ML20091J099

Forwards Nonconformance Repts C-03018,C-02181 & C-02818-HV Re Voids in Grout,Upper South Anchor 1-3/8 Inch from South Edge of Plate,Lower North Anchor Installed 2-5/8 Inch from C4 Embed & Upper North Anchor 4-1/8 Inch from C4 Embed

ML20091J099
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	05/25/1984
From:	Kinne J CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To:	Ridge J STONE & WEBSTER, INC.
References
CIO-0057, CIO-57, NUDOCS 8406050392
Download: ML20091J099 (12)

Text

,

f 'o-1

^i,

t PRitg,lPAL STAFF WW8 dA ~l MTRP i

J/RA DE V

A/RA

-TAS F 3C WA AO 3CS

[AA DOCUMENTATION TRANSMITTAL

'4 L

_)

=NF File /lW To: Stone & Webster.- CIO Transmittal No:

CIO- 0057 PO Box 19630 -

Date:

May 25, 1984 Midland, MI 48640

.fj !

s.-

Attention: John Ridge The documentation listed below _ is provided herewith, J was previously provided on 5-22-84

as requested by John Ridge Documentation

Description:

Nonconformance Reports:

C-03018 C-02181 C-02818-HV CIO-has X has not been placed on routine trans=ittal for the described documentacion.

AAGlW 4f Q S(inature b

1 RJCook,'NRC Site (w/a, unless volu=inous)

JJHarrison, NRC Region III (w/a, unless volu=inous)

DDJohnsen, SMO (w/o)

JGKeppler,*NRC Region III (w/a, unless telue:. nous) l BHPeck, SMO (w/o)

NIReichel, SMO (w/o) 0g RAWells, MPOAD (w/o) k i

CMThompson - File 24.2 (w/a, unless volu=inous) 0406050392 840525 g1 M10384-0001A-QLO6 PDR ADOCK 05000329

)

(

PDR 8

h-

l 16 NCR NO.

I l-l l

gh

/$

[

- hI$1.AND PROJECT

.h a

5 au 17 QATE ISSUED 18 REY quai.ITY AssusancE DEPARTMENT NONCONFORMANCE REPORT 9- # V O

is PAGE \\

OF T 1 ITEM LOCATION hM LM kOhDED LAAIb % b M CI -

~5 N

~

L 4. ITEA SERIAL No.

U 2 ITEN OftANING/PART NO.

3 ITEM PART NA E N.M -7MM - LEM aM1 bI b M.L b G G aOf buMZF 5 ITEM DESCRIPTION A tl S oO_C' s 0G*

990TT 6 ITEM STARTU SYSTEM N0.

7 REFERENCE DocupD T 8 ASE A.N.I IRED "2.G M

O h 9d"d 9 Ml'2L M Pl.

O TES NO 9 IR5PECTICN RE NO.

LOS NO.

REY 110.

10 RESPONSIBLE ORGANIZATION 8/A

1. M N

O ONST12M en rd 11 NONCONFORMANCE DISCOVERED CURING:

O DESIGN O RECEIYINE CNST O m rm Ix5PECT O POST INSPECT O TuiuiOysm O p0ST Tvius0vER O $"

O F O vsxINSPECT T

Q 12 RECUIRDOT

} q,g(o pm (..$ (ZT-QLilEGS 6,@Ls? 'T O EE 1 A31GCT9t> 'T"O QOw PLQTEL" Fi g.(,,

we oot.ss

() 4-y(. 93,u ts.2. \\.1 EGnuiass 1Eca.T Hot.esTo ET. c% bc<.woou 1 Ya" 1 Li %NEEH'ux1E

'tmm (2.sotuve.es w as.u s m a s ) L " 1e > G d 6 6 o r P L.eg s

@ M-ut, b a.t 1.a., Esquiew yTur wo.g we.s gs ioggyu.esd i w Ac.coenwe s toimN b co n s 13 NONCCNFORMANCE d \\) oim & fist

• t u TM G E.cou7

@ U 99ed. 6ou:sw eWicweR. is 13/8' 1:can toum e-dc,c op et.ur.

