|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20217E1551999-09-28028 September 1999 Comment Supporting Pr 10CFR50 Re Elimination of Requirement for Licensees to Revise ISI & IST Programs Beyond Baseline Edition & Addenda of ASME B&PV Code ML17313B0651999-07-30030 July 1999 Comment on Draft Rg DG-1076, Service Level I,Ii & III Protective Coatings Applied to Npps. ML17313B0161999-07-0101 July 1999 Comment on Draft Rg DG-1074, SG Tube Integrity. ML20196K5631999-06-29029 June 1999 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50.55a Re Elimination of 120-month Requirement to Update ASME Code ISI & Inservice Testing Program ML20207D1591999-05-20020 May 1999 Comment on Proposed Rules 10CFR21,50 & 54 Re Use of Alternative Source Terms at Operating Reactors ML17313A9791999-05-20020 May 1999 Comment Opposing Draft Reg Guide DG-1084, Qualification & Training of Personnel for Nuclear Power Plants. as General Comment,Util Believes That Many of Proposed Changes Will Limit Ability to cross-train Mgt Level Personnel ML20205A4271999-03-18018 March 1999 Comment on Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-64 Which Requested Greater Clarification by NRC Re Possible Financial Obligations of NPP Licensees as Reflected in NRC Final Policy Statement on Restructuring & Economic Deregulation ML17313A8521999-03-0505 March 1999 Comment Supporting Proposed Change to NRC Enforcement Policy.Suggested Rewording of Sections Provided ML17313A8191999-02-24024 February 1999 Comment Supporting Secy 99-007, Recommendation for Reactor Oversight Process Improvements, & Comments Provided by NEI & Regional Utility Group Iv.Offers Comments on NRC Approach to Using Performance Indicators in Assessment Process ML20198J4031998-12-11011 December 1998 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Requirement for Monitoring Effectiveness of Maint at NPPs ML20217B9761998-04-0909 April 1998 Comment Re Draft RG DG-1029, Guidelines for Evaluating Electromagnetic & Radio-Frequency Interference in Safey-Related Instrumentation & Control Sys ML20216A9091998-04-0303 April 1998 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50.55a Re Industry Codes & Stds ML17313A3361998-03-27027 March 1998 Comment Opposing Proposed GL Re Lab Testing on Nuclear-Grade Activated Charcoal. Believes That Proposed 60 Day Implementation Schedule Would Severely Challenge Resources of Limited Number of Qualified Vendors ML20217E8781998-03-27027 March 1998 Comment Supporting Proposed GL, Lab Testing of Nuclear- Grade Activated Charcoal ML17313A2511998-03-0303 March 1998 Comment on Proposed GL 98-XX Re Yr 2000 Readiness of Computer Sys at Npps. ML20203L5521998-02-25025 February 1998 Forwards Comments on Draft Reg Guide DG-5008, Reporting of Safeguards Events ML20202E4251998-01-30030 January 1998 Comment on Draft RG DG-1070, Sampling Plans Used for Dedicating Simple Metallic Commercial Grade Items for Use in Npps. Draft RG Should Be Revised to Clarify That Alloy Analyzer Can Be Used Consistent W/Guidance in EPRI NP-5652 ML20199E0871998-01-17017 January 1998 Comment Opposing PRM 50-63A by Pg Crane Re Amending Emergency Planning Regulations to Require Consideration of Prophylactic Use of Potassium Iodide for General Public ML20202G4461997-12-0101 December 1997 Comment on Proposed Final Rule 10CFR50.Licensee Requests That Effective Date Be Delayed from 980101 to 0601,in Order to Provide Enough Time to Request & Obtain NRC Review of Exemption from Rule ML20212D1391997-10-17017 October 1997 Comment on Pr 10CFR55 Re NUREG-1021,Interim Rev 8, Operator Licensing Exam Stds for Power Reactors ML17312B4241997-04-23023 April 1997 Comment Supporting Draft Rg DG-1068 (Proposed Rev 3 to Rg 1.134, Medical Evaluation of Licensing Personnel at Npps) ML20134J9671997-02-0606 February 1997 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50, Draft Policy Statement on Restructuring & Economic Deregulation of Electric Util Industry ML20134N2521996-11-14014 November 1996 Comment on Draft RG DG-1012,proposed Rev 3 to RG 1.8, Qualification & Training of Personnel for Npp ML20117E3871996-08-0707 August 1996 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR26 Re Mod to fitness-for-duty Program Requirements ML20113C6981996-06-24024 June 1996 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50, Financial Assurance Requirements for Decommissioning Nuclear Power Reactors. Cautions NRC Not to Adopt Rules That Are Too Restrictive & Could Lead to Premature Decommissioning ML20117P1261996-06-24024 June 1996 Comment on Proposed Rule 10CFR50, Financial Assurance Requirements for Decommissioning Nuclear Power Reactors. Urges NRC to Approach Rulemaking Re Decommissioning Costs in Manner That Will Facilitate Federal Legislative Solution ML20095A8461995-11-28028 November 1995 Comment on Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-62 Re Proposed Changes to 10CFR50.54.Util Endorses Industry Petition & Response Provided by NEI ML17311B2931995-11-27027 November 1995 Comment Opposing Draft NUREG/CR-6354, Performance Testing of Electronic Personnel Dosimeters. ML17311B1601995-08-31031 August 1995 Comment Opposing Review of Revised NRC SALP ML20087H7241995-08-16016 August 1995 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR2 Re Comment on Revision of NRC Enforcement Policy ML20087H7501995-08-0404 August 1995 Comment on Proposed Rule 10CFR52 Re Std Design Certification for ABWR Design & Std Design Certification for Sys 80+ Design ML20087H7331995-08-0404 August 1995 Comment on Proposed Rule 10CFR52 Re Standard Design Certification for ABWR Design & Standard Design Certification for Sys 80+ Design.Concurs w/ABB-CE Comments & NEI Recommendations ML17311B0071995-06-27027 June 1995 Comment on Proposed Review of NRC Insp Rept Content,Format & Style. Insp Detail Should Be Brief & Ref Previous Rept by Section or at Min IR Number ML20083N5031995-05-0505 May 1995 Comment on Proposed Rev to 10CFR50,app J, Primary Reactor Containment Leakage Testing for Water-Cooled Power Reactors. Proposed Rev Will Result in Highly Efficient Regulation ML20082P7461995-04-19019 April 1995 Comment Supporting Proposed Rules 10CFR170 & 171 Re Proposed Revs of NRC Fee Schedule for FY95 in Fr ML20082H0971995-04-10010 April 1995 Draft Policy Statement Re Freedom of Employees in Nuclear Industry to Raise Safety Concerns W/O Fear of Retaliation ML20081B5721995-03-0808 March 1995 Motion of Plains Electric Generation & Transmission Cooperative,Inc to Withdraw,W/Prejudice,Petition for Leave to Intervene,Request for Finding of Significant Change & for Antitrust Hearing & Comments.* W/Certificate of Svc ML17311A6691995-02-0202 February 1995 Comment Supporting Draft Rg DG-8014 (Proposed Rev 3 to Rg 8.13, Instruction Concerning Prenatal Radiation Exposure) ML20078H0671995-01-20020 January 1995 Comment Supporting NUMARC Position on Proposed Rules 10CFR20,30,40,50,51,70 & 72 Re Radiological Criteria for Decommissioning of Lands & Structures ML20077M5471995-01-0404 January 1995 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Shutdown & low-power Operations for Nuclear Power Reactor Proposed Rule ML17311A2461994-08-25025 August 1994 Comment on Draft Reg Guide (DG-1031), Monitoring Effectiveness of Maint at Npps. Term Maint Preventable Failure Needs to Be Defined & Compared to Term Maint Preventable Functional Failure. ML17310B1911994-04-12012 April 1994 Petition to Intervene of Public Utility Commission of Texas. W/Certificate of Svc ML17310B2041994-04-12012 April 1994 Petition to Intervene of Public Utility Commission of Tx ML20062M4141993-12-27027 December 1993 Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-21-2 Re Procurement of Commercial Grade Items ML20056G3351993-08-27027 August 1993 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR2 Re Review of 10CFR2.206 Process ML17306B2461993-01-15015 January 1993 Comment Supporting in Part,Draft Reg Guide DG-1020, Monitoring Effectiveness of Maint at Npps. ML17306A9571992-09-0808 September 1992 Comments on Proposed Rev to Staff Technical Position on Radwaste Classification.Supports Rev ML20099E0621992-07-29029 July 1992 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50.63, Loss of All AC Power ML20090F9661992-03-0909 March 1992 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50 & 52 Re Training & Qualification of Nuclear Power Plant Personnel ML17306A4501992-02-0404 February 1992 Comment on Draft Reg Guide Task DG-8007 (Proposed Rev 1 to Reg Guide 8.7) Re Instructions for Recording & Reporting Occupational Radiation Exposure Data 1999-09-28
[Table view] Category:TRANSCRIPTS
MONTHYEARML20214H4031986-10-14014 October 1986 Transcript of R Zimmerman 861014 Deposition in Phoenix,Az. Pp 1-108 ML20214H5311986-10-10010 October 1986 Transcript of MD Schuster 861010 Desposition.Pp 1-81 ML20214H5901986-10-10010 October 1986 Transcript of DW Schaefer 861010 Deposition.Pp 1-53.W/ CE Mullins 870520 Transmittal Memo ML20214H4491986-10-0909 October 1986 Transcript of Gn Cook 861009 Deposition.Pp 1-104 ML20203H4191986-04-23023 April 1986 Transcript of Commission 860423 Discussion/Possible Vote in Washington,Dc on Full Power Ol.Pp 1-67.Viewgraphs Encl ML20138K0661985-12-12012 December 1985 Transcript of 851212 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote in Washington,Dc Re SECY-85-367A on Palo Verde 1 Leaseback & SECY-85-371 on Refund on Black Fox License Fee.Pp 1-4 ML20198E3301985-11-0505 November 1985 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Cessar/Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station 851105 Meeting in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-326. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20126M3591985-06-12012 June 1985 Transcript of 850612 Hearing in Phoenix,Az Re OL Proceeding. Pp 3,091-3,137 ML20126E3001985-06-11011 June 1985 Transcript of 850611 Hearing in Phoenix,Az Re OL Proceeding. Pp 2,894-3,090 ML20128P5061985-05-30030 May 1985 Testimony of RB Samworth Re Rate of Emission of Drift from Facility Cooling Towers.Related Correspondence ML20126G7621985-05-30030 May 1985 Transcript of Commission 850530 Discussion/Possible Vote in Washington,Dc Re Full Power Ol.Pp 1-66.Viewgraphs Encl ML20062D5231982-08-0303 August 1982 Proposed Corrections to 820427-30,0525-28 & 0622-25 Transcripts of Hearing ML20128N3741982-07-15015 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Rc Ruff on 820715 Re Allegations. Pp 1-7 ML20128N3601982-07-15015 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Rc Ruff on 820715 Re Allegations. Pp 1-8 ML20128M8941982-07-14014 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Wm Baker on 820714 Re Allegations.Pp 1-30 ML20128N5861982-07-13013 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Yoshimoto on 820713 Re Allegations.Pp 1-12 ML20128M8721982-07-13013 