ML20129F103
Text
U.b. NOULLAH HLGULAIUM y CUMMih6UN
%HC FoaA HEQUEST fvuMBEHIS)
% FOIA 208 RESPONSE TYPE I' RESPONSE T@ FREEDOM OF x l FINAL l l PARTIAL INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUES o^'E E 27 E
- .lE oVE ST E R h ooCKEi nuuBEmSmrapow mn Mr. David K. Colapinto PART l.-AGENCY RECORDS RELEASED OR NOT LOCATED (See checked boxes)
No agency records subject to the requast have been located.
._ No additional agency records subject to the request have been located.
Requested records are available through another public distribution program. See Comrr.ents section, j Agency records subject to the request that are identified in Appendix (es) . _ are already available for public inspection and copying at the
-3 NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC.
X A 9'"c"co'ds subjec'. to the request that are ideMfied in Appendix (es) A are being made avaita' u fe for public inspection and copying :
et the A . ' Nblic Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC,in a folder under this FOIA number.
The not u .atary version of the proposal (s) that you agreed to accept in a telephone conversation with a member of my staff is now being made available for pubh. iect;on and copying at the N RC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washingtnn, DC, in a folder under this FOI A number.
Agency records subject to the request that are identified in Appendix (es) may be inspected and copied at the N RC Local Public Document j Room identified in the Comments section.
t X Enclosed is information on how you may obta n access to and the chargr's for copymg records located at the NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, 1 N.W., Washing *on, DC.
Agency records subject to the request are encinsed.
X Records subject to the request have been referred to another Federal agency (ies) for review and direct response to you. DOJ g Fees You will be billed by the NRC for fees tntaling $
You will receive a refund from the NRC in the amount of $
in view of N RC's response to this request, no further action is bemg taken on appeal letter dated , No.
~
PART II. A-INFORMATION WITHHELO FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Cittain information In the requested records is being withheld from public disclosure pursuant to the exemptions described in and for the reasons stated X in Part 11, B, C, and D. Any released portions of the documents for which only part of the r s being withheld are being made available for public innpection and copying 80 the NHC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washint in a folder under this FOI A number, COMME NTS On May 24, 1994, you informed us that you have the Report of Investigations and its exhibits.
Therefore, these records are not being addressed in this request.
On June 21, 1994, you further narrowed the scope of your request stating you do not need any type of pleadings, filing or depositions from DOL proceedings and any filing with the NRC Licensing Board by any parties.
[IG RE. DIRECTOR DJ lSloN ON REEDoM INF MATioN AND PUBLICATIONS SE RVICES 7
\ 4, t
%gdsmesd 3a. wa~ . s #Th b b% Yi?"? 0 f Y - bY Y 1 .
Y ' c-
.p ,
ft '
+
K '
p,
.7 :. P ,4^sf Q.!n 1- ykp' gj.%y w ad, W feQ dy W
COLAPIN94-200 PDR
,, g : 4p - %.T,f yg, kTN 4.g g g j p g.g? 7y *
% Vy g f? f QN;
.p f fWGQW , _' k ' 4 " '
f p cPo n.e1nn n
l ronusnetass oun
[ E ESPONSE T3 FREEDOM OF
] INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST FOIA 208
{
(CONTINUATION) M 2) l PART 18 8- APPLICABLE EXEMPTIONS Records subject to the request that are described in the enclosed Appendix (es1R P : D are being withheld in their entirety or in part under the Exernption No.(s' ano for the reason (s) given below pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552(b) and 10 CF R 9.17(a) of NRC regulations.
- 1. The wethheld information es properly classified pursuant to Executive Order. (Exemption 1)
- 2. The withheld mformation relates solely to the mternal personnel rules and procedures of NRC. IEnemption 2) l l3. The wethheld enformation ss specifically esempted from public disclosure by statute indicated. (Ememption 3)
Sections 141145 of the Atonne Energy Act, which prohibits the disclosure of Restricted Data or Formerly Restncted Data (42 U.S.C. 21612165).
Section 147 of the Atomic Energy Act, which prohibits the disc'osure of Unclassified Safeguards information (42 U.S.C,2167).
'4. The withheld mformation is a trade secrat or commercial or financial mfo mation that is being withheld for the reasontal indicated. (Exemption 4)
The mformation is considered to ';e confidential business loroprietary) information The mformation is considered to be proprietary mformation pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790(d>l11.
