ML20206U544
Text
p%
f r
W' 9
UNITED STATES g 7,, y,o,,
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 47y i
g
- g-
/g. E WASHINGTON. D. C. 20566 MAY 0 61985 See atta:.hed page for addresses.
The NRC Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation ~ recently published Supplement 8 (NUREG-0797) to the difety Evaluation Report for the Comanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant. This supplement contains information regarding the Comanche Peak Technical Review Team evaluation and resolution of 86 technical concerns and allegations in the civil, structural, and miscellaneous areas.
Per our agreement, we are enclosing a copy of this SER for your information.
Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact me collect at (301) 492-7903.
Sincerely, l
Vincent S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Project
Enclosure:
As stated cc:
M.E. Kline c)
D 4.11 1
8 1
i t-gg a
j r
<!g S
l s)!
[
4 q'9 53 3.!!I" li
(
4 8
I 4%
l e
I!
N {!l1.1
. ]s @ i }
m et a
{ m i l f;l a
.i io 8607110016 860624
$2 fd i ei
- i 00$3 d
5X dX W
e cSRDE8 9
PDR 5"EW" NNN 4
D r,
,,g
.,m
,.w a,
h w, o 6 198 5 o
w. #;
~..:: ;~,
-~ - A...,. -
,r. - --
.,...,;...A,.r-
. ~.- a 1...... '.
&.g - -
w*
- a.. +. s u
.m. ;
e.,
- u...c.,
+
.' x.
- a. r.s..e,u...
.,.?
b' y - - '..
c
-:..'... y g;,.
- .+,. -.. -
./
yy*.,g n.
+
.r 4-g.
+T
+.4,
+.
3
,/
,.,,.. +
.q 4
s. <.
.,y, p
t i <
... -.y.. s,.' -'
e.m -
?
.c..
.e
((.
- e
(' * '
- '+-
I.,-...,,,. -- -
4 'h
.I f,~-**,,*','
~
.u j.
F.*- '
g.. 4,r,
?
. *i..
M
. ' '.* f 2 f. e G..
I.I, -,
g, &y.
~*
p
- [g 4
r>
.; s
.: r,. - g,g 4
f s
4'
',...,\\.-_
2-e y> y j.
f..-
+
g -
4 9
-w Jr s..
- s i
4 g.
.(
)
p, hy._
{,.
4,,
- ^ ".,
4
- p. *
.I
'*k*
I' '...
, +,
,->j f
i
, ' g*3
.x
.%g-f,
p 'f 4
p$,%... l4.
.v
- \\.,.(
z,a y
,*h 9,_
.e.-
7 4 w s E-
- P
}
4.-
(
- /
=.
?
-y
, +.,
L-..+,y,j.
,1
<e~
.... +
o-., a g-c
. - u.. t., s....
.,. ",n,4, f, - _ ;,..
- 3 f... m,..
- .p
,.,s S.
S
. + ;.
t.
.., 2.
J*.
.a
- e...e
'p
~
g
.1..
a
-i 4, 1
- _.-,_,., S,
g.
y R-
- 4 V"
., g
[D.h
- ^5 ' 4..
.,,,k
+
,...#Ys t4'
- ,e..-.-i....,.... wi e,ee -s.-
),
e-
'r W-
-t.-
. h..
.(*
,.Y,,',
i gr U,,
.?
' i.
?,..-9..- -j.
..[,.J.g4
.".g,.
,4
. ;s.,,#
.. K le t
g.,).
,c 3 n','g *
.q WB 7,
T9 i
V
/
p a
+
w.<
g u..,.
.. r. jm.-
l n
3,
'.L =, 4
. ~I
'n
. /,A
. a
[
-g
.R *e.
,, > y.
g m
,6-
- Q % y -
}
. j.;, ll '.
1 i
}';[J _. Y.
. T_*
ae u,.
\\
~
n+
, >. 5 ;,.W
_. )
- ,;s __q A. ;...- 4.),.; '.a. J.., -
y_
,f 3{..-
yI
.f s.
[ ,' 3
- 3 *i f.!,.Q."...y. v l
+
,t.
\\
l ('
}~.' g ' }
i.
5 +- $%
' ^,
,_ f*
- ,,.+
g g
.p
~ '
I g
.g
E p
g
,(._'
S r
- 9... :,
a p p
.... ) '. * '.. <N - )n.-
4/
- ; } ; *.
'qs.
j, g
gH.g ?
- j'd, ' A,
.4,,C.i._
e..f h.a n,7 ' [hAi l
.e I
'- wr.
-t
.g-1
. k'd s' p.
,y
.+#
g- +. '. --:, '*
.g
?,s_-p t-f.
y f,..,*_+.
l v
,t 4
7 ;
7.i. y ;
s. w.,. (!.f. i n.
- $, 1
- 4. 4.. ? it v5 - ;r j - ' -
+.
