ML20215E650

From kanterella
Revision as of 19:01, 19 April 2021 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot insert)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Further Response to FOIA Request for Records Re Insp Repts 50-456/85-21 & 50-457/85-22.Portions of Documents in App C & All Documents in App D Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 5,6 & 7).App C Documents Also in PDR
ML20215E650
Person / Time
Site: Braidwood  Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 10/07/1986
From: Grimsley D
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To: Guild R
BUSINESS & PROFESSIONAL PEOPLE FOR THE PUBLIC INTERES
Shared Package
ML20215E651 List:
References
FOIA-85-777 NUDOCS 8610150423
Download: ML20215E650 (6)
v • d • e


See also: IR 05000456/1985021

Text

f$f. d/f

g

f[ %g UNITED STATES

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

y :p WASHING TON, D. C. 20555

...../

OCT 0 7 19lE

Docket No. 50-456/457

Mr. Robert Guild

Business and Professional People

for the Public Interest

109 North Dearborn Street, Suite 1300 IN RESPONSE REFER

Chicago, IL 60602 TO F01A-85-777

Dear Mr. Guild:

This is in further response to your letter dated November 21, 1985, in which

you requested, pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (F0IA), copies of

all records related to Inspection Reports 50-456/85-21 and 50-457/85-22

regarding the Braidwood plant.

Portions of the 47 records listed on the enclosed Appendix C and all of the

records listed on the enclosed Appendix D contain advice, opinions, and

recommendations of the staff and/or are investigatory records compiled for law

enforcement purposes and are being withheld from public disclosure pursuant to

Exemptions (5), (6), (7)(A), and (7)(D) of the F0IA (5 U.S.C. 552(b)(5), (6),

(7)(A), and (7)(D)) and 10 CFR 9.5(a)(5), (6), (7)(i), and (7)(iv) of the

Commission's regulations. Disclosure of the information would inhibit the

exchange of information during the agency's deliberative process, would

constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy, disclose the identity

of confidential sources, or interfere with an enforcement proceeding. The

nonexempt portions of the records listed on Appendix C will be placed in the

NRC Public Document Room (PDR) in folder F01A-85-777 under your name.

As we indicated in our March 4, 1986 response to you, these records will also

be placed in the Local Public Document Room (LPDR) for Braidwood, which is the

Wilmington Public Library, 201 South Kankakee Street, Wilmington, IL 60481.

The records will be made available to you for your inspection at no charge and

copying for a nominal fee.

Pursuant to 10 CFR 9.9 of the Conunission's regulations, it has been determined

that the information withheld is exempt from production or disclosure, and

that its production or disclosure is contrary to the public interest. The

persons responsible for this denial are the undersigned and Mr. James G.

Keppler, Regional Administrator, NRC Region III.

3

This denial may be appealed to the Commission's Executive Director for

Operations within 30 days from the receipt of this letter. As provided in

l

$ 01 g 3 861007

GUILD 85-777 ppg

!

)

. . - - .__ _ ___ _____ _ _ _ - ___ ._- . ._---1

_ _ _ _ _ _ _

Robert Guild -2-

10 CFR 9.11, any such appeal must be in writing, addressed to the Executive

Director for Operations, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC

20555, and should clearly state on the envelope and in the letter that it is

an " Appeal from an Initial F0IA Decision."

This completes NRC action on your request.

s

.

Sincerely,

fxt& Y nc <y

Donnie H. Grimsley, Director

Division of Rules and Records

Office of Administration

Enclosures: As stated

_ _ - _ . . . - . - _ . - . . _ . , _ _ - _ - _ - _ _ - _ - _ - - _ . _ . - - _ . - . _ _ . _ - - _ -

RE: F0IA-85-777

APPENDIX C

1. 3/29/85 Memo for R. Warnick and C. Weil from L. McGregor and R. Schulz,

re: Quality Control Allegations from L. K. Comstock Inspectors

with attachment (8 pages) - Exemption 6, 7D

2. 3/29/85 Memo for R. L. Spessard from Charles Weil, re: Allegation Re:

L. K. Comstock at Braidwood, ATS No. RIII-85-A-0067 (5 pages) -

Exemption 5, 6, 7A, 70

3. 4/4/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil (1 page), with attached

3/29/85 memo for R. L. Spessard from Charles Weil (ATS No. RIII-

85-A-0068; ATS Form; and 2-page excerpt (4 pages) - Exemption

6, 7D

,

  • 4. 4/4/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Well, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 70

5. Undated Memo for R. F. Warnick and C. Weil from R. Gardner, re:

Allegation from CECO that Certain LKC Inspectors will Attempt

to discredit certain LKC Managers (1 page) - Exemption 6, 7D

6. 4/5/85 Memo for Charles Norelius from Charles Weil, re: Allegations re:

L. K. Comstock Quality Assurance Program at Braidwood (6 pages),

with attached

a. AMS Form No. RIII-85-A-0072 (1 page),

b. 3/29/85 memo cited as No.1 above and not included here, and

c. 3/29/85 memo for R. Warnick and C. Williams from L. McGregor

and R. Schulz, re: Telephone Conference Call with Common-

'

wealth Edison in regard to L. K. Comstock Quality Control

Problems (4 pages) - Exemption 6, 70

    • 7. 4/8/85 Letter to A?Ieger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

'

Exemption 6, 7D

    • 8. 4/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 70

    • 9. 4/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

    • 10. 4/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

    • 11. 4/8/86 Letter to Alleger from Charles Well, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

  • Attachment same as enclosure to No. 3
    • Attachment same as enclosure a. to No. 6

_ - - _ _ _ -- _ _ - - - . __- . . _-- _ __.._ __ - .

