ML20206U465

Summary of Telcon Interview W/Allegers Re Technical Review Team Disposition of Allegations AC-22 & AC-23 Concerning Category 2 of Civil/Structure Sser

ML20206U465
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	07/07/1986
From:	Jeng D NRC
To:	NRC
Shared Package
ML19284C882	List: IR 05000445/1984005 ML20204J047 ML20204J151 ML20204J162 ML20204J174 ML20205B090 ML20206U369 ML20206U374 ML20206U380 ML20206U384 ML20206U389 ML20206U396 ML20206U403 ML20206U408 ML20206U412 ML20206U417 ML20206U422 ML20206U429 ML20206U435 ML20206U441 ML20206U445 ML20206U452 ML20206U456 ML20206U465 ML20206U478 ML20206U484 ML20206U491 ML20206U500 ML20206U506 ML20206U507 ML20206U513 ML20206U518 ML20206U524 ML20206U529 ML20206U533 ML20206U537 ML20206U544 ML20206U546 ML20206U551 ML20206U555 ML20206U559 ML20206U564 ML20206U572 ML20206U579 ML20206U588 ML20206U592 ML20206U600 ML20206U603 ML20206U607 ML20206U620 ... further results
References
FOIA-85-59 NUDOCS 8607100496
Download: ML20206U465 (2)

Text

-

qq 23 ,c MEMORANDUM FOR: File FROM: D. C. Jeng

SUBJECT:

m uov oc ELEPHONE INTERVIEW WITH ALLEGER 5 s

~

~ _

1. Interview ,

At ~-

a telephone interview was held.

The attencees were:

D. Jeng, R. Philleo, R. C. Tang, and the recorder.

Upon introduction of participants' names, title, responsibilities and work experience, the TRT reviewer Mr. Philleo explained in great detail the basis for TRT's disposition of Allegations AC-22 and AC-23 (Category 2 of Civil / Structure SSER). Basic approach used by TRT was to randomly pick 23 packages of concrete placement records and examine any irregularities or non-conformance reports. Fifteen non-conformance reports were identified and disposed of adequately according to established procedures. The alleger was also informed that TRT staff's field inspection trip showed no degradation of concrete. Two QC inspectors interviewed also confirmed that necessary procedures were followed in placing concrete during the period they were directly involved.

The alleger felt that TRT has correctly interpretedWdoncern and has ~

adequately resolved the concern. A copy of SSER wiTl be sent te as a basis for closing the allegations. M agreed to have the

~

transcript of the interview made available to the public.

2. Interview with _

A a telephone interview was held withh

_In attendance were:

D. Jeng, R. Phillio, C. Hofmayer, R. C. Tang, W. P. Chen, R. Masterson, V. Ferrarini and i

the reporter.

With reaard to AQC-13, AOC-14, AC-18 and AC-40, C. Hofmayer explained to the steps' taken by TRT to resolve M concerns. It appears that the concerns were clearly and correctly interpreted by the TRT.

However, the alleger did not agree to the bases and conclusions drawn by TRT on the number of unauthorized holes drilled and number of unauthorized rebars cut. E suggested some other approach to the TRT. Upon review of g suggelition, TRT reviewer will propose needed followup actions.

With regard to AC-31 related to hanger inserts, Mr. Philleo (TRT reviewer) explained the basis for TRT resolutions. The phone communication was rather difficult at times to carry on an effective dialogue. In essence, did not agreet to TRT resolution at the end of the interview.

Parties agfa d that the item will be f3110wed up further, possibly in a direct neeting. ,

,, s 8607100496 860624 PDR FOIA GARDE 85-59 PDR s

i

/

)

O I. ,

i

, indicated that AC-36 (Trash dumped in the bottcm of a form and covered by concrete) concern was not originated byllEEEE TRT retracted the item from the discussion. The item will be follows'd up elsewhere.

AC-43 was not idised because of the agreement that a second meeting will be scheduled to handle all unresolved issues.

Based on the phone conversation, the Civil / Structural staff came to a con-clusion that the next meeting should be a direct meeting and should involve an option of a joint plant trip between TRT reviewers and the alleger. This point was conveyed to R. C. Tang for her followup.

Another impression obtained through the interview is that the closure of issues with allegers will be a tedious, time consuming effort and one should not underestimate both the time and resources needed for this task.

C. Hofmayer and R. Philleo will work with D. Jeng by 11/5/84 to define specific steps to be taken on the above issues.

D. C. Jeng cc: L. Shar

,