W %426S MMW hcmg,Gn40uTGb A-elCHsits AGE 10STFh.l.nd s,

14 RCR CRIGINATED BT (PERSON) SL. y-as-/y klcs otS2. 40Wi% R*1CN tb I MSTnu C-b 7 *ft5-g, g gg y.pg em a. 4 e-nen o,TE b 4 OcCf POQ.TM,/W1cMCt W )06TNLA.ED 4 'h$ '

15 NCR CRIGINATED ST (DISCIPLINE)

M

1. dN.

(*w C.i & B1E-D 20 NUMBER OF HOLD TAGS (IF APPLIED) 21 LOCATICN CF HOLD TAGS Ed $LYr#/ptf^

22 POTENTIAL 50755(e) 24 ACTICN ITEM NO.

26, ITEM PRIORITY CODE NO.

28 R I '

BT:

'~~

O TES No

[0?[0l b N c'(\\k W ETL 212 -

23 REPORTED TO MANAGER 25 015CIPLINE:

27 CATE:

i EdT'"0 CODE-- 3 N c1l

,y z s e+

I j l H

E E' - A o c o t CONTINUED ON REVERSE F-2.*f / lA (Rev 1) l h

t' a.

29, CAUSE h kOf.Eko46H19

@ WKt* @ %P f

@ NM4*w QQc.sm n l

30 PROCESS CORMCTIVE ACTION O m3 %

Qan m.

31 REctN U SED OISPOSITION 32 CONDITIONAL M LEASE REMDRE O 3CaAP/ maECr O ' REPAIR USE AS IS C TEs O no 1 *IL M 7_

4

-j f 31A A0blYIONAL INFORMATION I

i 33 OISTRIBUTION FOR ACTION 34 OI5705ITION CONCURA D CE PROJECT FIELD E M INEER DATE MPQA0 CONCURR DCE DATE PFQCE (ASE )

DATE PQAE (ASE)

DATE LEAD DESIEN ORS DATE CP Ce SM (for turned over systems)

DATE l

A.N.I. (ASE )

GATE 35 OISPOSITICN ACTION TAKEN 36 METH00 0F DISPOSITICN ACTICR VERIFICATION 37 NCR CLOSED ST RESULT OF O!$ POSITION ACTICN VERIFICATION IF UNACCEPTABLE. REFERENCE

""C" '" " "E" O ACCEPTast!

O uMACCEPTAst!

PPQA0 QATE A.N.I. (ASME)

GATE l'

l l

c

- _j

1 NCE NO.[ d y / g l-

,uzDLAsD rnonct g

, WU A8N as DATE ISSUED y-2.0 -/t/

der N l

30scourosnascz arronT PAGE 3 Or CONTINUATION M Eterr 12_ Cf)dr l

((.) 6.-tJL ( rants "E- ~hT huar-c mor M/' 6 ecum, ecmc M-ihm i s:-h da 1.GCs TMA o 7 " F h 6 4 C W M5b4

-~

I i

l i

1 i

'l I

l.,

l 1

F-2M/1B (Ru 'l L

J

1....

.mJ=>==

ORIGINAL 1T

-m.

naran w sT NONCONFORMANCE REPORT J-N-/V C

19 al. y f 0F d $544 PAGE 1 ITU LOCATIM g /.[' /t/ a.T t d g[7, // 'p

• jd4ST d[

7, p/

f l

d Auv.AlAt.

Rso No. aK A-anD m r m n & o

2 ITa ORaulneDant n0.

3 I1tM PART NA M 4, ITD SU!AL NC.

faz-m.2 HBc.ss;p. -t-M/

S ~,a /l Go a P.w L.a-T' A//n

\\

5 ITU DESCRIPTION s: _ // Re.e % L. win-T~d&sel< ed N l:u.a A}a.15 3 // 8C-552-1 s 1Tu sTAaluP sisTu no.

i REFnaCE mCauNTSpot. At JS/, A s ASE A.N.I. REQUIRED 3 AJ A O TEs Cl-we' 10 RESPSSIBLE OASANIZATIM REY y/

fat.a< % Lec Nok LOS 30.

INSPECJIONRECORDNO.

