ML20126C905

Opposes Restart of Facility Due to Foreign Object in Reactor Vessel Inhibiting Mobility of Control Rods.Related Documentation & Draft Petition Encl

ML20126C905
Person / Time
Site:	Big Rock Point File:Consumers Energy icon.png
Issue date:	11/01/1979
From:	Christamaria BIER, MILLS, CHRISTA-MARIA, ET AL
To:	Hendrie J NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
Shared Package
ML20126C900	List: ML20126C898 ML20126C901 ML20126C905
References
NUDOCS 8004140031
Download: ML20126C905 (8)

Text

, 0

' l, -

~ 1 - r.iI

~!1

~

i i

(

,t

..i

'i i

L l! ~

/ <s. -.

w, j 7 -. :. l... ;

~

2,,

~

'I i

l i.

i o

t

.3 r',, f M S (j 1

i._

}

A.M' c,

. M +-

I

}

i.

i Yu.-

_ $s0c'f '. Q ~1.

% "L l i

n A.

I.

dl. i Ws l ~ cc c L = M'L!

t 1

is/.

rT

~~~c,<

f ll

. i -+10J.= a Ma~~7t'

-g

!e aJ

-ct-

=.!

~

9 m N A ge_<_

x_g4-A c 0

g [- ' x.J & <u =

a-,<.cc T -1 i

=.

J~

ga" *-!% -

l l

3 y;

Q "I l..

0 ~ ap2 g W is : ~~~&

.- %' '7Da%3S ca.mq )Mn s

-s a

% ~ ~12 W. ~~D4 /M' oc seb. asp ag N

m.s e C' sk-g

!ch-ic A nGJK (vi:

A ce_ l

=

2

~ (6 w 4 c e c/ - # +

p e

-- w cao-ou_0;

.i i~~P ~ ~. C o.

.r i s c e ; -

I au a a

~,

oL! w m s g ku i k

,'sl "

sd x

ie.LL-C I (3 eM

( ~( O u S

g 3

i

--ac il

.-i h w

i j

)

h,cb d

A u.:-# [ I d

L4 Cf S 3

I f

d!

p a. ( d 2 O_.c.t_, -d>

-$ 6 W__;t.c4 6 ('

4

/

s 2

% M9y.

)

6 JA

'?

o_Es_o m'-

u,

/,, 6 '.m 'td_cf- / /w. 6locc'T l+~.L hl oce M r

3 C -. u s e-A M _. + A t' A :t_..

3

\\

( g M 4, M WA

~'IU M. O_a 40-

%c, o

r-d cc~~.cL \\ j'=.4 A 7 M (%-

C &

C f ~L M a

3

!a-$to4 a-si)2#

Z4 :6::

c" g'

e u c p -0 0 2

o_ft-4 m>c c i - Le b cd h k C > :-*f f d g. gg

3

+a r

-/

"J K

aJs_

5-4.

u

.i-A

^

ei

~

.j,,

s e

I I:

.I I

l 4

l..

a

,e I

f Si f

i

~

~,8 j~

e

.i

.. 4....-.,t

. i

.i:

p....

r-t 7

..y s

j..I '

M A U h P -. l ~ M f C. I

%. lT N3

..I J! M O E _.f$ x _,

IM5 I

/dtr i '

/YA ;l y f~Ee'l'. M b

, i,9.(f_.

L1 3

i4-A. wl

.y

-g. m me #:-

m

-6:c.a m b,'.:

g cit b//9x

)we y crA-

&6c.6 l

f v

Nj l /

f l

6 L.

4.,W.A.[ g k'

i bj g s ~ Mw sM

/

1

\\' 3 f Yp e-?-p. a vc c~ a& ' +' *~ M i

6i L---

d~

UM l 4l.

.. 7,

~

e cm f

j dc n

c c cc<

c b

a:*.)

VA) f ( e.e_s

/

?

3 A

n s

,j 3

m wr, u~'

pu j:-

hps ge<_,

L e

s a L-

, 2.0 - o n-o l w.

C W b cd e/-- b[

~

.,,t~rmMh to cl r cc(r~e (L;N.

s c

e-8 r

L i

i

k. ~< w% e-6 M~

• us W

b

't.f.

<.M.

L45' T.

"3 C

i

'~R. w E L%

2 h

/ Nf1 E

4 0

h l

. hi 6

F iu+ k -

A=Ad

.t :

.c e k,b b 6 /

a r e. c n h.

i s

o

. l & w~,,, { D w ks I

?

.\\..

l

., i-

1. v o c~ c- >

. ; [.

!l t

,, W n m H

% a% J ~ W d,,' s.

m an-A d 2 Ga J eb w g, f

i q!J'a_2_

J.

s' ~ c m,

- b Mei F

0 Q c. 94 t

o w

can'N L.)

C A a c +,x

'Ibe Concerned Citizens for the Charlevoix Area

.V.O._%. I e Charlevoir, Michipn 49720

~

October 3, 1979 Dea.r Neighhcr:

We need ycur help.

Each day new evidence cencern:.ng :ne cc:gers and costs of nuclear power cores befcre the pub;ic.

