ML20206Q973

From kanterella
Revision as of 05:01, 6 December 2021 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Further Response to FOIA Request Re Records Concerning NRC Comanche Peak Task Force Established in Mar 1984.Forwards App G Documents.App G Documents Placed in Pdr.Portions of Records Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)
ML20206Q973
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 06/25/1986
From: Grimsley D
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To: Garde B
GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT
Shared Package
ML20206Q979 List:
References
FOIA-85-59 NUDOCS 8607070042
Download: ML20206Q973 (28)
v • d • e


Text

~

12Cfc

'M '

TDHllo 1

  1. UNITED STATES l

[\)g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

% .j IVASHING TON, D. C. 20555 0, -

O

%, V...../ JUy ~o o: a.:_

Docket Nos. 50-445/50-446 Ms. Billie Pirner Garde, Director Environmental Whistleblower Clinic Government Accountability Project 1555 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Suite 202 IN RESPONSE REFER Washington, DC 20036 TO F01A-85-59

Dear Ms. Garde:

This is in further response to your letter dated Jcnuary 21, 1985, in which you requested, pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (F0IA), records related to the NRC Comanche Peak Task Force established in March 1984.

We are now placing one additional box'of records (box 6) in the QA/QC category, covering Appendix G records numbered 1 through 332 into the Public Document Room (PDR) in file F01A-85-59 under your name.

Portions of the records identified at numbers 95, 140 through 158, 160 through 209, 211 through 221, 223 through 239, 242 through 269, and 271 through 332 are being withheld from public disclosure pursuant to Exemption 5 of the FOIA (5 U.S.C. 552(b)(5)) and 10 CFR 9.5(a)(5) of the Commission's regulations. The records contain the advice, opinions, and recommendations of the staff concerning potential violations. The nonexempt portions of the records are being placed in PDR file F01A-85-59 under your name.

Pursuant to 10 CFR 9.9 of the Commission's regulations, it has been determined that the information withheld is exempt from production or disclosure and that its production or disclosure is contrary to the public interest. The persons responsible for this denial are the undersigned and Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation.

This denial may be appealed to the Executive Director for Operations within 30 days from the receipt of this letter. Any such appeal must be in writing, addressed to the Executive Director for Operations, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC 20555, and should clearly state on the envelope and in the letter that it is an " Appeal from an Initial F0IA Decision."

\

8607070042 860625 PDR FOIA 3 GARDE 85-59 PDR_ >

Mrs. Garde The records identified at numbers 1 through 73 and portions of the records identified at numbers 140 through 142, 159, 201, 202, 240 through 242, 264, and 281 through 283 contain information subject to the agreement reached between you and the NRC staff at a meeting on May 8, 1985. Therefore, we are not invoking an F0IA exemption regarding the deletion of this information.

A separate set of the released records is being made available for public inspection and copying at the Local Public Document Roan (LPDR) located at the University of Texas Library, 170 South Cooper Street, Arlington, Texas.

Additional records subject to your request are currently under review and will be placed in the PDR and LPDR upon completion of the review.

Sincerely, int L' $ k sj Donnie H. Grimsley, Director Division of Rules and Records Office Of Administration

Enclosure:

As stated l

I i

(

I

.. =..

RE.: FOIA-85-59 Box 6 - QA/QC s APPENDIX G DATE PAGE

1. 3-17-81 QA Initial Personnel Certification 5 Summary Record
2. 3-19-81 QA Initial Personnel Certification 4 Summary Record
3. 8-25-84 Personal Log 67
4. 8-26-84 Copy of Spiral Notebook w/ 27 '

Notes of Mark W. Eli, TRT

5. 8-26-84 Nonconformance Report (NCR #3 3 00768)
6. 8-26-84 Handwritten Notes 13
7. 8-25-84 Handwritten Notes of Rad Waste 61 Inspection
8. 8-26-84 DWG #GGH-00-X-AB-024A Rev 4 1 Pipe Support Design Group Small Bore Pipe Supports
9. 8-26-84 DWG fBRHL-CC-X-AB-024A Rev. 0 1 Component Cooling Water
10. 8-26-84 DWG #BRHL-SI-1-AB-004, Rev. 0 1 Safety Injection t
11. 8-26-84 DWG #BRHL-SI-1-SB-053, Rev. 0 3 Rev, 1 and Rev 1 Safety Injection
12. 8-26-84 DWG #BRHL-CC-1-RB-065, 1 Rev. 1 Component Cooling Water
13. 8-26-84 DWG #BRHL-CC-1-SB-004 1 Component Cooling Water i
14. 8-26-84 DWG BRHL-CC-1-SB-004, Rev. 8 1 Component Cooling Water
15. 8-26-84 DWG #BRHL-S1-1-SB-015, Rev. 3 1 Safety Injection
16. 8-26-84 DWG #BRHL-S1-1-SB-015 1 i Safety Injection 17, 8-26-84 DWG #BRHL-CS-1-RB-038C Rev. 0 1 Chemical & Volume Control
18. 8-26-84 DWG-BRHL-CS-1-RB-038C 1 Chemical & Volume Control 19, 8-26-84 DWG 2323-EL-0032, Sheet #56 1 SW Development & Conn Diag.
20. 8-26-84 DWG 2323-EL-032, Sheet #57, 1 TBX-RCPCAX-02, BKR 1PCPX2 Schematics Diagram
21. 10-31-80 QA Inspection Certification 1
22. 4-10-81 QA Inspection Certification 2 2 4