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of T Bunting on 820713 Re Allegations.Pp 1-40 ML20128M9651982-07-0202 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Nj Doebler on 820702 Re Core Drilling Allegations.Pp 1-8 ML20128N5641982-07-0101 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jt Hanze on 820701 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17 ML20128M9161982-07-0101 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of WR Burdick on 820701 Re Allegations.Pp 1-28 ML20128M9451982-07-0101 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of RA Deakins on 820701 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17 ML20128N2191982-06-30030 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of RA Rehfeld on 820630 Re Allegations.Pp 1-37 ML20127P5181982-06-29029 June 1982 Transcript of Tape Recorded 820629 Interview W/Hr Nunez Re Allegation of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20128N1701982-06-29029 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of HR Nunez on 820629 Re Responses to Allegations.Pp 1-44.Info Deleted ML20128N5371982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of JB Sweet on 820628 Re Allegations.Pp 1-28 ML20127P6631982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/Jg Sandoval Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work Done at Facilities ML20128N4071982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jg Sandoval on 820628 Re Responses to Allegations.Pp 1-14 ML20127P6881982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/Jb Sweet Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20128N0021982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Mb Goldberg on 820628 Re Allegations.Pp 1-7 ML20054J8871982-06-25025 June 1982 Transcript of 820625 OL Evidentiary Hearing in Phoenix,Az. Pp 2,455-2,710 ML20054J8641982-06-24024 June 1982 Transcript of 820614 OL Hearing in Phoenix,Az.Pp 2,223- 2,454 ML20054K0321982-06-23023 June 1982 Transcript of 820623 OL Evidentiary Hearing in Phoenix,Az. Pp 2,020-2,222 ML20054J9891982-06-22022 June 1982 Transcript of 820622 OL Hearing in Phoenix,Az. Pp 1,779-2,019 ML20128N0161982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Ga Kennard on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-18.Info Deleted ML20054F9301982-06-17017 June 1982 Testimony of Wg Bingham Re Circulating Water Tests, Flexibility in Design & Operation of Circulating Water Sys & Reliability of Facility Water Reclamation Plant ML20128N4721982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Kh Seger on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17.Transcript of Interview of RB Keith on 820617 Encl (Pp 1-17) ML20127P5371982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/Ga Kennard Re Allegation of Falsification of Termination Cable Cards for Work Performed at Facilities ML20127P5511982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/P Aguayo ML20127P5971982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/Dj Mast Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work Done at Facilities ML20127P6221982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/Sj Moody Re Allegation of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work Done at Facilities ML20128N4411982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jh Schuh on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17.Info Deleted ML20127P6761982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/Jh Schuh Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20128N1311982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Sj Moody on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-15 ML20128N1051982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Dj Mast on 820617 Re Allegations. Pp 1-17 ML20128M9331982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jh Crane on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-32 ML20128N4991982-06-16016 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of P Sollami on 820616 Re Allegations.Pp 1-9 ML20128N5761982-06-16016 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of C Wallerstein on 820616 Re Allegations.Pp 1-27 ML20054F9231982-06-16016 June 1982 Testimony of Ek Swanson Re Contamination of Groundwater in Phoenix,Az Area Documented by State of Az Dept of Health Svcs.Trichloroethylene Briefing Document,Raw Data & Dibromochloropropane Sampling Program Encl ML20127P7091982-06-16016 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/K Wallerstein by Ej Power & Oc Shuckleton Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20054F6891982-06-15015 June 1982 Testimony of Jj Lemmon Re Contamination of Groundwater in Phoenix Area & Possible Adverse Impact on Available Water Supplies to Municipalities in Foreseeable Future.Supporting Documentation Encl 1986-04-23
[Table view] Category:DEPOSITIONS
