ML20091G959

Provides Document Control Assurance Group Final Response to Nonconformance Identification Rept 027 Re Deficiencies of Document Stations 59 & 501

ML20091G959
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	05/25/1984
From:	Quamme D CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To:	Karr J STONE & WEBSTER, INC.
References
27907, CSM-0778, CSM-778, LWW-27-84, NUDOCS 8406050002
Download: ML20091G959 (2)

Text

-

J - -

y6 I

kN ig const!msrsh{[g Dean L Quemme Site Manager 1 ~-

a Midland Project

~ , li ,Y s

-a Midland Proact: PO Box 1963, Midland. MI 48640 . (517) 631-8650 , PRINCIPAL STAFF MA %C DPRP t ['d May 25, 1984 D/RA DE A/RA DRMSF 1C URMA 1

j AO SCS Mr J E Karr

~ Stone & Webster Michigan, Inc. 1 TA ML /

P O Box 1963 e File /.er '

Midland, MI 48640 MIDLAND ENERGY CENTER PROJECT - GWO 7020 STONE AND WEBSTER CONSTRUCTION IMPLEMENTATION OVERVIEW NONCONFORMANCE IDENTIFICATION REPORT NUMBER 027 DATED 03-31-84 FILE: 24.2 SERIAL: 27907 CSM-0778 LWW 27-84 Stone and Webster Nonconformance Identification Report 027 identified defi-ciencies of document stations 59 and 501. The following items address each of the concerns identified. This is Document Control Assurance Group's final respoase.

• Drawing revisions and attachments at work stations could not be reconciled with status as reported with the DDR.

DDR is now being converted to show field drawing distribution and ammend-ment status on the same register. FDCC personnel perform drawing, revision and amendment verification check prior to distribution to the field.

The DDR was checked by DCAG and attachments for Design Drawings / Field Revi-sions were corrected to reflect all outstanding attachments.

l l ~*It was determined that the registers could not be used to establish which changes should be distributed to holders of the parent documents.

1 An established field distribution list (FDDL) exists for drawings. All l

incoming amendments nre distributed to their parent drawings per the FDDL.

In addition, drawing the DDR is status and amendment now being on theconverted to show same register. field FDCC distribution,le-estimates comp tion by 7-31-84.

• Discrepancies existed between controlled drawings used by BPCo field engineers and controlled drawings in BPCo DCC. The following items address each of the concerns identified.

Case 1, Item A - Rev 12/F1 was incorporated into Rev 15. DDR was checked I and project Dwg. (Rev 15) reflects the applicable attachments.

Item B - IDCN 24589 was indicated on Rev 13 on 1-29-84.

Item C - IDCN 24587 was indicated on Rev 14 on 2-10-84.

Item D - Detachment A was changed on Rev 13 on 1-29-84.

Case 2 and 3 Spocifics identified in case 2 and 3 are related to HVAC items. HVAC Zack l

' does not receive or use field revisions for their activities.

has an ongoing status assessment program and use only the current design document. Zack is not a part of the CCP.

• In the interim period prior to conversion of field revisions into design Field engineers will use current design drawing along with drawings,ision field rev while performing status assessment.

• Prior to initiation of Phase II work and in accordance with the Construc-tion Completion Plan (CCP), The drawing used to inspect any commodity will be compared with the latest revision of that drawing at the time the commodity is released for construction.

\

l gg$$s oIS8h wd N, t 2

n -

~

. '~ .

.Page 2 Serial: 27907 CSM 0778 May 25, 1984

• This review will insure that any drawing changes affecting the status assessed commodity will be implemented during the construction phase of the CCP through punchlists or corrected through the existing, FCR, FCN, or NCR program, as applicable.

Should you or your staff have any questions on the content, contact Lonnie Worley at extension 7707.

DLQ/LWW/jpf/ pal CC: BBurgess. NRC Resident Inspector JJHarrison, Chief, Midland section, Region III Dehorn, MEC DDJohnson, MEC J5Kepplerf,TRegionalrAdminis traioE CRAgion':III BHPeck, MEC NIReichel, MEC RASpellman, MEC RAWells, MEC LWorley, MPQAD e

d l

l rn r- 1--*w --

.-,r --,w +

wwy . y - - -T-- er w - - , = - --, a-+-+g w ,--