7

23. 11-19-81 Procedure-QI-QP-11.3-24.7 Rev. 3 11
24. 1-19-82 Procedure QI-QP-11.10-2 Rev. 9 13
25. 3-18-82 QA Inspection Certification 1
26. 6-29-82 Procedures CP-QP-15.4 Rev. 2 2
27. 9-21-82 QA Inspection Certification 1
28. 12-30-82 Procedure CP-QP-22.0 Rev 0 7
29. 3-2-83 QA Inspection Cert. 2
30. 2-24-83 Sketch #2323-El-0032 on Elec 3 Cable Separ. & Firing of QC
31. 4-11-83 B&R Memo from Karen Mor ton 2 to Dist. Subj: Update of Certification Matrix
32. No Date Sketch - #2323-El-0032 3
33. 4-23-80 Weld Data Card #13265 3
34. 7-18-80 Modification Manufacturing 2 Record Sheet 35, 1-6-81 Sketch RH-1-024-003-S22P, Rev. 4 1
36. 10-15-81 Sketch G1227037-5.3-3K 2
37. 5-4-82 Documentation Checklist 6 S1-1-4D-003-7 2-25-83, As Built Reverification Report Form 2
  1. 1859 3

r -

k- -

38. 3-2-83 As Built Reverification 3-Report Form #2045
39. 3-2-83 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #2051 40, 3-3-83 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #2046
41. 3-3-85 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #1814
42. 3-3-85 As Built Reverification 1 Report Form #2106
43. 3-3-85 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #1971
44. 3-3-85 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #1970
45. 3-3-85 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #1931
46. 3-3-85 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #1902
47. 3-4-85 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #2461 48, 3-4-85 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2152
49. 2/25/85 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #1859 4

r

50. 3-4-85 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2151
51. 3-4-83 As Built Reverification 4 Report Form #1879
52. 3-14-83 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #2659
53. 3-14 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #2709
54. 3-14-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2689
55. 3-14-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2762
56. 3-14-83 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #2678
57. 3-14-83 As Built Reverification 4 Report Form #2648
58. 3-15-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2760
59. 3-15-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2686
60. 3-15-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2685
61. 3-15-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #3005 5
62. 3-15-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #3006
63. 3-15-83 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #3007
64. 3-16-83 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #2010
65. 3-16-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2009
66. 3-16-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2008
67. 3-17-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2889
68. 3-18-83 As Built Reverification 4 Report Form #2767
69. 3-28-83 As Built Reverification 2 Report Form #2781
70. 3-31-83 As Built Reverification 3 Report Form #2471
71. No Date Copy of Hilti Architects and 18 Engineers Anchor & Fastener Design Manual
72. No Date Examination & Documentation 16 Checklist on Spool Picce No.

S!-1-YD-03-7 6

,e --m y , - , , - - w w,- nn---,~~-----------+~--.--,w -----.---n,, m--- - -. - - - - - . .

73. No Date Folder of Bob Harbon, Reviewers 41 Notes
74. 3-31-81 USNRC SSINS #6830 5
75. 4-11-83 NRC ltr to TUGC-

Subject:

8 Construction Appraisal Inspection 50-445/83-18, 8 50-446/83-12

76. 7-27-83 NRC Ltr to TUGC G. L. Madsen 29 to R. J. Gary - RE: Special Inspection of Fuel Bldg completion
77. 10-3-83 NRC Ltr to TUGC-RE: Inspection 6 of 7-27 thru 9-16-83-Region IV follow up of CAT
78. 10-13-83 NRC Ltr to TUGC from E. H. 6 Johnson to R. J. Gary RE:

Response to NRC ltr and Notice of Violation dated 7-27-83

79. 10-31-83 Misclassification of Material 14 Case Exhibit 1,052
80. 11-30-83 Nonconformance Report #11,809 6
81. 1-6-84 SIS Report - Case Exhibit #1,054 3
82. 6-21-84 NCR ltr to TUGC - Richard L. 44 Bangort to M. D. Spence RE:

Special Inspection of Cable Spread Room 7 .-

83. 3-83 CAT Inspection Summary 72
84. 7-11-83 CPSES/FSAR 27
85. 10-83 Handwritten Notes of Review of 3 TRT Members Answers to CAT Report
86. 7-6-84 NRC ltr to TUGC-Richard L. 17 Bangart to M. D. Spence - RE:

Inspection conducted under the Resident Inspection Program

87. 8-17-84 USNRC IE Information Notice 8
  1. 84-67
88. 9-11-84 TUGC0 Memo to B. R. Clements 13

" Comanche Peak Special Review Team Report (July 13,1984)

F

89. 9-17-84 8. R. Clements, TUGCO, ltr to 3 R. P. Denise, USNRC " Welding Allegations additional Response File No. 10066.5"
90. 9-10-84 R. L. Bangart, NRC ltr to M. 88 D. Spence, TUGC0 RE: Special Inspection of Unit I reactor Containment Bldg.
91. 12-07-84 D. R. Hunter, NRC ltr to M. 50 D. Spence, TUGC0 RE: Special Inspection of the Safeguards and Auxiliary Bldg.