MONTHYEARML20214H4031986-10-14014 October 1986 Transcript of R Zimmerman 861014 Deposition in Phoenix,Az. Pp 1-108 ML20214H5311986-10-10010 October 1986 Transcript of MD Schuster 861010 Desposition.Pp 1-81 ML20214H5901986-10-10010 October 1986 Transcript of DW Schaefer 861010 Deposition.Pp 1-53.W/ CE Mullins 870520 Transmittal Memo ML20214H4491986-10-0909 October 1986 Transcript of Gn Cook 861009 Deposition.Pp 1-104 ML20203H4191986-04-23023 April 1986 Transcript of Commission 860423 Discussion/Possible Vote in Washington,Dc on Full Power Ol.Pp 1-67.Viewgraphs Encl ML20138K0661985-12-12012 December 1985 Transcript of 851212 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote in Washington,Dc Re SECY-85-367A on Palo Verde 1 Leaseback & SECY-85-371 on Refund on Black Fox License Fee.Pp 1-4 ML20198E3301985-11-0505 November 1985 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Cessar/Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station 851105 Meeting in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-326. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20126M3591985-06-12012 June 1985 Transcript of 850612 Hearing in Phoenix,Az Re OL Proceeding. Pp 3,091-3,137 ML20126E3001985-06-11011 June 1985 Transcript of 850611 Hearing in Phoenix,Az Re OL Proceeding. Pp 2,894-3,090 ML20128P5061985-05-30030 May 1985 Testimony of RB Samworth Re Rate of Emission of Drift from Facility Cooling Towers.Related Correspondence ML20126G7621985-05-30030 May 1985 Transcript of Commission 850530 Discussion/Possible Vote in Washington,Dc Re Full Power Ol.Pp 1-66.Viewgraphs Encl ML20062D5231982-08-0303 August 1982 Proposed Corrections to 820427-30,0525-28 & 0622-25 Transcripts of Hearing ML20128N3741982-07-15015 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Rc Ruff on 820715 Re Allegations. Pp 1-7 ML20128N3601982-07-15015 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Rc Ruff on 820715 Re Allegations. Pp 1-8 ML20128M8941982-07-14014 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Wm Baker on 820714 Re Allegations.Pp 1-30 ML20128N5861982-07-13013 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Yoshimoto on 820713 Re Allegations.Pp 1-12 ML20128M8721982-07-13013 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of T Bunting on 820713 Re Allegations.Pp 1-40 ML20128M9651982-07-0202 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Nj Doebler on 820702 Re Core Drilling Allegations.Pp 1-8 ML20128N5641982-07-0101 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jt Hanze on 820701 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17 ML20128M9161982-07-0101 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of WR Burdick on 820701 Re Allegations.Pp 1-28 ML20128M9451982-07-0101 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of RA Deakins on 820701 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17 ML20128N2191982-06-30030 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of RA Rehfeld on 820630 Re Allegations.Pp 1-37 ML20127P5181982-06-29029 June 1982 Transcript of Tape Recorded 820629 Interview W/Hr Nunez Re Allegation of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20128N1701982-06-29029 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of HR Nunez on 820629 Re Responses to Allegations.Pp 1-44.Info Deleted ML20128N5371982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of JB Sweet on 820628 Re Allegations.Pp 1-28 ML20127P6631982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/Jg Sandoval Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work Done at Facilities ML20128N4071982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jg Sandoval on 820628 Re Responses to Allegations.Pp 1-14 ML20127P6881982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/Jb Sweet Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20128N0021982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Mb Goldberg on 820628 Re Allegations.Pp 1-7 ML20054J8871982-06-25025 June 1982 Transcript of 820625 OL Evidentiary Hearing in Phoenix,Az. Pp 2,455-2,710 ML20054J8641982-06-24024 June 1982 Transcript of 820614 OL Hearing in Phoenix,Az.Pp 2,223- 2,454 ML20054K0321982-06-23023 June 1982 Transcript of 820623 OL Evidentiary Hearing in Phoenix,Az. Pp 2,020-2,222 ML20054J9891982-06-22022 June 1982 Transcript of 820622 OL Hearing in Phoenix,Az. Pp 1,779-2,019 ML20128N0161982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Ga Kennard on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-18.Info Deleted ML20054F9301982-06-17017 June 1982 Testimony of Wg Bingham Re Circulating Water Tests, Flexibility in Design & Operation of Circulating Water Sys & Reliability of Facility Water Reclamation Plant ML20128N4721982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Kh Seger on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17.Transcript of Interview of RB Keith on 820617 Encl (Pp 1-17) ML20127P5371982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/Ga Kennard Re Allegation of Falsification of Termination Cable Cards for Work Performed at Facilities ML20127P5511982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/P Aguayo ML20127P5971982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/Dj Mast Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work Done at Facilities ML20127P6221982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/Sj Moody Re Allegation of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work Done at Facilities ML20128N4411982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jh Schuh on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17.Info Deleted ML20127P6761982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/Jh Schuh Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20128N1311982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Sj Moody on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-15 ML20128N1051982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Dj Mast on 820617 Re Allegations. Pp 1-17 