=
.1, w
n-v
.e
.j' 1 - : J',~- - ~..
-- t y
y+,?. ',y.
em.
+..#
. ;#9,. -,
,_,V
.,, g., -.'
g
- - y..,,
j
,s
-s
. i..,
p
,(
- Ia [
- j. :
- $ y$.m[,
y!
r Y'
f h '.
& -?
- .?,yW' s.
3 dQ a
,i
.... s -_. '.
.g.,',,
- .v
- p
..,p
^
f.,
~
- e
.y_-
>(
I
.. /w w ]*
' ~a; k.. p
- j
' =,'
y 4'_.
A, '\\, k ' '.w' l
\\,
(
+
'h '
s
?:
- [
\\4
.... ;... i<-..
r.7* f /\\
[
. e g
(
A.
a m
.,....-,.>..<.,, +,-
, A t_,
}
'4 I
?
e..
5
, y -
s.
s-.
i g:,
'7.,...
<9.
.a 4>;
l s -
3..,,;y. > v> ~
..,. x _-
g
,c
./. -
=
L.
-g. 'w., q:
y v.+.-
+
j '. =...
p-
'.., -. e.; -
g
?
4 s
- -+
?
i
's._
. +.. ~,,. < ps.
A..
v e
x..
.s s.
,.., p 4,...
?
2 I.[.
..s...,
f :
i 4.x.
- +.. '..
,y
.{
- '[
5_ $
t'.,
~
.:..-., k[..
9*.
7 A#,
4,,
g
', ' ' [_," ; g
}.,
O V g
t-
, - N:_
s y
. _fJ f -. '. '., _
r
. V.'
p.
~,.
,~
..T...'...,
/
' '- z ) 'hp., ' r. f U.* <
p.
&Y s,_
,...,.. +
- n..,;... $ ;,. --
........,, -, -..+
. w x..y.+: K. :
1-. - s - yg -6 c.-
g 4
s..
m... i z.,.'
z
,~
.v+
-,. g,y y
....La-
-p.p',
W-sg.
g
.].
G
';?-
. s. ;e f
gY,.- M
- n g-
'4.
..,_2
.. -, - W
.~7,. >L m
.y.
/y,y-
.1 g i-.
s,.
, 4 4
g,,,
- * ~.,,.
- ,e
... 's'."-r,1.
.t a.%
j _,, a. -
,, aA,..
9
=* *,,
e
.. I
.~
.-s' A
.'i2 3
. p-6
-)
,4
)...A r r o
e.
?
.s
..,.' s s
y.
+
,,, y, z~
- L..' ;t j,
- r..
- 1. r n L.
9-
~..
.,, J. 8.,:., L.
z',',
,,~**yw
..,.e?, *.-..,
,. h..,l W +
+
+
1
<c s'
e s
y g
..-M'
.e.
)
p 8-t.:
(s )
. 6; 4
... -4 w
'f r
g',-y p,"
'.AA : k '
t'
- eo E
c,.L.Mr > &..
-~>~c'-
%V,
~
5
- A..
k.b_w,
-'.y. M.L 4 W "
- 3. atRu { f - [ 4Wf ' N '3 yy. }
- v. d w-4:
%m-, #
- j...
i
,g
,a ii,
s
yf, pn vlouq'o C
/
UNITED STATES
[ 'yg, e f[,,g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION gp E
WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 MAY 0 61935 See attached page for addresses.
The NRC Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, recently published Supplement 8 (NUREG-0797) to the Safety Evaluation Report for the Comanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant. This sapplement contains information regarding the Comanche Peak Technical Review Team evaluation and resolution of 86 technical concerns and allegations in the civil, structural, and miscellaneous areas. Per our agreement, we are enclosing a copy of this SER for your infonnation.
Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact me collect at (301) 492-7903.
Sincerely, Vincent S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Project
Enclosure:
As stated cc:
M.E. Kline F01A-85-59 d
(2l L
W 0 6 1985 a
s - ='
- ; y.,3.. *.,, g ' N, T.
[~.s ;
' f%
, cro p l ", p,. [ ;##.;;/ ' 3 4,
^
..,,.. 7g ',
j,
].?/ ' '[
[
4
. q;, :*.
f.. -
,4
.. g/*., v
, a,
"'.. g &. p a
j, g
.. _. 3 J -
~
7
,,.,., j 4,
.8 is,,. + :. T..-. y o<
..^-4.'
3.
,, go v-
..+e.**.
- 5,g
]qy,.'
~
w =, oy ^.-
e.
, +
u' L._,
f N,,
a
~
~~
a e
?,
'.'fp M ' Y
.-. i
%, n ;...
+ s
{ J *. ??
- f.;) "',
,A i
., 7 w, $. Q..,
x
?.J.
~E
,..g.. [ *t g j, % [,
)
- . s., s yg,.
k
, 94. '9(9, '.[, ;[13 _
4*
. -g
- 7
- t...
