ML061560055
| ML061560055 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Oyster Creek |
| Issue date: | 06/02/2006 |
| From: | Young M A NRC/OGC |
| To: | Abramson P B, Baratta A J, Hawkens E R Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| Young M A, NRC/OGC, 301-415-1523 | |
| References | |
| 50-219-LR, ASLBP 06-844-01-LR, RAS 11710 | |
| Download: ML061560055 (29) | |
Text
June 2, 2006Administrative Judge E. Roy Hawkens, ChairAtomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop: T-3F23 Washington, DC 20555-0001Administrative Judge Paul B. AbramsonAtomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop: T-3F23 Washington, DC 20555-0001Administrative Judge Anthony J. BarattaAtomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop: T-3F23 Washington, DC 20555-0001In the Matter ofAMERGEN ENERGY COMPANY, LLC(License Renewal for Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station) Docket No. 50-219-LR
Dear Administrative Judges:
Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.1203(c), the staff of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("Staff")herein notifies the Licensing Board and the parties that it has updated the Hearing File for thisproceeding in accordance with 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(d) and the Board's Memorandum and Order of April 19, 2006. Materials in this June 2, 2006 Supplement may be accessed through the Agencywide Documents Access and Management System ("ADAMS"). An index containing the ADAMS accession number, date, and title or description of each item in this supplement is appended hereto as Attachment 1. In addition, on or about Friday, June 2, 2006, materials inthe June 2 Supplement will be made available via the Electronic Hearing Docket ("EHD"), whichmay be accessed at the following URL: http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/ehd.html/. Materials inSupplement 2 will be contained in a sub-folder entitled, "Hearing File Supplement 2" in the"Oyster Creek 50-219-LR" folder of the EHD.The Staff is also updating its privilege logs at this time, which are appended hereto asAttachments 2 and 3. The Staff will preserve and maintain all privileged documents during thependency of this proceeding. Also attached, as required by 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(c), are the Affidavit of Donnie J. Ashley and the Declaration of Frank Gillespie.It has come to my attention that in the deliberative process log (Attachment 2 to the Staff'sApril 3, 2006, letter), at pages 4 and 32, a non-privileged document was inadvertently included and an NRC Foreign Assignee was improperly identified. Enclosed as Attachment 4 arecorrected pages for the April 3, 2006 deliberative process log. As requested by the Board, the Staff hereby provides notice that there is no change in theschedule of proposed dates of issuance for the draft SEIS, the SER with open items, the Final SER, or the Final SEIS.Sincerely,/RA/Mitzi A. YoungCounsel for NRC Staff
Enclosures:
Attachment 1: Hearing File Index - Supplement 2Attachment 2: Privilege Log - Deliberative Process- Supplement 2 Declaration of Frank Gillespie : Privilege Log - Attorney-Client Communications - Supplement 2Affidavit of Donnie J. Ashley : April 3, 2006 Deliberative Process Log (6/2/06 Corrected Pages 4
and 32)cc:Service List Page 1 of 5ATTACHMENT 1OYSTER CREEK HEARING FILE AND MANDATORY DISCLOSURESHEARING FILE INDEXSupplement 2 -June 2, 2006SuppNo.Accession NumberDocument DateTitle/Description:02-1ML0607403548/17/2005E-mail: Long Range Planning Question (PD).02-2ML0615103004/3/2006E-mail: Drywell Q & As (PA).02-3ML0615102994/4/2006E-mail: Commitment letter- OC Containment items (PA).02-4ML0609702884/4/2006Oyster Creek, Commitments Associated with Containment (Drywell and Torus)Condition Monitoring Related to AmerGen Application for Renewed OperatingLicense.02-5ML0615102984/5/2006E-mail: RE: Audit Q & A (Question Numbers AMP-141, 210, 356) (PA).02-6ML0615102954/5/2006Email: RE: Audit Q & A ( Question Numbers AMP-141, 210, 356)02-7ML0615102944/5/2006Email: RE: Audit Q & A (Question Numbers AMP-141, 210, 356).02-8ML0615102744/7/2006E-mail: RAI response 4/7/06 (LRA Section 4.7) (PA).02-9ML0615102814/7/2006E-mail: RAI response 4/7/06 (LRA Section 4.7) (PA).02-10ML0615102804/7/2006E-mail: RAI response 4/7/06 - Attachment 1-B.pdf (PA).02-11ML0615102964/7/2006E-mail: RAI response 4/7/06 - Attachment 1-C.pdf (PA).02-12ML0615103014/7/2006E-mail: RAI response 4/7/06 - Attachment 1-D.pdf (PA).02-13ML0615102614/7/2006Email: RAI Response 4/7/06 (LRA Section 4.7) (PA)02-14ML0615102884/7/2006Email: RAI response 4/7/06 (LRA Section B.1.12, B.2.3, 2.3 & 3.3).02-15ML0615102714/7/2006Email: RAI Response 4/7/06 - Attachment 1-A (PA)
