PNO-III-86-009, on 860131,earthquake Felt at Plant.No Significant Damage Reported.Some Site Personnel Evacuated. Site Area Emergency Declared.Supporting Documentation Encl

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
PNO-III-86-009:on 860131,earthquake Felt at Plant.No Significant Damage Reported.Some Site Personnel Evacuated. Site Area Emergency Declared.Supporting Documentation Encl
ML20210T519
Person / Time
Site: Perry, 05000000
Issue date: 01/31/1986
From: Davis A, Norelius C
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
To:
Shared Package
ML20195C722 List:
References
FOIA-86-91 PNO-III-86-009, PNO-III-86-9, NUDOCS 8605300651
Download: ML20210T519 (15)


{{#Wiki_filter:. _ - -_. _ _. . _ . PRELIMINARY NOTIFICATION OF EVEP' OR UNUSUAL OCCURRENCE--PNO-III ~5-09 Date Januar 9 This preliminary notification constitutes EARLY notice of events of POSSIBLE safety g or public interest significance. The information is as initially received without verification or evaluation, and is basically all that is known by the Region III g 'g A, staff on this date. i l Facility: Cleveland Elec. Illuminating Licensee Emergency Classification: i Perry Nuclear Power Plant Notification of an Unusual Event 1 2 Perry OH 44081 Alert  ! XX Site Area Emergency I Docket Nos: 50-440;50-441 General Emergency Not Applicable  : I Subjtet: EARTHQUAKE Th2 licensee notified the Headquarters Duty Officer via the Emergency Notification System at 12:05 p.m. (CST) January 31, 1986, that an earthquake had been felt at the Perry plant.  ! Tha United States Geological Survey said the quake registered 5.0 on the Richter Scale, with the epicenter about 30 miles northeast of Cleveland. 3 Rigion III activated its Incident Response Center at 12:15 p.m. (CST), and conferred with

,    Headquarters personnel, the Perry resident inspectors, and the licensee.

t Th2 licensee reported no significant damage because of the quake. Some site personnel were svacuated. The licensee also declared a Site Area Emergency, although this was not n:cessary since the facility has not received an operating license; therefore, its emergency l plan is not yet in effect. Fresh fuel is stored on site, but has not yet been loaded into the reactor. There is no indication of any structural damage to areas where the fuel is i stored. Licensees at other plants in Ohio and Michigan notified the NRC of the earthquake. Detroit i Edisen said that passive seismic monitors at Fermi did register the quake, but the active i  ; monitors did not. There was no damage. The Davis-Besse, D. C. Cook, and Palisades plants had na " registered" ground movement, and no damage. However, personnel at Davis-Besse and D. C. Cook reported " feeling" ground mover.1ent. i Regicn III also contacted material licensees in the affected area who handle large quantities of radioactive material. None reported damage. l' DISTRIBUTION: 1 H. St. EDO NRR E/W Willste Mail: ADM:DMB Chairman Palladino PA IE MSS DOT:Trans only

Com. Zech ELD OIA RES Com. Bernthal t
 '                                                           AE00 Conn. Roberts                                                                                                                      ,

Com. Asselstine SP 8.*CO Regional Offices

ACRS i SECY INPO $;2,0 MSAC S!26 CA RIII Resident Offic i PDR Licensee
15 0 _

E)(Corp. Office - Reactor Lic. Only)

@3g1 860321 Region III HIATT86-91 PDR Rev. November 1985

PRELIMINARY NOTIFICATION OF EVENT OR UNUSUAL OCCURRENCE--PNO-III "*-09 Date January 31, 1986 l Regicn III (Chicago) plans to send an Augmented Inspection Team (AIT) to the site to assess the damage or impact to safety-related equipment. Th2 States of Ohio and Michigan will be notified. This infonnation is current as of 2 p.m. (CST), January 31, 1986.