9 A// -

A)fA-8.lf 11 NONCORFORMACE DISCOVUG DURIM:

O DEsIsa O RECEIVIm O ConsT e e lsAsE FM 1RSPECT O PasT tasPECT O Tunn0vu O Post Tunn0vEn OF O'rinkivu O evn tesPECT 12 REQUIREMNT fk 5"/~4 /{eT'o og T s 5 6 a f u A c C o u d e k C.er. LA) ' $ < b yj/sc v eb Des f g, Qs-ce w.'ssg Ass O S at-- P1" 3 3(o b f

13 nonCCnFORMnCE q g,fg,,,,

No (.ga $

pa,,, gf yg Q r c n L o,}s[u. api, yn g4 $,f,y Q,,,w;u rio-r.,,

a sieas., eige q rr.,

i rs a (TT*8iTf'9).

.,w J

14 CRI TED (PERSON) cA C.# p prefy N %ff/'

/

g y

o urt -

15 NCR CRIGIRATED 87 (0!$CIPLINE) 5'.0/d l'""*,e 's. e ou ; s c ( /*1er l e

(s su g)

- a..a...n s. a h At# eta 0F MOLO TAG 3 (IF APPLIED) 21 LOCATICN CF HOLD TAG 3 ON&

$1&

L h'. W l> A f ~I~~

22 POTENTIAL 50.55(e) 24 ACTION IT U NO.

26.! TEM PRIORITY CODE NO.

25 O Yts Q=0 sosa62 7

ggg MMGEA 25 OISCIPLIM:

27 TRD O CODE

\\

CATE:

REPORTEDTO74 u -0 4 3 w/gr 23 0

v CONTINUED ON RKYERSE F-2M/1A (Rev 1) l

\\

D

4..z, s 4 4%ja o cAmt GJo ~/d s.ene $417 a essess: Causena mim Om 911ii en m.

n - essresmu n

1. i n Comemsm. auAst O sama O sCmF/ m aCT Bilienza BilifE a is O ns k

e nA AantitemL InteamT1on s) gjgg)g g*$ : pnygg gy ;ua,;g7o g (u m j

Qov9h As 'C~W< Wad.

3) @ e va <% _ R.e ye W.TT:an.2ti fet. S,*ec. /st -3 3 b fa se. 6".* / b o 3 e i

i a us=En. = ACum I ao -# G, a ni,em -

5,$ e M / 6 L u

<4.s / dn a a / L i mao s7l0la im-l p. myna anma ma som Cmamma

= =.

,,wa cAs=>

==

AlA roe <ASa) un

./

Y h. Y rfI k B 4-Afjq

.b LU b

~

LEAS RESI M M 8 J, DATE CF Ce SW (for turned over systems)

SATE g

A.N.I. (ASE)

BATE 35 015P05 m ON ACTION TA m 4

e i

36 MTNW OF BISPOSITIM ACTIS m!FICATIM 37 NCR CLOSED ST RESULT OF St3P05mm ACTim MIFICATIM IF UNACCEPTABLE, REFDMCE mom un O AcarTAsu O umCCamsu A.a.I. (ASE)

SATE

)

n

NCE NO.

C-02181

• . O FBIMECTORIGIN p p

'. - =

= = -

z., -

o unmenrwCEM&BCE REPORT (4 -

PAGE 3 OF d M g couTInu& Tion saEET p

13 )

sk a s -fa - ~.n u - (cn.rs }

d e n % / m L.,. m - a c co /h %..r. n. ) i A s eu e.

>=n:< r.

/n t r " :ws Loxn rw G2'Da.ou- &;ouco h 7 Ah a-L /:.L r7 a w # f, 5 67& m Faex A'/ 3X3' 7"~S..

l l

P l

l l

l F-2x/in (Rev 1) i.

_,2 n

i

0~ OEIOI SA

., Mint.AND PROJECT QUALITY AssunANcz DATE ISSUED ggy

-DEPARTMENT 3 -3o-84 o

NONCONFORMANCE REPORT PAGE d 0F d CONTINUATION SEIIT Bloc K 31^

( cour. )

PR o3 ECT E M G i U EERI N G-D *5 po~s i YthM ITEM di PR o -J E C T E N GIN EE R/MG CoNeuRJ 68YH THE Fi s_to

' DJE i s i.r '

p m ug EM Gt M EG RisJG p_gcomug u nsp ai5 postys'cw -Teo F~ s t - M - 2 H G C-( s 2. M i c.9 ) R. 3-

.A n b

c. 4. L-c u t. Av i cN 4.c o -

do 7 7 (9 ) E4 HAVE Pie E M issusb To r2EFL-E c7 AMD coAUhy IN s-r4 L v E D co M D i fleN As D e r c. PJ f3 EC

[4 B 1,cz. ld

(% oF MC il.

i

1. 1gH 42 P R O 3 ECT f 46f MEEPjNCr con CU P J Le t'T H THE p.g g E9CsI H EEPJ NCr D is P O S1 1 l O ro P. E P A ) P I.

i M l d ed d Ar

~

ru +-t a 4-

' emg/

j l

I I

l l

t l

F-2M/lB (Rev 1)

[

(

~

g Is ata m.

l*-022/9 Hi/b %w MIDE.AEB PatWECT g mg gsag gg g,

W Y-,Y-99' O

omr m NONCONFORMANCE REPORT ORIGINAL I o.

11.

sa. sa - ei.sgse476.* +r's. ordD x 7#a or@

, u. -..

,o.,-

.. u., _..

pst-/na Aed-SSD-/-N3(c)/A rst-in. 2H8t-SSa - /-H3 N/A s IT m s acaIrr! m M //.$ S/71ati Bot f s op M a r 6 ITM STMTW 575T5 me.

7 EMEME g Aseg A.N.I. REWIRED

&&JA WZPd30 rd!PQ30-DS-/

O ns E no 53r W 51 ELE W AABIZATI M s InIFBCTIs MCMB W.

LOS NO.

MV W.

10 lbVS7 ale"MA/ / $ Wdd $ N $

P230-/32vil.2hB' C-S.C-l/B *LA5"747 O

11 N 013COME0"IE8 O DESIEE O RECEIVI M O CBST '

O PELIASE PW IEWECT E post Ins m er O Tanuma O post Tu m ova OF G 'T b O canInspect I2 RE@IENET j f$g7p23dpjtA3.V.3b 6vn22Mes-/.57 ports..'mgcotrA<erep sqiDS seca Be th wnay sure ererAgq or omer owne menmMS. Do.su, zs, srsus),

a. ARrA23<&msA : dQba, e ea.coas s7sres... Veen etuendees ofAss stasissweisessss ses As Sa7es '

/. ASA/WSI?WAdOW 7bW NY'7HF/S7fMCfft/f/Dff/72V7) /7b3//s. Ssp I fl/'2DHs; Afes of/ddf#Pdf7Ffid$osV 2 fearasaf 7o~ 7c~ hao4 7wetc./SddrsesferAerateE/VP/A"Asv 76/rBer70/71 l

t

1. fSDP&L7~-P&S DPAMd6 CAttS Me ///7l/W r$s 'O&)

l f

14 IG CRIGINATED BT (PD50R)

/ Y A Nennbd/ ??/23 *YW8V

/

O(4Ela5 A..SidrV47L Mn 15 NCR ORIGINATO BT (DISCI, LIM)

/?l MAD /7?fdV'-//A46fdS IJ lasWR W ima TAA5 (IF APPLIIB) 21 LOCATIE W MOLS TM5 l

/Yfd2'.$ //2771 $

22 MTUTIAL SS.SS(e) 24 ACTIM ITM EO.

26.ITM MINITY CODE NO.

N NCE RETIDED BY:

M -97 SD 66'l7 S~

ffpf C. O d seems To no mesa a oIsCtrum:

27 Two est un rf mn MA n1 pyy-q. j y -g y

' carmann as arvaass F-zu/1A (see 1)

t o Can a naass Cassma ACn=

Om O=

om m.

n Commau. auASE n nacanema orsresma O amam OCas/must O mma O us As is Om Om m Amman twomana 33 0137R!affim M ACT!m x armame -

f M FNLD MINER Daft IWQASCSCW DCE DATE PPQCE (ASM)

GATE

\\

Pons (AsE) ma 1

LEAS DESI M M QATE CP Ce SS (for turned over systems)

DATE A.N.I. (ASE)

DATE 35 O!3POs m 05 ACTI M TA S 37 nCR CLOSED BY O METNN OF BIlpts! TIM ACTIN VUIFICATIS mMT OF SISMEmW ACTIE mIFICAT13 IF WACCIFTABLE. REMEDCE MPQAO Daft AC3PTAALA UNACCIFTAALI i

A.N.I. (ASE)

MH r

e --- - - - - -, - - - -

,w,.,--r e-,,-n-

--n v-,--

\\*

.. Rid..:..._-

c >'g;g n.

-),

. g.

g g

l X

t

.h

'p lues eg g

• )

l l

1Elthd b

g nhi u

__ D-

,S

<?S i

i g

E r i

~

m TH l

i I

pf!

zm g

l s

i I

... 3 9 e.

s l_C p

\\

, 2 a

1 1 Q

ay h

6$ j @

g m

1 l g

, I g g

,- E h[

g i

g e g 5

l i

g n

% I bas.:

- 5 j.

1 I

e1 I

@l g

1!

I i

e g 9 g 0-s g s m

e 4

3 4

R E g

g I I

=

il l lll $

y 3 f g(

i E

$ I 3

r-a g

! g 2 j 8-l l

tehJil m

I ;.

e i

t e e

r e

i m. i s s-i i

n :w e! $ l

$q 5 i i

l 5

,[

89M I

=

=$

g I

t

~

hp a

e

, w a i

.n y g

z Y j i

i t

u ;

'l t e

l I

g g

~

s 5

a 1

m e.l t

b s u a.

ia l l ! ! !e si 6

=

n y

i in

~

si !

nT y m frz%

tH i N$

y b5

.E e

g Id S

j k

Qn

' F.F 5

h

• w=

l a

(M:g'll-C yo R

a s on u t.

=

m

. l-m g $ $pg$

jibe DD I y

E 3

c i l

di il 1

y p

p a

, s 3

y a

Tis e

u s

s 5

.,e s{g y

n-w n

Q f

i Wi

- O' g:.

s e-6

. 11 s

/1 1-T< :-<,

".; (

P'*> l O gl@

s

.N

~

1 x -su Q

- //

e' 5:-<

E a

+

$=:lEg y b 5

8 s

e g

+

e s-a

.:qishg5l"-

__. d j l s

nunos umno s

${

s y

g t9619aty..N 4gll S

5 5 '-

8

I p.

• (<h

. *.ht y s z,

's',.

,.g.

~-

p e

.9 =

m m x

s s

0 7.::n 1

l l

7 h J M s

3 i

44 fj

?

j~

I s

5 i ;

g ri l R

?

i i i i

%s i i i F' 1 l V 4 +

W r

T

,1 lill.M c

l

. i.,

~

3 g l ] ]

l i

r.

g e

P g :ll' i l r

v 8 E

8 I ! I g

5 g

B iil l.ll l g :

g i

i g 2 j 8

l

.I m

4NJ ii l !!

[

f E$

i f>i E

iU t

i n ha l s

e e

s s

i i

l-u w l $

9

$! j l lt

?

i g,j E92 tl i 5

5 e

a i ;

a s u

l y

1 l

Y j I

7 t

ggi l'd

~

k p

g l

I

~

~

7, 5

~'

a g g g

=

183l!

1 e :

a s a

s l s i pr I!ll rII {.k !

If 4

~

l i

%a, an (rz%

e $

si e.!

i I-5 g

k {

h's 9 1*

E a

5 8

l qi y 3

$ l g

3!4

'il' g

.y.y c

n a

an a. yi s

1 m -

I g iD D.;a5,:

,w 3p '

8 m

mg w-32 ih.t\\ i 1

m i

n 9

.I c

h l.1 p

a v.

$g g

c e

h

\\kh s

T l

j nu

-===

3 g

3

'gg l

W l

' '\\ v.

=

1 y

• '~

g Eg

{

'gik O 's 4

5 e

../,u T c:.f.$ I. i$i e

i W8l i

a

-. g, y a

[._ h h

'+ d 6 gg wl1

,g

_6 I

,"A ap e

s s5-

, t, e u.y

.