The mformation was submitted and received m confidence pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790tdit2) s 5. The withheld mformation consists of interagency or miraegency records that are not evada' ale through discovery during litigation (Exemption 5), Apphcable Privilege:
Deliberative Process: Desclosure of predecisional information would tend to inhibit tne open and frank enchange of ioems esseritsal to the deliberative process X wh.re records are withheld m their entirety, the f acts are mentricably intertwined with the predecisionalinformation There also are no reasonably segregable f actual portions because the release of the f acts would pefmet an mderect mQuery into the predecisional process of the agency Attorney work product prevdege IDocuments prepared by an attorney en contemplation of htigation e 3 Attorney.chent prieslage. (Confidential communications between an attorney and his/her chent.)
- 6. The wethheld mformation is enempted from public disclosure because its disclosure would result m a clearly unwarranted mvasion of personal privacy (Exemption 6)
~.
i
- 7. The withheld mformation consists of records compiled for law enforcement purposes and is being withheld for the reasondsl indicated (Ezemption 7)
Disclosure could reasonably be expected so interfere with an enforcement proceeding because it coWd reveal the scope. direction, and focus of enforcement efforts, and thus could possibly allow recipients to talte action to shseld potential wrongdoing or a violation of NRC requirements l from investiostors. (E nemption 7 ( A))
Disclosure would constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal pnvecy. (Exemption 7(C)) '
1 X
The mimmation consists of names of individuals and other information the disciosure of ahich c ould reasonably be enoected to reveal identities of confidential sources. (Ememption 7 (DI)
[.?
' OT H t]< \
% f Dirclosure wOuld reveal techniques and m OCedures. (Exemption 7E) l l PART 11. C-DENYING OFFICIALS Pursuent to 10 CF R 9.25(b) and'or 9 251c) of the U S Nuclear Reguistoiy Comm<ssion regulations. it has been determined that the mformation withheld is enempt from pro.
duction or disciosure. and that its productton or disclosure is contra <y to the pubhc interest The persons responsible for the denial are those of ficials identified below as denying officiais cnd the Director. Divmon of Freedom of information and Pubications Sennces. Off <ce of Admitustration for any denials that may be appeased to the Ex*utive Director for Ooermons (E DOI Of NYING Of FICIAL TIFLE <Of f lCE RECORDS DENIED APPELLATE OFFICIAL l
Associate General Counsel for lS,G.
l Burns Ronrinom vnfnrcomont_&_ Admin: Appnnd4cne B ?. n y_
G . E.s Caputo hirnetor. OT Apponaly, c _x l
l l
l l
l PART 11. D- APPEAL RIGHTS The dond by each denymg opial identified in Part ll.C may be appealed to the Appellate Official identified there. Any such appeal must be made m writmg within 30 days of receipt of th5 response. Appeals must he sucessed, as appropnate, to the E xecutive Director for Operations to the Secretary of the Commission or to the inspector General. U S. Nuclear Reguistory Commission. Washington, DC 2MS. and should clearly state on the envelope and m the letter that it is an " Appeal from an initial FOI A Decmon."
NHC FORM 464 (Part 2) (191) U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
o I
- i 4
i
- 6 [
Re: POIA-94-208 !
l* APPIROIX A
! RBIRDS BBIIG PLACID INIO 'DE RR 120ER 'IIE ABOVE REURST MPERR l
- i l NLPBER DA3B DESGIPTICN PAGES l 4 !
j 1. Undated Draft letter to M. Kohn 56 l frun T. Murley with attachmnt [
j 2. Undated Typewritten write-up of Failure to 2 j 4
Perform Adequate Shutdown Margin ;
i Calculation TAvh to Near Miss ;
Inadvertent criticality ;
i
! i j 3. Undated Typewritten notes of technical 3 !
- violations i l 4. Undated Handwritten notes 2 l l
! 5. Urxbted Listing of Audio Tapes Provided 6 !
