ML20199J978
| ML20199J978 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 12/22/1998 |
| From: | Skinner P NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II) |
| To: | Beasley J SOUTHERN NUCLEAR OPERATING CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9901260301 | |
| Download: ML20199J978 (13) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:., ; I I l l- I December 22, 1998 l Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc.
- ATTN
- Mr. J. B. Beasley, Jr., Vice President i
P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham, AL 35201-1295 l
SUBJECT:
MEETING
SUMMARY
- DISCUSSION OF SEISMIC CLIP INSTALLATION AT THE VOGTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT - DOCKET NOS. 50-424 AND 50-425
Dear Mr. Beasley:
l This refers to the December 9,1998, meeting held to discuss the installation of seismic clips on Cutler-Hammer electrical circuit breakers at the Vogtle Electric Generating Plant. I have enclosed a list of attendees and a copy of the slides that were used during this meeting. in accordance with Section 2.790(a) of the NRC's " Rules of Practice," Part 2, Title 10, Code of Federal Regulations, a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be placed in the NRC Public l Document Room. l l No reply to this letter is required. However, if you have any questions concerning this matter, 1 please contact me at 404-562-4520. Sincerely, I (Original signed by Pierce H. Skinner) l Pierce H. Skinner, Chief i l Reactor Projects Branch 2 Division of Reactor Projects Docket Nos. 50-424,50-425
- License Nos. NPF-68, NPF-81 l
Enclosures:
- 1. List of Attendees i 2. Licensee Presentation Handouts l
cc w/encts: J. D. Woodard Executive Vice President I Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc. E P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham, AL 35201-1295 cc w/encls continued: See page 2
- .- 260014 9901260301 9fs1222 PDR j ADOCK 05000424 4
P pop
o j l SNC. 2 l l l t L i' l cc w/encls: Continued
- J. T. Gasser - !
l General Manager, Plant Vogtle l Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc. l l- P. O. Box 1600
- l. Waynesboro, GA 30830 l- . J. A. Bailey
! Manager-Licensing h
' Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc. ,
. P. O. Box 1295 i
Birmingham, AL 35201-1295 l Director, Consumers' Utility Counsel Division l . Governor's Office of Consumer Affairs i f 2 M. L. King, Jr. Drive
- Plaza Level East; Suite 356 l: Atlanta, GA 30334-4600 I
L Office of Planning and Budget Room 6158 270 Washington Street, SW Atlanta, GA 30334 l L Office of the County Commissioner
- i. Burke County Commission -
Waynesboro, GA 30830
- Director, Department of Natural Resources I-205 Butler Street, SE, Suite 1252 Atlanta, GA 30334 i
- < Manager, Radioactive Materials Program l Department of Natural Resources L 4244 International Parkway
- i. ' Suite 114 - )
L Atlanta, GA 30354 l i 1
- l. Attorney General l Law Department l- 132 Judicial Building i Atlanta, GA 30334
( [_ ~cc w/encls continued: See page 3 h i U 4 l ! i 2 t m ; i I I 1
. m. .- -_ . .. _ . __. _ _ _ _ _ _. _ __ _ . _._ - -, _- - .-.
- e ,
s i- SNC' 3 l cc w/encis: Continued i Program Manager l Fossil & Nuclear Operations
'Oglethorpe Power Corporation l 2100 E. Exchange Place Tucker, GA 30085-1349 j Charles A. Patrizia, Esq.
Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker j
.10th Floor i 1299 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, D. C. 20004-9500 l '
Senior Engineer- Power Supply i Municipal Electric Authority ! of Georgia ; 1470 Riveredge Parkway NW l ! Atlanta, GA 30328-4684 i ( l Distribution w/encis: ) i L. Plisco, Ril l D. Jaffe, NRR l PUBLIC NRC 3enior Resident inspector l
' U.S. Nudear Regulatory Commission 8805 River Road Waynesboro, GA 30830 <
'l l
I OFHCE RH:DRP j MTURE pg NAME C Rapp Wt DATE 12/\% % 12/ /98 12/ /98 12/ /98 - 12/ 198 12/ /98 12/ /98 COPY? YES (NO) YEs NO YES No YEs NO YEs NO YEs No YEs NO I OFFICIAL REbD COPY DOCUMENT NAME: P:WTGSUM.129 l i a j>
1 . 1 1 1 LIST OF ATTENDEES NRC V. McCree, Deputy Division Director, Division of Reactor Safety (DRS) K. Landis, Chief, Engineering Branch, DRS N. Merriweather, Senior Reactor Inspector, Engineering Branch, DRS W. Rogers, Senior Reactor Analyst, DRS L. Plisco, Division Director, Division of Reactor Projects (DRP) P. Skinner, Chief, Reactor Projects Branch 2, DRP J. Zeiler, Senior Resident inspector, Vogtle Electric Generation Station, DRP LICENSEE S. Kitchens, General Manager, Support, Vogtle, Southern Nuclear Operating Company (SNOC) G. Hooper, Engineering Supervisor, SNOC A. Prestifilippo, Maintenance Team Leader, SNOC B. Whitley, Licensing Engineer, Vogtle, SNOC D. Lloyd, Project Engineering Manager - Vogtle, Southern Company Services B. Goforth, Equipment Qualification, Southern Company Services Public B. Hausner, Staff Attorney, Consumers Division, State of Georgia Enclosure 1
AGENDA DECEMBER 9,1998 MEETING WITH NRC REGION ll- ATLANTA, GA
- Overview of Problem...................... Skip Kitchens e Demonstration of Seismic Clip and Latch Arrangement.......................... Greg Hooper
- Discussion of Effect on Seismic Q u alificatio n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... Dale Lloyd
- Scope of Components Affected........ Brian Whitley e Root Cause & Corrective Actions...... Tony Prestifilippo !
I Fhclosure 2
Attachment . File: 98-VAA002
. Log: SG-16614 Page 2 of 4 Configuration Top Bottom Top Bottom Top Bottom Comments Right Left Right Right Left Left Latch Latch Clip Clip Clip Clip K x x x x Remains Functional y
L x x x x Remains Functional
, . sa 2: 9 . . .e . -a .
M x x x x x Remains Functional
. . .r > ;; ,
a. i N x x x x x Remains Functional O x x x x x Remains Functional 7 , , P x x x x x Remains Functional - . _ . _ 7 y, :e .~.? , n .,, .. . O x x x x x Remains Functional
;r , mn, .3 .
R x x x x x Remains Functional S x x x x Remains Functional T x x x x Remains Functional ! a op '
,, ,. .: ma..i < '
U x x x Indeterminate - Assume Not Functional (contacts may chatter or breaker trip) X denotes properly installed i T.\REA\98VA A002\SGt 6614. DOC
h I l 4 . A
! ?
I q -
- 3. ' .
{- .b l a ;f, I 1 .. e ,. . l- g f-[t, l'- N
~
3' N1 >, ykr '- l %' { - < % j: :' 7 s i
'M 9 %
g gg '
,g,,. ,,
r;Yyb s% , - J': i . ., , . < rig ? , ,.
. , ' As. yn g% . 3
.;-~.. .
3, J.T lks, 5 yg [e
.q y.l
. - $Z ?. Jy ajeu.,., / .~ f?I" 5. y [-(
$ [$,i l"
,a ,
l lU
+
h 3s mjy u uql* ';:? ,, y '.f^ }' 5,-l- -l A **lq f.t ., w n 9 7. ' vy. . x;
.c f- Dd
.M{ y ".
e 12 0 ** s iR.;?" u .
.e f: k
.t J!!
yf _ 4 ..
-, ,eo
*"/".-
't, i *
. $ 3 .-
}'. ' '
- l. 15 , . e,
~
I' y ^; , k, -
.g f . , .
- 7[.
&1 "NI). ' ,.* [H '.
e ., t TL . j
.m ,,,42,, -
y5e,AA.aa ---s._,__ , a ..mm.---m, -,,4_m-- a.mm,u.s x,amumr_s, aa - - - -~- ---
\
\ i \ . c g' kn n i p.s., 1 y.- 6_ ' , p1 \. D. e@ [ p
- g .'
8 i m,~. t
? gas g $c
" rl?]>
v . n t \
\ k sts ng:. .
iii I1!
)x i 1 i!!_. ..
\
,} !
\ ;!! 11 }. :
.:Q ,
\ .<
, a\
k ( ,.- \ f.. % ,
~\
y~ $ifh_
.\ !t 9.n g .
g _. ~ . _- , f ? ;
, .r ..
i rl;-~ ?; i o (c;' , c
. l, l',l ,c {
^
ec .Ws;e-
\
$[f'
~
W , Sih53 ~ i pg?ft ' n I V e
. e~ .c E
( : l - i . t//. p
'dl .
,Q a
-[* , , , .
<., i
)'-{
~ _,
t 3.: .
