ML20206U620

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Partially Withheld Ltr Expressing Appreciation for Allowing Technical Review Team Opportunity to Discuss Concerns Re Facility.Forwards Transcript.Ser Will Be Forwarded.W/O Encl
ML20206U620
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 02/11/1985
From: Noonan V
NRC - COMANCHE PEAK PROJECT (TECHNICAL REVIEW TEAM)
To:
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
Shared Package
ML19284C882 List: ... further results
References
FOIA-85-59 NUDOCS 8607110040
Download: ML20206U620 (5)
v • d • e


Text

.. _ - _ __ _

, a s aseg'o UNITED STATES a y o NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

{ $ WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555

  • ..../ FEB 111985

\

l 7c Thank you very muchifor al owing our Technical Review Team members the opportu-nity to meet with y6u on to discuss concerns you raised regarding the Coma che eak facility. In accordance with your reque~st, we are enclosing a copy of the transcript of the interview. We will provide you with a Safety Evaluation Report when it has been completed.

If you have any questions, please call me or Ms. A. Vietti at the followirg numbers: (301) 492-7903, (301) 492-4449.

Sincerely, I #

% a Director o anche eak Technical Review Team

Enclosure:

As stated F0lA-85-5E 8607110040 860624 PDR FOIA GARDE 85-59 PDR 4l

FEB 111985 l

7c Thank you very much'.for allowing our Technical Rev w Team members the opportu-nity to meet with you on to discuss concerns you raised regarding the Comanche Peak facility. In accordance with your request, we are enclosing a copy of the transcript of the interview. We will provide you with a Safety Evaluation Report when it has been. completed.

If you have any questions, please call me or Ms. A. Vietti at the following numbers: (301) 492-7903, (301) 492-4449.

l Sincerely, Vincent S. Noonan, Project Director Comanche Peak Technical Review Team

Enclosure:

l As stated l

l l

l t

RT NRR/CPTRT i i t g VNoonan 11 /20/84

/p/84

..,-,----,,---w--' rm FC'--W* " * - '

  1. '$$$5Lhhr.g,.y.%. -

.m; Y G..4 MbRb

? 45v. sh + QQr[$j 4Ahlh, yt4a*vu*u*nf+0.

ah ,

O.s ENDE.K.

.m- .a r.C^L.w?* -~ *nM. .lTO"me'enth6 ~p T. o, b .

t your.eddreself M 'r F

73 frereeks h reteits , gpecilent-this4; erd 1W.;.-

~

6Lg h. .r ytgWou 'tQs fehernedtayowThet'seweteaminefeeudts needse c;. .

the name 09ee N _. - _ ees.*et*w case of. - g 9 deem.y or soottJonet teeW fostew4eq serwetes ere- f,.. 2 t-1 eveHatne.4onsult postmeste(e andehook-tiem4es) .i, -

g., '4*r.senic61 toquestey$m,'f@1Ay%.j,?rp p iQ 3 l

I g 1.mp Show ~ to 'whorn;Wees andederessef dehrery>O. * . ti c:.. zu.ui.c, yn;# .m . .m. .

~l .x, v;*gl;.%'1Q&ffj  : . , Q*i! ' *% .La I u 2..O no.trictee oen,orgMdwp}.L,{s;'

( 'N, '

  • fj 'C-:.'.,, Mdif tjy;tNy; g .i. 4 -....s.,,

S t

I i

q. . g  ;

. i. . ~.y *

,:9..

h.

,; ,. _ . 4:

  • p M '_ . e l :a a.. *.. -

a ., "Q,.c -

+e "

't 4 '

a

,r, u ,

. ;p# ., :.g, l_4

.[..,  %'

l N'

l 'g -

.1. ~ $

.?r- .,y

~

,e.. .- '

g **. 9M ' ;

"- -'s5- -s.h 4,. .' .1. g

  • ' . ... , sf asf. . ,3 '"..

O,, , .v

_.. . l i

i J

l s

"Y, 4*

c  ? *e" ~>,, ~? f, *Q,%"r g  ?. 2.L' .: .

I

i

.. . s,. . . . .