SuppNo.Accession NumberDocument DateTitle/Description:Page 2 of 502-16ML0610102424/7/2006Oyster Creek - Response to NRC Request for Additional Information, dated March10, 2006, Related to License Renewal Application.02-17ML0609605634/7/2006Oyster Creek, License Renewal AMP-AMR Audit Questions AMP-141, AMP-356,AMP-210 Set 1 and Cover Email.02-18ML0609605684/7/2006Oyster Creek, License Renewal AMP-AMR Audit Questions AMP-210 Set 2.02-19ML0609606024/7/2006Oyster Creek, License Renewal AMP-AMR Audit Questions AMP-210 Set 3.02-20ML0610206374/7/2006Response to NRC Request for Additional Information, dated March 10, 2006, Relatedto Oyster Creek License Renewal Application.02-21ML0609704634/7/2006Transware Request for Withholding Information from Public Disclosure for FluenceEvaluation for Oyster Creek Reactor Pressure Vessel for the Oyster Creek NuclearGenerating Station, License Renewal Application (TAC No. MC7624).02-22ML0605902604/10/20062006/04/10-Summary of Telephone Conference Call Held 02/02/2006, Between theU.S. NRC & AmerGen Energy Company, LLC, Concerning Draft Request forAdditional Information Pertaining to Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station,License Renewal Application.02-23ML0615102474/12/2006E-mail: Update to Drywell related response AMP-141.02-24ML0610304194/12/2006Oyster Creek, License Renewal AMP-AMR Audit Questions update to AMP QuestionAMP-141.02-25ML0615102454/13/2006Email: Request to add to database.02-26ML0611601944/17/2006Email from T. Allison, Argonne National Laboratory, to M. Masnik,
Subject:
"Housinggrowth controls in Lacey Township", April 17, 2006.02-27ML0615102434/17/2006Email: Audit Follow-up Letter.02-28ML0611503204/17/2006Oyster Creek - Responses to Action Items Associated with Plant License RenewalAudits.
SuppNo.Accession NumberDocument DateTitle/Description:Page 3 of 502-29ML0614300644/17/2006Email: Housing Growth Controls in Ocean County (PD).02-30ML0614303884/17/2006Email: OCGNS Employee Locations (PD).02-31ML0614300614/17/2006Email: OCGNS Taxes and Local Tax Revenues (PD).02-32ML0611103394/18/2006AmerGen, Response to Request for Additional Information - Application to UseWeighting Factors for External Exposure.02-33ML0615102544/18/2006E-mail: 2130-06-20298 Response to RAI on 2.5.2 (PA)02-34ML0615102364/18/2006Email: 2130-06-20298 Response to RAI on 2.4 & 3.5 (PA)02-35ML0615102404/18/2006Email: 2130-06-20298 response to RAI on 3.1, & B.1-23 (PA).02-36ML0614200864/18/2006Email: FWD: Oyster Creek Non-Routine Environmental Operating Report (PA)02-37ML0611001294/18/2006Oyster Creek - Response to NRC Request for Additional Information, dated March20, 2006, related to Oyster Creek License Renewal Application (TAC No. MC7624).02-38ML0611001274/18/2006Oyster Creek - Response to NRC Request for Additional Information, dated March 20, 2006.02-39ML0611001384/18/2006Oyster Creek, Response to NRC Request for Additional Information, dated March 20,2006, Related to License Renewal Application.02-40ML0611001314/20/2006Request for Additional Information for the Review of th Oyster Creek NuclearGenerating Station, License Renewal Application (TAC MC7624) - ApplicationSections 3.6.202-41ML0611504794/24/2006E-mail from T. Allison, Argonne National Laboratory to M. Masnik,
Subject:
"Communication with David McKeon", April 24, 2006.02-42ML0611504554/24/2006E-mail from T. Allison, Argonne National Laboratory, to M. Masnik,
Subject:
"Conversation with Alan Avery", April 24, 2006.
SuppNo.Accession NumberDocument DateTitle/Description:Page 4 of 502-43ML0611504494/24/2006E-mail from T. Allison, Argonne National Laboratory, to M. Masnik,
Subject:
"Conversation with W. Maher", April 24, 2006.02-44ML0611505724/24/2006Email from T. Allison, Argonne National Laboratory, to M. Masnik, "Conversation withW. Maher", with Attachment Containing Employee Residence Location Data, April 24, 2006.02-45ML0614201064/24/2006Email: Highlights from RLRC (PA).02-46ML0611503304/24/2006Oyster Creek, License Renewal AMP-AMR Audit Questions update AMP-071, AMP-204, AMP-072 and others.02-47ML0614204844/24/2006Email: Communication with David McKeon (PD).02-48ML0614202054/24/2006Email: Conversation with W. Maher (PD).02-49ML0615004424/24/2006Email: Questions to go over tomorrow (PD).02-50ML0611601614/25/2006Oyster Creek, License Renewal AMP-AMR Audit Questions Update AMP-072 andAMP-358.02-51ML0615102494/26/2006Email: 2130-06-20298 response to RAI on 4.2 & 4.7.02-52ML0612101144/26/2006Oyster Creek - Response to NRC Request for Additional Information, datedMarch 30, 2006, Related to Plant License Renewal Application.02-53ML0615102394/28/2006Email: Response to "Mechanical" RAI set (NRC Letter March 30, 2006).02-54ML0612203064/28/2006Oyster Creek, Response to NRC Request for Additional Information, dated March 30,2006, related to Plant License Renewal Application.02-55ML0615102245/1/2006Email: RAI Response on Fatigue or Rebar Corrosion (PA)02-56ML0612401715/1/2006Oyster Creek Generating Station - Supplemental Commitments Associated withAmerGen Application for Renewed Operating License - (TAC MC7624).
