ML20209H953

Wishes to Ensure That Violations Noted in Insp Repts 50-454/84-51 & 50-455/84-35 Re Failure to Implement Piping Dimensional Insp Measurement Program Becomes Part of Official Record & Will Serve to Demonstrate Concerns

ML20209H953
Person / Time
Site:	Byron
Issue date:	09/04/1986
From:	Mitchell S COMPUTERIZED INTERFERENCE ELIMINATION, INC.
To:	James Keppler NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
References
IEB-79-14, NUDOCS 8609160088
Download: ML20209H953 (5)

Text

s c~

Dm13 e s COMPUTERIZED INTEL ltFEREAICE ELIMINATION, lNC.

2045-152ND AVENUE N.E. O REDMONIl , W/SHINGTON 98052 O PHONE 206 747-0222

% cf d

September 4, 1986 Mr. James Keppler Regional Administrator Region III Nuclear Regulatory Commission 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137

Dear Mr. Keppler:

CIE has been informed of the following:

1. That the failure to effectively implement the piping dimensional inspection measurement prog.am is not only a violation of CECO procedure PI-BB-t 26 and NRC IEB 79-14 but NRC regulation 10 CFR 50, Appendix B, Criterion X (454/84-51-04; 455/84-35-05).

2. That Region III inspectors found that the Byron Unit I plant as-built walkdown drawings had discrepancies and further that as-built craft personnel performing IEB 79-14 walkdown measurements had not been properly certified. It is our understanding as of this date that this violation is still open.

3 CIE has received a copy of Westinghouse letter CAW-9781. This letter reviews three (3) of the five (5) original error notices submitted by CIE to CECO concerning violation of CECO procedure PI-BB-26 and IEB 79-14 on Byron Unit I. In reviewing the answers from the field it appears that the analyized piping data utilized in the stress analysis reports (Piping Analysis Book) is different when compared to the as-built data. Therefore, we feel that the various analytical analyses appear to be erroneous. The phrase " garbage in, garbage out" seems apropos.

The purpose of this letter is to ensure that the above l'tems become part of the

offical record which will serve to demonstrate our specific concerns.

i S'

s"S re

_p [ k ler R. Mitchell l 1 President SRM:ws ,

cc: State of Illinois Department of Nuclear Safety c"c1-

,p5\l pg8"to88R SI8$g4 Ps g G

l a ATTACHMENT A .

Page 4 or 4 ,

CAF-97a WESTINGHOUSE NUCLEAR TECHNOLOGY DIVISION

• TeTLS ' AGE ho} seest h gne $$O ' $= "h / lCb th e'OE fny l

~ *~~~*' "

S o.

% a -i &k cAc=o.

4$ll" *WASbb5 caou*- . ~ '

Pkb -n c.

%;.u:- 5 uLe '

%_ k q& . m sse sz-n  % . ..;

- . - - . . - 1 bk<, m -

A CL t t- 4

. _s_. _ A. ./lclok ,._ C/d/rg

/ 5 ser. A 5 1)- A4..fress.s.~ M. ..?!.7*tCeB.._!f.Wi.l_. . .

p) n1a 1

• o!.K ._M twe r. fr a . ..$uttoF.T_$ rairu._ty-r.eo, ,

I I 94ALB __

foe, L hw -

Wi Coc estp _ S f.h M N T .._ % c ? _. W E .. 8 te ve'.y W e t,. l.$ Z e 4 9 IC ' wsen Ar - A 3_* g_t.u.s.rs.A D ._oE_ ._J ! .*M a _Mt.$..}a.c.s.a.._

. .tw a z (S us c.Ao sr1 ix nie. core #e L.__a4t_m . _ _...

<rtmM . T&ypwwg Stustes /W P4 ne. rutty of TWE fiff s~

_.ME 7MutMt-b Aesoc) . 6tNet Th(G NEu A ufs/6 tt Mof'E i -

M L B E _ _ M b.... $ - A rE E ttt*t M E Co*J o ~D(lE y t !t u t s 4 m 16 GunuMce. . . . _ . . . _

NM. swr a _dinnt . 2 $ 3o 9, . i s.ao s* ea t ._ . .. . _ _ _. . .

" Ad 4

<. 4 9*. . ._ -. ' i .--.. -.

l EkLJ> 'r 4__J 99e.. _. a _ - . . . . _. ..

o r:. 1 e e_ s g ..

