ML20212N063

Discusses Plant Conformance to NUREG-0654,App 3 Re Emergency Broadcast Sys,Per Board 860812 Order.Related Correspondence

ML20212N063
Person / Time
Site:	Vogtle
Issue date:	08/26/1986
From:	Churchill B GEORGIA POWER CO., SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To:	Linenberger G, Margulies M, Paris O Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
CON-#386-505, RTR-NUREG-0654, RTR-NUREG-654 OL, NUDOCS 8608280073
Download: ML20212N063 (4)

Text

I i

ff SHAW. P1TTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE

....v . . ...Cou.. o o,.. .eco C r.oN.

NEcMID QOMf.5roner.n3 isoo u syyy wassisotow. 9waooas (aoa; saaaooo ,,o,,, c ,,u oo r. me u .n [

• • M s .T o. . ort.. . e staveN M. Lucas. c . ' "

It*E'o*w"sN5fE*. \

En4"I. o."ET" ."kE* SiilIs"r."T"n J, .E R,L,.5.S.

• C.**"s's' veCTomia uE .'"ifr. 'E . c. EiE".fEL E"E**EosN AL M A. T 4vLom, s m.* wetet RT wasMcNOTo as

. ERAV3 CManwoFF. . C.

m LIE S N TM IN

.u? .u .*.o.

A I.

C oouot.48.

N A SL s .. . e ,,n.

s .T,, ., .g pg g,Y t. c. - suo.NA TM .E....Nou.ERMAN re m.TM'T.o..o.NM WC. "JJ."!!!!8!,an sa. ^

b^~****"*"

',"EY,^1'ChhIform. c. i'#.;'t,"^.h"f.9N.on a^""a= 'a s"sv'Cc"i

• "T.: " **c",2".'ak. "f. . c. 2*&"'J " "t#;.""'*" y fe C#? f15""2"to-aN

• Ef W ei^='"

1. 2L*. T*?J'."#ML

'ff0".i."."ti'6E" "a"t tact!.M" 0FPd@"#?

OccK " " A"".'J.". "e "='"' "

E3.. "'v"f,@

.N,u . .Yudic**

=, "f*1E't 286.%'t.

c'

== am-da ca=a . a-'

9*-p S r .od a~ !.@,A T

,U) 'a*"( ;E .. $. nut

.,. M .

..f. .."g*o^$.*;NN , .'c"~'::o..

N o. s. . . e ^3,. .

"*:'".^4't*tW *,, e 'g;;^.** A8't: 5:"o'"

g^v',;t c;;;'J.* h,,,~,ag,ta,,

VImolksA OFFICE STE e. MtIMAN8: ": l'.!T*N.

n!Y.Mt ANNE s. .tCMT AR.E ON s sCNES. C. ,,yg, CARLE'at M ;7". M Ec.

,,,g, j

• o' Far ca<orr oa've "^r!!.^o" '" /o"Jf.'icu n .",". 'n*,*.t',"^o* ""

1"?"^ gg;;~,' ,,*,,og,=l,=,,,,,,, ""**"v'"*'"'^**'o* d",,"#ct ^:!?,"?,. c"$i" "'. 8,..',**

M4;";fi ".#JI." *. e. on.oa ..*u==

scoTTa.aNahmano (to s) 7eo.7soo osman .UNoEN Ce ARILYN Fo.Et3 "*

/tuvaN L. wnTar m. a c. ~8//,"'

!s"h". '.*?".e* -

MT* " J%"/!".. 2"C..".'2

$,",lr,.an'.'" c C".'go,.',".?

=c../.ggf,?.,'."..

" " co"' < "

." nomaem

e. * *tia."f"","';',n,,, g;;'/. ,e."^.,at..;*.a**s' C . u uM n.Mtt..",?c"ob oE US$4 A. RioOWAT M -vu C. .o o Bowoo,.M. .

N Tma.

u.a JaNg7 C. HECR*

,. o f 'I t .e.t . MUTTL t 4. . C. -

N s.E M A. Oa NonA A aL os g .*

,, od o WME f M LLER* FRE. oNASNEN J MES MAM

Uv'7"'E"Mit'" so-N r. o=== I' m ", # 3 b roN ,,,  ?,",?Jr^2!

n,o'"'

L^ a'T?C"iWJ., moggn?E. CONN JEFFRET o SERMAN RsCMamo C. ooNa.,o.oN#'

feCMAmOg staTt? meCMano J. .ammeNo ll8:'N 1 f,*o*t?"."fe n'J"^:;"d!!b. oroaos r. vao=== oor U fu" 'U""ou. E. M'.s"M8'o'l,".".*

m. .

couN.u

. m.

August 26, 1986 ...n . ....et ..w h uu n .

(202) 822-1051 Morton B. Margulies, Chairman Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger, Jr.

a.tomic Safety and Licensir;g Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Board U.S. tluelear RegulMtory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commit: tsion Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. Oscar H. Paris Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 In the Matter of Georgia Power Company, et al.