8 .

92. 2-19-79 B&R Materials & Operations 8 Listings
93. 9-21-84 Handwritten Notes by Bob 11 Hedderick Action Plan
94. 10-10-84 Handwritten Notes to Mark: RE: 11 Material Traceability Problems encountered during As-built j

Inspection

95. 10-10-84 Handwritten notes by Bob 13 Hedderick "As-Built Material Traceability"
96. No Date Copy of page 5010CFR50 1 Appendix B.

l

97. 12-18-84 USNRC Memorandum Before Admin 10 Judges ASLBP #50-445-OL, I

50-446-OL

98. 4-27-81 TUGC0 As Built Checklist 10 2
99. 6-4-84 M. R. McBay TUGC0 Office 25 Memo to Dist. RE: CPSES NF-4725 Locking Device" 1

j 100. 6-5-84 TRT Guidance - June 1984 18 1

101. 7-30-84 TUGC0 "As-Built Verification 3 4

Package Contents,"

CP-El-4.5-1 4

i i

9 l

102. 9-21-84 Handwritten Notes by Robert 3 Harbron RE: Chronology of Delays and Roadblocks 103. 12-5-84 Handwritten notes 3 to Herb.

104. 1-22-85 Handwritten notes to 1 Herb " Inspected Supports" 105. No Date Copy of Page 117 and 109 2 of 1983 Edition of NF-4000 106. No Date Copies of Pages 454 thru 3 459 of Chapter 1 - NRC Part 50 App B.

107. No Date Copy of Appendix A to CP- 1 t

IABV-1 3

108. No Date Handwritten Listing of 1 Procedures 109. 7-2-79 Karl V. Seyfrit NRC to 12 R. J. Gary, TUGC0 RE:

Action on IE Bulletin 79-14 110. 7-18-79 Karl V. Seyfrit, NRC ltr to '12 R. J. Gary, TUGCO-RE: IE Bulletin 79-14 revision to limit scope of work required 111. 7-24-79 J. T. Merritt Memo to 2

0. N. Chapman " Request for Extension of Time to Answer IE Bulletin #79-14 10

O

! 112. 7-20-79 Antonio Vega, Office Memo to 1 J. T. Merritt " Revision 1 to NRC IE Bulletin #79-14 113. 7-20-79 Handwritten Copy of Telephone 1 Conversation I

114. 7-26-79 Antonio Vega Office Memo 1 t to J. T. Merritt RE: Request for extension to IE Bulletin 79-14 QA File-IE Bulletin 79-14 8-17-79 Karl V. Seyfrit, NRC ltr 7 e

115. 8/15/79 R. J. Gary, TUGCO-RE:

Supplement to IE Bulletin 79-14 i

I l 116. 9-11-79 Karl V. Seyfrit, hRC ltr to 7 l R. J. Gary, TUGCO-RE: Supple-ment to IE Bulletin #79-14 117. 9-11-79 Antonio Vega, office Memo to 8 J. T. Merritt - RE: Transmittal of Supplement #2 - dtd 9-7-79 QA File: IE Bulletin 79-14 l

l 118, 10-25-79 R. J. Gary, TUGC0 ltr to Karl 1 V. Seyfrit, NRC - RE: Response l to IE Bulletin 79-14 File No.

10115 119. 10-25-79 R. J. Gary, TUGC0 Ltr to Karl 2 V. Seyfrit, NRC, RE: 1981-83 2300 MW Installation, Response  !

to IE Bulletin 79-14 File #10115 11

120. 12-14-79 J. T. Merritt, TUGC0 Office 2 Memo to A. Vega - RE: Progress Report on Response to NRC IE Bulletin No 79-14 121. 12-19-79 Mike Laue, TUGC0 Office Memo 1 to J. T. Merritt, RE: Progress, Report QA File: IEB-79-14 122. 12-20-79 Design / Construction Significant 1 Deficiency Analysis Report #027 123. 12-21-79 Brown & Root Message Form RE: 2 BDAR-0027 124. 2-29-80 J. T. Merritt, TUGC0 Office 2 Memo to A. Vega, RE: IE Bulletin 79-14 Ref: QNB-47 125. 3-3-80 Mike Laue, TUGC0 Office Memo 3 to J. T. Merritt, RE: Progress Report QA File: 1EB-79-14 4-24-80 126. 4-24-80 Licensing Correspondence Distribution File #10115 3 127. 4-30-80 J. R. Ainsworth Speed Letter 3 to M. Laue - RE: Progress Report of IE Bulletin 79-14 128. 5-5-80 Mike Laue, TUGC0 Office Memo 1 to J. T. Merritt, RE: Progress Report QA File: IEB 79-14 129, 6-27-80 M. R. McBay, TUGC0 Office Memo 1 to R. G. Tolson, RE:NRC IE Bulletin #79-14 Ref: CPP-3404 12

