ML17284A432: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:k ,-"kCCE1ZRATED D+R1BUTJON DEMONSTT1ON SYSTgg REGULATORY INFORMATION DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM (RIDS)I'I'ACCESSION NBR:8807180324 DOC.DATE: 88/07/08 NOTARIZED:
{{#Wiki_filter:k
YES'OCKET FACIL:50-397 WPPSS Nuclear Project, Unit 2, Washington Public Powe 05000397 AUTH.NAME AUTHOR AFFILIATION SORENSEN,G.C.
      - "kCCE1ZRATED           D+R1BUTJON           DEMONSTT1ON
Washington Public Power Supply System RECIP.NAME RECIPIENT AFFILIATION Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk)
    ,                                                                                      SYSTgg REGULATORY I
INFORMATION DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM                 (RIDS)
'I' ACCESSION NBR:8807180324         DOC.DATE: 88/07/08 NOTARIZED: YES                       'OCKET FACIL:50-397   WPPSS Nuclear Project, Unit 2, Washington Public                   Powe   05000397 AUTH. NAME         AUTHOR AFFILIATION SORENSEN,G.C.       Washington Public Power Supply System RECIP.NAME         RECIPIENT AFFILIATION Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk)


==SUBJECT:==
==SUBJECT:==
Responds to IE Bulletin 88-004 re potential safety-related pump loss.DISTRIBUTION CODE: IE11D COPIES RECEIVED:LTR ENCL SIZE: TITLE: Bulletin Response (50 DKT)NOTES: RECIPIENT ZD CODE/NAME PD5 LA SAMWORTH,R INTERNAL: AEOD/DOA AEOD/DSP/TPAB NRR/DEST/ADE 8H NRR/DEST/MEB 9H NRR/DOEA/GCB 11 NRR~~hSJ LRB12 LE 02 GN5 FILE Ol EXTERNAL: LPDR NSIC COPIES LTTR ENCL 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1*1 1 1 1 1.1 1 1 1 RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME PD5 PD AEOD/DSP NRR RIVENBARK,G NRR/DEST/ADS 7E NRR/DOEA/EAB ll NRR/DREP/EPB 10'UDOCS-ABSTRACT RES/DE/EIB NRC PDR COPIES LTTR ENCL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 h j h TOTAL NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED: LTTR 21 ENCL 20  
Responds to       IE Bulletin 88-004 re   potential safety-related pump loss.
DISTRIBUTION CODE: IE11D COPIES RECEIVED:LTR             ENCL                   SIZE:
TITLE: Bulletin Response (50 DKT)
NOTES:
RECIPIENT         COPIES            RECIPIENT                      COPIES ZD CODE/NAME       LTTR ENCL      ID CODE/NAME                    LTTR ENCL PD5 LA                 1    0    PD5 PD                              1    1 SAMWORTH,R             1    1                                                          h INTERNAL: AEOD/DOA                 1    1    AEOD/DSP                            1    1 AEOD/DSP/TPAB           1    1    NRR RIVENBARK,G                    1    1 NRR/DEST/ADS 7E NRR/DEST/ADE 8H NRR/DEST/MEB 9H NRR/DOEA/GCB 11 1
1 1
1 1
1 NRR/DOEA/EAB NRR/DREP/EPB 10 ll                  1 1
1 1
1 1
                                                *1 NRR~~ hSJ LRB12        1                            'UDOCS-ABSTRACT 1    1 LE        02    1    1    RES/DE/EIB                         1     1 GN5    FILE    Ol    1     1 EXTERNAL: LPDR                    .1     1   NRC PDR                            1     1 NSIC                    1     1 j
h TOTAL NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED: LTTR         21   ENCL   20


WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM P.O.Box 968~3000 George Washington Way~Richland, Washington 99352 Docket No.50-397 July 8, 1988 G02-88-150 U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Document Control Desk Mail Station Pl-137 Washington, D.C.20555 Gentlemen:
WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM P.O. Box 968   ~ 3000 George Washington Way ~ Richland, Washington 99352 July 8, 1988 G02-88-150 Docket No. 50-397 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn:   Document Control Desk Mail Station Pl-137 Washington, D.C. 20555 Gentlemen:


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
NUCLEAR PLANT NO. 2 OPERATING LICENSE NPF-21 RESPONSE    TO IEB  88-04, "POTENTIAL SAFETY RELATED PUMP LOSS"


==Reference:==
==Reference:==
Letter,    BWROG-8836, D.N. Grace (BWR Owners Group Chairman) to        US NRC, same subject, dated July 5, 1988 The  subject bulletin requested all licensees to investigate and correct as appli-cable two minimum flow safety related pump design concerns: dead heading due to pump-to-pump interaction and the adequacy of installed minimum flow capacity for a single pump in operation.            With regard to the first concern WNP-2 has no safety related pumps with detrimental pump-to-pump interaction.                    The second concern, minimum flow line adequacy, is addressed in the attached report.                      The attached commits to providing additional information on this concern within 75 days of this response.
The Supply System        is  a  participant in the BWR Owners Group and as such endorses the referenced      letter      submitted by that group to respond generically to the bulletin. The attached report provides additional information on plant specifics detailing both short and long term action and schedule, and endorses the justifi-cation for continued operation supplied in the reference by the BWR Owners Group.
Should you have        any questions,      please contaCt    Mr.. A. G. Hosier, Manager,    WNP-2 Licensing' Very  truly yours, G. C. rensen, Manager Regulatory Programs PLP/bk cc:  JB  Martin -    NRC RV NS  Reynolds    -  BCP8R RB  Samworth    -  NRC DL  Williams -    BPA/399 NRC  Site Inspector - 901A 8807i80324 880708 PDR      ADQCK 05000397 8


NUCLEAR PLANT NO.2 OPERATING LICENSE NPF-21 RESPONSE TO IEB 88-04,"POTENTIAL SAFETY RELATED PUMP LOSS" Letter, BWROG-8836, D.N.Grace (BWR Owners Group Chairman)to US NRC, same subject, dated July 5, 1988 The subject bulletin requested all licensees to investigate and correct as appli-cable two minimum flow safety related pump design concerns: dead heading due to pump-to-pump interaction and the adequacy of installed minimum flow capacity for a single pump in operation.
STATE OF WASHINGTON)                                
With regard to the first concern WNP-2 has no safety related pumps with detrimental pump-to-pump interaction.
The second concern, minimum flow line adequacy, is addressed in the attached report.The attached commits to providing additional information on this concern within 75 days of this response.The Supply System is a participant in the BWR Owners Group and as such endorses the referenced letter submitted by that group to respond generically to the bulletin.The attached report provides additional information on plant specifics detailing both short and long term action and schedule, and endorses the justifi-cation for continued operation supplied in the reference by the BWR Owners Group.Should you have any questions, please contaCt Mr..A.G.Hosier, Manager, WNP-2 Licensing' Very truly yours, G.C.rensen, Manager Regulatory Programs PLP/bk cc: JB Martin-NRC RV NS Reynolds-BCP8R RB Samworth-NRC DL Williams-BPA/399 NRC Site Inspector-901A 8807i80324 880708 PDR ADQCK 05000397 8 PMl t STATE OF WASHINGTON)
)COUNTY OF BENTON)


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
I, G.C.Sorensen, being duly sworn, subscribe to and say that I am the Manager, Regulatory Programs for the WASHINGTON.
PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM, the applicant herein;that I have full authority to execute this oath;that I have reviewed the foregoing; and that to the best of my knowledge, information and belief the statements made in it are true.DATE4/g~Z , 1988 G.C.Soyensen, Manager Regulat4ry Programs On this day personally appeared before me G.C.Sorensen to me known to be the individual who executed the foregoing instrument and acknowledged that he signed the same as his free act and deed for the uses and purposes herein mentioned.
GIVEN under my hand and seal this day of 1988.otary u)c)n a d or the STA E OF WASHINGTON Residing


EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL SAFETY RELATED PUMP LOSS: IEB 88-04 1.Safet Rel ated Pum Evaluati on Table 1 lists 83 pumps at WNP-2 which are considered safety related (Table 1).Of these pumps, 38 are centrifugal pumps which were specifically evaluated for problems related to pump-to-pump interaction and minimum flow operation.
                    )
The remaining pumps are positive displacement pumps.The results of the WNP-2 evaluation are presented in Table 2.In summary, no pump or piping configurations were found which could lead to detrimental pump-to-pump interactions.
COUNTY OF BENTON    )
From the Table 2 list, 24 of the 38 pumps were found to be of no concern and 14 pumps were found which could experience short periods of dead head and/or minimum flow operation during normal pump start up and routine testing.Specific discussion on these pumps is provided below.2.Short and Lon Term Evaluation Pro ram Of the 14 pumps identified from Table 2, six have been evaluated as not having or not susceptible to concerns related to inadequate minimum flow capacity.Records of these evaluations will be maintained per the guidance of IEB 88-04.The remaining eight, subject to continued evaluation are: o Reactor Heat Removal Pumps 2A, 2B, 8 2C o High Pressure Core Spray Pump 1 o Low Pressure Cor e Spray Pump 1 o Standby Service Water Pump 1A, 8 1B o Reactor Core Isolation Cooling Pump 1 A description of the continuing evaluation for these pumps is provided below.Prior to the issuance of IEB 88-04 all ECCS pump operating procedures were modified to include caution statements to the operator to ensure that the minimum flow valves opened upon starting the pump, and that the amount of time the pump is operated on minimum flow is minimized.
I, G. C. Sorensen, being duly sworn, subscribe to and say that I am the Manager, Regulatory Programs for the WASHINGTON. PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM, the applicant herein; that I have full authority to execute this oath; that I have reviewed the foregoing; and that to the best of my knowledge, information and belief the statements made in it  are true.
These changes adequately address, the need for short term modifications to operating procedures as required in the bulletin.The evaluation programs, short and long term, are as follows:
DATE4/g ~    Z  , 1988 G. C. Soyensen,     Manager Regulat4ry Programs On this  day personally appeared before    me G. C. Sorensen  to me known to be the individual who executed the foregoing        instrument  and acknowledged that he signed the same as his free    act  and  deed  for  the uses and purposes herein mentioned.
GIVEN  under my hand  and seal this          day  of                 1988.
otary  u  )c )n  a d  or the STA E OF WASHINGTON Residing


