ML20027E511

Forwards Documents Responsive to 820830 Request,Numbers 17 & 23.Svc List & Index of Documents Only Encl.Related Correspondence

ML20027E511
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	11/08/1982
From:	Brunner J CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To:	Stamiris B STAMIRIS, B.
References
ISSUANCES-OL, ISSUANCES-OM, NUDOCS 8211150445
Download: ML20027E511 (4)

Text

. .

U p;rzo emp h Skb 82 F.0V 12 m :29 l November 8, 1982 ~  : MC:G.= ?

n;$5b;M I;C &N '

Mrs Barbara Stamiris U 5795.N River Road DOMET NUMBER J. . ,,

p gO Freelend, MI h8623 M0. & UT:' FA ,...m.... .

Dear Mrs Stamiris Enclosed' herewith are documents responsive to your request of August 30, 1982, Nos 17 and 23 Because of my absence from the office, I was unable to mail these documents on November h or 5 However, I have provided them to you by Federal Express, which should more than make up for this delay.

In responding to your request, the following interpretations were adhered to:

1. Regarding request number 17, documents provided are those relevant to reduced life expectancy because of reactor vessel velds.

2. Documents and correspondence provided under request number 23 include those relating to the reactor vessel velds properties and relevant to the contention on reduced operating life expectancy (Contention 1). '

Many of these documents are highly technical in nature due to the technical content of your contention.

3 Attached herewith is an index of documents indicating author and addressee, if available. Other documents were written by either Consumers Power Company, Babcock and Wilcox, the NRC, the AEC, or other parties identified on the documents.

h. Proprietary documents of the Babcock and Wilcox Company or Consumers Power Company vill be provided under a separate cover when a pro-tective order is put into effect by the Hearing Board. A list of Babcock and Wilcox proprietary documents is attached to this sub-mittal. In addition, there are a few miscellaneous proprietary documents of B&W not yet on the list and of Consumers Power Company. All of these documents are highly technical in nature and appear to be cumulative of the other documents supplied to you.

Very truly yours

(

J es E Brunner CC OL-0M List 8211150445 821108 PDR ADOCK 05000329 G PDR I

'DS03

- t EXHIBIT A

\

1. Letter, C.L. Whitmarsh to A.L. Lowe, " Midland 1 Addendum to BAW-1511P",

6/11/82.

2. C.L. Whitmarsh, Calculations in Support of Item 1 Above, 6/9/82. -

3. Letter, R.M. Reyns to Distribution, May 12, 1977 Meeting, RV Weld Replacement".

6/8/77.

4. Table, "Mn-Mo-Ni/Linde 80 Wire Flux Qualifications", undated.

5. Table, " Weld Record", undated.

6. Table, "Preirradiation Charpy Impact Data", undated.

7. Table, Reg. Guide 1.99 - EFPY to 50 ft-lb, undated.

8. Table and Figures, " Predicted Time to Drop Below 50 ft-lb", undated.

\

9. Table, " Analysis of WF-70", 9/9/76.

10. Letter, H.S. Palme to Impact Toughness Task Force Members, " Fracture.

Mechanics Preliminary Evaluation", 8/18/76.

11. Letter, C.E. Harris to Distribution, " Completion of Atypical Weld Test Program",

4/19/79.

12. ketter, R.A. Fearing to J.I. Qureski, " Test Material Source for Available Data Generating Program", 5/22/79.

13. Tables, Figures, Graphs, Charpy Data, undatea.

14. Letter, W.L. Gilbert to Distribution, "177 FA Archive Weld Metal Inventory, 12/13/76.

15. Letter, H.L. Helmbrecht to N.C. Jessen, "Cu, P, S, and Va in Weld Metal Subject to Radiation", 4/13/71. ,

16. Letter, R.A. Fearing to H.S. Palme, " Test Results of Beltline Materials for Selection of Surveillance Material", 9/12/74.

17. Letter, C.E. Mahaney to J.D. Agar /J.0. Howard, " Overpressure Protection:

Atypical Weld", 2/29/80.-

18. Letter, R.M. Reyns to E.0. Hooker, " Trip Report - Copley Meeting - RV Weld Replacement", 5/13/77.

19. Letter, R.M. Reyns to Distributi_on,""RV Weld Replacement - Copley Meeting",

5/6/77.

20. Letter, R.F. Hollander to C.E. Mahaney, "QA Data Package", 10/20/75.

21. Letter, W.P. Durant to File, " Shop Baseline Inspection Meeting - June 14, 1973",

6/15/73.

22.

Letter, C.E.

1974", Mahaney to J.E. Hoke, "CPC0 Meeting at Mt. Vernon January 23-24, 2/14/74.

' 23. Letter, C.E. Harris to C.E. Mahaney, " Atypical Weld Issue",10/3/79.

24. Letter, S.B. Skaar to C.E. Mahaney, "Non-Compliance with 10 CFR 50 App. G and H and Atypical Welds", 7/13/79. .

25. Graph, WF-70,12 in. Thick Nozzle Dropout.

26. Letter, K.E. Moore to W. Gilbert, "Cv use Projections for Irradiated RV Beltline Region Welds", 9/29/ST. '/f,

27. Letter, G.N. Emmanual to J.H. Taylor, 'JResponse to NRC Bulletin 78 Atypical Weld Material", 11/13/78.

28. Letter. A.S. Heller to K. . Moore, " Phase 1 Summary Report - Task D Chemistry Characterization", 11/23/77.

29. Letter, A.S. Heller to K.E. Moore, " Phase 1, Task D - Chemistry of Welds",3/22/78.

30. Letter, A.S. Heller to K.E. Moore, " Weld Chemistry Analysis", 8/17/77.

31. Table, " Chemistry Laboratory Work Request", 5/24/77.

32. Memorandum, R.A. Fearing to C.E. Harris, " Surveillance Weld - NSS 12",

5/3/78.

33. Table, " Chemical Analys1s of Weld Metal from 177 FA Plants", undated.

34. Table, " Record of Filler Wire Qualification Test", 10/21/69.

35. Letter, L. Katz to R.R. Seeley, "ASME Fatigue Design Curves for Cast -

Materials and Weldments", 4/27/78.

36. Report of Impact Toughness Task Force for Period June 2,1976 - December 15, 1976. .

+

O

. k D

',, SERVICE LIST  !

Frank J Kelldy, Esq Atomic Safet7 & Licensing -

Attemey General of the Appeal Panel .

Statecot Michigan U S Nuclear Regulatory Ccmn Carole Steinberg, Esq Washington.,. D C 20555 Assistant Attorney General .

Enviren=e=tal Prctection Div . Mr C R Stephens 720 Lav Building Chief, Docketing & Services.

Icusing, MI hS913 ~

7 S Nuclear Regulatory Comm.

Office of the Secretary Myren M Cherr7, Esq ' Washington, D C 20555 Cne tam Pla a:

Suite h501 Ms Mary Sinclair Chica6o, IL 60611

• 5711 St=m:erset. Street -

Midland, MI h86h0 Mr Wendan E Marshall RFD.10 .

William D Paton', Esq ,

Midland, Mr.h86h0 . - Counsel for the NRC' Staff U S Nuclear Regulstery Ccmm.

Charles.3echhoefer, Esq Washington,D C 20555 Atcmic Safety & Licensing ,

3 card Panel . Atcmic Safety & Licensing U S Nuclear Regula cry Cc=a Board Panel Washingten,.D C 20555 'E S

• Nuclear Regulatcry Cc=n

-- . Wash % gton, D C 20555 Dr Frederick.? Ccvan .

~ '

6152F.T Verde. Sail ,

Barbara Stamdris Atp 3-125 .

5T95 North River Road.

Boca Raten, FL 33h33 Rt 3 Freeland, MI h8623 .

Jerry Earbour Atc=ic- Safety & Licensing Bo'ard Panel Carroll 'I Mahaney U S Nuclear Regulatory C-Babcock & Wilecx Washington, D C 20555 PO Box 1260 '

Lynchburg, Virginia 24505 Lee L 31 shop '

Har=ca & Weiss James E 3 runner, Esq 1725 "I" Street , NW #506 Consumers Pcver Cc =any Washington, DC 20006 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson, MI h9201 M I Miller, Esq Isham, Lincoln & Beale Mr D ? Judd Three. National Plaza 3abcock & Wilcoz. 52nd Floor PO Box 1260 Chicago, IL 60603 Lynchburg, VA 24505 John Demeester, Esq Steve Gadler , Esq Dov Chemical 31ds 2120 Carter Avenue Michigan Division at Paul, MN 55108 Midland, MI h86h0

.