3..-
,- 4
- +
Q} 4 :,
7 m
y
.r v
s
.g9 y.,
.-R * ; Y ?. x 1; q.- 2 t,
9,. t c
" h...
e
.;s
+
V 4'
t
. %}y -
.g,. <,%.
ao,,
..y y Q } ". x_ y % %.. l,
- t.. /. _
._. [. -. * *.
F:4 '- ~
4,
.. g m' '
y 4
p-
- ~
z.
a
- * ~
-. ' f. >. r m'
W' s
r _s i
,lc e
- e...
l
? f. [i. -
.. ;,.A; x. -,
.o.,
. &,.,.t
~
- [~,
Q.; ":.
.,, ~ '
y *'
n y y
- g
~..
. f j@v, (.. f y:
_ ?
. f) \\,5.- %,
w-1^9
, E.h>, k^
",,3
....d
> 3, v
y
. n,,
w,
'3c3 7 ".,y ".(, g +. T -*
f. ;, f.g y$,
.a -
. ~..
e.
., /.e. -.
w-y 3. ~,
3;,.3 3 s
-,,.3.. 3
..,,.s
.-.. R,,
.,,g 5
?-
f. ?
g.
y,
- Q,, c4...s g g., e
+ >
j -7..,...
'., } - 'y,} f'Q (.;.f A,,i ff x,. t.. r.. h..,f [.*
. 4; -,,, --
s
- 7..
r.-
4
,.. - -+ - 9.~,A-:.7,c,
_ y.,
-. n.. s. t a #[.. ' g.
e.;
- k.g
..A
,4
+., -
[ d n_. g -
g
-....a
- n,-
c,_,...
.8
.g, -y.. - r ;.
m.:
[
p.
,m
-+y
.a. _ ; -
y g:
- y
. -. +
~
,, l- ) y *,,
,,s.
' 4 r l( A ~
r e. :.
..5 % W
'.' e
{ l ;. ' ' f. r e
L
- }._-); M f.
- n 5_ N l #
., w%. -
o
) :3
- f..
Q.y*. - '
l f o~., ' e '. g., H, ' ' - *..
- s. -
.s...~.'
N.
_,v..
39g
- ~
4.:. '
'_ ' i.
e
_ r
- ". ' %,- l &Q:..
p -
.. M3.
, g. 4y '..@
't j
.e..
m s u w 4>
n s -
+ %er,' -.-. ?g "'-
..g
. $. 2. -.
,1 -
T
'A.P 3
fi 2
.j
- 4..,;
5
- f.... <
.?-
f
,y
,, s 4*
r S V& 7 we.-. ".-- a
. y,.,, ',.? ;' 4
.4-h r
wq q.
j ; 1,+ L- 'w
. ; =.
y C
}.,,, /
.- '.?
' T ',4 ' " " '.'.. :.L...' ^"?:.. w.
t -...
- e 1
1
-j
..r h,..
g*)%r
.tr.
s, '
a.
.[
~
[
[
.: h ['t
.s..
.. L.'
4 s.
s
. T.
x;Mf. f, b
. { ;
,[,; j
~.
e l
l ^
~.a i,}.,
p..
4 u
s.
.- -.W,."
. m
- l
~ '
+.,
g
. g..
,.. A a#.,
- -. ?
. w
- p. -
e, oz -...
s,
4.
- g...
y %4 -.
'~.
.\\
1
.i e,
.."V,.u
%4-.
d; r
.?
g' a ',
*W-4
. d
+. i
[...
%^]
- h
),
$ Q.,
D' y
.a n
F
'N
- ' r
~
f E'R
- ". i
',x..., s y. p,.; 6 ;
~m %: +;,
- t.,-
,s r
- s... m('
y
~
as e
n^
s
- e v.
x.
4 cjv _
c..
-'),
. J
,,s y
/ '
.. -, W g'. *.'
.(
9
- y.
+
g
. a',..,;.. 4 9
iy
. ^. /', '.(. f, h ' i
- ~..
4 t
e
%. ;o]g.p. -, +.
fb-9
,., _. x s.
, i
< s.s ' -
n r
s j
t
. t',.,'
3., j. $
.?.
4
.. ',..~
4 '*u
. 3 ',..g/.7 ',
yeC'[.-
~
4
., [
.-(,
- 4 i, _' ' ".
/
p~
~ [
9 <
l a$k,-
9
~' -
g,
e
-3 ;;.. -
t?
, *= ;
... y %
4
],
e n
\\'
+ ~
- i. - ', ".
- ,. - -/"*..;,,; % '
'Y. p ' f,
^
- - ?-.,i * '
, 4.
- p E
y,
7'd? '.
I%-
, g,
.'*.?
' - - +, %
u,
-'f. '
A
..T*,,,'
4; 1,*
p(
k...
v
,1
. y'*~ p *; y + i.k.u
.,%. + j..
a t.
