ML20091B640

Forwards Const Implementation Overview Nonconformance Rept 5063-HV Re Lack of Criteria for Matl Damage in Pqci P230R

ML20091B640
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	05/18/1984
From:	Kinne J CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To:	Bulter K STONE & WEBSTER, INC.
References
CIO-0052, CIO-52, NUDOCS 8405300356
Download: ML20091B640 (8)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:. -4 SRINCIPAL STAFF [ TA psopp 'y q/RA ag p A/RA DiC.Gl RC akt A DOCUMEiTATION TRANSMITTAL SAO ses SGA 'il JNF pgto i To: Stone & Webster - CIO Transmittal No: CIO- 0052 PO Box 1963 Date: May 18, 1984 Midland, MI 48640 Attention: Ken Butler s 1 The documentation listed below _ is provided herewith, L was previously j provided on 5-17-84

as requested by Ken Butler Documentation

Description:

Nonconformance Report - 5063-HV l CIO has X has not been placed on routine transmittal for the described documentation. Ut4%YA Bfgnature AO 8405300356 840518 PDR ADOCK 05000329 S RDR CC RJCook,'NRC Site (w/a, unless voluminous) JJHarrison, NRC Region III (w/a, unless voluminous) DDJohnson, SMO (w/o) JGKeppler,:NRC RegioncIII (w/a, unless volu=inous) 3HPeck, SMO (w/o) NIReichel, SMO (w/o) RAWells, MPQAD (w/o) CMThompson - File 24.2 (w/a, unless voluminous) M$Y 24 g {d\\ MIO384-0001A-QLO6 4 m

~ NONCONFORMANCE REPORT g 2/1f/

1. PflOJECT NAME JOS NO.

19 20 'bV AtJk,,.I A lu Plo.,F uu%,_k z 7zzo ad 5093 P,ce. i 0,3 g

2. UNITISI kl. DRAWINGhART NO.

REY

4. ITEM DESCRIPTION

5. BTEM LOCATION

_?_ -._.h k *N*5 _ _.._ E __ nb 2 Bkte ia ) % BlJs S.\\ Vr'i' M" W "1

6. P.O. OR SPEC NO.

7. SERI AL NO.

8. REPL ACEMENT P RT 9.SOU CE

10. CONTRACIOH! SUPPLIER P/N _ Mh. R EV.E' SE R N O. d_

4 -.-t&..... -. 21Y .s_ '14. D.wnvereas Dusing

15. Equip F ur nnha il Ilv WI" I - f _y__._[3 1'A. ASME AUTHORIZED

13. SKETCH ATTACllED

/

11. INSPECTION CHITERI A o

INSP IO REQ'D tionG ty) SPEC t4 OTHER NO _ _ __ ()4 YES I)NO I ) Rec's I IConst p4 Test i ICleent i lEng N f L D 'I y 16, NdNC05FdRMikdCONDITION: 4/

24. DISI OSlilON CONCUllRENg i

1b cnLc1Au_s_wxio'xia~ PIA 1,. tslieL 'viis "? "'""- 2*~ tsi

.Cend17 no..c. ukes __Lc_mduiaLclamg_S kh L fllt] g( qcf,// h,k 3 exists.MQC.LPK3oh.

~, L on Hlm_1$' l N AS_httn ? Q M M3 nA_ VSE_N C_Mk g, lg O 46 [1R' C 0 C/1 _RA f5 __Ol d.Nf. }cu.1f f DLLh_b S 1 kR&t__h_2__Q C%@ A9 gf P 4 y p N'hk 4 shut._J.h

• 3 cdbdteO N
• 2.

......o,n,,,,,.s,.<,o., f0CI. P.2 30_ Actiait LLLad3s_LE__3_sW_in d_t"u Jerw h

17. REPORTED BY ATE

18. VALIDATE Y

ATE ~ s O_____.- _L'Y j 21. UilNG: ELD ENGINEERING ( ) TO OTH RS (SPECIF ) / t, ~ii.~ ii F eid Eog nes.Joapos.t.on Kr. eld Engineering flecommended Di to Prosect Engineenne IV u m f M G. L : DEALDI TY C, TD 8 1. ef tjCieK~EO P f C. F CJV m-lD~lbi i f ' if \\ l(( - 1 4.. ;;.,_ (L'Dd"+E P0 S )