A.Short Term Program l.Authorize the pump manufacturers to reevaluate pump parameters and determine if.current low and minimum flow operating parameters should be revised.2.Perform base line vibration testing with temporary equipment at low and minimum flow operations.
EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL SAFETY RELATED PUMP LOSS:    IEB 88-04
Analyze the data and determine the rotordynamic effects of the observed vibrations and develop a data base.3.Based on I and 2,'etermine if any operating or hardware modifica-tions are required, in the interim, prior to completion of the long term program, These short term actions cannot be completed until the pump manufac-turer's evaluations are completed, necessitating a follow-on report to be submitted within 75 days of this response.BE Long Term Program 1.Complete data collection and analysis confirming the results of the short term program.2.Based on vendor recommendations and the results of the short term program, future test requirements will be defined and incorporated into the current periodic inspections of the ISI program.Data exchange through the BHROG wil-1 enhance the historical data base development and is an integral component of this plan.3.The results of the shor t term bases development could lead to hardware and operating mode changes.Among the potential hardware changes are piping modifications, pump internal modifications to adjust A and 8 gaps to reduce hydraulic instabilities, or use of adjustable speed drives.The long term program and data base development will pr ovide feedback as to the adequacy of any short term modifications and identify any additional areas requiring modification.
: 1. Safet    Rel ated Pum    Evaluati on Table  1  lists  83 pumps at WNP-2 which are considered safety related (Table 1).       Of  these  pumps, 38 are centrifugal pumps which were specifically evaluated for problems related to pump-to-pump interaction and minimum flow operation. The remaining pumps are positive displacement pumps.
4.The interim long term program which embodies the requirements for 10 year inspections per the ASME code will remain in effect until the necessity for modification is determined from the results of this program.
The  results of the      WNP-2  evaluation are presented in Table 2.
3.Justification For Continued 0 eration (JCO)The Supply System endorses the JCO provided in the referenced BWROG sub-mittal and r eiterates the following in support of continued operation:
In summary, no pump or piping configurations were found which could lead to detrimental pump-to-pump interactions.             From the Table 2 list, 24 of the 38 pumps  were    found  to  be of  no  concern  and  14 pumps were found which could experience short periods of dead head and/or minimum flow operation during normal pump start up and routine testing.                 Specific discussion on these pumps is provided          below.
A.The common minimum flow line design shared by two or more pumps does not exist in any safety related pump design at WNP-2.B.The ECCS pumps at WNP-2 were procured to the highest industry stan-dards.C.The reliability and history of the ECCS pumps at WNP-2 have been demon-strated to be equal to that addressed in the BWROG JCO and therefore encompassed by that response.
: 2. Short and Lon Term Evaluation Pro ram Of the    14 pumps identified from Table 2, six have been evaluated as not having or not susceptible to concerns related to inadequate minimum flow capacity.      Records of these evaluations will be maintained per the guidance of IEB 88-04. The remaining eight, subject to continued evaluation are:
TABLE 1 VNP2 PUMPS IMPORTANT TO SAFETY TAG HO, FUNCTION SAF REI PUMP TYPE MANUFACTURER IEB 88-84 PUMP COMMENTS CCH-P-IA CCH-P-1B COOLING VATER FOR CONTROI ROOH CHILf ERS COOLING VATER FOR CONTROL ROOH CHILLERS YES CEHTRIPUGAL YES CENTRIFUGAL GOULD GOUI D NO CMS-P-I/13 SPARED IH PLACS CMS-P-I/14 SPARED IN PLACE CMS-P-2/13 SPARED IN PLACE CMS"P-2/14 SPARBD Ilf PLACE CMS-P-1381 CONTAINMEHT ATMOSHERE SANPLE PUMP CMS-P-14SI COlfTAIHMENT ATNOSHERS SAHPf E PUMP NO POSITIVE DISPI ACEMEHT HETAI BEf f OVS NO POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT METAL BELLOVS NO POSITIVE DISPI ACEMEHT METAI BELLOVS NO POSITIVB DISPLACEMENT METAL BE!,LOVS YES POSITIVE DISPIACEMEHT AIR DIMENSIONS IHC YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT AIR DIMEHSIONS INC NO CLASS I PU!{P SPARED IH PIACE POR FUTURE USE CLASS I PUMP SPARED IH PLACE FOR FUTURE U CI ASS I PUMP SPARED IN PLACS POR PUTURE USE CLASS I PUMP SPARBD IN PLACS POR FUTURE USE CRD-P-IA CRD-P-1B CONTROL ROD DRIVE VATER PUMP CONTROL ROD DRIVS VATER PUl!P DIESEL EHGIHB CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER UNION HO CENTRIPUGAL NO CEN'TRIPUGAL YES CSHTRIPUGAL GM-EHD.DCV-P-IA2 DCV-P-IAl DCV-P-IBI DCV-P-1B2 DCV-P-IC DCV-P-2AI GH-EMD YES CEHTRIPUGAL DIESEl, ENGIHE CIRCUf,ATING JACKET COOLING HATER GM-EHD DIESEL ENGINE CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATBR YBS CENTRIFUGAL GH-EMD GM-EHD YES CEHTRIPUGAL YBS CEHTRIPUGAL YES CEHTRIPUGhf YES CENTRIFUGAL YES CEHTRIFUGAL YES CENTRIFUGAL DIBSEL EHGIHB CIRCULATING JACKBT COOLING VATER DIESEf EHGIHE CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER GM"EMD DCV-P-2A2.DIESEI ENGINE CIRCUI ATIHG JACKET COOLIHG VATER GM-EHD DCV-P-2B1 DCV.P-2B2 DCV-P-2C DLO-P-Il DLO-P-IA1 DLO.P-IA2 GM-ElfD DIESBL ENGIHE CIRCULATIHG JACKET COOLING VATER DIESEf, ENGINE CIRCUf ATING JACKST COOLING VATER DIESEL ENGINE CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER EHERG.DIESEL BEGINS OIL DRIVE PUHP EMERG, DISSEI ENGIHE OIL DRIVE PUHP EMERG.DIESBf ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP GN-EHD GH-EMD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EMD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EMD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EHD DIESEL BEGINS CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER YES CENTRIFUGAL YES YES YES YES YES YES-YES YES YES YES HO TABLE I VHP2 PUHPS IMPORTANT TO SAFETY TAG NO.FUHCTION SAF REf PUMP TYPE MANUFACTURER IEB 88-84 PUMP COMMENTS DLO-P-181 DLO-P-182 DLO-P-2A1 DLO-P-2A2 DLO-P-2BI DLO-P-282 DLO-P-3A1 DLO-P-3A2 DLO-P-3A2 DLO-P-381 DLO-P-382 DLO-P-4A1 DLO-P-4A2 DLO-P-481 DLO-P-4B2 DLO-P-5A1 DLO-P-5A2 DLO-P-581 DLO-P-5B2 DLO-P-6 DLO-P-7 DLO-P-8 DLO-P-9 EHERG, DIESEl ENGINE OIL DRIVB PUHP EHERG.DIESEL EHGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP EMERG.DIESEL EHGIHE Olf DRIVE PUMP EMERG.DIESEI BHGIHE OIL DRIVE PUHP ENERG.DIESEL EHGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP EMERG.DIESEL EHGIHE OIL DRIVE PUMP EMERG.DIESEf, ENGIHE Oll, DRIVB PUHP EMERG.DIESEL ENGINE Olf DRIVE PUMP EMERG.DIESEf, ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP ENERG.DIESEL, ENGINE Off, DRIVE PUHP EMERG.DIESEI ENGINE Oll DRIVE PUNP BHERG.DIESEL ENGINE Olf DRIVE PUHP ENERG.DIESEL EHGIHE OIL DRIVE PUMP EHBRG.DIESEL ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUHP EHERG.DIBSBl ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP BHERG.DIESEL ENGINE Olf DRIVE PUMP EHERG.DIESEf BNGIHE OIL DRIVE PUNP EHERG.DIBSEf BHGINE OIL DRIVE PUHP EHERG.DIESEL BNGIlfE OIL DRIVE PUHP EHERG.DIESEf BNGIHE OIL DRIVE PUHP EHERG.DIESBL EHGINE OIL DRIVE PUNP EMERG.DIBSEf ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP EHERG.DIESBL EHGIHE OIL DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EMD YES POSITIVE DISP!,ACEMEHT GM-EMD YES POSITIVB DISPLACEHENT VIKIHG YES POSITIVE DISPLACENENT VIKING YES POSITIVE DISPI ACEMENT VIKING YES POSITIVE DISPl ACEHEHT VIKIHG YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT VIKING YES POSITIVE DISPI ACEHEHT VIKING YES POSITIVE POSITIVE DISPf ACEMENT VIKING DISPI,ACEHENT VIKING YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT VIKING YES POSITIVE DISPLACEHENT GM-EMD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT GM-EHD YES POSITIVE DISPLACENEHT GM-EMD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-END YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GH-EHD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT GH-EMD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EMD YES POSITIVE DISPf ACBMENT GM-EHD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT VIKING YES POSITIVE DISPf ACEMENT ALLISON YES POSITIVE DISPLACEHENT ALLISON YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EMD NO HO NO HO NO HO HO TABLE 1 VNP2 PUMPS IMPORTAHT IO SAPETY TAG HO.FUNCTION SAF REK PUHP TYPE MANUFACTURER IEB 88-84 PUHP COMHENTS DO-P-IA DO-P-IB DO-P-2 DO-P-3hl 00-P-3A2 DO-P-3BI DO-P-3B2 DO-P-4AI DO-P-4A2 DO-P-4BI DO-P-4B2 DO-P-5 DO-P-6 PPC-P-1h PPC-P-1S SPCS-P-1 BPCS-P-2 HPCS-P-3 LPCS-P-1 LPCS-P-2 RCIC-P-1 RCIC-P-2 RCIC-P-3 DIESEL FUEL TRANSPBR PUMP DIESEf FUBI TRANSFER PUMP DIESEK FUEK TRAHSFER PUMP DIBSBL ENGIHE FUEL PUHP DIESEL ENGINE PUEf PUMP DIESEL ENGINB PUEK PUHP DIESEK ENGINE PURL PUHP DIESEK, EHGINE FUNK, PUMP DIESEK, ENGINE PUEI, PUMP DIESBI ENGINE PURL PUMP DIESEf BNGINE FUEL PUHP DIBSEL EHGINE PUEL PUMP DIESEf, ENGINE PUEL PUHP FUEL POOL COOLING VA'TER SUPPLY PUMP PUEI, POOL COOLING VATBR SUPPLY PUHP HIGH PRESSURB BHERGENCY HAKEUP TO REACTOR BPCS DIESEL SERVICE VATER PUHP HPCS KEEP FILL SISTBH PU!KP LOV PRESSURE EMERGBNCI HAKEUP TO REACTOR LPCS KEBP PILL SISTEH PUMP MAKEUP TO REACTOR DURING ISOLATION EVENTS GLAND CONDEHSBR VACUUH PUMP RCIC KEEP PILL SYSTEM PUMP YES CENTRIFUGAL YES CEHTRIFUGAI YES CEHTRIPUGAL CRANE-DEMING CRANE-DEMING CRANE-DEHING IES CENTRIFUGAL IES CEHTRIFUGAf YES CENTRIFUGAL IES CEH'IRIPUGAf YBS CENTRIFUGAL YES CENTRIPUGAL YES CENTRIPUGAK NO CEHTRIFUGAL NO CENTRIFUGAL HO CENTRIPllGAL VORTRIHGTOH VOR'THINGTON IHGERSOLL-RAND PACIPIC CRANE-DEHIHG INGERSOLL-RAND CRANE-DEMING BINGHAH-VILK AMET NASH CRANE-OEMING YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT VIKING YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT VIKIHG YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT VIKING YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT VIKING YES POSITIVE DISPI ACBMENT GH-EMD YES POSITIVE DISPLACENEHT GM-EHD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM"EHD YES POSITIVE DISPf ACEHEHT GH-EHD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT GH-EMD YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT VIKING YES YES YES YES YES YES IES YES IES YES YES YES IES IBS YES YES TABLE 1 VNP2 PUMPS IMPORTANT TO SAFETY TAG NO.FUNCTION SAF REL PUMP TYPE MANUFACTUPER IEB 88-84 PUMP COMMEHTS RCIC-P-I RCIC-P-5 RFV-P-1A RFV-P-1B RHR-P-2A RHR-P-28 RHR-P-2C RRR-P-3 RRC-P-1A RRC-P-IB SLC-P-IA SLC-P-18 SV-P-1A S'lf-P-18 GLAHD CONDEHSER CONDEHSATE PUHP TURBINE OIL PUMP.FEEDVATER PUMP FEEDVATER PUMP LOV PRESURE EMERGENCY MAKEUP TO REACTOR LOV PRESURE EMERGENCY MAKEUP TO REACTOR LOV PRESURE EMERGEHCY MAKEUP TO REACTOR RHR KEEP FILL SYSTEH PUMP REACTOR RECIRCULATION PUMP REACTOR RECIRCUf ATIOH PUMP STANDBY LIQUID COHTROL INJECTION PUHP STANDBY f IQUID COHYROL INJECTION PUMP EHERGENCY SERVICE VATER SYSTEM PUMP EHERGEHCY SERVICE VATER SYSTEH PUMP NO CENTRIFUGAL HASH HO CENTRIFUGAL NO CENTRIFUGAL YES CEHTRIFUGAL YES CENTRIFUGAf YES CENTRIFUGAL YES CEHTRIFUGAL YES CEHTRIFUGAL YES CEHTRIFUGAI INGERSOLL-RAND INGERSOIL-RAND INGERSOLL-RAND IHGERSOLI-RAND INGERSOLL-RAND CRANE-DEMING BIHGHAM-VILLAMET BINGHAM-Vflf AMET NO POSTIVE DISPLACEMENT UHION HO POSTIVE DISPIACEMENT UNION YES CEHTRIFUGAL YES CEHTRIFUGAL INGERSOLL-RAND INGERSOLL-RAND HO POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT TUTHILI NO YES YES YES YES YES YES HO YES YES IAILI 2 rvxrs EVALUATED roa taa le Ii IAC Io.IUNCIios sAF RIL ever IIFE bit fiov toss Icsf EfFlciewct fLovilEfl hiii fcov/I 0F REF conelts CIM.P-IA cce r-ia CRD.P.IA (RD.P.il COOLIIC BTER foi COBROL Rooh CliLLERS (OOLIXC BIKR fOR COIIROL ROOli CllLLERS CONTROL ROD DRIVE WATER PVB COKHOL lOD DRIV6 VATKR FUNP ocv.e.iu OCV P.ibi PIESEL BCIXE CIRCULATIXG JACKET COOLiev VAIKR Diesel EICINE CIRCULATIWC JACKET COOLIWC BIER DCv.r.lal DIESEL EICIII CIRCULATIIC JACKET COOLIIC VAIER OCV P.IC o(v.r-lii OCV.P-l12 OCV F.201 OC'f.r-ill DIESEL IVCIV6 CIRCULATIWC JAC16T COOLIVC WATER Otesei BGile CIRCULAlilv JACKET COOLIIC VAIKR DI6$6L EIGiiie CIRCULATIWG JACI61 COOLIKG VAIER DI6SKL KVGild CIRCULATIN JACKET (OOLIIG VATER C DiaseL Balll cilcULATiic JAclev cooLING vAHR DCW P IC DitslL BGIIE CIRCULATIIG Jl(lev COOLIVG VAtIR Do.p-li oo e.ia 00 P-2 DIESEL FUEL IRARsflR PUNP DIESEL FUEl TRAKSFER Pvhe DIESEL FUEL IRAVSHR FVNP fPC.P-IA FUEL fooL COOLHC BIER SUPPLI I'Vht fPC'P.il arcs-e-I KPCS-P-2 fvEL POOL COOLIIC TAIER SUPtLI FUKP liCI FR6SSVII 6iiKICKKCI NAKKUP Tv REACTOR ates atcsel seavict BveR evht KFCS.P.I IFCS ll6P fiLL$1$16N evhp LPCs.e.t Lov BISSVRE lhelCEICI lliievP To IEACIOR LFCS-P.l LPCS IKB FILL SISHN FUKP R(i(-P-I a(I(-P-2 RCIC-P-3 RCIC.P I Rfr-P-ii lfV F.il RIR.P.lA ala.e-ll RER.r.lC NAXIVP 10 IIACTOR DURIIG ISOLATIOR EHRIS CLAID COIDBSER TACUvii evhe RCIC lait FILL Stsnli FUB CLAID COKDIVSER COXDEISATE FUKP fldDVAHR PURP felDVATB PUKP Lov eacsvaa Kheacclct Nuevr To aeicfoa LOV FRISUIK liieRCBCT NBKUP To leiCTOR Lal BISURE IBRCEICI iiil6VP To RBCIOR DCV.F.IAI DIESEL EICIRI CIRCULATIN JACXEI COOLIIC WATER ns (6ITRHUCAL IKS CKWH I FVC1L Wo CEITRIFUCAI KO CENTRIFUGAL TES CEIIRIfvCAL Ids CKKIRIfICAl 16$CEXTRifvCAL 16$CEIHifvCAL Hs CKVTRIFUCAL Ifs CKNIRifUCAL HS CEWIRIFUCAL Ies CKRIRifvGAL HS CalnifvCAL IKS CKITRIFUCAL HS CIKTRIFUCAL 16$CKKIRifvCAL Ies CBTRIfvCAL Hs CKVHIFUCAL IES CHIR IFUCAL IES CENIRtfUCAL Hs CelftlfvCAL ns clwIR IF vciL Hs (EIHIFUCAL HS CElIR If NAL Vo CEXTRifVGAL lo CHIR I FUGAL lo C KEIR If UCAL lo CKRTRifvGAL lo (El TRIFUGAL lo CERHIFUCAL HS CERTRifvCAL IKS CEXIRIFUGAL IES CEIIRI FVCiL Io IO Hs 16$Io lo lo lo Io Io lo Io ho la NO IES lv ns Io ns lv lo lv Tas 16$'tee 16$ns lA IA 211 vpa 211 gpa NA VA IA RA IA RA KA 61 Ki IA ai IA IIII apa IA IA SSII afs Io 151 Spa Io lo lo ICfil Ipa lifn fps 5151 1 pa Siil apa SI5 I apa VA IA 2I Vpa/til 21 Sfs/III Ii WA IA Ni Wi IA IA NA IISf fes/III B KA 635 fps/22I li ill aps/l 3\IA IA WA iif1 fps/III iif I qpa/III 551 fps/III 551 fps/I II 551 apa/ill SIX IB OFBAIKS$1$'Hh DFERAns hih FLOW OCCURS AT BTID FLOW, Io hil REQUIRED 11 RATED FLOW, lo Nil REQUIRED OILI ova OPaallot ERROR OR,fAILURI SISIBii OPERilds Stsieii OPERATES SISTait OFERAHS SISTKii OPERATES XIIIIII OPERATES itin!i opeRAHI Stsnh OFKRAHS SISTEN OP6RATIS SISIEN OPIRAIES Slstdh OPERAHS sisleii opBAHX stsvah oefntes$1$1EII OPBATES SISTIN OPBATES SISIEN OFIRATIS hil fLov occUas SISIEN OPBATES SISI6N OPBATIS hil FLOW DURHG SISIEh OFBAIES hil FLOW Dali!G slsnh oplRAHI stsIB opaRlns ststeh orle@Is NIN fLOV DURIIG AT IATED FLOW, KO hil REQUIRED iT Rlilo FLOV, lo hii REQUIRED 11 sino riov, ao Nta acavtaeo Al RAIKDFLOV, lo Nil REQUIRED Al RAHU FLOW, vo hiv REQUIRED AT RATED fLOV, lo Nii REQUIRED AT RAIED fLOV, lo hik REQUIRED 11 auao ri,ov, wo hia REavieao 1T li'itD fLOV, I0 Nil R69UICED B Riveo Fcov, ao Nil RcoviRco iT IATED fLOW, No hii RIQUIIFD 11 Rino FLov, Wo Nil Rcaviaco AT RATED f LOW, lo Niv REQVIIED AT RATED fLOV, lo hil RcavtRED il RATED flOW, V0 llil REQUIRED OURIIG TEST iio REACTOR RIGK LKV6L iT IAHD fLOV, lo hil IEQUIRKD AT RAHU fLOf, lo iiil REQUitED TISIHG 110 IIII.Loci RESFOISE AT RATED fLOV, lo htl REQVIIEO TEST OR Ove Io FAILURI OR OPER.BRUR AT Rino fLOV, 1T RATID fLOV, AT RATED fLOV, PLAXT Slliot I lo iiil REQUIRED l0 itic IE9JIRED Io hn ItaviIED SIUIOOVV iiii fLOV Dviila FLART SIARUP I Sev'IOOVW iiii fLOV OVRIIG T6$T AXD iliT.lOCA REIPOISE iiil FLOV DURIWC 1651 AVD IVII.LOCi Rcsfolsa iiil fLOV OUIIXC TEST AID llii.LOCA RESFOISE lith fLOV 0((VIS OVLI DUI OPERATOR ERROR OR FAILURE 0
o  Reactor Heat Removal Pumps 2A, 2B, 8 2C o  High Pressure Core Spray Pump 1 o  Low Pressure Cor e Spray Pump 1 o  Standby Service Water Pump 1A, 8 1B o  Reactor Core Isolation Cooling Pump 1 A  description    of the continuing evaluation for these          pumps  is provided below.
TAILE I FUNFS KTALUATEO fOR tll ll.lt TAG RO.FUKCIIOK SAF RRL FUNP TTPE btl fLOV FUSS EESI KfftCIERCI FLOV(llf)htl FLOV/\OF Elf CONNTRTS RKE P-I RRC-P.IA EIC-P ID SV P.IA SV P-tl RIR REEF FILL SISIKN PUNP REACTOR IRCIRCULAIIOV PUllP REACTOR EECtRCULATIOR FVEP EttdRGKICI SERVICI VAIER SISTKtt PUNP KNERGEICT SERVICE VAIER SISIEN fKEP IES CRUIRIFUGAL lO TKS CKVIRI FUGAL IES IKS CERIRIFUGAL IES 16$CKRIRtfVGAL IES TES CKVIRIFUGAL IES RO II SIT Tpa IIIII gpa tllll Vpa IIIII Tpa IA tllll Tpa/Ill 1tltl Tpa/Itl ltll Tpa/331 l3ll Tpa/331 SISIEX OPERATES AI RATED FLOV, RO NIV IEOUtRED NIR fLOT LttttIED IT fLOV CORTROL TALVE FOSITIOV Ntl fLOV LIRITED bl fLOV CORIROL VALVE POSITIOR Ntl FLOV DURIKG Iltf.PUNP START fOR 51 SECORDS Ntl fLOV DUIITG IIII.PUNP SIATT fOR SI SECOIDS}}
Prior to the issuance of IEB 88-04 all ECCS pump operating procedures were modified to include caution statements to the operator to ensure that the minimum flow valves opened upon starting the pump, and that the amount of time the pump is operated on minimum flow is minimized.                    These changes adequately address, the need for short term modifications to operating procedures as required in the bulletin.
The  evaluation programs, short        and long term, are as  follows:
 
