|
---|
Category:CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS
MONTHYEARML20137N1591997-03-31031 March 1997 Informs That Licensee Facility Scheduled to Administer NRC GFE on 970409.Sonalsts,Inc Authorized Under Contract to Support NRC Administration of GFE Activities ML20058M0361993-04-12012 April 1993 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents.Forwards Records in App L Which Are Being Withheld Partially for Listed Reasons,(Ref FOIA Exemptions 5) ML20248D6521989-07-20020 July 1989 Forwards Response to Util Re Bills D0184 & D0185 for Plant OL Application Review Costs by Various Program Ofcs Through June 1984 ML20245D9621989-04-28028 April 1989 Forwards Addl Info Re Bunker Ramo Instrumentation Penetration Modules,Per 890131 Request.Util Believes That Modules Environmentally Qualified in Accordance w/10CFR50.49 & NUREG-0588,Category II ML20205C3521988-09-23023 September 1988 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Plant. Forwards App D Documents.App D Documents Also Available in PDR ML20155A7001988-06-0202 June 1988 Informs That Const on Conversion of Plant to gas-fired Facility Began on 880404 ML20155A7401988-05-18018 May 1988 FOIA Request for Documents on 850731 & 870312 Meetings Re Plant.Document Re 840314 Meeting Previously Obtained & Therefore Excluded from Request ML20237B4361987-12-14014 December 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents.App B Document, Board Notification 84-024,encl & Also Available in PDR ML20236X6141987-12-0808 December 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request All Documents.No Addl Records Subj to Request Located ML20236U2571987-11-0505 November 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Ball Type Main Steam Isolation Valves Used at Facilities ML20235B3081987-09-21021 September 1987 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents,Including AEC to ACRS Forwarding Safety Evaluation Re Zimmer.App a Documents Cannot Be Located.App B Documents in Pdr.App C & D Documents Withheld (Ref 10CFR2.790) ML20235M4251987-07-13013 July 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Acrs. Forwards Documents for Categories One & Three of FOIA Request.Review of 21 Addl ACRS Documents Continuing ML20235K1731987-07-0909 July 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Info Re Certain Contracts Awarded by NRC for Reporting Svcs.Forwards App a & B Documents.Documents Also Available in PDR ML20234F0911987-06-26026 June 1987 Responds to Appeal Re Denial of FOIA Request for Documents. Forwards Document 5 in App F.Portions of Document 5 Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 6 & 7).Other Requested Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20215K1981987-06-19019 June 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Allegations Concerning Plant.Forwards App G & H Documents.Documents Also Available in Pdr.App H Documents Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20213F9351987-05-0808 May 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request.Forwards App F Document & Weld Allegations.App G Documents Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20206H4951987-04-13013 April 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Bechtel Employment Discrimination.Forwards App E Documents.App D Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20235G2321987-04-0101 April 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Forged NDE Inspectors Certification Supplied by Barclay Intl for Use at Quad Cities Nuclear Station & Stated Investigations at Plants ML20211A9531987-02-13013 February 1987 Advises That Financial Info Submitted for 1987 in Util Satisfies Requirements of 10CFR140.21 That Each Licensee Maintain Guarantee of Payment of Deferred Premiums for Operating Reactors Over 100 Mwe ML20212M7651987-01-16016 January 1987 Informs That Due to Demands on Staff,Nrc Will Respond by 870430 to 850607 Request for Review of Invoices D0184 & D0185 Re OL Application Review Costs Through 840623 ML20207C0151986-12-19019 December 1986 Forwards Notice of Withdrawal of Application for OLs & Termination of Proceeding,Per Util 860711 Request & ASLB 861217 Memorandum & Order Granting Motion ML20207C1191986-12-18018 December 1986 Forwards Order Terminating CPPR-81 & CPPR-82 Based on Fact That Const of Facility Ceased,Units Inoperable & Site Environmentally Stable,Per Util 860701 Request to Withdraw Application to Amend CPs ML20215B9641986-12-0505 December 1986 Notifies Util of 870204-05 Early Emergency Responders Workshop in Chicago,Il to Discuss Lessons Learned & Current Problems in Coordination & Integration of Emergency Response Efforts.Meeting Agenda & Preregistration Form Encl ML20214Q0911986-11-24024 November 1986 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Ofc of Inspector & Auditor Investigations.Forwards App B Documents. Documents Also Available in PDR ML20214A0761986-11-14014 November 1986 Forwards Insp & Evaluation of Plant for Adequacy of Stabilization Plan,Documenting 861015-16 Site Insp & Review & Insp of Site Stabilization Rept.Environ Stabilization Satisfactory ML20215N0241986-10-28028 October 1986 Forwards Order from DOE Economic Regulatory Admininstration Granting Exemption from Prohibitions of Power Plant & Industrial Fuel Act of 1978 & Puc of Mi Opinion & Order Granting Relief from Commission 850329 Rate Order ML20215M8851986-10-28028 October 1986 Forwards Insp Repts 50-329/86-01 & 50-330/86-01 on 861015-16.No Violations Identified ML20211B5401986-10-0909 October 1986 Further Response to FOIA Request for Eight Categories of Documents Re Ee Kent Allegations Concerning Facilities. Forwards Documents Listed in App K ML20210S9971986-10-0202 October 1986 Requests Change in Facility Svc List Address to Ref Address. Related Correspondence ML20210S4131986-09-26026 September 1986 Further Response to FOIA