- _ . - . -. - - - _ - . - __-

.

C-2

'

    • 12. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

    • 13.. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

t Exemption 6, 7D

,

    • 14. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

    • 15. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

i

_

Exemption 6, 70

    • 16. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

    • 17. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

    • 18. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

i **19. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Well, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

    • 20. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 70

3

    • 21. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

4

Exemption 6, 70

'

    • 22. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

i' **23. 4/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment - -

Exemption 6, 7D

24. 4/10/85 Fax to C. Weil from L. McGregor, re: Corrections to Allegations

given to NRC by L. K. Comstock QC Inspectors on March 29, 1985,

q with attached correction sheets (3 pages) - Exemption 6, 7D

25. 4/17/85 Memo for C. Weil from P. Pelke, re
Braidwood Allegation Review

Board Meeting on April 12,1985(2 pages) - Exemption 5, 7A

l 26. Undated A11eger Identification Sheet (1 page) - Exemption 6, 7D

27. Undated Unsigned, typed, double-spaced memo, re: Allegations (2 pages) -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 28. 11/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

i ***29. 11/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Well, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

    • Attachment same as enclosure a. to No. 6

i *** Attachment identified as record available in PDR on Appendix A of 3/4/86 aesponse

- . - .- _ - . .- - ._..-,.-.- -.- -_ - ____-. .- . - - _-

C-3

      • 30. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 5, 6, 7A, 70

      • 31, 11/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 32. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 33. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 34. 11/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 35. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 70

      • 36. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 37. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 38. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 70

      • 39. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Well, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 40. 11/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 70

      • 41. 11/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 42. 11/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Ex' emption 6, 7D

      • 43. 11/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Well, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 70

      • 44. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 45. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

      • 46. 11/8/85 Letter to A11eger from Charles Weil, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

l ***47. 11/8/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Well, without attachment -

Exemption 6, 7D

l

[ *** Attachment identified as record available at PDR on Appendix A of 3/4/86 response

l

.- _

- ._ ._ - . _ - . _ . . _ _ - - - . - - _ .

- _

_ _

RE: F0IA-85-777

l

APPENDIX 0

1. 4/4/85 Letter to Alleger from Charles Weil, with attached ATS No.

RIII-85-A-0067 (6 pages) - Exemption 5, 6, 7A, 7D

2. Undated Alleger Identification sheet (1 page) - Exemption 5, 6,

7A, 70 .

. 3. 11/1/85 Allegation Management System computer sheet / Allegation

i

No. RIII-85-A-0067 (8 pages) - Exemption 5, 7A

r

6

4

l

!

!

_ . - _ - _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ , . , . . - . . __

, UNITED STATES

/ pe ne7*g e:ue:.un accutnony co;m.u:sion

CEZION lli f'

g 799 ROOSEVELT RO AO {4

O SLEN ELLYN ILLINOIS 60537

_

March 29, 1985

MENORANDUM FOR: R. L. Spessard', Director, Division of Reactor Safety

FROM: Charles H. Weil. Investigation and Compliance Specialist

SUBJECT: ALLEGATION RE: L. K. COMETOCK AT BRAIDWOOD

(50-356; 50-357)

,

(ATS NO. RIII-85-A-0067)

Reference: Undated Memo (Atta'ched)

.

On March 28, 1985 this matter was discussed with E. T. Pawlik of the Office

of Investigation RIII Field Office, and it wa's concluded that investigative

effort by OIR3 is not warranted at this time for the reason given below.

Should additional facts or information relating to possible wrongdoing

concerning this allegation become available, please notify me promptly.

This allegation will continue to be carried as "open" in the Allegation

Tracking System pending final resolution / closeout by your Division.

Charles H. Weil

Investigation and

Compliance Specialist

Attachments: *

1. ATS Mer.,o

2. Undateo itcmo

-

.

cc w/ attachments:

A. B. Davis

B. A. Berson

W. L. Forney

E. G. Greenman

J. ;J. Harrison

E. T. Pawlik i

R. F. Warnick

C. C. Williams

SRI-Braidwood

BASIS: Wrongdoing was not alleged.

~ t , , n , c- ~= . Y

c1v s ~

_ . _

p - - -- - - . _ . - .-

c. _ z_

- -

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20215E650&oldid=3237100"