                        &                                                                      {18 CONTACT:         C. E. Norelius                                            A. B. Davis FTS 388-5717                                               FTS 388-5681 j

i i f I k

                                      . . _ _ _ . _ . _ . _ . _ _ . . . . _ _ . _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . . . _ . . , . _ _ _ _ . _ _ , , . _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ , . . _ - , , . _ _ , _ . , . _ , _ . . _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ ~ _ _ .

NUCLEAR NETWORK OPERATING PLANT EXPERIENCE OE VONDRASEK (CEI) 31-Jan-85 g, ,, [

  • J k

SUBJECT:

Site Area Emergency  % @* W # &$ W On Friday, January 31, 1986 at approximately 11:47 a.m. (EST) a / moderate earthquake was felt at the Perry Nuclear Power Plant. Shortly after noon a Site Area Emergencyfwas declared by Cleveland Preliminary information Electric Illuminating Company officials. indicated that the earthquake measured approximately 5.0 on the Richter Scale and the epicenter was located near Chardon, Ohio about 15 miles southwest of the Perry Nuclear Power Plant. The event was downgraded to an alert at 1:00 p.m. and the event was terminated at 2:25 p.m. There is no damage to major plant systems and no injuries. Nuclear fuel is located in containment in the upper pools and in the fuel handling building, but no fuel has been loaded into the reactor. An , Incident Response Team has been dispatched by the NRC and will be at the plant tomorrow. February 1. n t

__. I!C.
                                   '.O ?.P."G'./! CF !.'/ !!.Y !?!STRUCTIC!is-~----..-..-,.,-................l
  • 8 f.;'!.*T.i 2 1 ,1 4 5 6  ?

l,U3! 'm. 3 ~~ l~ XQQT

                                                      %l                g j^ '
                                                                             . _ _      d~   .      }&-W l qp,                             OM1A:    PAF4201 l I." j..'pftL_ .! .%b_
                   ;i           ,.

djl p i - k [ N"*l Y I i F-

                                               ;W
                                                         ,-               -:             immfem                  -

Aee.chment 2 i '

                                                                                                              ' l                      Form: PAF4201-2 l'.f0 "J.I.            !     ky.Cl         N                       i l l C .7 ','

L22. .C. . . l

                                                            ~~l~                        ]f           [
                                                                                                             ~

j/(ej. Date: //3//6 G Time: / / /92 o Page: 1 of L

                      ~

C lA sY m x 1hr > '

                                   - ,A ~                        n d                           L r A A , ,2 f L .
                               ' 44%sy.-                      a            EdufA//                                                     /

Arid a<- /n,A roAA a sn/<aa # wL L-6 nWMMMAdm 2 ea arn dea cha-as /

                                   ' AJAtAm Ad'L,hs WAneAfh2&Ada                                                                                                    /u
                              % f M / lro,a i t                                                                                         !              '
                                                                                ,y                                         .
                                 /z& A2% ,,i drh,AJA ze' mv7oA                         L //14 kV L/Ie deAWI im Nmed, &
Affxdam 9/ ' ' .
                                                                                                                                                       /

4/' . A,, s LJAe / -

                             /                    i'. '                         '(&/)                    c                                           ,
                                                                                                                                                              ~
                                                                                                          /y                               C/
            .                                                                      Approved:

A4( v *

                                       ,                                                                                ~ CSU                .

Ab / - --

1- t ~~~~ ~ ~TT.';'.'.:.T., . - ' , - / - :- .LJ.: c l ':. ...'.. . ..h ?.. . -1.Y !?'Q'. UC T'c y5--=-,---.----..,l

                                                                                     ~
 ,                                ,       3.... 7 ;               g 7                    .i          ,                             ,----                    i
                                 ,        . . l .'                           ,
                                                                                                               !~                                  ~[~~                   ;             OH1A:        PAP-0201
                                                                                                               .--.-.....,___.j Page:        16

_ .; .[** < ..g.-- Rev.:

                                                                                                                                                                          !                          1
                                                   ; gpu
                                                                                                                                                             --.- -- . . l' l
                                                                                - -- ;- ,              . ... , .. Daily inet ruction.. l l                                              Attachment 2
                                                               ,-        .-----                 . . . . .
  • I I Form: PAP-0201-2
                              'l g"                         ,-                      . - -- - . .

Date: //3')% j j c ,;, .,i '

                                                                    ~..'
                                                                        .                    .~           .. -
                                                                                                                     / .' . . . _- _--q l
r. . . . . . _ .

Time: '/v&O

                                                          . . . . . - . .. .. . .! .. ... .. ... j .. _                                                                                 Fa3e* 1 of Z,,
                             ... ..                                                                                        .., -                       i                jTA.
                                                     ,                               ' Ed4                                        A4ff //kW                                  ArtJ                J
  • z-2a L J L 4 ,1 J"Z A R L i /

A r3/AA6Ma&did/a

                                                                                                                                               "           '            ~

kmJ'

                                                                                                                                                                                                 /

( 7 ~' - 14 - C h aLAAi h a 4th %.uMbl.d mu&mt r&w Ak M, %M

                       ~
                                                                                                                                                                                        &A .                                 .

Lilk 'n40m.A&t h. Adh 1she A L ht%b %vd me M

                                                                                                                                                                                                              %m O

e Approved:

                                                                                                                                                           /                   /

M M// M

                                                       ,                                                                                                                           GSO             .

l l ___ __. _ _ . - . . _ _ _ _ ._ -_ . _ . _ . _ __ __ _ _ _ _ _ . _ -. _ _ ~ . _ ,

                         !!rT f !!D r.P/*EW OF C M'?.Y l.Tii'JF..'!O'.G "il3  S      1             2           3           4        5        6
*r I f OM1A: FAF-0201
            !      ? ?;. ..           . I_.. ^

r I.. . ,' _ M [I- -

l. , M Page: 16
                , u.3 i        '
                                     .P A '                         w              l (py               R"      1 MD i y Ins ructi               Ab     .          Attachsent 2 Form: FAP-0201-2
                 ,C.{.j,_
                ,,                     !Q                      IAfl iis.o.

i i c'n-i , n.te: z/r/n I , t. b~ n r- -{ lh) l j - i Time: Page: 1 of

                                                                                                                 /Y oc 3

C.ii..t ' et$ l _ _r  !

                                              . j --         : _m___

i l $1bla t h & A51 Arc 9tcL.)2t u me4A 8' -n-r& M G A f

          .f
2. 1 J/ AL M J Atatelnib iso . &Ab MW M1 finG>t/ Jtx Y eb c dt- f red f?)

MLLJ s /tn M -

           '/
3. A & & L Au/A/wa Rd L ;, P Y / c/

v l l d l l 1 l l l Approved: 9

                                                                                         /                 /

ACia7fcan f GSO . ,

                                         ,    ,                                                                        8E
          /G

'0 % l?E THE CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATIN'] COMPANY I no longer miah to

                                                                                                     <erei e ihi= =aieriai-03
      ,c.......                                   MEMDRANDUM                    \    i
' TJ         Managers                   nooM         rnow       M. D. Lyster              oArc February 2, 1986 General Supervisors                    phons      5704       no     SB306 Project Organization                   sumacci Work Control Due to the earthquake the following activities and work rules must be followed by all Project Organization Personnel. It is imperative that no situation produced by the earthquake be compromised without being identified and analyzed.
1. Plant Walkdown results. (write 1 CR)

Get typed and copied - RAS Structural Identities - Kritzer Photograph and analyze each. item. Initiate WR's for work necessary. , NR for anything beyond design. .

         .                 Non-Structural Items Do same thing                           -
2. Incoming WR's ,
    -                      Assemble structural and system. engine'ers to assess all WR's.

If potentially or actually earthquake caused - code and analyze and negotiate disposition. If not earthquake caused - process and work W/ POD.

3. Directions to Field
a. No work other than POD shall be allowed unless approved by Project Mgt. (MRE, AK, MDL, FRS, RAS)
b. Any work being performed first requires and observation of the equipment and area. Any abnormal conditions shall be documented via WR.
c. In the course of performing work if something abnormal is found then STOP, document via WR and await further direction.
4. SVI's
a. ALL SVI's shall be performed only if they are on the POD.

I l l i

e +. l

b. Any SVI activity shall be preceded by an observation of the j area and any abnormalities identified per 3b above.
5. Preventative Maintenance l Repetitive Task Cards shall control preventative maintenance activities as before however, the actions identified in 3b. and I . .c. must be taken.

I l Any deviation from the above criteria shall be cause for severe dis-ciplinary action including dismissal. i 1 4 4 i O e 8 g e D e e . g

  • S I e e .*

MDLa*vjm . . s 4 i i i l i e

MEMORANDUM 70: ALL Instrument & Con r is Section Personnel FRON: G. R. Anderson i DATE: February 2, 1986

SUBJECT:

Instrument Calibration and As-found Date l i As a result of the recent seismic event, it has become necessary to place controla in effect to identify, monitor, document, and rework any damage which might have been caused. All abnormal or unusual observations shall be documented by a Work Request, and EQL be reworked, repaired, adjusted, or otherwise disturbed prior to Engineering review and disposition. All Work Requests will be screened by designated personnel in the PWC for relationship to the seismic event. The following guidelines shall apply: When first arriving at the jobsite, survey the area for any visible damage. This includes sticking or binding doors, covers, or other movable items around or near the l device to be worked on.

,                                         During the disassembly or removal of covers, etc. on the i                                        device worked on, be especially aware of any abnormal phenomenon, which may not have been experienced prior to the event. This includes, but la not limited to excesalve friction,      loose or misplaced parts or wires, and wetness             ,

l not expected to be evident under normal conditions. ' ) Additionally, as-found data is now even more important to aid in the evaluation of potential seismic damage. This data can be used to determine the presence of calibration / trip point shift  ; l due to the event, above and beyond the normally expected instru-ment drift. In this light, the following guidelines shall be ob-1 served during the taking of as-found date. l During the taking of as-found date, it la required that a j second person observe the measurement of the data. I&C l Engineers will be placed on-shift to seeist in this j effort, however they are only required to be present for SVI activities. In other cases, a second technician should be present to observe the data taking. The purpose

of this policy la at ensure the accuracy of the as-found data, and to provide a second pair of " eyes" to observe ,

for potential damage. l During the performance of SVI's, as-found data found within the , Leave-as-la-Zone (LAI2), and data found outside of the LAIZ but INSIDE of the Technical Specification Allowable Value need not be I reported on a Work Request, and celtbration adjustmenta may I proceed as usual. As before, all as-found data is to be recorded  ! l

                                                                                                           .          1 i

Any data, including non-Tech Spec

        /*. - endata, the cpplicOblo which la COto found'chent.

outside of the Allowable Value shall be IMMEDIATELY reported to the Unit Supervisor and the I&C j/' Supervisor. This will in turn be reported on a Work Request, and

 ,e             a Work Order inaued prior to performing any ad3 ustaant or rework.

please note that the above guidelines for reporting abnormal ob-servances and potential violations of Technical Specification data is the same as would occur during normal operation. It la especially important that all of us be aware of the importance of the identification and reporting of damage which may be at-tributed to the recent events and the Company's obligation to report this damage to the proper organizations. Should there be any questione concening this memo, please contact me directly. cc: R.P. Jadgchew S.F. Kansicki M.D. Lyster R.A. Stratman W.R. Kanda J.J. Waldron D.J. Takaca l 0 1  ;

                                                                  , _ .          ..  ....--.-~-s E

1lUTI_Abb.2..W--.'.N 2.i!'.f.'.b5 505 0E l f si: Iris 0 l 1

                          ,r
                                      -     t _ _f .. . , .b - -          .

