ML20247R202

Partial Response to FOIA Request for Records.App C & D Records Available in Pdr.App D & Portions of App E Records Encl.App E Record Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6). App F Records Completely Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)

ML20247R202
Person / Time
Site:	Seabrook
Issue date:	09/26/1989
From:	Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To:	Brock M MASSACHUSETTS, COMMONWEALTH OF
Shared Package
ML20245K651	List: ML20245K649 ML20247G333 ML20247R202 ML20247R210 ML20247R227 ML20247R245
References
FOIA-89-309 NUDOCS 8909290206
Download: ML20247R202 (10)

Text

- - _ _ _ _ - _ - _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _

y.S. R UCL R REGULATORY COMMISSION wac FoaA HEQUE61 NuptUe.L FOIA E9-309

,k

. [see,h

/ useo se rm i e S- RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF l ~u I X l eaa=

l INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST eenee .SEP 2 61989 DoCLET NUMB (.Ri$) fff appigendel REQUE $"a ER I

l Matt hew Rrnt-k PART 1.-- AGENCY RECORDS RELEASED OR NOT LOCATED (See checked bomes)

Nu agency records subject to the request have been located.

No additional egency records subsect to the request have been located.

Requested records are available through another pubhc distributed program See Comments Section.

'y Agency records subsect to the request that are identifed on Appendialesh b are already avaHable for pubk inspecten and copying in the NXC Pubhc Document Room 2120 L Street. N.W., Washington. DC 20555 _

X Agency records subsect to the request that ase edentifed on Appendratesi are being made available for pubisc inspecten and copying en the NRC Pubhc Document Roorn, 2120 L Street, N W., Washmgton. DC. in a folder under this FOIA number and requester name.

The nonproprietary vers +on of the proposal (s) that you agreed to accept en a telephone conversation with a membef of my staff as now bemg made available for pubhc irupection and copying at the NRC Pubhc Documant Roorr. 2120 L Street N W.. Washington, DC m a folder under tnes FOIA number and requester name.

Agency records subject to the request thet are identsfed on Appendiates) may be snspected and copied at the NRC Local Public Document Room edentifed in the Comments Section.

Enclosed is information on how yb may obtarn access to and the charges for copymg reco ds placed in the NRC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street. N W., l Wrshington. DC.  !

Agency records subject to the request ore enclosed.

HX n Pacords subse.:t to the request have been referred to anotNr . n OCumgQ{Sareen{l05gd.NoneXemptportionsOf

t. .ht vie a er t por t y6u.

1 You will be bmed by the NRC for fees totalmg 8 In view of NRC's response to this request. no further schon is bemg taken on appealletter dated No.

J PART 11. A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE I Certain enfoemat on m the requested records is bemg withheld from pubhc disclosure pursuant to the enemptons descr$ed m and fCw the reasons stated e Pyt fl. I X secteons B. C. and D. Any released portens of the documents for whech only par' of the record is being withheld are bemg rr.ade available for pubhc inspecten and .

copymg en the NRC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street, N W., Washmgton, DC.m a folder under this FOIA number and reauester name COMMENTS {

1 l

I 8909290206 890926 PDR FDIA BROCKO9-309 PDR

. /)

SIGN U E, DIRECTOR, I ISION F 1EEDOM OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICATIONS SERVICES s

. . ~ . .

. FREEDO OF INF RMATION ACT RESPONSE FOIA NUMBER <si FOIA no_yo DATE: SEP' 2 6198q PART g.B- APPLICABLE EXEMPTIONS Aecords subject to th> rsquert thst are dezeribed on th3 snelossd Appendiales) tre being withheld in thsir gntirsty or in pirt undIr the

Estrnptions and for the reasons set forth below pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552(b) and 10 CFR 9.17(a) of NRC Regulations.-

1, The withhMd information is properly class 6fied pursuant to Executive Order (EXEMPTION 11

2. The withheld information relates solely to the intemet personnel rules and procedures of NRC. (EXEMPTION 2)

3. The withheld information is specifically exempted from pubic disclosure by statute mdcated. (EEblON 31 9 '

Sections 141145 of the Atome Energy Act which prohibits the disclosure of Restncted Date or Formerly Resticted Data (42 U S C. 21612165L Section 147 of the Atoms Energy Act which prohibits the disclosure of Unclassified Safeguards in!armation (42 U S C i.1.

4. The withheld informate is a trade secret or commercial or fmancial information that is bemg withheld for the reason (sl edet* . IEXEMPTION 4) x The information is considered to be confidential business (propristory) info malion.

c.

