ML19326B029: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Line 19: Line 19:
{{#Wiki_filter:"
{{#Wiki_filter:"
                                                                                                               ' Q '' '
                                                                                                               ' Q '' '
                                                                                                                                          '    '        "  ''
!
   ,      (i5Ue rd M. & trenbtua                                                                                                    *f8/7{
   ,      (i5Ue rd M. & trenbtua                                                                                                    *f8/7{
70L Uniost Cc:.nerce Bidg.                                                                          g ,,, g , g,      ,        ,g ,g    ,, ,
70L Uniost Cc:.nerce Bidg.                                                                          g ,,, g , g,      ,        ,g ,g    ,, ,
Cleseland, Onio                                                                                                  S/26/70                                                          .- ._
Cleseland, Onio                                                                                                  S/26/70                                                          .- ._
ACTIt 'N PROCES$1NG DATES  INFORMATIOe'At COPY DISTRIBUTION Ad nowledged                      Cho;r man  -- ACNS                      COM Chairc.an                                                                                                    ,
ACTIt 'N PROCES$1NG DATES  INFORMATIOe'At COPY DISTRIBUTION Ad nowledged                      Cho;r man  -- ACNS                      COM Chairc.an                                                                                                    ,
* ou              30,                    33 Dep. Dir.        OGC                    SLR
* ou              30,                    33 Dep. Dir.        OGC                    SLR final                            A. D.            RL                  _ ML DESCRIPTION        Iet r      O or o:aai                                    DCopy                    0 Other                  REMARK 5 Expresses concern that pemission may be given for pre-licensing work at the Davis-Besse plant before public hearings l        On the project have been scheduled.
        '
final                            A. D.            RL                  _ ML DESCRIPTION        Iet r      O or o:aai                                    DCopy                    0 Other                  REMARK 5 Expresses concern that pemission may be given for pre-licensing work at the Davis-Besse plant before public hearings l        On the project have been scheduled.
l l
l l
__
REFERuD TO                                            DATE l
REFERuD TO                                            DATE l
Ib notification CO the JCAE l                                                recOcaended ?
Ib notification CO the JCAE l                                                recOcaended ?
Morris          f/ prep.approp.                                      8/31/70          Send copies of rc: ply to reply                                                            the Chairt.an Cys: Shapar Ymvt.SLB-PDR (50-346) -N8
Morris          f/ prep.approp.                                      8/31/70          Send copies of rc: ply to reply                                                            the Chairt.an Cys: Shapar Ymvt.SLB-PDR (50-346) -N8 DIRECTOR OF REGULATION                                              Form HO42 (7-65~
    .
DO NOT DETACH THf 5 COPY COMMUNICATIONS CONTROL                                                  U.S.AEC l
DIRECTOR OF REGULATION                                              Form HO42 (7-65~
l e
DO NOT DETACH THf 5 COPY
THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS POOR QUALITY PAGES 8003060                                                  ,
      ,
COMMUNICATIONS CONTROL                                                  U.S.AEC
!
l l
                                                                              . _ . . .
e THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS POOR QUALITY PAGES
:
8003060                                                  ,
                    .. . -___          . . . _ . . . - _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ . _ ,          -
                                                                                               ,.__...----_ _                      -                              _._.-...,_.,_,..._r
                                                                                               ,.__...----_ _                      -                              _._.-...,_.,_,..._r


          . .                    .
e jvs OFFICE OF TiiE CilhIit'4AM (Date)
e
TO:                  3A D                        For appropriate -henaling gp                      ,
                                                                                                              .
jvs
                                                                                                                                .
OFFICE OF TiiE CilhIit'4AM (Date)
                                          .
TO:                  3A
                                                                          '
D                        For appropriate -henaling gp                      ,
                                                                                                                  ,
                                            '
heply for Chairman's, signature
heply for Chairman's, signature
                                               ;                .        .
                                               ;                .        .
For Information:    GM  /        Conunissioners /
For Information:    GM  /        Conunissioners /
                                                                                                  .  .
D R_ __
D R_ __
Remarks                    f h, Mu'                              7 %,A
Remarks                    f h, Mu'                              7 %,A
             ;
             ;
J              ,                    y      " 4
J              ,                    y      " 4 5                                                                                    Julius II. Rubin For the Chairman 9
.          #
f u._____      _ . _ _ _ _ . . _    _2._. _ _ _ _ _ .                              _ _ _
5                                                                                    Julius II. Rubin For the Chairman
                                                                                              -
            .
* 9 f
u._____      _ . _ _ _ _ . . _    _2._. _ _ _ _ _ .                              _ _ _


,.  .                                                                                            /L llOWARD M. MLT/ENDAt*M
,.  .                                                                                            /L llOWARD M. MLT/ENDAt*M
                                                           ~O0 t*NION COMMEkCE DIDG.
                                                           ~O0 t*NION COMMEkCE DIDG.
C LEV ELAN D 18. O1110
C LEV ELAN D 18. O1110 I  7    ; j  ['
                                              .
I f
I  7    ; j  ['
I
  .
f
(/L      'l)'
(/L      'l)'
August 26, 1970
August 26, 1970
                                                                                                -


