ML20206D821

Responds to Re 860310 Motion for Summary Disposition of Contention EP-5.Applicants Did Not Address Savannah River Plant Plan Because Reception Ctrs Not Related to Issue Raised.Kp Twine Affidavit Encl.W/Svc List

ML20206D821
Person / Time
Site:	Vogtle
Issue date:	06/16/1986
From:	Churchill B GEORGIA POWER CO., SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To:	Linenberger G, Margulies M, Paris O Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML20206D825	List: ML20206D821 ML20206D832
References
CON-#286-634 OL, NUDOCS 8606200243
Download: ML20206D821 (4)

Text

'

\ph

. SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE j A PARTNERSMep INCLUDING PROFESSCNAL CORPORATCNS 1800 M STREET. N. W.

WASHINGTON, D. C. 20036 RAMSu D, POTTS, P c STEVEN M. LUCAS, P C. THOMAS C. MILL DOANE F. KsECHEL m STEua#T L. ptTTMAN. P C. DaveO M. RyggNSTEIN, P C. f L DUANECMEIM SRUCE S. MCELVElNO P TEPMEN D. POTTS. P C. MATIAS F. TRAVIESO-Ot&Z, P.C. t MDCMAEL M. M ADDEN ALAN O WASSERMAN GERALD CHANNOrr, P C. V+CTORiA J. PERuiNS, P C LE CC"'E " '/ / RAL*M A. Tav witSE RT WASMINGTON N E"M.'"T"., S*,T*O'*."P"c' N *" * * * ' *"'"' N* sp JuDITM OA'E."AN.'*En'OR.iESERMAN R.* " *T 'CA"f *"" "

JJL"NMIN' GEORGEM ROGERS, JR. P.C.

FRE D A. LeTTLE, P C f,"" LS ",n'.P"C"

JEFFEnv L yASLON, P.C.

JACR McRAY, P C

• N RAplFAx 800 au A. SANDLER AMP DOUGL AS L. MILLESCE CMANDLANSSACMER JOMN 3. RMINE LANDER. P C. MARRY M. GLASSpegGEL TMOM AS E .C ROCm E R, J R JOYCE L OWNER GRUCE W. CMuRCMcLL P C.

LESL8E A NICMOLSON, Jft , P.C. THOMAS M. McCORusCn WILLgAM P, gagN*

RO@ S22- ',

7 PETER J. FE RRARA M ARTHA SOONE ROWAN.*

TMOMAS J. CATUOTA EVANS MUSER MARTIN D. mRALL P.C JAv E SeLSERG. P C payL r,u, cagy,Ja JOHN L CA Rft. J R l

% 9* RENNETH

/OMNM.MORE R. MILLER JUDY WTISSURGM ETMAN J. FmEDM AN SARGARA M. ROSSOTTI. P C. ROBERT M. GORDON s% AUL S. PILECKl PAUL M SANGSER NE ofp ^"""E" "'"E'E" ng Lv MATMANoE L P. GRE E D. JR., P.C. ' #

Ul EA MATM WS -

• f4 E D i STANLEY M .SARG SMM M TE SE NN SU SARSARA S. MANNIGAN VAN M ARet AuGENSUCR, P C.

e RNE ST L. SLanE. Joe . P C gMARLES M. MoNT A,NGE

, , M(, (,' k'f5 / f LE TRAVIS f 4 SUE R.T SROWN, JR. JOSERM L KENDALL ROSERT M. De GCVANNI CARLETON S. JONES P C. d, ," N " O J # VE g V8RGl E

/- STEPMEN S. MEIMANN ANNE M ARfE PECHT TMOM AS A. SAxTE R. P C. 'U"E NI 'S". G"OW' E B k PANELA M ANDERSON JOMN N. NASSenAS Ill' OMELDON J. WEISEL P C. **^"E""^"

REDIT DmvE; D'- ALEXANDER D. T OtANE S. SMAP RO J. PATR C= MiC=Ev. P C.

J. TMOMAS LE NMART, P C. "O**"O "S DESONAM SAUSE R M(

g FA 9 Gi JErrREv J. A. G OMAS2C2Un SSS CRiSTEENA G. NASER.

3 LAURENCE W COMEN CALVIN M. COSS les itTEVEN L. MELTZER, P.C.

DEAN D AULeCR, P SCOTT A. ANENGERG Paul M. TMOMAS

% DE RER W. UNDEN MAiULYN F. DRE ES JOM N E NG E L P C. C. JOHN M. SRYSON H, N,

• SyLvea M.LOTRECM JEFFREY R. SNYDgR.

SUSAN C. LONGStREET*

MDCMAEL C. MOETELL 3"E TEC N E M M'. M SMEILA MCC.MARVEY ASIAN (703) 82t-23S7 TA J FN E STEIN S TT E. SARAT CHARLES 3. TEMMIN. P.C. david R.SAMR LESLIE C. ZIMS MEPME N S. MUTTLER, P.C DEUSSA A mDGWAY _ C. SOWOOIN TRAIN JANET C. MECK.ERGe*

WINTM8 TOP N. SROWN, P.C. N'"N8tTM J MAUTMAN JEFFREY W. MAnWELMAN JIME S 3. MAMUN, P C. D6Veg L&WMENCE MILLER

• FRED DRASNER RENNETH A. GALLO DIANE MENDRA MONTLLOR A. GALLAGMER wmG.MT**

PANDAL S. nELL P.C. FREDEmCR L KLEIN JOMN P* DEALvo OAveD R. LEWIS DOROTMY A. SCMLOTM*

OL SCOTT CUSTER JR, STEVEN P.PITLER A. PATRICK LEIGMTON Ill NANCY C. WAGNER F eCMAND S. SE ATTv MCMAND J. PAmmNO ROBERT E. CONN JEFFREY G. SE RM AN RICHARD C. DONA

• ROBERT E. ZAMLER. P C. ELLEN N. A. DOLAND FREDEL . KEvtN FLYNN KELLY M. CARNE ROSERT 3. ROSSINS, P C. MAME GEORM F. TROwSmDGE COUNSEL E. SuF. SPRAGut Oest L MOORE.S.LDSON

• s or Aonsmus see o c.