-n
\ ,. m
1 l
.; i -
1
., ! .3 j 7 i. ,
,I
~I. hj ,.
/
e'.. rv . A. h
'}"
. .r ,
.h .,
n :. , [ . e Aer "$ $ .
$^
j t% j J. ). .
,..; $22'd T y *! -
b W! TL .E % ....,.'4,f3h :. .m Qi. . l47 '- I mmm" ' mw m-pvMt,. y;. ,y m: . yg ._x+ - i w-8 1.. . Q _ ' ,_. '.'.._,; . = . - . .- !
-.~. g..,..... n -- ;
%w ~ c .:. , ..
-'1 l.:;4%Wn;i
~ .;
i
@ll 3, .
.4 6 ;.;.- -
g.fu.3 .~ :3.. 3
.. ., i
}l 5 s 'A $'*
) .
. u.. e .
l,
- =
i LV - 7 .; _ ;" +..
. : . . ,f
' l jg, O g. '- M .i . ..
I ;Y Q,, ,.?'[ .
! [
htN [w$.:, . ? I.- h.kf i h , g kgl__ y, ;
~
, sm .
,s
- g l
V ' (_.. r. l;
;I-I ' : mge , 3M -
n
)fp . ll
'a
,t . 4 , 3 ~
A t,I i . . .
.i
.h
' .J,.
' <s'y. -
p. l'. - e.-
-s;
. h- *
.5 .g ' a . .
~
1 . . ,/ ,
.~
~
1 O. q,, .' . *w.' .
~ J ;'i 2 ;
m _ _
'k l/
. ,ghk0 5 a
=
-ammzfi
;, :p .
; i-. ;
[h-f;(i,@ aIl - - c . , . . , i}!j7g;[ N".7h.h ir_ - - YY 2$p%n,t. yn$s i :. ) 7 M MR;iO5?S<. .;1 ,y; Is. m esw - g ;. t r,%g $~7 (; 'l ' I ?jkk$ U A{!l$f;;;*il me NGMMi% s .
". go E ; -
'* A'
? , ftl
- S w- v w.fi@ w/.)@
.s.o ,. t i 'O wf,{e;fS
- - W w-
,;c y ,
. ;,y j
u' o z :g i . D" C t1TI ER - F-
., =:.g}5'%@ [ Q ,
h s!" ROL ' -
~
~
..$!.3%.% ~
l;hhDbb .N5Ml 1.ya . 4 n -:- rs\, - ..,.. ,
; L.yj k :sj.
yl90 t Q . 1 W3
.ux, c; -
g-
?'y I )F '
- a. _. .
Ib n :,ix
'gg '
- w. .
f *,$,' y) -
. 5 ym .i
*1h$$ '
m;w a ;- h350.2.),., , . . 1 p e *
+i I a e:Ma ,
th. i;Q spe h$
- ha .-
^
i
,. ' ; G :. ; }f g - Q Q.:y fM ?{ G y Qq. , .
;;; i n
.' v ,; s-[p. :4 :mcs v Nt 3};%?';f.+yl3,?g 3,;+,,':'f}g:g; y
uma
.: y I ',. a f, .. [1.f <q.;.gp .a.a.4 m j'
y, Mione !?@[jff
mm . ,
a 4 2. 3
.4
'!. (N5' ,
y papf
- .i O.V.sk75 d Eg d h"d '" - 3if#-
y .. .
,, . ;L c
~j em
.MI f r
9
' ;;' ij)7@'4
.vgy '
... 1 f' l}
(fQ s
- f,,
,, w
{f 3'v'j' fdf@ i * ,, B i , f. .
] t
'A A *
.. t $
.. . ..* _ $. .j'l"
., , ..k 'f.
- f. E r-J, e Ic5'hff i _.
- c. e i I
);
.c h
- - s 4
m8ng 2: MM.
.. s"~
< ']
f Ij ' t [ f ff,{gpg{ gj x. cn n> Av g+ > ga 5 { - p% spa:n g i t o O I- v ' o ,M i g - %. 8
'1
%y)$% '
^
~^ ',_
M W:. .. d: :Wt19 f 4
;q
{k,q
+ ~ - l['}m}t M(&.'&a : -
**2%;% \
b M is
. .+
- n. ;
;. .; gN M ky:6 C"f.Qc. '
w. u Y f'.. kxy m .< ng*ku
'.; -:j. W ~~
'?
5j m4 ; ... ^ua. Q>x A,;.19n~
+, p$j g.;yg Y .; . e n, ,*
p Q{' . .-l ^ l i=.Q.. .',f~.ff g: '
~' _
'} ' ,
., q '
y' lV" $$.