SuppNo.Accession NumberDocument DateTitle/Description:Page 5 of 502-57ML0612402175/1/2006Response to NRC Request for Additional Information, dated March 30, 2006, Relatedto Oyster Creek License Renewal Application (TAC No. MC7624).02-58ML0615004495/1/2006Email: Question to the Applicant (PD).02-59ML0615102205/2/2006Email: Oyster Creek, Response to NRC Request for Additional Information, datedMarch 20, 2006, Related to P (PA)02-60ML0615102145/2/2006Email: Supplemental Commitments Letter (PA)02-61ML0612501725/3/2006Oyster Creek - Supplemental Response to NRC Request for Additional Information,dated March 20, 2006, related to Plant License Renewal Application.02-62ML0613806475/3/2006E-mail: Commitment (PD).02-63ML0615100955/3/2006Email: Notes (PD)02-64ML0611200035/3/2006Federal Register Notice w/ attachments - re: Proposed License Renewal Interim StaffGuidance LR-ISG-2006-01: Plant-Specific Aging Management Program forInaccessible Areas of Boiling Water Reactor Mark I Steel Containment Drywell Shell -Public Comment02-65ML0615102125/4/2006Email: Oyster Creek Generating Station - Supplemental Commitments Associatedwith Amergen Application for R (PA)02-66ML0614200895/5/2006Email: OCNGS Reporting Requirements for ESA (PA)02-67ML0613101395/9/2006Oyster Creek - Response to NRC Request for Additional Information, dated April 20, 2006.02-68ML0613801095/15/2006Oyster Creek - Supplemental Information for Response to NRC Request forAdditional Information, dated March 30, 2006, Related to Plant License RenewalApplication.02-69ML0615003395/15/2006Email: Supplemental letter w/ Upper Shelf Energy Info - RAI 4.2.2-1.
Page 1 of 14ATTACHMENT 2OYSTER CREEK HEARING FILE AND MANDATORY DISCLOSURESPRIVILEGE LOG - DELIBERATIVE PROCESS PRIVILEGESupplement 2 - June 2, 2006Certain documents otherwise subject to inclusion in the hearing file and mandatory disclosures for this proceeding have been determined by the NRCStaff to contain information subject to withholding from public disclosure as predecisional, deliberative information. Pursuant to 10 C.F.R.§ 2.336(b)(5), the Staff is providing this log to identify the following documents withheld under the "deliberative process" privilege.PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountDP-02-1ML061530265Lagory KANL; Allison TANLEmails To and FromLagory, Kirk (March29- April 27) To NRCLicense RenewalEnvironmental StafffRegarding OCNGS 3/29/2006-4/27/2006E-MailLagory KArgonneNational Lab(ANL); Allison TANL Lazaro, MANLContractorcomments on draftinput for the SEIS.
5DP-02-2ML060970575Shum D H, NRCE-mail: SER Input forOyster Creek LRA(PD).4/3/2006E-Mail,SafetyEvaluationReportAshley D J, NRCProvides draft inputfor SER.62DP-02-3ML061430049Ward J A,PacificNational LabEmail: RE: EFHImpact Levels (PD)4/3/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Nash H L, ANL, NRCIncludes contractorcomments to Staffre: SEIS review.
3 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 2 of 14DP-02-4ML061430050Nash H L, NRCEmail: RE: EFHImpact Levels (PD)4/3/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Ward J A,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL), PacificNational LabStaff-contractordiscussions ofSEIS review.
3DP-02-5ML061430053Ward J A,PacificNational LabEmail: RE: EFHImpact Levels (PD)4/3/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Nash H L,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL),NRC/NRRStaff-contractordiscussions ofSEIS review.
6DP-02-6ML061430054Ward J A,BattelleMemorialInstitute,PacificNorthwestNational LabEmail: RE: EFHImpact Levels (PD)4/4/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Nash H L,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL), NRCStaff-contractordiscussions ofSEIS review.
9DP-02-7ML060950699Cranston G V,NRC/NRR/ADES/DSS/SBWBOyster Creek:License RenewalApplication, VesselFluence for 50 EFPYof Operation (TACNo. MC7624).4/5/2006MemorandaLund A L,NRC/NRR/ADRO/DORLProvides draft inputfor SER review.
3 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 3 of 14DP-02-8ML061070414Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)EMAIL: RE:Reconciliation (PD)4/5/2006E-MailMathew R K, NRCStaff-contractordiscussions ofSEIS review.