(Vgtle Electric Generating Plant"'~UiiTts 1 and 2)

Docket Nos. 50-421 and 50-425-o G Gentlement In its August 12, 1985 " Memorandum and Order (Ruling on Joint Intervenors' Proposed Contentions on Emergency Planning)"

(" August 12 Order"), the Licensing Board rejected Joint Interve-nors' proposed Contention EP-2(d), which would have required Applicants to " ensure that all residents have televisions or ra-dios to turn to for additional While the information Board agreed in the withevent of a ra-Applicants diological accident."

l that NUREG-0654 does not require Applicants to ensura,that all residents hase radios or TVs, the Board noted that,NJREG-0654 "unequivecally requires that Applicants demonstrate that the EDS is in place." August 12 Order at 17.

8600280073 060026 j'] PDR ADOCK 0500

SHAW, PITTM AN, P,oTTs & TRC,WBRIDGE A PARTh(R$selP INCLUDING PROFESS *ONAk CONMRATION$

August 26, 1986 Page 2 Specifically, the Board expressed concern about language in Appendix 3 of Revision 1 of the "Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Unit 1 and Unit 2 Emergency Plan" ("Vogtle Plan") which indi-cated:

Detailed information and instructions may be broadcast en local commercial radio and television stations; and Within the plume exposure pathway EPZ the system will provide an alerting signal and notification by NOAA radio; further notifi-cation might also be provided by local com-mercial radio and television stations which may be, activated via EBS.

(Emphasis supplied by the Board).

' Although the Board acknowledged that the Vogtle Plan includ-ed letters of agreement from local radio and TV stations, the Board characterized the language of the plan itself as "equivo-cal." The Board therefore directed Applicants to " change the language in Appendix 3 to the Vogtle Plan to conform to the clear intent of Appendix 3 to NUREG-0654," and to " inform the Board when the appropriate change of language has been made and distri-buted to holders of copies of the Vogtle Plan." August 12 Order at 16-17.

By letter dated February 25, 1986, Applicants transmitted to the NRC revision 5 of the Vogtle Plan. (Copies were also pro-vided to Joint Intervenors and other holders of controlled copies of.the Vogtle Plan). Appendix 3 of revision 5 eliminates the equivocal language quoted by the Board, and affirmatively states:

Detailed information and instructions will be broadcast on local EBS radio and tele- '

vision stations. Twenty commercial radio stations (13 AM; 7 FM), three commercial television stations; and one educational

! television station whose broadcasts are received in the plume exposure pathway EPZ have agreed to broadcast emergency

. Instructions and information in cooperation i

-2 Y

SH Aw, PITT M AN, P0TTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNEN%8889 INCLUDING PeorESSION AL ConPON47'ONS f

s August 26, 1986 Page 3 .

with offsite officials. Each of these commercial stations is a member of the Einergency Broadcasting System.

(Emphasis supplied).

Applicants trust that these clarifications resolve the Board's concerns about the conformance of the Vogtle Plan to NUREG-0654, Appendix 3, S B.3.

Sincerely yours, s

a Bruce W. Churchill Counsel for Applicants 1

cc: Service List (attached) e j n i

i 4

-,---.,-,---,-.-.---nn-.-.---, . -

t

'4

\

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCHMISSION Before the Atomic Safety ar.d Licensing Board

)

In the Matter of )

GEORGIA POWER COMPANY, et al. ) Docket No. 50-424

) 50-425 (Vogt!.e Electric Generating Plant. )

)

Units 1 and 2)

SERVICE LIST Morten B. Margulies, Chairman .

Douglas C. Teper Atomic Safety and Licensing Bcard 1253 Lenox circle U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comminsion Atlanta, GA 30304 Washington, D.C. 20555 Docketing and Service Section Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger Office of the Secretary Atomic Safety and Licensing 5dard U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555

. Washington, D.C. ,

Bradley Jones, Esquire Dr. Oscar N. Patiu Regional Counsel Atomic Safety ana Licensing Board U.S. Nuclect Regulatory U.S. Nv; clear Reculatory Commission Commiasion Washington, D.C. 20555 Suite 3100 Bernard M. Bordanick, Esq. 101 Marietta Street Atlanta, GA 30303 Offics of General Counsel U.S. Fuclear Regulatory Commission R. Joseph Flynn, Esquire i 20555 Washington, D.C.

Assistant General Counsel Federal Emergency, Management

! Atomic Safety and Licensing Agency Board Panel 500 C Street, S.W.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20472 Washington, D.C. 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing i Appeal Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

. _ _ _ - - - . - . _ _ . _ _ __ _ _- _ _____. _ - - . . _ - _ _ _ . _ _ _ - _ _ - - - _ . - - _ _ _ - - _ _ _