A. Short Term Program
: l. Authorize the    pump manufacturers to reevaluate pump parameters and determine if. current low and minimum flow operating parameters should be revised.
: 2. Perform base line vibration testing with temporary equipment at low and minimum flow operations.          Analyze the data and determine the rotordynamic effects of the observed vibrations and develop a data base.
: 3. Based on    I and 2,'etermine    if any operating or hardware modifica-tions are required,        in the interim, prior to completion of the long term program, These  short term actions cannot        be completed until the pump manufac-turer's evaluations are        completed, necessitating a follow-on report to be submitted within 75 days of this response.
BE Long Term Program
: 1. Complete    data collection and analysis      confirming the results of the short term program.
: 2. Based  on vendor recommendations and the results of the short term program, future test requirements will be defined and incorporated into the current periodic inspections of the ISI program. Data exchange through the BHROG wil-1 enhance the historical data base development and is an integral component of this plan.
: 3. The                           t results of the shor term bases development could lead to hardware and operating mode changes.        Among the potential hardware changes are piping modifications, pump internal modifications to adjust A and 8 gaps to reduce hydraulic instabilities, or use of adjustable speed drives.          The long term program and data base development    will  pr ovide  feedback  as to the adequacy of any short term modifications and identify any additional areas requiring modification.
: 4. The  interim long term program which embodies the requirements for 10  year inspections per the ASME code will remain in effect until the necessity for modification is determined from the results of this  program.
: 3. Justification    For Continued 0 eration (JCO)
The Supply    System  endorses  the  JCO  provided in the referenced      BWROG  sub-mittal  and  r eiterates the following in support of continued operation:
A. The  common    minimum flow line design shared        by two or more pumps does not  exist in    any safety related pump design    at  WNP-2.
B. The ECCS      pumps  at  WNP-2  were procured    to the highest industry stan-dards.
C. The  reliability and history of        the  ECCS pumps  at  WNP-2 have been  demon-strated to      be  equal  to that addressed    in the  BWROG  JCO and  therefore encompassed    by  that response.
 