23. PROJECT ENGINEERING DISPOSITION

\\ / Tt L E l E.LM_ E fTa lM EEENCa _fFmedM n10 E 0 Dis posamm ro U S E. AG 15. is uAlo L_16_7ijofuh1TLCjt_ 00f55 tJ71' FPFeCT T116 lijff(2f LL'f or-TRE__ h svateLm..Miccari neuen t-Qa/oc f*xcoom ozAcot.Ho_1mitcT ~ amuew,a_ces._cunu resrab r>mm ea;<aw esa2ceo- % tau;th h_l - b rot Enaiveo w p u urs tui ra n1E ! icncLdtdMW '" "" ^""'^" "^ (~eurt-iteJOEa__f?LhfMLI10M TD h 45 L5' WAfBf AS Ftu & __. _. DATE (()1 I l \\/y; JSECM Oth(bSI T I OtaEO APP 2coEO (f 7 - zs-a d. NO e u i ) AlflilOH12ED INSPECIOR g o,. t. s

1. '*w

t o ,5 }'i N O$$ Q-lG 'h g qg S 2' .a ,)

u. r. H

_b T,) E 5 h 5 N -'~ 9 t0 2 7 (

• M s k k' 5,

= o

• '1.T h

M 3 b E

• (S'*E

.8 J LS 3 d," % " 2,5 5B$Z 493 i F N* dv2 4 2 3 O a u k+ 2$s 'd ~ +9 - s ~8' )*g- [ M! -+- 3 ~2. v

• 2,

') s t3 i Wd =o 5 -r -=: + v Q.,1 E g3 4 E hs. + .+-a = u g un am v e 9r s.J di Mk* p l c: 0 0 -+$ O Jc -4. s W H 1 (Q c-N*4 - O OmM x 5 o 2-J 3 g',u Y. d 22 o' 2 o 'E *. hs U j E r 3 A u w

r

~g w f 5 f5 S h 'C k,$ ' " h @h E d,M e %b .M ch h G 4= -+-.c - a b 2 4 12}s

• E8 i q 4 ".A i G

pD o6m i 8 ., o >s b.4-

3*-

e i 3 g e s s) 2 s - Q x y L 1 0*73- .S$ h# I 'bd 2 l' i i A4 s ; Ay . 0 .c., d !M i l a%N I g$.4. /,, o,i -! I 9 5 i l -! !,.)- E ! ~<) g a r t j!7 - S ! 96!.$5k5 fl 0 t = u me 9< i. g e u-c -g, .m ~ i ;: m a 6 8 v,. - t + a-r v ;> ,,a2 q! 9 l l 1 7G a u +. -3 O! sy' s I}p 5C ] cf O 44 # 6 p c k_ 4 x s,9 ky 8_ u 3.ho. 2 e e y 4 n D't b.3 g Yma y.a S w : E , c E 5 8 gJ. .a N Q J pu u w 3 4 'h, Y s IN V 'h d.t g D 9 J O I '3 E v 3 g -+- ez ! pb,,au g' O Gr [ei Uz du e o c gc -5 r " e M'r e -E s a r d 3 Nd : lE v eg c a s: c, o Pd 4 _a L +u +". C o if

• -+- u

,Q -3 . u s:' o I, .d o 4 I O 6-{ o 4 -s a,w u. ,,,) 2 c. N e z a' u o o. 8 > *u a". o-.4-4 e,e 2# w ,a>+2 Ofs 8 om o o c e l_w

• 'E m 3 3 2 +;2 h ul r p

Rb u e g 4 w. o o u

• a z'4

is

c. c B P c a,

2cc s 'r 9 a v o-2% 4 ye p". z a :: i e - 8:o e= a , o J,, l j c 51 $ % p w, G e o9

s. J.; e x w

o = a t,e w s. _e. t : 1

1. * + g, m e._

a u, c n ~ o 23 3 g- - - o-t_ e 'g, p n a s.;. o u o 1

=-

.y y h ,c,.9

1. G, a :, $-

. O Je .c a to3 3 3 3 .; ua u ;

5. _:m )>

s a s. s a, x nr a sL .t -~ a m 1e o va 7, 3 =- u m u-s u 3-s

2 ~

t3g23 v- +. 3 oE ,e+ 3 s .c om 7 3 a c $fy Eo 39 oi c.5. c^ t 5 ~' m 8 . 7 z.e j Sa u a, Z e v n a- ~ ~v wc-m. ,z .,3 2 o o y s a s o s. 3

== .cn 3 g M.= s * - C.4 3~ b c.,_ 0J . c< x Ul 8 a f r o *

• 9 C'-

3 ?, v') Is ~*= 3

• )

A 3 5 :r N x v a c' s. -') e- , g-s o y A g -*- A. b k, f ~ ? A 6 e h, ) D 4k ~2 = - w a z,m a =- ,- I u -= o e =:- e q o,,, v 4 -> l o Q ,d m g ~~ a s