2DP-02-9ML061070423Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)EMAIL: SectionA7.3.3 of the OCGSAudit Report (PD)4/5/2006E-MailMathew R K, NRCProvides draft inputfor audit report.
9DP-02-10ML061070409Morante R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)EMAIL:FWD:BWRVIP-25InspectionRequirements (PD)4/6/2006E-MailMathew R K, NRCStaff-contractordiscussions ofSEIS review.
3DP-02-11ML061070416Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)EMAIL: OCGS AMPB.1.31 Write-up (PD)4/6/2006E-MailMathew R K, NRCProvides draft inputfor audit report.
19DP-02-12ML061070427Mathew RK, NRCEMAIL: ElectricalSection - PeerReview Comments(PD)4/6/2006E-MailLofaro R J,BrookhavenNational Lab(BNL)Provides draft inputfor audit report.
17DP-02-13ML061070407Morante R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: OCGSContainmentDegradation Q/R No.AMR-164 (PD)4/11/2006E-MailAshar H G, NRCDiscusses auditreport review.
5 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 4 of 14DP-02-14ML061430047LaGory KE, ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: RE: AirQuality - OysterCreek (PD)4/11/2006E-MailKeto E M,Masnik M T,NRC/NRRStaff-contractordiscussions ofSEIS review.
4DP-02-15ML061070411Morante R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)EMAIL: RE: ExitMeeting (PD)4/12/2006E-MailMathew R K, NRCStaff-contractordiscussions ofaudit review.
2DP-02-16ML061380390Morante R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: OCGS -Applicant responseto AMR - 356 (PD).4/12/2006E-MailAshar H G,Chang K C,Mathew R K,NRC/NRR/ADES/DE,NRC/NRR/ADRO/DLRProvides questionsand views re:applicant response.
2DP-02-17ML061500379Davis J A, NRCEmail: New Questionfor Q & A Data Base.4/13/2006E-MailAshley D J, NRCProvides draftquestions fordatabase.3DP-02-18ML061430071LaGory KE, ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: RE: OysterCreek Followupquestions (PD).4/17/2006E-MailMasnik M T,Nash H L,NRC/NRRStaff-contractordiscussions ofSEIS review.
3DP-02-19ML061430074Masnik M T,NRC/NRREmail: RE: VisualAesthetics (PD)4/17/2006E-MailKeto E M,LaGory K E,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL)Staff-contractordiscussions of draftSEIS.2 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 5 of 14DP-02-20ML061430107Masnik M T,NRC/NRREmail: Oyster CreekFollowupquestions/comments#1 (PD)4/17/2006E-MailLaGory K E,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL)Staff-contractordiscussions of draftSEIS.2DP-02-21ML061430115Masnik M T,NRC/NRREmail: RE: OCQuestion/Comment 2(PD)4/17/2006E-MailLaGory K E,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL)Staff guidance re:documentation ofSEIS review.
3DP-02-22ML061430122Masnik MT, NRCEmail: RE: OCQuestion 4 (with 5Subquestions) (PD)4/17/2006E-MailLaGory K E,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL)Questions for SEISreview.3DP-02-23ML061430400Keto E M, NRCEmail: TurbineAcreage (PD).4/17/2006E-MailMasnik M T, NRCDiscussion of SEISreview.2DP-02-24ML061430403Keto E M, NRCEmail: TitaniumTubes (PD).4/17/2006E-MailMasnik M T, NRCDiscussion of SEISreview.2DP-02-25ML061430407Nash H L, NRCEmail: RE: OysterCreek (PD)4/17/2006E-MailMasnik M T, NRCDiscussion of draftSEIS.2DP-02-26ML061420212Masnik MT, NRCEmail: Oyster CreekQuestion 5 (PD)4/18/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Ward J A,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL), PacificNational LabStaff comment ondraft SEIS review.
2 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 6 of 14DP-02-27ML061430085Ward J A,PacificNational LabEmail: RE: OysterCreek question 5(PD)4/18/2006E-MailMasnik M T,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL),NRC/NRRStaff-contractordiscussion of SEISreview(entrainment andimpingement).
2DP-02-28ML061430395Masnik MT, NRCEmail: RE: OysterCreek (PD).4/18/2006E-MailKeto E M, NRCStaff-contractordiscussion of SEISreview.2DP-02-29ML061380483Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: Peer ReviewComments on OCGSAudit Report (PD)4/19/2006E-MailMathew R K,Morante R J,BrookhavenNational Lab(BNL), NRCComments oninputs to draft auditreport.1DP-02-30ML061420206Wescott KL, ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: RE: Emailing:Revised wind_April14 2006.wpd (PD)4/19/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Masnik M T,Pham B M,Schaaf R G,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL), NRCStaff-contractordiscussion of SEISreview.4DP-02-31ML061420208Lazaro M A,ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: RE: OysterCreek Question 7(PD)4/19/2006E-MailMasnik M T, NRCStaff-contractordiscussion of draftinput to SEISreview.3 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 7 of 14DP-02-32ML061440325Wescott KL, ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: RE: OysterCreek Question 6 (CNU)4/19/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Masnik M T,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL), NRCComments on draftinput to SEISreview.2DP-02-33ML061420218Lazaro M A,ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: RE: OysterCreek Question 7(PD)4/20/2006E-MailMasnik M T, NRCStaff-contractordiscussion of draftinput to SEISreview.3DP-02-34ML061420199Ward J A,BattelleMemorialInstitute,PacificNorthwestNational LabEmail: RE: EFHQuestions (PD).4/21/2006E-MailMasnik M T, NRCStaff-contractordiscussion of draftinput to SEISreview(impingement).
