ML20136J473
| ML20136J473 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Harris  |
| Issue date: | 01/08/1986 |
| From: | Baxter T CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT CO., SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE |
| To: | Bright G, Carpenter J, Kelleg J Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#186-698 OL, NUDOCS 8601130395 | |
| Download: ML20136J473 (7) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:smo twuummone SHAW, PITTMA,,N,,ROTTs & TROWBRIDGE a pantNER.H4 IMgt,h.oIMo WMart$$toNAt CommoMAT@NS v# i u, 1800 M STREET. N. W. WASHINGTON. D. C. 20036 =a==a,;,aa,g;;3.ac,. Ig**. '86 JM 78'Th Bi""o'l"di.F^cT"^1== "^" S^*tik t",",5kf '" @Ma*'a.w{#' c. =, "cRa .c. E g# c. m co.... m!n.".wan'a ran 8y -a e. creat saa-ione a eaz+ee "S'"f f4t""'" t','edN. #
- 1"
s dPg."., J"'!"gtwa 9c a. c u e J.,,, eo "33L*.123ht",* 9" yV' Mp;A*1-mum.. i. flQ1*("g.? d" ** g,;g,g Bia"o.. h,guaacpw,,=,=go,, y's.',; ram"w '" jio"&g.".t.,"g.5' c"z " *pif, s ^o . ce- ' age
- '*?c
rsa e-PTd v-o.pd, Mu"< ymg dour A""'" 0g."v'".'c.<.b'ifc s s nu -. m= wa ~e $,,c~fg,(r,'*^a,[p o... o. u v"u, 'T 4 gum p igoge-Of
- ' fo"^"f et!
- #c
.?.E.t.h'a"v.Y!.*[o;.g\\cm.,c. _ 3 c.. 6.. wsw) '~o oy $'/;b,c. fay,*o. t_'$f[,$'4. sjO'.*gg,,8"*v
- i',,'1"f..l.J.g t"t.o ca ta swawtaw' c
ya*a. m _.w ..~~. E" M5c1.*d~c" ,.c_ NEff(([uL. "H 8= g v'"o'a'^ o"'c' $anhU:. t.p,. "',918.!.... 20?!.'~^oin'a. **o"J."rezu. t%H?r k"s* Bah =i s"Ilff.,2.,6.* cit.?.q*. ca eta g4.., O,,,,,,, ."v.o." e. r.e.,?a. ".." ^.*E' t.m.,,n,..%. 'u""f.," c"'"" ggppa-u
- b. y# 'k'OK('*? ".
m o. iY. "o287*o* 7 awe!...T'5a"~"a .? ?.".*W*k 2 a i Co'.$. W.
- m. we.
s 1?,"o%^it" 2"' d" ** c"2 WAc?r.". we. "8'c"A :'.o"I'v I,gb :'??*t. v v "1"a"<t'cti &*#<*" ^E'I I '"'e. ~as#'".' cetid,?" N 6
- T20 # A. #!o"2'"4. c' 1
E't"J." ". t'#f!?c= ea as.. w4uun. ocussa 4. n.oowar senasv a. savosa. sus *= c. Lonosracer. raco omasasa = =oe mo a o c so. r.on tv. RicMamo s..EATTY Ro.E AT E. CONN CoWNSEb wRtTER S OsmeCr OtAL NUMatR January 8, 1986 (202) 822-1090 James L. Kelley, Esquire Mr. Glenn O. Bright Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. James H. Carpenter Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 In the Matter of Carolina Power & Light Company and North Carolina Eastern Municipal Power Agency (Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant) Docket No. 50-400/,L_ Administrative Judges Kelley, Bright and Carpenter: By letter of January 3, 1986, I transmitted some informa-tion responsive to the Board's " Order (Request for Siren Infor-mation)," dated December 26, 1985. Enclosed is information which completes Applicants' response to that Order. ? PDR ADOCK 05000400 -l 50 / 8601130395 860108 ~ 8 PDR )
i.B SHAw, PlTTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNER $M8P INCLOO'NG PmOFESSiONAL CORPORAff0NS James L. Kelley, Esquire Mr. Glenn O. Bright 4 Dr. James H. Carpenter January 8, 1986 Page 2 Item 2 (on page 2) of the Order requests "any recording of l siren produced sound levels at any location in the Harris EPZ where the peak sound levels are 80 dBC, plus or minus 5 dBC, e and where the record length is 5 minutes or more." In the telephone conference on January 3, 1986, I advised the Board that I was confident Applicants did not have such information for.a period of 5 minutes, and that we were in the process of obtaining measurement data from CP&L's consultant Acoustic Technology, Inc. We received those data today. ATI conducted field tests in the Harris EPZ, in May
- 1985, during the day time, to verify the acoustic coverage of the siren warning system obtained through the ATI computer model which was used to demonstrate FEMA-43 compliance.