• U

^u b w",e f y J s .c v .g ..aa-- o a 27i _3 0.T-h cl y h ..O -d I - d M $

1. ' I M 6

~ I'

.I - g - uritiAt s in OPEP ATIONS t y b, g,5 : ge I D Li 3.i QUAN SillF .i l-ci a .ti 7-gNg, M s._.. n z w A E W M'i i ,,,, m.,,, c. .,, _,, s y [ 'I V.lb,. %*.) i i.- -_..m,,,,2 'I ia 1 2L)'-- ' 1 .T w ii n. w o.- i n., m-.s v. k. 4 O F r-c.g.ta ;t, G - 2 J. r w.- + c 1_. j r 'st ? i Re.dL/ 'N@ v.s...i m e a-mi _r-hr y j 5i v~ y - r-- -,.,.,. n.,,, n-. T-- X t h q,',, I i b O' y i x ~~ m ~E,w 2, E, u,..i ,o - u,,,, ~, s 'b e 'M. in,f,,,,. ~-4 g .l % 1M'- W T"' " " ' ' ~ " " ' ' y- - -r" -f+ - :-- 3 4 i < m n..- 7 p_, ,,, w im g x g,,g yg i-5~m v i,. i...., % -, e.. j _y k ~ 8 t- .. l 4 a p t r e - r*>--a e t -e. T w. =" i ~ . S. 6 ' %4-r~ s m. - _-- ifid "' ~ ' " " " l -F-N I D, i _%]- _2 _hS$'l-4,h,--- 4.,,,,,,.,,. i...n. 2.... i,,,.,...w. i-

1. 9-R--

q ph j' 7-j y'-- - g [ _r_._ __ o j. r w"~ M- * * .lq..g. r6 et)$;ewere o,,y d ( i g co,e pa.u A ,ei-e u - 5 / ,n g ; j i ; !_y,, f,[ ,, g.,.,.,,.,,, ,y,, r 2-{ m Aucc.insg. i M *"*> g ~,. au , Uggwut (' ! ~L o,n, 'I .~ C, w.m r BT - ,1cw%MN!'Jt*LU0 ttM .. A.c. r er.~- .0 L ! amo o t' *. ' ' ',.aj - !--{- e =4g' (, y9,. v w SZdi ' ~ - ' o'. t/ s I _ ( ..' N ',-[ IV -iMM ~ ( '^ h(iU~ ~ ~ ' e ' "~"' "^" O . h o E i " *Jd.; 9' ! I W-1 5I i_- t ...mr...n e e. n:m n m.m. r. ~~l'~'"'", r' I UD I norn Mu::',it ') r ?"

E, 16'8.s,..>...n.,.

- -- i _[h_ 7__L'._ i <,,,,c i h) r m Ino. W E>'i 2 MWW 6'rv P T-"' # - U-g 'r ': [ I -I62 - M'u-G 'I'c'! ! " ' ' l'I ~ y 7 nm rar ;t ? r m ;ut r..$is-e G G E.B.L Mi,<... t T Fv M o " M. o

="",n ? 2 CRIT! CAL

-m gI;i g,~l%...dSE j t, . e = $ = (,e I 5.y ~ -.mn___ ron eATtwts Ano cxnatiotas ccc sur.Tcit no. _m...satt_i_.,cz., o g j

t. f a, j

e l', _l]', conomo::s Fu l Fy F: 8ta I r.otrs I '- Mb G' ? u (f l ITT GRIMMELL ~ .-/ ~ ,i j "tPE H3 P!GFIt DIVISIC!I Of SIGN '. ' _l~ EI.

1) All tolettesces in *tcordance

~- F '. I ~ ~~~'l~~~ . 4 M,. -+-. g -t ', q.- - - - - .7 . *--- b..- ! ' ' ' - -~ ~ ' , ', N)'

) F.. h. P-e,c y.lu e.- I+c'af 301.,u

. t ). a t th CCP, T. VI il 13. '.0. __n_ 3..n'i f 3t if.1Hf Wi. --f '*1 h' l '" Y I ,g FLfG^ ~ [ e t,- l_'i ~ -- } - - [ -l I ;l .' ?.i f /Oh!.__ { l 1.: s. 8

$) All n%' w.