4DP-02-35ML061420481Ward J A,BattelleMemorialInstitute,PacificNorthwestNational LabEmail: RE: OysterCreek Question.(PD).4/21/2006E-MailMasnik M T,NRC/NRRStaff-contractordiscussion of draftinput to SEISreview.2DP-02-36ML061440328Nash H L, NRCEmail: RE: OCDischarge Question (CNU)4/21/2006E-MailMasnik M T, NRCDiscussion of SEISreview topic.
2 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 8 of 14DP-02-37ML061500327CheruvenkiG S, NRCE-mail: AdditionalRAIs on IsoCondenser (PD).4/21/2006E-MailAshley D J, NRCStaff discussion ofdraft input for auditreview.4DP-02-38ML061420472Ward J A,BattelleMemorialInstitute,PacificNorthwestNational LabEmail: RE: EFH &egg entrainment(PD).4/23/2006E-MailNash H L,NRC/NRRStaff-contractordiscussion of SEISreview.2DP-02-39ML061420203LaGory KE, ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: Re: OCQuestion 9 (PD).4/24/2006E-MailMasnik M T, NRCStaff-contractorcomment on draftinput to SEISreview.2DP-02-40ML061420216Nash H L, NRCEmail: RE: OysterCreek (PD)4/24/2006E-MailMasnik M T,Discusses draftinput for SEISreview.2DP-02-41ML061420219Ward J A,BattelleMemorialInstitute,PacificNorthwestNational LabEmail: RE: OCQuestion 9 (PD).4/24/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Masnik M T,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL), NRCStaff-contractordiscussion of draftinput to SEISreview.3 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 9 of 14DP-02-42ML061420221LaGory KE, ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: RE: OysterCreek Question 8(PD).4/24/2006E-MailMasnik M T, NRCDiscusses draftinput for SEISreview.3DP-02-43ML061420485LaGory KE, ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: RE: OCQuestion 9 (PD).4/24/2006E-MailMasnik M T,Ward J A,BattelleMemorialInstitute, PacificNorthwestNational Lab,NRC/NRRProvidescomments on draftinput to SEISreview.3DP-02-44ML061420487Masnik M T,NRC/NRREmail: RE: OysterCreek FollowupQuestions/Comments #1 (PD).4/24/2006E-MailMonette F A,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL)Discusses draftinput for SEISreview.3DP-02-45ML061420501Nash H L,NRC/NRREmail: RE: OC EFHeggs (PD).4/24/2006E-MailMasnik M T,NRC/NRRDiscusses revisionto draft input forSEIS review.
2DP-02-46ML061510264Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: OCGS AuditReport.4/24/2006Audit Report,E-MailMathew R K, NRCProvides draft inputfor SEIS review.
52 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 10 of 14DP-02-47ML061420247Masnik MT, NRCEmail: RE: OCQuestion (PD)4/25/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Ward J A,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL), PacificNational LabStaff-contractordiscussion of draftinput for SEISreview.3DP-02-48ML061380644Morante R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)E-mail: RE:Comments on OCGSAMP B.1.33 (PD).5/2/2006E-MailLofaro R J,BrookhavenNational Lab(BNL)Contractordiscussion of draftinput for auditreview.3DP-02-49ML061420252Pham, B NRCE-mail: Questionabout OCNGSDSEIS chapter 85/2/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Wescott KL,ANLStaff-contractordiscussion of draftinput for SEISreview.2DP-02-50ML061380486Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: OCGS AuditReport Section 3.5(PD)5/3/2006E-MailMathew R K, NRCProvides draft inputfor audit review.
49DP-02-51ML061510275Mathew RK, NRCEmail: RPT.5/3/2006E-MailLofaro R,BrookhavenNational Lab(BNL)Provides draft inputfor audit review.
8DP-02-52ML061420517Mathew R K,NRC/NRREmail: FWD: RevisedOCGS B.1.27 andB.1.33 (PD).5/4/2006E-MailAshar H G,NRC/NRRProvides draft inputfor audit review.
56 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 11 of 14DP-02-53ML061290151Bloomer T E,NRC/NRR/ADES/DCI/CSGBOyster CreekGenerating Station,Unit 1 - SafetyEvaluation OfLicense RenewalApplicationRegarding GeneratorStator WaterChemistry And BoralNeutron AbsorbingMaterial In SpentFuel Racks.5/5/2006Memoranda,SafetyEvaluation Lund L A,NRC/NRR/ADRO/DLRProvides draft inputfor SER review.
