Environ Review of Zimmer Site Status for Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co. W/Two Oversize Figures.Aperture Cards Are Available in PDRML20091J146 |
Person / Time |
---|
Site: |
Zimmer |
---|
Issue date: |
05/31/1984 |
---|
From: |
DAMES & MOORE |
---|
To: |
|
---|
Shared Package |
---|
ML20091J135 |
List: |
---|
References |
---|
NUDOCS 8406050409 |
Download: ML20091J146 (8) |
|
|
---|
Category:NON-RECURRING TECHNICAL REPORT (ENVIRONMENTAL)
MONTHYEARML20091J1461984-05-31031 May 1984 Environ Review of Zimmer Site Status for Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co. W/Two Oversize Figures.Aperture Cards Are Available in PDR 1984-05-31
[Table view] Category:TEXT-ENVIRONMENTAL REPORTS
MONTHYEARML20129A3931985-04-0909 April 1985 Notice of Environ Assessment & Finding of No Significant Impact Supporting Issuance of Order Revoking CPPR-88 ML20091J1461984-05-31031 May 1984 Environ Review of Zimmer Site Status for Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co. W/Two Oversize Figures.Aperture Cards Are Available in PDR ML20083N0451983-01-31031 January 1983 Rev 6 to Environ Rept ML20062K9281980-08-31031 August 1980 Public Version of Preliminary Evacuation Time Study of Plume Exposure Emergency Planning Zone Around Wh Zimmer Nuclear Power Station,Unit 1 1985-04-09
[Table view] Category:TEXT-SAFETY REPORT
MONTHYEARML20215G2441987-06-16016 June 1987 Part 21 Rept Re Failure of Load Sequencing Equipment Supplied in Aug 1977 During Scheduled Testing.Caused by Open Electrical Connection on One Crimp Lug.Since 1978,insulated Lugs Used on All Equipment ML20206S0841986-06-30030 June 1986 Part 21 Rept Re Possible Cut Wires in Wire Harness of Bbc Brown Boveri K600/K800 Circuit Breakers.Initially Reported on 860509.Safety Implications Listed.Gear Guard Designed to Prevent Cut Wires ML20129B2831985-07-0909 July 1985 Part 21 Rept Re Hk Control Device.Initially Reported by TVA in 850703 Morning Rept.Parts to Be Supplied for Completion of Insp/Adjusting Procedure Included in 830322 Part 21 Rept ML20091J1461984-05-31031 May 1984 Environ Review of Zimmer Site Status for Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co. W/Two Oversize Figures.Aperture Cards Are Available in PDR ML20080N0191984-02-10010 February 1984 Final Deficiency Rept S-18 Re Structural Steel Beam Nonconformances.Initially Reported on 840113.Due to Plan to Convert Facility to coal-fired Power Plant,No Further Action or Correspondence Planned on Item ML20086L7101984-02-0303 February 1984 Final Deficiency Rept,Item E-58 Re Flammability Control Unit Motor Control Terminal Cabinets.Initially Reported on 840104.Deficiency Determined Not Reportable Per 10CFR50.55(e) ML20079N2781984-01-17017 January 1984 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-104 Re Qualifications of Energy Absorbing Matl Used in Design & Const of High Energy Pipe Whip Restraints.Initially Reported on 831219.Test Procedure Development in Process.Next Rept Due by 840401 ML20079H3021984-01-16016 January 1984 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item E-50 Re Annunciator Sys Replacement Light Bulbs.Dimmer Rheostats for Lamp Circuits in Main Control Room Annunciator Sys Will Be Bypassed to Minimize Line Resistance & Maximize Short Circuit Current ML20079F8391984-01-10010 January 1984 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-67 Re Lack of Procedural Qualifications for Pipe Bends.Initially Reported on 821109. Post-qualification Program Completed for 35 Bends.Corrective Action Program Will Be Conducted ML20079E8101984-01-10010 January 1984 Final Deficiency Rept,Item E-53 Re Switchgear Wiring Diagram Discrepancies.Initially Reported on 830922.All Discrepancies Resolved.Deficiencies Not Reportable Under 10CFR050.55(e) ML20083J1651984-01-0606 January 1984 Rev 2 to Vols 1 & 2 of Environ Qualification Rept for Class IE Equipment ML20079E2621984-01-0505 January 1984 Quality Confirmation Program, Monthly Rept for Dec 1983 ML20086G7551984-01-0303 January 1984 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item Q-14 Re Control of Design Specs.Initially Reported on 831013.Measures to Ensure That Approved Specs Issued as Controlled Documents in Progress. Final Rept Will Be Submitted Upon Completion of Activities ML20086N0421984-01-0202 January 1984 Final Part 21 Rept Re Potential Problem Concerning Radiography of Branch Connection Welds Covered by Reinforcing Pads.Welds at Byron,Braidwood & North Anna Acceptable.Weld 7 at Clinton Reradiographed ML20091A2241983-12-31031 December 1983 Ohio Edison Annual Rept,1983 ML20091A2421983-12-31031 December 1983 Duquesne Light Co Annual Rept,1983 ML20091A2551983-12-31031 December 