.=e.-,.
s
. j4i
.s
,,f
. g c q,,e -
F-4
.y,
$4
- v y
.a
.:. s M
.-.,~.,1 p-f,.,'.
..,,f
<3
.. + -
l h.
.T
.y u.
.e'
?
4 3-g.
{'
1.
s 4'
}.
t
=, ' ',. -h.M..
, g-
, 4, C /,
w~ Q~,f{,
g
.'4
.,g...'
- . +,,..;
s p
3 y.
..s
.v, 3
i.,
j A*
(%j
[,' ',: '
g, -
2
. ;h [
4
?.
,a
. x, > n..
j
/
.,.m.#,,..<
. 3. 1.,
",g } ', (.
e a.".. u... $.7 l
'.?
>j N.
_' I I
l l
1
)/ / /7 ~ '
/
. [p, ne cg'o UNITED STATES 5 }Tpi w(p NUCLE AR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3
W ASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 l;; g\\*%>/..
E
- e. v31.7 8 g
g s..-
- j p.AY 0 6 1035 CJ See attached page for addresses.
The NRC Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, recently published Supplement 8 (NUREG-0797) to the Safety Evaluation Report for the Comanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant. This supplement contains infortnation regarding the Comanche Peak Technical Review Team evaluation and resolution of 86 technical concerns and allegations in the civil, structural, and miscellaneous areas.
Per our agreement, we are enclosing a copy of this SER for your information.
Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact me collect at (301) 492-7903.
Sincerely, Vincent S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Project i
Enclosure:
As stated cc:
M.E. Kline u
4e.m.
nun ti i
- Ti! ";
{
4 853 5
3 I ' fl! I l
j!
{
o 0: 518
'!!i! ai i
I r5:
i it F01A-85-59 Il0;"g!!!!
s.i h:
o u m"'1 5 i f.! E lf a.
-RO
. mg.sggj %
ts OMESTIC RETURN RECEt 5 Form 3811,Juty ang f
[ 2-
/
I
/
.,+, y-
.- >~
.a
.g g g. g..,
- y... y
~
..t
. g37 y.
. R. ^:;.,>x.. *yt,
A z
.s V.-
t;._Qf m-
~
~. ;- -
y; l - : --
r.'. $.
g,.
__ y
. r c.L
^ +
+
e,, -
.-a
.s _.
'm
+
j
+g.
c3 k :,,.
6,
~. x.
- r
- - 3;, -
2
?
. -; m..
- d. -
f.,.
~,
in
.y
%,r
...;.. ;g.. y-c c,.
s:-
.rn..~ ;.
,r n,
/,
(.[J'M,g.,%,/-,
v 4.1 1 -. b. f 7 W
"9
,],,
s.
.,f. U 3 a.4 #
', ' 4 i..,,
S.
.n J
, t4..
.. ~
p'.'"
/[. _@f, 't t ' J f. p
-- +
. A.
'C t,
,4 i
.../a-j>f s..
., s_ 4'-'. " '
j
\\w p p +...,.,
- , e,
.s i,
+
s - --
1
+
v.
+...
.r.
s s
. (_. y.
.sp,
f<
- ~.Q
{\\
Y ~ .
,, f
,,. -. = + -
. ^
^ '+ '.
f'.
.4
':/.
}
e-
+
7
.ly
. :-. : H 3
- 45- $,Q. '
~
Lv
/_r-qs >. - J" g *,,
1 &.
a: ;
}.,
- 4. '.}
. *Y 4
s,,
Y V
N p*
.). ' ~ ' -
+ %. (.
.r.
'. +
n.
" ~.j
!, w-e
.y.L, ! L.. L
- s. 4
. ~.-(N
. * ." \\'...
v
.4c '. h..
.~-
^.
-}
.g. 4a/ /. -
? *.*.
j.
$s
..p..
i
,.?-:..
.. ~ ~ -
k, x. l-
.k.
- i 6
i -
-s f,
g 7
'?-
v_'
g
,l Q A ' '
j *- -/
.)
,., y Lvl ' } ' f_ ~ ' A., ~,
- ,s
. s.
- y. -. *
'R _ +
- l
. <f
' d '.] _-. -...p ;.,.
_ Q.'., - - -..,
s.,
j y~ 1$
p.e
,. y j. -
- h.,".y
- A. _ -
/. /
_w
., yy+'
s f g :?
- l e:
. 1-w R. W' r..
s e
- ~.
' M >7,/ -, <
a-J' :
,,, ; 4,,.,.3. c :
/_, Q. Q ;,n '.
., y,7,, / (-
- r
- +
. + f ',..
i
.)
. ,7 -
g
. e...
.,,, l y;.
., s
- q. +
p.. y.
a-2, %.-. 't,%
p..,a -t
- ,.;.,- +'
-.p
,l
,, e
.*r-4 y'
e g
v y
-.. ^
.s.