6DP-02-54ML061500329ParczewskiK I, NRCEmail: SER forOyster Creek (PD)5/5/2006E-Mail,Memoranda,SafetyEvaluationAshley D J, NRCProvides draft inputfor SER review.
9DP-02-55ML061500332Mathew RK, NRCEmail: SER Input -pkg. 37.5/5/2006E-MailAshley D J, NRCProvides draft inputfor SER.3DP-02-56ML061420353Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: DraftExecutive Summaryfor the OCGS AuditReport (PD)5/8/2006E-MailMathew R K,NRC/NRRProvides draft inputfor audit report.
9DP-02-57ML061420254LaGory KE, ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: RE: OysterCreek Question 10(PD).5/9/2006E-MailMasnik M T,Ward J A,NRC, PacificNational LabStaff-contractordiscussion of draftinput for SEISreview.2 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 12 of 14DP-02-58ML061420270Masnik M T,NRC/NRREmail: RE: LastQuestion(Number11) (PD)5/9/2006E-MailLaGory K E, Staff-contractordiscussion of draftinput for SEISreview.2DP-02-59ML061420271Masnik MT, NRCEmail: RE: Wordingon EJ-Question12(PD)5/9/2006E-MailLaGory K E,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL)Discusses revisionof draft input forSEIS review.
2DP-02-60ML061420272Ward J A,BattelleMemorialInstitute,PacificNorthwestNational LabEmail: RE: OysterCreek Question 10(PD).5/9/2006E-MailLaGory K E,Masnik M T,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL), NRCStaff-contractordiscussion ofrevision to draftinput for SEISreview.2DP-02-61ML061420279Ward J A,NRC/NMSSEmail: RE: LastQuestion(Number11) (PD)5/9/2006E-MailMasnik M T,NRC/NRRStaff-contractordiscussion ofrevision to draftinput for SEISreview.2DP-02-62ML061420282LaGory KE, ArgonneNationalLab (ANL)Email: FW: LastQuestion(Number11) (PD)5/9/2006E-MailMasnik M T, NRCStaff-contractordiscussion ofrevision to draftinput for SEISreview.3 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 13 of 14DP-02-63ML061420285Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: RevisedOCGS Audit Report(PD)5/9/2006(attaches4/21 draft)E-MailMathew R K, NRCProvides draft inputfor audit review.
2DP-02-64ML061420342Morante R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: MPR-953(PD)5/9/2006E-MailLofaro R J,Mathew R K,BrookhavenNational Lab(BNL),NRC/NRRContractordiscussion of draftinput for auditreview.2DP-02-65ML061420343Morante R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: RE: RevisedOCGS Audit Report(PD).5/10/2006E-MailLofaro R J,Mathew R K,BrookhavenNational Lab(BNL),NRC/NRRStaff-contractordiscussion of draftinput for auditreview.3DP-02-66ML061420099Masnik M T,NRC/NRREmail: Another QACheck5/10/2006E-MailKeto E M, NRCStaff discussion ofdraft input for auditreview.2DP-02-67ML061420349Morante RJ, - NoKnownAffiliationEmail: RE: RevisedOCGS Audit Report5/10/2006E-MailLofaro R J,Mathew R K,BrookhavenNational Lab(BNL),NRC/NRRProvidescomments on draftinput for auditreview.3 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountPage 14 of 14DP-02-68ML061420350Morante R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: RE: RevisedOCGS Audit Report(PD).5/10/2006E-MailLofaro R J,Mathew R K,BrookhavenNational Lab(BNL),NRC/NRRContractor-staffdiscussion ofrevision to draftinput for auditreview.3DP-02-69ML061420354Masnik M T,NRC/NRREmail: RE: OysterCreek Question 13(PD).5/10/2006E-MailLaGory K E,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL)Staff-contractordiscussion of draftinput for SEISreview.2DP-02-70ML061420346Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: Draft OCGSSER Section 3.6(PD)5/11/2006E-MailMathew R K, NRCProvidescomments anddraft input for SERreview.12DP-02-71ML061420508Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: OCGS SerInput - Draft Sections3.1 & 3.2 (PD).5/12/2006E-Mail,SafetyEvaluationMathew R K,NRC/NRRProvides draft inputfor SER review.
