ML17276A420

From kanterella
Revision as of 15:29, 29 October 2019 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Disputes That Util Has Been Unresponsive to Seismic Issues. Consultants Do Not Conclude That Seismic Design Basis Inadequate.Meeting Proposed to Resolve Dispute
ML17276A420
Person / Time
Site: Columbia Energy Northwest icon.png
Issue date: 11/06/1981
From: Ferguson R
WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM
To: Dircks W
NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO)
Shared Package
ML17276A417 List:
References
NUDOCS 8112170709
Download: ML17276A420 (10)


Text

~ V,

'1

)

~

~

)lggl.. 4r t ~ Q.7((" 1 <<e ~ +'Q'la (.'.~<~~~4~T

'

~ S (

j

~ ~

~ ~ t. ~

) ~

)

I 4 ~( '

NRC BHDA 01 RI CHLAXDpVA NOV 6p 1981 %e-TVX 7 1 082404 1 SMR C BHDA'. ~ r>>

NUCLEAR REGULATORY. GOMNI.SSI ON VASHINGTONp DC >>

)

I

>>

ATTENTIOMr,; HR ~ BILL DI RCKSp.,'EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS

"

NRC >>

5UMECTt..NRC REVIEW OF HANFORD SEISMIC'ISSUES

>> I

)' t DEAR BILLt <<

~

  • I

~'

".t .... RECEMTLYi A MEMBER: OF t THEi NRR STAFF CONTACTED'ON 'BOUCHER'

~, ) HY, STAFF, 'AND INDICATED THAT. T  ! GEOSCI. NOES REVIEW SCHEDULE FOR"

. VNP 2 HAY BE IN. SERIOUS JEOPARDY AMD.THAT= THE SUPPLY SYS'd EN' '."

MOT BEEN FULLY RESP'OMSIVE TO 'NRG ',CDNCERNS RESTIVE' t'AS.

q THE'- "" j

'

~

'

. SITE SEISMI C I SSUES ~ . THE 'NRR 'STAFF'UGGESTED '.HAMFORD

'ND'VER".:

,." j

'WE, AGRFED yTO'HAVE,TECHMICAL AND MANAGEMENT MEETINGS'N i T I ~

"': '

'IS

~

TOPIC'N ~D-ÃOUENBERa';

N

~ r

(~

1 I VOULD,LIKE.To. HAKE,TMO POINTS TO YOU,REGARDING='THXFORSSUE.'-

eg ~

FIRSTp,,I WOULD'ISPQTE: STATEMEMTS THAT THE SUPPLY~ SYSTEM "

~ ~

, ~

.BEEbt UNRESPONSIVEtt ON HAMFORD SEISNI C'SSUES 'AMP I ASSU \

YOU, QE) INTEttD TO CONTINUE,A RESPONSIBLE POLICY'M'HIS RE 4ARD'T- p )j'i~)

)

I

.I,")'. IN, FQCTp ~ SINCE, %HE <MP-B, PSARp THE SUPPLY SYSTEM HAS,'OND

-

i$

ED, EXHAUSTIUEp MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR PROGRANS *DIRECTED AT 0

'l-'" "i-'

1 ~

501VING( MRC CONCERNS ABOUT HANFORD GEOLOGY AND 'SEISMICITY TiHE NRCi STAFF HAS BEEN PRO I DED ATA F ON THESE PROB RAN 5 AND' t

AND i,HAS BEEN KEPT..INFORHED OF. THIS'ORK 'THROUGH NUMEROUS

(

~ tt t 'i]) -'" ",'

MEETINGS ~ . THOUGH,MUCH NEW DAHB HAS BEEN GENERATED.) 'OME OF' $

r

!

l..:.

f

'. j THIS IMFORMATION 'LEADS US OE3'UR CONSULTANTS TO CQMC1 UDE'" 2 I

}>>

~

.. THAT, OUR,, CURRENT. SKI SNI C DESIGN 'BASIS IS!'ZNADEQUATEe' ' ""BgLZEVg~t~,'

~

.--~<~, SAV~f~"UNPtSSPOMSIVZVKSS" VO MRC STAFF,'OUESVZONS STXfCS \

a) r e'ii2170709 Bii20'll ~ '

PDR ADQCK 05000397 ~

gt,.'b ~+~t("y ~Q-

~ )

4 ~

'() ~ QgM4 i &' 't'lt

r r

'I I

1, i) l

J NT b~

I CHES . JP?FPEREh" C ZN JUDG EMENT I BETW EZN'Ou CONSULTANTS AND ~ 1 W

THE NRC REVIEWERS 'ON THE APPROPRIATE METHODOLOGY'FOR'NTER

'F PRETAT I ON THE HNAFORD GEOLOGICAL AND SEISMIC'ATA' SECONDLY I I AH CONCERNED ABOUT CONTINUING TO PERPETUATE, SUPPLY"

SYSTEM UNDED GEOLOGY RESEARCH PROGRAMS 'AND "WHAT 'IF" 'SORT OF QTI ON SVWZ CONTRIBUTE TO IMPBQVED SAFETY OF OUR PLANTS ~ IT APPEARS TO, US THAT PART'F THE DIFFICULITY I MAY'BE',

I RAPIDLY-CHANGING NRC STAFF REVIEWERS> RESULTING EACH TIME: IN A NEW SERIES OF QUESTIONS MEETINGS AND CONCERNS "

'I BELLIEUE' THAI .'PHE 'QUESTION OF THE APPROPRIATE SEI SMIC DESIGN BASIS rFOR,l THE HNAF)ORD .SITE IS AN ISSUE WHOSE RESOLUTI0!4- REQUIRES SOUND>'" .' !I

'I

~ ~

CONSIDERkD JUDG ehfENTS AND I AM HOPEFUL'HAT THE" NRR,MANAGEMENT:"I!

\ 4

'";"="

G CAN DEUOfE THE NECESSARY ATTENTION TO RES03 VE THIS ISSUE IN ') '>

IN A TIM LY ~ I ~ G f

IN A TI/ELY FASHIONG X4OFUPPORT 'OF OUR,'WNP 2 'OPERATING LICENSE- , l 1

~

g REU IEW ~

', I ~ BECAUSE )HE SEISMIC ISSUE AT HNAFORD'S 1 OF SUCH BROAD -QIGNIF I CANCE )NCLUDING THREE. SUPPLY SYSTFP1. PLANTS'HE ENTIRE DOE HANFORD COMPLEX (BOTH CIVILIAN AND YiILITARY PROGRAMS) 'AND I.

THE NESCO 'SKAGIT PROGJECT> AND BECAUSE >tE WANT'TO MAINTAIN ~

')'I'I<';I OUR MNP- REVIEW SCHEDUl'E~ I,'WOULD.. LIKE TO DISCUSS . THI S'ATTERI-e VITH YOU PERSONAL Y! AS SOON 'AS POSSIBLE FOLLOWING'HE r~

CAL I

AND MEETING'S BEVWEEN QUR 'STAFFS,

~

TECHNI-")"'ANAGEHENT IN 'MID-NOVEMBERN ~ '! '"Il ~ .

I

OOK

,

g THANK Y0$ FOR YOUR CONSIDKRAITON OF. THIS "I SSUEG Ft I t. I"

~ 1 TO C ON- THIS MATTER IN AFEW. WEEKS+  ! I.' I'r'ATTING I

~ ~ ~

I ROBER T FEP.GUSPN I

l: ".'.".: :

" .=.il:!';

'",

I, il* "'.. " I

--" ~ i'- '

!,I  !

~

%

MRS  ! ~

\

~

~

~

~ MANAGING '; "." SYSTEM.ARD

"-'.'IRECTQR

~ ~

  • ~

WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER, SUPPLY ":I ~ ~ 1 ~

r..t. =  !~ .,'

3040 GEORGE WASHINGTON MAY: 1

\ RICHLANDiVA 99358 v.~ TWX 510-'770'0864 t

~l WA PUBPWQ RCLD

\,

+.,. ~,

+ '".I..:8BG-',BHDA .

< '~0k' ~

Il, I'

~

~

~ I

~

~

1

'.

i' ;MKA'4L'~

~

~

wr've4 i I'

0 \ '

I

(

~h J

(J~ LJ

~ h 1, ~ '...,,

-'i ~

.' ~ ~,, h

@

Jh

~

'

~

~

~

~

<<,, l

~

'<< ~ ~

~ ~

~

~

~

J

~

'

~ ~ ~

J h ~

' h

~ I ~

\ ~ C ~ ~

h'

~

' ~ ~

'r

'h ~ g

' "., h.i lh 4'.~ / I h h

~ ~

~ ~

t

~ ~

h

~

' i"'". 4 J

','

h

~ ~ ~

h

  • h-

~ ....

h h 'I

<<Jh /L h

  • , hl SL'! ~

~

h

~ ~ L ~, '8 I L J,h: y '$ '(f irgC r

J / ~

~ ~ h

~ ~

~ ~

I

'h

,~

'RC BHDA h ~ L I LAST i OZ,.ZES ~

AGE TO ~ BILL. DIRCKSi .NRC rg ~ ~ ~ ~

J CCS HAROLD DIRECTOR NRR DEPUQTY EXECUTIUE 3DIAREFFCTOR 5ENTQNp'TELLOp

~ ~

V I CTOR NRC FOR,'PERATI ONSET h

~ ~

t h

THANK YOU ~

h h h,

h NRC BHDA lL g

' 981 RI CHLAND VA lfOV Si .' ,I,

'

WX =

7 108540 I SNRC 'BHDA N UCLEAR REGQ LATORY CO MMISSION

".

.;.,'", ',";, '.". = *',>"..':I. ": .,: -:-;., ',;,<'i,";,"".f ..

ASH I NGTON p DC l'

h SOBER'ECT'f:.

.."-".;.';'-'<;,i

/ m~'TTENTIQNti M R,BD'L DZRCKS . EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONSÃlr..!!!."

',.".'...

":

'R

. h'. r I 'l.',-.~;:,r,.

ISSUES' ~

I r.;",h; ',".",--< i:.':;.:

'-'. ":. NR C"'REVIEW::OF'ANFORD';.SQISMI0 DEAR BII I a ~ ~

XKCENT LYp A,' MEMBER OF'HE NRR:STAFF J h ')

'

~"

NRC BHDA

~ j,', h HCA NOU 06 f 427 ~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~

I h

r r 0 0 ~/ E

/So

~

~ 'I Iq

'I

DISTRIBUTION:

  • With Incoming

".Docket:Fi-le-50:3972

  • TERA
  • Local PDR EDO Reading LB¹2 File (Plant/Green Ticket) I HDenton ECase THurley ~(Y~1iggg a FSchroeder DEisenhut RPurple RTedesco ASchwencer RAuluck MService 4 ti) I

) (, l+A >

RVollmer OELD PBrandenburg (EDO ¹11068}

JLeonard LBerry OI&E (3}

PPAS Reading DRoss SCavanaugh Cornell'ehm VStello DeYoung Sha par Ninogue Kramer RNattson RJackson OFFICEI SURNAME/

DATE 0 NRG FORM 318 (10-80) NRCM 0240 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY USGPO; 1981~5 960

0 0 's e II

ACTION CONTROL iTES CONTROL NO.

PdhQVC FL<<f'~~IJISQD COMPL DEADLINE basbfegtet~ Pub) 4c'Pw~cw Sv~ply ACKNOWLEDGMENT DATE OF DOCUMENT

"-voter INTERIM REPLY BI@4'3 TO: PREPARE FOR SIGNATURE OF:

Pt~hs FINAL REPLY Q CHAIRMAN

<< F I LE LOCATION Q EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR o- m.~~a>M DESCRIPTION Q LETTER Q MEMO Q REPORT OTHER SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS OR REMARKS l~~>@farl Se)scfc Yssucr, 'e =ere e~~t tlRC SMC

) yaW ve'"e ef %be.

40 f"'frchs B,Ss~e @acf

)egfey PaeefhTe

@Avows es vB) es ~ p~ap"sa8 )fat Cf vitae~>3 to meC$ n<e ytapem4 Q Faep~ean TAN@.

CLASSIFIED DATA DOCUMENT/COPY NO. CLASSIFICATION NUMBER OF PAGES CATEGORY POSTAL REGISTRY NO. Q NSI QRD 0 FRD ASSIGNED TO: DATE INFORMATION ROUTING '4FGAL REVJ EIIII Q F INAL Q COPY 9/5 kali i M44 ASSIQIVEOiTOC ';" <<.c>>DATg; NO LEGAL OBJECTIONS NOTIFY:

c'.,'f;, '".'<<..".i'. ""/1 .,<,<<a<i '<< EXT.

<<4MJ

<< I '<<j',I<< COMMENTS, NOT IF Y:

EXT.

f~l "<<

<<,.<<Vc, 4 JCAE NOTIFICATION RECOMMENDED: Q YES Q NO 4 NRC FORM 232 EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS NOT REiÃOI/E THIS COPY' (11-75)

PRINClPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL'O

l lpl h g h A~ A A ll