130. 6-25-80 B. J. Murray, TUGC0 Office Memo 2 to Mr. R. McBay, RE: Progress Report on NRC IE Bulletin 79-14 131. 7-1-80 Copy of Speed Letter from M. 11 Laue to J. R. Ainsworth RE:

Progress Report-IE Bulletin 79-14 132. 12-4-80 J. N. Baker, TUGC0 Office Memo 6 to M. R. McBay, RE: Progress Report on NRC Bulletin IE 79-14 133. 12-8-80 M. R. McBay, TUGC0 Office Memo 3 to H. C. Schmidt, RE: Seismic Analysis for As-Built Safety-Related Piping Systems, Ref CPP-4265 134. 8-6-82 D. W. Westbrook, TUGC0 Office 3 Memo to R. G. Tolson, RE: Tech-nical Services Response to IE Bulletin 79-14 135. 10-22-82 M. R. McBay, TUGC0 Ltr to H. C. 2 Schmidt of Nuclear Licensing Texas Utilities Services, RE:

Response to NRC IE Bulletin 79-14 136. 12-3-82 R. J. Gary, TUGC0 ltr to John 3 T. Collins, USNRC, RE: Compliance with NRC IE Bulletin 79-14 13

137. 11-11-83 Fred W. Madden, TUGC0 1 Office Memo to M. J. Riggs, RE: IE Bulletin 79-14 Ref (1) TXX-3597, (2) CPP-8001, (3)CPPA-34942,(4)GTN-59850 138. 11-17-83 Chris Vale, TUGC0 Office 2 Memo to L. M. Bielfeldt, RE: IE 79-14 As Built 139. 6-8-84 A. Vega, TUGC0 Office Memo 1 to J. T. Merritt, RE: As-Built Piping Verification Program 140. 4-15-85 SSER AQ-46-Draft 9 141. 4-15-85 SSER AQ55 and AQ78, Redraft 18

?

142. 4-22-85 SSER AQ-128, AQ-44, Rev. 4 8 143. 4-13-85 SSER AQ15-AQ-89, Draf t 5 ..

144. 4-13-85 SSER AQ 90-I, Draft 5 145. 4-13-85 SSER AQ-21, 22, 119, Draft

  • 7 146. 2-28-85 SSER AQ-103, AQ-72 Redraf t 8 147. 3-16-85 SSER AQ-99, Redraf t 4 148. 4-15-85 SSER AQ-110, Redraft 5 149. 4-15 85 SSER AQ-102, Draf t 8 14

150. 4-16-85 SSER, AQ-100, AQ-123, Draft 7 151. 4-16-85 SSER AQ-16, Redraft 9 152. 4-16-85 SSER AQ-3, Draft 10 153. 4-17-85 SSER,AQ-33, Draft 5 154. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-17, AQ 107 10 155. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-105, Redraf t 6 156. 4-18-85 SSER,AQ-111, Redraft 5 157. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-134, Redraft 4 158. 4-18-85 SSER, AQH-1, AQW-13 Draf t 5 159. No Date SSER, AQ-19. Draf t 6 160. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-49, 74,125, Draf t 7 161. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-45, Draf t 5 162. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-75, 76, Draf t 4 163. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-129, AQH-16 Redraft 5 164. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-137, Redraf t 4 165. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-7, AQ-83, Draf t 2 l

15

166. 4-15-85 SSER, AQ-23 Redraft 18 167. 4/15/85 SSER, AQ-73 4 168. 4-23-85 SSER, AQ-91, Final 4 s

169. 2-28-85 SSER, AQ-130, Redraft 4 170. 2-28-85 SSER,AQ-131, Redraft 3 171. 4-16-85 SSER,AQ-61, Draft 4 172. 4-18-85 SSER, AW-37, AQ-52 Draft 12 173. 4-19-85 SSER, AQ-68, AQ-82, Draf t 6 174. 4-19-85 SSER, AQ-117, Draft 4 175. 4-19-85 SSER,AQ-88, Draft 3 176. 4-19-85 SSER,AQ-43,AQ-47,AQ-51, 5 Draft 177. No Date SSER,AQ-98, Draft 3 178. 4-22-85 SSER, AQ-77, 79 & 138, Draft 20 179. 4-18-85 SSER,AQ-54,AQ-65, Draft 11 180. 4-15-85 SSER, AQ/QC 5.0, Draf t 25 181. 4-16-85 SSER, AQ-53, Redraft 4 182. 4-17-85 SSER,AQ-5, Draft 6 16

- s -_ _. 4 %. . . _ . - . - . . . _ . . _

183. 4-19-85 -

SSER AQ-12, AQ-13, AQ-14, Draft 6 184. 4-19-85 SSER AQ-40, Draft 4 i

185. 4-19-85 SSER AQ-41, Draft 4 186. 4-15-85 SSER, AQE-41, Draft 4 187. 4-15-85 SSER, AQ-70, Draft 4 188. 4-15-85 SSER, AQ-38, Revised 6 189. 3-19-85 SSER, AQ-9, Draft 3 i

190. 3-20-85 SSER, AQ-127, Redraf t 6 191. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-20, Draft 4' 192. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-25, Draft 4 193. 4-18-85 SSER,AQ-69,AQ-122, Draft 4 i

194. 4-18-85 SSER, AQ-133, Draf t 8 l 195. 4-18-85 SSER AQ-132, Draft 7  !

