ML20211E231

Forwards 860328 & 0402 Communication Repts Re Phase 4 Independent Assessment Program,Including Use of ACI 349 & Board Notification on Comanche Peak Response Team Plan

ML20211E231
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	10/20/1986
From:	Williams N CYGNA ENERGY SERVICES
To:	Ellis J Citizens Association for Sound Energy
References
84056.105, NUDOCS 8610220382
Download: ML20211E231 (3)

Text

!

8** _

2121 N California Blvd . Suite 390. Walnut Creek, CA 94596 415/934-5733 October 20, 1986 84056.105 Mrs. Juanita Ellis Presidents CASE 1426 S. Polk Dallas, TX 75224 s

Subject:

Communications Report Transmittal #17 Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Independent Assessment Program - Phase 4 Texas-Utilities Generating Company Job No. 84056

Dear Mrs. Ellis:

Enclosed please find some communications reports associated with the Phase 4 Independent Assessment Program.

If you have any questions or desire to discuss any of these documents, please do not hesitate to call.

Very truly yours, b' ldk N.H. Williams Project Manager NHW/ta Attachments cc: Mr. J. Redding (TUGCO) w/ attachments Mr. S. Treby (USNRC) w/ attachments Mr. J. Finneran (TUGCO) w/ attachments Mr. D. Pigott (Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe) w/o attachments Mrs. A. Vietti-Cook (USNRC) w/ attachments t

San Francisco Boston Chicago t j 0610220382 861020 PDR ADOCK 05000445 A PDR

Communications .

. 1 6 i Report E!MillllHillllllHil 1

T I company: E * * " "****#

Robert L. Cloud Pro,.ct Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Job N 84056 Independent Assessment Program - Phase 4 oste: 3/28/86 sue,ect Cygna Review Issue Regarding the Use of ACI 349 Time 9:45 a.m. )

Place SFR0

Participants:

Martin Huano of pnhart i rinna r. acenciatne John Russ ,, CES of item Comments Reg'd Action By Mr. Huang called to inquire what Cygna's intent was regarding the Review Issues on the use of ACI 349. He asked if Cygna was questioning the consistency of use of the code passages of ACI 349 as employed by Gibbs & Hill. I replied that Cygna questioned Gibbs & Hill's selective use of the code provisions for qualifying some anchor bolts with spacing violations and the use of the code provisions in arriving at the allowable values for Richmond Inserts as reported by the on-site testing program. Mr. Huang also asked about Cygna's issue on the provisions of section 7.3 of Appendix B. He wanted to know how this provision affected the factor of safety of expansion anchors. I stated that this provision was to be applied to code derived anchor allowables.

3. <

-f l~ r .

~

Page/ # I Signed " [ ] {/ d Qgff Q s 1 of Distribution 61 . Will dmd, V.MUuuing, V. t1nneran, M. t1055, d. HUS5, 5. IreDy, d. Lills.

A. v s t L L i- Cuu r s ' I V J t.N L r6se

COmmuniCGlionS

( 6 i Repod Mlllllllllllllllllll t  !

Company: C ES 10 Teiecon a conference Report Pro $t: Texas Utilities C PSES IAP Phase 4 Job No. 84056 D *

4/2/86  !

suwt: D ** '

Board Notification on CPR T Plan 2:05 p.m.

Place-

Participants:

Billie Garde G AP (Gov't. Acct'ty Prj.)

Of J. Russ cygna of of item Comments Reg'd Action By Ms. Garde called to request a document from Cygna. See stated that a Board Notification com menting on the CP RT plan had been sent to the ASLB during the last week of March. This Board Notification was either sent to Cygna or by the N R C Staff with Cygna's com ments at-tached. She stated that she could notlocate this document anywhere else and requested that Cygna check to see if it was originated by them or was in their possession.

,,of. 4,

, ) s signed ' j j Q(Q, Q,Q/dL;/ Jg /ta page 1 or 1 y ......c...,v. m m m, m. ,,_,,m. ....,m. . . . , , . -

o,,,,,,,,,,w. . . . o o . , > , v . m c m v . . 3, e .

. - _ - - _