88 C. Conklin, E. Thomas, RAC, letter

Subject:

Technical l Region I, NRC FEPA, Region 1 Review of the Oraf t

! Radiological Emergency l

Response Plans for Four l Local Cor.tunttles ti the Pligria Nuclear Power Plant Area (2 Pages) l l

l l

\ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _

o

' '* - I

• . , r i

I SW1DLER & BER1JN ownmo t M04 K ITSAIT N T [

. nm Me ,

• ATHL*dCTON. O C. seestMei f t

I t== w n >

faecc*ue : set)tes .,es i TREDOM Of iNFORMAT!05 [

Director ACI M M SI . i office of Administration [d,I'4 4 g 9 '

O.S. Nuclear Regulator' Commission b 9 M - P ,(

Washington, D.C. 2055 [,

In re: Freedom of Information Act Requ nt .

No. 88 ,__, Concerning Pilgrim Nuclear Pcwer Station 1

I

,i

Dear Sir:

[

t 1 In accordance with the provisions of the Freedom of i l Information Act, ! U.S.C. 5552 and Part 9, Subp3rt A of 10 .

) C.F.R., it is requested that the records identified below be made  ;

i available for inspection and copying:  ;

t

. 1. Records of any votes iaken by the Commission, and records or I

! transcripts of Commission meetings, with respect to the f shutdown of the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station, or the t

,I restart thereof, on or af ter April 12, 1986. j f 2. All SECY papers, attachments thereto, records and other [

materials supporting or forming the basis for positions j

. taken therein on the subject of the Pilgrim Nuclear Power t

Station, prepared on or after January 1, 1980. }

}

3. All records prepared or dated on or af ter January 1,1980 l (but excluding documints included on Docket No. 50-293 [

accession listings availaats f rom the Public Docurent Room)  ;

of NRC *tegion I, the of fice of the Executive Director for j.

Operations, the Office of Inspection and Enforcement, the l Office of Investigations, the Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, the Of fice of Nuclear Materials Safety and f Safeguards, the Advisor 1' Committee for Reactor Safeguards,  :

the Of fice for Evaluation of operational Data, and the NRC l Emergency operations Center which discuss, refer to, take positions on, or form the basis for decisions concerning, i the performance cf the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station in the [

following areas: 1 I

I i

,a .

A. Management B. Staffing C. Organization and Organization Structure D. Radiation Protection E. Quality Assurance F. Surveillance G. Maintenance H. Offsite Emergency Planning I. Fire Protection J. Security K. Management Response to NRC Regulatory Activities

4. All records of Region I, the Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, the Commission, the Office of Inspection and Enforcement, or other Staff or Commission offices relating to, discussing or forming the basis or support for, the Director's Decision (DD-87-14) dated August 21, 1987.

5. All records (other than those categories of documents excluded from Item 3) of any office referred to in Item 4, above, discussing, describing, assessing, evaluating, or otherwise relating to actions by the NRC staff, FEMA, the ACRS, or other NRC or Commission offices, to follow-up or monitor actions by Boston Edison Company, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, other jurisdictions within the 10-mile emergency planning zone for Pilgrim Nucidar Power Station, to address issues raised in the Director's Decision (DD 14) dated August 21, 1987.

6. All records of the NRC offices referred to in Item 4 discussing, describing, assessing or evaluating, or otherwise relating to actions of the NRC staff to evaluate the July 198*. Aestart Plan, and cther actions by Boston ,

Edison Company, its agents or contractors, relating to the restart of the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station.

7. All records of communications (whether written or oral and occurring from April 12, 1986.to the present) between any office of the NRC Staff, or of the Commission or offices reporting directly to it, and Boston Edison Company, concerning the status or startup of the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station.

9. All records of communications (whether written or oral, and occurring from April l'4, 1986 to the present) between any office of the NRC Staff or of the Commission or offices reporting directly to it, and FEMA, other Federal or State agencies or governmental entities, or persons concerning the status, startup, or issues relating to startup, of the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station.

1 1

O 3_

. 9. All records in the possession of any NRC Staff or. Commission office pertaining to (a) the evaluation by F2MA, NRC, or any other entity or agency, of the adequacy of offsite emergency l plans for the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station, and (b) the i j

conduct and/or evalustion of drills, full scale / full participation or partial scale / partial participation exercisec conducted or planned for the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station.

, For purposes of this request, "record" or "document" is defined to include, but not be limited to, notes, memoranda, reports, meeting minutes, logs, transcripts, letters, position or policy papers, interpretations of requirements, and guidance documents, and refers to drafts as well as any final version of

.tr.y record or document requested.

Sinc ly, l t / Kk r eE Jo son, Esq.

(202)944-438 GEJ/veg