It has new becc:e the responsibility of infomed, caring citizens to join tcgether to protect the heal-h and safety of ourselves and our en11dren.

\\

Socn after the Th ee Mile Island incide.:, a nu:ber of citizens in the Charlevoix A ea fomed a. Energ,y Awareness Gr up. We found that the Eig Rock Point

'iuclear Power Plant, Iccated two miles ncrth :f Charlevoix, and nuclear plants across the coun:rf, have alamingly u.satisf ae: cry safety histories.

The Union of Concerned Scientists has named the Big Rcck ';uclear Flan ene of the ten =ost dangerous plants in this count:/! We also fou.d tha: there is absciutely ?iO safe method by which adicactive nuclear -2ste caterials car. be st: red.

When Co..c;=ers Power Co:pany put a recuest befcre the Nuclear Regulatory Cc= issien t: ex_and the stcrage capaci y cf its spent fuel stcrage pool at sig Fock, a ne crga.iraticn, The Conce-.ed Citi:e..s fer the Charlevoix Area, was forced. We '. ave p e titi oned the N.E.C. fcr the right to intervene in this request by Censurers Pcwer.

Our petitien has raised questicas regarding the tech. ical soundness cf suc': a_. action, as well as cuesti:ns :encerning the health and safety cf the general public.

The N.R.C. has responied that this petition is adequate for interven:ica.

To pu sue this legal process is, howeve., cc: plex and extremely costly.

We =ust therefere appeal to you, and all cencer.ed persons, te stand behind us now.

We need your st=por..

'Any donations, pledges, or co==it=ents of ti=e will enable us to cor.t:.nue ir. our efforts to inst e a safe an'd healthy environ =ent for curselves and our children.

Please ser.d all centributions to The Cc.cerned Citizens for the Charlevoix

Area, P.O. Scx 2CO, Charlevoix, Michigan, 4 37 0.

The Conce.ned Citizens for the Charlevoix A en a-4- -he process of inco porating and obtaining ncn-pr' fit, o

tax exe=pt s atus.

Thar.k you for you: help.

Very truly yours, Chk N

A 1

l

+

O

=

the undersigned, living within a fifty =ile radius of the Big Rock Pcint We, Nuclear Pla.nt, on behtlf of curselves ar.d our children, wish to express cur support of he fcilewir.g petitien ne suh=ined en the twenty-second day of August, 1079 to the Nuclear Eegulate:f Cc==istien.

om A IS OT >>I.P*OA h~JOLIAy, p.IgvLA CRY cov.XISSICN the undersiEted, wish to petition the.Welea-p.egulatory Cc= mission to we, inte rvene cn t,.h4LT of c,urs elve s a:.d cu.r childre., in the catter of,'the

/

applicatier, of Censumers Pever Oc::.any f a increase the capacity of tts spent

(.,

f uel s to a g e p c.cl a t the Big P c,ck Poir.t hu:lcar ?larat.

Pursuant to the N.C.R.

m %, '

- %r 10 cTI Lec tion :.14 (A) ct citi:,e.s livi g dthin a fif ty sile radius of the gig Rock Point Nuclear g,

, A3Plar.t. we snodd be pereitted to it.te-vene, s o that we :.ay exeMise our right (v

i to pectect se hsalth arid safety of de pu:lic and of the environment.

, b,g,

r-west by C:nswers Power Cec a'ry to increase the fuel storage capacity R [/f

-' e at the Big.;c.ck ?oint No: lear P ant ; resents a direct threat to our perscr.al healta, t.he hea.1% of oc-childrer. a.d to cur pr:pe rty.

are especial ly conte:.ed r gar:dir; the integ-ity of the South wall of the we s p en t f u e l s tc rs ;e p c,ol, a s d i se le s ec i.. a r-c en t technical report.

we a n c onc erned ab<nzt t.he ice.;-t e m e f f e::s of high icvel rr.diation and sev ers thenal stressir.; cr. the c :/stalh-st: ::t.;re c f zetals used is the facility and cf the weld erts the. e tc.

It is public kno.<1 edge that s p er. t fu e l elece.ts, unde r le.g-t e m stcra;e, bve dangerously weakened c 12 id L.g, tsnitir; in leakage cf adica::ive s: lids into the cpen storage pool.

Se a'.so erre r.s great ccnc er= cve.- tne in:res sed relea se of adioactive gases f r:.s de sic a g e p :,el to tr.e off-g a s syste= and then:e irto our at=osphere.

tl.e pres ent :ime tr.ere is no sa fe =e:.h:d 1y hich highly radioactive vaste At c ar. h e s tered. To allcw Csnsu ces t.e.-

=;ary to ine. ease the st e r2 Ee capacity cf the sper.: fue'. hcidi.ng tank at the 11g Rock Poir.t Nuclear Plant fr e is fuel e;e=ents to 4c elemen:s we.1d be a dangerous ar.d destructive act. ard ufrir.;es c. th e -i g h t: 'r ealth a.d safe ty of all area reside:.ts.

W y

Y Y

9 J

%'I / tdi 2J DA3ce f ; 's bdu. IO f

I i

1 4.-.'W.erMeem

-e e

.e-g.-

W N -

_g C'

---.+.w.-w...u..

{

a..

.s 'J r

2 j ; ' ',, ' ; f '

,;),. 7,.

... i-s yo I

l:

. g.1 J

I

• I.,',

l '.

I, i

d. ;

..t j

i F.-

9 i

4 t

t

+

.c~ -

s 4

3..m... s.:. -.- W o. p 0 2

t

.e.,

i 3 p./

Ccr.s t.=e n ?:ve rl CO:;'t:

l

$Q.I

,.r p

7l 3

I

.j. d ;

.I.

-~ C C. < ^ e:

l E g Mch ?:1.:t Pla:t, l

.ry: ;q.. 't e-f_,. 1-i' Q. g-i. l ' 'I " =ing sh*.:ti:v: cc:ditice.s c: dpril 23, 19~3.s= h. M m cf the cc t d -l red d.-ive :ee: f: le th a.ge as se ed ate d vith w. rec. s=2 4:iw '. ' r F-2 ( G?.-T P-, p ' I, l!* ETp i a vitestice ty;e :eise vu :sticed is tha pri=s:7 rJutes "Wd vith cperti 6 e f re s.:: r re tt r :1cie: ;==; 11. ...u.. j -

6...

i 1 $. -,. g } .] ~.: ;a.rtile1 vith activities e.ssocia,ted viti:I2% ~5-lf f:el c d othei kI 1:te r:als vere re==ved fr:: the reactor for C tan the icver amas o f i-i ..- q f the wssel. C. Ju=e 9,1979, the ais pertion of the f ffsmer ever the El &L re ei r:t'.1 at10: 7.:=; 20" dia=eter 1:1et vas fo=d ,N7 Tocse ed leiM is 'i the cant 7 betvee: the vessel vall, the con s=pp=:c pste and a largs flev be.f: ?.. ,f 1' -@ ) ' A s =a.ll ;:rties of the diff::ser, he,1: ding cz.e cf t$m tze t=per citar'---:t etr vss f:= d t el:v th e co re s t:ppe rt pihe. r M i h

• rpectie: O f the di f f.:s er e ve r the f2 re " - ' -"-- p::=p 20* di e. meter.

%l l 1:1e i re w ' s * ' a.: th e sis cle icve r att> Nt us lease w!:i:.venld allev that di f P.:s e : tc ::ve c: its t:ppe atta ^- -ts 1:: e " g w and rate l.h]y = :t a.: vith th e l a.rge t e.f f".e. '"his pr:bably. ves thre r::n=em cf the vibrztier. I tr;e ::ise fin t :cti:ed :: >;:ril 20,1979 2. 1 ^1, 3] il s u e d :: seer.et:7 f ac.cn ::d nov dat, we 6 :wt deiese that now y ): 110 ci s.ss h r s e e c ur-e d. "5e 1: cide:t is

==t rep. *"**w s=d "ere h.as be== co '. *, -l effect c: p t:hli c he alth a:d s s.fet7 y~ T '. ' ' i ,' '[ A:::=t ahilit7 e= d s e e.r:h fer diff.:s er tv-- - ".eems is i= p r: g es s. D Y)d' e '"h e ftiled b:*.ts ( 3 : - h e Il di ff.:s e r a:d 1 ce ti:= f2 #' N a.:e,c /5 ( di c.=e e r s h= '.:1 de : hcits vith 1/2" diareter th.r sik:E ---+'. asui vere insta.11e i .N 'd '::r 1:itia* ;1e.st epen. tie: 1: 1962. Cue well-ec=a b::22 jiece Es.n bee: retric t Oi duri:g til: cut a.ge a:d c*her vell-ver= pieces a te man'helie9med tc h. ave bea re.- I.$

• rievei is pric? 7e a s dati g ba.ch to 197h.

rt. .h

• 9 te date =ize t.etier the di.!fe.ss:=c c:=t b$ ; --= e-.17 re=:eved

?P'd Ir 1.:.Ati c j;j cr redesi f.ed iJ i: ;7 gres s V.th *he a.ss1.sta ce a:f tha za::'.:sse stes: g7 stas f. b"-

@ a r.

l ,1., Ytf.t.M d. 3 - p i f-p% L. s.

_s T f?

l j d bc.C y/)/w ,~ s N.. 'il 4 E0.I h . :l ~ .r y o (.. ,6 i4 - i t i ...s -; M W t t .,J l e .i .J. w.O a, y$ 4 e. ..JT,: 3 g ) c.s-s u e. M da ~ m. $ a,,_. . f Acda D, bl # ~ ~ ~ >e d %. k. N ? 4-f m W,; >. w.g (9 y/ Hts:It.G.ew =qt dv):<*&U-A O 'Z

• a 1

^%,, e . '. - g,( w 0)0cm.hk, t-aq'--e.! I*m G '~

• ( -i ;,

T7 I t = = y ) e,,, 2 f.r t Vk].. (( ?[: r-f Y~ [ 4 .A.e <.as .q.4,.A.s a t*7 % w. l do.a% (,> c,.; 1y N.T 'II[W-R 9 4 1 (c Ata (o c.. s.t.;. r-s t., n ( e.. J th y < in -

.,e &, q b-gAgde 4.g.'. i. -(y '..

4 ow

._z.! ', M i# TI~k M C A6'-"A N ' /. -. u 4 ut 1

4 1.he trrpla-low teysl was mne a eJthogh the watse leved in the oor, Safety Mcit for au Inode.sWch shroud area went below the tdp'.4 low f. ' ', %, n gis Fo$ltion*- level merpoht the con n abed

. At least two recirck ation loop ib.

covered and censequently to 'uel ischarge and suction valves must da:. age would be expected. rernain in the full open position. Cause of Causee--A spudeus rtactor .The time duration of the low-low - m.....pressere scrs= was !.itiated by a levd sipd was required to be not "h i pressure ;ae en tr.e reacter high greater than that used in the safety press are s: a= swu:hes,. caused by an analysis for the limtttng loss.cf. it.s't.:.=ent te::.rJ::a.n w Ce perfor ' inventors transient. su vedlasce testL.g. h wever, de ne NkC staff also recor. mended t$at fundamentad causes of the nsuhbg the li:ensee consider the surveillance sequence cf events were: arogram and le vel instrument (1) De cperators essentially isolated [mprevements. l l e the reac'er ansulus and core regio: from it was concluded that no evidence of I each cther by shutting au recirculatics fuel damage was apparent, and that the I Pump is # arie YdveL f acilty could be safely returned to (2) Nc'es or Cautions spinst closir.g opera tion. SU suct!)o and 6scharge valves in the Based on the satisfactory actions retirculation loops were not adequate, taken by the licensee, on May 30.1979 the NRC authorized the li'censee to Acu.ans Tcs, enIo Pre ven: P.ecurrence 7,, ue, ap,7,,g an, m possible generic implications of L/ ensee-The licensee performed a the Oyster Creek event have been therouth evaluation of the evest to considerei Nine Mile Point Unit 1 dete :-2ne whether any fuel damage had occumd and develo;4d follow up (operated by Niagara Mohawk Power Corp; ration and located in Oswego actions. As a result of the evaluation County. New York) and Lacrosse and is:::siena with Se NRC, the (ope ated by Dairyland Power !!:ensee t:ck the fcucwi:; sig.15 cut Cce;eratise and located in Monroe s ::.le na:

3. The triple.lew 1 bhsFed County. Wisconsin) are the only as a Sdety IJmit forkvelwas es:

react:n presently cperating which are il t odes cf nector susceptible to a similar event. opera ti:n.s immediate requirements similar to those

. a. m;uhment was added to the which were required for Oyster Creek l

Technics! Spe: ficatiens that the suc:fon (~echnical Specification changes 1 and l a.d dis:nme valves la at less! two

) were implemented at these f acilities l

I reeircuLtierilo:ps be open a' all tir es. prict to their start up lthey were both in l Tne precedures were changed to a shutdown condition at the time of the Ir,p;er ent this requirement. C)) ster Creek event).The third l' ~

3. 0; ara tor trainin sessions were held, the es e.1 was thercqhly ret.pitement will be implemented as d.scussed a6nd the revised p.ocedcres soon as practicable..

g' i Two other plants [Dresden Unit 1 and rniewei NRC-Fol'.sw;ng n:tifi:a: ion ficm the E!; FM og;/). which are presently in { Iker.ser c! the event. nn NRC L spector n ens snutdowns, would also be l w'as dupe:ched to the site. Additional sus:eptible to a similar es ent. liowev.er, NRC nf s.;nnel rmed at the site on it is planned to impose appropriate May 3.U.n to reuew de situation and requirements on these two plants prior b ccirrm:ne tha statas of the plant. Fact lo their startup. finding by the NEC was su;plemented in addition, on May 29,1979 the NRC b inform tion obtained from the fasued LE Information Notice No. 7N3. 1/r enwe. ee reactor vendor (Ceneral detailing this event. to dl holders of j E:ectric) and fuel supp!ier (Euon). A operating licenses and construction ( ) seliav = valuation report (SER) of the permits. j rsent w as p vpared which discusses the I mtoir.ani water level experienced in the l re cter vessel and the fuel conditions. Tne in:lowits three rez.nrements were a di.i d in tne Technic.ar Spe:dt; cations: i. I

• At t.e n e of ue es er.'. ise li:.ete.e e ted.rLical es o! atwas onfo d the m,dadew.s'.ef tent as :

i e te y 1,.ms -ten us n a:nc see e-m.se na l the "M $".MWY F'i>r.e Wy. A hie r..a seleiy I eye ve :.as ais.e eiwc aied -d me dm.Us l 1 ,....ar Wei.m v.e essee e 'ir.:.a e la the -p Ur .i.cr. I,c= tre.s n the c3Me emic?. had l tm, m me w..w.e is i l r ,;.e e i:, a w. p 4 er ir e a t.w. c.f we tr a r s e-t. tu l 8 en.o... n. ire.e: h t3.e 1,cer en a e d a 5.e Iery l f' t a.a h.ed b'un en.4 led. I I t l 5 l 2 i l } } l i, 1

i,..- l e i ) 1 ~hese pre;-cied Te chnical Specifica: ices are consistent with; existi. t ope.a*..*..* --..e' es. I t t III. Ce e :1 us ic: 1 ?.ased c: the f:re g:in g, b::: the lig ?.ect ?ci:: Plant F.eview Co:cittee a:d the Safe:7 and Audi ?.eviev Scard have c:::luded tha: the cha:ge is acceptable f::= a safe:y s:.acd;:i::. CCNS M-**~'s'=% L..c..t.h'.' ~ l l 1 1 ' ' G.%Cv-., . m Ah 37 Ste; ev 3 Ecwell, See:, : Vice ?:esider.: ? Swer: act subs cribed.: bef: e se .t'is *1th day of Septe:ber 1579. ,1 / \\4 r d em '. 4_ase (SD.I.) Li da ;: ca rs.e s,.ve a 7 ? :;i: .'a c h s e : C:u::7,.".ic is a: .v coccissio: expires Ju:e M, 1911. i 4 t e I 5 a 4 L. I e 4 I q s k l l l l I j a

(' n g l ,-.o l l* 3:0 P00:' PoIr i I h # C**8 Di84 f, U. L ktLCL.D.A BEAU.LATC AY r *===* ssacus m LICENSEE EVENT REPORT i l co cas. n:c= f 1 I t i 1 1@ xuu er en ryn Att ateviato wemine o I i l [ Vg"'in Inl _in Ini n! d nI_ fnin l@l 41,1,!,13 l@lom g liillul-Is l e ! -19 t e u==u - u wam y s. am rm u l e;. gl09to15(7(9jg l 1 c l'$! M 11 @f01 51 01 1 011!5 13 @l 018 !21217 9 a n me:s.1 oe a w u o ....n c.Ars w Deu rr.-. a a rvo<T m m.o= a r:<w r.-st:.: :ts @ 71 Desi:: reviev cf reae:c: vessel level instre=ent syste=. 1.E RE09 a=d f l i I1.S 7I09 reves.lef that duri-e oestulated less ef cec 1 mnt U da-r ee-di?d-ref i i>> J the autenat': 1:.1:iatica ed reac cr sert =, contain=e : isolatie=, a:d core j i l c slf cerar aerum iens :Fe are inir'ated be this tvster ef( r -et fuse d_en due g . r 61 I to fl as'- f r e t h a : c:uld oce r f rhe ref ereec.1'- a /d-e -Wd daar-e ur-f ai211 1:stiet e l th e --d.2--v s v s t e=. Reeortable eer *ech Seee 6.0.2.a (c) 1 4 I 3 4 ..i : ia rs.Cw

• C tsa(gr a 8 '5*T W

.A.:t I CAu! c:::. w.::: C:.:4 ceci s.-. =4 e e m ..n e:28dtl@ W @ b'@ l f?! @ L,:_J @ !,1, ) @ l _ T i v i e I -l L .) le

1 m

.evu.o. ii.~., umL C o..i~ce ..e r (W en TLAA 81' lathe. CCCf TYPE a.C. 1ol

=T I 7 I 91 1-1

!OI2121 10111 11' @.*.W a y i %.,,3 4 M I." 24 26 37

S 2'l JW

. Jl .M ~ t. h."*v>as F.**.'*( 188I"" Idb h A*"T AC wwI e/T h99C P4 LWI CDedP. COM*Q.df WT i AA 1*e A4'" :p5 CP. *.a.m? k(7a?O MNai SVsw1TiSD P C* W 6W8. 3rJ"*U t m huad UF.4T(pm l A IIiylJ@ l~j@ I$ @ ! O I OI O O L [J_J@ lN l@ lN l@ I Y I OI II O (@ v =. emt :t:: r i: o:::= atenvt Arn:ss @ ..as...sco> s. 1 \\ . u -... s 3. <-.. s.. .:--=--. =-s. s..<- iss: \\ 1 .-u s, ,ij.#1 :he N.5.5.5. verder. ~he resolutice is still under stude to d e t e--' n e cor-f i I .;1 re::ive acti:: rier te eisnt start-up. -- - -- -r I !.:1I i l i,. i i = a wtwoo e-Ors:CVf RY D43.*ma T;Cru ,hr-, t *:nai a CTaf88TA*.15 D6h00*I*f e

,,sjiCIV lO: 0t 09J NA l W@l Design reviev re. lated :o i.

] i rt A.s S / se s

• e 44 ed

~2 E3 M 4 9,vn, c= rte LCCATbO's 08 mtLtAat f ii i t ! I -l I 19I a l I NA 1 a f L1A2 g * ** At LL458 Aae:Q*e"0844"tT*Y a u n Pt=s.: u t2-:s atz C4 s':n.6 I l t 4 : } } O! OO M."1,M, N A so

• =

am a.a i e v i a, u n et as:=..es ecs } est.aas t 4 CM N [s et} ] CiOIO!2'NA = v i n u t C93 Cd can D*an a 0.t *?. **d?.6J"'T tv

.u:m I_1 4 9 l I ** '.s$ v1

.v-- ~ i a nonc Lct CWr.Y i " 're F Ms 'N $ 1ItIfIffffff i _ ns s: y..

., e 3 1 4. '.- s

A

,,-w,, r sos 11o rig, l i i .}}