, 4._3_r$. 's f . _ . _ . . . . ._

7thc aismJ ava 7kinow of 1rrf6 PrAF Atov'D A.FF&CT, _ twt.._SWM!Ft_f._(/t'reygqis) does Ava 76. Acwnwasae 89ets.s_ Js**S_,..hbe,ev

~,

N. , .tk /WC. D m /w& /$ eIEp /D4

_a {

._ eu r# surMr t.ases ave n/e kcowerat souns toA>s 7 - - _ . - - _ . __

bl g

. . . ~_

l

.. .. ~

AS v. etv aufnOR OAft CnE'O Sv OA78 CMED.SV CATE NO OaTE urS ST 68e3=M p @mp (C6 @ _ _._ _ ..,__.._ _ _

e ATTACHMENT A _ ,

.~ue < - t :.  ;

ay_pr- .

WESTINGHOUSE NUCLEAR TECHNOLOGY DIVISION l

/*

\ 'iDIw.wpset er 6>90tWI #

DGwnedcf dH 5D Cc-46,pamP "f CF z PROJE CT OATE CM f DATE CnE'O. 87 gayg W

J 8YA0NI ,

'h/96 I

_b s o. / omou,

-- n2 e s or =o.

.._P. U.S._Sklii l~ __Y. o_5 WFLUA tE _ P$siv$

S'ys17M f.se.._. ..

-.=/.g.

- 9/54dEtRSN(f - Mdd

~

95v4, -tsYfett-- DGfeb  :

_._.__.._[.

_ _ __ __.,_-_/. 2t tts , . . . _ _ . . _ _

H W N '_'M_ . _ _ _ _ . . . . . _ ___ __ .. _iso, CC -46, $ev- 7P, A_ &_ m_ V _ Q~_ _ I* !.') _ . H W H 7 N_ _. 1s0, CC-4 6, Aerv-7)*-..

"t ')-1 CC / A0 -PA rH6 f;$DB/5 M-

-) 4L /*ed.e. -c.c9tFsp:e ,-10/syk1: ---

. W / cC2"J //9/NC. #jbe E W .s _ g g w );. _ _ _

.. g g. ja g

_. y p g 4 g (i ._ - _...____ _ _ _ _ . . . _ _ . _ . . _ . . _ _ . _ . . _ . . _ _ . _ _ _ ..

_ _ . . . . . . . . . _ . - _ . . . . . . .__ __ _= __ __. _.

o

' dis CA Es nncy ; _. . . 7ye ppsety.ssh pipina C,cinc l

_ _ _ _ _ . . _ - . . . . ' _ . . ff guaq _. ther ...hl%015AnCN .-/6R8-303

-- - m =--fpp. ny -~4gA W &.:'.~s'  %-~&

. . . . __. - _ ______ , - _ . . . .._ . . . . . _ _ m . . _ _ . _ _ _

_ . . . . _ . . _ _ . _ . . . ... . b '-60/lf ._ ._ _ClWD'YiCH.. _ -

_ -17tg g6. $354,_

l

/s ppH Gre)cM. s % 99 5% --8Y-ELMt-

~~

C'/sftM.s. / CC/ 9 Ar>rD / c c 27.

~~5U At ilflfi C N .' ~

rXN lcciq, 7"HC 6M 5 5Mk_ls CN _

- .gsc.oryyf 2.2 . sserflC H I$ 0.sS' C*f Ur/G .

1 EH icc17, f Ne A NCHat., l' Crl @ f4&7'

'_ {G , $n0 NICtf IS f t 9 F 7' f. CH O. S!!1 CG' agv agy Aufm04 CATS (..e n ' o s v OATA CMEO.8v CATE l 40 'OAft )

wes'rinomowsa acaw semiso  !

i

---__m.- , . - . _.

i ATTACHMENT A

. Pare 3 ~' t.

WESTINGHOUSE NUCLEAR TECHNOLOGY DIVISION CAN-9~i "hggyfog SF AWON / 'AsotSWC/ ON /.rd Ct46,4-7b ,, ""L.

' M W a y *}'

j% n a BO w-._  :