}

! 196. 4-19-85 SSER AQ-121, Draft 7 197. 4-19.a5 SSER AQ-126, Draft 7 i

4 j 198. 4-22-85 SSER AQ-113, Redraf t 4 1

199. No Date SSER AQ-112, Draft 5 200. 4-12-85 SSER, AQ-135, Redraft 15 i

i 17 I I

i _

201. 10-8-84 SSER, AQ-30, 31, 32, 34, 36, 30 37, 80, 85, 86, 87, 95, 96, 97, 106, 109, 114, 116, 120 and 124, Draft 202. 1-15-85 SSER,.AQ-55,AQ-78, Draft 16 203. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-79 Draft 5 204. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-79, Draft 6 205. 10-29-84 SSER, AQ-77, Rev. 1 9 206. 10-29-84 SSER, AQ-77, Rev. 1 7 207, 10-29-84 SSER, AQ-138, Draft 3 22 208. 1-30-85 SSER, AQ-77, 79, 138 Draft 3 21 209. 10-25-84 SSER, AQ54, AQ65. Draft 15 210. 10-25-85 Handwritten Sheet of AQ 1 Numbers 211, 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-12, 13, 14, 115, Draft 9 212, 10-25-84 SSER,AQ-40, Redraft 6 213. 10-22-84 SSER,AQ-41, Redraft 8 214. 11-6-84 SSER,AQ-5, Redraft 8 215, 11-6-84 SSER, AQ-53 Redraft 6 216. 1-15-85 SSER, AQ-53 Redraft 7 18

4 217. 9-6-84 SSER, AQ-70, Draft 6 218. 9-6-84 SSER, AQE-41, Draft 8 219. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-46, Draft 12 220. 10-25-84 SSER, AQ-35, Draft 7 221. 10-27-84 SSER,AQ-38,AQ-98 9 222. No Date Handwritten List of AQ 1 Numbers 223. 10-4-84 SSER, AQ-126, Draf t 7 224. 10-5-84 SSER, AQ-9, Draft 5 225, 10-5-84 SSER,AQ-9, Draft 4 226, 10-6-84 SSER, AQ-20, Rev. 3 7 227, 10-8-84 SSER, AQ-127, Draft, Rev. 1 8 228. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-121, Draft, Rev. 2 10 229, 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-132, Draft 5 9 230. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-121, Draft, Rev. 1 10 231, 10-24-84 SSER, AQ-25, Oraft, 7 232. 10-24-84 SSER, AQ-112. Draft 3 7 233, 10-31-84 SSER, AQ-113, Draft 2 11 234, 1-15-85 SSER, AQ-133, Draft, Rev. 1 9 19 u----_-

235. 10-8-84 SSER, AQ-44, AQ-128, Rev. 1 10 236. 1-14-85 SSER, AQ-135, Draft 5 14 237. 2-7-85 SSER, AQ-50, Redraft Rev. 1 49 238. 3-14-85 SSER, AQ-135, Rev. 2 15 239. ho Date T. Curry Note on SSER pages 17 "Back up for potential Violations Letter."

240. 7-27-84 CP Technical Issues from 38 Special Review Team Report of 7-13-84 Issues #SRT 1-10 241. 8-6-84 Comanche Peak Allegation 4 Work Package 242. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-100 and AQ-123, 18 Draft 2 243. 10-8-84 SSER, AQ-90, Draft 2 9 244. 10-27-84 SSER, AQ-21, 22, 119 Rev. I 12 245. 1-15-85 SSER, AQ-15, AQ-89, Rev. 2 8 246. 10-1-84 SSER, AQ-110, Draft 9 247. 10-1-84 SSER,AQ-99,AQ-136, Draft, 6 Rev. 1 2t8. 10-1-84 SSER, AQ-99, Draft, Rev. 3 6 20

249. 10-04-84 SSER, AQ-103, AQ-72, Draft 1 19 250. 10-5-84 SSER, AQ-105, Draft, Rev. I 10 251. 10-8-84 SSER, AQ4, Draft, Rev. 2 6 252. 10-9-84 SSER, AQH-1, AQW-13, Draft 8 key. 2 253. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-33, Draft, Rev. 2 8 254. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-134, Draft 3 6 255. 10-11-84 SSER,AQE-9,AQ-17,AQ-18, 11 AQ-42, AQ-58, AQ-101, AQ-104, and AQ-107, Draft 2 256. 10-11-84 SSER,AQ-16,AQ-57,AQ-60, 12 AQ-71, Draf t. Rev. 2 257. 10-24-84 SSER, AQ-19 Draft, Rev. 1 11 258. 10-10-84 SSER, AQ-3, Draft, Rev. I 11 259. 12-13-84 SSER, AQ-102, Draf t, Rev. I 10 260. 1-15-84 SSER, AQ-111, Draft, Rev. 2 7 261. 10-4-84 SSER, AQ-137, Draf t 2 5 262. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-45, Draf t, Rev. 2 7 263. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-49, AQ-74 AQ-125- 12 Draft 2 21

1

! 264. 10-12-84 SSER, AQ-7, AQ-83, Draft 4 5 j 265. 10-25-84 SSER, AQ-137, Draf t 2 5 l 266. 1-12-85 SSER, AQ-75, 76, Draf t, Rev. 3 6 l 267. 1-15-85 SSER, AQ-129, AQH-16, Draf t, 7 1

Rev. 4 268. 1-10-85 SSER, AQ-91, Draft, Rev. 4 7  !

