ML021070524
| ML021070524 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Peach Bottom, Mcguire, Catawba, Saint Lucie, Surry, North Anna, Turkey Point, Fort Calhoun, McGuire, PROJ0690  |
| Issue date: | 04/08/2002 |
| From: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | |
| Dudley N, NRR/DRIP/RLEP, 415-1154 | |
| References | |
| Download: ML021070524 (40) | |
Text
AGENDA NRC LICENSE RENEWAL MEETINGS WITH NEI AND THE LICENSE RENEWAL APPLICANTS APRIL 8, 2002
- 1. Meeting Between the NRC License Renewal Steering Committee and NEI License Renewal Working Group A. Introduction NRC 1:00-1:05 p.m.
1:05-1:30 p.m.
B. Status of applications
- 1. Turkey Point 3 & 4 Florida Power & Light
- 2. St. Lucie 1 & 2 Florida Power & Light
- 3. North Anna 1 & 2 and Surry 1 & 2 Virginia Elec. & Power
- 4. McGuire 1 & 2 and Catawba 1 & 2 Duke Energy
- 5. Peach Bottom 2 & 3 Exelon
- 6. Fort Calhoun Omaha Public Power District C. License Renewal Interest- Known NRC 1:30-1:35 p.m.
Submittals D. License Renewal Implementation 1:35-1:45 p.m.
Guidance Development 1:45-1:55 p.m.
E. Lessons Learned from Application Reviews NRC 1:55-2:00 p.m.
F. Summary Members of the Public 2:00-2:15 p.m.
G. Public Participation
.1 r. 1) "In P rk _,4 l;- 0_* F. t 1.
Prank II. Meeting Between NRC Management and License Renewal Applicants Introduction NRC 2:30-2:35 p.m.
A. 2:35-3:45 p.m.
B. Status of applications
- 1. Turkey Point 3 & 4 Florida Power & Light / NRC
- 2. St. Lucie I & 2 Florida Power & Light/ NRC
- 3. North Anna I & 2 and Surry 1 & 2 Virginia Elec. & Power/ NRC
- 4. McGuire 1 & 2 and Catawba I & 2 Duke Energy / NRC
- 5. Peach Bottom 2 &3 Exelon / NRC
- 6. Fort Calhoun Omaha Public Power District/ NRC Public Participation Members of the Public 3:45-4:00 p.m.
C. 4:00 p.m.
D. Adjourn NRC Attachment 2
Projected Schedule of License Renewal Applications Through FY05 FY 02 FY 03 FY 04 FY 05 SFY 01 slot Plant ISubmit 1 20 3Q I 4Q 1Q 2 30 4Q 1Q 20 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 30 4Q FY00 I II I I I I I
I I I I F F I I I I 1 1 1 1 ANO-1 Feb. I I I I I I. I--* I + I- F *1 *t I 2 Hatch 1,2 Mar 3 Turkey Point 3,4 Sep FY01 1
2 3
4 5II North Anna 1,2 Surry 1,2 Catawba 1,2 McGuire 1,2 Peach Bottom 2, P~mnIh Bottom 2_3 May-01 May-01 Jun-0i Jun-01 Ju -01.
I L3 I I IIfL......i'
-1 4
-I 4
4 t
4 F
F-+
4 I I
FY02 2
I ISt Lucia 1,2 7 (CRIhnun F~nrt 1Nov-Oil Jan-02 I
2 ' W +' I -4
- I* +-I AI
~
3 3 Rnhini~nn2 I*i n n*
,IIun-02 ,-7 ++
,jIjI-nO, Ginna§_umin_.r KU-ui: I12 FY03
, +..4 - F 1 Dresden 2,3R 2(4 2
3
ý12 aCAfl
%Q1 1 -I I I i_! _ _
__ 3Q 4I'.__ , 1 __- I I I 4 Farley 1.2 Sen-0s 1,_IAO2 re6i _ _ 1.2__ 11 11 VAA I
1 INineMilePoint 1,2 1 Oct-03 1 I 2 Cook 1,2P Nnv-03 3
4 Ferry 2,3 t~c01
,'IL t 0 Z _
on ,'+/-___
I __ 1_ _1_ _I_ _I_ _ __t 1 _ _I I
,!..L......i __ -4~.--- - -
Mill.tnn* 213 20 I ýLillslone 2 , 3 19 6 1Uninn.. Ned Q,
.7 / =rla 1:l*0 nflA 7 Beaver Valle y 1,2 ,
FYOM I I 1 jUnannounced 1Oct-041 ___ i ___ ___ __ ___ ___ ___ _____ _
2 1Davis-Besse IDec-041 I__ I__ I__ I____ __ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ __ _
,v_ Dec-04 A
Unannounced Davis-Besse 1 Oct-04 0(1 321Pilgrim 5 i§Unanune 2Q IC.*nnnr Anr-n*
Coo Ar-051 Assumptions
- 1. Schedules based on 25-month review without hearing.
- 2. Submittal dates based on fiscal year quarterly basis.
es Reviews Completed for Application Reviews are Ongoing or Application Anticipated for Submittal to Document Control Desk Slide 1 04_02_02 Interface Input - Resources.wb3 April 2, 2002
TURKEY POINT, UNITS 3 AND 4 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Final Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) Issued 1/11/02 Safety Evaluation Report Issued 2/27/02 2/01/02 Regional Administrator's Recommendation Received 3/13/02 ACRS Subcommittee Meeting Completed FUTURE ACTIVITIES ACRS Full Committee Meeting 4/11/02 5/17/02 Complete Commission Paper with Staff Recommendation 7/17/02 Issue Renewed License (if approved) 2
ST. LUCIE NUCLEAR PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Deadline for Filing Hearing Requests and Petitions for Intervention Passed 2/28/02 4/03/02 Environmental Scoping Meeting Completed FUTURE MILESTONES Issue Environmental RAIs 5/20/02 6/04/02 Complete Scoping and Screening Methodology Audit 7/29/02 Issue Safety RAIs 3
NORTH ANNA, UNITS I AND 2 SURRY, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Responses from Applicant to Safety RAIs Received 02/05/02 Scoping Inspections Completed 02/08/02 Draft SEIS and Safety SER Under Development Ongoing FUTURE MILESTONES Issue Draft SEIS (Surry) 4/26/02 Issue Draft SEIS (North Anna) 5/17/02 Complete Aging Management Review Inspections 5/31/02 Issue SER with Open Items 6/10/02 4
MCGUIRE, UNITS 1 AND 2 CATAWBA, UNITS I AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Pre-hearing Conference in Charlotte Completed 12/18-19/01 ALSB Decision on Standing and Contentions Issued 1/23/02 Environmental RAI Responses (McGuire) Received 1/31/02 Safety RAIs Issued 1/31/02 Staff Appeal of ASLB Decision on Admissible Contentions Issued 2/4/02 Commission Accepted Certified Contention on Terrorism for Review 2/6/02 Environmental RAI Responses (Catawba) Received 2/8/02 Scoping Inspection Completed 3/22/02 5
MCGUIRE, UNITS I AND 2 CATAWBA, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS FUTURE ACTIVITIES Receive Safety RAI Responses 4/15/02 Issue Draft SEIS (McGuire) 5/17/02 Issue Draft SEIS (Catawba) 6/7/02 Public Meeting to Discuss DEIS (McGuire) 6/11/02 Public Meeting to Discuss DEIS (Catawba) 7/2/02 Complete AMR Inspections 7/26/02 End of DEIS Comment Period (McGuire) 8/8/02 Issue SER with Open Items 8/12/02 End of DEIS Comment Period (Catawba) 8/29/02 6
PEACH BOTTOM, UNITS 2 AND 3 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Environmental Scoping Meeting Completed 11/7/01 Scoping and Screening Methodology Audit Completed 12/7/01 Environmental RAts Issued 12/20/01 Environmental RAI Responses Received 1/30/02 Safety RAIs Issued 3/12/02 "7
PEACH BOTTOM, UNITS 2 AND 3 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS FUTURE ACTIVITIES Receive Safety RAI Responses 5/27/02 Complete Scoping Inspection 6/24/02 Issue Draft SEIS 7/5/02 Complete AMR Inspection 8/09/02 Issue SER with Open Items 9/16/02 8
FORT CALHOUN STATION, UNIT 1 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS License Renewal Application Received 01/11/02 Acknowledgment and Press Release Issued 02/19/02 FUTURE MILESTONES Acceptance for Docketing and Issuance of Review Schedule 04/15/02 Deadline for Filing Hearing Requests and Petitions for Intervention 05/15/02 Environmental Scoping Meeting 06/18/02 9
FPL LICENSE RENEWAL TURKEY POINT AND ST. LUCIE PLANTS FPL AND NRC MANAGEMENT MEETING April 8, 2002 C,
iF:PL LICENSE RENEWAL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES - TURKEY POINT
- January 11, 2002 - NRC issued the final plant specific Supplement 5 to the GEIS for Turkey Point Units 3 and 4
- February 1, 2002 - Letter issued from NRC Region II
- No further inspection is needed
- FPL demonstrated the capability to manage the effects of aging during the period of extended operation
- Reasonable assurance that FPL's aging management programs provide an adequate foundation for renewing the licenses for Turkey Point Units 3 and 4 2
LICENSE RENEWAL F:PL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES - TURKEY POINT
- February 27, 2002 - NRC issued the Safety Evaluation Report for Turkey Point Units 3 and 4
- No open items
- March 13, 2002 - Completed ACRS Subcommittee site tour and public meeting 3
FPL LICENSE RENEWAL UPCOMING ACTIVITIES - TURKEY POINT
- April 11, 2002 - ACRS full committee meeting
- April 19, 2002 - ACRS letter
- May 17, 2002 - NRC issue Commission paper with Staff recommendations
- July 17, 2002 - Commission decision 4
F=PL LICENSE RENEWAL
SUMMARY
- TURKEY POINT On April 2, 2002, NRC informed FPL that SBO position issued to NEI on April 1, 2002 would have to be addressed
- NRC review to date had not identified an issue
- FPL concerned over schedule impact
- FPL and NRC meeting scheduled for April 10, 2002
- Commission decision by July 17, 2002
- Improvement appears feasible pending SBO resolution 5
LICENSE RENEWAL FPL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE
"* January 16, 2002 - NRC/FPL meeting
- Overview of the St. Lucie LRA
"* January 29, 2002
- NRC publishes Federal Register Notice indicating acceptance of the LRA
- NRC publishes Federal Register Notice providing opportunity for hearing requests
"* February 20, 2002 - NRC visited site to support scoping and screening methodology audit 6
F=PL LICENSE RENEWAL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE
"* February 28, 2002 - Deadline for filing hearing requests and petitions for intervention
- None received
"* February 28, 2002 - NRC publishes Federal Register Notice indicating intent to prepare an environmental statement and conduct the scoping process
"* April 2-4, 2002 - Site environmental and public scoping meetings 7
LICENSE RENEWAL FPL UPCOMING ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE
"* April 16-18, 2002 - NRC onsite for scoping and screening methodology audit
"* April 30, 2002 - Environmental scoping period ends
"* May 20, 2002 - NRC issues environmental RAIs
"* June 4, 2002 - NRC completes scoping and screening methodology audit 8
LICENSE RENEWAL PPL UPCOMING ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE
- July 29, 2002 - NRC issues safety RAIs 9
FIPL LICENSE RENEWAL
SUMMARY
- ST. LUCIE
"* All license renewal activities are on or ahead of schedule
"* Public offered strong support for license renewal at environmental scoping meetings
- Feedback on NRC process for soliciting input
"* Frequent communications between FPL and NRC are occurring
"* NRC to issue a revised LRA review schedule based on no hearing requests 10
Dominio" NorthAnna and SurryPower Stations LicenseRenewal Status April 8, 2002 0
2 CD I
April 2002 Domi nion LR Status Update Introduction
- Excellent communications both on safety and environmental reviews.
- Achieved closure on most issues 2
April 2002
- J~Dominion LR Status Update Dominion LRA Review Schedule Review Schedule Status - Completed Activities Milestone Target Date Actual Date Receive SPS and NAPS LRAs 05/29/01 05/29/01 FRN Published for LRA Receipt 06/28/01 06/28/01 FRN Published for Hearing Opporunity 07/27/01 07/27/001 Deadline for filing hearing requests 08/27/01 08/27/01 Environmental scoping meeting (Surry) 09/19/01 09/19/01 Environmental scoping meeting (North Anna) 10/18/01 10/18/01 NRC Issues Env. RAIs (Surry) 11/09/01 11/09/01 NRC Issues Safety RAIs 11/26/01 11/26/01 NRC Issues Env. RAIs (North Anna) 12/07/01 12/07/01 Dominion Responds to Env. RAls (Surry) 12/21/01 12/10/01 Dominion Responds to Env. RAIs (North Anna) 01/21/02 12/10/01 3
April 2002 1'rDominion LR Status Update Dominion LRA Review Schedule Review Schedule Status - Future Activities Milestone Target Date Actual Date Dominion Responds to Safety RAIs 02/08/02 02/08/02 Scoping Inspections Complete 02/15/02 02/15/02 Draft SEIS to EPA (Surry) 04/26/02 Draft SEIS to EPA (North Anna) 05/17/02 AMR Inspections Complete 05/31/02 Public Meeting to Discuss DEIS (Surry) 06/06/02 SER w/O issued by NRC 06/10/02 Public Meeting to Discuss DEIS (North Anna) 06/27/02 End of DEIS Comment Period (Surry) 07/18/02 ACRS Subcommittee review of SER 01 07/24/02 End of DEIS Comment Period (North Anna) 08/08/02 4
April 2002 "Dominion LR Status Update Dominion LRA Review Schedule Review Schedule Status - Future Activities Milestone Target Date Actual Date Responses to SER 01 Received 08/22/02 ACRS full committee review of SER 01 09/04/02 SER issued by RLSB 11/05/02 Optional Final Inspection complete 11/29/02 ACRS full committee review of SER 12/04/02 Final SEIS issued to EPA (Surry) 12/13/02 Final SEIS issued to EPA (North Anna) 12/13/02 ACRS Letter 12/20/02 Regional Administrator's Letter 01120103 SER issued as NUREG 01/28/03 Commission Paper w/Staff Recommendations 03/14/03 5
Commission Decision 06/27/03
April 2002
- Dominion LR Status Update Completed Activities Since Last Meeting
- RAI responses submitted on or ahead of schedule for safety/environmental.
- Scoping inspections completed; no open items.
- Clarifications to safety and environmental RAI responses provided.
- Containment walkdown at Surry completed; condition of component cooling water noted. 6
April 2002
- fDominion LR Status Update Issues o Station Blackout Scoping
"* Work Control Aging Management Activity
"* EAF on Charging Line and SI Line 7
April 2002
"'tic*nion. LR Status Update Near-Term Future Activities e AMR inspections scheduled:
North Anna 4/29 - 5/3 Surry 5/13-5/17
- Draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) scheduled to be issued:
Surry 4/26/02 North Anna 5/17/02 8
April 2002 Dominion LR Status Update Near-Term Future Activities
- Public meetings will be held:
North Anna 5/3 Surry 5/17
- SER with Open Items issued by NRC 6/10/02 9
SA p r il 2 0 02
'*Dominion LR Status Update Closing Remarks
- Development of the SER continues with open dialogue on issues requiring more information.
- 2nd quarter of '02 critical in understanding forward-going schedule:
"o SER with (or without) open items "o DEIS with (or without) public comments 10
PhDuke McGuire - Catawba rEnergy. License Renewal Duke/NRC Management Meeting April 8, 2002 P Duke IEnergy- Accomplishments
"* January 8, 2002 - NRC/Duke Management meeting
"* January 24, 2002 - ASLB decision on standing and contentions
"* January 30, 2002 - All NRC Safety Requests for Additional Information received by Duke
"* Duke provided Environmental RAI responses for McGuire (January 31, 2002) and Catawba (February 8, 2002)
"* March 22, 2002 - NRC Region II Scoping &
Screening Inspection completed April8, 2002 Duke NuclearLicense Renewal Project 2 1
Attachment 5
Ph Duke aWEnergy. Safety Review
"* Duke received 11 letters from the NRC containing 273 Requests for Additional Information
"* Responses due by April 15, 2002
"* Anticipate follow-up communications similar to Oconee experience
"* Safety Evaluation with Open Items due August 12, 2002
"* Open communications via telecons and at recent inspection have been helpful clarifying several of the RAIs and continue to advance the application review April 8, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 3
- 1. Duke rEnergy. EnvironmentalReview
- Responses to all Environmental Requests for Additional Information for both McGuire and Catawba, including a few follow up items, have been provided by Duke
"* Duke understands that the draft Supplemental Environmental Impact Statements for both sites are in full preparation
"* McGuire
"* Draft due by May 17, 2002
"* Public meeting in the mid-June timeframe
"* Catawba
"* Draft due by June 7, 2002
"* Public meeting in the early July timeframe April 8, 2002 Duke NuclearLicense Renewal Project 4 2
- !kdDuke OEnergy. HearingProcess
"* On January 2 4 th, the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (ASLB) issued their order concerning standing and contentions offer by the Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League and the Nuclear Information and Resource Service
"* Two contentions were admitted for hearing
"*One related to use of mixed-oxide fuel
"* One related to Severe Accident Mitigation Alternatives
"* One contention concerning security was certified to the NRC Commission
"* On February 4 th, Duke and the NRC staff appealed the ASLB decision to the Commission April8, 2002 Duke NuclearLicense Renewal Project 5
? Duke VEnergy- HearingProcess
"* Teleconferences among all participants with the aim of assuring continued progress were held on February 12th, March 13 th and another upcoming on April 10 th
"*A hearing will be held in July concerning the relationship of license renewal with use of mixed-oxide fuel at McGuire and Catawba
"* Additional plans to address the SAMA contention are under development April 8, 2002 Duke NuclearLicense Renewal Project 6 3
. Duke VEnergy. Expectations
- Expectations to be accomplished by next NRC/Duke Management Meeting (July timeframe)
"* Duke to complete responses to safety RAIs and submit to NRC by agreedupon date
"* NRC Staff to issue draft Supplement Environmental Impact Statements and conduct successful public meetings
"* Duke to work with NRC Region I/ to preparefor aging management review inspections in July April 8, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 7 PkDuke License Renewal RAI aEnergy. Categorization
- 1. Appropriate RAI
- 2. Administrative Error in the Application
- 3. Technical Error in the Application
- 4. Information Provided in the Application
- 5. Information Should Not be in the Application
- 6. Challenges the Adequacy of the CLB
- 7. Technical Error in the RAI April 8, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 8 4
P Duke McGuire - Catawba aEnergy.
Safety RAI Statistics April 8, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 9 5
Exekn.
Nudear Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station Exelon and NRC Management Meeting James Meister Fred Polaski April 8, 2002 Exekon.
Nuclear Peach Bottom LRA Review Schedule Milestone Target Date Actual Date Receive Peach Bottom LRA 07/02/01 07/02/01 FRN Published for LRA Receipt 08/01/01 07/25/01
'RN Published for Hearing Opportunity 08/31/01 08/31/01 Deadline for filing hearing requests 10/01/01 10/01/01 Environmental Scoping Meeting 11/07/01 11/07/01 NRC Issues Env. RAIs 12/28/01 12/20/01 Exelon Responds to Env. RAIs 02/26/02 01/30/02 NRC Issues Safety RAIs 03/12/02 03/12/02 Exelon Responds to Safety RAls 05/27/02 Scoping Inspection Complete 06/24/02 Draft SEIS to EPA 07/05/02 2
Attachment 6 1
Exelon.
Nuclear Completed Activities
"* January 2, 2002 - Exelon Transmitted Responses on Electrical Issues
"* January 23, 2002 - NRC Issued RAIs on Aging Management of Electrical and I & C
"* January 23, 2002 - Exelon Transmitted Requested Information Regarding Delaware Transmission Corridor
"* January 23, 2002 - NRC Issued RAIs on Scoping and Screening Methodology
"* January 30, 2002 - Exelon Transmitted Responses to Environmental (SAMA) RAIs
"* February 6, 2002 - NRC Issued RAIs on Aging Management of Reactor Coolant System, Engineered Safety Feature Systems, Auxiliary Systems, and Steam and Power 3 Conversion Systems Exelkn.
Nuclear Completed Activities (continued)
"* February 7, 2002 - NRC Issued RAIs on TLAAs
"* February 28, 2002 - Exelon Transmitted Responses to Scoping and Screening RAIs
"* March 1, 2002 - NRC Issued Scoping and Screening RAIs
"* March 1, 2002 - NRC Issued RAls on Aging Management of Containment, Structures, and Component Supports
"* March 6, 2002 - NRC Issued RAIs on Appendix B Aging Management Activities
"* March 12, 2002 - NRC Issued RAIs on Scoping Results
"* March 12, 2002 - NRC Issued RAIs on Appendix B Aging Management Activities 4 2
Exelon.
Nuclear Future Activities
"* April 15, 2002 - NRC Region I Begins Scoping Inspection
"* May 27, 2002 - Exelon Provides Responses to Safety RAIs
"* July 5, 2002 - NRC Issues Draft SEIS to EPA
"* July 8, 2002 - NRC Region I Begins AMR Inspection
"* July 31, 2002 - Public Meeting to Discuss Draft SEIS 5
Exelkn.
Nuclear Part 54 Project Performance
"* Schedule Adherence
- All dates met .
"* Communications
- Good
"*Interactions between NRC/National Lab reviewers and Exelon
- Good 3
Exebn, Nuclear Part 51 Project Performance
"* Schedule Adherence
- All dates met
"*Communications
- Good
"*Interactions between NRC/National Lab reviewers and Exelon
- Good Exelon, Nuclear Concerns
- Emerging industry issues are challenging the stability and predictability of the license renewal process, and may impact the Peach Bottom Application
- Perception that NRC technical staff believe that all GALL programs are required to manage aging effects 8
4
Exel n, Nuclear Summary
° Communications and interactions have been good. NRC Project Managers doing good job.
- License Renewal standardization and predictability is being challenged.
5