6. d..;i 4 h p s g g~g N/ , i ;, I i,, ;. l,'g,g- - - - - - - v *f 3 0,: .p ; -) cccur.11.Ac 2 1' h a': f, k 11C tid. I ~o,<,f.-,) s t,. fag t c... ] i,.,* j *u* ci';Cale i tou ., J: :r:t c'.:t.--_c_i_._ _ _-. \\ i ' I 5 N ? U - N N_.".'..I ,Q O~le', P ". j ' '. ' I' II I' f I

• ' u~

> i U tO II 'M ' ' e C e,g,, l e 3,, # 'i g L....f .i, "s .. -...' f i l f 1.. c l l; U'* I }: s, ', ar is c es * ** IT e fb --M lidC --k I *li h. 'l.',

• t. " '.,.. ' -- 1..,' (. )., _=. j -

[ .~[\\.-~.]. ,y 4"p __ g. >--j.[, b' 10 ,ap; ~ ! t-h' ' h_ 5"h*L _ _ ' _ '. _ '. ', ~~b Otn. C L AM :"#' _ ~ '* _ [.j / U l " " __ h ',, v. ir...cMir4 . s ~ 1 ll s I I. e . a. as m.s .m I

4 , M,I f I I t \\ f I A b N q / a \\ '9 iC y

m. p

)h f s A I a o I i i o

-a

$y

u a%

~ 1 ~ $g-9 }b o lA I d u M e I l p j h, -);f ? i 'T N j ~<,Q s e

A, in i

-n A l f: C ,i A\\ h ,a 1, . c 3 2 s e c. 7- 'Q j d 5 J., / i<a d h d$ ~f .~ a a i x c 3 ~ i ?) w ,u p 3 hN .[ @ '1 lq Q d* J h g at q n ,' gal l I f h 1 h. jlS ~ I e ? l l l } l ll

S g.

l;.I i 1 4'ar 1 l l l l l h fl; 0{ B; j $ P;1 (x j > c

l C

I s '*m "' ?.\\ a h f i< g 2 fl ' l ~ C 8 2 + jn' S1 .i p E +u8% l 3 3 { p Q ii e i. 1 i 0 31 / ~ .l;js i ,Y I, l w E r f l I x j e i I y .f5<p._ I l f o 0 1 l' i i ? 4 c O ~* t O 2 I ) j s. i e' F f > d 1 l ~ i 1 I O l l'f l -

or-

,Yl 5, .c l l# In ! h b' h ' l >; r l l I -L 9 q .6 i I lQ. e 0 i l b. h :pd hy te n ;j Id 1 1 u lz .a M, s -c 1 te 1 4 l m ' m 'lI f i lk l )&l.h 2 1 ~ u ,m ~ i t lll l l II l - li C Q bl_ l c E; ') i

Q I

r I r 7 T

.:' 1 .s mm.sv---- ~ J t i l I h d i )'s,i to tp sL11'd r J J ~ t I d cl. w,..Qf., =b..E,5Y? . b] bY W 7 a, e, ,n o a I 8' o M,l n f ?;d,l l Y O 4-O S US $ h'0? -i' 5 S.7) Ogo} ES y i, il g Q]:[s(s,a., y -. I >*M- .N d e'. 7 8* 6 a '#O'nu $,,( 7 $y , g [o 1 = u j!u-hE,gjnj *l 4 n [;f b' f o.1 ..i n w.i --i-c m

r u'

4 co.: u,u - m 1,l- ,.2, n d. e. 'r ; t NI p, ii If \\, % t...A.?,.

• • >,;i3

'w m^ s. o' f Cl ap6WR1551 s / c2: 9. 1 'I 7 Cr M 7 p h.) ko l ! ! N L sWp %_ J 5Pi C I J a eo La ( =- 20 a tt 3

M.1

. a* ,q-,- j gge - = - " e v, w [. ~ ' 3\\, N 3 ? hh I. il t-- W J 8 t . oa to 4 ~, _ T. ,m .e et. U* ig 4):I.d 0;"-

• g

.I r 1 ' h c. e i C.$ *g,0 !.] M i i C 9 r. j\\ . o.

• y' J

g f, I.(

t. *

'e r e ' a.-

• 2

-d, g a e'a .h IIJ,tidl2 ,j i @ e G M5 .j s 4

$d d'<

4 'u ( M 1.L C i 'p} lE5'c-n,m[i 't: It s 2,%

1. 2 I

r y ix g n.L.a i i i.- v A I . _I.. ' j i s N C Y [ h l Nf,,l a a j s' i'l d. gg ? y g /v 4 C -1 ( 0.. 3 x - N7 h ip c :.',! U '- , =,.. = 1. 3 .' t O 5 U 'gj { 3 I,l ; I, E !3 i ii l }. 'u -- = t. L; b' O ..d 4... ;

a. eu J

.i g

r.

e id f {, R Ty 2 i e 2M i ~ L5O_l; sFij I p I,13%; .i W-nq s 2 g i i-e 3 - T

5-,,,

0 5 l -- -t

o..'

p> 0 lr I..,:. X .i . D1 .- M h] ~ W (%- .t._ V\\ t;... F d' 3- ,l [O d: I e (- l}* e n I 1 ~

s.,

.\\* y

t,' ;

.'N 4 < ~. r i q f 4 k ' f* ~ { k u m .\\ i ts D

• e t

i i X a -l c i a. n <3 u-si-L g E9CE-# {-)E Sk ;o y s6ed \\._i ,;a '~ w-n.