).

269. 1-15-85 SSER, AQ-23, Redraf t Rev. 2 14 270. 10-24-84 SSER, AQ-73, Draf t, Rev. 3 6 271. 10-2-84 SSER, AQ-130, Draft 3 5 l

j 272. 10-5-84 SSER, AQ-98, Draft, Rev. 3 5

[ 273. 10-5-84 SSER, AQ-88, Draft, Rev. 2 5

274. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-117, Dre f t, Rev. 2 6 1

275, 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-61, Redraft, Rev.1 6 4

276. 10-12-84 SSER, AQ-131, Draf t, Rev. 2 9 l

l c 277. 10-24-84 SSER, AQ-68, Draf t, Rev. 4 10 .

4 278. 1-15-84 SSER,AQ-43,AQ-47,AQ-51, 8 i Draft Rev. 3 i

279. 2-4-85 SSER, AQ-52 and AW-37, Draft 12 1

i 280. No Date SSER Suninary 5  !

I i

22

281. 3-20-85 SSER, AQ-55, AQ-78, Redraft, 16 Rev. 2 282. 3-20-85 SSER, AQ-46, Rev. 3 7 283. 2-28-85 SSER, AQ-44, AQ-128, Draft, 9 Rev. 4 284. 2-22-85 SSER, AQ-90, Redraft, Rev. 3 7 285. 3-5-85 SSER, AQ-90-1, Rev. 3 6 286. 1-25-85 SSER, AQ-3, Redraft, Rev. 2 10 287. 2-25-85 SSER, AQ-4, Redraft, Rev. 2 4 288. 1-24-85 SSER, AQ-17, AQ-107, AQE-9 9 Redraft 3 289. 2-25-85 SSER, AQ-16, Redraft, Rev. 3 8 290. 2-25-85 SSER, AQ-19, Draft 4 9 291. 2-25-85 SSER, AQ-33, Redraft, Rev. 3 5 292. 2-28-85 SSER, AQ-103, AQ-72, Redraft 8 Rev. 1 293. 3-13-85 SSER, AQ-99, Redraft, Rev. 4 4 294. 3-18-85 SSER, AQ-105, Redraft, Rev. 2 6 295. 3-18-85 SSER, AQ-110, Redraft, Rev. 2 5 296. 3-18-85 SSER, AQ-111, Redraft, Rev. 3 5 23

297. 3-18-85 SSER, AQ-134, Redraft, Rev. 2 4 298. 3-18-85 SSER, AQH-1, AQW-13, Redraft, 5 Rev. 2 299. 3-18-85 SSER, AQ7, AQ-83, Redraft, 4 Rev. 2 300. 3-18-85 SSER,AQ-45, Redraft 5 301. 3-18-85 SSER, AQ-49, 74, 125, Redraft 8 302. 3-12-85 SSER, AQ-75, 76, Draft, Rev. 4 4 303. 3-18-85 SSER, AQ-129, AQH-16, Redraft 5 304. 3-18-85 SSER, AQ-137, Redraft 3 5 305. 2-28-85 SSER, AQ-73, Draft, Rev. 3 5 306. 3-20-85 SSER, AQ-91, Draf t, Rev. 5 5 307. 3-4-85 SSRE, AQ-23, Redraf t Rev. 3 11 308. 10-24-84 SSER,AQ-68,AQ-82, Draft, 8 Rev. 4 309. 2-28-85 SSER, AQ-130. Draf t 4 4 310, 2-28-85 SSER, AQ-117, Redraft, Rev. 3 4 i

311. 2-28-85 SSER, AQ-131. Redraf t, Rev. 3 3 312. 3-13-85 SSER, AQ-98, Draft, Rev. 4 3 313, 3-13-85 SSER, AQ-61, Draf t, Rev. 2 3 24

314. 3-13-85 SSER, AQ-88, Draft, Rev. 2 3 315. No Date SSER, AQ-77, 79 and 138 II, 21 Draft, Rev. 2 316. 3-15-85 SSER, AQ54, AQ-65, Draf t, 11 Rev. 4 317. 3-15-85 SSER, AQ-30, 31, 32, 34, 35, 23