TABLE 1 VNP2 PUMPS IMPORTANT TO SAFETY TAG HO,                           FUNCTION                  SAF REI        PUMP TYPE            MANUFACTURER  IEB 88-84 PUMP                    COMMENTS CCH-P-IA    COOLING VATER FOR CONTROI ROOH CHILf ERS          YES  CEHTRIPUGAL              GOULD CCH-P-1B    COOLING VATER FOR CONTROL ROOH CHILLERS            YES  CENTRIFUGAL              GOUI D                  NO CMS-P-I/13  SPARED IH PLACS                                  NO    POSITIVE DISPI ACEMEHT  HETAI BEf f OVS                  CLASS  I PU!{P SPARED IH PIACE POR FUTURE USE CMS-P-I/14  SPARED  IN PLACE                                  NO    POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT    METAL BELLOVS                    CLASS  I PUMP SPARED  IH PLACE FOR FUTURE U CMS-P-2/13  SPARED  IN PLACE                                  NO    POSITIVE DISPI ACEMEHT  METAI BELLOVS                    CI ASS I PUMP SPARED  IN PLACS POR PUTURE USE CMS"P-2/14  SPARBD  Ilf PLACE                                  NO   POSITIVB DISPLACEMENT    METAL BE!,LOVS                    CLASS  I PUMP SPARBD  IN PLACS POR FUTURE USE CMS-P-1381  CONTAINMEHT ATMOSHERE SANPLE PUMP                  YES  POSITIVE DISPIACEMEHT    AIR DIMENSIONS IHC CMS-P-14SI  COlfTAIHMENT ATNOSHERS SAHPf E PUMP                YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT    AIR DIMEHSIONS INC      NO CRD-P-IA    CONTROL ROD DRIVE VATER PUMP                      HO    CENTRIPUGAL              UNION CRD-P-1B    CONTROL ROD DRIVS VATER PUl!P                      NO    CEN'TRIPUGAL                                    YES
. DCV-P-IA2    DIESEL EHGIHB CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER    YES  CSHTRIPUGAL              GM-EHD DCV-P-IAl    DIESEL BEGINS CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER    YES  CENTRIFUGAL             GH-EMD                 YES DCV-P-IBI    DIESEl, ENGIHE CIRCUf,ATING JACKET COOLING HATER  YES  CEHTRIPUGAL              GM-EHD                 YES DCV-P-1B2    DIESEL ENGINE CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATBR    YBS   CENTRIFUGAL             GH-EMD                  YES DCV-P-IC    DIBSEL EHGIHB CIRCULATING JACKBT COOLING VATER     YES  CEHTRIPUGAL              GM-EHD                  YES DCV-P-2AI    DIESEf EHGIHE CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER     YBS  CEHTRIPUGAL              GM"EMD                 YES-DCV-P-2A2 . DIESEI ENGINE CIRCUI ATIHG JACKET COOLIHG VATER   YES  CEHTRIPUGhf              GM-EHD                 YES DCV-P-2B1   DIESBL ENGIHE CIRCULATIHG JACKET COOLING VATER    YES  CENTRIFUGAL              GM-ElfD                YES DCV.P-2B2    DIESEf, ENGINE CIRCUf ATING JACKST COOLING VATER   YES  CEHTRIFUGAL              GN-EHD                  YES DCV-P-2C    DIESEL ENGINE CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER     YES  CENTRIFUGAL              GH-EMD                  YES DLO-P-Il    EHERG. DIESEL BEGINS   OIL DRIVE PUHP             YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT    GM-EMD DLO-P-IA1    EMERG, DISSEI ENGIHE   OIL DRIVE PUHP             YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT    GM-EMD                    HO DLO.P-IA2    EMERG. DIESBf ENGINE   OIL DRIVE PUMP             YES   POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT   GM-EHD
 
TABLE I VHP2 PUHPS   IMPORTANT TO SAFETY TAG NO.                       FUHCTION       SAF REf       PUMP TYPE               MANUFACTURER IEB 88-84 PUMP COMMENTS DLO-P-181 EHERG, DIESEl ENGINE  OIL DRIVB  PUHP  YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT      GM-EMD                NO DLO-P-182 EHERG. DIESEL EHGINE  OIL DRIVE  PUMP  YES  POSITIVE DISP!,ACEMEHT    GM-EMD DLO-P-2A1 EMERG. DIESEL EHGIHE  Olf DRIVE  PUMP  YES  POSITIVB DISPLACEHENT      VIKIHG DLO-P-2A2 EMERG. DIESEI BHGIHE  OIL DRIVE  PUHP  YES  POSITIVE DISPLACENENT      VIKING                HO DLO-P-2BI ENERG. DIESEL EHGINE  OIL DRIVE  PUMP  YES  POSITIVE DISPI ACEMENT    VIKING DLO-P-282 EMERG. DIESEL EHGIHE  OIL DRIVE  PUMP  YES  POSITIVE DISPl ACEHEHT    VIKIHG                NO DLO-P-3A1 EMERG. DIESEf, ENGIHE Oll, DRIVB PUHP  YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT      VIKING DLO-P-3A2 EMERG. DIESEL ENGINE  Olf DRIVE  PUMP  YES  POSITIVE DISPI ACEHEHT    VIKING                HO DLO-P-3A2 EMERG. DIESEf, ENGINE OIL DRIVE  PUMP        POSITIVE DISPf ACEMENT    VIKING                NO DLO-P-381 ENERG. DIESEL, ENGINE Off, DRIVE PUHP  YES  POSITIVE DISPI,ACEHENT    VIKING DLO-P-382 EMERG. DIESEI ENGINE  Oll  DRIVE PUNP  YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT      VIKING DLO-P-4A1 BHERG. DIESEL ENGINE  Olf  DRIVE PUHP  YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEHENT      GM-EMD DLO-P-4A2 ENERG. DIESEL EHGIHE  OIL DRIVE  PUMP  YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT      GM-EHD DLO-P-481 EHBRG. DIESEL ENGINE  OIL DRIVE  PUHP  YES  POSITIVE DISPLACENEHT      GM-EMD DLO-P-4B2 EHERG. DIBSBl ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP   YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT      GM-END DLO-P-5A1 BHERG. DIESEL ENGINE  Olf DRIVE PUMP   YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT      GH-EHD DLO-P-5A2 EHERG. DIESEf BNGIHE  OIL DRIVE PUNP  YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT      GH-EMD DLO-P-581 EHERG. DIBSEf BHGINE  OIL DRIVE PUHP  YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT      GM-EMD DLO-P-5B2 EHERG. DIESEL BNGIlfE OIL DRIVE PUHP  YES  POSITIVE DISPf ACBMENT    GM-EHD DLO-P-6  EHERG. DIESEf BNGIHE  OIL DRIVE PUHP   YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT      VIKING                HO DLO-P-7  EHERG. DIESBL EHGINE  OIL DRIVE PUNP   YES  POSITIVE DISPf ACEMENT    ALLISON                HO DLO-P-8  EMERG. DIBSEf ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP  YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEHENT      ALLISON DLO-P-9  EHERG. DIESBL EHGIHE OIL DRIVE PUMP   YES  POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT      GM-EMD
 