ML20128M9331982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jh Crane on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-32 ML20128N4991982-06-16016 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of P Sollami on 820616 Re Allegations.Pp 1-9 ML20128N5761982-06-16016 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of C Wallerstein on 820616 Re Allegations.Pp 1-27 ML20054F9231982-06-16016 June 1982 Testimony of Ek Swanson Re Contamination of Groundwater in Phoenix,Az Area Documented by State of Az Dept of Health Svcs.Trichloroethylene Briefing Document,Raw Data & Dibromochloropropane Sampling Program Encl ML20127P7091982-06-16016 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/K Wallerstein by Ej Power & Oc Shuckleton Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20054F6891982-06-15015 June 1982 Testimony of Jj Lemmon Re Contamination of Groundwater in Phoenix Area & Possible Adverse Impact on Available Water Supplies to Municipalities in Foreseeable Future.Supporting Documentation Encl 1986-04-23
[Table view] Category:NARRATIVE TESTIMONY
MONTHYEARML20214H4031986-10-14014 October 1986 Transcript of R Zimmerman 861014 Deposition in Phoenix,Az. Pp 1-108 ML20214H5311986-10-10010 October 1986 Transcript of MD Schuster 861010 Desposition.Pp 1-81 ML20214H5901986-10-10010 October 1986 Transcript of DW Schaefer 861010 Deposition.Pp 1-53.W/ CE Mullins 870520 Transmittal Memo ML20214H4491986-10-0909 October 1986 Transcript of Gn Cook 861009 Deposition.Pp 1-104 ML20203H4191986-04-23023 April 1986 Transcript of Commission 860423 Discussion/Possible Vote in Washington,Dc on Full Power Ol.Pp 1-67.Viewgraphs Encl ML20138K0661985-12-12012 December 1985 Transcript of 851212 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote in Washington,Dc Re SECY-85-367A on Palo Verde 1 Leaseback & SECY-85-371 on Refund on Black Fox License Fee.Pp 1-4 ML20198E3301985-11-0505 November 1985 Transcript of ACRS Subcommittee on Cessar/Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station 851105 Meeting in Washington,Dc.Pp 1-326. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20126M3591985-06-12012 June 1985 Transcript of 850612 Hearing in Phoenix,Az Re OL Proceeding. Pp 3,091-3,137 ML20126E3001985-06-11011 June 1985 Transcript of 850611 Hearing in Phoenix,Az Re OL Proceeding. Pp 2,894-3,090 ML20128P5061985-05-30030 May 1985 Testimony of RB Samworth Re Rate of Emission of Drift from Facility Cooling Towers.Related Correspondence ML20126G7621985-05-30030 May 1985 Transcript of Commission 850530 Discussion/Possible Vote in Washington,Dc Re Full Power Ol.Pp 1-66.Viewgraphs Encl ML20062D5231982-08-0303 August 1982 Proposed Corrections to 820427-30,0525-28 & 0622-25 Transcripts of Hearing ML20128N3741982-07-15015 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Rc Ruff on 820715 Re Allegations. Pp 1-7 ML20128N3601982-07-15015 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Rc Ruff on 820715 Re Allegations. Pp 1-8 ML20128M8941982-07-14014 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Wm Baker on 820714 Re Allegations.Pp 1-30 ML20128N5861982-07-13013 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Yoshimoto on 820713 Re Allegations.Pp 1-12 ML20128M8721982-07-13013 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of T Bunting on 820713 Re Allegations.Pp 1-40 ML20128M9651982-07-0202 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Nj Doebler on 820702 Re Core Drilling Allegations.Pp 1-8 ML20128N5641982-07-0101 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jt Hanze on 820701 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17 ML20128M9161982-07-0101 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of WR Burdick on 820701 Re Allegations.Pp 1-28 ML20128M9451982-07-0101 July 1982 Transcript of Interview of RA Deakins on 820701 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17 ML20128N2191982-06-30030 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of RA Rehfeld on 820630 Re Allegations.Pp 1-37 ML20127P5181982-06-29029 June 1982 Transcript of Tape Recorded 820629 Interview W/Hr Nunez Re Allegation of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20128N1701982-06-29029 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of HR Nunez on 820629 Re Responses to Allegations.Pp 1-44.Info Deleted ML20128N5371982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of JB Sweet on 820628 Re Allegations.Pp 1-28 ML20127P6631982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/Jg Sandoval Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work Done at Facilities ML20128N4071982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jg Sandoval on 820628 Re Responses to Allegations.Pp 1-14 ML20127P6881982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/Jb Sweet Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20128N0021982-06-28028 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Mb Goldberg on 820628 Re Allegations.Pp 1-7 ML20054J8871982-06-25025 June 1982 Transcript of 820625 OL Evidentiary Hearing in Phoenix,Az. Pp 2,455-2,710 ML20054J8641982-06-24024 June 1982 Transcript of 820614 OL Hearing in Phoenix,Az.Pp 2,223- 2,454 ML20054K0321982-06-23023 June 1982 Transcript of 820623 OL Evidentiary Hearing in Phoenix,Az. Pp 2,020-2,222 ML20054J9891982-06-22022 June 1982 Transcript of 820622 OL Hearing in Phoenix,Az. Pp 1,779-2,019 