Siren sound level measurements were made for a representative, randomly se-lected sample of 15 sirens. The measurements are for.a single siren acoustic signal source (i.e., one siren at a time). 1 Two sets of measurements, for each siren, were made which recorded the variation of the siren signal (sound pressure a level) with respect to time for the tested rotating sirens. i (We understand these data to apply to the directivity pattern, the subject of the Board's Order.) First, siren sound pressure level was measured 100 feet from the siren. For each of the 15 sirens, ATI has provided CP&L with plots of three siren activations of roughly 2 minutes each. While the resultant sound levels are much higher than requested by the Board, en-closed as Attachment 1 is~ATI's plot of the measurements for 4 Siren No. 4 (the first of the 15 provided by ATI). Second, far-field measurements were taken at 12 locations for each siren. Locations were selected at various angles and i distances (ranging from 2500 to 8700 feet) from each siren tested. ATI has provided CPEL with plots of the data for three locations for each siren. Again, the measurements were for roughly 2 minutes. Enclosed as Attachment 2 is ATI's plot of the far-field measurements for Siren No. 4. According to the ATI data: Location 2 is 4700 feet from the siren, at a 115* [ angle fro.1 the East; Location 6 is 4800 feet from the siren, at a 200* angle from the East; and Location 10 is 4800 feet from the siren, at a 220' angle from the East. 4 .,v ,y,,, - .~~y-,, y- ,cw,- ,ry,w-u ,%#,.,-v,,-.,,.--w-,.-.---,.,,.em,. ._.,c, x,,-------.-,~,
SHAw. PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNEngseep OF PROFESSIONAL ComponAriong James L. Kelley, Esquire Mr. Glenn O. Bright Dr. James H. Carpenter January 8, 1986 Page 3 Similar plots are available for the 14 other sirens test-ed. Applicants read the Board's Order, however, as requesting a recording for a single siren at a single location. Here, we have provided measurements in 4 locations for one siren. The enclosed information was not utilized in developing Applicants' testimony in response to Eddleman Contention 57-C-3, and Applicants do not consider it to be relevant. Nei-ther do we appreciate how it might assist the Board in under-standing the similarities and the differences of the Applicants and NRC/ FEMA testimony. We understand that the Board was with-holding its judgment on the usefulness of this ATI data until it had the opportunity to review the information. Tr. 10,238. It is Applicants' position that the record should not be re-opened to receive the enclosed information. (In contrast, Applicants do not oppose the receipt into evidence of the graph of the directivity pattern used by Mr. Keast, if the Board finds it to be necessary for its decision.) Respectfully submitted, Thomas A. Baxter Counsel for Applicants TAB:jah cc: Service List attached
t UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 4 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of ) ) CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-400 OL and NORTE CAROLINA EASTERN ) MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY ) 4 ) (Shearon Harris Nuclear Power ) Plant) ) SERVICE LIST James L. Kelley, Esquire John D. Runkle, Esquire Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Conservation Council of 2 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comunission North Carolina Washington, D.C. 20555 307 Granville Road Chapel Rill, North Carolina 27514. Mr. Glenn O. Bright M. Travis Payne, Esquire Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Edelstein and Payne