~S
..m'
. ", < e f.
.s
't
+,
,,*. ',._,*.. - (
-f
., x 4
,t
.g g..
7 i - -
r gf s,,.
,,J' y
j o
<,W ; p. ( A f....
,g ',
s m*
,,I
., g 5
- +.l.e.
,., ' - Y.7
?
?
,A,,
~.
n
-.J.% % _j -
('e y
-,. '., f.. s,..
.y
...s
- N, s l
h fr. -
e - I
.a
,:js
.o '
t.7+.,4
- ~,g ; _
}
w f.
a
.. r..,... 1
... 4 $. y.
.. y
}*
v Y
~
p' c
+ %
'g r,
.p.,
.e,'
g.
.c.,
?-
}
. 1,-3
,v....,
p4..
^
. g '.N.,,
4 _'
v.
r.
.L
./
- '*. #,, g
^
1.
,. /.
}-
7 - a A,8 m...
v.
.y r.
p~:s i,
.. ' " Q e
s; r - - J,;i -%m.".%
., '.L %... -
,,...g
-+
't 9.
- % u..,.
i 2
i..
",c
._s_
,..w
,?
- g ;*.
~ -.
,1 s
e x
e.
g -
_w v,ry pf.,
.y;.
3..
4f*,;
.e.
f.y:,.,p N.. /. -
,l., t.w....3
.,J s.-
z w:
f a
.3 s
,k -[T,., m,
- t. L
+
c 4
3.
a
- -...- ?
y M.;
. a
' >~ -
N-
... 9
~.3,<
.~. -..,....-.
s.
c ~ - -
- a. s,#.,,
t
- '. p.. #
p
~.~:. '. -
~ ~ *
{ '
l,,
.4
.l
-A"w.
. ~
G-j -,.., qr 9
=
n.
+ -.
~.
1,
.. a+ ~.:,,.. a,., 7,.:u.-
...c Y'
+...
- 3..
r -
.,c.
9.
-,, m.,,.
h, j y w' M'"
- ?
.e+ y
.*y,,;,%
et e
4Q-
+_
- ! ' '. w.?.,,+ %', '
- -...... ~
',Q y
):b
....y(_ ' -* j.y, '.' r_')*
3 '
, *..h s.,, -'
s ' a'lo.,d';.
- $s J
v
+-
,.k
... m...
c,y.
'y
..e
.r e
+:
w 1'.
m
+
q,..,,.
_e,1<
. -l g
- n..
c..;
. s~
<- ~ i
...,+:. f.,,.
M 9
- * - i i
m 4.'. ;g a.
.x.
.9.'-
,.,h -(*
,,3g%~
'v.
eY>
r...
c
- c - :.
.e.
3l.... +4,.'3' 5
4 ;.._ r. q...,.
e y T'
- j
,a
.u
" 4
_v
- n
.t.
' rR
.c C
.t 9
8 (.
?
. ' 2 -s a., K,
(
e
- 4 +
y 8
g,,
@f8-
>p f....+.9
. ~,.
,1
.. 4
. e 1
?
g 47 p
- j
,.f s
s
- q+:
.i,,
.,, s.
- 2.-
.x, a.%, L..
- c. y m. ~
c
.a x;
s.
js.
4...n
,. - r.+v w,.
.*W. -. *,
- ;. g w-s.
e r
a.:.
mu u--mm hm gg w
l y
j
- llTEPVIEW FORMAT - FEEDBACK INTERVIEk5 1.
Ccver Page d 9
-i
- inte.:ww of....
Date: *2-l (.;: f6 f i Time: /t/c cs Location:
7j: 4g c ed
_l Parties present.
7 g cip/] A.I.3 sfe 'rL O M/14/ AIC 5 c
C 2.
Proceedings
( cotr LE Pc Ut G (on the. record)
"For the record, this is an inte.triew of for the purpose of providing feedback ~ regarding Tec'hnical Review Team as::essment o#
.s certain concerns raised abcut the Comanche Pea.k facility.
"The location of this interview is "Present at this ir.terview are (names / organizations)"
i "As agreed, this interview is being transcribed.
Describe mission of TRT "I wish to clarify oetails of your employment at Comanche Peak" (Obtain ATa~ a tO.
J Wad 7 details of employment /qualificaticns "We spoke with you on... ano have reviewed your statement (s) of...
Turn over to Technical Reviewer.
r q,,,
i.,
~
.l
)
r.
P i
t.
i 3.
Conclusion of Proceedings "The results of our evaluation will be published.:n a SSEr< wnicn w ll i
be available abcut January 1, 1785" I
"Where appropriate we will require corrective action by TUGCO."
"Do you have anything further you woulo like to add for the record?
"Have we adequately covered your concerns?
"Do you have additional concerns?"