&4jgp'm.-e,9. , '.q..g'W.;._,,

. ,. i s .D:

. :S,. ,, u V' p

.}h.

s - .'. y Y ..:'.{sc !

I

! i l

I I

I f

i l

1 1 .

i l .

I

- ~ ' - "

, . _ _ . . ,_ s -._ _ - _ _ . __.m. _--, -- .__m ..__m m_._ m - . . .a .u _-- _ _ _ . . _ . ,.

O

'- ^ ma h

$Y,5 h h$f= (

f7 _ w, h,&:,:,..R

~

~

. b) my b

1 g.

l.

i n 1 >*

ic ~~ - ag; g, att j },. .

I , -

g a i ,

%, ; i 5 .

~ -g . e 19 f g*g w%

Ie - -- _ . _ g 1

i e

%,514E4'Qu:: Lei

' 'C ;.) l" ?

5f ~

fiflCf;flMQ, ip StgSytps**

. ' ,*p. *.7,4

,ai.' . n ; *-f, ~~~ D Q QhifM A-U1 NUCLEAR CECULATORY COMMISSION

, . ~ ~S 'i'M RvOATE-d%Ef3:jpg5TJOR PFIEMlUM COSTMAll! SERVICE ' ' .

6. . v

' ';,qi ,. , . T' -

$y .lTMM3$[$33fjj$$"""" 'T t% " ' M ET**dT"" *"*'

  • J l Type p walt samvic%nieussiram jv [tXPRESS -

~ ~ ~

\

^[ l- l PMlORITY tut 1F. <DESCR197)Q:

- Q2 ' Ng%ar*% AkTICLE. #*

.h. '~ - l l PRIV ATE DELIVERY l lOTHER i

}qG .' ?M l s .

s l{

b.s viCE REQUESTED

. . , 4 , , , ,

k g se,.ysca CastTagacATioN- ourm vise ne pewa '

_ s,* a** ser ,

sessacas to sne ne st et ettes.es musw IJ.-J h 4 ,,, s [J '

  • l REGUESTEM-SIGNATURE lOATE '

l TITLE StuNAT E" slDR CPTNT '

lORG ANIZATION (Office, QMelon) ,

Comanche Peak Project lDATEeds -p u

l.apFfue I APP,4OVE * (Ar' 7f p nn nEjm EN 4 A40 A HOMall THE BLUE COPY T0: CHIEF, MAIL AND MESSEN 12ED 0FF)O(AL uSE OiU L Y. '

M.

lDATEc VENDO( ' "~fhf// / ~

c  ; - ra-hMl/2 Y l CALL NUMBER

/A> N/ - - : .%.

DATE EHIPP /Wl/h h =

h ff f $

t ~ ! ' '{ SIGN ATU '

w\m

'.g-REQUESTER COPY N $$N

.. (

.h l

l 6

i l

i I

t 1

i

.l

-m%_- ----e.w.-..- _ _ ,- . _.- - , - m.- .--_-.--.m -- m--

k

_ f C/

~-'\
.,...a,,~.c,.,.,.,.,.

. ,p: . -..

.. = -

y 4,. , .

a, r , , 7 L.,w.

.:, . , ~ : .;;

g. 3 . . .: .g p.9

. Q ; , '.-f .-

..~,qg, Jy . }e._a ', \

l ' y. -

. f p. y vl ".

7  ; . ,

='

The NRC Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, recently published Sur;1ement 10 (NUREG_0797) to the Safety Evaluation Report for the Comanche Peak Nuclear

.. Power Plant. This supplement contains information regarding the Comanche Peak Technical Review Team evaluation and resolution of 168 technical concerns and allegations in the mechanical and piping areas. Per our agreement, we are

enclosing a copy of this SER for your information.

$ Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact me collect

  • at (301) 492-7903.

i

[

Sincerely, isaan.a1 sign. cay:

'Y Vincent S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Project

Enclosure:

As stated i

F cc: M.E. Kline m

l u v5WDlO F

E '

m r- I c .+ n <,e -

. _ ,-< ,.,.e a, , ;- - ,,,- .