1983 Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co 1983 Annual Rept ML20083E4111983-12-31031 December 1983 Revised Audit of Program to Verify Quality of Const & Continuation of Const Plan ML20083J7521983-12-30030 December 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item E-30 Re Lack of Installation Insp of non-Class IE Cables in Panels.Initially Reported on 821027.Analysis Identified 575 Deviations Requiring Rework. Final Rept Will Be Submitted Upon Completion ML20086G7071983-12-29029 December 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-32 Re Incomplete Hydraulic Analysis of Control Rod Drive Piping.Verification of Installed Hardware Will Be Completed Under Plan to Verify Quality of Const Submitted 831216 ML20083F8281983-12-29029 December 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-46 Re Turning Vane Failures in Essential HVAC Sys.Initially Reported on 820510.Design Mods Completed.Adequacy of Vanes Less than 30 Inches Wide in Elbows Will Be Verified ML20083F8481983-12-28028 December 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item Q-12 Re Failure to Follow Procedure for Insp of Qa/Qc Rework/Repair Activities. Initially Reported on 830909.Hardware Will Be Inspected to Validate Design Drawings.Procedures Under Development ML20083J6451983-12-27027 December 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept S-10 Re Masonry Wall Const.Initially Reported on 830513.Reinsp & Corrective Action Program Will Be Selected Per Course of Action Approved by NRC on 831216 ML20083E1101983-12-14014 December 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item E-47 Re Target Rock Solenoid Operated Valves Used in Essential Sys W/Excessive Space at End of Coil.Initially Reported on 830803.Replacement Kits on Order ML20083J1771983-12-0909 December 1983 Vol 1 of Environ Qualification Rept for Mechanical Equipment ML20083F9121983-12-0808 December 1983 Quality Confirmation Program, Monthly Status Rept for Nov 1983 ML20082P6051983-11-30030 November 1983 Final Deficiency Rept,Item Q-10 Re Potential Defects in Catalytic,Inc QA & Const Programs.Initially Reported on 830812.Incidents Cited Not Representative of QA Program. Defects Not Reportable Per 10CFR50.55(e) ML20082P5551983-11-30030 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-101 Re Itt Hydromotor Actuator Oil Seal Leakage.Initially Reported on 831102. Corrective Actions Will Proceed Under 831005 Program.Item Not Reportable Under 10CFR50.55(e) ML20082P8631983-11-29029 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item E-39 Re Brown Boveri 125-volt Dc Control Device Failure on 6.9 Kv & 4.16 Kv Switchgear. Initially Reported on 830202.Insp & Adjustment of Applicable Circuit Breakers Continuing ML20082P8611983-11-29029 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item Q-11 Re Failure to Implement QA Program Corrective Action Reporting Sys.Initially Reported on 830907.Procedures for Corrective Actions Developed Per FSAR Chapter 17.1.Next Rept Will Be Submitted by 840130 ML20082P6671983-11-29029 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-96 Re Indeterminate Qualification of Cooperheat Per ASME Section Iii.Hj Kaiser Co QA Dept in Process of Performing Evaluation of Purchase Orders Re Acceptability.Final Rept by 840601 ML20082P5031983-11-29029 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item E-35 Re Electrical Equipment Foundation Welding.Initially Reported on 831104.Paint Removal & Reinsp of Welds in Progress.Corrective Action Will Be Performed ML20082P4301983-11-29029 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-54 Re Inadequate Qualification of Hydraulic Control Units.Initially Reported on 820726.Analysis of Proposed Mods to Units in Progress. Limited Scope Operability Testing to Be Performed ML20082H9041983-11-23023 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-102 Re Nonconformance of Feedwater Line Seismic Analysis W/Reg Guide 1.29.Initially Reported on 831028.Evaluation Continuing.Followup Rept Will Be Submitted by 840224 ML20082E3371983-11-17017 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-100 Re Warped Standby Liquid Control Sys Tank Mounting Flange.Initially Reported on 831021.Gap Will Be Filled W/Epoxy Grout to Restore Flange to Original Design ML20082D0131983-11-11011 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept Re Lack of Insp Personnel Qualifications.Qualifications of 252 Inspectors adequate,58 Inspectors Still Under Review & 47 Inspectors Not Certifiable.Followup Rept & Corrective Action by 840330 ML20082B8171983-11-10010 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item Q-14 Re Inadequacy of Control & Distribution