Request for 16 Categories of Records Re Facilities.Forwards App D & E Documents.Documents Also Available in PDR ML20214T7431986-09-24024 September 1986 Forwards Form 8-K Filed W/Securities & Exchange Commission. Util Believes Info Presented Bears No Issues Currently Before Aslb.Related Correspondence ML20214N4541986-09-0808 September 1986 Provides List of Activities Re Remedial Soils Work Being Modified Pending Final Disposition of Issues Described in Util 860701 & Counsel s Withdrawing Request for CP Extension.W/Svc List.Related Correspondence ML20209E6621986-09-0505 September 1986 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order.Documents Listed on App Available in PDR IA-86-235, Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order.Documents Listed on App Available in PDR1986-09-0505 September 1986 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order.Documents Listed on App Available in PDR ML20212K9061986-08-21021 August 1986 Forwards Request for Addl Info Re Environ Review of Util 860711 Request to Withdraw Applications for OL by 860828 ML20206M8311986-08-15015 August 1986 Forwards Util Response to ASLB 860716 Order.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20212J1391986-07-25025 July 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for June 1986.Listed Nonconformance Repts & Addl Documents Closed During June Encl ML20207D7261986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Aslab Jurisdiction.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20202F9581986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Util Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Appeal Board Jurisdiction,For Filing.W/O Encl ML20203B2351986-07-10010 July 1986 Informs That Review of 820622 Application to Receive Unirradiated Nuclear Fuel Assemblies Terminated,Per .Fission Chambers Should Be Disposed of & Licenses SNM-1904 & SNM-1905 Terminated,Per 10CFR70.38(b) ML20206T2401986-07-0101 July 1986 Advises That Since Facility Formally Abandoned as Nuclear Facility,Util Will Not Reply to Generic Ltr 86-05 Re TMI Action Item II.K.3.5 ML20202B1091986-07-0101 July 1986 Forwards Evaluation of 13 Specific Recommendations Contained in BNL Rept of Review of Surveillance & Maint Program,In Response to CE Norelius 860506 Request ML20206T4321986-07-0101 July 1986 Withdraws Application for Ols.Facility Will Be Converted to combined-cycle gas-fired Plant.Abandonment Actions & Equipment Sales Will Provide Assurance That Plant Cannot Be Used as Nuclear Facility ML20199J9181986-06-30030 June 1986 Submits ALAB-106 Quarterly Rept 51.No New Individuals Assigned quality-related Duties.Const Shut Down Since 840716 & No Const Activities Projected for Jul-Sept 1986 ML20211L0361986-06-25025 June 1986 Forwards Bechtel & B&W Nonconformance Repts for May 1986,per Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 ML20198E9051986-05-25025 May 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Apr 1986,including Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Equality Audit Finding,B&W Repts of Nonconformance & Audit Finding Repts. Only Nonconformance Repts Encl ML20205P9331986-05-23023 May 1986 Responds to Generic Ltr 86-10, Implementation of Fire Protection Requirements. Project in Surveillance & Maint Mode.Generic Ltr & FSAR Update Will Be Reviewed When Project Restarted ML20203Q2891986-05-0606 May 1986 Forwards BNL Technical Rept, Surveillance & Maint..., Based on NRC 851014-18 Insp.No Violations Noted.Items Identified Could Have Impact on Later Project Restart. Evaluation of Rept Recommendations Requested within 60 Days ML20203N3901986-05-0101 May 1986 Forwards Rev 2 to Tdi Owners Group App Ii:Generic Maint Matrix & Justifications. Rev Approved by Tdi Owners Group & Tdi ML20205N5861986-04-29029 April 1986 Forwards Corrected Page 1 to JW Cook to H Berkow Re Pipe Whip Restraint Design.Last Line Inadvertently Eliminated When Ltr Originally Issued 1997-03-31
[Table view] Category:INCOMING CORRESPONDENCE
MONTHYEARML20245D9621989-04-28028 April 1989 Forwards Addl Info Re Bunker Ramo Instrumentation Penetration Modules,Per 890131 Request.Util Believes That Modules Environmentally Qualified in Accordance w/10CFR50.49 & NUREG-0588,Category II ML20155A7001988-06-0202 June 1988 Informs That Const on Conversion of Plant to gas-fired Facility Began on 880404 ML20155A7401988-05-18018 May 1988 FOIA Request for Documents on 850731 & 870312 Meetings Re Plant.Document Re 840314 Meeting Previously Obtained & Therefore Excluded from Request ML20236U2571987-11-0505 November 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Ball Type Main Steam Isolation Valves Used at Facilities ML20216E4721987-05-28028 May 1987 Part 21 Rept 140 Re Potential Defect in Air Pressure Regulators Mfg by Bellofram.Dripwell Gasket May Fail Due to Mismachining of Gasket Seating Surface Causing Loss of Control Air & Starting Air Pressure ML20235G2321987-04-0101 April 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Forged NDE Inspectors Certification Supplied by Barclay Intl for Use at Quad Cities Nuclear Station & Stated Investigations at Plants ML20215N0241986-10-28028 October 1986 Forwards Order from DOE Economic Regulatory Admininstration Granting Exemption from Prohibitions of Power Plant & Industrial Fuel Act of 1978 & Puc of Mi Opinion & Order Granting Relief from Commission 850329 Rate Order ML20210S9971986-10-0202 October 1986 Requests Change in Facility Svc List Address to Ref Address. Related Correspondence ML20214T7431986-09-24024 September 1986 Forwards Form 8-K Filed W/Securities & Exchange Commission. Util Believes Info Presented Bears No Issues Currently Before Aslb.Related Correspondence ML20214N4541986-09-0808 September 1986 Provides List of Activities Re Remedial Soils Work Being Modified Pending Final Disposition of Issues Described in Util 860701 & Counsel s Withdrawing Request for CP Extension.W/Svc List.Related Correspondence ML20206M8311986-08-15015 August 1986 Forwards Util Response to ASLB 860716 Order.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20212J1391986-07-25025 July 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for June 1986.Listed Nonconformance Repts & Addl Documents Closed During June Encl ML20207D7261986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Aslab Jurisdiction.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20202F9581986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Util Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Appeal Board Jurisdiction,For Filing.W/O Encl ML20206T4321986-07-0101 July 1986 Withdraws Application for Ols.Facility Will Be Converted to combined-cycle gas-fired Plant.Abandonment Actions & Equipment Sales Will Provide Assurance That Plant Cannot Be Used as Nuclear Facility ML20202B1091986-07-0101 July 1986 Forwards Evaluation of 13 Specific Recommendations Contained in BNL Rept of Review of Surveillance & Maint Program,In Response to CE Norelius 860506 Request ML20206T2401986-07-0101 July 1986 Advises That Since Facility Formally Abandoned as Nuclear Facility,Util Will Not Reply to Generic Ltr 86-05 Re TMI Action Item II.K.3.5 ML20199J9181986-06-30030 June 1986 Submits ALAB-106 Quarterly Rept 51.No New Individuals Assigned quality-related Duties.Const Shut Down Since 840716 & No Const Activities Projected for Jul-Sept 1986 ML20211L0361986-06-25025 June 1986 Forwards Bechtel & B&W Nonconformance Repts for May 1986,per Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 ML20198E9051986-05-25025 May 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Apr 1986,including Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Equality Audit Finding,B&W Repts of Nonconformance & Audit Finding Repts. Only Nonconformance Repts Encl ML20205P9331986-05-23023 May 1986 Responds to Generic Ltr 86-10, Implementation of Fire Protection Requirements. Project in Surveillance & Maint Mode.Generic Ltr & FSAR Update Will Be Reviewed When Project Restarted ML20203N3901986-05-0101 May 1986 Forwards Rev 2 to Tdi Owners Group App Ii:Generic Maint Matrix & Justifications. Rev Approved by Tdi Owners Group & Tdi ML20205N5861986-04-29029 April 1986 Forwards Corrected Page 1 to JW Cook to H Berkow Re Pipe Whip Restraint Design.Last Line Inadvertently Eliminated When Ltr Originally Issued ML20197F8331986-04-28028 April 1986 Advises That Response to Generic Ltr 86-04 Re Engineering Expertise on Shift Inapproriate at Present Because Midland Not Currently Under Const.Commitment to Provide Info Will Be Added to Commitment Tracking Sys ML20210L2351986-04-25025 April 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Mar 1986,including Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts & Quality Audit Findings ML20203K8531986-04-23023 April 1986 Responds to NRC Re Allegation Concerning Adequacy of Pipe Whip Restraint Design.Project Records Placed in Storage & Personnel Performing Work Dispersed.Specific Design Approach Would Require Check of Records at Bechtel ML20203P1661986-04-21021 April 1986 Discusses 860407 Study Considering Options for Facility. Options Range from Abandonment of Facility to Completion as Nuclear Plant.Conversion of Plant to Combined Cycle gas-fired Plant Chosen as Most Favorable Option ML20209E6531986-03-28028 March 1986 FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order ML20140F8781986-03-25025 March 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Feb 1986,including Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts & Quality Audit Findings ML20154H9651986-02-25025 February 1986 Forwards Nonconformance Repts Written or Closed During Jan 1986,per Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 ML20154D3581986-02-24024 February 1986 Confirms Items Agreed Upon in 860219 Telcon Re soil-related Issues.Util Will Discontinue Monitoring Dike Groundwater Wells During Shutdown & Site Maint.Authorization Given to Seal Weeping Wall Crack ML20198H2401986-01-24024 January 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Dec 1985,including Bechtel Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts & Quality Audit Findings ML20136F4771985-12-31031 December 1985 Forwards PNL-5718, Review of Tdi Diesel Generator Owners Group Engine Requalification Program,Final Rept, Technical Evaluation Rept ML20138Q5531985-12-31031 December 1985 Submits ALAB-106 Quarterly Rept 50.No New Individuals Assigned quality-related Duties Since 850930 Rept & No Const Activities Projected for Jan-Mar 1986 ML20136C5711985-12-20020 December 1985 Forwards Monthly Rept for Nov 1985,including Bechtel Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts,Quality Audit Findings,B&W Repts of Nonconformity & Util Nonconformance Repts,Per ALAB-106 ML20138Q3871985-12-13013 December 1985 Ack Receipt of 851115 IE Bulletin 85-003, Motor-Operated Valve Common Mode Failures During Plant Transients Due to Improper Switch Settings. Valve Operability Program & Rept Scheduled to Be Completed Prior to OL Issuance ML20137Z1481985-11-27027 November 1985 Advises That Response to 851029 IE Bulletin 85-001, Steam Binding of Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps, Inappropriate at Present Since Plant in Surveillance & Maint Status.Schedule for Response Will Be Provided When Status Changes ML20137F2541985-11-25025 November 1985 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Oct 1985,including Bechtel Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts & Quality Audit Findings,Per 730323 Order ALAB-106 & Amend 1 to Cp.Svc List Encl ML20138J4431985-10-25025 October 1985 Forwards Monthly Rept for Sept 1985,per Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 & Amend 1 to Cp,Including Bechtel Nonconformance Rept,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts, Quality Audit Findings & B&W Repts of Nonconformity ML20138D0031985-10-14014 October 1985 Informs That Util Will Submit Schedule for Meeting Requirements of 10CFR50.62(d) Per Generic Ltr 85-06 Re QA Guidance for ATWS nonsafety-related Equipment When & If Project Reactivated ML20133F7581985-10-0808 October 1985 Informs of Plans to Physically Disable Equipment Installed in & About Evaporator Bldg to Serve Process Steam to Dow Chemical Co,Per 850925 Resolution.Equipment & Structures Abandoned Are non-Q.Related Correspondence ML20137Y7921985-09-30030 September 1985 Submits Quarterly Rept 49,per ALAB-106.No New Individuals Assigned to quality-related Duties.Const at Plant Shut Down on 840716.No Const Projected for Fourth Quarter 1985.Next Quarterly Rept Will Be Submitted by End of Dec 1985 ML20133A3141985-09-27027 September 1985 Forwards Review of Section 4.7 of Technical Evaluation Rept PNL-5600, Review of Resolution of Known Problems in Engine Components for Tdi Emergency Diesel Generators, Reflecting Views Re Crankshafts for 16-cylinder Engines ML20133H1261985-09-25025 September 1985 Forwards Bechtel Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Mgt Corrective Action Repts & Quality Audit Findings Written or Closed During Aug 1985,per Condition of Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 ML20138S0731985-09-17017 September 1985 Advises That Addl Excavation Between Tank Farm & Auxiliary Bldg Will Be Conducted Per NRC 850826 Authorization. Excavation Needed to Provide Supplemental Cathodic Protection.Svc List Encl.Related Correspondence ML20133H8841985-09-16016 September 1985 Discusses Ee Kent Allegations Re Plant,Per Encl . Decision Reflected in NRC Should Be Reconsidered. B Garde & T Devine of Gap Unwilling to Testify for Kent.Kent & Counsel Unable to Produce Expert Witnesses ML20140G8331985-08-23023 August 1985 FOIA Request for ACRS Documents Re Facility ML20137F7061985-08-12012 August 1985 Forwards Listed Documents Written or Closed During Jul 1985, in Accordance w/730323 Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 & Amend 1 to Cp.Only Nonconformance Repts Encl ML20133L8331985-08-0909 August 1985 Forwards Attachment 1 to Revised Exhibit D of Revised Compliance Filing & Application for Authorization to Issue Securities.Plan Is Requirement of Agreements W/Banks to Restructure Outstanding Debt.Related Correspondence ML20132B1841985-07-19019 July 1985 Forwards Monthly Repts for May & June 1985 Per Condition of 730323 Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 & Amend 1 to Cp.Related Correspondence 1989-04-28
[Table view] Category:LEGAL/LAW FIRM TO NRC
MONTHYEARML20236U2571987-11-0505 November 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Ball Type Main Steam Isolation Valves Used at Facilities ML20235G2321987-04-0101 April 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Forged NDE Inspectors Certification Supplied by Barclay Intl for Use at Quad Cities Nuclear Station & Stated Investigations at Plants ML20214T7431986-09-24024 September 1986 Forwards Form 8-K Filed W/Securities & Exchange Commission. Util Believes Info Presented Bears No Issues Currently Before Aslb.Related Correspondence ML20206M8311986-08-15015 August 1986 Forwards Util Response to ASLB 860716 Order.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20202F9581986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Util Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Appeal Board Jurisdiction,For Filing.W/O Encl ML20207D7261986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Aslab Jurisdiction.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20209E6531986-03-28028 March 1986 FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order ML20133F7581985-10-0808 October 1985 Informs of Plans to Physically Disable Equipment Installed in & About Evaporator Bldg to Serve Process Steam to Dow Chemical Co,Per 850925 Resolution.Equipment & Structures Abandoned Are non-Q.Related Correspondence ML20133L8331985-08-0909 August 1985 Forwards Attachment 1 to Revised Exhibit D of Revised Compliance Filing & Application for Authorization to Issue Securities.Plan Is Requirement of Agreements W/Banks to Restructure Outstanding Debt.Related Correspondence ML20116C0311985-04-19019 April 1985 Forwards Proof of Svc of Motion for Leave to Participate as Amicus Curiae & Memorandum of City & County of Midland,Mi Re Aslab 850405 & 0313 Orders ML20115J5271985-04-19019 April 1985 Forwards Util Memorandum in Response to 850405 Order for Filing.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20115J5181985-04-19019 April 1985 Forwards Motion for Leave to Participate as Amicus Curiae & Memorandum of City & County of Midland,State of Mi Re ASLB 850405 & 0313 Orders.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20115J5371985-04-19019 April 1985 Forwards Bechtel Motion to Participate as Amicus Curiae & Response to Aslab 850405 Memorandum & Order.Requests That Motion Be Granted & Response Considered.Svc List Encl ML20129A0371985-04-16016 April 1985 FOIA Request for Plant Biennial Quality Audits for 1978,1980 & 1982 & Idvp for 1982 ML20128R0261985-04-0202 April 1985 FOIA Request for Eight Categories of Documents Re EA Kent Allegations Concerning Plants ML20133H8531985-04-0202 April 1985 FOIA Request for Eight Categories of Documents Re Ee Kent Allegations About Facilities for Oct 1980 to Present, Including NRC Investigations,Findings & Disposition of Subj Allegations ML20100F6731985-04-0101 April 1985 Considers Refs to Performance of Bechtel in ASLB 850123 Partial Initial Decision LBP-85-2 Unwarranted.Bechtel Was Not Party to Proceeding.Comments on Aslab 850313 Order Re LBP-85-2 Offered.Svc List Encl ML20112J5751985-04-0101 April 1985 Requests That Board Take No Action W/Respect to Proceeding Until Further Notice from Util & Board Not Require Interim Repts on Dow Litigation.Util Will Inform Board of Any Change in Status ML20112J6291985-04-0101 April 1985 Forwards Memorandum of CPC for Filing.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20111B7021985-03-11011 March 1985 Forwards Executed Util Re OL Fee Assessment,Per ML20111B7551985-03-0808 March 1985 Forwards Util 850307 Response to OL Fee Assessment Bills D0184 & D0185.Encl Ltr Xerox Copy Due to Logistical Difficulties.Original Executed Copy to Be Delivered by 850311 ML20106D7051985-02-0808 February 1985 Forwards Applicant Response to Intervenor Stamiris 841224 Pleading.Related Correspondence ML20101T0421985-02-0101 February 1985 Requests Extension Until 850306 to File Petition for Reconsideration of 850123 Partial Initial Decision to Enable Applicant to Analyze Decision Implications.Nrc & Intervenor Have No Objection to Request ML20101S8971985-02-0101 February 1985 Forwards Motion for Extension of Time within Which to File Notice of Appeal of ASLB Partial Initial Decision.W/O Encl. Related Correspondence ML20101S8831985-02-0101 February 1985 Requests Extension of Time Until 850306 to File Petition for Reconsideration of 850123 Partial Initial Decision to Enable Applicant to Analyze Lengthy & Complex Decision.Granted for ASLB on 850204.Served on 850204 ML20125B2381984-11-28028 November 1984 FOIA Request for Records Re Coating Delamination Problem at Midland ML20092H9971984-06-22022 June 1984 Forwards Applicant Reply to NRC Further Supplemental Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law Re QA & Applicant Reply to B Stamiris Second Set of Supplemental Findings.W/O Encls.Related Correspondence ML20084H7321984-05-0202 May 1984 Forwards Memorandum Opposing Govt Accountability Project Petition for Review for Filing.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20083Q3831984-04-17017 April 1984 Repeats Request for ASLB to Withhold Decision on Intervenor 830808 Motion to Litigate Issues Raised by Dow Suit & to Open Discovery on Dow Issues.Review of Documents Should Be Complete in 2 Wks ML20090L6721984-03-15015 March 1984 Summarizes 840314 Telcon Decisions & Clarifies 840201 FOIA Request for Documents Re Facilities ML20087L0921984-03-15015 March 1984 Proposes to Defer Response to Stamiris 840304 Contention Re Transamerica Delaval Diesel Generators.Proof of Svc Encl ML20087G4191984-03-15015 March 1984 Proposes to Defer Response to Stamiris OL Contention Re Transamerica Delaval Diesel Generators Until After Receiving Stamiris Ltr in Support of Timeliness of Contention.Proof of Svc Encl ML20080N8721984-02-17017 February 1984 Requests Removal of Wc Potter from Svc List as Atty for Dow Chemical Co.Related Correspondence ML20086M7471984-02-10010 February 1984 Submits List of Corrections to 840127 Proposed Second Supplemental Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law for Partial Initial Decision on QA Issues.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20105C3081984-02-0101 February 1984 FOIA Request for Matls on Encl List of Concerns Re Facility ML20079Q2981984-01-27027 January 1984 Forwards Proposed Second Supplemental Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law for Partial Initial Decision of QA Issues & cross-reference to Previously Filed Proposed Findings & Responses to Proposed Findings on QA ML20079Q3061984-01-27027 January 1984 Forwards cross-reference to All Util Filed Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law for Partial Initial Decision on QA Issues ML20081B0741984-01-23023 January 1984 FOIA Request for Repts Re Results of Investigation of Failed Reactor Vessel Holddown Studs on Unit 1 Reactor Vessel ML20079H8351984-01-19019 January 1984 Forwards Util Preliminary Pretrial Statement Filed in State of Mi Circuit Court for County of Midland.Statement Sent in Fulfillment of Obligation to Keep ASLB Informed of Developments Relevant to Proceeding ML20083H6311984-01-0303 January 1984 Forwards Replies to NRC 831115 & Stamiris 831216 Findings on Remedial Soils Issues,Per ASLB 830929 Order ML20082J5701983-11-23023 November 1983 Forwards Summarizing Presentation on Behalf of Util at 831115 Enforcement Conference in Chicago,Il ML20082J5811983-11-22022 November 1983 Documents Remarks Made on Behalf of Util at 831115 Enforcement Conference Re Alleged Violation of ASLB 820430 Order.Escalated Enforcement Action Inappropriate Due to 820611 Landsman Approval of Minor Excavations ML20081G7321983-11-0303 November 1983 Forwards Exhibit C to Motion to Compel & Application for Enforcement of Subpoenas Against Govt Accountability Project Deponents.W/O Encl.Svc List Encl ML20081D7951983-10-27027 October 1983 Forwards State of Mi Circuit Court Protective Order Entered by Stipulation in Dow Litigation ML20085L3541983-10-18018 October 1983 Forwards Documents Not Served at 830728 & 0921 Hearings. Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20080T3371983-10-17017 October 1983 Corrects Typographical Errors Found in Applicant Response to Second Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Intervenor B Stamiris Motion to Litigate Dow Issues ML20079R0681983-09-29029 September 1983 FOIA Request for Documents Re Evaluation or Review of Design Const,Scheduling,Cost & Licensing of Facilities from 1977 to Present ML20080F7921983-09-14014 September 1983 Forwards Bechtel Ltr to Util Re Completion of Work Noted as Deficiency in Diesel Generator Bldg Notice of Violation. Installation Dates Derived from Various Unofficial But Reliable Documents.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20076L5131983-09-13013 September 1983 Forwards Seismic Margin Review,Vol Iv,Svc Water Pump Structure Margin Evaluation ML20077N7391983-09-0101 September 1983 Requests Depositions of CM Erb & Je Foster,For Defense in Lawsuit Re Claimed Failures of Structural Support Bolts 1987-04-01
[Table view] |
Text
~ ,- .. . .. . _ _ _ _ _ .
t i ak 4dp 1
. ISHAM, LINCOLN & BE LE
/ COUNSELORS AT LAW '
CCL'LI&
' 1120 CONNECTICUT AVENUE. N W * $UITE 840
=
WASHaNGTON. Q C. 20036 EDWWtc $. l$ HAM. 1972 1900 202 833-9730 CHICAGO OFFICE wYife"[ASI EE '65 Uh -4 NO LM.Tu'W.0 0. TELEPHONE 312 S447500 April 1, 1985 " ' "
p 7 :- Sa tila '
g~ ~.n. - s S g r r-
, p Mc -
Charles Bechhoefer, Esq. Dr. Jerry Harbour i
Atomic Safety & Licensing Atomic Safety &-Licensing Board Panel Board Panel --
i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 i
Dr. Frederick P. Cowan _ m 6152 N. Verde Trail
. Apt. B-125
. Boca Raton, Florida 33433 4- Re:- In the Matter of CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2) j Docket Nos. 50-329 OM & OL and 50-330'OM & OL
Dear Administrative Judges:
In a letter dated September 10, 1984, Consumers- ~
! Power Company (" Consumers" or "the Company") notified the j Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (" Board") that the Company t had announced complete shutdown of design, construction, and l testing activities for the Midland plant and that the Company l would not likely revive the project in the near future. In that letter, Consumers also indicated that it would file an
- additional report on the status of the Midland project with this' Licensing Board 6 months from the time of the September
, 10 letter. On January 23, 1985, this Board issued its Partial Initial Decision on the technical aspects of remedial soils
[ issues. Consumers Power Company (Midland Plants' Units 1 and 2 ) ,, LBP-8 5-2, slip opinion (Jan. 23, 1985). In LBP-85-2, the i Board stated:
i
- i. We agree.. . . that the Applicant j should file a 6-month status report. Such l
- j. report should include recommendations as to ~
)
i future hearings. In particular, it should i outline information' discovered in the Dow-CPC litigation which would affect these i proceedings, as to which Ms. Stamiris seeks
! 'further hearings. Such report should be j filed on or-before April 1, 1985. .
~
!!M8iliK8388%,
l 9 63
- - , , . .~.- ,, ., , . _ _ _ . . - - ,.- -,. ~ ,, __ _ , - - - , .. _ , _ , ,-,,- _ ___, , , . . . , , . . . . , - , _ _ . _ , . _
. I This letter constitutes the 6-month status report suggested in the September 10 letter and referred to by the Board.
Status of the Project The Midland project remains in a shutdown condition.
The objectives of current activities are preserving the accumulated project assets and preserving the option to complete one or both units under the appropriate conditions.
Consumers has established an organization to perform the activities essential to accomplishing these objectives.
The project shutdown encompasses two distinct phases, the Demobilization Phase and the Surveillance and Maintenance Phase. The substantially complete Demobilization
- Phase governed the transition from an active construction
> project to a steady state situation in which the facility can be maintained-in an appropriate condition. In the on-going Surveillance and Maintenance (S&M) Phase the Company plans and carrie's out activities to preserve the plant in its shutdown condition. This Phase will continue until a decision has'been
- made regarding the ultimate disposition of the facility.
Although the nominal transition date between the Demobilization Phase and the Surveillance and Maintenance phase was January 1, 1985, some surveillance and maintenance activities were initiated prior to that date and some demobilization activities extend beyond that date.
The activities of the Demobilization Phase included personnel destaffing, contractor demobilization, records collection and contract and purchase order closecut. The S&M
! Phase consists of a planned set of continuing activities requiring minimal resources while preserving the plant in its shutdown condition. These activities include system layup, preventive and corrective maintenance, soils monitoring, storage, corrosion monitoring, salvage and sales, and housekeeping. Part or all of each of the above activities is safety related. A Quality Assurance Program Plan covers the safety-related activities of the S&M Phase of the Project.
The Plan was submitted to Region III on October 1, 1984. In addition to the specific quality-related activities listed abovr., the Plan provides for the normal quality assurance activities of certifying audit and inspection personnel,-
non-conformance' management, evaluation of suppliers, determining reportability pursuant to 10 C.F.R. Part 21 and 10 C.F.R. S 50.55 (e) , and corrective action management.
The records management program is one of the more complex aspects of the Demobilization and Surveillance and Maintenance Phases. Consumers recognizes successful records management for its importance to continued plant 4
._. __ _ _ _. ~ __ ._.
licensability. The Ccmpany's general approach has been to return the permanent project records to the appropriate document control center or project file as part of the shutdown. During the demobilization phase, individuals
- leaving the project turned in documents in their personal possession for collection and retention. Records in document control or record centers will be stored or maintained as they were in the centers prior to shutdown to facilitate retrieval and active use during the S&M Phase. Most documents turned in during shutdown are classified as inactive records and are managed under a storage program which assures their retrievability, but not on short notice.
As part of the demobilization activities the permanent equipment and facilities of the plant were placed in a safe, maintainable condition and turned over by the Bechtel Power Corporation and subcontractors to Consumers. Consumers developed a long-term layup and maintenance program to preserve the equipment and facilities during the Surveillance and Maintenance Phase. The generic engineering reviews and overall planning are complete. The generation and implementation of specific detailed criteria is continuing.
All materials and equipment which would not be part of the permanent plant installation are being recovered, inventoried, and stored or salvaged.
The status of the soils work as of the July 16, 1984 shutdown was such that the tasks necessary to secure the underpinning in a safe layup condition were minor. Consumers wrote a series of letters to the NRC Staff in July and August which described the tasks necessary to secure the soils remedial work. These letters requested and obtained NRC concurrence to take the steps necessary to do so. As of December 1984, Consumers Power had provided Region III a draft proposal detailing the S&M monitoring requirements. Based on the NRC's general concurrence, Consumers implemented this monitoring program. Detailed monitoring requirements are still under review by NRR. Consumers will continue to keep NRC Region III informed as soils related shutdown activities are performed. The plant cooling pond dewatering, the last significant shutdown task related to soils work, was successfully completed in inid-December, 1984.
Future Hearings In the September 10, 1984 letter, Consumers informed the Board that it had discontinued all licensing activities concerning Midland except those necessary to preserve the option to complete the plant. The Company requested that the Board not hold any further evidentiary hearings in the OM/OL proceeding at that time. In a letter dated October 26, 1984 i
,,.- n. - - - . . - - - -
to the Board, the NRC Staff also recognized that it would not be productive at that time to hold any further evidentihry hearings in the OM/OL proceeding for the Midland project. In its Partial Initial Decision, LBP-85-2, supra at 18, the Board also stated: "We agree that no" further hearings should be held in the near future . . . .
In September the Company stated that it had no plans either to withdraw its operating license application or to surrender the construction permits for the Midland facility, i On November 5, 1984, Consumers furnished this Board with a copy of an affidavit of Mr. John D. Selby, Chairman of the Board of Consumers. In this affidavit, Mr. Selby had set forth in response to discovery requests in the Midland Rate Case Consumers' plans for the Midland project. Mr. Selby stated: "The Company is not planning to resume Midland construction or to spend any money for that purpose in 1985, 1986 or anytime in the future. The Company will not unilaterally resume Midland construction in 1985, 1986, or thereafter."
Mr. Selby further indicated that the only circumstance which would allow Consumers to consider resuming construction on the plant would be support of appropriate governmental officials to complete the plant as being in the public interest coupled with availability of an infusion of sufficient outside funds to complete the plant. Mr. Selby also indicated that by keeping the plant properly maintained and retaining the construction permits, the Company has a more marketable product because it will be able to keep a documented NRC Quality Assurance Program in place. If no
, interest in finishing the plant materializes, the Company will, no later than 1987, "do whatever is necessary to claim an abandonment loss for federal income tax purposes."
The status of the project has not changed since the fall of 1984. The Company still wishes to maintain for a i
finite time the option of reactivating the project, but has no
- present plan to reactivate. The Company has altered neither its intention to maintain the Midland facility construction permits nor its intention not to unilaterally recume construction in the future unless circumstances change as outlined above.
Consumers therefore requests that this Licensing Board take no action either to terminate the present licensing proceedings or to hold any further hearings on any subject
! until such time as Consumers announces a decision on the fate 3
of the project. The Company will notify the Board promptly of any decision regarding the disposition of the project, whether
. _ _ _ _ - - _ _ = -- - -- . - - .
it be reactivation of construction, abandonment, or some other alternative.
Reporting Recuirements Consumers will continue to provide reports of l conditions pursuant to 10 C.F.R. 50.55(e). In the September ,
10, 1984 letter, Consumers sought permission to discontinue I submitting audit and nonconformance reports to this Board. . I Separately, in a September 11, 1984 letter to H.R. Denton, Consumers requested that submittals pursuant to ALAB-106 be deferred. It has been agreed that ALAB-106 reporting requirements will be continued. The Partial Initial Decision requests that one copy of audit and nonconformance reports be provided to the Board. The Company will meet its obligation to supply the Board with these reports by placing the Board Chairman on distribution for the ALAB-106 report.
The NRC Staff and Consumers are still discussing the appropriate monitoring and reporting requirements pertaining to soils remedial work during the period of shutdown. The monitoring requirements proposed to Region III in December, 1984 are being implemented.
Disclosure of Developments in the Dow Litigation In the January 23, 1995 Partial Initial Decision, LBP-85-2, supra at 18, the Board requested Consumers to
" outline information discovered in the Dow-CPC litigation which would affect these proceedings." The standard governing an applicant's duty to disclose new information to a Board originated in Duke Power Company (William B. McGuire Nuclear Station, Units 1 & 2) , ALAB-143, 6 A.E.C. 623, 625-26 (1973) and has been followed in numerous cases thereafter. In McGuire, the Appeal Board identified the underlying ground for the disclosure rule as the risk that a Licensing Board might make a decision based on incomplete, outdated, or erroneous evidence:
If the presiding board and other parties are not informed in a timely manner of such changes, the inescapable result vill be that reasoned decision-making would suffer. Indeed, the adjudication could become meaningless, for adjudicatory boards would be passing upon evidence which would not accurately reflect existing facts.
Id. Along the same line, the Appeal Board more recently noted:
l A review of our case precedents . . . shows that the " Board notification obligation" of an applicant or licensee seems to pertain more to matters that could affect the course of the litigation, such as a change in the license application or an event that would moot or resolve some issue.
Metropolitan Edison Company (Three Mile Island Nuclear Station, Unit 1) , ALAB-774, 19 N.R.C. 1350, 1358 n.6 (1984).
McGuire states and Three Mile Island suggests implicitly that imminence of some decision is a major factor in evaluating the timeliness requirement. Of course, a decision to reactivate or abandon the Midland project would require prompt notification of the Board in the circumstances of this case, but the matter in the Dow litigation hardly rises to such a level of urgency.
The Applicant is also bound not to make materisl false statements under S 186a of the Atomic Energy Act of 1954 by omitting to disclose information that appears to raise serious issue. Id. Materiality relates not only to the apparent significance of information but also to its relation to issues before the tribunal and to the imminence of any decision by it. The Commission has stated: "There is no obvious boundary between material information and trivia, but clear cases of both exist, and a careful attention to context along with a healthy dose of common sense will resolve most problems." Virginia Electric and Power Company (North Anna Power Station, Units 1 and 2), CLI-76-22, 4 N.R.C. 480, 487 (1976). According to the Commission, the degree of materiality of information is also related to the imminence of a decision. Id. at 487-88. Only when the record in that case is closed and a decision has been rendered will the Company and the Board be in a position to judge materiality, which must be done in the context of the entire record and the court's findings of fact.
Since this Board is not currently adjudicating anything (see LBP-85-2), and since, we assume, no hearings are planned in the foreseeable future, the governing case law simply does not require that Consumers keep the Board completely current on every development in the Dow litigation.
In any event, the case law recognizes that a licensee has a
~
reasonable time within which to evaluate new information before the possibility of a disclosure requirement ripens into a present duty. See Three Mile Island, ALAB-774, supra at 1359; United States Department of Energy (Clinch River Breeder Reactor Plant), CLI-82-22, 16 N.R.C. 405, 408 (1982). Here,
%^ - -__
r t
it is not reasonable for the Company to digest and evaluate the significance of bits and pieces of the Dow litigation record before the record in that case has been' closed and a decision has been rendered.
I We have already requested that this Licensing Board not conduct further hearings.in this case until Consumers announces a decision on the future of the project. During i this time period, Consumers requests that it be excused from providing the Board with interim information regarding the Dow litigation except as it may be already required to be included in nonconformance reports or reports of conditions pursuant to
- 10 C.F.R. S 50.55 (e) .
At an appropriate time Consumers will inform the Board of any significant information bearing on issues relevant to the licensing proceeding which have been disclosed in the totality of the Dow litigation record, including providing a copy of the court's findings of fact and conclusions of law.
Conclusion For all of the foregoing reasons, Consumers respectfully requests this Licensing Board to take no action with respect to this proceeding until further notification by the Company. The Company also requests that the Board not l require interim reports on the Dow litigation. Finally, Consumers commits to informing the Board forthwith of any significant change in the status of the project regarding reactivation of construction, abandonment, or some other alternative.-
Sincerely, 4
%dadC frL Frederick C. Williams Counsel for Consumers Power Company FCW:kis cc: Service List 1
i 1
7-
esaw.ws srei ,
Frank J._Kolley, Esq. Steve Gadler, E2q. l
, AttornGy G9noral of th2 2120 Cartar Avsnus ;
Stato of Michigan St. Paul, Minnosota 55108 l Carole Steinberg, Esq. i Assistant Attorney General l':mic Safety & Licensing Environmental Protection Div. Appeal Panel 720 Law ~ Building _ U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.
Lansing, Michigan 48913 Washington, D. C. 20555 Myron M. Cherry, Esq.
Cherry & Flynn Chief, Docketing & Services Suite 3700 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.
Three First National Plaza Office of the Secretary Chicago, Illinois 60602 Washington, D. C. 20555 Mr. Wendell H. Marshall Ms. Mary Sinclair 4625 S. Saginaw Road 5711 Sc==erset Street Midland, Michigan 48640 Midland, Michigan 48640 Charles Bechhoefer, Esq. William D. Paton, Esq.
Atomic Safety & Licensing Counsel for the NRC Staff Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=m.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm. Washington, D. C. 20555 Washington, D. C. 20555 Atomic Safety & Licensing Dr. Frederick P. Ocwan Board Panel 6152 N. Verde Trail U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc=m.
Apt. 3-125 Washington, D. C. 20555 Boca Raton, Florida 33433 Ms. Barbara Stamiris Mr. D. F. Judd 5795 North River Road Babecek & Wilcox Route 3 P. O. Box 1260 Freeland, Michigan 48623 Lynchburg, Virginia 24505 Dr. Jerry Harbour James E. Brunner, Esq. Atomic Safety & Licensing Consumers Power Company Board Panel 212 West Michigan Avenue U.S. Nuclear Regula: Cry Cc=m.
Jackson, Michigan 49201 Washin'gton, D. C. 20555 Lynne Bernahei, ,Esq. Alan S. Rosenthal Thomas Devine, Esq. Chairman Louis Clark, Esq. Atomic Safety and Licensing Gcvernment Accountability Project Appeal Panel of the Institute for Policy Studies E/W 532 1901 0 Stree , N.W. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Washington, D. C. 20009 Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Samuel A. Haubold, Esq.
Kirkland & Ellis Thomas S. Moore 1 200 East Randolph Drive Atomic Safety and Licensing l Chicago, Illinois 60601 Appeal Panel
)
E/W 532 i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory l Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 '
l
_ ___ _