ML20236V635

Responds to Appeal Re Denial of FOIA Request for Documents Re Stello 871021 Memo Establishing Comanche Peak Rept Review Group & Notes of Stello Meeting W/Involved Individuals.Info Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6)

ML20236V635
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	12/02/1987
From:	Stello V NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO)
To:	Bauman L GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT
References
FOIA-87-596, FOIA-87-A-98 NUDOCS 8712040431
Download: ML20236V635 (1)

Text

l j[m PDe-oq3 UNITED STATES 1

j g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION j G j WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 1

%...../

Ms. Linda Bauman Government Accountability Project-Midwest Office IN RESPONSE REFER _,

104 E. Wisconsin Avenue TO FOIA-87-A-98 1 Appleton,'WI 54911 '(F0IA-87-596) ]'l

Dear Ms. Bauman:

This is in response to your letter dated November 6,'1987, in which you )

appealed Mr.'Donnie H. Grimsley's-response dated October 29, 1987.

Mr. Grimsley.'s response denied one record in its entirety and portions ofanotherrecordsubjecttoyour.FreedomofInformationAct(FOIA) J request for six categories of documents regarding the Comanche Peak. I Report Review Group. This response will address. the record identified -  !

on the enclosed Appendix D of Mr. Grimsley's response. .Mr. Chilk will.

respond concerning the record identified on Appendix C of Mr. Grimsley's j response.

Acting on your appeal, I have carefully reviewed the record in this case and have determined that the'previously withheld information will 3 continue of the F0IAto(5be withheld U.S.C. from public 552(b)(6)) and 10disclosure p(ursuant CFR 9.5 a)(6) of the' to Exemption (6)

Commission's regulations. Therefore, your appeal is denied.

Although you state in your November 6,1987, letter that the document was withheld in its entirety, only portions of the document were, in fact, withheld. Those portions. consist of the individual's social security number, date of birth, insurance and retirement infonnation I am unable to identify any legitimate public interest in the release of this information which outweighs the privacy interests of the. individual.

As set forth in F0IA This is a final agency) action on your appeal.(5 U.S.C. 552(a)(4)(B) , judicial rev district court of the United States in the district in which you reside or have your principal place of business or.in the District of Columbia.

Sincerely, s A

< v tor S lo J r. ..

.E cutiv Di ctor.for Operations

~

8712040431 871202E ~

PDR FOIA BAUMANB7-A-98 PDR

U S. NUCLEAR AEGULATORY COWh8 Esioes wcsoiastovtu i.vuota,s>

~s.s .

. Feza- -n 17 4, 9A i l HESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF l'*

• • " AAKgh

\,.....) INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST l cocart osvedsam<si ur assarames neoutsua

$ $Yh YWk PART t.-RECORDS Ret s AasO OR 8007 LOCAM tamp amusend&amur)

See agmusy sonores mAgass to se asemmat have been tecesad.

No mensh=uf agency reconds embases to tw regnest have been located.

Aeoney seemets nahenct to se summer Guw are adentimed h Appende are serumsy asesmes for peac repection and capti ng b the fenc Putec Docunsre Amen.

1717 H Smast, N.W., Wasm DC.

Agerey ammeses subesct es es nuesset that are idendAnd h Appences _

b are bemg mass metuate ty peec rupecison md copymg in the NMC Putec Doesuma

% 17T7 M Street, le W., Wungleigimm, DC, h e takist under the FOLA nureer and requester amusa T ,,. _ ona,. eps.a,- -as,s,,o - h.t.,~. _ .

. - e. . .ise. snow % r,.de.ve,so,e,o,,,,,c _

and costeg at die NRC Pgeac h Room,1717 N Street, N.W., Wash >geon, DC. in e 8adeur susaur sie RDA mater and requemar nano.