2 by Mosbaugh i
, 6. Undated Listing of Audio Tapes Provided 6 j
by Mosbaugh with handwritten notations i i
i j 7. Undated Statenent Excerpts frun Tape 54 l j pertinent to various individuals i
- 8. Undated Mosbaugh Tape Excerpts 86 i 9. Undated Statsmnts Pertinent to VB3P EDG 26 Problems Sorted Chronologically i
j 10. Undated Excerpt from AIM Tapes 1 l 11. Undated Descriptive Dialogue of Tape 57 & 58 15
- 12. Undated Descriptive Dialogue of Tape 58 7
! 13. Undated Excerpts frun 'Ihpe No.147 18 9 ,
i
- 14. Undated Excerpts frun Tape No.168 4 j i l
- 15. Undated Excerpts frun Tape No. 200 2
- 16. Undated Excerpts frun Tape Ib. 205 6 4
- 17. Undated Excerpts frun Tape No. 212 4
}
j 18. Undated Excerpts frun Tape No. 245 2 l
i 1- '
- 19. Undated Open Iten Trackirx3 Systen 1 4
1
Re: POIA-94-208 APPEI0IX A (cattinued)
RBONDS BEI!G PIACED INIO 'IHB F[R UHR 'DE ABWE REUBST MNBBR ID EBR IPGE IESGIPI'I(N PAGBS
- 20. Undated Unsigned letter to USNRC fmn W. G. 3 Hairstan, III, with attachments
- 21. Undated Unsigned letter to USIRC fmn W. G. 12 Hairstan, III, with attachnents
- 22. Undated Draft of LER 90-006, Revisian 0 11
- 23. Undated Diesel Testing 1A and 1B re 4 Overhaul and Inspection and Special Testing
- 24. Undated Typewritten Ibte to L. Robinson 2 fmn A. Mosbaugh
- 25. Undated Typewritten Ibte to L. Robinson 1 fmn A. Mosbaugh
- 26. Undated Note to Larry with attachment 7 fmn A. Mosbaugh 1
i
- 27. Undated Ibte to sent to Larry Robinsan 3 I
l fmn A. Mosbaugh with attachrent 1
- 28. Undated Note to sent to Iarry Robinson 3 fmn A. Mosbaugh with attachmnts i
- 29. Undated Note to Larry Robinson fmn A. 74 1 Mosbaugh with attachnsits
- 30. Undated Note sent to Lany Robinson fmn 72 l A. Mosbaugh with attachments
- 31. Undated Typewritten Allegation to IRC Attn: 19 Bruno Uryc, Allegations Coordinator, fmn A. L. Mosbaugh re: Georgia Power /SOtOPCD Respanse to 2.206 j Petition is Lies, Snuke, and Mirrors '
- 32. Undated Telecopy Request Sheet to L. Robinson 1 fmn Stephen Echn without attached DOL Order Granting Motion to Ccnpel (attachment outside scope of Itgaest)
- 33. Undated Georgia Power Organization Charts 6
Re: POIA-94-208 APP 90IX A (aantinued)
RBERDS IEIN3 PIACHD INIO 'IHB HR TJ0ER 'DE ABOVE xmuuteir NLMER NLMER DNIE D ES G IP TIC N PAGES
- 34. Undated Questians for the IRC - General 6 Questians an the Obligation of NRC Licensees to Provide Accurate Information to the NRC
- 35. Undated Facsimile Transmittal Sheet to B. 3 Hayes fran L. Robinson, with attached Declaration of L. L. Robinson
- 36. Undated Facsimile Transmittal Sheet to 6 C. Barth fran L. Robinson with attachmnt
- 37. Undated Facsimile Transmittal Sheet to 20 D. Wheeler fran L. Robinson with attachment
- 38. Undated Facsimile Transmittal Sheet to 4 D. Wheeler from L. Robinson with attachment
- 39. Undated Note to J. Vorse from L. Robinson 2 Re: DOL Order Requiring Mosbaugh to Provide Vogtle Documents to Georgia ,
Power Co.
- 40. Undated Draft of informatian for subpoena 1
- 41. Undated Drafts of Letters to USNRC RII fran 10 Georgia Power - VB3P Clarificatian of Respanse to Canfirmation of Action i Iatter
- 42. Undated Allegation Review Panel Cover Sheet, 19 with attachment
- 43. Undated Allegation Review Panel Cover Sheet, 4 with attachment
- 44. Undated Prepared questians for Interviewees 12 by Interviewer
- 45. Various NRC IIT Transcript Review 5 I dates Sheets
~.