The mformation is considered to be propretary information pursuant to 10 CFR 2.790ldHil.

c.

k:

g The information was submitted and received in confidence pursuant to 10 CFR 2.790tdM2)

5. The withheld informaten consists of interagenctf or antraaDency records that are not available through discovery during litegation (EXEMPTION 54 Applicchie Privilege; Cehberative Process: Disclosure of predecisionalinformation would tend to mhebat ti.a open and frank enchange of adcas essential to the deliberative process.

Where records are withheld m their entsrety. the forts are stentricably mtertwmed with the predeCisional mformation. There also are no reasonably segregable f actual K portions because the releasa of the facts would perrnst an mdirect inquiry mto the predecisenal process of the egency.

Attomey work product pnvilege (Documents prepared by an attomey m contemplation of htigation ) '

Attorney ~clent privilege (Confidential communicates between an attorney and his'hei client i y 6 J The withteld anformaten is exempted from pubic disclosure because its disclosure would resw m a cbarey unwarranted 6nvasion of personal pnvecy (EXEMPTION 6)

7. The withheld informaten consists of records compiled for law enforcement purposes and is being withheld for thf reason (s) andmated. (EXEMPTION 7)

Disclosure could reasonably be espected to mterfere with an enforcernent proceeding because it could reveal the scope. direction. and focus of en.

forcement efforts. and thus could possibiy allow them to take acten to shseld potential wrongdoing or a violaten of NPC requirements from evestigators.

E XEMPTION 7 tan Disclosure would constitu*e an unwarrantect envasen of personal pnvacy (EXEMPTION 7(CH The information consists of names of mdeveduals and other mformaten the disclosure tif which could reasonably be expected to reveal identities of confidentist sources (EXEMPTION 7 (DH OTHER PART 11. C-DENYING OFFICIALS Pursuant to 10 CFR 9 25(b) and/or 9 25 (c) of the U S Nuclear Regulatory Commission regulations. at has been determired that the mformation wrthheld is exempt from producteon or disclosure, and that sts production or disclosure es contrary to the pubhc mterest The persons responsible for the densat are those offcials identifeed below as cenymg oficiais and the Director. Division of F reedom of Information and Pubhcatens Servces. Off.ce of Admmistraten and Resources Management, for any densels that eney be appepied to the Esecutive Director for Operatens A DENYING OFFICIAL TITLE / OFFICE RECORDS DENIED APPELLATE Of FICIAL SE CRET ARY EDO g William T. Russell Regional Administrator. Rea. I App. F A F Y l

l 1

J l

f PART IL D- APPEAL RIGHTS The denial by each denying officialidentifed in Part II.C may be appealed to the Appellate Offcialidentified in that section. Any such appeat must be en wnting and must f

i be msde withm 30 days of receipt of this response. Appeals must be addressed as appropnais to the E xecutive Director for Operstenns or to the Secretary of the Commission.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commissen. Washington, DC 20555. and should clearly state on the envelope and m the letter that it is an " Appeal frorn an initial FOI A Decisen."

i NRC FORM 464 (Part 2) U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION (11 86)

FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION

f

. Re: FOIA.89-309 F ,

['

? . 3' APPENDIX C-  !

RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG PDR FILES

-NUMBER DATE' DESCRIPTION-

L ,10/9/86- Memo from T. Nurley to H. Denton, subject: Seabrook Stetion, Unit 1 Low Power License Recommendation, (3 pgs), Acc. d.

t 8706080162, with enclosure: Initial Operating License Review Report for Seabrook. '(83 pgs) Acc. No. 8706080166

2. 11/22/88 Memo from W. Russell to T. Murley,' subject: Seabrook Station.

Unit 1 Low Power License Recommendation, Supplement 1, (2 pgs).

Acc. No. 8908250194, with enclosure: Initial Operating License Review Report, Supplement 1 for Seabrook Unit 1. (35 pgs)

Acc..No.'8908250197 3.- 6/26/89 Letter from E. Reis to the Board re: CAL-89-ll. (3 (This document was sent to the Service List Parties) pas)'

4. 7/14/89 Letter from W. Kane to E. Brown, enclosing: NRC Region I Readiness Assessment Team Inspection Report 50-443/89-80.