TABLE 1 VNP2 PUMPS IMPORTAHT IO SAPETY TAG HO.                        FUNCTION          SAF REK        PUHP TYPE            MANUFACTURER IEB 88-84 PUHP COMHENTS DO-P-IA    DIESEL FUEL TRANSPBR PUMP                  YES  CENTRIFUGAL              CRANE-DEMING          YES DO-P-IB    DIESEf FUBI TRANSFER  PUMP                 YES   CEHTRIFUGAI              CRANE-DEMING          YES DO-P-2    DIESEK FUEK TRAHSFER PUMP                  YES   CEHTRIPUGAL              CRANE-DEHING          YES DO-P-3hl  DIBSBL ENGIHE FUEL PUHP                    YES   POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT    VIKING 00-P-3A2  DIESEL ENGINE PUEf PUMP                    YES   POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT    VIKIHG                YES DO-P-3BI  DIESEL ENGINB  PUEK  PUHP                  YES   POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT   VIKING               YES DO-P-3B2  DIESEK ENGINE PURL PUHP                    YES   POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT    VIKING               YES DO-P-4AI  DIESEK, EHGINE FUNK, PUMP                  YES   POSITIVE DISPI ACBMENT  GH-EMD DO-P-4A2  DIESEK, ENGINE PUEI, PUMP                  YES   POSITIVE DISPLACENEHT   GM-EHD                IES DO-P-4BI  DIESBI ENGINE PURL  PUMP                  YES   POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT   GM"EHD                YES DO-P-4B2  DIESEf BNGINE FUEL PUHP                    YES   POSITIVE DISPf ACEHEHT  GH-EHD DO-P-5    DIBSEL EHGINE PUEL  PUMP                  YES   POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT   GH-EMD               IES DO-P-6    DIESEf, ENGINE PUEL PUHP                    YES   POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT   VIKING PPC-P-1h  FUEL POOL COOLING VA'TER SUPPLY PUMP        IES  CENTRIFUGAL              VORTRIHGTOH          YES PPC-P-1S  PUEI, POOL COOLING VATBR SUPPLY PUHP       IES  CEHTRIFUGAf              VOR'THINGTON SPCS-P-1  HIGH PRESSURB BHERGENCY HAKEUP TO REACTOR  YES  CENTRIFUGAL              IHGERSOLL-RAND        YES BPCS-P-2   BPCS DIESEL SERVICE VATER PUHP              IES  CEH'IRIPUGAf            PACIPIC              YES HPCS-P-3  HPCS KEEP  FILL SISTBH  PU!KP              YBS  CENTRIFUGAL              CRANE-DEHIHG LPCS-P-1  LOV PRESSURE  EMERGBNCI HAKEUP TO REACTOR  YES  CENTRIPUGAL              INGERSOLL-RAND        IES LPCS-P-2  LPCS KEBP  PILL SISTEH  PUMP                YES  CENTRIPUGAK              CRANE-DEMING          IBS RCIC-P-1  MAKEUP TO REACTOR DURING ISOLATION EVENTS  NO    CEHTRIFUGAL              BINGHAH-VILKAMET RCIC-P-2  GLAND CONDEHSBR VACUUH PUMP                NO    CENTRIFUGAL              NASH                  YES RCIC-P-3  RCIC KEEP PILL SYSTEM PUMP                  HO    CENTRIPllGAL            CRANE-OEMING          YES
 
TABLE 1 VNP2 PUMPS IMPORTANT TO SAFETY TAG NO.                          FUNCTION        SAF REL        PUMP TYPE              MANUFACTUPER IEB 88-84 PUMP COMMEHTS RCIC-P-I      GLAHD CONDEHSER CONDEHSATE PUHP          NO    CENTRIFUGAL              HASH RCIC-P-5      TURBINE OIL PUMP                          HO    POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT    TUTHILI                NO RFV-P-1A    . FEEDVATER PUMP                            HO    CENTRIFUGAL              INGERSOLL-RAND RFV-P-1B      FEEDVATER PUMP                            NO    CENTRIFUGAL              INGERSOIL-RAND        YES RHR-P-2A      LOV PRESURE EMERGENCY MAKEUP TO REACTOR  YES  CEHTRIFUGAL              INGERSOLL-RAND        YES RHR-P-28      LOV PRESURE EMERGENCY MAKEUP TO REACTOR  YES  CENTRIFUGAf              IHGERSOLI-RAND        YES RHR-P-2C      LOV PRESURE EMERGEHCY MAKEUP TO REACTOR  YES  CENTRIFUGAL              INGERSOLL-RAND RRR-P-3       RHR KEEP  FILL SYSTEH PUMP               YES  CEHTRIFUGAL              CRANE-DEMING          YES RRC-P-1A      REACTOR RECIRCULATION PUMP               YES  CEHTRIFUGAL              BIHGHAM-VILLAMET      YES RRC-P-IB      REACTOR RECIRCUf ATIOH PUMP               YES  CEHTRIFUGAI              BINGHAM-VflfAMET      YES SLC-P-IA      STANDBY  LIQUID  COHTROL INJECTION PUHP   NO    POSTIVE DISPLACEMENT    UHION                  HO SLC-P-18      STANDBY  f IQUID COHYROL INJECTION PUMP   HO    POSTIVE DISPIACEMENT    UNION SV-P-1A        EHERGENCY SERVICE VATER SYSTEM PUMP       YES  CEHTRIFUGAL              INGERSOLL-RAND        YES S'lf-P-18      EHERGEHCY SERVICE VATER SYSTEH PUMP       YES  CEHTRIFUGAL              INGERSOLL-RAND        YES
 
IAILI 2 rvxrs EVALUATED  roa taa le Ii IAC  Io.                          IUNCIios                  sAF RIL  ever IIFE    bit fiov toss    Icsf EfFlciewct fLovilEfl  hiii fcov/I  0F REF                            conelts CIM.P-IA    COOLIIC BTER    foi COBROL    Rooh CliLLERS          ns    (6ITRHUCAL          Io                      lA                      VA        SIX  IB OFBAIKS AT BTID FLOW,      Io hil  REQUIRED cce  r-ia    (OOLIXC  BIKR  fOR COIIROL ROOli CllLLERS          IKS  CKWH I FVC1L        IO                      IA                      IA        $ 1$ 'Hh DFERAns 11 RATED FLOW,    lo Nil REQUIRED CRD.P.IA    CONTROL ROD DRIVE WATER      PVB                      Wo    CEITRIFUCAI        Hs                  211 vpa                2I Vpa/til      hih  FLOW OCCURS  OILI ova OPaallot  ERROR  OR,fAILURI (RD.P.il    COKHOL lOD DRIV6 VATKR FUNP                          KO    CENTRIFUGAL         16$                  211 gpa                21  Sfs/III    lith  fLOV 0((VIS OVLI DUI  OPERATOR ERROR OR FAILURE DCV.F.IAI    DIESEL  EICIRI CIRCULATIN JACXEI COOLIIC    WATER  TES  CEIIRIfvCAL        Io                      NA                      Ii        SISIBii OPERilds  AT IATED FLOW, KO  hil  REQUIRED ocv.e.iu    PIESEL BCIXE CIRCULATIXG JACKET COOLiev VAIKR        Ids  CKKIRIfICAl                                  VA                                Stsieii  OPERATES iT Rlilo  FLOV,  lo hii  REQUIRED OCV  P.ibi  Diesel EICINE CIRCULATIWC JACKET      COOLIWC BIER    16$  CEXTRifvCAL        lo                      IA                      WA        SISTait OFERAHS 11    sino riov,    ao Nta acavtaeo DCv.r.lal    DIESEL  EICIII CIRCULATIIC JACKET    COOLIIC VAIER  16$  CEIHifvCAL          lo                                              IA        SISTKii OPERATES Al RAIKDFLOV,    lo Nil  REQUIRED OCV  P.IC    DIESEL IVCIV6 CIRCULATIWC JAC16T COOLIVC WATER        Hs    CKVTRIFUCAL                                                          Ni        XIIIIIIOPERATES Al    RAHU FLOW, vo    hiv  REQUIRED o(v.r-lii    Otesei  BGile CIRCULAlilv JACKET    COOLIIC VAIKR  Ifs  CKNIRifUCAL        lo                      RA                      Wi        itin!i opeRAHI    AT RATED  fLOV,  lo Nii  REQUIRED OCV.P-l12    DI6$ 6L EIGiiie CIRCULATIWG JACI61 COOLIKG VAIER      HS    CEWIRIFUCAL                                  IA                                 Stsnh    OFKRAHS AT RAIED fLOV,    lo hik  REQUIRED OCV  F.201  DI6SKL KVGild CIRCULATIN JACKET (OOLIIG VATER        Ies  CKRIRifvGAL        Io                      RA                      IA        SISTEN OP6RATIS 11    auao ri,ov,  wo hia REavieao C
OC'f.r-ill  DiaseL  Balll cilcULATiic JAclev    cooLING vAHR    HS    CalnifvCAL                                                                      SISIEN OPIRAIES 1T    li'itD fLOV, I0 Nil R69UICED DCW P  IC  DitslL BGIIE    CIRCULATIIG Jl(lev COOLIVG VAtIR      IKS  CKITRIFUCAL        Io                      KA                                Slstdh    OPERAHS  B  Riveo Fcov, ao  Nil  RcoviRco Do.p-li      DIESEL FUEL IRARsflR PUNP                            HS    CIKTRIFUCAL        lo                      61                                sisleii opBAHX iT    IATED fLOW, No  hii RIQUIIFD oo  e.ia    DIESEL FUEl TRAKSFER Pvhe                            16$  CKKIRifvCAL        Io                      Ki                      IA        stsvah oefntes 11 Rino FLov,        Wo Nil  Rcaviaco 00 P-2      DIESEL FUEL IRAVSHR FVNP                              Ies  CBTRIfvCAL          ho                      IA                      NA        $ 1$ 1EII OPBATES AT RATED  fLOW, lo Niv REQVIIED fPC.P-IA    FUEL  fooL COOLHC BIER SUPPLI I'Vht                  Hs    CKVHIFUCAL          la                      ai                                SISTIN OPBATES AT    RATED  fLOV,  lo hil  RcavtRED fPC'P.il    fvEL  POOL COOLIIC TAIER    SUPtLI FUKP              IES  CHIR IFUCAL        NO                       IA                                SISIEN OFIRATIS    il RATED  flOW, V0  llil REQUIRED arcs-e-I    liCI FR6SSVII    6iiKICKKCI NAKKUP Tv REACTOR        IES  CENIRtfUCAL        IES                  IIII apa            IISf fes/III      hil fLov occUas    OURIIG TEST  iio REACTOR RIGK LKV6L KPCS-P-2    ates atcsel seavict BveR evht                        Hs    CelftlfvCAL                                  IA                     B          SISIEN OPBATES    iT IAHD fLOV, lo    hil IEQUIRKD KFCS.P.I    IFCS  ll6P fiLL $ 1$ 16N  evhp                        ns    clwIR IF vciL      lv                      IA                      KA        SISI6N OPBATIS AT RAHU fLOf,        lo iiil REQUitED LPCs.e.t    Lov BISSVRE lhelCEICI lliievP To IEACIOR              Hs    (EIHIFUCAL          ns                  SSII afs              635  fps/22I    hil FLOW    DURHG  TISIHG 110    IIII. Loci RESFOISE LFCS-P.l    LPCS  IKB FILL SISHN      FUKP                        HS    CElIR  IfNAL        Io                      Io                      li        SISIEh OFBAIES    AT RATED  fLOV,  lo htl  REQVIIEO R(i(-P-I    NAXIVP 10 IIACTOR DURIIG ISOLATIOR EHRIS              Vo    CEXTRifVGAL        ns                  151 Spa                ill aps/l 3\    hil  FLOW  Dali!G TEST OR Ove  Io FAILURI  OR  OPER. BRUR a(I(-P-2    CLAID COIDBSER TACUvii evhe                          lo    CHIR I FUGAL        lv                      Io                      IA        slsnh oplRAHI AT Rino        fLOV,  lo iiil REQUIRED RCIC-P-3    RCIC  lait  FILL  Stsnli  FUB                        lo    C KEIR If UCAL      lo                      lo                      IA         stsIB opaRlns      1T RATID fLOV,  l0 itic IE9JIRED RCIC.P   I   CLAID COKDIVSER COXDEISATE FUKP                       lo    CKRTRifvGAL        lv                      lo                      WA        ststeh orle@Is    AT RATED  fLOV,  Io hn ItaviIED Rfr-P-ii    fldDVAHR PURP                                        lo    (El TRIFUGAL        Tas                ICfil Ipa            iif1 fps/III      NIN fLOV DURIIG PLAXT    Slliot I  SIUIOOVV lfV F.il    felDVATB PUKP                                        lo    CERHIFUCAL          16$                lifn fps              iifI qpa/III      iiii fLOV Dviila FLART SIARUP I Sev'IOOVW RIR.P.lA    Lov eacsvaa  Kheacclct Nuevr To aeicfoa              HS    CERTRifvCAL        'tee                5151 1 pa              551  fps/III    iiii fLOV OVRIIG T6$ T AXD iliT. lOCA REIPOISE ala.e-ll    LOV  FRISUIK liieRCBCT NBKUP To leiCTOR              IKS  CEXIRIFUGAL        16$                  Siil apa              551  fps/I II  iiil FLOV DURIWC 1651 AVD IVII. LOCi Rcsfolsa RER.r.lC     Lal BISURE IBRCEICI iiil6VP      To RBCIOR          IES  CEIIRI FVCiL        ns                  SI5 I apa              551  apa/ill    iiil fLOV OUIIXC TEST AID llii. LOCA RESFOISE
 