ML20128N0161982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Ga Kennard on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-18.Info Deleted ML20054F9301982-06-17017 June 1982 Testimony of Wg Bingham Re Circulating Water Tests, Flexibility in Design & Operation of Circulating Water Sys & Reliability of Facility Water Reclamation Plant ML20128N4721982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Kh Seger on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17.Transcript of Interview of RB Keith on 820617 Encl (Pp 1-17) ML20127P5371982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/Ga Kennard Re Allegation of Falsification of Termination Cable Cards for Work Performed at Facilities ML20127P5511982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/P Aguayo ML20127P5971982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/Dj Mast Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work Done at Facilities ML20127P6221982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of 820617 Interview W/Sj Moody Re Allegation of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work Done at Facilities ML20128N4411982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jh Schuh on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-17.Info Deleted ML20127P6761982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/Jh Schuh Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20128N1311982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Sj Moody on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-15 ML20128N1051982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Dj Mast on 820617 Re Allegations. Pp 1-17 ML20128M9331982-06-17017 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of Jh Crane on 820617 Re Allegations.Pp 1-32 ML20128N4991982-06-16016 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of P Sollami on 820616 Re Allegations.Pp 1-9 ML20128N5761982-06-16016 June 1982 Transcript of Interview of C Wallerstein on 820616 Re Allegations.Pp 1-27 ML20054F9231982-06-16016 June 1982 Testimony of Ek Swanson Re Contamination of Groundwater in Phoenix,Az Area Documented by State of Az Dept of Health Svcs.Trichloroethylene Briefing Document,Raw Data & Dibromochloropropane Sampling Program Encl ML20127P7091982-06-16016 June 1982 Transcript of Interview W/K Wallerstein by Ej Power & Oc Shuckleton Re Allegations of Falsification of Termination Cards for Work at Facilities ML20054F6891982-06-15015 June 1982 Testimony of Jj Lemmon Re Contamination of Groundwater in Phoenix Area & Possible Adverse Impact on Available Water Supplies to Municipalities in Foreseeable Future.Supporting Documentation Encl 1986-04-23
[Table view] |
Text
--
c.. -
' co y
UNITED STATES.0F AMERICA c O NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION- ..
.BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD 00CHETED l .\)StJRC In the Matter of-15 'MY 31 P5 :54 ARIZONA PUBLIC. SERVICE Docket Nos. STN 50-529' .' .-
COMPANY, E 3 .. ) STN 50-530c77;cg g7 glgC ETAFv
-d- 00CXETlha & SEnvirl'-
-(Palo Verde Nuclear Generating ER AliCH Station, Units 2 and.3)
.NRC STAFF. TESTIMONY OF ROBERT B. SAMWORTH v
~
'0N THE RATE OF EMISSION OF DRIFT FROM THE PALO VERDE COOLING TOWERS Q1. Please state your name and-position.
~
.A1.- My name is' Robert B. Samworth. I am the Leader of the Environmental
- Engineering Section within the Division of Engineering, Office of
~
. Nucle'ar Reactor Regulation, USNRC..
-Q2. .Do you.have a Profeseional Qualifications Statement?
s A2. .A copy is attached to this' testimony.
~
~ Q3.1What is the purpose of your testimony?
- A3...To consider what the propericooling tower drift rate should be for
- the PVNGS cooling. towers. .Specifically, I shall compare'the drift rate utilized in Staff's environmental impact assessment, namely
'9506030550 850530 -
PDR- ADOCK OSO g 9.-
N
%...-.-,-y.r.w._.....-,.--.
0.0044% of the circulating water flow rate, with the results of the Environmental Systems Corporation (ESC) study which have been cited by the Applicant's witnesses in their testimony. The ESC Study measured a drift rate of 0.0002% of the circulating water flow rate
~
under one of its sampling methods. -
. Q4. Why did the staff use a drift rate of 0.0044% of circulating water flow to perform the environmental assessment?
I A4. This was the rate, which according to Staff's environmental report
, (ER-OL 3.4-3), was the des'ign value for the system and it is the rate which is specified by the tower manufacturer, the Marley Company.
. QS.- Were you concerned whether the Marley rate of 0.0044% could be met?
AS. No. The value was within the range used for other projects and within the' range of measured values for operating cooling towers.
I believe this.is a reasonable value even though this rate was questioned by the Intervenor's consultant, Dr. Michael W. Golay, in his comments that were supplied in January 1984.
'i Q6. Have you read the testimony of Applicant's witness, Dr. Morton I.
Goldman, which was recently filed in this proceeding regarding the cooling tower drift rate?
A6. Yes.
3-Q7. Are you aware of the drift rate which he has recommended?
~
A7. Yes. Dr. Goldman cites the study performed by ESC as determining
that the drift rate of the Palo Verde cooling towers will be 0.0002%.
-Q8. Have you reviewed the ESC study?
A8. Yes, I reviewed it briefly when it first came in to NRC in September 1983.
Q9. What is your opinion of the study?