i' Y !' OM1A: PAP-0201 L i b.S , l g , , , , _ _ _ . i.....---- j Page: 16

                                                                                          '- g l       12.'      .
Lj.[*  : A. --- p; ----- Rev.: I
        , ,- .m g                                   ,-       j              { gg j                                                                         l i

l' I j[ r -- i KM 19iTiGirugtion Attachment 2 _l.,_k_..Y .- .y* l C.O ! . ;. . ,--"-- Form: PAP-0201-2 I ~ ~ ~ ' ~ ~

       ..'                     j
                                                           'f'                                          //4     Date: E[t/F C-ij~C'                                                                     A                         '
                               '.....:....-...-                                           e-                    Time: N 2_f-
  ! e'                                         3 t              ! -- .__ }.                        Page: 1 of
      ,.(. .6,,Q             .,.!               ,                                                                            /

t ... c -

           $ nb y Yk                                                     df E Acts'~7bme.f JA4                              /h AL s -/ ddhan z d/i,inA
          '                                           W                           T

@ P6 A., -a A&as, M . A -+ 4 <~, d t -L u,,V A M, - O m 9 Approved: M L GSO . , l

                                                                -                                                                          l
                                                    .                                                                                      \

I

                                         ,     o hf

W* THE CLEVELAND CLECTCIC ILLUMINATIND COMPANY s ee n.. e r . a n.

     $;',, , . .,/'s r                             MEMDRANDUM                                     ':"' " C ' *  * !-

V

   .,3   Managers                    mooM         raoM      M. D. Lyster         DATs February 3,1986
  **g ' General Supervisors                       PHONE      S740     mooM SB306 Project Organization                     s ue.J act Work Control As a result of the recent seismic event, it has become necessary to place controls in effect to identify, monitor, document and rework any damage which might have been caused. All abnormal or unusual observations shall be documented by a Work Request (WR) and NOT be reworked, repaired, adjusted or otherwise disturbed prior to review and disposition.       All WR's will be screened by designated personnel in the Project Work Center (PWC) for relationship to the seismic event.

The following rules shall apply during the performance of work activities whether controlled by surveillance, maintenance instructions or other documents.

1. All Incoming WR's:

The PWC shall assemble a team of structural and system engineers to assess all WR's.

a. If potentially or actually earthquake-caused --

these will be coded, analyzed and disposition negotiated with the NRC.

b. If not earthquake-caused -- process and work via the Plan of the Day (POD) .
2. Directions to Fields
a. No work other than POD shall be allowed unless approved by project management (MRE, AX, MDL, FRS, RAS) .
b. Any work being perfonned requires an observation of the equipment and area as described in #5 below. Any abnormal
                                ' conditions shall be documented via WR's.
c. In the course of performing work, if something abnormal is found then STOP, document via WR and await further direction.
3. Surveillances (SVI) :
a. ALL SVI's shall be performed only if they are on the POD.
b. Any SVI activity shall be preceded by an observation of the area as described in #5 below and any abnormalities identified with a WR.
4. Preventative Maintenance:

Repetitive Task Cards shall control preventative maintenance activities as before, however, the actions identified in 2b and 2c must be taken. A/M

      ..  /*                                                                        Pig? 2
5. a. When first arriving at the job site, survey the area for
!                          any visible damage. This includes sticking or binding doors, covers or other movable items around or near the device to
           .               be worked on.                                                    ;
b. During the disassembly or removal of covers, etc. on the device tested, be especially aware of any abnormal phenomenon which may not have been experienced prior to tns event. This includes, but is not limited to, excessive friction, loose or misplaced parts or wires, and wetness not expected to be evident under normal conditions.
c. Additionally, as-found data is now even more important to aid in the evaluation of potential seismic damage.

Any deviation from the above criteria shall be cause for severe disciplinary action, including dismissal. MDL BJH 4 k a

                                                                                            +

I I a i 0}}