0 TAILE  I FUNFS KTALUATEO fOR  tll ll.lt TAG RO.                       FUKCIIOK        SAF RRL  FUNP TTPE  btl fLOV FUSS    EESI KfftCIERCI  FLOV(llf)  htl FLOV/\ OF  Elf                            CONNTRTS RKE  P-I   RIR REEF FILL SISIKN PUNP              IES  CRUIRIFUGAL      lO                      RO                      IA          SISIEX  OPERATES  AI  RATED FLOV, RO NIV IEOUtRED RRC-P.IA    REACTOR  IRCIRCULAIIOV PUllP            TKS  CKVIRIFUGAL      IES                IISIT  Tpa            tllllTpa/Ill    NIR fLOT  LttttIED IT fLOV CORTROL  TALVE FOSITIOV EIC-P ID    REACTOR EECtRCULATIOR FVEP              IKS   CERIRIFUGAL      IES                 IIIIIgpa              1tltl Tpa/Itl    Ntl  fLOV LIRITED  bl  fLOV CORIROL VALVE POSITIOR SV  P.IA    EttdRGKICI SERVICI VAIER SISTKtt PUNP  16$  CKRIRtfVGAL      IES                 tllll Vpa              ltll Tpa/331    Ntl FLOV DURIKG  Iltf. PUNP  START fOR 51 SECORDS SV P-tl   KNERGEICT SERVICE VAIER SISIEN fKEP     TES   CKVIRIFUGAL     IES                 IIIIITpa              l3ll Tpa/331     Ntl fLOV DUIITG IIII. PUNP SIATT fOR SI SECOIDS}}

Latest revision as of 14:57, 29 October 2019

Responds to IE Bulletin 88-004 Re Potential safety-related Pump Loss.Facility Has No safety-related Pumps W/Detrimental pump-to-pump Interaction.Min Flow Line Adequate as Addressed in Encl Rept
ML17284A432
Person / Time
Site: Columbia Energy Northwest icon.png
Issue date: 07/08/1988
From: Sorensen G
WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM
To:
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
References
G2-88-150, GO2-88-150, IEB-88-004, IEB-88-4, TAC-69992, NUDOCS 8807180324
Download: ML17284A432 (16)


Text

k

- "kCCE1ZRATED D+R1BUTJON DEMONSTT1ON

, SYSTgg REGULATORY I

INFORMATION DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM (RIDS)

'I' ACCESSION NBR:8807180324 DOC.DATE: 88/07/08 NOTARIZED: YES 'OCKET FACIL:50-397 WPPSS Nuclear Project, Unit 2, Washington Public Powe 05000397 AUTH. NAME AUTHOR AFFILIATION SORENSEN,G.C. Washington Public Power Supply System RECIP.NAME RECIPIENT AFFILIATION Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk)

SUBJECT:

Responds to IE Bulletin 88-004 re potential safety-related pump loss.

DISTRIBUTION CODE: IE11D COPIES RECEIVED:LTR ENCL SIZE:

TITLE: Bulletin Response (50 DKT)

NOTES:

RECIPIENT COPIES RECIPIENT COPIES ZD CODE/NAME LTTR ENCL ID CODE/NAME LTTR ENCL PD5 LA 1 0 PD5 PD 1 1 SAMWORTH,R 1 1 h INTERNAL: AEOD/DOA 1 1 AEOD/DSP 1 1 AEOD/DSP/TPAB 1 1 NRR RIVENBARK,G 1 1 NRR/DEST/ADS 7E NRR/DEST/ADE 8H NRR/DEST/MEB 9H NRR/DOEA/GCB 11 1

1 1

1 1

1 NRR/DOEA/EAB NRR/DREP/EPB 10 ll 1 1

1 1

1 1

  • 1 NRR~~ hSJ LRB12 1 'UDOCS-ABSTRACT 1 1 LE 02 1 1 RES/DE/EIB 1 1 GN5 FILE Ol 1 1 EXTERNAL: LPDR .1 1 NRC PDR 1 1 NSIC 1 1 j

h TOTAL NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED: LTTR 21 ENCL 20

WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM P.O. Box 968 ~ 3000 George Washington Way ~ Richland, Washington 99352 July 8, 1988 G02-88-150 Docket No. 50-397 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Document Control Desk Mail Station Pl-137 Washington, D.C. 20555 Gentlemen:

Subject:

NUCLEAR PLANT NO. 2 OPERATING LICENSE NPF-21 RESPONSE TO IEB 88-04, "POTENTIAL SAFETY RELATED PUMP LOSS"

Reference:

Letter, BWROG-8836, D.N. Grace (BWR Owners Group Chairman) to US NRC, same subject, dated July 5, 1988 The subject bulletin requested all licensees to investigate and correct as appli-cable two minimum flow safety related pump design concerns: dead heading due to pump-to-pump interaction and the adequacy of installed minimum flow capacity for a single pump in operation. With regard to the first concern WNP-2 has no safety related pumps with detrimental pump-to-pump interaction. The second concern, minimum flow line adequacy, is addressed in the attached report. The attached commits to providing additional information on this concern within 75 days of this response.

The Supply System is a participant in the BWR Owners Group and as such endorses the referenced letter submitted by that group to respond generically to the bulletin. The attached report provides additional information on plant specifics detailing both short and long term action and schedule, and endorses the justifi-cation for continued operation supplied in the reference by the BWR Owners Group.

Should you have any questions, please contaCt Mr.. A. G. Hosier, Manager, WNP-2 Licensing' Very truly yours, G. C. rensen, Manager Regulatory Programs PLP/bk cc: JB Martin - NRC RV NS Reynolds - BCP8R RB Samworth - NRC DL Williams - BPA/399 NRC Site Inspector - 901A 8807i80324 880708 PDR ADQCK 05000397 8

STATE OF WASHINGTON)

Subject:

)

COUNTY OF BENTON )

I, G. C. Sorensen, being duly sworn, subscribe to and say that I am the Manager, Regulatory Programs for the WASHINGTON. PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM, the applicant herein; that I have full authority to execute this oath; that I have reviewed the foregoing; and that to the best of my knowledge, information and belief the statements made in it are true.

DATE4/g ~ Z , 1988 G. C. Soyensen, Manager Regulat4ry Programs On this day personally appeared before me G. C. Sorensen to me known to be the individual who executed the foregoing instrument and acknowledged that he signed the same as his free act and deed for the uses and purposes herein mentioned.

GIVEN under my hand and seal this day of 1988.

otary u )c )n a d or the STA E OF WASHINGTON Residing

EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL SAFETY RELATED PUMP LOSS: IEB 88-04

1. Safet Rel ated Pum Evaluati on Table 1 lists 83 pumps at WNP-2 which are considered safety related (Table 1). Of these pumps, 38 are centrifugal pumps which were specifically evaluated for problems related to pump-to-pump interaction and minimum flow operation. The remaining pumps are positive displacement pumps.

The results of the WNP-2 evaluation are presented in Table 2.

In summary, no pump or piping configurations were found which could lead to detrimental pump-to-pump interactions. From the Table 2 list, 24 of the 38 pumps were found to be of no concern and 14 pumps were found which could experience short periods of dead head and/or minimum flow operation during normal pump start up and routine testing. Specific discussion on these pumps is provided below.

2. Short and Lon Term Evaluation Pro ram Of the 14 pumps identified from Table 2, six have been evaluated as not having or not susceptible to concerns related to inadequate minimum flow capacity. Records of these evaluations will be maintained per the guidance of IEB 88-04. The remaining eight, subject to continued evaluation are:

o Reactor Heat Removal Pumps 2A, 2B, 8 2C o High Pressure Core Spray Pump 1 o Low Pressure Cor e Spray Pump 1 o Standby Service Water Pump 1A, 8 1B o Reactor Core Isolation Cooling Pump 1 A description of the continuing evaluation for these pumps is provided below.