F. m O b* N 4 .3 y-tn ?W G gte i x> i s s 34* e: 3 ?wtats s v e. '1 3 g n 1 i, ~ a l [ h IO !i !E l

$ $.' I T

j [ t : eJ j y 3=, N s e 9 e i: f j a e c: uJ gg I h I I ";l h 3 E >;1 Ull NY 4 I '; J 4 % c. v + w m "9 e E % C

• 4 d

i 9 J i7 i i C ,s 1 i .o q z h h i hI = i d = t !q+14)3 h hi e i h l! T

• 5 i

8 !3l ! Li v' " g, 1$ i z y l l i I i o E l l 1 I ,t i I i a i c. j q g u z !.s ea j i c l "? I l l j ,e o i i i i i .o r l d gO t a l i g J. I i j i j i l 3 a i o A 4 a t e i I i ,4 + l 9 i j l I dl h l !I 'F i i i 5 i n 9 i ,i 5 1 M g J "c f,..! i i I f V i I e $ )8 a {' e i i l i o 9,,3 e y .a 4 w c ! = 1 {

• f I

I i . Od lM d ( 3 l fN l fj' O i I l l j W l 3 y a l { b I s j i 4 8% ,w i i I l i !. lN

G i

l I ,R I H l i i i . H l l I i i i i i i s i t - 2 - ;e

f. e' T t 2 2 4 I ,p .a 8, P a. p p p p W p o 2 2 2 o o a o o o e o o e o o o o o h) C C g C a w = a a a 'J s E g = g g w C C e s 3 .s .c -3 2 2 2 c .c o c o o a o c i 'I l .Z o I. .E o 2 o f. o u o o 1 o u o .i. o E o 3 .I - .,5 o 2 .I 5 1 g u s e c v g u E = r u E 5 E. 5 S a E 3 6 o 3* : 3 o 1 3 o a I u E 5 .E. 't 2 , j E t I E. 5 2 j J d :' o = u u e 5 u e = = e = = = c 'g _= = = c gg w u u u o w u .u .u w u u u o E=l p 8 2 2 ' u I u u g g c e I E E c 2 2 s C t c 3 3 3 g 14 o o o o o o o .= o o 8 E a e a 2 E E a s a 3 g .a e a 3 a l g' g w 6 6 . g i 6 6 6 6 = E $. 2 3 o I N s 2 i 't E . Q Q 1 f. 5 z \\ ~ pj.~' ; 7 -J ' se .i. . p... e ity. 3 .G e e = re. 3 .7 y r p<o v.'(i - -:. 3 4

• -4 +- < - <d o.? o :. o., *o e

/ r-o,. a.: o -W, p*.,Q**.?f'. o e o o o a o

• ..G -

g g 3 -f t - g ^, . W .*y ' y-g ' */' - a ~W E a C,@ a

7... -T - -

~- ~ ~ ~ 4 r n g g g g ..e 7; < 2 = = = i i i I g g g -o r g g o a o e O e I 2 E 2 o. i o

o. !

= 2 = = s = 8 2 a. 8 . u. o a u 8 .u o o e o e 1 2 c 2 .E s u e e u s u u t o a a E o a 4 e 1 $ 'aI t. I E I. I I i o 7* I $' I.. t S j E u. e 1 u u m u e = g e a v u o u a u u w a o u = 1 i "1 w- - = = t :j w u u-u. = = = = t.1 I t. t. =. I t. I t I

a..f. [.- t I

5 = g i =. = g ~ r =. = E E t:. : 3 o e o g 5 a o e o o o e o o o o o.- i 5 s s s .= = s, 3 I I s g t. o o o o i y z o o o 3 c I a g i 3 8 8 8 i 3 = 8 .t = g i = = i l y h g g g g s v u u u I o a o a o. l g o u s s o s I. J .z o 8 E E I 'E 8 8 j E u .e u W g,.D. 1 u g ~ / u u u w u.. ~ s g w u u. u w u o u u u 8 R W E k "], O I I I 8 E. E !.-l I a 2 8 E R W 6 I I t I a a a s x i < z r I e , _,., -,.. - _, _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -. _ _.., _. _. _., _.. _ _}}