%nll gp @w;p@'e.Q e , - -
- g ~
h., -
- -j
;.f '3 W
7-9 3ppeg,ps" f.
.g :. ';;. *4 bb ,2 s? Sysq[q[f y ,.;4
- WQ &rf -
) [If :k
,z, A.,g:
i < yq w;g .e g , gs,4; 4
' . . '4{p~gn, m L..
e I y .. t . , ,,U-fd*;$-:w.<.s s f mp ,
$e,.*',y); MN.,YIh,flhg .
.r.
U, f h
.F A llk..
'4
- 23 <
."' -% . -w$$rQ1 gYJw,
'h {. !. b$f J' Q , lC ".' M 0 @ v ..
w.emo(hl o
', I '!.. &,'N/G as E. m
, e
-}
m,,., j 1;: 3I 5
}$. .w[:-c.:.~. '.b 3 7. b 9 pq e; g
- 3. m.
y3 ug Ny
] y.p.*Tg ess
. _ . - - . - ._.._a ...-a_.m-----_es--mn_maau,.asu.~.,., --._.-,,--.xmuss.mx.m.s aa a u, sw.1--- --1.-.a_m..
'y 2 gL -
5
$4 yfM er
* [ 5k
?
d!jP*
,R io( h. . .s !
i .7 .
,A l
i
.o... '
l FJ Be. l i j
--ur- ,~7.- .
1 J!B / et c til0 ~ l l j ET
^ ny.y.['q,z,- 3;~ .-
.s ,
~
.w .
if 3 ', e.- ' 14- _g . .!.* , OC er
, :1; m ,
7
*y g
, i",.,
- M k
l W . .g ' : $ ]
- # Ybn .
1 .. .. - . . . . . . . . -._ _. .. ~ . _ - . . - . - . _ _ - _ . . . _ - . . .
y h hhfffff b Yg W % m]
.n.
?fQ Ni ? ' Q We y..
': yy~f g[%* {gc.Y:W u a M M g gp [i %
,e qfrer Q" m/.y}"lnr;* y r % g ;;. kg s"42MT;f*aggg
,. g%gy
&y .
. .. - n~ .
4+ 9~.,l. pMyyw m n k.s t gy n gu . lat E: _ m% _. -~ q W~-. += - .---,: ~. .- a. . . . ca.u . . tb;. p ,9 a
- : _ ~'
A *:
'A .
, .:i4 %
y[w&
.n-i.- Q;a~ .4 ,g t , _
l f f*.s ',' ,i/ ,
- s-3 g ,%, N
;+ - :p .'jn - c :
-- no _ .
.,h 3g % :,,s . . .
i.k 'p ';h m!. n
. ym p- ~.w1 n 0 -W:
p' ,?-
=-
W & %.. ?M. -C -
. . . s , , , , .
a 3 . a . ~-
- t. -
- h. ,
i
/ o., . , _
n. l-yl . q I. * .. ; ' ~'.. 'tw :. e, _ l j
.[,- .
i
- 1 4
i.
- ', . ') e
.'~. .
' I',f .
;pg
~
f ,
- j. : 14, . .4 j- . , . . . .
'l '.
~ '
E
};
. 5,...
2 -
"U' . .>
I 1
-[h gh) -
' ',: .[. .
i *' x :. O } !'Jf : 3 - x - . . ; J .> \ . - >;3 e .
, .m. g a .g.:i x,, .
%, . 4.y. .
.-.s m'
- f m . .,me* E.
c ' -
.s-
.. ., m ..
E .
._ =
- m. @],
~ $.
'~
A%&[ $'r Q4Q. , e i m- l l_. y,? y;. - C., ::. } _ I
.' s.;
? . ,
Y .4
,^-'l<.
_, _ ~': st W),;,y l gy -.', .* ?4 ..
/nhj . . ,
.. s2,t!I % -.
. + X.1 c. .
'aJM NO.1 q y;, g 1 _.. ;
3
. :. : . c . , , . x.: : , .;
- m. ,
4 ~ * ~
./ , . < ~ ...#
.m. :-- . .,,, f- l.y-
" *] s ~l *d , ,
4 ' f,,) e 5j *i J . . N.~,b N5w:~ w[f.
,.s - w.. i.,,My g i49:.[.a 3l1/.9 /,
,. y cp ;. , ;3 y;,,,.j *
[7 g,, J
' t .e . . ,u
_ _ - ,}}