IA-85-611, Further Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Davis- Besse Plant.Documents Listed in App B Available in Pdr.Nrc Unable to Identify Documents Re Number 5 of Request

Further Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Davis- Besse Plant.Documents Listed in App B Available in Pdr.Nrc Unable to Identify Documents Re Number 5 of Request

ML20136E281
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	11/04/1985
From:	Felton J NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To:	Webb R WEBB, R.E. (STUDIES OF NUCLEAR HAZARDS & CONSTITUTION
References
FOIA-85-611 NUDOCS 8511210452
Download: ML20136E281 (2)

Text

., o nea, i e

4[ 'o,,

o UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

E WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555

%.....) ob NOV 0 41985 Richard E. Webb, Ph.D.

Studies of Nuclear Hazards and Constitutional Law 4821 New England Lane, Suite 29 IN RESPONSE REFER Sylvania, OH 43560 TO F0IA-85-611

Dear Dr. Webb:

This is in further response to your letter dated August 29, 1985, in which you requested, pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act,14 specified documents pertaining to the Davis-Besse nuclear power plant.

The enclosed Appendix B identifies documents which the NRC has already made publicly available at the NRC's Public Document Room,1717 H Street, NW, Washington, DC 20555.

We have been informed by the staff that they have been unable to identify documents relative to number 5 of your request.

This completes NR"'s action on your request.

Sin erely, J

J. M. Felton, Director Division of Rules and Records Office of Administration

Enclosure:

As stated 8511210452 851104 PDR FotA WEBB85-611 PDR

. _ ~ . - .

Re: FOIA-85-611

, . ' APPENDIX B t

. ITEM NO.

3. 07/09/81 Letter from Crouse to Novak forwarding "Abnomal Transient Operating Guideline (AT0G) Program Description," in-

response to generic letter 81-16, per NUREG-0737 item 7

I.C1. (5 pages) - Accession No. 8107130259 06/30/81 " Abnormal Transient Operating Guideline (AT0G) Program Description." (34 pages) - Accession No. 8107130263 2

i i

4 4

i 4

i I

._.______.----____2_-____-_ . _ - - . _ . . . . _ . _ . . .

i Siudies of Nuclear Hazards  ;

and Constitutional Law Richard E. Webb, Ph.D.

~

4821 New England Lane, Suite 29 August 29, 198f, Sylvania, Ohio 43560 Telephone: (419) 882-6523 Mr. J. M. Felcon FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT Director REQUEST Division of Rules and Recor<is Offtee of Adminintration f.;SEGXaA QF INFORMAlit)N Freedom of Information Ant oft, ace ftEQUESL-U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission O Y b "M.8-(y//

Washington, D. C. 20555 J n

/y f -

Dear Mr. Felton:

As stat.ed in my lett.or of July U to the- NRC, whicb requests a public honring en the suspension of the Davis-Besse reactor operations following the Juno Ot.h loss-of-feedwat er mi shap. and which vn; repli-d t <. by the tiRC's General Counsel, Mr Hersel H.E Plaine, in a l e t.t.e r dated July 18, I am investigating the mishap and am seching information and documents related to the incident.  ! have issued au report of my invesitgation dated June 24th with a June 27 postscript, and have sent a copy for the NRC to the NRC's resident inspector at the Davis-Besse site The title of my report is:

" Report. al an Invenicut. ion of the Loss-of-Cooling Mishap at the Davis-Beaue Nunlear Power Plant on June 9, 1005", dated June 24, 1905 with a 'Pos tscr i pt' hted June 27th.

J havn also roccived cosaents by Toledo Edison on my report, and I 'un preparing a follow-up report of my evaluation of thei r con.menta This evaluation is part or a more in-tepth investigation /res+ arch of the minhap, which I am making. For thin work I need add i t,i ona l documents and information. My June 'd4/27 report discusses these needs for further i n f o rrna t. i on . I would like, therefort, to request.

your office to supply v.s with the documents that I need to onmplete my i nvra t i ga t.i on . (I already havn a o . . py of the inspection Team rnport, 110 REG - 11 ri4, which thn URC has sent me.

9 O

c w,

2 i

' The requested documents are as follows:

1. Reference document items numberred 2, 3, and 4 on page 7-7 of NUREG-1154, namely:

a. Davis-Besue No.1 Auxiliary Feedwater System Reliability Analysis Final Report. December 31, 1901.

b. Engineering Summary Report of A complete Loss of Feedwater Transient Analysis for Davis-Besse Unit 1, B&W June 22, 1982

c. Analysis of a Complete Loss of Feedwater Transient for the Daviu-Besso Nuclear Power Stations. Unit 1, June 15, 1979.

2. Review of the Davis-Besse Unit No.1 Auxiliary Feedwater System Reliability Analysi, NUREG/CR-3530, BNL-NUREG-51722, February 1984.

3 Sections of the Emergency Procedure 1201.01--- the Davis-Besse's versiori of the B&W Owners Group's Ahn9rma.L.Transisrd Operatine Cuidsljnss ( ATOG)---

which were relevant to the June 9th mishap, including the section titled: "Lach of Heat Transfer" 1 would like the Table of Contents of the Emergency Procedure 1201.01 (ATOG), and the sections which the operatoru consulted in tha course of the accident and all of those sections which provide instructions or guidance for the plant-operators in the event of a complete. loss of

" main" and ' auxi l l a ry" feedwater.

4. NUREG-0737, the Tt4I Action Plan.

5. The NRC' safety evaluation of the Davis-Bosse's ATOG emergency procedure for the complete-loss-of-feedwater transient and approval letterc---the documentary history of the NRC's approval of the emergency procedure, known as " feed and bleed."

6. A copy of the Technical Specification for_the Davis-Besse reactor plant, which is traditionally contained in chapt.er 16 of t,he plant'n FSAR.

7. A copy of the Licenne granted to the Toledo Edison for operatinst the Davis-Deuse r o tt a t o r .

_ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . ______.1

.,_m . .

3

8. A copy of the engineering design report on the Davis-Besse Safety Valves, PORV, and Block Valve used in the primary coolant system, including the design assembly drawing for these valves.

9. The summary report of the EPRI safety and relief valve testing program under the II.D.1 requirements of the TMI action plan, NUREG-0737

10. A copy of the NRC's report on " unresolved safety issues." I do not have the NUREG number.

11. A copy of the NRC's report on the subject of Anticipated Transients without Scram. Again. I do not have the report number.

I request a copy of these documents without a money charge, .w I have no money to afford t.n pay for the documents. (The computer used to type this was lent to me r.o help me speed the typing of my reports ) I think t. hat the public interest would be served if the NRC/ Government would send me a copy of the requested documents, as they would be put to good use in the making of an independent investigation of the Davis-Besse June 9th mishap and the safety of nuclear power plants in general.

With friendly greetings,

/

Richard E. Hobb 3

P.G. I request the following additional do 'uments :

12. " Valve Inlet Fluid Conditions for Pressuriser Safety and Relief Valven for B&W 177-FA and 205-FA flanta , ' prepared by if abconh and W i lcox, hynchburg, Va., EPRI NP-2352-LD, P ro.j ec t V102-17, cited in the report by Toledyne Engineering Cervices, Technical Report TR-5639--2 Revis:an 0 Davis-Bessa Analysis and Eva]uat, ion of the Cafet.y/ Relief Valvo Discharge System, per NRC t!UREG-0737, January 1983; submit.ted to t.be NRC to Toledo Edison let.ter dabed Fnbruary 1, 1083, Ger.No.905, Douhet. No. 50-346, License tio.NPF-3.