55DP-02-72ML061510309Lofaro R J,BrookhavenNationalLab (BNL)Email: OCGS SERInput - Draft Sections 3.1 and 3.2.5/12/2006E-MailMathew R K, NRCProvidescomments anddraft input for SERreview.55DP-02-73ML061420347Chang K C,NRC/NRREmail: RE: PleaseTake A look at it.(PD)5/14/2006E-MailMathew R K,NRC/NRRDiscussescomments re: draftinput for auditreview.3 June 1, 2006UNITED STATES OF AMERICANUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSIONBEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARDIn the Matter of)
)AMERGEN ENERGY COMPANY, LLC)Docket No. 50-219-LR
)(License Renewal for Oyster Creek)
Nuclear Generating Station))DECLARATION OF FRANK GILLESPIEI, Frank Gillespie, do hereby state as follows:1. I am employed as the Director of the Division of Licensing Renewal ("DLR") inthe Nuclear Regulatory Commission's ("NRC") Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation ("NRR"). My supervisory responsibilities include oversight of the NRC Staff's review and evaluation of theOyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station license renewal application.2. As part of their responsibilities in preparing the hearing file and mandatorydisclosures for these proceedings, NRC staff members under my supervision identified severaldocuments as privileged because they contained information concerning the Staff's deliberativeprocess. Those documents are listed in Attachment 2 to the June 2, 2006, submission ofSupplement 2 to the Staff's Hearing File.3. I have personally reviewed the 73 documents identified as privileged inAttachment 2, and have determined, in accordance with the guidance set forth in Management Directive 3.4, that they contain predecisional information concerning the Staff's review of thelicense renewal application. All documents contain either the Staff's analyses,recommendations, opinions, or evaluations, and may not necessarily reflect the final agency position with respect to the matters discussed therein. Each of the documents comprises part of the deliberative process necessary to the Staff's review of the pending license renewalapplication.4. Further, I have determined that disclosure of the 73 documents could result inharm to the agency, in that it would (a) prematurely disclose the preliminary views of individual Staff members and/or the Staff prior to reaching a final agency decision, and could thus createconfusion as to the actual policy or views of the NRC Staff; (b) hinder the efficiency of the Staff,in that forced disclosure of its internal discussions on an unresolved issue would tend to chill allfuture deliberations and would interfere with the Staff's ability to engage in a free exchange ofopinions and analyses prior to publishing its final review documents; and (c) imply or suggest incorrectly that the opinions of the Staff members involved in these communications are actuallythe final decisions of the agency, while no such final decision has yet been made.5. Accordingly, I formally invoke the deliberative process privilege with respect toeach of the 73 documents listed in Attachment 2 to the June 2, 2006, submission ofSupplement 2 to the Staff's Hearing File.6. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct to thebest of my knowledge, information and belief. /Original Signed By?
Frank GillespieExecuted in Rockville, MDthis 1 st day of June, 2006.
ATTACHMENT 3OYSTER CREEK HEARING FILE AND MANDATORY DISCLOSURESPRIVILEGE LOG - ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGESupplement 2 -June 2, 2006Certain documents otherwise subject to inclusion in the hearing file and mandatory disclosures for this proceeding have been determinedby the NRC Staff to contain information subject to withholding from public disclosure as attorney-client communications. Pursuant to 10C.F.R.§ 2.336(b)(5), the Staff is providing this log to identify the following document withheld under the "attorney-client" privilege.PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountAC-02-1ML061450007Nash H L, NRCEmail: OCNGS BORequirements (AC).5/9/2006E-MailMasnik M T,Moore J E, NRCCommunication tocounsel for thepurpose of seekingadvice.2 June 2, 2006UNITED STATES OF AMERICANUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSIONBEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARDIn the Matter of)
)AMERGEN ENERGY COMPANY, LLC)Docket No. 50-219-LR
)(License Renewal for Oyster Creek)
Nuclear Generating Station))AFFIDAVIT OF DONNIE J. ASHLEY CONCERNING MANDATORY DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT OF 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(c) I, Donnie J. Ashley, do hereby state as follows:1.I am employed as a Project Manager in the Division of License Renewal in the NuclearRegulatory Commission's ("NRC") Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation. I serve as a projectmanager for the Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station's license renewal application ("LRA"). Among other things, I am managing the preparation of the hearing file and mandatory disclosures in connection with the LRA at issue in this proceeding.2.I hereby certify that all relevant materials required to be disclosed pursuant to10 C.F.R. § 2.336 (b) and (c) in the captioned proceeding have been disclosed, and that thedisclosures are accurate and complete as of the date of this certification.3.I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct to the best ofmy knowledge, information and belief.
