ML19324C061

Ack Receipt of Response to Senator Harkin Re Author Ltr About Containment Sys at Plant.Nrc Taking Too Long to Mandate Changes at Plant

ML19324C061
Person / Time
Site:	Quad Cities
Issue date:	08/27/1989
From:	Shaff J AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:	Taylor J NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO)
Shared Package
ML19324B676	List: ML19324B677 ML19324C061
References
NUDOCS 8911130329
Download: ML19324C061 (3)

Text

eq> 3.o, "' ,

,- 4.; , m - -

y n t

./f,' ,.

'

.j

. '- ! ,

, j

- -

.

John T. Shaff j

' RR 1, Box 193 . e Chmanche. Iowa 52730, '

<319)S22-2554

'j

'

August 27, 1989

'

$

i

'

)r u

't

'

Mr'.l James M;' Taylor J Acting Execut'ive-Director for Operations -l United States Nuclear Regulatory Comm i ss i or3 - )

Washington, D.C.:20b55 ly

. - J' LDear Mr. Taylorp I r e c e i v'e d last week,your reply to Senator karkin regarding my . }

s letter about the containment system at the Guad-Cities Station. I

. appreciate your. reply whichJthe Senator sent on to me. ),

h Ny laymans underttending of the situation is that given the J right-(or wrong) accident at the plant conditions may be such that a j radiation leak or'even &: large release of.radiatien could occur earlk 6

,

duringLthe incident. Given what we know about the problems that we f are hearing about Chernobyl I believe that this is an unacceptable ,)

risk. d j

The first publicat' ion that I have found about the containment j

, units is an issue brief Order Code #'IBSo130 updated January 5, 1988. -[

I,t is now August 27, 1999 a year and one h a l.f later and it may be [

c three more years before this installation will take place that is a 2 7 minimum of 4 1/2 years and probabl y .more that the public in our area ,

has been subjected to a greater risk than need be.

f t

m Before I sound too much like an alarmist I realize that the {

chances of a major problem at any of these plants is small. Is that I

~

going to be any consolation to those of us in the aree if a disaster ]

'that could have been much less savere were to take place? According

'

'. 'to the NRC doctments It will take 10-30 hours to evacuate Clinton  ;

i with a mean time of 22 hours2.546296e-4 days <br />0.00611 hours <br />3.637566e-5 weeks <br />8.371e-6 months <br />. An evacuation might not even be }

'

possible during a bl!::ard. If an early radiation release were to take piece there are many in Clinton who would not be out of town

'

f' ,

yet. There are mkny here who have roots in this community who would be very upset at not being able to return home in the near future if f

[ ever. Chernobyl caused an evacuation of 100+ mile redius. The f

(, economic cost of a permanent eeen 10 mile radius around the Quad f

( ' Cities Station would be nearly unthinkable, j

'

? 4 >

Nuclear energy is needed now and in the future, but the best way l., '

'

to stop it it to have a disaster that goes. beyond the bounds of I L acceptable damage, Three Mile Island came close but if any [

[ containment system in this countr. ever geve wey the radiation it is .

"

supposed to contain I am sure that it would be the end of Nuclear {

power as we now know 1t. j i

V I 8911130329 891030 ,

L PDR ADOCK 05000254 j N H PDR 4 4-dMu _____ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___J

e~ vc -

3

~

'

- .i ..

. -

-[ .

I ' s'i mp l y feel that even though the local t4RC of f i ci al s are doing a line job, It is taking 'too l ong to mandate thera changes and that the NRC in WCshington is showing signs of looking too much at

' utility welfare and not enough at the welf.*re of the general pubile.

Sincerely,  !

,

,

John T. Shaff i ces Senator Tom Harkin d Governor Terry Branstad [

I i

i l

1 1

l-  !

- i l

t{ a .

j;

- .

_. . . _ . = - . ~ - . . - - . - ~ - = - -- .-

_- _ - ,

. c y-1;-l-e e-

'

7. -

.:

!

!

, .... .. ~. = - >u.a- ~~.:-u- -. ~ r ~~.* - "':-~"~^~~'*-' e" ~* " *" "'""-' " * 'N

~ ^*"**

"""-~"^~'****#^'~'E{

~ '

v

}

> a

!

,

United Etatts Etnatt / ,

i

• WASHINGTON. DC 20510

-

f r 5 Orric AL BUSINESS Uss. b 1

<

.

,!

t

'

i

!

.

James M. Taylor.  ;

Acting Executive Director for Operations '

Unites States Nuclear Regulatory Commission ,i Washington, D.C. 20555

- ,

- I

<

!

i l.1.III....f.I..I.I..l.i...!! I

!

<~_ . . _ ~ _ . . . _ _ . _ _ _ , _ _ _ _ . , _ . , _- _ .-- __

_

. 2. --.