==Dear Dr. Seaborg:==
==Dear Dr. Seaborg:==


I am alarmed at published reports that two utilities may be given Atomic Energy Commission permission to lay concrete at the proposed Davis-Besse anclear power plant even before public hearings on the project have been scheduled.
I am alarmed at published reports that two utilities may be given Atomic Energy Commission permission to lay concrete at the proposed Davis-Besse anclear power plant even before public hearings on the project have been scheduled.
A nuclear plant cannot be built legally without AEC permission and a hearing. Excavation at the Besse-Davis site is already underway, and to allow foundation work would be tantamount in
A nuclear plant cannot be built legally without AEC permission and a hearing. Excavation at the Besse-Davis site is already underway, and to allow foundation work would be tantamount in the public mind to giving a go-ahead to the full $270 million project.
        -
the public mind to giving a go-ahead to the full $270 million project.
The AEC argument that there is a difference between foundation work and actual construction is highly invalid. It just does not make sense.
The AEC argument that there is a difference between foundation work and actual construction is highly invalid. It just does not make sense.
Foundation work cannot be isolated from work on the rest of a proposed structure. Once foundations are completed, the plant will be well dovm the road toward completion.
Foundation work cannot be isolated from work on the rest of a proposed structure. Once foundations are completed, the plant will be well dovm the road toward completion.
Line 99: Line 62:
There is no such urgency that necessitates us moving before public hearings.
There is no such urgency that necessitates us moving before public hearings.
Sincerely,.    ,c            ,
Sincerely,.    ,c            ,
                                            .
                                               .,g      , ~ -
                                               .,g      , ~ -
7 ,' / ,//g          / , --            - - --
7 ,' / ,//g          / , --            - - --

Revision as of 01:02, 1 February 2020

Expresses Concern Re Foundation Work Being Performed Prior to Hearing on & Issuance of Cp.Allowing Foundation Work Is Tantamount to Giving Permission to Build Entire Facility
ML19326B029
Person / Time
Site: Davis Besse Cleveland Electric icon.png
Issue date: 08/26/1970
From: Metzenbaum H
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To: Seaborg G
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
Shared Package
ML19326B028 List:
References
780826, NUDOCS 8003060807
Download: ML19326B029 (3)


Text

"

' Q '

, (i5Ue rd M. & trenbtua *f8/7{

70L Uniost Cc:.nerce Bidg. g ,,, g , g, , ,g ,g ,, ,

Cleseland, Onio S/26/70 .- ._

ACTIt 'N PROCES$1NG DATES INFORMATIOe'At COPY DISTRIBUTION Ad nowledged Cho;r man -- ACNS COM Chairc.an ,

  • ou 30, 33 Dep. Dir. OGC SLR final A. D. RL _ ML DESCRIPTION Iet r O or o:aai DCopy 0 Other REMARK 5 Expresses concern that pemission may be given for pre-licensing work at the Davis-Besse plant before public hearings l On the project have been scheduled.

l l

REFERuD TO DATE l

Ib notification CO the JCAE l recOcaended ?

Morris f/ prep.approp. 8/31/70 Send copies of rc: ply to reply the Chairt.an Cys: Shapar Ymvt.SLB-PDR (50-346) -N8 DIRECTOR OF REGULATION Form HO42 (7-65~

DO NOT DETACH THf 5 COPY COMMUNICATIONS CONTROL U.S.AEC l

l e

THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS POOR QUALITY PAGES 8003060 ,

,.__...----_ _ - _._.-...,_.,_,..._r

e jvs OFFICE OF TiiE CilhIit'4AM (Date)

TO: 3A D For appropriate -henaling gp ,

heply for Chairman's, signature

. .

For Information: GM / Conunissioners /

D R_ __

Remarks f h, Mu' 7 %,A

J , y " 4 5 Julius II. Rubin For the Chairman 9

f u._____ _ . _ _ _ _ . . _ _2._. _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _

,. . /L llOWARD M. MLT/ENDAt*M

~O0 t*NION COMMEkCE DIDG.

C LEV ELAN D 18. O1110 I 7  ; j ['

I f

(/L 'l)'

August 26, 1970

Dear Dr. Seaborg:

I am alarmed at published reports that two utilities may be given Atomic Energy Commission permission to lay concrete at the proposed Davis-Besse anclear power plant even before public hearings on the project have been scheduled.

A nuclear plant cannot be built legally without AEC permission and a hearing. Excavation at the Besse-Davis site is already underway, and to allow foundation work would be tantamount in the public mind to giving a go-ahead to the full $270 million project.

The AEC argument that there is a difference between foundation work and actual construction is highly invalid. It just does not make sense.

Foundation work cannot be isolated from work on the rest of a proposed structure. Once foundations are completed, the plant will be well dovm the road toward completion.

If subsequent testimony at public hearings prompts AEC to withold a construction permit, the immediate losers will be every

  • customer of CEI and Toledo Edison, the citizens whose bills pay for capital expenditures. An enormous calculated waste of money will have occured, because two utilities--aided by the AEC--

rushed into construction.

There is no such urgency that necessitates us moving before public hearings.

Sincerely,. ,c ,

.,g , ~ -

7 ,' / ,//g / , -- - - --

i/ ,

Iloward M. Metzenbaum

/ , ,

Dr. Glenn T. Seaborg, Chairman U. S. Atomic Energy Commission

[$-[N 22- ' L A.  ;

Washington, D. C. 20545 [n t _ _ .. pe-2 771 HMM /ab

_