/Original Signed By
/_______________________Donnie J. AshleyExecuted in Rockville, MDthis 2nd day of June, 2006. ATTACHMENT 4
- April 3, 2006 Deliberative Process Log (6/2/06 Corrected Pages 4 and 32)PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage CountDP-00-15ML0608005 96Masnik M T, NRCE-mail: Oyster CreekEnvironmental Review(PD)08/08/2005E-MailAshley D J,Eads J H, NRCDiscusses Staff'sreview of OysterCreekEnvironmentalReport 2DP-00-16ML0608006 33LaGory K E,ArgonneNational Lab(ANL)E-mail: FW: OysterCreek AcceptanceReview (PD)08/15/2005E-MailMasnik M T, NRCIdentifiesinformation needsto reviewEnvironmentalReport 11DP-00-17ML0607403 54Hufnagel J,Exelon CorpE-mail: Long RangePlanning Question(PD).08/17/2005E-MailAshley D J, NRCInquires aboutschedule for CLBchanges 2DP-00-18ML0607403 52Zimmerman JI, NRCE-mail: FWD: RE:Oyster Creek (PD).08/19/2005E-MailCranston G V,Tran L N, NRCDiscusses plan forreview of buriedcables 2DP-00-19ML0523402 84Dyer J E,NRC/NRRMemo to W. Outlawfrom J. E. Dyer -Communication Planfor the Oyster CreekNuclear GeneratingStation LicenseRenewal ApplicationReview (Tac Nos.MC7624 andMC7625).08/23/2005MemorandaOutlaw W N, NRCPlan forcommunicatingwith public aboutlicense renewal 22 PDPNo.AccessionNumberAuthorName/Affiliation:Title/Description:DocumentDateDocumentTypeAddressee /AddresseeAffiliationCommentPage Count- 32 -DP-00-141ML0605200 33Manoly K A,NRC/NRR/ADES/DE/EEM BRequest for AdditionalInformation (RAI)Regarding TimeLimited AgingAnalyses for theOyster CreekGenerating StationLicense RenewalApplication.02/15/2006Memoranda, RequestforAdditionalInformation(RAI)Lund L A,NRC/NRR/ADRO/DLR/REBAPreliminary draft ofStaff Request forAdditionalInformation (RAI)concerning licenserenewal application 4DP-00-142ML0608100 40Green K, ISL,IncE-mail: NRC Contract03-03-038, TaskOrder 17, Sub-task 6(PD)02/17/2006E-MailShum D H, NRCCommunicationbetween Staff andcontractorconcerninganalysis in draftSafety Evaluation 56DP-00-143ML0607505 94Tanabe K, -No KnownAffiliationForeignAssignee to NRC E-mail: OCGS_List ofDocuments (PD)02/21/2006AuditReport, E-MailMathew R K, NRCCommunicationbetween Staff andcontractorconcerning draftinput to AuditReport 45DP-00-144ML0607506 82Green K, ISL,IncE-Mail: NRC Contract03-03-038, TaskOrder 20, Sub-task A-2 "Updated TER forOyster Creek" (PD)02/22/2006E-MailPalla R L, NRCCommunicationbetween Staff andcontractorconcerning draftinput to OC SEIS 35 UNITED STATES OF AMERICANUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSIONBEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARDIn the Matter of)
)AMERGEN ENERGY COMPANY, LLC)Docket No. 50-219-LR
)(Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station))CERTIFICATE OF SERVICEI hereby certify that copies of the NRC Staff letter dated June 2, 2006, providing notice of theavailability of Supplement 2 to the hearing file, with attachments, together with the affidavit ofDonnie Ashley and the declaration of Frank Gillespie in the above-captioned proceeding havebeen served on the following by electronic mail with copies by deposit in the NRC's internal mailsystem or, as indicated by an asterisk, by electronic mail, with copies by U.S. mail, first class,this 2nd day of June, 2006.E. Roy Hawkens, ChairAdministrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop: T-3F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 ERH@nrc.govAnthony J. BarattaAdministrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop: T-3F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 AJB5@nrc.govPaul B. AbramsonAdministrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop: T-3F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 PBA@nrc.govOffice of the SecretaryATTN: Docketing and Service Mail Stop: O-16C1 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 HEARINGDOCKET@nrc.govOffice of Commission Appellate Adjudication U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 OCAAMail@nrc.govDebra WolfLaw Clerk Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Mail Stop: T-3F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 DAW1@nrc.govLisa P. Jackson, Acting Commissioner*New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection
P.O. Box 402 Trenton, NJ 08625-0402 Lisa.Jackson@dep.state.nj.us Jill Lipoti, Director*New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection Division of Environmental Safety and Health
P.O. Box 424 Trenton, NJ 08625-0424 Jill.Lipoti@dep.state.nj.usKathryn M. Sutton, Esq.*Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP 1111 Pennsylvania Ave., NW Washington, DC 20004 ksutton@morganlewis.comRon Zak*New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection Nuclear Engineering
P.O. Box 415 Trenton, NJ 08625-0415 Ron.Zak@dep.state.nj.usSuzanne Leta*New Jersey Public Interest Research Group 11 N. Willow St.
Trenton, NJ 08608 sleta@njpirg.orgDonald Silverman, Esq.*Morgan, Lewis, & Bockius LLP 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20004 dsilverman@morganlewis.comAlex S. Polonsky, Esq.*Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP 1111 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
Washington, DC 20004 apolonsky@morganlewis.comPaul Gunter, Director*Reactor Watchdog Project Nuclear Information And Resource Service
1424 16 th Street, NW, Suite 404Washington, DC 20036 pgunter@nirs.orgJ. Bradley Fewell, Esq.*Exelon Corporation 200 Exelon Way, Suite 200 Kennett Square, PA 19348 bradley.fewell@exeloncorp.comJohn A. Covino, Esq.*Valerie Anne Gray, Esq.
Deputy Attorneys General Division of Law Environmental Permitting and Counseling Section Hughes Justice Complex
P.O. Box 093 Trenton, NJ 08625 john.covino@dol.lps.state.nj.us Valerie.Gray@dol.lps.state.nj.usRichard Webster, Esq.*Rutgers Environmental Law Clinic 123 Washington Street Newark, NJ 07102-5695 rwebster@kinoy.rutgers.edu/RA/
Steven C. HamrickCounsel for NRC Staff