of Design Specs.Initially Reported on 831013. Applicable Procedures for Review,Approval & Distribution Will Be Revised.Next Rept Will Be Provided by 840105 ML20081M7591983-11-10010 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-24 Re Seismic Qualification of 13 Essential Damper Actuator Mounting Brackets.Initially Reported on 801014.American Warming & Ventilation Analysis Delayed Until 831111.Next Rept Following Corrective Mods ML20081M3341983-11-10010 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-72 Re Lack of QA Program for Fire Protection Sys Installation.Initially Reported on 821214.Proposed Fire Protection QA Program Developed. Followup Rept Will Be Submitted by 840220 ML20082C0681983-11-0909 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item S-11 Re Structural Steel Bolting.Initially Reported on 830513.Comprehensive Reinsp Program for Accessible Connections Developed.Procedures Governing Rework Program Under Development ML20081M8471983-11-0909 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item E-50 Re Annunciator Sys Replacement Light Bulbs.Initially Reported on 830823.Two Contact Blades in Drake 4390 Socket Produce Metal Shavings Causing Short Circuit.Circuits Will Be Redesigned ML20078R5081983-11-0808 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item S-17 Re Main Steam Line Break Analysis.Initially Reported on 831020.Auxiliary Bldg Pressure Differential Resulting from High Energy Line Breaks Not Unacceptable for Masonry Walls.Final Rept by 840116 ML20081M6931983-11-0808 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Items E-20 & E-29 Re Adequacy of Cable Tray & Conduit Support Welding & Cable Tray Support Threaded Nelson Studs.Initially Reported on 820503 & 0928. Concurrence Requested for Procedural Development ML20081M1431983-11-0808 November 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-97 Re Jet Pump Instrumentation Welds.Initially Reported on 830922.Field Deviation Disposition Request 1120 Submitted to Document & Resolve Deficiency.Final Rept Will Be Submitted by 840316 ML20082K5321983-10-31031 October 1983 Quality Confirmation Program, Monthly Rept for Oct 1983 ML20083A1401983-10-28028 October 1983 Rev 25 to Natl Board Tasks Rept ML20081H6941983-10-27027 October 1983 Final Deficiency Rept,Item M-93 Re Improperly Supervised Fire Detection Circuits.Initially Reported on 830823. Inability to Verify Fire Detection Sys Unacceptable Condition ML20081F0871983-10-25025 October 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-61 Re Fire Protection Piping Suspended from Essential Cable Tray Supports.Mods Stopped by 821112 Show Cause Order Immediately Suspending Const.Final Rept Will Be Submitted Upon Mod Completion ML20081F1121983-10-25025 October 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item M-91 Re Overpressurization of HPCS Relief Valve 1E22F035.Initially Reported on 830818. Audit Finding Rept 83-19-05 Issued to Correct Defect. Followup Rept by 840518 ML20078M9971983-10-18018 October 1983 Interim Deficiency Rept,Item E-46 Re Lack of Type SIS Switchboard Wire Certification.Initially Reported on 830713. Sargent & Lundy Issued Design Document Change SLE-577 to Require Type SIS Wire for Future Use.Next Rept by 840131 1987-06-16
[Table view] |
Text
r ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW OF ZIMMER SITE STATUS FOR THE CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY MAY 31, 1984 JOB NO. 02580-057-17 Dames & Moore
- e. e w A D A
I Dames & Moore m uen si-,
Suite 501
[k w
Cincinnati, Ohio 45203 (513) 651-3440 May 31, 1984 The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company 139 E. Fourtn Street Cincinnati, OH 45202 Attention: Mr. W. D. Waymire Manager of General Engineering Gentlemen:
Environmental Review of Zimmer Site Status For The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company INTRODUCTION Dames & Moore has performed an environmental review of the Zimmer site status at the W.H. Zimmer Station as requested by The Cincinnatt Gas &
Elect ric Company (CG&E). This review focused on two particular items:
- 1. A description of the site's status, with part icular attention to disturbed areas and to related erosion and runoff control measures
- 2. Development of a restoration plan, including procedures and schedules for grading and seeding, that will stabilize the site until construction of the coal plant begins The study entailed a reconnaissance of the Zimmer site, discussions wit h CG&E personnel concerning the site status, a review of figures provided by CG&E showing the past and projected configuration of onsite facilities, and the development of a restoration plan for disturbed areas.