-36, 37, 80, 85, 86, 87, 95, 96, 97, 106, 109, 114, 116, 120 and 124, Draft, Rev. 2 318. 10-9-84 SSER, AQ-53, Draf t, Rev. 2 4 319. 10-25-84 SSER, AQ-41, Draft, Rev.1 5 320. 2-28-85 SSER, AQ-5, Draf t, Rev. 2 6 321. 2-28-85 SSER, AQ-40, Draf t, Rev. 3 4 322, 3-13-85 SSER,AQ-12,AQ-13,AQ-14, 6 Draft, Rev. 3 323. 2-28-85 SSER, AQ-38, Draf t, Rev.1 5 324 3-13-85 SSER, AQ-70, Draf t, Rev. 2 7 325. 3-12-85 SSER, AQE-41, Draf t, Rev. 2 5 326, 10-24-84 SSER, AQ-25, Draf t, Rev. 2 6 327, 11-16-84 SSER, AQ-112. Draft, Rev. 1 9 328. 3-19-85 SSER, AQ-9, Draft, Rev. 3 8 25

329. 3-19-85 SSER, AQ-126, Draft, Rev. 3 6 330. 3-20-85 SSER, AQ-127, Redraf t, Rev. 2 6 331. 3-18-85 SSER, AQ-135, Redraft, Rev. 2 14 332. 3-22-85 SSER,AQ-50-III 47 21

- ~

\ ,

\

GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTADILITY PROJECT 13 >5 Connecticut ? enue, N.W., Soire 202 Washington, D.C. 20036 (202)232-8550  ;

G:85:104 '

January 21, 1985

/

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST E & MORMATION ACI REQUESI ,

N M8 Director Office of Administration Nuclear Regulatory Commission kg h/~M-g Washington, D.C. 20555 To Whom It May Concern:

Pursua7t to the Freedom of Information Act ("F0IA"), 5 U.S.C. 5 552, the Government Accountability Project (" GAP") requests copies of any and all agency records and information, including but not limited to notes, letters, memoranda, drafts, minutes, diaries, logs, calendars, tapes, transcripts, summaries, interview re-ports, procedures, instructions, engineering analyses, drawings, files, graphs, charts, maps, photographs, agreements, handwritten notes, studies, data sheets, notebooks, books, telephone messages, computations, voice recordings, computer runoffs, any other data compilations, interim and/or final reports, status reg ports, and any and all other records relevant to and/or generated in connection

' with the overview, ragulation and investigation of the Comanche Peak Nuclear Plant by any person, branch, or department of the NRC since January 18, 1985.

This request includes all agency records as defined in 10 C.F.R. 5 9.3a(b) and the NRC Manual, Appendix 0211 Parts 1.A.2 and A.3 (approved Octeber 8,1980) whether they currently exist in the NRC official, " working," investigative or other files, or at any other location, including private residences.

If any records as defined in 10 C.F.R. S 9.3a(b) and the NRC Manual, supra, and covered by this reques.t have been destroyed and/or removed after this request, please provide all surrounding records, including but not limited to a list of all records which have been or are destroyed and/or removed, a description of the action (s) taken relevant to, generated in connection with, and/or issued in order to implement the action (s).

GAP requests that fees be waived, because " finding the information can be con-sidered as primarily benefitting the general public," 5 U.S.C. 5 552(a)(4)(a).

GAP is. a non-profit. -non-partisan public interest organization concerned with honest and open government. Through. public outreach, the Project promotes whistleblowers as agents of government accountability. Through its Citizens ' '

Clinic, GAP offers assistance to local public interest and citizens groups seeking to ensure the health and safety of their communities. The Citizens Clinic is currently assisting several citizens groups, local governments and ,

  • intervenors in the central Te~xas area concerning the construction of the

. Comanche Peak nuclear pcwer plant. .

^ -

yss aWW11l

.L.__ .-

~

, ., ',l' . ..- ,

Director Office of Administration .

Page Two i

We are requesting the above information a's part of an ongoing monitoring project on the adequacy of the NRC's efforts to protect public safety and health at nuclear power plants.

For any documents or portions that you deny due to a specific FOIA exemption, please provide an index itemizing and describing the documents or portions of documents withheld. The index should provide a detailed jusitfication of your grounds for claiming each exemption, explaining why each exemption is relevant to the document or portion of the document. withheld. This index is required under Vaughn v. Rosen (I), 484 F.2d 820 (D.C. Cir.1973), cert. denied, 415 U.S.

977 (1974).

We look forward to your response to this request within ten days.

Sincerely, LW Billie Pirner Garde Citizens Clinic Director O e 0

( (

\

SSINS No: 6830 Accession No.:

8011040282

. IEC 81-05 UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION OFFICE OF INSPECTION.AND ENFORCEMENT WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555 IE Circular No. 81-05 Maren 31, 1981 Page 1 of 2 SELF-ALIGNING R0D END BUSHINGS FOR PIPE SUPPORTS

Background:

By letter dated July 24, 1980, Bechtel Power Corporation notified NRC of generic deficiencies in pipe support sway struts furnished by Corner &

Lada, Inc., to the Callaway and Wolf Creek sites. The specific deficiencies identified involved the clamp end of the sway strut becoming loose and possibly being disengaged from the bushing. This could result in a large gap in the support :,ystem not acccJnted for in the original analysis. This deficiency was reported to NRC pursuant to 10 CFR Part 21 on May 14, 1980.

j In another letter dated October 8, 1980, Bechtel Power Corporation notified NRC of generic deficiencies in pipe support end bushings at Midland Units 1 and 2 and at Palisades. In this report, self-aligning rod end bushings on the ends of sway struts and snubbers furnished by ITT Grinnell, Pacific Scientific, NPSI, and Corner & Lada were found to be partially or totally disengaged from the structurai component. This report was identified as a 10 CFR Part 21 notification.