4 A9. It is a good study. ESC used two different techniques (sensitive paper and isokinetic sampling) to measure drift rate on three cells of one cooling tower at Palo Verde. In my opinion, the results provide reasonable satisfaction that the manufacturer's design
- drift rate will be met. The study also demonstrates the difficulties of measuring drift as evidenced by the fact that the results of the two sampling methods utilized in this study varied significantly.
Q10. Do you think the results of the ESC Study relied upon by Dr. Goldman (i.e. the 0.0002% drift rate) should be used for estimating the impact of drift from the PVNGS cooling towers?
A10. Although the ESC Study oives confidence as to the conservativeness of the manufacturer's design rate, there are some shortcomings to the study itself which indicate to me it is better to rely upon the manufacturer's rate. The Study was conducted unter a limited set of conditions. For example, Table 1, which is attached to my testimony',
summarizes selected. data from the ESC study. The actual collection of the data was done in a four-day period. Although one cell was measured twice, the study design did not allow computation of a
~
. confidence' interval for the drift rate. The station was not producing electricity and, as a result, the water temperature was at about 15 C (59 F) during the studies. During actual operation the water teinperature will range as high as 48 C (118.8 F). Similarly air temperature during the study period was in the range of 21 C to 24 C (70 to 75 F) whereas ambient temperature at the site ranges seasonally from 7'C.(19 F) to 47 C (116*F). (See ER-OL 5 2.3).
Another limitation of the study was that the quality of the circulating water during the study was not typical of what will exist during station operation.
Moreover, the study was not free of defect. The wind speed during the four days of data collection ranged from a low of about 6 miles per hour during the study of cell I to a high of about 38 miles per hour during the sampling of cell N. Although there are possibly other varying factors, it appears that wind speed may have affected' the amount of drift recorded,since lower drift rates were detected during the periods of higher wind flow.
L
A further problem appears to be that the two sampling methods utilized in the study (the isokinetic and the sensitive paper technique) are generally believed to be capable of measuring drift rate results that are within 15% of the true value. However, the values yielded by the two techniques in the study at Palo Verde "
differed by a factor of about 6 (i.e. the isokinetic sampling technique gave an average estimate ot drift rate which is six times the estimate by the sensitive paper technique.) I also note that in his testimony Dr. Goldman did not use the conservative isokinetic value but rather has based his analysis on potential agricultural crop damage on the sensitive paper technique which gave a lower value.
Q11. Is the drift rate indicated by the sensitive paper technique a reasonable rate?
.w All. The Applicant's witness, Mr. Karl R. Wilber, has reported in his testimony (at p. 9 and Exhibit W-8) drift rate measurements at other cooling towers. None of the values for these other towers was as low as the value for Palo Verde. Moreover, as he notes, the 0.0002% value has only been measured in laboratory environments where essentially ideal conditions existed.
I- _
In contrast to the values'in the ESC Study and for the cooling towers cited by Mr. Wilber, Table 2, which is attached to my testimony, shows drift rate values which have been used for assessing impact at nuclear power stations. Although these are
~
design values and not measured values (as is the case of the ESC' StudyandthecoolingtowershitedbyMr.Wilber),thevaluesreported at these stations are considerably higher than the value for Palo Verde in the ESC report using the sensitive paper method.
Q12. Based upon the information presently available, what are your conclusions regarding the drift value which should be used for predicting deposition rates at Palo Verde?
A12. I would recommend that the initial assessment of impact for the Palo
. Verde cooling towers be based on the more conservative manufacturer's drift rate of 0.0044%. The ESC Study is useful in demonstrating that the manufacturer's design rate will be met and that any estimate
'of drift based on this value will not underestimate impact.
Personal Qualifications Statement Robert B. Samworth, Ph.D.
May 29, 1985 Robert B. Samworth is employed by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission as th'a Leader of the Environmental Engineering Section, Environmental and Hydrological Engineering Branch, Division of Engireering, Office of Nuclear Rsgulation. He has held that position since 1976.
As the Section Leader, major portions of environmental impa[t statemen s are prcpared under his supervision. Incl'ubed are essentially all sections on non-radiological impacts to aquatic and terrestrial resources. Specifically caong impacts for which his section is responsible is the assessment of the offects of cooling tower drift.
Dr. Samworth is the senior staff expert on environmental engineering questions and is highly qualified for this responsibility through education cnd training. He holds a B.S. degree in Civil Engineering from the University of Del aware, an M.S. degree in Sanitary Engineering from the Johns Hopkins University, and the Ph.D. degree in Civil Engineering from Cornell Uni ver si ty.
Dr. Samworth joined the regulator'y staff in October, 1972, as an cnvironmental engineer during the period of the NRC's initial NEPA reviews of nuclear power plant license applications. He performed reviews related to impacts of power plant operation on water quality and water use and provided Environn, ental Impact Statement input for several projects prior to assuming th2 responsibilities of Section Leader. He participated in the development of review procedures as set forth in the Environmental Standard Review Plcns, revisions to Regulatory Guide 4.2, and revisions to NRC's regulations for environmental reviews found in 10 CFR Part 51.