U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P.O. Box 12607 4 Washington, D.C. 20555 Raleigh, North Carolina 27605 Dr. James R. Carpenter Dr. Richard D. Nilson Atomic' Safety and Licensing Board 729 Hunter Street U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Apex, North Carolina 27502 Washington, D.C. 20555 charles A. Barth, Esquire Mr. Wells Eddleman Janice E. Moore, Esquire 806 Parker Street Office of Executive Legal Director Durham, NC 27701 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cosuaission Washington, D.C. 20555 3 Docketing and Service Section Richard E. Jones, Esquire Office of the Secretary Vice President and Senior Counsel U.S.' Nuclear Regulatory Commission Carolina Power & Light Company i Nashington, D.C. 20555 P.O. Box 1551 Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 Mr. Daniel F. Road, President Dr. Linda W. Little ? CHANGE Governor's Waste Management Board P.O. Box 2151 513 Albemarle Building Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 325 North Salisbury Street Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 ,m--- v --ww.-w w, r e.rr-m,- ,,_mn_,n,_,. w ,m,.. awe,mn,wm,,wn.-
A L Bradley W. Jones, Esquire i' O.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region II 101 Marrietta Street Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Mr. Robert P. Gruber i Executive Director Public Staff - NCUC P.O. Box 991 Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 Jo Anne Sanford, Esquire Special Deputy Attorney General P.O. Box 629 Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 Joseph Flynn, Esquire FEMA 500 C Street, S.W., Suite 480 Washington, D.C. 20740 Steven Rochlis, Esquire Regional Counsel FEMA 1371 Peachtree Street, N.E. Atlanta, Georgia 30309 i I
Attachnent 1 I, First Activation 130 - ~~ - 1 _M.~__ C _- '_A.., ;. _,, -.,. M;. _ _ -. 1 .i ..... ___ g._ J._.._~_ j -o... _. -l 110 = I ^:_-- 0 ~~ ~* 10 0 7 ;, _. -- -(I_ g - a _ L._.__. i. ._ _ f,} ~ 90 t-- ~ ~ ~ ~ - - - - - ~ ~ ~__ I I m 5 I I B I O 30 60 90 120 150 o TIME (SECONDS) I m V Second Activation Z 13 0 I r- ~ g 120 .T--~-~._I'-l---'~_^..d. W .-~.C . f. 2 4 I W 110 i a _ p__y. __.- t m 100 l g s _ _.j___ .g.._ 3 M 90 g I 5 y g r m O 3 60 90 1 0 150 I TIME (SECONDS) m Q. Third Activation O 2 6 130 3 O I m 120 110 i I._T .\\. \\ 100 g_..._...-_._r.._... _" 5.. _..__..__.L_. l ._.=_ = 0 30 60 0 120 150 TIME (SECONDS) 1 SOUND PRESSURE LEVEL VARIATION VERSUS TIME l OUTPUT AT 100 FEET FROM ROTATING SIREN I SIREN NUMBER: 4 g Acoustic TECHNOLOGY INC.
Attachmcat 2 Fir s t Activ a tio n Measurement Location:10 80 _ -,,=_,_ _, -ua ~ 8 .._;,i._ j.s _ _ ia t_ jyg,- ,gn q/gt__ 70 [f.It- -~ ,ipTp f.y ;:d, 2Gy{I.-g. W- .. _ f., l 60 - < b;I:g .g 1 .JgJg ". r- ' .1 3* ~f~~~ u ?-'[' 50 ' ". ~ ..,~- _4. _ p ] ( g-- --- g i Y I. 40 N -~~~ I = w O 30 60 90 120 150 TIME (SECONDS) I o m V Second Activation Measurement Location:6 I I Z 80 ~ J i*
- ~
~" 70 C'~~ ~ Cg_w __ 7-n _._._.4171 W W i i r _f.- t,h. y y M- ' 'i b,' W n
- 4. 4 d-4,1.-
3-c i_. L hgC -5.T[*1-' (i. k i. i_q] .i 60 _u...wa a I 1 "" ~ ~aK ~ ~. -
- C fr i
Zi f:~- - nd_t,.=._ w I p .,(=:.y,ttg.p - r a: 50 p a_ g 2.. 40 ^ T- = QQ UJ 3 I 8 8 8 M E 0 30 60 90 120 150 w cc TIME (SECONDS) G. Third Activation I O Measurement Location:2 2 80 -= 3 it O - ~~. t I W M 70 i b ~~ ' - ~ - r-- 9. 60 .-{ ch.=n,=*:puitFfi;j y Q _1'y* Q -.P -- y __.-- 8 ~d; t_tif,:..= t., ,4y iMZh[ 50 [ L i,G ^ ^ 1___ . w' y~_I j t.' T S M
- u. '
k .p' t, =" t.=_ 0 ~ y.l . E 0 30 60 90 120 150 TIME (SECONDS) I l SOUND PRESSURE LEVEL VERSUS TIME l OUTPUT AT FAR-FIELD MEASUREMENT LOCATION 500 Hz OCTAVE BAND I SIREN NUMBER:4 I Acoustic TECHNOLOGY INC. .}}