Discussion:

The problem of loose bushings in snubber and sway strut assemblies is potent-ially generic to all sizes of all manufacturers' assembles. However, the potential for complete disengagement of the bushing from the assembly is limited to those cases in which tne assembly is attached to a clarrp where the gap is suf.iciently large to permit the paddle to slide completely over the bushing. s The consequences of complete disengagement of the bushing would be to inval-idate the original analytical assumptions used in the piping analysis, potent-ially creating an overstress condition in the piping or overloading the supports. This would be more significant for the seismic event since the gap would change the dynamic characteristics of the system and lead to impact loads that could damage the piping or supports.

F0lA-85-59 men -

f * **

~ -

(

~

c .

IEC 81-05 March 31, 1981 Page 2 of 2 The corrective actions' taken by licensees have been to replace the defective struts or to " stake" the loose bushing in place. However, some of the staked bushings subsequently became loose and had to be reworked. Another potential corrective action would be to shim the clamps where the potential for complete disengagement of the assembly from the bushing is possible. This method would prevent total disengagement even if the bushing became loose. If shims are used, consideration should be given to preventing any interference with required rotation of the assembly.

Recommended Actions for Holders of Operating Licenses or Construction Permits:

1. Determine whether your facility uses pipe strut or snubber assemblies using bushings that could potentially become loose.
2. Identify from design drawings or field inspections those supports using the strut or snubber assemblies identified in item 1 above where suffi-cient gap exists in the clamp attachment for complete disengagement of the bushing and the assembly.
3. Inspect where practical the snubber or strut assemblies identified in item 2 above to determine if any bushings are loose or disengaged. If a large number of supports are involved in this inspection, a statistical

.' sampling may be appropriaty to determine if your facility has a problem with loose or disengaged bushings.

4. If loose or disengaged bushings are found at your facility, take appro-priate corrective actions to ensure that complete disengagement of the assembly from the bushing cannot occur.

No written response to this circular is required. If you need additional l information with regard to this subject, please contact the Director of the

appropriate NRC Regional Office.

Attachment:

Sway Strut Assembly: Figure 211 9

T

( .. ,

\

\

( (~ '

A,ttactenent l March 31; 1581

~

IEC 81-05 zy strut assembly: __.___l _.. . c-C (: 1 /g"1 ADJUSTU.ENT ) ~

.211 rREAR BRACKET -

  • -A * (INCLUD(5 PavCT) . E~ ,,

~R- -RCD END ( R.H.) -ROD END (L.F'

--JAM NUT -- R -

-EXTENSION PIECE Il: .g,,i, ,h "f_...___.

..r=--

....._. O

-1i_

s m ,

~

l - d . . . .'- - - . . : . .-4 l -

l- ,

-T-- ' 'T-' PtPE CLAMP-

. GREASE' FITTING F F (m:Luccs stumi .

. W--

'~'

F -

R- -- A --- l i T- i

9. A. : me_ : ./,,,

n j

A gL H g4 r-  :

L 4k @c wk fk ' Qwsk a -

g .

- <. n t . . n. s *. 5 / r) c., OPTION I CPTION 2 -

ena yI ,. +. a tt,w W - -- N -

assmLl J Il 1p -

c- pI s./7/

. s ;..-e.7 th ,o , D, + _ yg.  :

I 6 o 4l, p,r,,. k , .. j e..sb l,, A. sid.

af 1%_ <_h p, l

(

l 4

/

r ~'~]

,',.: '* ( (

IE Circular No. 81-05 March 31, 1981 RECENTLY ISSUED IE CIRCULARS Circular Subject Date Issued To No. Issued 80-20 Changes in Safe-Slab 8/21/80 All Part 50 and Part 70 Dimensions fuel facility licensees 80-21 Regulation of Refueling 9/10/80 All holders of a power reactor Crews Operating License (0L) or 80-22 Confirmation of employee 10/2/80 All holders of a power reactor qualifications Operating License (OL)or Construction Permit (CP),

architect-engineering companies and nuclear steam system .

suppliers 80-23 Potential Defects in 10/31/80 All power reactor facilities Beloit Power Systems with Operating License (OL)

Emergency Generators or Construction Permit (CP)

- 80-24 AECL Teletherapy Un,it 12/2/80 All teletherapy licensees Malfunction 1

81-01 Design Problems Involving 1/23/81 All power reactor Indicating Pushbutton facilities with an Switches Manufactured by Operating Licenses (OL)

Honeywell Incorporated or Construction Permit (CP) i 81-02 Performance of NRC- 2/9/81 All power reactor facilities Licensed Individuals (research and test) with an While on Duty Operating License (OL) or Construction Permit (CP) 81-04 The Role of Shift Tech- 3/31/81 All power reactor nical Advisors and Impor- facilities with an tance'1f Licensee Event Operating Licenses (OL)

Reports or near-term Operating ~

Licenses (OL)

Enclosure -

%

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20206Q973&oldid=3322694"