Re: POIA-94-208 AWBlD1X A (rrveiravvi)
MPEBR DEIE DES @IPTIQi PAGES
- 46. Varicxis NRC IIT Transcript Review 3 dates Sheets
- 47. Various Data re: Diesel Generator Shutdown 8 dates
- 48. Various Handwritten notes 25 dates
- 49. Various Handwritten Notes - Nightshift activity 2 dates
- 50. Various Handwritten Investigator's Ibtes 6 dates
- 51. Various Handwritten Investigator's Ibtes 42 dates
- 52. Various Handwritten Investigator's Notes 13 dates
- 53. Various Handwritten Investigator's Notes 130 dates
- 54. Varin Memorandum to Case File 4 dates
- 55. Various M=uunurlum to Case File 13 dates
- 56. Various Investigation Status Records 4 dates
- 57. Various Evidence / Property Custody 4 dates Documents
- 58. Various LER 1-90-004 38 dates
- 59. Various Copy of Envelope with enclosures 64 dates Nuclear Plant Maintenance Work Orders
- 60. Various Unit One D/G Trip Sensor History 2 dates (Sunmary)
Re: POIA-94-208 APPEROIX A (cant-iruvri)
RBIRDS BEDG PUGO INIO M W UHR THE ABOVE RBOUEST NGEBR
!UNR DME DESCRIPTI(N PAGES
- 61. Various Unit h o D/G Trip Sensor History 1 dates (Sumnary)
- 62. Various VEGP Data Sheet 1, Diesel Generator 6 dates Start Log
- 64. Various Georgia Power VEGP Unit 2 Cantrol Log 58 dates
- 65. Various VEGP Procedure 14980-1 29 dates
- 66. Various Table 1 - Diesel Generator IA and 2 dates Diesel Generator 1B
- 67. Various Newspaper articles 10 dates
- 68. Various Newspaper Items 6 dates
- 69. Various VEGP Briefing Package 17 dates
- 70. Various Handwritten Calendars for March 2 dates and April 1990
- 71. Various Excerpts from AU4 Tapes 19, 69, 8 dates and 71
- 72. Various 172 Subpoenas to various 38 dates individuals
- 73. 3/2 Telepine lessage for AIM frun 1 J. Kane
- 74. 08/77 USNRC Regulatory Guide 1.108 4
- 75. 04/06/80 Deficiency Card # 190-186 2 ,
ke: FOIA-94-208 APP 901X A (mnHruvvi)
RBOME BBDG PUK:ED INIO 'IHB HR UOBR 'IHB ABOVE REUERTT IDER N(PEER DE DRSGIPTICN PAGES
- 76. 07/02/84 Letter to all Licensees of Operating 22 Operating Reactors, Applicants for An Operating License, and Holders of Cbnstruction Permits with attachments fuxn Darrell G. Eisenhut
- 77. 03/27/87 Georgia Power Interoffice 4 Cbrrespandence with attachtent Re: Plant vogtle- Units 1 &2 ESF Actuations
- 78. 12/09/87 Letter to USNRC Docunent Control 3 Desk fran Georgia Power Re: Plant Vogtle - Unit 1, IRC Docket 50-424
- Operating License NPF Respanse to NRC Inspection Report
- 79. 01/88 Handwritten Investigator Note 9 with attachments
- 80. 01/27/88 letter to Georgia Power Conpany 4 fran NRC RII - Re: NRC Inspection Report No. 50-424/87-57
- 81. 04/12/88 Letter to Georgia Power catpany 3 fran NRC RII - Re: NRC Inspection Report No. 50-424/87-57 82, 12/13/88 VB3P Procedure No. 00400-C with 9 attachments
- 83. 12/14/88 Hanteritten write-up of Initial 3 Review of RER 88-0898
- 84. 04/11/89 Georgia Power Interoffice 1 Correspandence Re: Plant Vogtle- Units 1&2 Operations Surveillance Procedure
- 85. 05/11/89 VEGP Nuclear Operations Diesel 4 Generator Operating 103
- 86. 02/12/90 letter to A. L. Ibsbaugh frun A. 1 H. Dauby
Re: POIA-94-208 APPEROIX A (capHrud) i<m1m<us unG PINW1 INIO 'IHB HR I20ER 'IHB ABOVE xuuumir NLPEER MDEER DEIE DES 0tIPITQi PBGEi
- 87. 03/13/90 Georgia Power Interoffice 1 (brrespondence to GPC Plant Personnel frcxn G. Bockhold Jr. Re:
OI Interview Guidelines
- 88. 03/20/90 VEGP Event Report 6
- 89. 03/20/90 VEGP Event Team Report No. 1-90-003 346
- Ioss of Off-Site and On-Site Power (IE)
- 90. 03/20/90- VEGP Unit 1 Control Iogs 57 04/08/90
- 91. 03/22/90 Nuclear Plant Maintenance Work Order 14
- 92. 04/90 PRB Ctxment Feview Sheet - PRB-90-59 1
- 93. 04/90 Letter to Georgia Power Co. 1 frun S. D. Ebneter re: Cmpletian of Confirmatian of Action Intter ammitments
- 95. 04/03/90 George Power Interoffice 1 Correspandence Re: Calcon Temperature Switches from M. S. Briney to G. Bockhold, Jr.