'"?)/(L WE' MPO O RO u*

_. EvsLUertetW ~ (C@t9t!Nlt61 _ _ _ _

l 7Heee t.s kt pHcste, an.b Tye seoirevy is

- - -- -- ShentY Cl>t%FE TC 'Dennest s* w ec~'/2 p g , tw

~~~~ ' ~ '

45* d W sNT9 7 ton Deutettav ts noy

.__ _ . . _ _ .. S 'C'NIF!mt<f.

..)"04towsM .. M _re S W

- --- SfGGusse s (N --7"HE - --ytcr Hity-pr -rup-kenre.

= . - . _ . _ _ _ . . . . _ . . . - - . . _ _ _ - . _ . . _

JNIHttf gigt.s et.j - tetn4D- -Efl.9F- -

, -- } g ) (IM* M bD h) b M [ M N,

((.

~ ~~~

Ns

• gf vo mo 2. 39 .e os 2 s ~~~1c. s~^ z

_ _ . _ . . _ _ . g . ..

(me-sm) {g.. . 'Ginih Cwaii) ~ ,

,g

_ ggt . _ . __ . . . .

(W . . . _ . _ . . _ . . .-

3

) .... W .._ _(.'_ D /

-- -- --- , fo+0' - sw sene, snpense s - Aer -stery -l.m, y _.g g, g .,f C#rs der C#dca uDGD WN pp/esu s spfJE

- . Id' 4 f>u, SCC 601M -$WD 14tv DE4 /Af4N

1. AS t/vs'/aiWFt W 7 #PMiref d'N itres Exs e .

~ ~ ' ~

5 5 (j l 7 - YM7 Pds/VG Sys wh 1.s 55 u #ccc M r

. . . . f/ YM THE WNk m i#ticM /H S545r Mih N @Nt .- - - -

aufmom DATE CME O SV DEIR Can O. Sv Ga?t REW mtv 40 0478 8tESTl4GreOWS8 8 Omed 483130

ATTACHMENT A

• 4 e, - Pss e 1 er 4 WESTINGHOUSE NUCLEAR TECHNOLOGY DIVISION c.g.97 t bsol.at:oor */ bit run slo Li **OATEZso-PR OJt CT (C-2 7 few. 9 L l a, /

C IV E CMEO.av gayg sned -I A$uf W 6/urt kMh6b*O)A2VOAour s O. Cp. no. ' * /

PAD-HTC.

. l ' '

r -

R A ;' ' Yo >w to64 tke _ddcrq*Cre's. - . . _ f'd .*c _ . _ . . _

';"~4 0 - CC - 3 '7 Aes 12.J._ . .-. . . _

l i I l 1 l l I t

i l I i -

E,4,,,A,o 1, ll)! Is0- dC.?7 htu3NL _ . _

I l  ! I2) PA6er Ape.t /c.c i UC i7 l i l2j bbd-1 (at(yt7&Hi J ( t1.Q k.nf.53 .

l l 7shs,4 AMSLytt$ AA*Th e*<

0-) $d'Af. 9 FIT l . >fS.CA*D's< J' ChKlt.. N. + - 4 ... ...

l I l 2y A oAssad.4 W 1 JBfs./.f_ U _..._ _

i lEtkuf) sal V  ! I

. l 5N_A & $ s hi. . t b (Aft 2 o A G ( c i c ) ___

~

W NrML AM N $f. k. . . $f.dFMENT._.dW N .h__l$ . . ..

I D i' .a / d . usws r>k dent unwtwit ap n}g _ Aguled _

I hre % ua de un- l '- 11 Y, " + to '- /% " - t2. '- %.*_. _ . . '

\ 34 kwe & 9th' M4cdis Ay.m41 /e_ 3. _M-@6.T

. IAscawe.auriel ' rst.ssmer . LonAW OF J2.rd,' W .C _ vsee . l I & rela. Au*errren ' hem Mb. W t.s esamewp_ve.jse_,_p, '

i re eA O ' 7Me red Nes neoes.m. ea .2Me . em.yren, u.ne<. .

hkes ^<s. .. ... D 9*. Tb . J C 6 M 44'V*m/T 13 h]k m' M 148* M- 8../(N _. Zd FNidV# ._172EE*f _.#._

NE 4M!rl /W M _./9Wd. 2 - . ... .CAtumed . _ . ___

A*J f _!PI .& - ic~- @ ._ _. - ..

' ed 9 (A?v m -. -

.. _t .w_ p u--

M to svil p __.__ _ 1 s o v.js: _

det4 915 / Mop- - Wsp ' .__ ._.

We Linun us wh+r. Astm ..!t. Y. Seua 'Mk_.hae*Wt -

-. Lh%R O.etM.es. L as b h@T. M*ecT.. 5.Buh. duet *) .*F

( A .Aha& (*. le.~xW AMred'., cm .se .k'ce&* ._,.. eve <r.. of' DM t .as.- ou >+w run tous lavTnOA is Nesucias 3 A E v. Adv DATE CMEO.av OA?t CME'O. 8 7 QATE NO DATE WSBTahGMOuts PC Ate 563130

--- - - - - - - - - - _ . - - - - - - - - - - - _