Er=*amed is hdormselon en hus, you nur etstun access to and the charges br copymg records phrad a sus tdRC PteAc Document Room,1717 H Street, N.W., Was% DC Agmay roommits mesmet to se messet me eM Any applicabe charge for copses of the racemns & mid smewent procedures se nosed in the commons amm Receeds adiact to Wie reemet hoe huma reemed to another Federsi agency (ins) tot review anal eress amuseres a ymm In vise af estC's respones e ads sequest, no eurther accon is herig taken on appeal letter deemd PART ll.A-18ePORMATIOff WFTHMELD PItoet PtM rar5-Certake hdemsedan h the anommed seemsde is bakg autthheld ham putec h=e pureumit to Wu PORA smengemus emocitsed M and for Ww reasono sapend h Put 5. sur-eens S. C, and D. Any rudesund sortman of the docwnene for whsch onfy port of the record is berg assheiskt me hang made avetehis der putec inspecton and cepeng a she petC Paesc Documere thers.1717 M Street, N.W., Washington, DC, h a fakser under vis FotA musemer and aumaner name.

Commenes f/f t

, ,Qll , ,, '

jy v i 4%= b = l,*)

,' ,, f l "

2 sc -

p

/'

ld:hf ' , ,, ,

CST.C FO M eos e n C-ast

l FWEEDOes ()st gesF RMATigACT RESPo*'" fotA NUMBExisi I caTE ' . a

[ PANT A 4- APPLICABLE pf tA EXEMPTtopf8 Recorde mApoet to the request that are desenbod et te encsoned Appendeces h are bang wrthheid r *e ,%rsey or in part under FotA Exempesors and for the reasons est forth below purwt to 5 U S C. E2(b) and 10 CFR 9 5(a) of NRC Regutetsons.

1. T)e asseutd adormeson a property ciasmAnd awmaare m 8- Orcer 12386 IEXEMPTION li

2. 71e mAhtised informetton raisese sehey to the beunus asumamal edum was amcedwee of NRC. tEXEhePT1086 2)

3. Ties udsomed kdormodon is specfncae r en.wed kom pseer slusammes by statute indested (EXEMPTION 31

+

l Secomm 141+145 of the Atomic Energy Act wouch aneene se desammwe of Reemeted Data >or Formerly Resencend Deu let LiC Ots1-2Est.

Seseen 147 of the Aseme Energy Act =8uch Pu8due 8e em8mmne of Uncesseined WM informonian let U.S.C. 21871

4. Tle usmened trWormation is a tenir--ascret er conmarmi er W edermanon that is bomp wethheld for the seemsnia) bdusses Weierfes 4)

{

~, - n. d. -. - -

m inge,metion is coredered to be popnsiery edor*uman serumore to 10 CFR 2.790(d111).

, i The teamrmenlon was submined and essened h emiRemus tem a ameign source pursuant to 10 CPR 2.7I01dC3

5. The utaened kdormadon earuises al hemagency er beaussmus emmets Sier are not ovatable decovey muuss umas e inhaist the apen and *ere anthemes of iemus emmastus as the eseneretfwe process. ademesa. huemumme Pof =d-en~isi hiermseen receries me m our emanuey, em face are hometaster meth the aus espregabie factusf porWons becanae pas ratesse of se team amass puntit en Q ,,

W 7,. .te m.d .dorme.on = e.or,ed *om ic - - A. ure -ound ,es w. rend -, s -Ex Priou . q

7. The needusks irdormation coruses of amenismry recore ."w8ml tur leur erdorcement purposes and is bosng usediefd for sie summum signemed. (EXEhePTION 7)

,, _ . .e.1 m , - . - - . - m. .n. - _ . d . .d pommeer asow them m sehe ecdon to spuntf poemesi erurgensg er a violonen of NRC reou; . e fmm WNestgeners IC(ERIPIOb MAS Deucesswo would conssineet an weerweed kneman af pomousf penecy (EXEhePTION 7tCH 7te insormadon consise of nones of hedeuses arts seer adwammon the disceaewe of .hir$ woiad rowealitseems of cannemens - sEx g Paar e.C-Osseviaeo oppec ALs pwoues a le CPR 9.8 and/or 3.1s se se U.S. mesme

,,,g ging as ormeaamg h careerv to se tum Cannumman eeussears, a has bem doesm*wd out su bdennuson nepvem e ammus eusn sueducean er ende Chrtdan of and Records, Omme of Ameramenen, ter e,ust 1he ammans responsete for the denief are these eftseds idmesRect e hans as ems ng ofRsames emust aus any to spoested to the Execueve Dessaar ter Operosere unn l OEgeveso 0FFtCLAL TTTil/OpW' ICE RECOROS DEnem AppgLLATE GiFm.aAL

-- so WA $$O #

l g ymmsp /mo.*w. borze W D- l X l

I I

I I

g Paar n o- APPsAL RiowTs The dernes epy each denying ocucialidensed bi Port LC ser be ==a==8ad to the Appenste Official identined in that necean. Any emuti appeal must be in g,ng an,s trivet be rnede etNn E deve of reesipt of ein seasonen. Appenis must be addressed as appropriate to the have Drecaer for opersdone or to the Secrocary of the Commission. U.S. sendeur Reguineary Commmemon, Weehsngton, DC 20566, and should cieerfy etens an this enselope and in the letter that k is as " Appeal from en haltial FOIA h ess. F0(A RESPONSE CONTINUATION "'"'"

7'7 Yf4 Re: FOIA-APPENDIX g RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG POR FILES NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION ,

/, Jz h3/s 6 wm E W M /d;,/

, 2 /. c . f & s ; # 6 c A = = % = -

fff Y l8%E'7 Z r 8 ,5 Jw&A ,ys. v6-/o (9'pf)

" fk= s

(/'.

Foz:n- 9 7-s-/p 2, /z// 7/T & 7

~?rt p' AS/6 M .2.ra-: e/ & prif w He/ % &o- W Yh o'g4 -/o ( /g ) { ford- S'7-g-iy e_ .. j 3, / z/n b 4 -y.irm.Ay)))/~4'lprxx.w& & : cp%A Yk 6.'6%/

ws . ra- /o

/ f - j ej n $ w n s

(py) Jt' ras If , /////17 w n -c . 3 l.6 k k W d-9 -os/ 7A 6N s2s y -/s# (f .e-4%l[F#TA-y - 17-/Y-

/ 4 " W

s' , //z//r 7 m .3 A' Wh] M-JEb srs u6s: ns-/o orJW]h

( Po.7/f-S 7- f -/tt' 1 % v/

wJ 4'.

b- /b//17 M.p-rns.J .//& ph s:ms- n wp YA 74-/o -dde/Q M W(2 rs 7-;? m %m --

t',cors-

Re: FOIA- 7 '/ - # 7 8 )

APPENDIX M RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG PDR FILES NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION

?, 2)s/v7

'-a/ w . 6 6. 2We dzsM*

AdC%a. f m /-

%4qOmMpore- l s7-my) 1

s. > Arm ~~sa.xs p xx

/ 9 8 -se .' M f 4 e d -

srs y(9 . 71-M M NW m' "=NForf -

S 7- s - M )

Re: FOIA- 9 7- ((M APPENDIX [

RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE ABOVE REQUEST NUMBER .

NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION-WW/9 7 -x.+~o fr SWd -

W4

/.

s:W .A sr#

&A Jy p o

2. Th/s? ma sr. wt n: r

-p \

i 3 f/9/T7 / &d$/Y

/ 2p-=p .= } & 1/3/ ^ )J '

I m A W. %

M /We: I

&& fly /

4 zin/s 7 q rp pws.acci,p~.e x "

YW ' **

F

e. sn/>7 4 ,,

sspp/J, A.,;%, / /M.

1. t

?/' 2. ~ }' 'T D

S. y/s/s1 / f"g/ 'Y &

w.wo . g " rw --

s,,,1:.

Y dd /&

}

(z- y Wr &

'///.ch , /

7.

wov &. << r

/w yo.

" YO O & / A & 4 = -r- '

M6,akff f"

.4 Re: FOI A-- 87-I[I APPENDIX 8 RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE ABOVE REQUEST NUMBER NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION

%- 6//w sp / y,;g w,_ i

/di.s;akp,7; U<go.s(gfe)b;<'t'fai ' )

4 /G /

' &yys,sW 4hi/92 9o 2J, r-enn fw:

l 'Af~,cs '" ( & ,/ a-s.

u, wsn -

, s.g a.-

f sw&

ar W

nsn (A4)a' G .,

u s i o, W>i/y 7

/ ~ f& ws, .

l N4 vh/n Jad w x.

y s; A s ," Y

& wf / - sm:

"e ,

[< = wM # ~

i"h /m. ' W o.

~f/

i), y/z v,47 "

s/o, &

41 : S& /

n' +,a p%

2 on, &

& - # An

~

/

.,s":

'A 's.

S4 f l

Re: FOIA. h7'I/[

APPENDIX 17 RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE POR UNDER THE ABOVE REQUEST NUMBER NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION j W brhp

//p'a' f g a // v/s'. k c / 7 , s . No , " r/

fya: }

?% A%d A 1

/m gCyyfq j i

//. S'/Zff7 wwN

//

's'

/M ff& lW \

f' W #

i 7, 2 /g h7 / A f/ $ '

WD.

iffo 7 At .7 "r '

./M' d*rA, f / $-

[ *W

/V 3/y h '7 &'f) ~-//

/ ' & Ws.

. / m .-

G 1

so4 &. s, oc, ' -

M /k" (JpyW

/r fN/8 ? /&fdA , xx #xc &$

,& ( if) \

zo . Wu/r?

~

f kkA ws.

009 m.ofu r / . * /m; Ae c< s=

, ( '2 ) -

'2-/, y A+/r2 w% .s ,

, , 7~ , , , )

kA 49/& -ce.'/ /'4

- anyysa

&# 4

'~'

mf y&yN/

f "A-!

j

g -

-.s.

, q v7 q

-) K u \ 4 s

. .  :-) ' 6. ,

' N I 1

[ A Re: t-RI A. I ((

L. -

, 3 .

4 t  !

! (fPENDIX 1 '

RECOR05 MAIN'l AINED IN TH1PDR UNDER THE A80VEc REQUE57 NUMBER- ,l

, , p '

NUM8ER TE DATE, 7

ll' DESCRIPTION 1 'g

• , l  ?

• b '

M : J A y e ,,, r4' d/n >

Sw' pc,x,s, ,sy4 a.

' J f D i p y % (4 ? ?- A ;.beav{

Q fu /

7 4,<

l d 1:6$U& I46~' .

!,I hYG,,,lc ~

j 'l /J ,,

i {(,

) k (

)

, , )

,3

' .}

s p 1I

'6 - *

\ -

g

• ! t

.g t A r.

I 1.' i g .

s, t, i

l. l n!, j k N y'. k l-, i

(.

1 l $,( f i,

y. , -

,g.u f' r.

,()

1,r . n E fef 1 ,

q

,j

\

'% 1

)

.' y t ,

i 3 i g ./

i dkx

, > s, ,, .

-;,a l

s

'(. ,..

t n

_ n a

Re: FOIA- $7pjf APPENDIX O l RECORDS TOTALLY WITHl.' ELD L W ER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION

F & 3 . g; f g

- E.x. c fIr l

I i

e  ?

Re: FOIA- 7/- /78 APPENDIX 9 RECORDS PARTIALLY WIT) FIELD NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION -

/, /z/st)e6 'n.'o-o F M S f em

/d0 -ma& n:& 7 -7 on' ss Y2e a r~*1r6-/o ses (>y);M}

n Am:4 7 a-6

• 22, Ak e ,=r / M , .

( *

.s x & t/6h7y 9

w ws.sf.ayli g

(

l 1

l 1

.. f. . .

. . . . . . . . . .. . ...~ j

- r /o ; ,,3. .. . ~l j m--...  ;: .~.2 2')2 6.'.0 0 *

. . ..v.- n i

w.ua. a 7:cu l 1.:1 .? . ...i C~AISIN T.*/E!!UC i I

1. K L:'."..:, .  !.ISCORSI:: SEl .;E97

)

September 1, 1987 a'

fAEED000 0F INFORMATION E?...2 0:'

') F D:PORMATID': , .C F F4 U:'S M W EST Dire: cr Fora-s2.s %

Of fice of Administration U.S. :'uricar Regulater; Ceriscion

1. d h* M4f W.a shing t on , D.C. 2021C TO MI!O: IT MAY CONCERN .

Pursuan: to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA, 5 U.S.C. 552,) the Government Accountability Project (GAP) requests copies of any and all agency records and informa: ion, including but not limited to notes, letters, memoranda, draf ts. cinutes, diaries, logs, calenders, tapes, transcripts, s ur..ma ri es , in:erview reports, procedures, instructions, i engineering analyscs, drawin s, files, graphs, charts, maps, photographs, .

l agreements, handwritten notes, studies, data. sheets, n::ebooks, books, te'c hone mecsages, computations, voice recordings, cc. puter runof f s, and a..y :the-r d.sta compilr.:icns, in:crim and/or final repcrts, status reports, and an" n..d all other records relevant to and or generated in connection with:

1) Mr. Stello,1/21/87 meno establishing CPRRG, 2) Enclosures 3-6, letters to R;gion IV personnel, 3) Notes of Mr. Stello's meeting.with individuals involved

4) Region-wide training program and guidance plan-any contracts or work orders occigning this task 50 Mr. Martin's 12/17/86 memo to Mr. Stello from Mr. Martin

6) OGC's 12/23/86 meno to the Commission. These documents are referenced to 13 Mr. Stello's 4/14/86 meno to Mr. Zeck. -

j This recues: includes all agency records as defined in 10 C.F.R. 9.3a(b)  !

and the NRC Manual, Appendix 0211, Parts 1. A.2 and A.3 (approved October 8, 1980) whether they currently exist in the NRC of fical, " working" investigative or other files, or at any other location, including private '

. residences. -

If i..-" records as defined in 10 C.F.R.

~

9.3a(b)'and the NRC Manual, supra, l and covered by this request have been destroyed and/or removed af ter this re:uest, clease provide all surrounding records, including but not limited "to a l'ist of all records which have been or are destroyed and /or removed, a description cf the action (s) taken relevant to, generated in conn-oction with and/or issued in order to implement the action (s).

l% }

• c ,x

__ __ __________J

I 1

. ,- /,. .. . r. ; . : , .-

. . . r,i t hc : .if ornini i'ai s p .: .' .. ,

e .ta] pi: : ic, "'i n "..

'i . >:,,. Gn:

.  :.t . - r ' I r. . u - p.7 le i u t " r eci t

,;:: ,.  :::. ,n .. . 'e.. <

.:' , ; e r nr:0 n ? . Thiough po:' -

ou:r -  : .e 7:ojec: ;ro. cot *s .:::i .- t . s . . ;r r s o r, agents of government cccc : .:.i .t.J Tit r ou. .. it Enviromes... - :ist-leblower Clinic, GAP of f ers

e :o ;ecc.1 p.:b}ic, inter st n:

assis. ci ti zens groups and interveners in t..s ::n::::: for safety,at nuclear r: er plants.

We ars req esting this .inf or:nat-ion as pcr: of on ongoing snonitoring project of ths ::.'.C 's ef f orts to protect., public ..ealth. and sa f ety a t and near' .

nucler.: pr :essiing pla:ils ~ and radioacti te waste facilities. ~

For nr.; C:::ments or jiortions thn t yet: 'e::y due to a specific FOIA .

cxempti:"., please 'p rc cide an index itemizing and describing the documents or porti:n3 of docuinents withheld. The index should provide a detailed justi:i:r :i:r. cf your. graands for clai:. .ng each exeinption, explaining . why each e:-:erption is . relevant..to, the doctu:.ent or portion of the document withheld. This index. isj' required under Vaughn v. Rosen (I), 404 F.2d 820 (D.C. Cir. 1973),. cert. . denied;.415 U.S. 977 (1974).

U6 loc.;; forward to your response to this request within ten (10) working days.

Sir.ce rely ; ,

, Linda Bauman '

TOIA Coordinator

.  ; Midwest Of fice .

v ,.

Respor.se :: this request should, be maile:1 to the Midwest Office: .i .

• 04

. E. i;isconsin Avenue,-B.;, ,

o Appleo:r., Kisconsisi

?

5j,911- 4.8

,* 9 7' ,',. , ,i, ,

vt' ~. - '.

! . a./

. .s, :

I g . O o s'

. b h

O e

J l .

.- 1 s

_ ___--- _____..-___ __-_-