SITE STATUS Figures 1 and 2 show the configuration of onsite facilities as of January 21,:,1984. These figures show the location of major onsite struc-tures, borrow areas, existing roadways, access routes, parking lots, fence lines, and the switchyard and transmission corridors. Figure 3 presents the projected configuration of plant site facilities as of the end of December 1984. A comparison of Figure 3 with figures 1 and 2 shows that most of the construction trailers and miscellaneous buildings will have been removed by the end of December 1984. The trailer and butiding-removal process is already well underway.
The basic site profile and elevations have remained largely unchanged for approximately 7 years, except for the following major site modtficaltons:
Dcmas & Meere O
The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company May 31, 1984 Page *A craf t-workers' parking lot covering approximately 10.6 acres was constructed immediately north of the main plant buildings during the fall of 1983; extensive fill and grading were required. The parking surface and access ramp were blacktopped during December 1983 and January 1984 to minimize dust impacts on the estimated 3,000 craft-workers, plant personnel, travelers on U.S. Route 52, and nearby resident s and communit les.
'A parking lot addition (see coordinates F-6 on Figure 2) was con-structed during the same period as the craf t-worker's parking lot.
This parking lot was also blacktopped to minimize dust emissions.
- The existing parking areas along U.S. Route 52 (coordinates A-3 through A-6 and 0-3 through B-6, figure 2) were also paved in late 1983/carly 1984 for the same environmental reasons indicated above.
The parking area bounded by coordinates A-6 through A-8, and B-6 through 8-8 was not paved because this area was designated as an overflow parking facility and the anticipated use was minimal.
- In the case of the formerly proposed buildings G, H, and I (see figure 2), p alings were installed, but the buildings were never constructe/.
The top of the pilings protrude approxcnately 2 feet off the existing ground sur face. There are no immediate plans to remove or grade over these piles; as presently envisioned, these areas will be used as laydown areas.
Overall, with the except ion of the areas listed above, site drainage has been well established over the last several years. Sheet runoff is directed towards drainage ditches and conduits, and no evidence of severe onsite erosion was observed during a May 1984 reconnaissance of the Zimmer site. In general, the recent site modifications listed above conform to existing drainage patterns, and there is no rer. son to expect a significant increase in the rate of erosion due to these modifications.
The t railers and temporary buildings that either have been or will be removed are typically underlain by crushed rock or slab foundalions. There are no plans to remove the slabs or take up the crushed rock at this time.
It is envisioned that areas covered by these materials could be used during construction of the coal plant facilities. Unpaved areas interlying the trailers and buildings are covered by bare dirt, crushed rock, or a combination of the two. Invader species of grasses and weeds are scattered throughout these areas.
I ll lI I Ill
Dames & Moore G$'
The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company May 31, 1984 Page RESTORATION PLAN Site restoration work should be designed to minimize erosion and wir dborne dust originating from disturbed areas onsite. It should also be designed to preclude areas of standing water and saturated soils. However, it should not necessarily be designed to landscape the site, which will undergo additional disruption when coal plant const ruction act ivit ies begin.
The recommended restoration program should include three components:
grading, revegetation or the addit ion of crushed rock, and limited modifications to site drainage patterns.
Grading: As indicated in Plates 1 and 2, limited grading is required and no significant cut and fill operations are envisioned. Grading should be designed to spread small mounds of dirt and rock found onsite; eliminate depressions where water is found to accumulate; smooth sur faces so re-vegcLated areas can be maintained; and, reduce slopes, especially adjacent to some of the drainage courses, presently subject to higher rates of erosion. During grading, supervision of earthmoving act ivit ies should be provided to ensure that grades are const ructed to direct runoff towards drainage ditches. Grading should be scheduled as soon as practical, prior to any revegetation programs.