Prior to the issuance of IEB 88-04 all ECCS pump operating procedures were modified to include caution statements to the operator to ensure that the minimum flow valves opened upon starting the pump, and that the amount of time the pump is operated on minimum flow is minimized. These changes adequately address, the need for short term modifications to operating procedures as required in the bulletin.

The evaluation programs, short and long term, are as follows:

A. Short Term Program

l. Authorize the pump manufacturers to reevaluate pump parameters and determine if. current low and minimum flow operating parameters should be revised.
2. Perform base line vibration testing with temporary equipment at low and minimum flow operations. Analyze the data and determine the rotordynamic effects of the observed vibrations and develop a data base.
3. Based on I and 2,'etermine if any operating or hardware modifica-tions are required, in the interim, prior to completion of the long term program, These short term actions cannot be completed until the pump manufac-turer's evaluations are completed, necessitating a follow-on report to be submitted within 75 days of this response.

BE Long Term Program

1. Complete data collection and analysis confirming the results of the short term program.
2. Based on vendor recommendations and the results of the short term program, future test requirements will be defined and incorporated into the current periodic inspections of the ISI program. Data exchange through the BHROG wil-1 enhance the historical data base development and is an integral component of this plan.
3. The t results of the shor term bases development could lead to hardware and operating mode changes. Among the potential hardware changes are piping modifications, pump internal modifications to adjust A and 8 gaps to reduce hydraulic instabilities, or use of adjustable speed drives. The long term program and data base development will pr ovide feedback as to the adequacy of any short term modifications and identify any additional areas requiring modification.
4. The interim long term program which embodies the requirements for 10 year inspections per the ASME code will remain in effect until the necessity for modification is determined from the results of this program.
3. Justification For Continued 0 eration (JCO)

The Supply System endorses the JCO provided in the referenced BWROG sub-mittal and r eiterates the following in support of continued operation:

A. The common minimum flow line design shared by two or more pumps does not exist in any safety related pump design at WNP-2.

B. The ECCS pumps at WNP-2 were procured to the highest industry stan-dards.

C. The reliability and history of the ECCS pumps at WNP-2 have been demon-strated to be equal to that addressed in the BWROG JCO and therefore encompassed by that response.

TABLE 1 VNP2 PUMPS IMPORTANT TO SAFETY TAG HO, FUNCTION SAF REI PUMP TYPE MANUFACTURER IEB 88-84 PUMP COMMENTS CCH-P-IA COOLING VATER FOR CONTROI ROOH CHILf ERS YES CEHTRIPUGAL GOULD CCH-P-1B COOLING VATER FOR CONTROL ROOH CHILLERS YES CENTRIFUGAL GOUI D NO CMS-P-I/13 SPARED IH PLACS NO POSITIVE DISPI ACEMEHT HETAI BEf f OVS CLASS I PU!{P SPARED IH PIACE POR FUTURE USE CMS-P-I/14 SPARED IN PLACE NO POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT METAL BELLOVS CLASS I PUMP SPARED IH PLACE FOR FUTURE U CMS-P-2/13 SPARED IN PLACE NO POSITIVE DISPI ACEMEHT METAI BELLOVS CI ASS I PUMP SPARED IN PLACS POR PUTURE USE CMS"P-2/14 SPARBD Ilf PLACE NO POSITIVB DISPLACEMENT METAL BE!,LOVS CLASS I PUMP SPARBD IN PLACS POR FUTURE USE CMS-P-1381 CONTAINMEHT ATMOSHERE SANPLE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPIACEMEHT AIR DIMENSIONS IHC CMS-P-14SI COlfTAIHMENT ATNOSHERS SAHPf E PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT AIR DIMEHSIONS INC NO CRD-P-IA CONTROL ROD DRIVE VATER PUMP HO CENTRIPUGAL UNION CRD-P-1B CONTROL ROD DRIVS VATER PUl!P NO CEN'TRIPUGAL YES

. DCV-P-IA2 DIESEL EHGIHB CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER YES CSHTRIPUGAL GM-EHD DCV-P-IAl DIESEL BEGINS CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER YES CENTRIFUGAL GH-EMD YES DCV-P-IBI DIESEl, ENGIHE CIRCUf,ATING JACKET COOLING HATER YES CEHTRIPUGAL GM-EHD YES DCV-P-1B2 DIESEL ENGINE CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATBR YBS CENTRIFUGAL GH-EMD YES DCV-P-IC DIBSEL EHGIHB CIRCULATING JACKBT COOLING VATER YES CEHTRIPUGAL GM-EHD YES DCV-P-2AI DIESEf EHGIHE CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER YBS CEHTRIPUGAL GM"EMD YES-DCV-P-2A2 . DIESEI ENGINE CIRCUI ATIHG JACKET COOLIHG VATER YES CEHTRIPUGhf GM-EHD YES DCV-P-2B1 DIESBL ENGIHE CIRCULATIHG JACKET COOLING VATER YES CENTRIFUGAL GM-ElfD YES DCV.P-2B2 DIESEf, ENGINE CIRCUf ATING JACKST COOLING VATER YES CEHTRIFUGAL GN-EHD YES DCV-P-2C DIESEL ENGINE CIRCULATING JACKET COOLING VATER YES CENTRIFUGAL GH-EMD YES DLO-P-Il EHERG. DIESEL BEGINS OIL DRIVE PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EMD DLO-P-IA1 EMERG, DISSEI ENGIHE OIL DRIVE PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EMD HO DLO.P-IA2 EMERG. DIESBf ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EHD

TABLE I VHP2 PUHPS IMPORTANT TO SAFETY TAG NO. FUHCTION SAF REf PUMP TYPE MANUFACTURER IEB 88-84 PUMP COMMENTS DLO-P-181 EHERG, DIESEl ENGINE OIL DRIVB PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EMD NO DLO-P-182 EHERG. DIESEL EHGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISP!,ACEMEHT GM-EMD DLO-P-2A1 EMERG. DIESEL EHGIHE Olf DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVB DISPLACEHENT VIKIHG DLO-P-2A2 EMERG. DIESEI BHGIHE OIL DRIVE PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACENENT VIKING HO DLO-P-2BI ENERG. DIESEL EHGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPI ACEMENT VIKING DLO-P-282 EMERG. DIESEL EHGIHE OIL DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPl ACEHEHT VIKIHG NO DLO-P-3A1 EMERG. DIESEf, ENGIHE Oll, DRIVB PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT VIKING DLO-P-3A2 EMERG. DIESEL ENGINE Olf DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPI ACEHEHT VIKING HO DLO-P-3A2 EMERG. DIESEf, ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP POSITIVE DISPf ACEMENT VIKING NO DLO-P-381 ENERG. DIESEL, ENGINE Off, DRIVE PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPI,ACEHENT VIKING DLO-P-382 EMERG. DIESEI ENGINE Oll DRIVE PUNP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT VIKING DLO-P-4A1 BHERG. DIESEL ENGINE Olf DRIVE PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEHENT GM-EMD DLO-P-4A2 ENERG. DIESEL EHGIHE OIL DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT GM-EHD DLO-P-481 EHBRG. DIESEL ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACENEHT GM-EMD DLO-P-4B2 EHERG. DIBSBl ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-END DLO-P-5A1 BHERG. DIESEL ENGINE Olf DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GH-EHD DLO-P-5A2 EHERG. DIESEf BNGIHE OIL DRIVE PUNP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT GH-EMD DLO-P-581 EHERG. DIBSEf BHGINE OIL DRIVE PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EMD DLO-P-5B2 EHERG. DIESEL BNGIlfE OIL DRIVE PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPf ACBMENT GM-EHD DLO-P-6 EHERG. DIESEf BNGIHE OIL DRIVE PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT VIKING HO DLO-P-7 EHERG. DIESBL EHGINE OIL DRIVE PUNP YES POSITIVE DISPf ACEMENT ALLISON HO DLO-P-8 EMERG. DIBSEf ENGINE OIL DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEHENT ALLISON DLO-P-9 EHERG. DIESBL EHGIHE OIL DRIVE PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM-EMD

TABLE 1 VNP2 PUMPS IMPORTAHT IO SAPETY TAG HO. FUNCTION SAF REK PUHP TYPE MANUFACTURER IEB 88-84 PUHP COMHENTS DO-P-IA DIESEL FUEL TRANSPBR PUMP YES CENTRIFUGAL CRANE-DEMING YES DO-P-IB DIESEf FUBI TRANSFER PUMP YES CEHTRIFUGAI CRANE-DEMING YES DO-P-2 DIESEK FUEK TRAHSFER PUMP YES CEHTRIPUGAL CRANE-DEHING YES DO-P-3hl DIBSBL ENGIHE FUEL PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT VIKING 00-P-3A2 DIESEL ENGINE PUEf PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT VIKIHG YES DO-P-3BI DIESEL ENGINB PUEK PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT VIKING YES DO-P-3B2 DIESEK ENGINE PURL PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT VIKING YES DO-P-4AI DIESEK, EHGINE FUNK, PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPI ACBMENT GH-EMD DO-P-4A2 DIESEK, ENGINE PUEI, PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACENEHT GM-EHD IES DO-P-4BI DIESBI ENGINE PURL PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT GM"EHD YES DO-P-4B2 DIESEf BNGINE FUEL PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPf ACEHEHT GH-EHD DO-P-5 DIBSEL EHGINE PUEL PUMP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT GH-EMD IES DO-P-6 DIESEf, ENGINE PUEL PUHP YES POSITIVE DISPLACEMEHT VIKING PPC-P-1h FUEL POOL COOLING VA'TER SUPPLY PUMP IES CENTRIFUGAL VORTRIHGTOH YES PPC-P-1S PUEI, POOL COOLING VATBR SUPPLY PUHP IES CEHTRIFUGAf VOR'THINGTON SPCS-P-1 HIGH PRESSURB BHERGENCY HAKEUP TO REACTOR YES CENTRIFUGAL IHGERSOLL-RAND YES BPCS-P-2 BPCS DIESEL SERVICE VATER PUHP IES CEH'IRIPUGAf PACIPIC YES HPCS-P-3 HPCS KEEP FILL SISTBH PU!KP YBS CENTRIFUGAL CRANE-DEHIHG LPCS-P-1 LOV PRESSURE EMERGBNCI HAKEUP TO REACTOR YES CENTRIPUGAL INGERSOLL-RAND IES LPCS-P-2 LPCS KEBP PILL SISTEH PUMP YES CENTRIPUGAK CRANE-DEMING IBS RCIC-P-1 MAKEUP TO REACTOR DURING ISOLATION EVENTS NO CEHTRIFUGAL BINGHAH-VILKAMET RCIC-P-2 GLAND CONDEHSBR VACUUH PUMP NO CENTRIFUGAL NASH YES RCIC-P-3 RCIC KEEP PILL SYSTEM PUMP HO CENTRIPllGAL CRANE-OEMING YES