"Have you given this statement to us today freely and voluntarily?"
... off the reccrd
-s i
4 Administrative Guioance J
Ask if incivicual wants ce;'y uf transcript. Advise them that reir. script will be part of public reccrc 'except for confidentir.1 iources. cr if they request confidentiality).
5.
Guidance Limit to topic of interest Ask:
Is this a new issue?
Have you prrvided this tc NRC?
y..m
l 3
Did you do it?
Did you see it?
Seek:
names, dates, locations, documents, o
Be courteous and considerate o
Be sure individual appreciates the importance cf his concsrn(s) and the staff / technical effort expended to review and evaluate.
o Be sure individual understands we will require corrective action and that we are dedicated to safety.
When presenting negative finding 1_fi.e., when allegations are found to be of no merit), do not tell jndividuals that they are "wrcr.g",
askidtheTRThaspossiblymisseohispoints....
')
sar A z j
DO NOT DISCLOSE DEC 3 1984 Thank you very much for allowing,_pur Technical Review Te.am members the opportunity to meet with you on to discuss concerns you raised regarding the Comanche Peak facility.
In accordance with your request, we are enclosing a copy of the transcript of the interview. We will provide you with a Safety Evaluation Report when it has been completed.
If you have any questions, please call me or Mr. R. Wessman at the following numbers: (301) 492-7903, (301) 492-8432.
Sincerely, pigg d Signecby&
Vincent Noonan, Project Director Comanche Peak Technical l
9 Review Team
(
Enclosure:
}
As stated 1
DISTRIBUTION:
})
(
w/o Encl.
J. Zudansv p
l l
l 7
C
- CP:TRT g
- PD:TRT i___:___p_____:VNoonan ME :RWessman TE :11/;O/84
, h[//84 0FFICIAL RECORD COPY
'l. =
d
~s,i.
a I
9i
)
2 1
ty
l DO NOT J,SCLOSE l
DEC 3 1984 C
Thank you very much for allowin ur Technical Review Team members the opportunity to meet with you on to discuss concerns you raised regarding the Comanche P facility.
In accordance with your request, we are enclosing a copy of the transcript of the interview. We will provide you with a Safety Evaluation Report when it has been completed.
l If you have any questions, please call me or Mr. R. Wessman at the following numbers: (301) 492-7903, (301) 492-8432.
Sincerely, pg4 sisaea os s Vincent Noonan, Project Director Comanche Peak Technical Review Team l
Enclosure:
As stated DISTRIBUTION:
w/o Encl.
J. Zudansv i
I i
7
- CP:TRT g
- PD:TRT// :
/__:._________.:_________...:_____-___-__:______-____-:____-------
p
_______.7
.,s,,,
- n
- I
- RWessman
- VNoonaa
- ____ _-_-___:-_,_________.:_e___------
,_:___________:h_7/84
- 11/;D/S4
/
l:
0FFICIAL RECORD COPY
,,3 ygrp 3
1.,
.f, u.;=,O x Q
h, :i.
A.
% a i. ' ' -
p.
UNITED STATES p#
YJ NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
[.%,4[~f' f. 'j
)
T
._i.
WASHINGTON. D. C. 20555 g.
0...- f Y
y s, -
1 l
Thank you very much for allowing _our Technical Review Team members the to discuss opportunity to meet with you on',._..
In accordance concerns you raised regarding the Comanche Peak facility.
with your request, we are enclosing a copy of the transcript of the interview. We will provide you with a Safety Evaluation Report when it has been completed.
If you have any questions, please call me or Mr. R. Wessman at the following numbers: (301) 492-7903, (301) 492-8432.
Sincerely,
/
Ac o
roJect Director manche P ak Te hnical Review eam
Enclosure:
As stated i
l
.m._._,-._.-
C' e.a a s c g,,'c.,
r UNITED STATES p
NUCLE AR REGULATORY COMt.11SSION
! fi. h, ?' i e
5 WASHINGTON. D. C. 20555 h,%o, & / !
o,
.: =* y Thank you very much for allowing our Technical Team cembers the to discuss opportunity to meet with you on i
l concerns you raised regarding th' omanene FeaK facility P In accordance
)
l with your request, we are enclosing a copy of the transcript of the l
interview. We will provide you with a Safety Evaluation Report when it has been completed.
If you have any questions, please call me or Mr. R. Wessman at the following numbers: (301) 492-7903, (301) 492-8432.
Sincerely, l
roject Director o
manche P ak Te hnical Review eam
Enclosure:
As stated l
i Y
YD
~
l l
f
^l20
c%
UNITED STATES POSTAL. SERVICE 1e.fc
.mm -
.l n=.
SSNDERINSTRUCTIONS e
' Tl C
D l
g : 1 : : = o..
w.o.
oT o.s..
. u.... -
=
=.