Prior to joining NRC he was the Chief of the Grants, Research, and Statistics Branch with the Department of Environmental Services of the Government of the District of Columbia. There he was responsible for Cvaluating new technology f or achieving department objectives in water supply, wasterwater collection and treatment, and solid waste collection and dicposal. He served as liason between laboratory scientists and design cngineers in-the design of the treatment processes employed at the Dietrict's new wastewater treatment plant.
B fore that he was employed as a Public Health Engineer with the Tennessee Valley Authority where he conducted research concerning environmental problems associated with power generation at steam- and hydro-electric g:neration facilities.
-,J
T.___
a e
I C E 1. -Sc: ary of Falc Verde Eccling ic>er Test Results Free the ESC Stu:y.
~ --
.6
', Sas;le/ itse Tener t.ir Ter;erature .... kind Mass Drift Rate
.i Eate~ Interval Cell ----------------- - ------ -- ---
- Dry Bulb Wet Balb Speed Direttien SP IK ce; C. deg C. sph degrees g/s g/s
........ ........- ........ ........ ........ ===. ........ ... ... =
May.7 14:05.-1s:05 1-1 22.4 14.1 9 230-360 19:10-21:10 1-2 22.7 13.7 3 270-290 1.51 8.4
'May 8 14:55-16:40 K-1 30.8 17.9 16 210-200 17:35-19:20 K-1-R '29.0 14.0 17 210-205 Maf 9 09:45-11:30 K-2 24.4 13.) 16 200-120 1.82 11.9 12:05-13:M K-2-R 29.9 14.1 24 210-220 2.29 10.6 16:32-16:15 P-1 32.0 14.7 29 230-240 May 10 08:50-10:37 P-2 23.2 13.2 40 200 1.10 9.83 14:00-15:32- N-1 30.1 15.0 35 210 ~
17:35-19:12 h-2 28.9 13.9 40 210 0.425 4.91
)
h
o TAELE 2. Fower Plant Cooling Systes Data ,
a Station Unit Capac- Cooling .
Drift Nater NRC Date of ity'Systee Rate Source Rgn.Coseercial Mme Type 1 Operation Arkansas 2 858 NatD 0.01 Arkansas R. 4 1980 Eeaver Valley 1 810 NatD 0.05 Ohio River 1 1976 ..
- ~
Beaver Valley 2 852 NatD 0.013 Ohio River 1 E1987 Byron -1 '1120 NatD 0.002 Rock R. 3 L1985 Eyron 2 !!20 NatD 0.002 Rock R. 3 C1996 Catawba 2 1145 CircMech 0.008 Catawba R. 2 E1986-
~
~Cataeba 1 !!45 CircMech 0.000 Catawba R. 2 E1985 .
Farley 2 814 MechD 0.1 Chitahoochee R. 2 1981 Farley 1 804 MechD 0.1 Chatahcochee R. 2 1977 Fersi 2 1093 NatD (0.1 Lake Erie 3 1986 Grand Gulf 1 .1250 NatD ' O.008 Mississippi 2 198?
Grand Gull 2 1250 NatD 0.000 Mississippi 2 E19??
Harris (Shearon) 915 NatD 0.002 Cape Fear R. 2 E1986 Hatch 2 771 NatD (0.1 Altaeaha R. 2 1979
-Hatth. 1 -757 NatD (0.1 Altamaha R. 2 1975 Hope Creek 1067 NatD 0.00375 Delaware R. 1 E1986 Liwrick 1 1065 NatD 0.03 Schuylkill R. 1 E1986 p Liser.ck 2 1065 NatD 0.03 Schuylkill R. I ????
Palisades 635 MechD 0.005 Lake Michigan 3 1971 Palo Verde- 3 1304 CirtMech 0.00j4PhoenixSewage 5 E1987 Palo Verde l' 1304 CirtMech- 0.0044 Phoenix Semage 5 E1985 Palo Verde 2 1304 CirtMech 0.0044 Phoenix Semage 5 E1986 Peach Bottos 2 -1051 MechD (0.2 Susquehanna R. I 1974 Peach Bottos 3- 1035 MechD (0.2 Susquehanna R. I 1974
- Pe ry 2 1205 NatD (0.01 Lake Erie 3 E19??
Perry 1 1205 NatD (0.01 Lake Erit 3 E1986 Frairie Island 1 503 MechD (0.2 Mississippi R. 3 1973 Frairie Island 2 500 MechD (0.2 Mississippi R. 3 1974 Rancho Seco 873 NatD -(0.01 Folsoe South Canal 5 1975 River Bend _
934 CircMech 0.01 Mississippi 4 E1986
-Sequoyah 2 !!48 NatD 0.01 Tennessee R. 2 1982 Sequoyah. I !!28 NatD 0.01 Tennessee R. _ 2 1981 Susquehanna 1 1052 NatD 0.002 Susquehanna R. 1 E198?
Vogtle 1 1100 NatD 0.000 Savannah R. 2- E1987
. Vogtle. 2- 1100 NatD 0.006 Savannah R. 2 E19??
~
bi