- 96. 04/03/90 Excerpts from Tape No. 257 6
- 97. 04/09/90 letter to USNRC RII from Georgia 14 Powers, with attachment, Re: Vogtle Electric generating Plant Confirmation of Action Intter
- 98. 04/09/90 Ietter to S. D. Ebneter frtxn W. G. 32 Hairstan, III, with attachnents
Re: FOIA-94-208 APPBIOIX A (crmHrmwri)
ManaB IEIfG PIAOD INIO M PIR Il0ER 'ITE ABOVE FWYMP NLPEBR IDERE DM DBSOIPTKN PAGES
- 99. 04/09/90 Ietter to S. Ebneter frcm W. G. 4 Hairston, III - Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Confirmation of Action letter 100. 04/19/90 Ietter to US?RC Document Cantrol 2 Desk frcm W. G. Hairston, III - Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Licensec Event Report - Ioss of Offsite Power Leads to Site Area Bnergency 101. 04/19/90 Ietter to UStRC from Georgia Power 9 Co. - VEGP Licensee D/ent Report -
Ioss of Offsite Power leads to Site Area Bmrgency 102. 04/19/90 Letter to USIRC Document Cantrol 13 Desk, from Georgia Power Cmpany
- Re: Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Licensee Event Report -
Ioss of Offsite Power leads to Site Area Bmrgency, with attachment 103. 04/19/90 Faxed copy from A. bbsbaugh to L. 8 Robinson 'Ihe Definition of the Cmprehensive Test Program In Relation to Southern Nuclear's Material False Statsmnt 104. 04/19/90 Telecopy Cover Sheet with attach mnt 2 105, 04/30/90 Georgia Power Interoffice Memo frca 8 A. bbsbaugh to G. Bockhold with attachmnts I 106. 05/02/90 Ietter to Georgia Power Co. frcm 19 Wyle Laboratories, with attachment 107. 05/14/90 Ietter to USIRC Document Control Desk, 6 l
from Georgia Power Cmpany - Vogtle Electric Generating Plant - Corrective Actions for Site Breweucy l
l
j ,
h
! Re: POIA-94-208 ;
l
(
APPEROIX A (canHrnwri)
(
j xmu<uS NTIC PINun INIO 'IHB P[R 170ER 'IHE ABOVE Mii)UtSir NLDEER ]
NLDEER DME DESCRIPTICN PAGES 108. 05/14/90 Letter to USNRC finn Georgia Power 6 l Co. - Vogtle Electric Generating l
! Plant Corrective Actions for Site -
} Area Emergency with attach mnt 1 i
! 109. 06/13/90 Intter to L. Robinson frun M. Kohn 2 l i re: Masbaugh's 2/8/90 interview l' J
.110. 06/13/90 Letter to L. Robinson frun M. Ydin 5 1 with attachment ;
111. 06/14/90 Handwritten Investigator Note with 7
)
] attachment
- 112. 06/15/90 Management New Sumary Article 8 l frun Fulton County Daily Report i 113. 06/19/90 Handwritten Investigator Note with 11 i attachment l 114. 06/22/90 IEtter to USNRC Document Control Desk, 2
- from Georgia Power - Ra
- Vogtle
- Electric Generating Plant - Corrective Actions for Site Etergency f 115. 06/22/90 Letter to USNRC Document Control Desk 2 r frun W. G.Hairston, III Re
- VEGP l Special Report Valid diesel General
- Valid Diesel Generator Failure 316. 06/29/90 Georgia Power Interoffice Mano 11 j Re
- VEGP-Units 1&2 Special QA Audit 4 of Unit 1 Biergency Diesel Generator Starts-OP26-90/33 4- 117. 06/29/90 Intter to USNRC Docurtent Control 11 i Desk, frun Georgia Power - Re:
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant, I
Licensee Event Report - Ioss of Offsite Power Inads to Site Area Diergency J
118. 07/12/90 VEGP Plant Review Board Meeting 4 Minutes
)
i^ l
l Re: FOIA-94-208 APPBIOIX A (m+irm wa) i RBIRDS BEIN3 PLACED INIO 'I1E POR INJER 'ITE ABOVE R100EST IDEBR PUERR DBIE IESQIPIT(N EEES 119. 07/17/90 letter to USIEC Document Cantrol 6 Desk frun W. G. Hairstan, 'III, with attachment VB3P License Event Report Painting Activity Results in Inoperable Diesel Generator 120. 07/18/90 Investigative Interview of Allen 254 Mosbaugh 121. 07/19/90 Handwritten Note with attachment 10 122. 07/31/90 Letter to C. C. Miller frun W. C. 103 Ramsey with various attached documentation 123. 08/06/90 1RC Reactive Inspect'.on 1 124. 08/06/90 Georgia Pcwer Meeting Attendance 2 Record NRC Operational Assessnent Entrance 125. 08/07/90 Letter to USNRC Document Control 19 Desk, frun Georgia Power - Re:
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Special Report - Valid Diesel Generator Failures, with attachment 126. 08/16/90 Draft LER 1-90-004 25 127. 08/16/90 Chart of Area of GP Ctricerns 1 128. 08/17/90 Diesel Starts and Failure Reporting 3 129. 08/22/90 I.etter to Georgia Power Conpany 4 frun Inis Reyes, with attachment re:
Canfirmatian of Meeting - Enforcement Conference 130. 08/28/90 Georgia Power Interoffice Memo to G. 1 R. Frederick from C. C. Miller Re:
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Audit Finding OP 13-90/29- 430
Re: POIA-94-208 APPEPOIK A (otmtintal)
RBIRDS BEING PLAOD INIO WB PER U0ER ER ABOVE REURETT NWERR M MIBR DB;Di DESCRIPTICN PAGES 131. 08/29/90 Telecopy Cover Sheet with attachments 14 sent to L. Robinsan by A. Mosbaugh (Rcvd 6/13/91) 132. 08/30/90 Intter to S. Ebneter from W. G. 5 Hairstan, III - Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Clarificatian of Respanse to Confirmatian of Action Ietter 133. 09/11/90 Intter to Han. Kenneth M. Carr with 25 l attachments, fram M. Kahn l
134. 09/13/90 Fax frun OI to S. Kahn with attached 3 Declaratian of L. L. Robinson 135. 09/13/90 Fax from A. Mosbaugh to L. Robinson 1 Handwritten note without attached DOL letion for Protective Order (attachment outside scope of request) 136. 09/14/90 Typewritten Bibliogwydy of Doctments 39 137. 09/17/90 Office of the SECY Action Ticket, 2 without attachment 138. 09/26/90 GA Power Mano to File 1 139. 10/01/90 Letter to J. Schaudies from Bull & 1 Associates, without attached copy of Depositian of R. P. Mcdonald an 9/17/90 (attachment outside scope of request) 140, 10/01/90 Letter to Georgia Power Ca@any, 19 with attachment, frun Luis Reyes Re: Enforccment Canference Summary 141. 10/9/90 EDO Principal Correspandence Cantrol 1 Sheet without attachment 142. 11/01/90 Menorandum to J. Vorse fran S. Ebneter t,
- Request for Investigation
I i
I i
i* ;
I Re: POIA-94-208 APPEIOIX A (erreirmwi) ;
i 1 FM I Eqfi MTE PINE INIO 'IHB PN 00ER 'IHB ABOVE REDUEST MPBER i NWERR DEDE DESOIPTIGI PMRS 143. 11/06/90 OI Response to Status of D y est 1 [
} for Investigation l 1
! 144. 11/06/90 Investigative Plan 1 )
3 145. 11/06/90 OIMIS Data Entry Sheet 1 1
146. 11/28/90 biutcudum for Chairman Carr frun 1 i B. Hayes - Investigation Notification 147. 12/13/90 Mstorandum for J. Vorse frun Larry 4
[
i Robinson - Recuiw aiatian of Tapes l l for Transcriptian with attachtent ;
j
! 148. 01/10/91 Letter to UStRC Document Control 2 Desk frun W. G. Hairston, III I re: VEGP Additional Informatie an i' Diesel Generator Jacket Water
)
'Ibiperature 149. 01/11/91 Ietter to Georgia Power Canpany, 42
. from USIRC RII - Re: Vogtle Special Team Inspection and Notice of Violatian i (NRC Inspection Report Nos. 50-424/90-19 and 50-425/90-19 l!
- 150. 02/05/91 Niuscuuum for B. Hayes frun J. 2 4 Vorse - DOL Order i
i 151. 02/26/91 Intter to L. Robinson frun A. H. 2 Dcmby re: OI Ongoing Reviews at l
the VEGP i
j 152. 03/22/91 Letter to Larry Robinsan frun M. Kohn 1
) 153. 03/26/91 Handwritten Investigator Note with 2 i attached fax fran M. Kohn to L.
i' Robinson without attached DOL Deposition of A. H. Domby & R. P. t
- i. Mcdonald (attachnent outside scope l
of request)
I 154. 05/28/91 Handwritten note with attachment 12 I
i
i
~
f i
l Re: POIA-94-208 APPEIOIX A I (erreirmwri) {
EEDRE BEDC PINE INIO 'mE PDR UtGR 'mE ABOVE xmAmt N0 PEER .
IDER DE DESTIFI'I(N PEGEi j 155. 06/19/91 Meno to J. Vorse fmn S. Ebneter - 30 Re: Adckndum to RII Request for Investigation No. RII-90-12 Georgia l Power Ocupany, Vogtle Electric Generating Plant with attachnent i
156. 07/08/91 Intter to Ivan Selin Chairman and 108 Mr. James M. Taylor frun Michael D.