. . .o June 16, 1986 WRITER S D, RECT D.AL NoMSE,,

(202) 822-1051 Morton B. Margulies, Chairman Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger, Jr.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Board U.S. Nuclear Regelatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission .

Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. Oscar H. Paris Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 In the Matter of Georgia Power Company, et al.

(Vogtle Electric Generating Plant, Units 1 and 2)

Docket Nos. 50-424 and 50-425 O L

Dear Administrative Judges:

, Chairman Margulies' letter of May 29, 1986 advised Appli-cants of the Board's view that Applicants' March 10, 1986 motion for summary disposition of Contention EP-5 was incomplete. Spe-cifically, the letter stated that Contention EP-5 (as restated by the Board in its August 12, 1985 Memorandum and Order) relates to reception centers encompassed in all of the emergency response plans for the Vogtle Plant (not just the Burke County plan), and that Applicants' motion for summary disposition is silent as to the emergency preparedness plan of the Savannah River Plant (SRP) federal reservation.

8606200243 860616 4 PDR ADOCK 0500 G Cn n

- QVD

, _ ~ . - .- . . - - . . - - _ .

j h' SH AW, PITTM AN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNERSweP ONCLQO+NG PROFESteoNAL CORPORATIONS June 16, 1986 Page 2 l l

Applicants did not address the SRP plan in their motion be-cause Applicants did not perceive the SRP reception centers to be related.to the issue raised in the contention as framed by the Joint Intervenors. ' Joint Intervenors' contention was a single sentence related to the "early evacuation" of students at Burke County Comprehensive High School, one of the Burke County recep-tion centers:

Furthermore, the [ Burke County] Plan does not specify whether the designated Reception Center, the Burke County Comprehensive High School, has developed an adequate plan for early evacuation.

Joint Intervenors' Revised Contention Relating to Emergency Re-sponse at 4. The "early evacuation" aspect of the contention, puzzling because evacuation is not required for a school outside i of the EPZ, has been taken by the parties and the Board to raise the issue of whether it is necessary, not to " evacuate" school children, but to dismiss them from school to make room at the re-4- ception center for evacuees.

l The Board's restatement of the contention, at pages 27-29 of its August 12, 1985 Memorandum and Order, refers to " reception centers," without limitation to the Burke County Comprehensive High School. The Board's discussion, however, was clearly in the context of the issue raised by Joint Intervenor, i.e., early dis-missal of students if necessary, and the reflection of that pos-sible necessity in the emergency preparedness plan.

i-

^

Accordingly, Applicants addressed all of the reception cen-a ters (all of which are schools) for the plans of all four counties within the-EPZ, and demonstrated that adequate capacity exists without the need for early dismissal of students. The re-

! ception centers at SRP are SRP facilities -- not schools -- and-the issue raised by Joint Intervenors therefore was not consid-ered to be applicable to them. (Moreover, Joint Intervenors were given the opportunity to submit contentions on the SRP emergency plan, and declined to do so.) Hence, the SRP reception centers were not addressed in Applicants' motion for summary disposition of Contention EP-5.

t The enclosed affidavit of Kevin P. Twine provides in-formation concerning the availability and capacity of reception centers at SRP. The affidavit shows that there are a number of designated reception centers at SRP, outside of the Plant Vogtle EPZ, any one of which has adequate capacity to accommodate the r

i l

1

'SHAW, PITTM AN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE

' A PARTNERSMer DNCLUDsNG PmOFrsssowAL ComponATows June 16, 1986 Page 3 maximum potential number of SRP evacuees without requiring the relocation of personnel already assigned to those facilities. '

Sincerely your ,

n f a l 9 i

, B ce W. hurchill Counsel for Applicants.

cc: Service List (attached)

Enclosure f

f f

f 1

k

, ,,, . , , - . - - - . - - . - - , . . - . - - - .- ,~. . . --- .- . - - - .

i i

i

, 4 l l

l UNITED STATES OF AMERICA l NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION J l

Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board

)

In the Matter of 1

) .

GEORGIA POWER COMPANY, et al. ) Docket No. 50-424 )

) 50-425 (Vogtle Electric Generating Plant, )

Units 1 and 2) ) l SERVICE LIST i I

Morton B. Margulies, Chairman Douglas C. Teper l 1

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 1253 Lenox Circle U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Atlanta, GA 30306 Washington, D.C. 20555 )

Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger Office of the Secretary Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission .

Commission .

Washington, D.C. 20555 washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. Oscar H. Paris Bradley Jones, Esquire Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Regional Counsel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Washington, D.C. 20555 Commission Suite 3100 Bernard M. Bordenick, Esq. 101 Marietta Street Office of Executive Legal Director Atlanta, GA 30303 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 H. Joseph Flynn, Esquire t

Assistant General Counsel Atomic Safety and Licensing Federal Emergency Management Board Panel Agency U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 500 C Street, S.W.

Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20472 Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Panel U.S. Nuclea,r Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Steven M. Rochlis Regional Counsel Federal Emergency Management Agency 1371 Peachtree Street, N.E., #700 Atlanta, Georgia 30309

-.._. _ . ~ _ - _ _ . . _ . . _ , _ . _ .. ..-__..___.. __ _ _.-._ ___._._,.____.