TABLE 1 VNP2 PUMPS IMPORTANT TO SAFETY TAG NO. FUNCTION SAF REL PUMP TYPE MANUFACTUPER IEB 88-84 PUMP COMMEHTS RCIC-P-I GLAHD CONDEHSER CONDEHSATE PUHP NO CENTRIFUGAL HASH RCIC-P-5 TURBINE OIL PUMP HO POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT TUTHILI NO RFV-P-1A . FEEDVATER PUMP HO CENTRIFUGAL INGERSOLL-RAND RFV-P-1B FEEDVATER PUMP NO CENTRIFUGAL INGERSOIL-RAND YES RHR-P-2A LOV PRESURE EMERGENCY MAKEUP TO REACTOR YES CEHTRIFUGAL INGERSOLL-RAND YES RHR-P-28 LOV PRESURE EMERGENCY MAKEUP TO REACTOR YES CENTRIFUGAf IHGERSOLI-RAND YES RHR-P-2C LOV PRESURE EMERGEHCY MAKEUP TO REACTOR YES CENTRIFUGAL INGERSOLL-RAND RRR-P-3 RHR KEEP FILL SYSTEH PUMP YES CEHTRIFUGAL CRANE-DEMING YES RRC-P-1A REACTOR RECIRCULATION PUMP YES CEHTRIFUGAL BIHGHAM-VILLAMET YES RRC-P-IB REACTOR RECIRCUf ATIOH PUMP YES CEHTRIFUGAI BINGHAM-VflfAMET YES SLC-P-IA STANDBY LIQUID COHTROL INJECTION PUHP NO POSTIVE DISPLACEMENT UHION HO SLC-P-18 STANDBY f IQUID COHYROL INJECTION PUMP HO POSTIVE DISPIACEMENT UNION SV-P-1A EHERGENCY SERVICE VATER SYSTEM PUMP YES CEHTRIFUGAL INGERSOLL-RAND YES S'lf-P-18 EHERGEHCY SERVICE VATER SYSTEH PUMP YES CEHTRIFUGAL INGERSOLL-RAND YES

IAILI 2 rvxrs EVALUATED roa taa le Ii IAC Io. IUNCIios sAF RIL ever IIFE bit fiov toss Icsf EfFlciewct fLovilEfl hiii fcov/I 0F REF conelts CIM.P-IA COOLIIC BTER foi COBROL Rooh CliLLERS ns (6ITRHUCAL Io lA VA SIX IB OFBAIKS AT BTID FLOW, Io hil REQUIRED cce r-ia (OOLIXC BIKR fOR COIIROL ROOli CllLLERS IKS CKWH I FVC1L IO IA IA $ 1$ 'Hh DFERAns 11 RATED FLOW, lo Nil REQUIRED CRD.P.IA CONTROL ROD DRIVE WATER PVB Wo CEITRIFUCAI Hs 211 vpa 2I Vpa/til hih FLOW OCCURS OILI ova OPaallot ERROR OR,fAILURI (RD.P.il COKHOL lOD DRIV6 VATKR FUNP KO CENTRIFUGAL 16$ 211 gpa 21 Sfs/III lith fLOV 0((VIS OVLI DUI OPERATOR ERROR OR FAILURE DCV.F.IAI DIESEL EICIRI CIRCULATIN JACXEI COOLIIC WATER TES CEIIRIfvCAL Io NA Ii SISIBii OPERilds AT IATED FLOW, KO hil REQUIRED ocv.e.iu PIESEL BCIXE CIRCULATIXG JACKET COOLiev VAIKR Ids CKKIRIfICAl VA Stsieii OPERATES iT Rlilo FLOV, lo hii REQUIRED OCV P.ibi Diesel EICINE CIRCULATIWC JACKET COOLIWC BIER 16$ CEXTRifvCAL lo IA WA SISTait OFERAHS 11 sino riov, ao Nta acavtaeo DCv.r.lal DIESEL EICIII CIRCULATIIC JACKET COOLIIC VAIER 16$ CEIHifvCAL lo IA SISTKii OPERATES Al RAIKDFLOV, lo Nil REQUIRED OCV P.IC DIESEL IVCIV6 CIRCULATIWC JAC16T COOLIVC WATER Hs CKVTRIFUCAL Ni XIIIIIIOPERATES Al RAHU FLOW, vo hiv REQUIRED o(v.r-lii Otesei BGile CIRCULAlilv JACKET COOLIIC VAIKR Ifs CKNIRifUCAL lo RA Wi itin!i opeRAHI AT RATED fLOV, lo Nii REQUIRED OCV.P-l12 DI6$ 6L EIGiiie CIRCULATIWG JACI61 COOLIKG VAIER HS CEWIRIFUCAL IA Stsnh OFKRAHS AT RAIED fLOV, lo hik REQUIRED OCV F.201 DI6SKL KVGild CIRCULATIN JACKET (OOLIIG VATER Ies CKRIRifvGAL Io RA IA SISTEN OP6RATIS 11 auao ri,ov, wo hia REavieao C

OC'f.r-ill DiaseL Balll cilcULATiic JAclev cooLING vAHR HS CalnifvCAL SISIEN OPIRAIES 1T li'itD fLOV, I0 Nil R69UICED DCW P IC DitslL BGIIE CIRCULATIIG Jl(lev COOLIVG VAtIR IKS CKITRIFUCAL Io KA Slstdh OPERAHS B Riveo Fcov, ao Nil RcoviRco Do.p-li DIESEL FUEL IRARsflR PUNP HS CIKTRIFUCAL lo 61 sisleii opBAHX iT IATED fLOW, No hii RIQUIIFD oo e.ia DIESEL FUEl TRAKSFER Pvhe 16$ CKKIRifvCAL Io Ki IA stsvah oefntes 11 Rino FLov, Wo Nil Rcaviaco 00 P-2 DIESEL FUEL IRAVSHR FVNP Ies CBTRIfvCAL ho IA NA $ 1$ 1EII OPBATES AT RATED fLOW, lo Niv REQVIIED fPC.P-IA FUEL fooL COOLHC BIER SUPPLI I'Vht Hs CKVHIFUCAL la ai SISTIN OPBATES AT RATED fLOV, lo hil RcavtRED fPC'P.il fvEL POOL COOLIIC TAIER SUPtLI FUKP IES CHIR IFUCAL NO IA SISIEN OFIRATIS il RATED flOW, V0 llil REQUIRED arcs-e-I liCI FR6SSVII 6iiKICKKCI NAKKUP Tv REACTOR IES CENIRtfUCAL IES IIII apa IISf fes/III hil fLov occUas OURIIG TEST iio REACTOR RIGK LKV6L KPCS-P-2 ates atcsel seavict BveR evht Hs CelftlfvCAL IA B SISIEN OPBATES iT IAHD fLOV, lo hil IEQUIRKD KFCS.P.I IFCS ll6P fiLL $ 1$ 16N evhp ns clwIR IF vciL lv IA KA SISI6N OPBATIS AT RAHU fLOf, lo iiil REQUitED LPCs.e.t Lov BISSVRE lhelCEICI lliievP To IEACIOR Hs (EIHIFUCAL ns SSII afs 635 fps/22I hil FLOW DURHG TISIHG 110 IIII. Loci RESFOISE LFCS-P.l LPCS IKB FILL SISHN FUKP HS CElIR IfNAL Io Io li SISIEh OFBAIES AT RATED fLOV, lo htl REQVIIEO R(i(-P-I NAXIVP 10 IIACTOR DURIIG ISOLATIOR EHRIS Vo CEXTRifVGAL ns 151 Spa ill aps/l 3\ hil FLOW Dali!G TEST OR Ove Io FAILURI OR OPER. BRUR a(I(-P-2 CLAID COIDBSER TACUvii evhe lo CHIR I FUGAL lv Io IA slsnh oplRAHI AT Rino fLOV, lo iiil REQUIRED RCIC-P-3 RCIC lait FILL Stsnli FUB lo C KEIR If UCAL lo lo IA stsIB opaRlns 1T RATID fLOV, l0 itic IE9JIRED RCIC.P I CLAID COKDIVSER COXDEISATE FUKP lo CKRTRifvGAL lv lo WA ststeh orle@Is AT RATED fLOV, Io hn ItaviIED Rfr-P-ii fldDVAHR PURP lo (El TRIFUGAL Tas ICfil Ipa iif1 fps/III NIN fLOV DURIIG PLAXT Slliot I SIUIOOVV lfV F.il felDVATB PUKP lo CERHIFUCAL 16$ lifn fps iifI qpa/III iiii fLOV Dviila FLART SIARUP I Sev'IOOVW RIR.P.lA Lov eacsvaa Kheacclct Nuevr To aeicfoa HS CERTRifvCAL 'tee 5151 1 pa 551 fps/III iiii fLOV OVRIIG T6$ T AXD iliT. lOCA REIPOISE ala.e-ll LOV FRISUIK liieRCBCT NBKUP To leiCTOR IKS CEXIRIFUGAL 16$ Siil apa 551 fps/I II iiil FLOV DURIWC 1651 AVD IVII. LOCi Rcsfolsa RER.r.lC Lal BISURE IBRCEICI iiil6VP To RBCIOR IES CEIIRI FVCiL ns SI5 I apa 551 apa/ill iiil fLOV OUIIXC TEST AID llii. LOCA RESFOISE

0 TAILE I FUNFS KTALUATEO fOR tll ll.lt TAG RO. FUKCIIOK SAF RRL FUNP TTPE btl fLOV FUSS EESI KfftCIERCI FLOV(llf) htl FLOV/\ OF Elf CONNTRTS RKE P-I RIR REEF FILL SISIKN PUNP IES CRUIRIFUGAL lO RO IA SISIEX OPERATES AI RATED FLOV, RO NIV IEOUtRED RRC-P.IA REACTOR IRCIRCULAIIOV PUllP TKS CKVIRIFUGAL IES IISIT Tpa tllllTpa/Ill NIR fLOT LttttIED IT fLOV CORTROL TALVE FOSITIOV EIC-P ID REACTOR EECtRCULATIOR FVEP IKS CERIRIFUGAL IES IIIIIgpa 1tltl Tpa/Itl Ntl fLOV LIRITED bl fLOV CORIROL VALVE POSITIOR SV P.IA EttdRGKICI SERVICI VAIER SISTKtt PUNP 16$ CKRIRtfVGAL IES tllll Vpa ltll Tpa/331 Ntl FLOV DURIKG Iltf. PUNP START fOR 51 SECORDS SV P-tl KNERGEICT SERVICE VAIER SISIEN fKEP TES CKVIRIFUGAL IES IIIIITpa l3ll Tpa/331 Ntl fLOV DUIITG IIII. PUNP SIATT fOR SI SECOIDS