Revegetation/ Crushed Rock Additions: Plates 1 and 2 also show existing grassed-areas and areas where grass seed should be applied. All bare soil areas should be reseeded; it should be at a field supervisor's discretion to decide hich areas of limited or sparse vegetative cover should receive seed to thicken ground cover.
Prior to seeding, the ground surface should be prepared by turning the soil with either a spring tooth harrow or a disc to a depth of opproximately 4 inches; large rocks and debris should be removed. Based on typical.
Clermont County soils, a seed mix consisting of the following grasses and legumes is recommended:
Percent Composition Sericea lespedeza (hulled) 25 K-31 fescue 25 White clover 15 Kentucky /Marion~ bluegrass 25 Perennial eyegrass 10 Onsite soil chemistry tests should be performed prior to ordering the seed mix to adjust the mix for any unexpected condit ions.
4 Dames & Moore Q
The Cincinnat i Gas & Electric Company May 29, 1984 Page ..
This seed mix is readily available, cost ef fective, quick germinating, easily maintained and effective for a fall planting. The legume component will help provide staying power over several seasons.
Broadcast seeding is recommended on flat to moderate slopes at a rate of 65 lbs per acre. If the use of a hydroseeder is required for steep slopes, this rate should be at least doubled. A common 10-20-20 blend fertilizer is recommended for application at a rate of approximately 350 lbs per acre. Also, application of pellet tzed lime is recommended at a rate of 80 lbs per acre. After the seed mtx, fertilizer and lime are applied, a chain should be dragged across the surface to turn the seed under. Straw mulch should then be blown onto the reseeded areas at a rate of 1 ton per acre. From a scheduling standpotnt, the seeding effort should take place no later than the first week of October.
The addition of crushed rock should also be applied at the discret ton of a field supervisor. in general, sufficient rock should be applied to cover dirt surfaces as required.
Although most of the areas requiring seed and rock are located at the main plant site (see Plate 2), there are some areas that require seed and/or stone in the larger general site area (Plate 1), including:
- 1. The perimeter of the settling basin and certain adjacent areas =
- 2. The two borrow areas immediately north of the new craft-workers' parking lot
- 3. Areas adjacent to the meteorological tower west of U.S. Route 52
- 4. Areas immediately adjacent to the access road leading to the meteorological tower east of U.S. Route 52
- 5. The borrow area along 345 kV t ransmission corridor east of U.S.
Route 52 The two borrow areas (llems 2 and 5 abcve) will also require some drainage modiftealtors, as discussed in the following section.
Drainage Modifications: Minor modi ficat ions to the exist ing site drainage are suggested to minimize erosion potent ial and/or eliminate areas of standing water. These areas include the two borrow areas previously dtscussed. In general, these modificalions are relat ively minor. One area requaeing parLicular attention is a small impoundment immediatc1y norLh of the new craf t-worker parking lot. This impoundment should be drained and contoured to direct runoff towards Little Indian Creek, which would conform to natural drainage patterns before the new parking lot was constructed.
Rip-rap should be laid in the channel draining the pond and the area should be revegetated according to the specificalions presented herein.
.i
i l D mas & Muro 66 1
The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Company May 29, 1984 Page At the borrow area east of U.S. Route 52, a diversion ditch should be cut in the northeast part of the area to direct water into a nearby creek.
Al present, water runof f is flowing down the borrow area access road, causing in.nor crosion. The borrow area should be reseeded and stone laid on the access road CLOSING If you should have any questions regarding this letter report, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Very truly yours, DA!1ES & tiOORE Glenn D. Martin Associate GDM/ds
.DOCU V1ENT ~
~
~'
~
PAGE .
PU_ LED A \lO.w - n NO. OF PAGES b REASON O PAGE ILLEGS2 .
C MARD COPt Fu.ED AT. PDR CF owEn 1 3 D BETTER COP ( REQUE$1ED ON a m E10FLM.,oR F
D .,
OTHER g .
d D FEMED ON APERTURE CARD NO - '
M Sh l
i j _ . . . . _ _ . . . . . . . . _
- . _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _