ML20215A234

Informs That H Schierling Gave Orders to Destroy Restricted Documents DKM-7-84 on 840802

ML20215A234
Person / Time
Site:	Diablo Canyon
Issue date:	08/14/1984
From:	Morton D EG&G IDAHO, INC.
To:	Novak T Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML20213E750	List: ML20213E747 ML20213E752 ML20213E783 ML20213E788 ML20213F010 ML20213F018 ML20213F073 ML20213F078 ML20215A023 ML20215A063 ML20215A107 ML20215A144 ML20215A168 ML20215A234
References
FOIA-86-197 NUDOCS 8612110217
Download: ML20215A234 (4)

Text

"

,,...m..- - . - . -- 4- - -

_ _ . . _ . . . . _ . . . . . ~ . . .~ _ _ . . . . . .i .

6qi d i.) ~ '

[jij

! . .d.-

• j,L-

1. )

} [ EGzG . .  ! gpt ,

l;.j P.O. BOX 1625, IDAHO FALLS, IDAHO 83415 thi p [

g?_

f August 14, 1984 2r g

L'

.: 2 Mr. T. M. Novak L Assistant Director for Licensing Division of Licensing i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission e Washington, D.C. 20555 i ,

DISPOSAL OF DIABLO CANYON RESTRICTED DOCUMENTS - DKM-7-84 h5 W

Dear Mr. Novak:

7. t' M On August 2, 1984, Mr. Hans Schierling indicated that both T. K. Burr and B I could destroy the restricted documents which you had sent us via your June 1, 1984 memorandum. The documents (Copy #6 and #7) were the in camera

$j! transcripts of the meeting on May 22, 1984, in San Francisco. Both Copies

.jy} #6 and #7 were properly disposed of per the Department of Energy's procedure A 'f for destroying secret--restricted data. This process was witnesscd by myself and EG&G Idaho security officer H. E. Schnuckel. If I can provide O any further information to you, please telephone me at FTS 583-1274.

s.

ig Very truly yours, w

is h.V.h f3 D. K. Morton jp Applied Mechanics Branch ll; jb

%7.? cc: J. O. Zane, EG&G Idaho

[9 6

M W%

W

im POI W

w W

w m

O; f7

!. - y 8612110217 861205

/' }

PDR FOIA PDR ,/

M HOLM9586-197 l0 /

Q N-

-: d /

w-vm m=umum w nnw.awaw a x ww= w w -

v..--

fg.,

t  ?. .

fG d- , .e o -.

%M~ YgpL1 L-e -- reC t. s.r sn. ~L n --

1.,1 1 L i. 1.

._1 i.

,,,R ~y._

n. 9 ,*-* l- C f<a i ~

I' - - .,'

g jCE T4 DisTRIC: of CoLU :Ss A C A CU;T g ,

I . .

. / .. -

l Nb. .34_1410 September ~~,_. m,19 g3 San 1.uis Obispo F.others for ?eace;

. Scenic Shereline ? reservation Conference, An c . ,; : c c.t o gy .s. e t:. cn C, ub ; S a . c.ra Silver; cc:6en silver; Ili abe:h A.pfelderg; ane :u.iilsd SIEi5s Courim, AppE.:Jh.

j John J. ?c: ster, tr ue :-r. .: d a-m c-a-- -

?ctitioners - -

l -

iBI.B AUG 1 7 1924

. i

v. {

l GEORGE A.115HER CLE.RK

, Unit ed Stat es I;uclear Regulatory Co-:ission

{ and U:.ited States of J.merica, Respondents 1

EIFORI: Vright and Ginsburg, Circuit Judges, and Robb, Senior Circuit Judge 1 .

J

.8 O .R D

-- .E.- R. .

1' t

s u

Petiticeers seek a stay >ending this cour:'s review of the Nuc1 car Regulatory C . issfcn's (NRC kr the C. 4ssion) decision au:hcriring full-pacer cparation of the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plan: (D=i: 1).

Toe licensing proceedi gs for;the Diab 1o Ca.nyen f acility have had a II troubled histe y. ',Tn e: Pacifjt Cas and Electric C==pany (?CEI) ce=enced ,

cens uction of the plant, it:vas assumed tha: the closes: ear:hquake t fault vas about twelve -il es sedE v .th a p5stblat ed =agnitu6e of 6.75 l en the ?.ichter scale. Tour yhars later, however, it was discovered that the plant size was only three =iles f ro= a =ajor active of f shore earthcuake fault - the Eosg-i Tault - vith a postulated =agnitude of 7.5 cs the Rich er sca.le. Construe:1cn of the plan: conti=ued after

~j discove y.cf its p cxi=ity to the Bosgri Fault, with ccacurre:: r ear.aly sis

~

of the facility's seis=ic de' sign.

(o o

T In icS1, the Cc-i ssics e -5 a-' ed lev-pover (less thrs 5 of full

,.: pover) operatica ant! resting cf the Diablo Canye: f acility. - Wo cenths fi 3 eter, however, the NRC suspended the Icu-power license after learning I .1f newly tiiscovered errors in the seisnic design cf eeuip=es: and

.f %

t  :

... Y l .

1

.* 6%

4 & $ . kg *e g 8 'I # . *A J  % e  ? # '

u,

,, .,,. . .. m .t.a -

a . l. . -- -- - wi. d.Adu,. -- e - : ~~ - - - - - - - - - ~ ~ - - - - - - -

..~a

• A. ,

21

.)

l rm 64* e. # #

f 4 q* 2 d.Y .1

'fN1MY3h - IC12Nb ~

O1.1D1 (([ kUUpdf$ J n FoR THE ots:4tCT of CoLU6dBI A CIR C U;T

. ,]

i N o. 34_1410 september Term,19 e3 .

? AGE T40

-ti piping and o, veaknesses in ?Go._,:. s cuality assurance progrs=.

Ine fi: Co-< ssion lif t ed the low-power license suspensics 1: par en Seve:ber 8,1953, and lif:ed the re=ainder of the suspension en April 13, Ics4.

1

~1 0: Augus: 10, 1984, a divided Cc=issien issued the crder at j issue here, authori:.ing ?GT.iE to operate the Diablo Canyc= f aci.lity

'j n full pouer. Tnree of the five Cc 'ssioners vo:ed for be crder.

one of -he Co=issioners, 1.ando V. Zech, Jr.,

, several = ore weeks beIore lhe) cou2c c ome to a cstatedbe"wouldneed[ ec:. sics. " Ano ber,

, James 8 f.s s e ls tin e , expressed grave concern abou: " be C:=ission's 9  ::ea:=ent of two issues: the ec plica:ing ef f ects of e.arthcuakes en emergency planning, and the re-evaluation of the adecuacy ei seis ic d" design f or s a.11 and Iz:ge bore piping 1.2 -he pla : . " As :o the firs:

ca::er, Cc=issioner Asselstine stat ed his vier that " be Co- # ssie: is cc=pelled as a arter of law and legic :o af f erd the pa.rries to this 7 proceeding a: epporruti:y to li:igat e the issue prior to auth ' " g

!? the issuance of a full power li'cesse for the pla:t." i.7ith regard to seis=ic design, Cc=issicner Asselstine reported ha is "::: yet satisfied that.the Co=ission has the infc:=atice needed to ecotlude, rich a high AI' r

degree of confidence, that a.11 significant seismic design er:crs fer t:ns plan: have be g _ aden::.a:.ec anc corrected.n -ze ec=s ceres I ._ ne Cc desion's 4- ediate final dispositica of the adequacy of-the plant's m seis ic design "pr:icularly unfertusa:e" since e.:;:loration of the C questiens involsed in sufficien: detail "could be ce=pleted i= a =atte c.i a f ew we eks . " .

g,; ve' share _:he viev, suneerted bv the s: :c=.ents ef C =issienz:s M 2ech and Asselstine, that if a ciese cali is involved. the east history S cf this project and the publi: conce ns at stake counsel addine to the

) balance en extra reasure of cau::en. / tthough responde: and intervenor f -

s % est that the prchabm y r is ve y lev tha.n any accide:t v".:h significan hG eff-site consecuences vill occur chile the petition for review cf the, Cw_ission's licensing decision is pending, ve conclude tha: the zagnitude

? of the harm that could res'd1: sh=hld that prehabiliry eve::uare varrants i grant of a stay. Accc:dingly, it is .

M' >

'Q O?.DE?J_D by the Cour: that the NRC's August 10, 1984, Order g -

a autherizing full-pever cperatien cf the Diablo Cz=yc= Nuclear ?over M. pla:t (Uni: 1) is s:ayed pending the court's revice. It is

". f is 6.j . _ . .

. _h e

- t a

$h5SNAk NNIS? NYYS e***N < $h $

A . - . a .. . .- . .. . . .. . ~ ._ : -

a c <. .A . .=. - -

1. *

. t i.

r hyn II2 ti3 hIcIL25 NU1Ir~t D E R I'III 2 EI[ E

.i , -

1 .

I %oR T Mt otSTRICT.or CoLOWill A m3RCU3T

.I . .

s.

ho.34-1410 k. September Term,19 s3 1 -

l ?AGI TdRII

i c..;

_I?. ORDI*.ID by the Cour: that this ca.se be expedited, and ,

1 the case shall be scheduled for oral argu=es- during -his court 's

! Nove=ber-Dece=ber 1984 sitting period. ine case snall be scheduled

']

for argument on the sa=e day'and bef ore the same panel as San Luis Obispo Mothers for.?eace, et al. v. NRC, No. El-2035 and censolidated

[] '

cases. Tne f ollo -ing briefing schedule shall apply:

a Certified index to the --

Augus t 27, 1954

ecord to be filed

~

/

petitioners' brief to - Septe=ber 17, 1984

[ be sened and filed Respondent's brief to - October 9,19S4 .

be served and filed

~

7:

~ .; , 3rief of intervenor in F . support of responden:

5 4

to be served and filed - October 22, 1984 in petitioners' reply brief ,

if any, 7o be served and - Novembe 6, 1984 if . '

0 filed **

r dN .

[. To the extent that the issues in No. 51-20S5 overlap vith the issues I. presented in this case, the parties =ay incorporate by ref erence

(; ,

portiens of their briefs in No. 81-2035. -

P .

Per Curia =

ga ..

.v - .

m .

69 - ~

Q n.

-9 hs YC--

.5.i

~

Senior Ci:cuit Judge Echb Ecu1d no: grant the stay. ..

_t .

t I

l

'k a ,

h k'f* h hhit k .k-kh*1Y. h$ElM5h 4 E [(h * ,

g