ML19303D345: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
Line 26: Line 26:
On September 2, 1986, Brazos filed its responses to Staff's inquiries relating to new activities and present circumstances. Brazos served copies of its comments on representatives of each of its co-applicants, as indicated on the certificate of service.          In addition, Brazos has forwarded its comments to CASE, the intervenor active in the Operating License proceeding. If any other individuals or organizations should be served with copies of Brazos's comments, please inform me by letter or telephone.
On September 2, 1986, Brazos filed its responses to Staff's inquiries relating to new activities and present circumstances. Brazos served copies of its comments on representatives of each of its co-applicants, as indicated on the certificate of service.          In addition, Brazos has forwarded its comments to CASE, the intervenor active in the Operating License proceeding. If any other individuals or organizations should be served with copies of Brazos's comments, please inform me by letter or telephone.
Additionally, Brazos has discovered that the letter of July 7, 1986 labeled as Exhibit All to its comments was included in error--that letter is a draft that differs somewhat from the actual letter sent nine days later. Six copies of the correct Exhibit All are enclosed, and copies are being forwarded to all parties served with Brazos's comments.
Additionally, Brazos has discovered that the letter of July 7, 1986 labeled as Exhibit All to its comments was included in error--that letter is a draft that differs somewhat from the actual letter sent nine days later. Six copies of the correct Exhibit All are enclosed, and copies are being forwarded to all parties served with Brazos's comments.
Sincerely yours,
Sincerely yours, Ben Finkelstein Counsel for Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.
                                                                        .
Ben Finkelstein Counsel for Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.
cc: Mr. William G. Counsil Robert Wooldridge, Esq.
cc: Mr. William G. Counsil Robert Wooldridge, Esq.
Blake Tartt, Esq.
Blake Tartt, Esq.
Line 34: Line 32:
tl 8609120133 860'708 PDR ADOCK 0500044$                                                            f' g                        CF
tl 8609120133 860'708 PDR ADOCK 0500044$                                                            f' g                        CF


        -
s; S P I E G'E L & M c D I A R M I D G50 NEW YORK A VE NUE N W GE ORGE sri [GE L PC                  WASH'NGTON D C 20005 4798            JOHN MtCHAE l ADR AGN A ROBE HT C McDiARM'D                                                        JOSE PH VAN E ATON b#      # # b      '                                                                        " '
s; S P I E G'E L & M c D I A R M I D G50 NEW YORK A VE NUE N W GE ORGE sri [GE L PC                  WASH'NGTON D C 20005 4798            JOHN MtCHAE l ADR AGN A ROBE HT C McDiARM'D                                                        JOSE PH VAN E ATON b#      # # b      '                                                                        " '
TE LEPHONE (2O21879-4000            PA TRIC2A E ST ACM ODBE RT A JABLON s,yte N HopwooD                        TELECOP'ER (2027 879 4001          P DAN +E L BRUNER ALAN J HOTH                                                                SCOT 1M STRAUSS FRANCESE FRANCl$                                                            NANCY [ W7EGERS DAN +E L i david $CN                                                        BE N FINVELSTEIN
TE LEPHONE (2O21879-4000            PA TRIC2A E ST ACM ODBE RT A JABLON s,yte N HopwooD                        TELECOP'ER (2027 879 4001          P DAN +E L BRUNER ALAN J HOTH                                                                SCOT 1M STRAUSS FRANCESE FRANCl$                                                            NANCY [ W7EGERS DAN +E L i david $CN                                                        BE N FINVELSTEIN
Line 49: Line 46:
William H. Burchette, Esq.
William H. Burchette, Esq.


                                                                                                          .
4
        .
     .                                S PIEG EL & McDI A R MID (350 NE w YOr<M AVE NUE N W GE ORGE SME G[ L PC                      WASH,NGTON DC 2QQQ$.479g              JC5HN MICF AEL ADRAGNA R3bE RT C MCDI ARM'D                                                          JOSE PH VAu E A T ON LANDPAs STREBEL                                                                STEPHE.N C NICHOwS p            g7g RDBE RT A s A BL ON                                                            PATRICi A E 5' ACK sAMES N HORwoOD                            T ELECOP'ER 12O2 r 879 4001        ,onmiEtsuc%ts ALANJ ROTH                                                                    SCOTT H STRAuS5 8RANCESE FRANCl$                                                              NANCY E wtEGERS CANIEL i Dav'DSON                                                              BEN F INKE t eTElu THOMAS N Mc HUGH    .s R                                                      DO%LD WElGHTMAN DANTE L CUTTM AN                                                              SCOTT HEMPLtNG PETEErw MATT                                                                  M ARGARET A Mc GOLDR C#
* 4
     .                                S PIEG EL & McDI A R MID (350 NE w YOr<M AVE NUE N W GE ORGE SME G[ L PC                      WASH,NGTON DC 2QQQ$.479g              JC5HN MICF AEL ADRAGNA R3bE RT C MCDI ARM'D                                                          JOSE PH VAu E A T ON LANDPAs STREBEL                                                                STEPHE.N C NICHOwS p            g7g RDBE RT A s A BL ON                                                            PATRICi A E 5' ACK sAMES N HORwoOD                            T ELECOP'ER 12O2 r 879 4001        ,onmiEtsuc%ts ALANJ ROTH                                                                    SCOTT H STRAuS5 8RANCESE FRANCl$                                                              NANCY E wtEGERS CANIEL i Dav'DSON                                                              BEN F INKE t eTElu
                                                                                                -
THOMAS N Mc HUGH    .s R                                                      DO%LD WElGHTMAN DANTE L CUTTM AN                                                              SCOTT HEMPLtNG PETEErw MATT                                                                  M ARGARET A Mc GOLDR C#
DAytD R STRAUS                                                                DANIEL J SCHNEE HONNiE S BtAtR                                                                BARRARA 5 ESB'N HOMAS C TRAUGE R JOHN J CORE'E T T Cm H. A s B- AD GARVJ LEWE L L Septenber          8. 1986 M o RC R posRiE R Mrs. Juanita Ellis President, CASE 1426 S. Polk Street Dallas, Texas 75221 Anthony Z. Roisman, ".s g .
DAytD R STRAUS                                                                DANIEL J SCHNEE HONNiE S BtAtR                                                                BARRARA 5 ESB'N HOMAS C TRAUGE R JOHN J CORE'E T T Cm H. A s B- AD GARVJ LEWE L L Septenber          8. 1986 M o RC R posRiE R Mrs. Juanita Ellis President, CASE 1426 S. Polk Street Dallas, Texas 75221 Anthony Z. Roisman, ".s g .
Trial Lawyers for Public Justice 2000 P Street, N.W., Suite 611 Washington, D.C.          20036 Re:      Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Unit 1, Docket No. 50-445A; Antitrust Operating License Review; Responses to Regulatory Guide 9.3
Trial Lawyers for Public Justice 2000 P Street, N.W., Suite 611 Washington, D.C.          20036 Re:      Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Unit 1, Docket No. 50-445A; Antitrust Operating License Review; Responses to Regulatory Guide 9.3
Line 62: Line 55:
I have been informed that CASE was provided, by Mr.
I have been informed that CASE was provided, by Mr.
Wooldridge's office, with a copy of TUEC's responses to NRC Staff inquiries concerning new activities and present circumstances relating to the NRC's antitrust review obligations. I am forwarding to you the comments filed by Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc., as co-applicant, in response to the same Staff inquiry.
Wooldridge's office, with a copy of TUEC's responses to NRC Staff inquiries concerning new activities and present circumstances relating to the NRC's antitrust review obligations. I am forwarding to you the comments filed by Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc., as co-applicant, in response to the same Staff inquiry.
Sincerely yours,
Sincerely yours, Ben Finkelstein Counsel for Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.
                                                      &
Ben Finkelstein Counsel for Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.
enclosure cc: Robert A. Wooldridge, Esq.
enclosure cc: Robert A. Wooldridge, Esq.
Blake Tartt, Esq.
Blake Tartt, Esq.
William H. Burchette, Esq.
William H. Burchette, Esq.


  .          .,
                ,
                                                                         .,u ,.. c ....E.      s o ~,                                u.x .. . s . . . . , ,
                                                                         .,u ,.. c ....E.      s o ~,                                u.x .. . s . . . . , ,
  .
o.c.o ..~ su ,,...,. .. ,,.
o.c.o ..~ su ,,...,. .. ,,.
Y~
Y~
      ,
                                                                                 ~7h The Brazos System Brazos Electric Power Cooperative,Inc.
                                                                                 ~7h The Brazos System Brazos Electric Power Cooperative,Inc.
RICHARD E. McCAsKILL EXECUTIVE YlCE P ESOENT July 16, 1986 AND GENERAL MANAGER Mr. John W. Beck Vice President Texas Utilities Generating Company Skyway Tower 400 North Olive Street, L.B. 81 Dallas, Texas 75201
RICHARD E. McCAsKILL EXECUTIVE YlCE P ESOENT July 16, 1986 AND GENERAL MANAGER Mr. John W. Beck Vice President Texas Utilities Generating Company Skyway Tower 400 North Olive Street, L.B. 81 Dallas, Texas 75201
Line 82: Line 69:


We have received your July 14, 1986 letter, concerning the NRC antitrust review. We shall follow your suggestion that we respond directly to the
We have received your July 14, 1986 letter, concerning the NRC antitrust review. We shall follow your suggestion that we respond directly to the
,
(                  NRC.        In this context, I note that Section 20 of our Joint Ownership Agree-ment for Qmanche Peak restricts our ability to transmit power and energy in interstate commerce. Similar language is found in other contracts with your company. I am advised by our counsel that Section 20, and similar pro-visions in other contracts, restrain trade through their effect of restrict-ing Brazos to buying and selling within the ERCOT area of Texas.
(                  NRC.        In this context, I note that Section 20 of our Joint Ownership Agree-ment for Qmanche Peak restricts our ability to transmit power and energy in interstate commerce. Similar language is found in other contracts with your company. I am advised by our counsel that Section 20, and similar pro-
            ,
visions in other contracts, restrain trade through their effect of restrict-ing Brazos to buying and selling within the ERCOT area of Texas.
Two simple examples point up the difficulty that Section 20 brings:
Two simple examples point up the difficulty that Section 20 brings:
: 1.      If Comanche Peak continues to be delayed (and we are forced to retain our ownership share), we cannot practically replace such deficient power and energy from economical power supply sources outside of ERCOT.
: 1.      If Comanche Peak continues to be delayed (and we are forced to retain our ownership share), we cannot practically replace such deficient power and energy from economical power supply sources outside of ERCOT.
Line 92: Line 76:
We therefore, request that we be released from such " interstate" clauses.
We therefore, request that we be released from such " interstate" clauses.
Since your response is necessary to respond to the NRC antitrust review, I t
Since your response is necessary to respond to the NRC antitrust review, I t
* t'
t'
                     .... ...... ........        ...-a er v a c se get ..' 9 0c  De.er%JC f A 171 7 A7-7%fi t # (*.F94FRAL OFFICE 240d LasALLE AVENUE
                     .... ...... ........        ...-a er v a c se get ..' 9 0c  De.er%JC f A 171 7 A7-7%fi t # (*.F94FRAL OFFICE 240d LasALLE AVENUE


  ',.,',-
/
/
        .
(
(
(
(
Mr. John W. Beck Page 2, 7/16/86
Mr. John W. Beck Page 2, 7/16/86 would appreciate an early reply.
                .
would appreciate an early reply.
Very truly yours,
Very truly yours,
                      '
($
($
ichard E. McCaskill "ZM/1w
ichard E. McCaskill "ZM/1w cc:  Mr. J. S. Farrington, Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Texas Utilities Electric Conpany Mr. Michael D. Spence, Division President
            .
(              Texas Utilities Generating Company Mr. Frank Bennett, Director Southeast Area - Electric Rural Electrification Administration Mr. John H. Butts, Manager Tex-La Electric Cooperative of Texas, Inc.
cc:  Mr. J. S. Farrington, Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Texas Utilities Electric Conpany Mr. Michael D. Spence, Division President
Mr. Ed Wagoner, General Manager Texas Municipal Power Agency t
(              Texas Utilities Generating Company Mr. Frank Bennett, Director
          -
Southeast Area - Electric Rural Electrification Administration
* Mr. John H. Butts, Manager Tex-La Electric Cooperative of Texas, Inc.
Mr. Ed Wagoner, General Manager Texas Municipal Power Agency
                                  .-
                                                      $
                                !
t
     ..}}
     ..}}

Latest revision as of 13:14, 1 February 2020

Requests Info on Whether Addl Individuals/Organizations Should Be Served W/Brazos 860902 Responses to NRC Inquiries Re New Activities.Brazos 860707 Ltr Labeled Exhibit A11 Included in Error,Due to Draft Status
ML19303D345
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 09/08/1986
From: Finkelstein B
BRAZOS ELECTRIC POWER COOPERATIVE, INC., SPIEGEL & MCDIARMID
To: Funches J
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
RTR-REGGD-09.003, RTR-REGGD-9.003 A, NUDOCS 8609120133
Download: ML19303D345 (5)
v • d • e


Text

-

S P I E G E L & Mc D I A It M I I)

L350 NE W YORK AVENUE. N W GE ORGE SmE GE L PC A ASH'NGTON D C 20005-4798 JOHN MICHAEL ADRAGNA HDDE RT C McD'AHMID JOSE PH VAN E A?ON

$$NDDA J s'HE DE L STE PHEN C NtCHOLS T E L E PHONE (202) 879 4000 PATRICIA E ST ACM y g TE EECOPf E R :202 679 4001 P DANTE L BRUNE R A6AN J HO T H SCOTT H STRAUSS FHANCESE I RANCIS NANCY E WIE GE RS DA N :EL 6 D A v lD50N BEN F INeELSTE tN THDMAS N McHUGH J4 DONALD WElGHTMAN DANIE L GUTTMAN SCOTT HE MPL tNG f'E T E R K MATT MARGARET A McGOL DmCF david H STHAUS DANIEL J SCHNEE HONMtE b BLA:R BARB ARA S E SB'N THOMASC T RAUGE R JOHN J CORDETT cvNi- s Bcw AD September 8, 1986 GAuv J NE WE t t M ARC u Porn *E k Mr. Jesse L. Funches, Director Planning and Program Analysis Staff Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Re: Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Unit 1, Docket No. 50-445A; Antitrust Operating License Review; Responses to Regulatory Guide 9.3

Dear Mr. Funches:

On September 2, 1986, Brazos filed its responses to Staff's inquiries relating to new activities and present circumstances. Brazos served copies of its comments on representatives of each of its co-applicants, as indicated on the certificate of service. In addition, Brazos has forwarded its comments to CASE, the intervenor active in the Operating License proceeding. If any other individuals or organizations should be served with copies of Brazos's comments, please inform me by letter or telephone.

Additionally, Brazos has discovered that the letter of July 7, 1986 labeled as Exhibit All to its comments was included in error--that letter is a draft that differs somewhat from the actual letter sent nine days later. Six copies of the correct Exhibit All are enclosed, and copies are being forwarded to all parties served with Brazos's comments.

Sincerely yours, Ben Finkelstein Counsel for Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.

cc: Mr. William G. Counsil Robert Wooldridge, Esq.

Blake Tartt, Esq.

William H. Burchette, Esq.

tl 8609120133 860'708 PDR ADOCK 0500044$ f' g CF

s; S P I E G'E L & M c D I A R M I D G50 NEW YORK A VE NUE N W GE ORGE sri [GE L PC WASH'NGTON D C 20005 4798 JOHN MtCHAE l ADR AGN A ROBE HT C McDiARM'D JOSE PH VAN E ATON b# # # b ' " '

TE LEPHONE (2O21879-4000 PA TRIC2A E ST ACM ODBE RT A JABLON s,yte N HopwooD TELECOP'ER (2027 879 4001 P DAN +E L BRUNER ALAN J HOTH SCOT 1M STRAUSS FRANCESE FRANCl$ NANCY [ W7EGERS DAN +E L i david $CN BE N FINVELSTEIN

' HOM AS N Mc HvGH JA DONALD WEiGHTMAN DAN.[ L GUTT MAN SCOTT HEMPt iNG Pt it R n MATT M ARGARE T A M c GOL DR 'C W pav:D R S'RAUS D NIEL J SCHNEE BONN;E 5 DL air 84 BARA 5 E EB'N THOMASC TRAUGER sOHN J CGRBE TT c ~ ~As e moR^o GARv s NL WE LL September 8, 1986 MARC R 52Or pf[ R Mrs. Juanita Ellis President, CASE 1426 S. Polk Street Dallas, Texas 75224 Anthony Z. Roisman, Esq.

Trial Lawyers for Public Justice 2000 P Street, N.W., Suite 611 Washington, D.C. 20036 Re: Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Unit 1, Docket No. 50-445A; Antitrust Operating License Review; Responses to Regulatory Guide 9.3

Dear Mrs. Ellis and Mr. Roisman:

I have been informed that CASE was provided, by Mr.

Wooldridge's office, with a copy of TUEC's responses to NRC Staff inquiries concerning new activities and present circumstances relating to the NRC's antitrust review obligations. I am forwarding to you the comments filed by Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc., as co-applicant, in response to the same Staff inquiry.

Sincerely yours, Ben Finkelstein Counsel for Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.

enclosure cc: Robert A. Wooldridge, Esq.

Blake Tartt, Esq.

William H. Burchette, Esq.

4

. S PIEG EL & McDI A R MID (350 NE w YOr<M AVE NUE N W GE ORGE SME G[ L PC WASH,NGTON DC 2QQQ$.479g JC5HN MICF AEL ADRAGNA R3bE RT C MCDI ARM'D JOSE PH VAu E A T ON LANDPAs STREBEL STEPHE.N C NICHOwS p g7g RDBE RT A s A BL ON PATRICi A E 5' ACK sAMES N HORwoOD T ELECOP'ER 12O2 r 879 4001 ,onmiEtsuc%ts ALANJ ROTH SCOTT H STRAuS5 8RANCESE FRANCl$ NANCY E wtEGERS CANIEL i Dav'DSON BEN F INKE t eTElu THOMAS N Mc HUGH .s R DO%LD WElGHTMAN DANTE L CUTTM AN SCOTT HEMPLtNG PETEErw MATT M ARGARET A Mc GOLDR C#

DAytD R STRAUS DANIEL J SCHNEE HONNiE S BtAtR BARRARA 5 ESB'N HOMAS C TRAUGE R JOHN J CORE'E T T Cm H. A s B- AD GARVJ LEWE L L Septenber 8. 1986 M o RC R posRiE R Mrs. Juanita Ellis President, CASE 1426 S. Polk Street Dallas, Texas 75221 Anthony Z. Roisman, ".s g .

Trial Lawyers for Public Justice 2000 P Street, N.W., Suite 611 Washington, D.C. 20036 Re: Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Unit 1, Docket No. 50-445A; Antitrust Operating License Review; Responses to Regulatory Guide 9.3

Dear Mrs. Ellis and Mr Roisman:

I have been informed that CASE was provided, by Mr.

Wooldridge's office, with a copy of TUEC's responses to NRC Staff inquiries concerning new activities and present circumstances relating to the NRC's antitrust review obligations. I am forwarding to you the comments filed by Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc., as co-applicant, in response to the same Staff inquiry.

Sincerely yours, Ben Finkelstein Counsel for Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.

enclosure cc: Robert A. Wooldridge, Esq.

Blake Tartt, Esq.

William H. Burchette, Esq.

.,u ,.. c ....E. s o ~, u.x .. . s . . . . , ,

o.c.o ..~ su ,,...,. .. ,,.

Y~

~7h The Brazos System Brazos Electric Power Cooperative,Inc.

RICHARD E. McCAsKILL EXECUTIVE YlCE P ESOENT July 16, 1986 AND GENERAL MANAGER Mr. John W. Beck Vice President Texas Utilities Generating Company Skyway Tower 400 North Olive Street, L.B. 81 Dallas, Texas 75201

Dear John:

We have received your July 14, 1986 letter, concerning the NRC antitrust review. We shall follow your suggestion that we respond directly to the

( NRC. In this context, I note that Section 20 of our Joint Ownership Agree-ment for Qmanche Peak restricts our ability to transmit power and energy in interstate commerce. Similar language is found in other contracts with your company. I am advised by our counsel that Section 20, and similar pro-visions in other contracts, restrain trade through their effect of restrict-ing Brazos to buying and selling within the ERCOT area of Texas.

Two simple examples point up the difficulty that Section 20 brings:

1. If Comanche Peak continues to be delayed (and we are forced to retain our ownership share), we cannot practically replace such deficient power and energy from economical power supply sources outside of ERCOT.
2. Brazos has made application for 7.5 MW of non-ERCOT SWPA power.

The value to us of such power is greatly reduced because of our inability to have normal A.C. transmission of such power.

We therefore, request that we be released from such " interstate" clauses.

Since your response is necessary to respond to the NRC antitrust review, I t

t'

.... ...... ........ ...-a er v a c se get ..' 9 0c De.er%JC f A 171 7 A7-7%fi t # (*.F94FRAL OFFICE 240d LasALLE AVENUE

/

(

(

Mr. John W. Beck Page 2, 7/16/86 would appreciate an early reply.

Very truly yours,

($

ichard E. McCaskill "ZM/1w cc: Mr. J. S. Farrington, Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Texas Utilities Electric Conpany Mr. Michael D. Spence, Division President

( Texas Utilities Generating Company Mr. Frank Bennett, Director Southeast Area - Electric Rural Electrification Administration Mr. John H. Butts, Manager Tex-La Electric Cooperative of Texas, Inc.

Mr. Ed Wagoner, General Manager Texas Municipal Power Agency t

..

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19303D345&oldid=2374502"