L asa w-
-. u.oo
..e a m.u.ew.
m use.o R
RN g
~
%Lo Bub >
(Napie of Senden WlS fWt> bhst.u, ll2 (SL'oet or P.O. Box) a W$
A./ 7bf
?y' n
(City, State, e'nd ZIP Code) 3 J er -
_.;.hi;,'
1,a 1, < : -
L UNITEDSTATES POSTALSERVICE F
7 omesAi.suSmass SDSER BsSTRUCTIDNS Print your nonw.em and BP Code in the e
spees belour.
k d
e composee items 1. 2. s. and 4 en the reverse e Attach t front of art.i.le if space permite, P9eALTY FOR puwatt othenstee afitsto be It of artide.
M 8888 Endorse article *1stum Roselpt flaquested" edieceset to number LL MA
,~_...e _,
f/b Y
(No. and Street. Apt., Sutto P l
%usuhl 77/d.O.een or R.D.Pte.)
&/70/
(cetyj state, one Z ar code, I
I o
9 ER Aa A i
l
~ ~ ~ -
f
=
i a
I h~
=
- t t
~5
$a g
l flE
?Xh, l)N'T
~
i.5-l.c @
e 8
IF u,
an ng Uflli W
y J ' ~d.
se
-j I
him e
h,g, h,k o
e-el,lingt S
R, I
u d
ul g
qAlld e =)
y g
4a00 g
~
M31. July 1962 J
(
r
~
~ L
~
~
~
6 S
M.;t u!,s a
=::
- =If 2
{
a
'g:n.
ii
.~
~
~gu i ll.
8
. 2
- n :
?
o l
4 3
Iot* ; ? P.
J s
g
~
5 5
h n
55EII 3
=
I d' i e' a
s
!i lQit a
4i i
I isa!lv1e e
sii' La l'
?
i i
1 ah
- s u
u-i a$1 # 2
'jj j
9 a
i g. "} "
g i
a z
g.-
s.
t%.a 6
5 Wi ag
)x )
z
@ E 2>?!)
- g ox 1
- g; ~
- 'M 211, Jury im DCMEM$RM7 l3V V
MWA2 r
'9 5
V.
g_
- 3 } Yd'v,F, 4-
- '
- E f.." f p -
' I JF=7 7a,,2-,3 1
/g. arc '*-
c UNITED STATES y*
, y ',
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
{.
7,i WASHING TON, D. C. 20555 gjg/
.--W DO NOT DLSCLOSE
- y (' ; aq
- .. :- '.-
y,....j_
.. r.
f ..
.... e.$
l,:p...%s':y:^'.'.f..G.Q,:lW.
. - ;. f '\\f; f;f.;;;;
Y, -f
%w
. :._.i
.,f.y..
~-
..r y.
.m Thank you very much or a owin ur Techni 1 Revi members the opportunity to meet with you on.
~
to discuss concerns
[
you raised regarding the Comanch. dkFacility.
n accordance with your request, we are enclosing a copy of the transcript of the interview. We will provide you with a Safety Evaluation Report when it has been completed.
The NRC ma.de copies of the documerts you loaned to us during this interview.
=
They are being mailed to you separately.
If you have any questions, please call me or Mr. R. Wessman at the following numbers (301) 492-7903 and/or 492-8432.
Sincerely.
/
/*
4 ff y m
Vi N
, Project Director acc e P ak ech ' cal Review Team
Enclosure:
As stated e
JO NO-JLSCuOSE
=
EG.3Ak8L-,39 a
R a,,,
.m.
i o
Uu WOf DISCLOSE 2
=
DEC 2 1934 Y
y 4 f -
n
",4 '.: N
. ".,.,1
~ iz NA \\1&z;.-
4 2
~... -
o, A
... L td*.
, j,;_ ; r ;.,_s' 2:.
,.f_
.. / -
%*..'.' "'e ',_..
]._
Thank you very much for allowina_our Technical Review T c1 embers the
/-
opportunity to meet with you on to discuss concerns
=
h you raised regarding the Comanc e Peak aci
- ity, n accordance with your request, we are enclosing a copy of the transcript of the interview. We will
?
provide you with a Safecy Evaluation Report when it has been completed.
e 4
The NRC made copies of the documents you loaned to us during this interview.
They are being mailed to you separately.
i; If you have any questions, please call me or Mr. R. Wessman at the following y
y numbers (301) 492 7903 and/or 492-8432.
g Sincerely, 7
7 12risisal 3igned By:
m m
Vincent S. Noonan, Project Director Comanche Peak Technical Review Team d
_2
^
Enclosure:
As stated DISTRIBUTION:
J-J. Zudans
- g m
4 r
2 K
4
_ _ : - _ _ _ _.,fV]_ _ : _ _ _ _ _ _
J
- TRT
- PD:TRT
// :
E :RWess an:pf :VNoona / g_ :____________:____________:____________:____________:
=
..:____________:____g_______.____________.____________.____________:____________:__
E :11h6 /84
- 17/ 6 /8 4 8
- WW W gA,..g p
N M lI llg sn MI! l q w-R fj
@ b ic g jN
~
jN 6-Ifillllp
.,s
~.
,s
+
A
' " ' ~ ' ~ - ~ ~
,. = _
eM
,g,3 g a.
e c e' #
W re o th e
..I/['. ?.i.
NrTsed to you. The r e; H Dw',
p w, g, y, gm
? 'N' }g gg, e;WJ 3.. /'s,. i,
y,, p sur""**** m of the person M.
wg
.gmmma con oostuww tee. v..'Q[~
.,t C3
., ( ' ' ',}.,
~ '. _ -,
2 9 or e
,,,c, t.,
- j,_
^
.s.-
wa ponm to, <. '*" *M i'enI
- .g.,.,. c. r -)
,-pds) towartsti
- ;' [;j.jf c.
hf 5.$ $,$ $ s M -ia * =. e e.. _,,
5 Mastricted Detivery.
.. ',e
)
..,;g
\\.
e..
y. s
.s..
I9; s q,lp.+.7' '
^
c.d -
hwK
'r.. a.
'l 8
L
/
C s
1
\\
l 1
l 1
a,,
-v,-
CCNFIDENTIALITY ACREEMENT I have infomation that I wish to provide in confidence to the U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission (NRC).
I request an express pledge of confidentiality as
)
a condition of providing this information to the NRC.
I will not provide this l
infomation voluntarily to the NRC without such confidentiality being extendec to me.
It is my understanding, consistent with its legal obligations, the NRC, by agreeing to this confidentiality, will adhere to the following conditions:
(1) The NRC will not icentify me by name or personal identifier in any NRC initiated document, conversation, or comunication released to the public which relates directly to the information provided by me.
I understand the term "public release" to enccmpass any distribution outside of the NRC with the exception of other public agencies which may require this infomation in futherance of their responsibilities under law or public trust.
(2)
The NRC will disclose my identity within the NRC only to the extent required for the conduct of NRC related activities.
(3)
During the course of the inquiry or investigation the'NRC will also make every effort consistent with the investigative needs of the Commission to avoid actions which would clearly be expected to result in the disclosure of my identity to persons subsequently contacted by the NRC.
AT a later stage I understand that even though the NRC will make every reasonable Effort to protect my identity, my identification could be compelled by orcers or subpoenas issued by courts of law, hearing boards, or similar legal entities.
In such cases, the basis for ~
granting this promise of confidentiality and any other relevar.t facts will be communic ned to the authority ordering the disclosure in an effort to maintain my confidentiality.
If this effort proves unsuccessful, a representative of the NRC will attempt to infom me of any such action before disclosing my identity.
I also understand that the NRC will consider me to have waived my right to confidentiality if I take any action that may be reasonably expected to disclose my identity.
I further understand that the NRC will consider me to have waived my rights to confidentiality if I provide (or have previously provided) infomation j
to any other party that contradicts the infomation that I provided to the NRC or if circumstances indicate that I am intentionally providing false infomation I
to the NRC.
.,----c r
,-. 'k.
- 2 hk.' f -' *,g -
.b' f
[
.T l
f f f]g['Q_'iffif' y,:.:.L-}lLf.*.f : ( Q* -(..
)}.
3
- Y, " ;
- .5..,
's.
.:.h.
,. j 7,,;7
.,g [,
% ? f -} l y.T' h g,. - % } [ 9.}. %.
' {?,, ',.
> 4, *?
. c._
4 i1 Y'. ', ( g
[q
-n-er 7
(
4
., D '. : ';
",Q_=
3~.*?*
l _ ' ','
\\.=_ _,, i n
[., 6 : {-
j' T
w,
_[
..,_-[.f,y'f_ f,.
).,
t,
_ ' e: J '. -
?
. =,.,. -
- f.
p
.C' 7,w
- ,'.,. l,
. & idl,
.L.
l
^ -
i,. -Q
.*c 4
s
+t p 9...
t,
-.- [ ;
'l,
~
.A' J',Y.
,Y'"
_ 3 ~.
'., ^, 4,. '% {j$
l
- ;3. c
,,N s
<s x --.., ~.',...., y Q %
' +
.i.i+,; _,l f"
-y t_
g ". y,'.
- s. f r[. g c,
.j,.. sM4. g c
',i
.{ ( g g g;
, gcQ*,._. -
y-lT ;
'l },
s
/y 7.7 -. p4 ;-
.~
.,.4
,-,,.p(3
,_2;
,,-4. g t,; s - n.-.. t '-
' -- +'
1*
,, k %.,
'^
p
'. L; S* l P%.
[
(h D\\
C3:e 3ignature T,uc cr Fonted Name and Title i
Resisicn 1.
i
-. - - -