E- Up ' ' . . , , .t . -

1

= '

._b 3' e .!! d '.. ; '0 ' P.

g.h.g  ;. .*ly

j

'~

.; .c J l ,

L,P P :CPP t 1.

3 g r, g 4

_ _ //g, :/_ _.e _ _g;g j E_ ,

p . j,. %

r- ___:____________:_____ , o  ;

yg j 7 y 3 .. . ,

..g .7,

,y.i 4E :CPosiusny :VSNoo  : 9- E i, .: sC ic .e #,)+ . 7 ,..>-

_,,'..s /' -

a p , / , .j

'd iu . f 7 ,o. g ; g7

- o &, , . , . 7, - -.

A, S y j jj j

[

TE : / /85 ,

y,",[85  : j.jJT."'.t;. .

, r ' . *. * , s.

W; . . -

2' ". 2- 3 '? j kJ , ' ' ' ' '~ ' !; L(/( 6//W P ' / c l'..- 

                                                                                                                                        $i ' t J .1
0FFIblALRECORDCOPY j g i$! ]i E j - - "

MOid>. . .( 4. *- % . <f*e.f ' ' > ' C ' ' =g J 4' y *! Eli 

                                                                                        ,er a
                                                                                                ! ji           ! i
                                                                                                                 . 1                  pA.tv-(i 6.-                                                   . D      'i  /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ,.e  ,

5 3 e 2 e E. w. p c ,$.u, -v ~, 

                                                                                                                                                                                     .                                           - C ' .,:ev( . - . ~- -+ -

y m .m u . 

                     ;,l Je            ,

F i'** .:'*" , i~is~ha o A: ?Ei 4 g ? E%eh '% .n~b.' , i g' 

                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ..                'sk'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   , /.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          =

t t---/] ^. 

                                                               *'c                 Y j;f ;g f.3!'8             e ;                    . f,4.y%     ,;.d . , 5,'. ,', ,
                                                                                                                                                                 .V.          i4 .T '..'*..,Q!                    v ;*
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     . . 4.- (-J .4 V-s . . . -                        -

a: . e a y ,,9.., 

                                                                                                                                                                        ..u-                                              ,e                 . . ..

og? 2 y *y,cE}c h 

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   .>,;.-" Q .

a  ; 

                                                                                                                                            .,                f:         >,c',                               ,'
                                                                                   ;' } . ? l                      *                                                                &,'

0 Ogp '$ i: i pl '" O :ff'3.rn 5 t j.4i k 

                                                                                                                                                 ,;h,-             [,?f           yl                  '         ['4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 " '$j ,    -             9 -W $ '

~. = ' ] i ! 3 ;* i } E' a c.  ;." A.: N " ' Ii- 

                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ;f,.P'fb>ll.'e,"v<

f I/ ' 'M% , i . ' 

                                                                                                                                             '              "                                                               0 Pf ESTIC,3E10Hf4 HCC

= Ps rmm 3311, July IStrl - LbO

JO NOT DLSCLOSE Telephone Conversation Record: 10-29-84 

                                  ~

Contacted from CPSES resident trailer on 10/26/84 re possible close-out interview with him. He agreed and I said I would call him on I called today at Monday to confirm the interview date and location. 1 p.m.; he said that he would not be able to be interviewed I asked him whether he had anything to say to us, he said no. l 1 gave him my name and Dick Wessman's name and asked him to contact us through NRC operator 301-492-7000 should he have any questions, ccmments, etc. AC T R. C. Tan TRT DO \ 0T J SC _OS E 

                                                                  .m..~    *
                                                                                       ~

es T , 4 a s

D\ cs FEB 2 21535 i TELECON WITH ALLEGER A-21 I contacted alleger A-21 at the suggestion of .JuanitaEll[ (CASE) to determine how best to provide the alleger with feedback on his concerns regarding the construction of the Comanche Peak Nuclear Power Plent. Alleger stated he was quite disappointed with NRC efforts as a result of previous contacts and was wondering what the NRC has been doing with his allegations. I informed hin of the TRT efforts regarding his allegations and assured him we have investigated his allegations thorcughly. I asked hin if he would like to receive a copy of the SSER containing his allegaticns and he responded affirmatively. He acknowledged that he had declined any further l l contact with NRC after the last telecon but would be interested in receiving a copy of the SSER. He gave me his current address as: 6w g John J. Zudans e 

                                                                  ~                        n.

i" w .o > 

                                                                                     . " u j l) s

[ _

v - - - - - - - __ 

        '                                                                                      p                          /                  /
    -                 ..',, ,,,<,                                       unn t n su 3, s
                                    "                   Nuct i e n H E GU L ATOR Y COf.t'.'45SION        00 f;OT 0]$(LOS[
f. '-
                                   ' i W ASHINGT O*. DC ?!,'.'/
               *i. s,'A.r.1'U}pl
                                                                                                                                   ,p/ f
  • Mn 1 e ny,
                                                                                                            /                          -
                               "EPORP:.1d ' F02.: Larry Shao, Leader Civil a l'cchanical Tew                                                               '

Comanche Peak TRT \ M A /y h ' A' J . FR0ll: Shou-nien Hou f*echanical f. Piping, TRT

SUBJECT:

ItiTERVIEt. t'ITH ALLFCERS (ll/S/M-ll/14/C/.) ' Enclosed herewith are summaries of recent interiieves viith allerers Highlichts conducted ty TRT renbers in the Fechanical f. Pipin; area. of discussions, intervieve results, and suggested folic.up actions, if any, are incluced. 

                                                                                                'f h<u-              *W Shou-nien Hcu Mechanical 2. Pipinc, TP.T

Enclosure:

As stated cc: V. "00nen - f bO700 O--S A 

                                                                                                                               .., ,e-    ' s,
                                                                                                    ..            ..          l',>,;,',

DO NOT DI SC ','; E J Telephone interview witt j Category 24 . 

;                                                 / .< , - : s, Allegation: A(p - 70

( TRT told the alleger that a review of the records dic not reveal that the l two welders mentioned had been burning 240 rods per day. The TRT emphasizec that the weld foreman was probably exaggerating when he mentioned having all the welders meet the 200 rods per day goal. The alleger was told that, in any case, when the work resulting from the speec up in welding failed 

!                          to meet the requirements, the QC program caught these non-conformina l                          items and so the system worked. The alleger confirmed that, tollllll knowledge, no nonconforming items were installed.                                                                     ,

i The alleger agreed with the conclusions reached by the TRT. Action Reouired l The alleger suggested that the TRT call the following individuals to verify ' l llllll allegations: - --, t General Foreman - l Welder Welder , l The TRT agreed to do so but stated that the TRT did not question the truth of the original allegation and further information to verify it would not change the conclusions of the SSER. R. W. Hubbard November 9, 19E4 j i i t i I p b

r. 

                                                                                .v.s.
  • Telephone Interview with , , _ _

1 :00 p.m. 11/8/84 AW-66 The TRT discussed the results of our review with was told that based upon the TRT's interviews with both B Q.C.personnelandseveralwelderswhowor$edatthesitein December 1981, the TRT could neither substantiate or refute the allegation. The TRT also said that since QC stopped the work during this occurrence that was evidence that the O.C. system was working. The TRT then asked for any further information concerning this incident and he provided the following information: - (1) has a transcript of an interview with ehere jescribed the incident and identifie/s other welders who were present during the l incident. " - (2) An 01 report date describes an interview J between nd fir. Brooks Griffin of 01 during which time the same information as in (1) was given to the tF.~. (3) dentified two welders who were witnesses to the occurrence as (4) The incident took place in the lower valve room of RC 1. (5) My stated that Q.C. stopped the work approxinately 1 hour af ter the start of both the welding and concrete chipping activities. When aas asked about any other similar occurrences that .itnesse:, 3rovided the following information.

L 0;,, ~ 2-00 NOT DISCLOSE I (1) A similar incident took place in the florth Valve Room of Ur.it 2 Auxiliary Building (2) A welder by the name of <fas present during the incident. The TRT assured that this new information would be followed up and the I results reported to .i l R. J. Masterson l l t 

                                                   .                                                                                                                     l
 - _.                                  . - _ _ _ _}}
Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20206U620&oldid=3053052"