Kahn with attachments Re: Aimsults to Petiticners Marvin Hobby's and Allen itsbaugh's September 11, 1990 i Petitian; and Response to Georgia ;
Power Ocupany's April 1,1991 1 Subnissian by its Executive Vice l President, Mr. R. P. Mcdonald 157. 07/23/91 t4mo to Chris VanDenburgh, Vendor 56 Inspection Branch, fran Luis A.
Reyes, Director Division of Reactor Projects - Re: Vogtle Special Team Inspection 158. 10/03/91 Letter to L. R&inson fran A. Domby 2 159. 10/03/91 Iatter to William C. Parler fran 3 A. H. Damby Re: Nuclear Regulatory Comnissian Office of Investigatians' Subpoenas Issued to Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Biployees 1
160. 10/04/91 Ietter to FBI fran Ben B. Hayes 1 161. 10/16/91 letter to A. Damby fran W. C. Parler 1 Re: Subpoenas 162. 11/01/91 Letter to Georgia Power Canpany 35 fran RII, with attachments, Re:
Vogtle Special team Inspection Report Nos. 50-424, 425/90-10 ,
Supplement 1 l I
163. 11/04/91 Typewritten note to UStRC (Attn. 3 Bruno Uric, Allegations Cbortlinator i frun A. Mosbaugh ll
. .. ~ . . . - - . . . . . _ . . . - . . - - - - . . . . . . . . - - -...
. i i
Re: POIA-94-208 i
APPEtOIX A (cxxitimed)
RB0306 BRIN 3 PIAOD INIO 'IHB PIR 120ER 'ITE ABOVE RBOUBST NWEER IDJilE DB2B LESCRIPTICN PAGES l
164. 01/15/92 Letter to Arthur Dmtrf fran Larry 1 $
Robinson ,
1 165. 07/28/92 Letter to D. M. Shapiro from M. D. 1 Kahn - Re: Mosbaugh v Georgia Power Conpany :
166. 07/29/92 Letter to M. Kohn frun B. Hayes 1-Re: Mosbaugh v. Georgia Power Co. ,
167. 08/09/92 Radio'IV Reports, Inc. Nuclear Power 3 Plant Whistleblower ;
i 168. 08/23/92 Letter to Bryan Lavine frun J. Vorse 1 169. 01/21/93 Facsimile Transmittal Sheet with 2 attachment - Newspaper Iten ;
170. 06/14/93 Diesel Generator 1B and 1A for Unit 1 6 ,
171. 07/06/93 Letter to Honorable Joseph I. Lieberman 1 frun K. C. Rogers 172. 07/19/93 Handwritten note with attachnent 2 173. 07/27/93 Letter to John Lamberski frun J. 2
, Vorse s
- 174. 07/27/93 Letter to Richard Hendrix frun J. 2 Vorse 4
l 175. 07/27/93 Letter to Bruce Kirwan frun J. 2 Vorse 176. 07/27/93 Letter to Bruce Morris frun J. 2 Vorse i 177. 08/04/93 Iatter to J. Y. Vorse frun B. 4 J
Lavine Re: IRC Office of
. Investigations 178. 08/14/93 Memo for Personal Files - D. B. 2 Matthews Re: Vogtle Meetings re Managatent Concerns 4
9
- h s
k r
i i .
Re: POIA-94-208 i APPEROIX A (rrmH rnwri) .
RIKIRDS BEDG PINm INIO 'IHE HR 12 OBR 'IHB ABOVE xajutbT NLPEBR NLDERR DNIE DhSTIPTICN PAGES 179. 08/26/93 tiemo to File fran J. Vorse 1 l 180. 09/20/93 Intter to Larry Robinscn frun Arthur 4 !
Damby
- 181. 10/06/93 Ietter to L. Robinson from Arthur 1 l 182. 11/05/93 E-mail fran D. Hood to R. K. 1 l Hoefling Re: IIT Supporting Docs j 183. 05/10/94 1RC Office of Public Affairs 1 [
Atlanta - Ikus Release !
184. 05/10/94 Georgia Power Co. Update Response to 1 l tRC Action 185. 06/09/94 Meno to J. Johnson frun P. Skinner 4 Re: Calcon Switches at Vogtle During l Bnergen",r Event l l
i l
d 4 Re: POIA-94-208 l APPIDOIX B t i
Ktstu<uS PARTIAILY W1'HGED NIFBER DiUE DESTIFITCN & EKIDEFFI(N PAGE
- 1. Undated Typed document beginning with 1
"(Exhibit 9) presented to IRC j
- i by Bockhold an April 9"
. EK. 5-Predecisicmal
- i i 2. Undated Case Briefing - VEGP - Alleged False 3 Statanents Regarding Operability of !
- Diesel Generator EK. 5-Pr*inimal
- 3. Undated OI typed Sunmary of GPC personnel 5 ,
~
1 testinony EK. 5-Predecisicmal t
- 4. Various Handwritten Investigator's Notes 45
- dates EK. 5-Predecisional ;
- 5. Various Handwritten Investigators Notes 12 ;
i dates EK. 5-Attorney / client, Pr*inianal t
- 6. 12/19/91 Case Brief - Plant Vogtle for NRC 13 l Staff by OI:RII EK. 5-Pr*inimal l i
e I Memo to J. Johnson frun P. Skinner 12 i 7. 07/23/92 s
- Assessment of Vogtle Tape Review EK. 5-Predecisicmal i
- 8. 143torandum tc, S. Ibneter frun P. 18
- 10/06/92 Skinner - Analysis of EDG Information Provided by GPC in the Original and i Revised Responses to LER 90-06 and the Confirmatian of Action Letter Re Vogtle Site Area Biergency of I March 20,1990 EK 5-Predecisional
. 9. 04/29/93 Case Brief - Plant Vogtle for 19 i Senator Joseph I. Lieberman &
Staff by NRC OI EK. 5-PreSeeisicmal i
l I
f
_ _, _ , _ _ , . _ l
Re: FDIA-94-208 APPH OIX C REDRDS PARTIAILY WI'I1DELD DESCRIPTIOJ & EGMPITCN P!GES J
Nr1F2 IEIB
- 1. Various Hardaritten Notes EX. 7C 5 dates 1.etter to A. Masbaugh fran G. R. 3
- 2. 03/09/93 Jenkirs EX. 6
+
Re: POIA-94-208 APPBIOIX D RBJERS_2GBLLX_MHED NGESR DhTE DESOUPTION & EKEMPTIN EM
- 1. Undated Excerpt frun Unit 1 - Control Iog 3 EK. 5-PWinimal s
- 2. Undated Facts to Elicit from Bockhold 3 EK. 5-Attomey work product !
Draft of NRC Subpoena 1 I
- 3. Undated EK. 5-Pr*inimal
- 4. Undated Draft nemotcusinn for O. DeMirancia frun 5 P. Skinner - Allegation RII-90-0092, Violations of 'Ibchnical Specifications EK. 5-Predecisimal
- 5. Various Mmorandum to Case File 10 dates EK 5-Attorney / client, Predecisimal
- 6. Various Case Chronology 52 dates EK. 5-PrEdecisimal !
- 7. Various Portions of Case Chronology 6 dates re Ocmamications with Alleger EK. 5-Predtr.isimal
- 8. 10/22 Suggested Questions for Mosbaugh 3 EK. 5-Attorney / client, Attorney work product
- 9. 08/07/91 Mmorandum for B. Hayes frun J. A. 11 Fitzgerald and J. F. Cbrdes Re:
Exclusion of Attorneys in the Matter of Georgia Power Ocupany Investigation with attachments EK. 5-Attorney / client, Attorney work proinct, Pr*inimal & 7E
- 10. 10/01/91 Mmorandum for D. B. Matthews frun 1 J. Y. Vorse - Disposition of Vogtle l Allegations EK. 5-Pr*inimal l
- 11. 04/06/92 biuscudum co File frun S. Vias - 15 l Vogtle Special Team Inspection !
EK. 5-Prudacisimal l l
l 4
I
L l..
\
Re: POIA-94-208 ,
I l APPSDIX D '
(crneirmwa)
I RBOWDS 'IUPALLY WTD5HD NWBER DM DESOIPTRN & EXilMPTIgi PAGES [
- 12. 02/10/93 Memorandum for J. Thylor fran W. 7 l Parler Re: Allen Mosbaugh v. Georgia i Power Co., Case Nos. 91-ERA-1, !
91-ERA-11 (October 30, 1992) with -
attachrent EK. 5-Attamey/climt, i Attorney work W l
- 13. 02/12/93 Marorandum for B. Hayes frun J. A. 2 i l Fitzgerald Re: Fifth Aiedrelt i Assertian EK. 5-Attorney / client, ;
Attorney wodc pruitet, Pr*inimal !
& 7E ;
- 14. 03/02/94 E-mail from M. Young to Duke Wheeler 1 i Re: Missing Tapes BK. 5-Attorney /
client j 1
i l
l l
1 i
,.l