ML20112J839

Forwards Motions Addressing 12 Contentions.Summary Disposition of All Outstanding Admitted Emergency Preparedness Contentions Except Wilson Contention 11 Sought by Applicants

ML20112J839
Person / Time
Site:	Harris
Issue date:	01/14/1985
From:	Baxter T CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT CO., NORTH CAROLINA MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCIES, SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To:	Bright G, Carpenter J, Kelley J Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML20112J843	List: ML20112J839 ML20112J852 ML20112J864 ML20112J867 ML20112J876 ML20112J883 ML20112J890 ML20112J898 ML20112J904 ML20112J913 ML20112J928 ML20112J936 ML20112J952 ML20112J959 ML20112J966 ML20112J976 ML20112J980 ML20112J999 ML20112K015 ML20112K038 ML20112K042 ML20112K046 ML20112K054 ML20112K067 ML20112K077 ML20112K080 ML20112K082 ML20112K094 ML20112K100 ML20112K105 ML20112K116 ML20112K118
References
CON-#185-157, RTR-NUREG-0654, RTR-NUREG-654 OL, NUDOCS 8501180388
Download: ML20112J839 (2)

Text

t /M SHAW, PITTMAN PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A pamTNERSMep OF PROFESSeONAL CORPORATIONS t' a : Jr'rq 1800 he STRE tT, N. W.

WASHINGTON. D. C 20036 rawSay o. POvv3 oc. STEmwrN ..MuTTtra.e c.

02) 822-COO o,y,o g, cy,,g,g, ,,,, t gy , ,,,a

~

to F TR an p.c. J MES e wau'gfn y e Ou SI A .a ATwt wS mas muTLgoog

?i'25"cS*?~M."dg c "a%?'4 :"Iht ",c,e '

=ft'r'.:O ca'A m eT -e.w.Cc c.

erennec.;~,.c c ,82S,@,77,,2) :55 =tu""vT:m:? ^r=T

=~ r = Rw ="

L TT

• DE Cn u t g IN' A E A OEm 0 TO AS2C2Um D M $F.Tmav" SO A2 C mapsFAE 500 f%"2 "R""':'u'h'"C"' '.t'."5"c" "fJO^cM*c"u"'"* U nosafe' 2W.c 4 2 3'C !"O's "fa'a'm"~O UI/R WC M Pa"<t

^

000hE.:--G i SE4 4 "

sh"N8m E t i.#,yt,,.

t.'L.V'~^d'2:'&',*#& d"

= m SS u .c

• roma s v. ausa am.. c..

. TFF.J"*.V. Q ".(. M .

w:.u=otASSm

• m=v w

, c.

.,0 ~m con sc ..es tees (Swawtaw wSw)

"fle,"aic'.

g

.ww.T.

";'$<*?g ou,,,, c,,, , , ,  :; a : ,e,.,O:

sur. R,, x, n Iu"'? ?"'w'Ee'S"fe"m'.e .

• "d"ff"J'.*J,?.""'c*

w caetc "Swawtaw" gC ;*tg,qggcy,

, ^;'J,'s, Fga3'sTEia

^!.".'M.'s ".""c'.'. % e" " '

• Ef0'J?oM83^." ' -

=g,"^.".< STgrt; m"a" c PP.*,,9o;",7;'A .,,

mL TON J .* E S ** C. L# . Am Y m CM ARO A. A O v 0 m LEW YwomaS a. maatte p c. Mont av .e. GORDON ISOt Fan e CRED47 Omivt TwOwa s E. CmOCnER. JR- A R47m'CM LElG YON He' MC A N. W R@ M A ,210, C

. AT CM REY #C W RO M M FEmMAN V,'K TE R FE Ama m Ne HO Au meACM fvl"? :^*,i!"TtN ."c'

!!a?"i".". *t.4*JG" -

h'r::l?,"O'CF.M mow. .. ^',a"..?,o*.* Y'."r"%

'?!,t" ?.^ott'c"c ".' E^ 2* *'s.a',n'S"* " " " ' ' ' ' ' '

"8::"."J" "On",'"*" *&"s,"J.*."e~fif,," 'I.

87.".?? i.."4"?.".': "f' i?""mo" ?"L*f,l7,b".T. sa . " , c, ' ' 7 *S. ,','";T 0"AllIc".Lc w "oO"u n".S'i'. @ .Or.

,,0.. sv .. cO - . . - -

waster S DemECT OIAL Numete January 14, 1985 (202) 822-1090 James L. Kelley, Esquire Mr. Glenn O. Bright Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. James H. Carpenter Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 In the Matter of Carolina Power & Light Company and North Carolina Eastern Municipal Power Agency (Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant)

Docket No. 50-400 O /

Administrative Judges Kelley, Bright and Carpenter:

The Board previously has imposed the parties' proposed deadline of' January 14, 1985, for the filing of summary dispo-sition motions on emergency preparedness contentions. Prior to today, Applicants had filed 14 such motions (EPJ-1, 3, 4(a) and 4(b); CCNC 8; CHANGE 17; Eddleman 57-C-3, 57-C-7, 57-C-13, 144, 154, 215(1), 224 and 240). With the additional 11 motions being filed today addressing 12 contentions (EPJ-2, 4(c), 4(d) and 5; CCNC 2; Wilson 12(b)(2) and 12(b)(3); Eddlemen 30, 57-C-10, 213, 213-a and 215(3)), Applicants have now sought summary disposition of all outstanding admitted emergency D "

Oh0!0004oo ",

PDR s L.

_ , ,___. _ - _ - _ - _ ~~

'o .-

)

i SHAw, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNEMHip OF PROrtsssON% Commn4TIONS I f

i James L. Kelley, Esquire j

Mr. Glenn O. Bright

.Dr. James H. Carpenter January 14, 1985 Page 2

{

f

!. preparedness contentions except for Wilson Contention 11. *

(Eddleman Contentions 250 and 251, however, have been rejected '

subject to a condition not yet fulfilled by Applicants.

LBP-84-29B, 20 N.R.C. 389, 418 (1984).) '

In an effort to explore the potential settlement of Wilson 11, Applicants informally provided Dr. Wilson with technical information from the North Carolina Division of Emergency Man-agement and from HMM Associates, the Carolina Power & Light

' company consultant which performed the evacuation time estimate study. Based upon his review of that material, Dr. Wilson de-cided to withdraw his Contention 11, and so informed Appli-cants' counsel on December 17, 1984. In a subsequent conversa-tion shortly thereafter, Dr. Wilson agreed to prepare and to

, file with the Board a motion to withdraw, or notice of with-4 drawal of, Contention 11.

. Applicants have been unsuccessful in recent attempts to contact Dr.' Wilson by telephone to determine why his filing has

i. not been made. I assume the reason to be the distraction of the recent holidays and/or the press of work. We will continue efforts to communicate with Dr. Wilson on this matter. Howev-er, in view of the passing deadline for summary disposition mo-tions, Applicants record here their reliance on Dr. Wilson's oral representations in foregoing the opportunity to file a timely motion. Based on our past experience, I have no reason to speculate that Dr. Wilson has changed his position without informing us. If that nevertheless turns out to be the case, Applicants will seek the Board's leave to file a late summary disposition motion on Wilson 11.

Respectfully submitted,

"~

J Thomas A. Baxter Counsel for Applicants TAB:jah Enclosures cc: Service List

/

- . . . - - . . - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - - . ~

_