Acc. No. 8707240017. (This documents was also sent to the Service List Parties) i l

l L_ - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

)

.1. .

i pi APPENDIX D L DOCUMENTS BEING PLACED IN THE PDR p FOIA REQUEST NUM8ER 89-309 DATE sRIGINATOR . RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION

.f. 12/20/88 G. Kann D. Moody Intra-Company Business PSNH- PSNH Memo

Subject:

'Startup Test. Department Personnel Qualification and Training Matrix (5 Pages)

2. Undated Seabrook AIT Report Handwritten Notes (1 Page)

3. Undated Trip Notes (1 Page)-

4. Approved Seabrook Station Startup Test Procedure Field Change - Test No.

6/21/89 1-ST-22 (28 Pages)

5. 6/29/89 R. Gwinn P. V. Gurney Memo

Subject:

Basis for NHY NHY the Minimum Pressurizer Level Trip Criteria for the Natural Circulation Test 1-ST-22 (1 Page)

6. Approved Quality Assurance Surveillance Checklist / Report - QSAR No. 89-00577 5/8/89 (3 Pages) 7._ Reviewed Quality Assurance Follow-uo Report - QASR 89-00577(2Pages) 8/3/89

8. 6/16/89 J. Warnock D. E. Moody Memo

Subject:

Quality NHY NHY Assurance Audit Report No. 89-A05-01,

" Technical Specification" (IS Pages) g, Approved Quality Assurance Surveillance Checklist / Report - QASR No. 89-00549 6/16/89 (6 Pages)

10. Approved Quality Assurance Surveillance Checklist / Report - QASR No. 89-00417 6/5/89 (4 Pages) jj* Approved Quality. Assurance Surveillance Checklist / Report - QASR No. 89-00383 5/18/89 (6 Pages)

i

^

, ,2 APPENDIXD DOCUMENTS BEING PLACED IN TiiE PDR FOIA REQUEST NUMBER 89-309 DATE ORIGINATOR RECIPIENT .

DESCRIPTION

12. Approved Quality Assurance Surveillance Checklist / Report - QASR No. 89-00399 5/26/89 (9 Pages)

13. Approved Quality Assurance. Surveillance Checklist / Report - QASR No. 89-00480 5/10/89 (4 Pages).

14. Undated Nuclear Quality Group (NQG) - Summary (1/1/89 - Present) and Procedural Noncompliance (3 Pages)

15. Undated Handwritten Notes (1 Page)

16. Undated Miscellaneous Pages from Procedures (5 Pages)

17. 1/16/89 G. Kann J. M. Peschel Memo

Subject:

PSNH PSNH Startup Test Program Administration (1_Page) 18, 5/25/89 Seabrook Open Items by Contributing Department (1 Page) 19.. 1/9/89 A. Merrill P. Gurney Memo

Subject:

PSNH PSNH Non-Procedural MTC &

ITC Translation to Parametric Conditions (2 Pages)

.20. Undated Handwritten Notes (1 Page)

21. Undated Handwritten Notes (1 Page) 22* Undated Front Panel / Rear Panel Diagram with the C-E Reactivity Computer Users Guide (23 Pages)

23. 1/1/80 Wishlist (1 Page)

24. Undated 1-ST-16, Rev. 4, 1-ST-19, Rev. 2 with miscellaneous pages dealing with Test Procedure Review (5 Pages)

25. 6/12/89 Test critique (3 Pages)

26. 6/22/89 NRC Event Notification Worksheet (2 Pages)

F i

~~

APPENDIX D o

DOCUMENTS BEING PLACED IN THE PDR . . .;. p r % -

F0IA REQUEST NUMBER 89-309 ,

DATE ORIGINATOR RECIPIENT . DESCRIPTION

27. 7/10/89 E. Brown 'All Site Employees Memo

Subject:

Procedural NHY -Compliance (1Page)

28. 7/19/89 E. Brown All New Hampshire Memo

Subject:

Core NHY Yankee Employees Values and Work Ethic (5 Pages)

29. 6/22/89 NHY - Seabrook Station Main Plant Computer System Post Mortem Report (72 Pages)

30. 6/29/89 M. Miller J. Huntington Phone Conversation Region I, NRC Atty General's (1 Page)

Office, State of NH

31. Undated Portion of Drawing from FSAR (1 Page)

'32. 6/30/89 R.'Strome W. Russell Request for access to State of NH- Region I, NRC the ongoing investigation Executive Dept., of. circumstances Office of surrounding the shutdown Emergency Mgmt. of low power testing at Seabrook (2 Pages)

33. 7/12/89 G. Huntington W. Russell Confirmation of phone Atty General's Region I, NRC conversation 7/11/89 Office, State (I Page) of NH

34. 7/6/89 Fax sheet (undated) with attachments NHY Memo SSP #890965 and Seabrook LCO on RCS - Pressure / temperature Limits for Pressurizer (3 Pages).

35. 7/13/89 NHY Press Release (3 Pages)

36. Multi Newspaper Articles on Seabrook (23 Pages)

Dates

37. 8/8/86 NRC Manual Chapter 0513 - NRC Incident Investigation Program (16 Pages)

Letter from J. J. Warnock, PSNH, regarding SAT recommendations. (39 pgs)

38. 10/31/88

39. 5/ 21/89 Letter from V. Nerses to E. Brown, subject: Seabrook Low Power Physics Tests. (16 pgs)

_ _ -- - - _ - - - - - _ - - _ - - _ - - - . - - - _ - _ _ . _ - - - _ . _ _ _ i

~4-

h. RE: F01A-89-309 - .

APPENDIX'D l

h. DOCUMENTS BEING PLACED IN THE'PDR  !

j L  :

40.: 6/26/89 . Memo from' V. Nerses to. addressees, re:. Seabrook - Compfetion of Low l Power Testing. (.1 page)

,~m ,a ,

. , , . , ., ,- .c ,, , ,

41.. .

Undated Handwritten memo from "Me" to " Russell" re: NRC Observation Regarding J

' Seabrook Natural Circulation Test.. C'1.page)  :

.i42.- Undated..Section Assignment Inputs. .(6 pgs) l i

i

.i 0

1 i

4

.I i

l 4

l

.l i

i

- _ _ . - - - . . - . . _ - _ _ _ . _- ----____-_----._-_-___-_.--- _ ..-- --.-. _ _ _ A

n . . ,. ..

< . h: ,

',i_[.' ,

ire: LF01A

'Ro ano.

};p Q ,

.APPE'NDIX E-

' RECORDS PARTIALLY WITHHELD

.;c NUMBER ,

.-DATE - -

DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION:

ic % .l.- -

. 7/19/86 Power Ascension Test Group i Transient ~ Analysis . Test. - (8 pgs) ~ .

[/  ?%. . - - Portions withheld pursuant' to. Exemption 6, -

S;_;l\.

0

.;.k-;.

E

,h-

' s .

r yk.

5 1

i s

.i T

.S' N, ( .,'1 J

_t. - . -- - - . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . - _ _ . - - . . _ . - - - _ . - - - - _ _ . _ -

p .y - - - - - - - - - -

7 T. -1 l ,

6 ..

L

' APPENDIX' F .v 1

l WITHHOLD IN ENTIRETY UNDER EXEMPTION 5 ,

L FOIA REQUEST NUMBER 89-309 DATE ORIGINATOR RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION

1. Undated Handwritten Notes (1 Page)

2. Undated Handwritten No'tes (1 Page) l 3. Undated Handwritten Notes (1 Page)

,4 Undated Input to AIT Inspection (6 Pages)

5. Undated Inspection Input (6/9-6/11) M. Markley (3 Pages)

6. Undated Test Group Section (6 Pages)

7. Undated Seabrook AIT Report Topical Outline (Draft) (7 Pages)

8. Written Draf t Input to AIT (37 Pages) 6/25/89

9. Undated Draft Input to AIT (15 Pages)

10. Undated Adequacy of Technical Support Staff Response to the Event (5 Pages)

11. Multi NRC Log Record 5% Power Testing (63 Pages)

Dates

12. Undated Stuck Rod Test (11 Pages) 13; 4/13/89 Draft Memo

Subject:

Augmented Inspection Team (AIT) (2 Pages)

14. Undated Handwritten Notes (2 Pages)

.15. Undated Draft Handwritten Notes and Typed Version (22 Pages)

16. Undated Section 4 Plant and Equipment Performance (7 Pages)

17. Undated Section 5 Operations (7 Pages)

Ic. Undated Draft Input (11 Pages)

l.l -2 g_ . -

l AFPENDIX F M '

n gp.. . mv. .eu -w m-w J

. -- , .y .

.,,a .

WITHHOLDINENTIRETYUNDEREXEMPTI5e

- +nM~WW F0IA REQUEST NUMBER 89-309-DATE ORIGINATOR RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION

~19. Undated- Draft Appendfx'A & 8 (5 Pa9es)

20. . Undated DraftChronologyofEvents(8Pages)

21. Undated AIT Input or References (21 Pages)

22. 7/2/89 ExitNotes(6/30/89)(Draft)(5.Pa'ges)

23. 7/2/89 Seabrook AIT Exit Notes (43 Pages)

24. Orafts of Augmented Inspection Tears Inspection Report No.

50-443/89-82 (744 Pages) 2b. Note's on Plant Trip (3 Pages)

26. 6/26/89 Notes (1 Page)

(cont'd)

27. 6/28/89 Inspection Summary Report No. 50-443/89-81, OI List, 766 and Report Draft (37 Pages)

28. Undated Exit Meeting 6/23/89 Notes for Team Inspection 89-81 (4 Pages) 29* 7/5/89 Questions from July 5,1989 Operating Reactors Events Briefing Concerning Seabrook Event on 6/22/89 (AIT) (1 Page)

30. 7/19/89 Draft Inspection No. 50-443/89-81 (54 Pages)

31. Undated Changes to Draft (4 Pages)

_ _ - - - - - _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -