IR 05000446/1985011

Cable Tray Support Mods Insp Rept 50-446/85-11 on 850930- 1002.No Violations or Deviations Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Cable Tray Support Mods

ML20238A226
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	03/04/1986
From:	Barnes I, Gilbert L, Ireland R, Westerman T NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
To:
Shared Package
ML20237K807	List: IR 05000445/1985007 IR 05000445/1985014 IR 05000445/1986008 IR 05000446/1985011 ML20237K804 ML20237L110 ML20237L125 ML20237L136 ML20237L151 ML20237L159 ML20237L179 ML20237L203 ML20237L268 ML20237L298 ML20237L321 ML20237L367 ML20237L407 ML20237L453 ML20237L464 ML20237L493 ML20237L577 ML20237L797 ML20238A290 ML20238A390 ML20238A485 ML20238A535 ML20238A548 ML20238A573 ML20238A583 ML20238A596 ML20238A609 ML20238A642 ML20238A654 ML20238A667 ML20238A719 ML20238A749 ML20238A782 ML20238A833 ML20238A839 ML20238A868 ML20238A883 ML20238A903 ML20238A923 ML20238A966 ML20238A974 ML20238B015 ML20238B131 ML20238B210 ML20238B251 ML20238B352 ... further results
References
50-446-85-11, NUDOCS 8708200406
Download: ML20238A226 (19)

Text

- - _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ .

.

-

APPENDIX F U. S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COPHISSION REGION IV <

,

! CABLE TRAY SUPPORT MODIFICATIONS INSPECTIONS '#"

f NRC Inspection Rep 2rt: 50-416/85-11 CP: CPPR-127 Category: A2 Docket: 50-446 Applicant: Texas Utilities Electric Company 400 North Olive Street I Dallas, Texas 75201

,

~ ~

Facility Name: Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station (CPSES), Unit 2 Inspection At: Glen Rose, Texas

.

Inspection Conducted: Se tomber 30 - October 2, 1985 f

-

s SMM6 ,

Inspectorbl. V.)Mlbeft, Reactor Inspector Aa)4

.

Reviewed By: * be .3d[N 1. Barnes, Group Leader, Region IV Date CPSES Group Approved: [ _

Y Y/4 T. F. Westerman, Chief, Region IV CP5ES Group Date Y ./2bv R. E. Ireland, Chief. Engineering Section SN/Pd'

Date Reactor Safety Branch 87082OO4d6 070312 5 DR ADOCK 0500

.

^ " - - - - - - - _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

. .

-2- ,

inspection Summary Inspection Conducted September 30 - October 2.1985 (Report 50-446/85-11)

Areas inspected: Routine, unannounced inspection of cable tray 8@ Port modifications. The inspection involved 24 inspector-hours onsigby,one NRC ,

inspecto Results: Within the aree inspected, no violations or deviations were identified.

1 e

• e l

l

_ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

_ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ - _ _

.

. .

-3- -

DETA1LS 1. . Persons Contacted

"

M bent Personnel

• P. Halstead. Site QC Manager Brown & Root (SAR) Employees W. E. Baker. Senior Project Welding Engineer D. Mantz. Cable Tray Hanger General Foreman D. Geeo, Cable Tray Nanger Foreman

. Other contractor personnel were also contacted during the course of this inspection activit * Denotes those present at the exit interview.

,

. Safety-Related Cable Tray Support Modifications The NRC inspector reviewed the docraentstion traveler packages and inspected the weldments for 12 cable tray supports that had been modified using tube steel in the new design. The following support' were inspected:

.

Support Classification

CTH-2-11843 Class 1 CTH 2-11846 Class 1 CTH-2-11841 Class 1 CTH-2-11684 Class 1 CTH-2-10040 Class 1 CTH-2-9741 Class 1 CTH-2-11542 Class 1 CTH-2-11641 Class 1 CTH-2-11540 Class 1 CTH-2-9732 Class 1 CTH-2-9733 Class 1 CTH-2-10033 Class 1 In the areas inspected, the cable tray support weldments complied with the requirements for welding in Weld Procedure Specification No.10046 and the requirements for visual weld inspection in Instruction QI-QP-11.ti-1. The documentation for the supports was consistert with the status of the wor No violations or deviations were identifie6.

-

. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _

- . .4

1. s

!

.

-4-l Exit Intervi'W l

l The NRC inspector met with the applicant representative denoted in paragraph 1 on October 2,1985, and summarized the scope and findings of the inspectio .

. p ., .

l l

l-i

• .

a

e i

.

.

I

.

_

.

. .

vac o m u.s.aivet. san negutAtony conasassion .n.a.u .a.ec,o. , .. .,

EsNU .

WSPECTOR'S REPORT Wd__'stt'IAM4/;TWer4" dE:'

_

Office of inspection and Enforcement M ,pygytes4 #j arpaaesg* #::

"

~':,:"'P*. h fi- T / M 'rt a * " **v a * 7='= =

m +'~ r

W T f t FS,fA ." + " t, T ; % * N i h -~~ ,,W- y,*Et*a

-=.* a *- . l

- -

- gn_

-

,,,; -

. ,,,,.

. , .~ ;,. .,. r,, , ,

c .1

.. , ,.

.resw u,.,uwes mm '-'"""

5 = - -

e re o e w ens a ~

_r , a - ._

, . _ , ,

e ro . . u s,

.

r, e i .

,

_

. -II Lact l D wa+:. w .: s . .,z. .. . , < . . . . . . . . . . .

. . .

. ,. n .. ev . . .. n m o anni a, , co,, _ . i ou .. ~ ,omca.suo so f ,me. S _" * R""L'*fR R, *~"'*

'

'%

- n, ,, _ ., ,. .. n on + ---

-

I9 SIe sif e e-

Ie ali el(~

e 8 - ***a**c' ama maa

..... v ' :. u c. .... w e . '.....

'-

-.....i

@ d+ -

-

8t- i

, .

.. .. .

,. m a 1 a.eso A Act TV e os actsv1Tv Co.oueT.D aC. ass .s. a.s ans ""U" *

M C5 - SA rTV

_

W - 40Sa,1 wWff

. W=. ,

la . .,0uJtV i . .: .. m . meneer er - e.eam ,, - e.ANY

. en.voi W - m.viur

~ ~~ ~ ~~

{ n - emes $rrr m. - m - wee u - m e.swtjesiont

~~ ~~

a so.n suon e - aans. ace ""

w. n.a s

> ~. ~ . s. . ss , sc~s.% ; , .~.:

,-~~ y w. ~e* *

.

2** * ,' j ' T:p "; ' w " gg n *.p , *7

.. .m .=

. . .

. __-- .. _

_ _,___

. - - _ _ _ _ , _ ,

.

.._

. . _ .

-.,

__

.

.-

_,_

-

m

-e n ve= a j slc o a . c o . . c o em ., .o ., t *-=***='e esos , , i-* i-= m o r, FM

,

I I l

. . . . . . . .. ..e o ~. . ~ . m-n .- ,., . ~ < {

. ~ . .n ..  :. ... . :,,e .

_ _ . . . . , _ _ .. _ ,_  ;

< _ _ _ _ . . ,

,,, _ . _ . m _ , _ _ . _ .

l

illsielv.e,31 ll n l l!!!!lli ! Ill ll s i IllLIa l l !!!,lllli ! 111 il  !

5 -

e i fir ,, i l . i a fisivirial a oi r a ii i IiiI

'

oai . . i I..I =

. . . . i l .I

=

ii . . . id =

1 i s i e liil

=

.. . . i liil =

i n .. i i .i s f"I M e 7f r i e, o e i liiI . . 3 titivienil a asia ii v,alem 11

=

.. . . , I..I = , . .. . 1..I

" . . , I '

i . i i liii a . , , l .I '

. . .. , l..I 2.2 ve rlwicial a ei ra s .ei o i liil . i 3 fisJ7 eit! '

e ie .i violzmiW  ;

a si . i liil ~

a i e is i lsil c

.. . . . l1 c

. . .. . i " *

.. , , i liil . , ,i . 1..I i s fiz.b a2] '

aisi s , i vielsivial . i J f ribi s itt *

ei a ii i I,ii

=

. l *

.. i . . . i, i i c *

.. . . , l.il i i ,, . Iii1 224'E".,_ a

.. . i , l iI a i i ii i Ii I

,,i. .. .. . .. , . a . .i . i . .. , , . . .. w a

oc sonune UA.e.WCLSAR A40WLATORY C0 tem 8840sv s mo.saepsctompus mer est av.us INSPECTOR'S REPORT ,,,,,,,,

Office of Inspection and Enforcement e.ecreas

,v =m,a,,;= ,. e c o . e.v,,o er> . ,,o ,,

s -seat ,

-

s _""",m -eneer .

, - en e

_

a -asm o

. g.e +:,. ; e ,.y .n : ;.. . <. n .in... a a m . m,. =}

.

moom visie.,e., .ic c . .. enem maven anna e mo m , oconooe smou to i - mese== omca sie jenen La"".' *,,",,",, ZW,*""* '

., ,,, ., .. n - --~

l I I I I I 8 - '*'oamaac' ****"'5a"

, . m e .: e' .

~:s w.c :. w ~ r. ~.a : 7

. .

. m: ~-?m #.~ , <;. ;e -

.a e i

,. ne,m two w actwnv camoucte .

,

"""""*"""d e - sa.rry

_

a - esswe. von _ e - nasnsec _

w - me v

,

i- macseem ei _

m-semen _

e -assou _

et - anon.wat m-esvestinaten

_

s- ammonsessem wrven e,- smonosunut m - we sen u - mousnesent

• - ~ ~

m - meur.auen m - e.at.ace o. ament

,,ea.,. - -. ; . ~.' . .: *w x-= m.' W .;. % are.c...;*>. ' -s '

-..p= a== =

-m ,e cs . .,cm ur,. , n,. .avi o

w vimaos e se6s as.onice.nt amon.aren t o e c erwiens ,

amne senmei apontoon

-

< - mun * * * **'*

s- unavne iseve .suse "a"te=

c

- eswven a a e o a e c e a e c o on, v ma, vn 8- uma m 6eratea , , , i - vos e - ves

,

l l l l l l

. .).y, w s p y. w .4 .

I%: *,,% p %g as,.isa % .f,-..ep.s n e-w..- h e e ..,.m

.

Moe Li imatic g pygg g gagg,,

a o.ou -. . 3 o.ou u, m , ,.o u u

~

'

l ill ll n i f. gillll! ! I ll r

ll 0 1 1 11 ll al l h,,illlli 1 1 11 ll i a risint a i, i , i liil i , i liil a si . . i i '

e it , i.... e . I a ii , , . I..I

=

.. , , . liil = i , i liil

=

.. . . i liil '

ii . . . I .ra leiral a . . . liil i . . a . . i lini

=

ea.s . . . i l .I '

.. . . . l..I

=

.. . . i i '

. . . . i i =

.. . , . l..I =

. . . . i t..I i n e iileirisl a i, . . i l s i i I a s i . . i t .I :

a eais . .. i liil _

a si i s i lial

'

.. . . . l..I * .. . . i t..I

'

.i . . . l.il a

.. . i . Iiil i r ritle,ml a . . , l . i i liil -

i , i , i liil a e,mm ea,e . I,,I * . , i . . Iii1

'

. . , , , lI * ,, .lia l ML".* # Le '

, , i i , IiiI =

, , , , i liiL= l ni. . . .. . . . . . . ., , . ,p si . i . . . .. ,, ,, . .. ,, l

_ - _ - - - -

,.

);

.

g, mi u s.wuca. san naoutATony co.insisssoas m pect ai-., ,

""'"** *

INSPECTOR'S RE ,,,,.,

Office of Inspection and Enf cement

. _ . .

aarams.aa,,gss v.a.S&CT.*e ggggygg ggg,,,ggggg 67 .stJrt .s tc .A . .= we>> .. .

.?

~

l

, j

~

. ..

~ .

--

l

- . . avi m.._

-- ~

.

c

.- j .

• • , y's ',. ' ;'* r 5, ' . S l' ' ' ' 5 . ,'.,* [$'g i.' t, [, , * '.le ',dts ,. t';im SWs 8.fWO.?t.a? / 8.cTeDes .sg.get.n. a sv .P m . . . ace.,m j ovi g_a=.l fsti.fDs .M g , e.esis Cose.u. m, ,. m, . mm , c, --.

_

-~

l I I I I I 8-.== =aacama** *

a s . w: ,. . e. Cg.' m' / r're ,m ' . :..? :. .- - 7--' s .s . .

.,,,,, ,, ~ uc, -

- - ~ ~ . . . ,,,, ..

_

.

_ .. . .

.. .

4 . c ., . . , .. ,,.

_ _ _ _

, . . ..

- .. .. .. , ,

_

- - -

. . ,, . . , . , . .. ,

..... - . - . . g.m m . . ~~m .~. u . =m.r.m . . , . w . : . .- .

.

---

,vot g e.a.cs .s

. . .

. "'gi, g;;g t",=,'-- ,,

e c s4. c gLe vn .p rt.a.swrvaan

, , , , , , , ,,,,,,,,,,,,

-a

,

.'..'" un"L "#,.l"

..

{

l . . c . . . . . . . . . . ., ,. . .. -

.-sum.is.a.r-tm.

l , , , , t - v . l l l l 1 I

. . . , ,. . .' ,4.> M;p ee;9.. . : . ig.aHer,-4 :94. t J :p 4/:i..--- e + .- . .. e e ... .e ,

._ .

_ . , _

m _ _ _ . . ___ r., _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . ~

.

l i .

ill,i ,i.. a .

ll t i l f,, il ,lll! !

. . . ,.... .

Illll !l uw

. i .i . .

ill ll i ll I.,ll lH li i ll ll i in .

... , ii . ~

.

,. m.... . . i..i . ...., ,. .. .a

=

.. . . . l =

.. .. i liil

=

.. . . i i =

... .. , l . . .. . . ,i .

. . . . < .. , .. . .i . . . .. ... .. . i..i

.

=

.- .. . ..m . 4 m ... .. . i..i

.. . . . l..I =

.. .. . l =

.. , , . l..I =

.. .. . l..I i r fimbia.il a oe4 .. t fithie sl i i vith eis! -

e a.it ii i I,ei  :

=

. it ,i e sisl,,,is! =

.ii i s ii i Iiii  !

= ~- l

.. . . . l..I =

.. .. . I..I

' =

.. . . . Ii l , ,i , I

!i t t ih a, il @ ALS .i n r.e le. e,el . i s. rirliivirl * ,, i IiiI

@ 4 14 .. S r..l o gi d =

e iw n ,.. e . Ii I

=

.. . . . l : ,

i, .. . li I

!%"**"#1.,_ a

.. . . . Ii l =

ii i, i 1eiI

1.ls . . u . . . . . e em ili si . I s . . u . . . . ., ei .i

)

- _ - - - - - _ _ _____ .

d sinicanssesociennus.m me *r avausse y U.S. esWCLAAA REGULATORY C0entlSSs0s geensMe

• " ' " *

INSPECTOR'S REPORT .

Office of inspection and Enforcement e, menis Cfm myse? es.s,argesc o.78 Ugeestettwasseen ggggg, ,,, g,,,,,

.e ,,,s - no . ,,e ,,

. . meert ,

-

. . , .

( - . - -

. _ .

e Fd.v.p* T;M 4. pr,MirWdcdi;t.;e.W .ith se senseseausstent e ,as ev e - e, amansava eene e mee , e es eve,.

ses= to . . esee== emes sean jonen ha***'.*,,",,,", Z ' M * .

a -

me av em , s.esseseveseseven I I I I I I a. weimaassannama nam o n .1s . wen m *.verwn:c.twepy'aummang7.v.v.y g n'r m ei-. ,

' d tves es artwvfv demewcvse acausa se aus eseri amasm m action

• =*=*'"*' . . unev _,

e . neur. veer ,_

e..w ve _

w . sousiv e.essem . w,mr i.encesim o, ,,,

e . neenwr , ,_

ii . enorr.v _

,,

e.seenement m . vemea .. eareseene A- mesmaemss were - - -

e.seen,

-

e . news.auerr e . nor.ace . .m.- o ner .s v w. :::.. oc e.p,mr.+mm m aj: ppm ..,p:myg,, y:: -] *:, ? . .>

. I

-

"'E s ar,Jr. l" - ' ,o'g gg seenceen.sewenancs s see,r,,t,e,,,u,tgne weveer essene vnenewita pre

• * = * = aee sec , es,, !

'~ *" isrEn'e'ese "aSe*="

s."wouse e e, a ne w, j s . eswintem a e e o a e c e a e e e a . ve6aten a usvi. ten - , , , , i . vus ..,a l l l l 1 l l r .nwuwwm; = 2x e.w.w.x.. ;;;3;;;1ww %e ==, w a

--a- -,

omAa A00 8ekteWW8 E asseWLR esWRIOpe see 3 asseWitRSS 8eLLoufWe 5 AsseWL4 asubdete luS8 ~

l illfis hll. tri ld$gll i lli l ill ll s il ill 11al l $gllll! ! I ll ll !

i s T* .. . Iiil i . i IiiI a i i .. i IiiI d i- s is, s , , , l..I

=

i i . . i l..I

= ,, . . . liil

i , i i

.. , , iliil 'i i i . . . l . 1, 3 1 a

.. , , .l.il . . . l.il a s i . . i t..I

=

.. . . .l..I = . . .. .l..I

=

i, i , ,l..I =

. . .. .li I

=

.. .. . . l..I =

. . . . .l..I i i lin 1 a

.. , , il..I i n i I a

. . .. .l..I  :

=

in . i i liil =

i e in iliil

^

=

.. . . . l .I =

. . .. .l..I

=

.. , , , I,il =

. . , , 3_ .l..I i i liil a ii . i i I . i i liiI a

. . i , elial

=

. . . . i lI =

. . i . ii * ileil

=

is i i liil i . . .

• 'f E = ,, i i , I = , , , i i I e i l'=

iii.i.'re'J., . . .. e . . . e n ,e ,1. .i . i . . . ,, . . . . e, c

.

- - - - . . _ - - - _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _

.

.

'kjf****^ "mo'lefdoE5"vTM"U

,,, , woova numesa

'

s uc em .

mo ,

eso 314111ttWri t t INSPECTOR'S REPORT O fe e e aM F _f / ta a * *' *" "" *" ** *eg' o= pa p N1 (Continuellen)

8 . s' . ,l e

- -

Office ofinspection and Enforcement S x -

_.o , - , o.oinar .. . . um - ..-a n .. - . - um .a, ,

,

a n e A- e*f*_ _ -

-

w v r s ' .,,P Ae J * #9F W D C WA MCC {

>s a . _ [A - _ 2/"~/L .G &".T.h E

• - As- ./ d W = A~_ _

o pp Y *' .* f f M J--# - '_1 W JH n- -

N- N *

V

_

e

' A significant number of instances'of missing data entries ws noted

'

in water chemistry records covering the period March 1983 through (

j

. September 1985, with respect to the chemistry samp11 frequency

' requirements of Procedures CM-501, " Chemistry Contre ef the Steam li

=

Generators," and CW-508, " Chemistry Control of the Primary Cooling i Water Systems." No annotations w re made in the records to explain

,,- why the samples were not taka o Review of the water cheatstry records showed instances of failure to

,, make required entries to indicate when the Shift Supervisor was w

notified in regard to out-of specification chemistry result .

,, The records did not identify what corrective actions were taken afte entry of out-of-specification result ., Inadequate reviews were performed of the acceptability of water

chemistry data, as evidenced by the presence of review and approval

,,

signatures on forms containing discrepant data result <

l n l s, -

n

n De B

v 7s

(

y .

D'

...

,

ni i

ul xl 6'

aI ,,

,,,,..., u.s. NUCLEAR REGULATORY CoMWissioN l

. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

I

. .

.. - . _ , , . _ , . _ . , -- - - .  ;

l ii'# .

'= a ' -'> a > => o i no uw 7iort, -

INSPECTOR'8 REPORT i ' * ~'e *"a =' o ong'e- * .no

'

l d f0 0 ##6 ey (Continuation) o f f e , , , , , , 8%'l )

Office of Inspection and Enforcement c 3 p I.o-

.

_

i

~,..no..-,-..--..-.--..__, -

.. I

a f. Ab tis Cv i%- . f A od . . 8.__4,, soeta P a ro I O P}va n & L A Pr,~ D w ',' c P a s p.ul.t 0 ~ , , 6 e s-

,

'

s

- s %) c ?- c Ph- C 9 D . eu oc.A vh e r en t C & __.a s

. eh w d .ft.;t k % :1 of a w.%. mum wall

. u,ot at h., aw w e l i ai-h. ;, com om+ cc - 2- RS- oss

' ho 1 bsen a e r ~ al . k e l ud in al f d a mm m f.k .

. +L at J 4.a m L m e.,a G m m a.c + fo r d .

e N

O

W *

a le

%

b

4 to D

1. 1

0

>

N P

W

.

P W

D ..

>

n

.

O t

-

, l'

W.S. NUCLEAR R E Q ULATORY COMMISSION

_ . _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ .

- _ _ . - - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _

! l

-

1 1;

- a

• • * 2 "'"v"*

anc eoa= m A e m.o c,e. ;j'flg s coverm io. u.c.e.=u- ,,, no g g,7,g p

INSPECTOR'S MEPORT I i '

I *

• • "' *' " " *" aa o' ' t' ** 3 g-o fO O O '(# 4 P i i i * , e

'

.

1 .

,

.e -

(Continuation)

Office of Inspection and Enforcement

y p 3 e o_

_,o....,.._......___...-.. _

..-- . _ . ,

, e Cov1 % m tn, d.v. k& v o+ Aon J.'a A n r o e rit Ps v+ a s W J blewn i (Lw1 P> o n km '& p - 1 L .:. s ny

.

• Satellite document control center 307 was noted on

. October 14, 1985, to be in possession of a controlled copy of

'

Component Modification Card 96181 for which receipt had not been signed for and dated on the Document Distribution Lo .

. .i

, A copy of superseded Design Change Authorization (DCA) 21446,

,_"-

Revision 0, was noted on the same date to be present in two packages for Drawing 2323-El-1702, Sheet 002. Revision 2. Both 32 copies of DCA 21446, Revision D, were not stampXed " VOID" on

,,

the face of the document; Il to

t$

to f4

!'%

>

B B

.5

n f1 P __

M M

N M

C l'

t U.S. NUCLE.AR REovlAToRY CoMMIS$loN

_

.

.

'

' "

anc roam see A as.oni ascova.wussa

'Tiffem ene

" " ",r,.,o

' g "8.,,,8**.>

mo eso M1l%l10 1 ll l INSPECTOR'S REPORT o f o o o */ */ f r f I et * **'*""*"****g'e= ens (Continuat6on)

Office ofinspection and Enforcement o Ko a e at 4 6 r i i i e c

, , , . . . D1 p I _- so . . .

eron on oevate aa . seso. _ __ .===a= esmeenmassoas amen.e.em ,um unneusemenmes .sm.:

i s ) b kW A b beb i E o[ M t 's 6 de to r r it

, 0 4 o f . 70 c, to a n . L > A.. 3 U s. o 9 - . ', :- 1

.

WJ '

P 5 m( v M * 7nr c ~k u-i.i.T, . 4L/

s' dlv t A e d L -8 i:) k W / h s , 'n m W r del r &,,-

• 4;L S N*4 A en O L 4wl L= - n L? 196 E . h Uns,a $-- % le e d ai )

'

h $W- K h h)s $s n N & nav J L M1.s L f ns,M)

. L o < Li,C,h w f s/ A L L u a' L t'kehL..' e ve n ;,..

~

. e. .l L LI 1 1 im La. m sn m . U Se [

u

• *

is la is tt

"

i te m

si a

D

>

a s8

_

t'

n w

t'

a m

L

..W

"

!

'

e 2 s,

• o ses.sei W.S. NUCLEAR REO WLATORY COMMISSION

,

_ _

_ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __-

l

..

l

. o

! ===

0*w M A MNT "d "

., A, ,. , .

,

Do.C.at.t. o 80.gneiOR LC..EN,38 owenn ,, , ,,, , , u , ."., ,", g.,

INSPECTOR'S REPORT e r e eo 4 uf f r 8 a a * ' * *' " "" c* *' &,' a 55,, -

(Continuation) e , , , , , , ,c

-

Office of Inspection and Enforcement c

, o ,

Q eo

, 1

- no ono m ,o . . = - -.. - m . .- ,. ,,,,u .. ,

t

, y r e V& S ( u.. I L q ft C- T- A 1 ' W"

' 5.t'n., ^_ .:.. Jose, the QA/QC Records Achinistrator does not TeNffe

copies of requests to provide for control of these documents {

• l

_' i s

to it

--

..

13 u

is si l

,,

e

{

9

2

e

'

,

l

'

s

• l

i f

s d

!

,

, D s e '.o e i U.S. NUCLEAR REQULATORY COMMi&$loN

_:______________ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

-

.

.

.

k,** "* * ' accattaogmasp ao a'

on ucense as. cat =cowa =unassa e ac an -

,, ,,, g , ,g;g j.,;, gp INSPECTOR'S REPORT of e e a s.a. Et' s f , g, a mee we, onseg . ,

• en (Continuation) e , , , , , , %g 1 Office of inspection and Enforcement c o ,

g ~

.,

,

-

-

.,.......,.--a-====a.=e..a=====-'====*-=*4

~

,

e f _ _ /- _ A gate _ a _ # #- E M E e.T - e e9 E-* *' -

V V ,

_

,

' x , -r

• 1. ' Review of ERC accepted documentation for conduit C14R13047 showed

,

that the ERC inspector failed to identify that the certific6 tion to _

the applicable Procedure 01-0P-11.5-23 had lapsed for the TUGC0 T

electrical inspector signing IR-E-4608 , The ERC completed inspection record checklist for conduit C13016037

• in Verification Package No. R-E-COUT-064 did not contain to docentation numbeg C f^^of^ the

_

58M

^ : 2^;. _ It or latest construction operation traveler 1, -

,3 ed il 96*

$

0 at

'm 9'

as a

N

T'

3r a

E

,,

I

D W

M

i

,,

l

......... .. oc o -ou w o- co = s..

L - - - - - -

--_ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ .__ . _-.

t

.

ll EC sonu pm A socastno se, wienucceegg aport "00WJ "W88'"

."j!'s .

ao av aioouctma es* no eso Lf 9 F2.1To4 INSPECTOR'S REPORT d C' #as a at F# # 4 a

• ^ '*" " " * " ** ** * g' ca .

3 * g" j (Continuation) * : "

Office of Inspection and Enforcement *

i e . , e x .c

~,

Q [e o[

i

., . .

.--..-.- ,. -a

,

.

C L_s eff'C f,4.19 cadyT .h e*

s

.

ARVPL -

/%,. V o l . c~

"

• i

'_ - _ - -

the following examples were noted of inadequate

,

procedural guidance and document reviewer perfomeece in regard to

, nonrecreatable and inaccessible attributes:

,

e ..

l

• Quality Instruction (QI) QI-013. Revision 4. lists no specific >

is attributes, but instead specifies that the inspector verify '

" installations in accordance with one or more of a listing of TUGC0 procedures;i.e.,QI-QP-11.8-1,-5,-5,and-8. The Ifst of er .

appropriate procedures does not, however, indicate the applicable

-

revision number of each procedure. In that the number of a

nonrocreatable or inaccessible inspection attributes can vary from revision to revision of a procedure (e.g., Revisions 0 and 1 of TUGC0

,, procedure QI-QP-11.0-8), the absence of guidance en applicable

.

,

procedure revision numbers does not constitute detailed instruction ,, During the documentation review of Verification Package a

No. R-E-CDUT-064, in accordance with QI-009, Revision 0, there was no evidence that a documentation check was ande of inaccessible _ 1

,, attributes for conduit C13816037 that were caused by the installation

of separation barrier sa.terial,444tdet&4=9=00)r ft

[

B l

.  !

,,

r,

=

n

=

3'

"

= l

"

i n

.

> ,,

......... u.s.wuctsAn naoutATony comussew l

._

- __-_-__ _-_- . _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - . _ _ . __ ._ _ - . _

-. _ __

l

- .

i l

I soov2*" mes, q

'

assomt . .,

sacerv no e-o3_ _ *_t><n.cea,u ,, gg p

" " * * i o. ,,

n u,sese-. g, ,,n (

en

• .

e f a S . Adi i

• ro e e in. f 1 1 i

e 9 9 e t 0 $aC INSPECTOR'S REPORT -

9 -

(Continuation)

c

,

{4 - .

, ,

.

_

f6ce Gfinspection and Enforcement - -

.--- ..-. -.. , r 3,o..,...,__-=

O F- A w m,P c~99n W -A ~_ ~

-

~J 2 h f "~~ A *~~

- lb A._p Al i A/ *I1 r b  ;

?.h"ldid UL

-

-. } .

E- 1- t ]

s- .~ l

. . g > ~ J .* & J** - .*

ff A9 m l

'

_n - -- t L --- -- - h =

o, f >- _ i-n j( _ g _e _ f_ y ,

s E7 V 1

-

i I

D '_ wk- .,p y!_ _ a - -h -p _A--,AL v

t e. 1.'. -

a y

_7" _c L A .f f yn ~ . '"t f .

I k ~ . / L C _._ Z ~ r _ . T nE -Mw2iv k

. '

.,,c _ . o~' ' )

b- D. s - E & A- - Alu' \

.

• J z Je - Ed3-N ~O W"

-

,

i i

,

_

e i

.

e

,,

"

!

oi

,I pI

__

,,

de t

U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

........,

\

,

__ . . _ .

- _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _

..

=ac*o*= MS^ *eroa' 88cov*u"*8 "

'gy wo <svno nocasv aaooverm ' es

is.. ..o.u.c ao ao . FIT 12#t ic tfi -

INSPECTOR'S REPORT e r o ci'o u ar # h * '*"'**""'*""**'*"

o Sie-e (Continuation) , , , , , , c Office of Inspection and Enforcement c g , p e o[

_ .o.o.,... . ~ -. -.~ - .. - . _ .. ,

,

, g '

gk_ h C *H vi J k " 1 *a 8 b '~ > o & A M ,

,

t _ E m 1. a ) rl'i- AJ-- - *- 'AG M - A

/.p Q. !) C 2*7'A - LL o T A$n  % - A **

.

, w , , s, a L , de- Z = C v -'-l g,-

"

M Af--! i-f

, .

__r- i a.- N o E ~<1 e r ~ 5 -

s

, .. . mine as-built drawings were revised and distributed

• ' by TUGC0 Nuclear Engineering to reflect NCR identified undersite weld without receiving TUCG0 Operations review, approval, and authorization to

.

distribute the revised drawing M tt

13

_

il

13

. .

!' ' -

n

"

/

es 3a

" l

s' l

!

a n

ft l'

"

l n

- M

fl

• I i,

=n>.. u.s. MucLun nrouLAtony comuissioN

- _ _ _ _ _ _

.

,,,,, .covu mmesa N.e."m","'"uc * "8 ef. loo E Ess" , .o eso e It is.1 TOC INSPECTOR'S REPORT e e e a e u. h. f Fr * ***'********vg'* en (Continuation)

1. a e , , , , , , $g 1 Office of inspection and Enforcement c o

g

_

p }. . ,_

-

. . . . . . . . - . . . - . . . . .,

t 3 F~ r- k=~ A ~ f W- v J AL " 1 % B &~so e F L 3 &

P . "J s_-=> s y n L E

'

s ro 6 L - - _ 11, g o

, E 9 - al p / 1 .l _ "P- [' *- tw ".- m

,

/ /

• . it was noted on October 21,1985, Meuman'tationforClass1ElightingsystemconduitEAB1-1thattheduring review of

,

electrical inspector, who had signed inspection reports E-1-0024951 and

' E-1-0027419 had not been certifled to the applicable Precedure i

'

e O!-0P-11.2-25. Revision 17. dated February 13. 1984. *1aspection of New Installations for Class 1E Lighting $ystems.'

..

-

, 13 to Il

17

4

21 N

B

>

M

.

• M . 4

,l W

D ts

- 1

,

0l

.

80 etta ei u.S. NUCLSAR REGULAfoRY CoMMISSIO

I

~

d 85-/Y (5-u ,

,

l l

-_