ML20246K378
| ML20246K378 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 05/22/1989 |
| From: | Colapinto D KOHN, KOHN & COLAPINTO, P.C. (FORMERLY KOHN & ASSOCIA |
| To: | Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM) |
| References | |
| FOIA-89-47, FOIA-89-52 NUDOCS 8909050452 | |
| Download: ML20246K378 (15) | |
Text
m
'b.
~~~
+ ~ )HN, KOHN & COLAPINToe n
3l ..
ATIORNEYS ATLAW 526 U STREET, NW . WASHmGTON, DC 20001 202 234 4663 OF COUNSEL-h0 Cam.D.Kolm - DANIEL 1.OSHTRY STEPHEN M.KOHN
- ANNETTE R. KRONSTADT
' DAVlD K.COIAPlh% *
- ADMrntD N PA
. . ADMrnID DOO :
ADMrnto m oc May 22, 1989 Donnie H.-Grinsely Director
' Division of Freedom of Information and Publications Services Office of Administration U.S.. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Re: Fee: Waivers for FOIA-89-4 7 and 89-52
Dear Mr. Grimsely:
I-am writing to inquire about the status of the NRC's determination of pending fee waiver I have reguests received no for the above-response to my referenced FOIA letter of March 30, 1989 requests. in which I detailed the reasons supporting the granting of these fee waivers.
- Since my-letter of March 30th much concerning the subject matter of the above-referenced FOIA requests has happened to strengthen the arguments in favor of fee waivers. For example, inter alla:
-On May 1, 1989 Mr. Macktal was granted (1) intervention status by the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in the case of Citizens for Fair Utility Regulation _v. U.S. Nuclear
~
Regulatory Commission, et a l ._ , No. 89-4124; 1989 the U.S. Senate Nuclear Regulation (2) On May 4, held hearings to publicly examine- the Subcommittee
[
legal and policy implications of settlement agreements at Comanche Peak, including the Macktal and July 1988 4 agreements; and l '_
(3) The labor NRC notified all licensees to assure that "any agreements or other agreement affecting compensation terms, conditions and privileges of employment..." do not include "...any restrictions on employees or former employees See,providing information Letter from Victor to any members of the NRC..." 1989.
Stello to all NRC licensees dated April 28, l
l L
hok90fhjj2890522 l COLAPI NTB9-47 PDR
~ _- . _ _
t
- Donnie H. Grimsley May 22, 1989 Page Two In addition to the Senate's inquiry, both the Macktal and and July 1988 Comanche Peak settlements have received Enclosed are public exposure through the national media.
some of the press clips and Senator Breaux's press releasesIt is obvious th regarding benefit thesefrom greatly matters.
the information requested, that a significant portion of the public is interested in thesubjec disseminate the information to the public at large and to the Senate subcommittee which is continuing its investigation of this matter.
I lock forward to your prompt determination of the above-referenced fee waiver requests. In the event of an agency denial of these requests or the failure to responddays within ten (10) actions.
Respectfully, f p/ - W David K. Colapinto Encl.
- ~ - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _
7 t
l.
LIST OF ATTACHMENTS
- 1. April 18, 1989 Press Release of Senator John Breaux;
- 2. April 20, 1989 Press Release of Senator John Breaux; May 3, 1989 Philadelphia _ Inquirer, " Workers Paid j
3.
Not to Testify";
1989 New York Times, "N.R.C. Bars Paying
- 4. May 4, Whistle-Blowers for Silence";
May 4, 1989 Washington Post, "NRC KncW of Whistle-5.
Blower Paynent".
1 i
l l
l l
L__ _--- -- )
m ev- - - - ._,
V8(YF O,iM MD \\
(t2 48)
- ***g c
S STATEMENT OF ESTIMATED FEES FOR FO!A- 77-fz. l DAT E FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST I,% Y , FEB 1 s nn NRC CONT ACT 1ELLPHONE REQUESTE R
~ hp # Sh g, .
r #
i Pursuant to the NRC's regulations,10 CF R 9.43. 52 FR 49350,the NRC notifies a requester when estimated applica exceed $25.00 or a limit stated in an FOIA reget. The estimated fees for processing your FOIA eequest are note wish to re scope your request to reduce fees, you may telephone the NRC contact identified above to discuss re-sco Otherwise, please provide a written response on required action noted below. If the NRC does not receive notice fr i
re 4 coping your request or the recuired written response within 20 days from the date of this notice, the NRC will pr you have no further interest in NRC processing your request and will close the file on your request.
EST*1 MATED FEES l
SEARCH $ j Jg -
/k
[
REVIEW $ g if $ f / p ) g h & f g n DUPLICATION * $ j' g / , g [ ,g g gj
/
l TOTAL $ g7 2p
' Duplication estimate is based on the assumption t'at you want copies of disclosed records mailed directly to you the NRC will make dhelosed records avanabte at the NRC Public Document Room. Washington. D.C. or at a Local Public Document Room for inspection free of charge and copying at fees charged at those tocations.Ptease note your prefer i the Response section below.
I Please note the comments provided on the attached NRC Form 509A.
l l
1 For fee purposes,the NRC has aggregated the multiple requests identified above under the presumption that the r I records could have been the subject of a sirfe reouest.
Your request for a waiver or reduction of fees does not provide sufficient information under 10 CF R 9.41 for the NRC make a determination to aaive or reduce fees. If you want the NRC to consider this matter further, picase submit a wri
[ recuest pursuant to 10 CF R 9.41 within 10 working days from the receipt of this notice.
REOUIRED ACTION Picase agree in writing to pay fees as hip" as estimated by signing and dating the Response section of this form a the form to the NRC contact identified aco.e at the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.,20555 20 days from the date of.this notice.
Please provide an advance rayment of tre estimated fees by submitting a check made payable to the U.S. Nuclea Commission within 20 days from the date of this notice. Mail the check to the NRC contact identified above, U.S. N Regulatory Commission, Washington. D C.20555. Any overpayment of fees will be refunded to you.
SIGNATUR CHIE F, F Ot A f DR BRANCH lOATE L AM '7/7
RESPONSE
As required above, I agree to pay fees as high as estimated, or enclose ad6ance payment. I agree to pay estimate if the NRC conducts an unsuccessful search for responsive records or determines records located are exempt from disclos I prefer that copics of disclosed records be provided as stated below.
~~
PLACED IN THE NRC PLACED IN THE LOCAL MAILED TO ME BY THE PUBLIC DOCUMENT ROOM
_ FOIA/LPDR BRANCH '! PUBLIC DOCUMENT ROOM _
SIGNATURE I'OlA Fit 0ULST ER lDAtE NHC FOnM f,09 t 2 889 i
c -- - _- __ ____ - _ _ _ _____
( REOUEST ND.
i Nc U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY CO( llCN ,
n:4.eORusos g '
FOIA-fryP. '/7 3
p \ STATEMENT OF EST! MATED FEES FOR DATE i FREFDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST s
FEB 101989
. '.... i NRC CON T ACT TE LEPHONE REQUESTER ,
k Pursuant to the NRC'sVregulations,10 CFR 9.40,52 F R 49350, the NRC notifies a re' quester when estimated ap exceed $25.00 or a limit stated in an FOIA request. The estimated fees for processing your FOlA request are noted below. If you wish to re scope your request to reduce fees, yots may telephone the NRC contact identified above to discuss re scoping the request Otherwise, please provide a written response on required action noted below. If the NRC does not receive notice from you on re. scoping your request or the required written response within 20 days from the date of this notice, the NRC will piesume that
- you have no further interest in NRC processing your request and will cfose the file on your request.
ESTIMATED FEES _
SEARCH $ /g f l/D - j l REVICW $ .
DUPLICATION * '$ j 2 .$( , g7c) - [ j2jg TOTAL $ % /G , @
- Duplication estimate is based on the assumption that you want copies of disclosed records rnailed directly to you, if you prefer, the NRC will make disclosed records available at the NRC Public Document Room, Washington, D.C., or at a Local Public Document Room for inspection free of charge and copying at fees charged at those focations. Please note your preference in the Response section below.
Please note the comments provided on the attached N RC Form 509A.
For fee purposes, the NRC has aggregated the multiple requests identified above under the presumption that the recuested records could have been the subject of a single request.
Your request for a waiver or reduction of fees does not provide sufficient information under 10 CFR 9.41 fur the NRC to make a determination to waive or reduce fees. If you want the NRC to consider this matter further, please submit a written recuest pursuant to 10 CFR 9.41 within 10 working days from the exeipt of this notice.
REQUIRED ACTION Please agree in writing to pay fees as high as estimated by'se;ning and dating the Response section of this form and returning the form to the NRC contact identified abovt at the U.S. Nuc! ear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C.,20555, within 20 days from the date of this notice.
Please provide an advance payment of the estimated fees by submitting a check made payable to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission within 20 days from the date of this notice, V. ail the check to the NRC contact identified above, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C. 20555. Any ove< payment of fees will be refunded to you.
SIGNATU CHIEF, FOt R BRANCH lDATE 3
h /C f
RESPONSE
As required above, I agree to pay fees as high as estimated, or enc!cse advance payrrent. I agree to pay estimated search fees even I if the NRC conducts an unsuccessful search for responsive secords or determines records located are exempt from disclosuie.
1 prefer that copies of dir,ciosed records be provided as stated below.
l -
PLACED IN THE LOCAL PLACED IN THE NRC
) ] MAILED TO ME BY THE PUBLIC DOCUMENT ROOr' PUBl.ic DOCUMENT ACOM l FOIA/LPDR BRANCH ,
e SIGNATURE - FOIA REQUESTER lDATE NRCFoRu 509(12 88)
, y ,_
- y. -
Q Y ijJ O_ML oU .L HJ
_ es.,--
w"i 0.* meum It* t - t=a= FHlDAE $U'TEMBEH 16 19% _.
Comanche Peak Whistle-Blower Accuses Nuclear Watchdogs of SellingHim 0ut By DIANNA Sous Staff Reporter of Tnt w Au.,sTmarT JwpaL In exchange, the citizens group agreed attorneys who represents Mr. Macktal A whistle-blowing foreman at the 19 bil- to dismiss its Comanche Peak challerge now, "From our perspective, this is, per-lion Comanche Pea's nuclear project ha before the Atomk Safety Licensing Boartl. haps, the most critical safety allegation take.n on a new adversary-a well known e!!ectively ending public hearings. Shortly that could ever be raised. Because to group of public interest lawyers that once after, two GAP lawyers resigned calling tempt people with money for an exchange represented him. the settlement co option by the utihty and of not going to the NRC thoroughly unfer-The action of the former electrical fore. against the best interests of the whistle- mines the rp" Story process."
man Joseph Macktal, has ex;csed a deep blowers, some of whom they took with But Ms. Garde counters. "This is about rift at the Gosernment Accountab[lity money not safety." Indeed, in an .Au tf'em as clients.
Project, or CAP. one of the nation's most One such client is Joseph Macktal. The letter, obtained by this newspaper, Mr.
credible nuclear watchdog g'oups. Mr. Macktal's attorneys ask that 1750,000 of the 46 year-old electrical foreman had told the Macktal feels that GAP sold != eut in ex. NRC of concerns that included improper 55.5 milhon whistle-blouer fund be ear-change for a 5%.000 payment from the design and installation of electrical con- marked for two former Comancha Peak plant's contractor-515.000 of which he ad. dults-allegations he claimed led brown & workers specifically-one of If em is Mr.
tmts to auepting himself to setle a Labor Root to retaliate against him. forcing him Macktal. "We intend to sue the utility, athe Department cornplaint. to resign in 1986. Before long, GAP had citizens group). Tony Rotsman and Bt!be GAP, for its part, sugges s that Mr. hel;*d him draw up a complaint under fed- Garde on behalf of any whistle blower who Macktal really wants mort mcney and is cral whistle-blower projections with the is cut out of the fund," says attorney MJ.
new in the hands of some reakr.:s and dis. Labor Department. chael Kohn, Stephen Kchts brother and affected lawyers, who were farced to re. To resolve that labor claim, Brown & the other former GAP lawyer representing sign Irom GAP in July. Either way. "This Mr. Macl@,
is so horrible," says Bilhe P. Garde, a for. Root offered a confidential settlement.
w hich Mr. Macktal made public this week. lost in a uch of the fracas has been an rner GAP attorney who now orks for the As his current attorneys see it, the electri- examination of the merits of new safety organization as a consuhant "I worked too clan was prohibited ! rom " voluntarily" ap concerns Mr. Mackfal says he wants to hard to be the target of this kind of pekring as a witness before the NRC on raise. He says his new concerns include (
thing." Comanche Peak concerns. problems related to electrical wiring and The controversy involves one of the design problems related to back up safety world's biggest and most expensive nu- In an affidavit attached to recent labor systems.
clear plants. which a unit of Texas t*ttlltles Department filings Mr. Macktal says be Meanwhile, a Brown & Roct spokesman Co. has nearly completed on a site 75 m!!es balked at agreeing to suence. But he says says the engineenng and construction con-south of Dallas. The utthty and the prime one of his former attorneys, Anthony Rots.
rnan, who wasn't employed by GAP, told cern can't " account for or comment on contractor, the Brown & Root Inc. unit of any recent safety concerns that Mr. Mack-Haltiburton Co., Dallas, underment an ex- him that the utility or its contractor would tal may now express." Brown & Root a.nd haustive investigation by the Nuclear Reg- " pursue you to the ends of the earth" if a Texas Utilities spokesman note that Mr.
ulatory Commission, which nearly four Mr. Macktal breachea the confidentiality Macktal had the opportunity to air all his years ago took the step of hair g beensing clauses of the agreement. (Under the safeiv concerns before the NRC in cor.fr
.proceedmgs. agreement, if Mr. Macktal discloses the dential safety disclosures.
GAP, now a six attorney, nor. profit or- settlement, Brown & Root has the nght to ganization that Wall Street analysts say recover its $35,000 payrnent, plus interest has the ;rwer to rock utihty stacks, was a and reasonable lawyers fees.)
major f actor in the years of 6elay. In July, Mr.Macktal now says he has broken his GAP,s chent. the Citizens Association for sDerge to air new safety concerns, though Sound Energy, and Texas Utt!ities agreed Mr. Rotsman says the settlement never to a pact in which the citizens group w111 precluded him from going to the NRC. Ad-be given a formal voice in certain safety ditionally, the Labor Department has and oversight activities and will be reim- asked for a copy of the settlement agree-bursed as much as 110 milhan for a variety ment. which Mr. Marktal's current attor-f expenses. including $5.5 nullion to settle neys term the " money for slience agree-claims with whistle-blowers. The money s ment "
disbursement by the cittiens group wi!! be g,ys Stephen Kohntone of the exCAP
" discretionary" and GAP says '41 plans to ask for 5200,0A in expenses, including an hourly lawyer fee "far below market rate."
l l _ ._ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
dat el a l a
iRtaJt oaa bchhosa liDh n cl ee t eiat r s u m o aTwl ,a
, sA gi l r t t nN n if syo s .hnssJ al et n o sr
,t ll s an e e no ca boy t me r.alya ngt ikr t ti
,ae s - , ei l
P' he auE n n toen.w t f h y im de io 1 t s nso eu ne C eu yJ t iz ne e ed .r y p ef o
- d ep n f.hdt a n ,
rP Sipe et va "
$wo 9 t nt e ga h at ei rAl lixd
- a ni u
,a q o wem g hCioxi ehC cf t n iErli d o i f ih . s
- u oh ef C m e s gt t c h ol s l t n
oI s t
t ne t l eul aendepn ,dau ceg smat ni o" n d s 45. i peat f
ae aiHae b h ol t
n , t .
t rtl s a f
o wa lao k t s e n syu auEe h da vo a c
r e c t omps 1
d.
v not o ol oSt sr ia g n u r pS A i
eemni en$r r otsaber iei a r st m en n,g t a
foleet mbn e r shrCt ubg e h r g o ad fih wp
- et c son a h' aCeei a t e o Eothhp ndoen ivn s imo oio **
r inhe t awelat of swi t t s
t re in e n l
t
. er t
e eelm i,sid Nl*f , \ r e 0 Sor n 8 , n d pet t
wld a e nnn S gnb a t t gemasie a ahn a if a o 's sDs oiowe Ae ginis o es9, sap
,rl ol adgt f r is f t sv wtn ie ke i l c p n a kc tub l Oas p oine ape pt omCnt nts u9l r7ln or u o h pi ane e ae ae ncib1Eot icf r eoh nei tyMaG a oli b t 0{ a lplhEPht ockt i l
tett l,o t tl ednd s d ryt - eng. n.ood nmi .t ia t al eoen at iea dst go ehwinisictu wet ,g8 leds t
rrnr u om n7 ce k C
R s. nl eM ae aoo f e Dt omtyl, sy e mf i
r "w r u is ig cbs a a iyj fiRd dnme t
rt a r a r ei9 eeac s N ce se ng vnf vi a ue t a
e d ug es t r sBienet o n lcaf at dsTdy h g
s1 t a hl " .musr M nh he en i a tyt o p& r bi t t oo oi s c eh ee d u cet L gai n 6 gh ji tt a .n a a ag ,s e ue r s hoedyr t ch t lutiadr n n e s, in u ti lent t drgntt ina nt s
v8 nt r n seia a ns we a9isi fo e aegn rpe s .
ot z net c a atnle1 o h dene"n. on e a o "e,esh t
t efi r n agm mv e a th p m niJ a Rwt a mi e ebad o ci sh t bk ga p u e is aBt o da i
yr e ,el et en &aoet tl ar b, usr S r a oi o ar roe8v6 n t
n sntadeg on sdad' e el gpe r ht t ei hievrg t a . thwt s
k il ais e vse s i c dml o o la uf n 9 t
emtn n ddahgt d.i s
i sd ,y a a e 6 a n oe t
a nimmn n e1 e wia h yh anasJ l
Jad h a a n dT t
t ov t wou n l
c s et a m o r sah ho ef swt aft d ioeei rh e9 8
mdprf oe t
ir e gia wec'.a at s e nmPwl a
s lat e nf nb t
nini ir sOmd e t t
uee obr ge B yi g ed wd ec a t
t t o
rl s le ta ep1, xe hsslas5 t
sda
't i e aat iae aa t s cmms ta n r kc e at a ikr2 l
8 9
f 1htk a re pakm t e t nkc ce Vampoowsvt s r et
.eeksa e o e ode To nk ge hne n M aoah t r n. e -n hni To 1
m oT
- e n gh go i p a no I rmReu ao pc&h sN g wih M"ih s't MfJt wf i
, ib ha mMio nt .i .l t
s Mc st 3 , - syn l ri . . yr hU e 1 - t * .e - n e "t,t o yl i i lva oh"eiTt a c h
- t isn ng mil t r gn ca 'n is o
r e ea ora usth t a n a
sar "y okt v c a o"lch t pr E u w tne t e s rb Mhc ca es td n nr na t
d". t t hoie st dc R i
mn eeh e a rw i
l u
l aiMeai"N , nge r
ra r a an n dn mct d w c e imuot. emovag psnko .ms"e istoo o p eR l
d Wmys i
)Ili e a e (aoo lt ru l
iee vh l
etabhc ne e r a"h "
t l
a e t df r e
t hkandn t c et ri r af s"hir i s o O
f aoo amgnsoodedhdti mhe i
un w y "s.n de l
el t oier s oey e e re . s hno t
rMst mma l s ePnt H
. n admge G
(
of ewde rhn e ei el e d r.reI so a tl e nin o r et e c a d"w hs mt l
e s s nT 'm ec nd h
t ,ut dbdo r nb ol a n doic uMa anRro m "wi rn ewt phc en t nCwc oh ne C re r oit i e e s rha e t
.f l ul aant a h l
ia s'uka ardd leak s h m c e M"et io a s , r p I" :. ye s or sh s pe ,t t aea ur rda m e R- uc si ce s le dr nhwf t
t goi A1 .hxe s e iae ecat osn"l aei c c i t T o .
mbenfi al ea e t ao i t
f sh c sa r l
T yC g nca k ,
t r
ediyma Gluc hst n o eae eMruCh af i
is"alu dr cn t t.
s, n t ei e
e EB mo a oani t f n ,i c t ndr T at p y gi h d y '" w gl l lu s m n yd " Ia nt na el e eill it r l ht aea l ,t n M eo e hpn aaisnhnRwEp n npa I
RF ai r l
a Ato ecw wood uf o d ,, thmGb st t D a r t y,teaeuae - ,l ,d s
- el ssti .oal i.st a te y
aarygmty t t r 7 s ani mfe nht ecne tR i whomD ahe s dDhl t nk t t a c ol a yicdrC ni cdt hnun a g0 ir .
eJat e r acnpf a s pa sf n0 F S.ng s nMd - t t
et e rC on muoenMcm e
r cif aho tem5 a ht 8 gh n a i aci5 &
SoC19 nt wlptr 3 .o estd ed ,f
't n oi0, r nUiei k h i y
.atpe honwe c oD O si ys l
mlcPr o
fkdopst.f aetn enn a egie kil oal ada otayrdWrBhlErf dt nroo u
.t eecm$e f
o aay or s s haf , o gfnicsna cehr t
nt ossl,u e ou pi ribn i li ft et e
f lad
.il nrMac ad o owaot n nbe i i s r t pt e ui r sr t heoa kk nao rdUmtbt e r Lin e iah t64 tr e C o cecct ge cr a sFynTiaat ,h pl a n ae 3 ml nW a
y n
t l eh e ctf r "ylehaoJ nn o
re aa as n a o m9 eatMw l t 6 ,nloa,r 8 ip cemon e n e d a f 'l o s a st s oamtnivg8 esmkt iof o po m w,ana e r7wlie sa b s, t t l m mlpw ogshho r 1 n etswrrntk mk9rS oa eC rf s
w ro mnmpwf ye rruoarnca et a9 e i e e
,k au ef mHt r eo beea t
mit c 1 h si nl b ec OoUfJ xsn oCrhhal y rn l
s f e n s, nc m e Mlie a dt r t s e y y a o r Ae wt a seboe uvoJlliv a enn aoof r oa oi prmasmrp e r a C wC EO c hohherrp t pt " PJ cf ojl ct f I ,
e f - l ok eahi
. en la d .ns e
o ht ai t l s xh ct 0 odAd l s
4 p
cos to0 a t "s
a eM,MAi0 ts ex is n 0 f
t ivdo . 1 heinhn og e t da wia e
a r 2 e t e h udsla5 . 0edrisaP nhonnt c0b r ayoo ecn t
w lo a ek ri0 or dt c b ot r nt iz cf eu i eCMee51 a t
c 0. o G w s E el aAl s
xe
- t le coh gl i a t s eCpt da nE 5 n
ehUdmleBw h osC nN eA dp yea i i
r h et t h cr e t z
wt n. n fu nSt m d n, i M o a o osdf . o cTviel s
emct e t iO at n "e ht r
lpcCegs ni oet n s ye r r f na maC C r r e ismie sd n o ho wt nrn aet o bi d e
dl nr t nbaaa i e r t aohcweek0
, amfe nl el c0 y nst a a 0.g nonr iot h Rne y seM e ro l
mT a
r g
e e
i t
ah s u
p i1 hedo-o a
o1 m9 ews t
AerootTsh nlt h aKieesl t t
- - et g
t a
aM5 l
3 5 at r
. apt aeu mh e op(
einac T- s t t t s Dltt eehtam s v o mo oge mo r
r a s a a ooA r . e le r s s S
t t l e hf wd ns e t d se n e
t s
z S.
Uihs go e
s hteb d r pct pestltA ab e e s r oo s n t
n n ani h nep ot r ne ht l r yet a i p C y. tt upy rl b s poz ashy i
t at r
o wlt i xee gat at r e tnhlliC at i t i i h et h r v emf owom.c f r a
a os Wt r
ca s eulaind weg ct h e gE e ayntnnabi t in d sk orf r f o- o.
nsW0n t o el t 1 ar 5 c m hFeo al t
e o
rr e d bi 0 e u 0 soasLahb t
r d E F
r ek r l
ud t
a u 0. reShf e
s2 e1 rf t b1s r nc p r l e rr e eoat detv Ds k
of en nnn c
ah last adaiU pi e a ro vT f
s ge e o
on r
k t ad
( yeoamtadl tik e wowMupwaa l o
yi M ta nu t r eo l
pW e acn iytinw t
e a wtoaic pmwh Mwt b r ok t l
a e U l laahe r e yf r n oo d&d e
t e
P i
nn a ice f s,s T be h T
r lca o w s t gw Y
t c uh mv o nr r. o e si oro toh n i t
leek nt yh a etcc r B'. tc iw
- t l
en c a
t E*
l .
t t
ia r met cp rePrh rh si aas ed udeorhit e pc nwwnya e s ay c o. .nfbca naoh ar erst t
t owl p l m in t m W.iocnynwt f ad I, sf anJ s ihh et rje isocr.
so t vame r+ gah q
ess lpta a l h cynt t e a
i C A t wfo Che ahcih r or "n eniah hr mafl c m'tsbel o andmr r
ess ae h x-E W
- r. st i
M e.
yt e
oa r ri t
a a pe r np n p n l d weoM6 ao v r "no f0 p1h9 heoaa e0 e 8
peray ch c
r t, s ai r c
a
.W met anc 0. os 2. towgc I
t t t t
Aews ne r
o ue5at l J1 n oJRh a eil tie fo pwi is$ s
~
- 4 ,
_ ysen t
1%.'
Md*% g' - Se l 7
8 8
9
~
s m.am : .t r e Js o 1 _
. latt n
, ki
- g 3 ' .
ed 1 _
a e r
e Mrco
' b -
hf m p e
" - e as s
ow t
p e
S.
~
( -
Jeh g .
M. ,t, A . y' -
, l y
r T
Secti:n 1, Page IU Tort Worth Star. Telegram / Tuesday A30, Septemhr 18,1988 T Comanche [From Page11
_ "It's a classie hush-rmney situa-l The Kohn brothers were forced to MNs concems were Mladdnned resign from theirjobs with the Govern- dunng NRC inspections and included tion.* said Stephen Kohn."We feellike in the utility's plans to conect flaws at thiscase willset nationalprecedent.,He ! ment Accountability Project, the a Wash-plant, mgton legal group that represents nu-is the first whistle-blower m the nation clear whisN-blowers and handled Macktal went Public with his con-who hascome forward with proof that Citizens Association s protest of Co.
j such a gag order was m pixe.
Macktat. of Stephenvitie. said he has manche Peak before the Atomic Safety
"[ p and beensing Board. or safety concerns would not solve been unable to find steady wori. since The Gosernment Accountability problems at the plant' hewasescortedfrom hisjobatComan. Project said the Kohn brothers were ,
che Peak, which is under construction At the time. Government Aemunta-fired because they breached Citizens near Glen Rose 45 miles southwest of ! Association's relationship with the bilay Project attorney Billie Garde i
ca' led Macktal,a "very s,gnificant wit-Fort Worth. But he said construction ' Project and filed an unauthorized legal flaws and falsified records be saw be. brief with the lixnsing board, res m pendmg proceedmgs before ,
fore leaving convinced him that the the Atomic Safety and bcensing .
The Kohn brothers since have said Board. That March, a Department of piznt is the worst in the natiort they will help whistle-blowers testify i l#or investigator reported there was Comanche againstComanche Peak and are part of re esidence that Macktalhad been ha-mgtohappen.,
he said. The Peak only way is a diuster a push by Citizens wa t-for Fair Utility Reg. rued because of safety complaints.
$ ulation to reopen the licensing hear. l haI Garde and Roisman appealed on be-a d r li e la i to hf ektal sa,d ha!f of Macktat. On Nov. II.1986, l i he j,o,med Brown &
censing teard-Macktal said he initially agreed to a -
ButGarde said Mackta'd.d not com- Rmt as a journeyman electncian m plain of the settlernent 09td Brown & .
msed settlement because his law-Root delayed payment in December yes wamed him he would base to pay -
1985 and was named a foreman m them 512.000 in fees if he refused to go 1986 - causing him to wor ) that he cQeof a teamofelectricians workmg could not meet Christmas espenses. n the plant,s Unit 11 reactor. abng, BothGarde and a utilay officialsaid lie said he w2s harassed into quitting Macktal said he changed his mind - I the settlement would have prevented after uthnmg safety problems at the w henlawyers delayed etecuting the set.
Macktal from being a wi: ness in plant plant. many of which he later took to tkment. He said Garde warned him licensing hearings but would not have the staff of the NRC. Among the 13 that his decision to reject the offer and kept him from raising new safety ques- c mpt mis listed m documents' filed coose it to reponers was " absolutely tions with the Nuclear Regu!atory yesterday are charges that: sane" according to a partial tran- !
l Commission. a Stainless steel conduit carrying script of the telephone con ersation.
"This is not about sarcty. it's about critical wiring and materials had been Macktal said Roisman, a lawyer for money" Garde said. *l know he was- Tnal Lawyers for Public Justice.
dissatisfied about mone3. Most people contaminated t.nd would conode. ]
damagingthe plant s elenricalsyste9 marned him that TU Electric would file are. in a settlement.- a Plant offr;ials falsified trammg a lawsuit and would " pursue )ou to the . l TU Electric spotesman Kathleen sheets to speed construction and gain ends of the earth."
Miller said Macktal resigned while NRC approval for construction at the being counseled about chronic absen -
plant.
teessm on the job.
a Electrical conduits at the plant Stephen Kohn said he expects the
" Generally, we are nat in the busi-were irnproperly designed and installed U.S. Secretary oflabor to decide with-ness of tryingtodiscourage people from and the equipment made off site by in 10 days whether to overturn Mack- l coming forward with safety allega-vendors was improperly modified at tafs settlement agreement. j tions" she said. .
the site, !
Citizens for fair Utilny Regulation, He said he since has become con- l based in fort Wonh. has asked the NRC to reinstitute licensing hearings cemed that TU Dectric has faiied to i remose Kapton from the plant site.The i that were canceled wh-n the Citizens insulation has been found io explode or j Association dropped its remaining !
safety complaints in a July I settlement catch fire under certain conditions and with TU Dectric. has tren linked to dozens of accidents i The Citicens Association was paid in military and civilian aircraft. Its use !
at Comanche Peak is under review by
$4.s million and pronthed that whistle-special projects inspectors from the ,
blowers would receive as much as 55.5 million to settle their perxfing lawsuits NRC. l Chris Grimes, chief of the NRC's j against the utility. In return. the associ-special projects team monitoring con-ation was assured a five-> car role instruction of Comanche Peak, said managing the plant.
- - - - - - __ _._ -_ ' ' ' ' _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ ' - - - " - - " " ^ - - " - - . _ . _ _ _ _ _ , _ _ _ _
7 - }* _=:==~
Q
= .::=.-, ...
=:Efir~~ W~MN- ThlitEd $tak$ SC110tt FI e as > oos CouutT111 On tieneouglNT AND PV8UC WOM5 WA$H4HG108LDC 306104175.
'taan l:
Contact:
Bob Mann/ Mark Folse
'FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: (202) 224-4623 April 18, 1989 EAK PROBE NUCLEAR REGSen. SUBCOMMITTEE John Lreaux, chairman of the. Senate ISSUES SUBP i aid SASHINGTON Environment Committee's Nuclear Regulation subcomm ttee, investigation into today his subcommittee is conducting an l t agreements at-the legal and policy implications of sett emen l Rose, Texas.
the- Comanche Peak nucicar power plant in .G en The subcommittee . last Friday met in closed session' to issue subpoenas to all the partieshis and attorneys who appear time.
to be involved at Comanche Peak at t facilit/ and f ormer employees appear ify before or-provice Breaux to the ability of those employees to testinformation to said.
oso Breaux said that one major aspect of the investigation the payment m centers around any possible relationship between l by the Texas Utilities Generating Company ofPeak approxima 55.5 million to former e ployees to settle Comanchel l of com power claims and the withdrawasafety in the construction of the C plant. he The subcommittee is also examining the actionhof t l ities Nuclear Regulatory Correission and the res in the licensing proceedings.
have
-These settlement agreements could prove to* Breaux said.
undermined the nuclear regulatory process, ion
-This process relies on complete and accurate informat i pertaining to the safety of nuclear power plants be ng
- provided to the NRC in a timely manner.
The subcommittee has scheduled a hearing for May 4 t l
publicly examine this matter. investigation also includes !
legislation may be necessary. I l
i
)
f
- - - ~ _ _ ~~----- - ^ ^ ^ - - ~ ~ -wm__
t?M'.~=w w ..-.- -
%'.*.L*'ltW"**
'J'. C '..*a~
- O.=MZm
.ui
((g ggg Q { "J ." couumit ou temut.cr up mue %
E l'a Ye M U E E roa WASwatCToot.DC 20S 10-4 t M
Contact:
Bob Mann/ Mark Folsc FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASEL (202) 224-4623 April 20, 1989 BREAUX BLASTS
- INCREDIBLE" NBC RULING ON HON WASHINGTON -- Sen. John Breaux, .. chairman of the U.S.
Senate's Nuclear Regulation subcommittee, criticized a rulin:
~
today by the ' Nuclear Regulatory Commission, withdrawing as *an- its former blessing of. a money-for-silence agreemen significance.*
"Today's ruling by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission denenstrates once again the NRC'shastonishin -
the public as to the proper standardssaid expected Breaux.w en practicing before the Commission, At issue is the validity of an agreement In return for $35,0C:
between aCo whistle blower at Ecse, Texas and a nuclear contractor.the whistle blower dropped his te himself and his attorneys,the contractor and' promised not to testify claim'against before the NRC regarding his concerns about safety at the p plant.
- ., This previously secret agreement came to light after t
- -Tod licensing hearings had been concluded. settlement, but frcm its previous bleesing of the secret all on its legality.
declined to rule at
-I find it incredible that af ter nine kncw whether monthsit is proper of study, for the Commission still does notu:ilities or contractors to pay testify before the' Commission,- Ereaux said.
-This vacillation on such a fundamental question regarding the integrity of the regulatory system demonstra:-:
that the structure of the Commission hes fbecome nuclear a hindr power to public health.and *I safety and the future ointend to move agg Ereaux added.
structure of this agency.-
Breaux is the author of legislation, passed overwhelmingly last year by the Senate, to abolish the n?C l and create the Nucicar Safety Agency governed by anThe bill, which administrator appointed by the president.
vas,not acted upon by the House, will be reintroduced soon.
Breaux will hold hearings on May 4 to take testi2nony from witnesses involved in the agreements who were subpoena.
by his subcommittee last Friday. .
e 4
Wninesday, May 3,1989
- ,e
. me. r Workers paid not -
to testify Pancl: Pacts bar n c tesu m m Panel: 2 agresd~to deal By Robert Burns mx_ s- not to testify to '\,_RC tuittee said yesterday that it had un.
SAFETY, from t.A pearir:g as a witness before the NRC.
covered at least two " silence for. but it said the intent of this prost-money" deals in which Texas raise safety issues with the NRC. the compant nuclear plant workers who raised The notice, which also was sent to - sion was to protectfrom 'the nee safety concerns were paid for agree. D.ucicar plant vendors, was signed by his labor Department complamt it.
' tog not to testify at bcensing hear. \ictor Stello Jr., the commission's mgt cxecutive director for operations. He another forum.
The Senate Environment and Put>
es o r port It said Macktal had empic opportu-ti{structed the c mp nity to provide any safety informa-hc Works subcommittee on rmclear regulation also is insestigatmg at July 31' tion to the NRC before signmg the least one other secret deal between a Subcommittee sources, spcakmg deal.
nuclear-plant contractor and an em. 0"> condition they not be identified Breaux said the Matktal agree.
ployee to determine the frequencv farther, said documents indicated ment,came to hght after the NRC's.
and legahty of such practices. sus that Joseph J. Macktal, a for mer elec. at mic safety and bcensmg board coinmittec sources said trical foreman at the Comanche Peak ended its Comanche Peak h(arings Sen. John B Breaux, the subcom. nuclear station, received 535.000 for II' I' mittee chairman, said such arrange, himself and his attorneys an a Janu.
m(nts held frightenmg imphcations Subcornmittee sources said inc for nuclear safety.
ary 1987 agreement with the plant's panel had documented ano'her case l
builder, Brown & Root. The sources at Cemanche Peakin whirn a worker
' "h turns the hcensmg process mio said the deal barred Mackta! from who bad raised safety cos:cerns re-a sham if witnesses can be paid testtfymg to the NRC regardmg his ceived $30.000 as part of a deal with money to withhold their testimony.- concerns about plant conditions, Gibbs & lbli inc., a contractor at the the IAuisiana Democrat said Macktal conteads in a new com. plant stie. They saio the arrange The panel has scheduled a hormg tomorrow to hear from parties to nne plaint with the Labor Dcrartment "'
that he signed the deal under duress. g
- j f of the Texas agreements and from 13rown & Root in a statement from the NRC about safety issues' '"
Nuclear Pegulatory Commission its !!ouston headquarters, said the At Gibbs & Will headquartsd itn Chairman tendo W. 2cch Jr who payment to Macktal and his a,1or. New York, spckerwomen Debfapy ' -
was not involved Iri the deals. neys was in sett!cment of an carher said she-was no,t familiar wittrmhe , l Breaux has criticized Zech and other con- complaint he made to the labor De, case, and,po compiny'offictiCwas NRC commissioners for not partment that he was forced to quit Immedinley evadable 1e comhgt. , l demning the deals. because he had questioned Brown & ,
The commission has not cumment, The subcommittee also is'liUti.
Ruot's quality Peak, near Glen controls Rose. at Comanche geting a contractor worker %g7 ed publicly on the issue, but in pri- rient involving the' Mi!]storg- .
vate notices to nuclear plant opera-tors last weck,it said operators could The,peyment was meant 1o hmit cleer power station in Watonfo I tigation costs, the company said. Conn the sources said. No Cct$1s, I not make deals with employees that The company acknowledged that in any way restricted their ability to the deal prevented Macktal f rom ap- were prowded. y (See SAFETY on 4 A)
I l
I 1
- ~ ~ - - - _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ - - - - - - - - - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - - - - - . - _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ . , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
- e. a .cn,. e
,,e ta ,,dWer s t nf ndr e s ta t
teehtteb not e e
- .e
. e, se e e p a a tb f m e
ct h w ,, ,d r Wt e t.nt dA t e el ye ew
_d,x,i e
e
,( w ie y , ,, e, e m
cNl I e el s
tge e e
- Rl nv it fl e neP I oe e
t..
. e MaM.dt eenwft ,ht
. ,C d w i M m. et i
. ee ~ m M a ,,
t
- fod.tIhtt i l
,. . r-t.
s.
, mt
, e J, cen e d gttahh esi et.dt e eet i e teh ciein e o e e Mmf ct er r
- s. .~
. oe : n d r t g .c hte tttg o Prt ae s .
t.
e_~
~.bwe e ce . o&aiMet h n,,.
c . ,,
,n n .hd M i hd ,i, sehsem tye rethnmmctlt e n et et e t af fwa.nh e tb t
sc e~.
ee,
~ ora p ., i
, r a eet
, Bd t oMdP.dmv l
e,t eeie 9 e
mD wp . ryt e n
,e ret - c Mn e.e eemM
,. _t,rdnni n e Ae w
, u, fot sea e
r k te rhrtCe et eht gr re od leMnt eeel n
,e s' y a M.et en e ee hu
~d e ir
, e M e ic e md yrH e t r e.,
~.eeid, ,
rM h,nodhce h gte t
,ef r n ce.he f e c a e e ,e , tia, e
n st s e eMemidndl d
s e n of t e at t ft ne e r e o pn.? u 9 ef u,
.~teFd t
r *e tee, se t e r nil e aet e v yi W t t
1me mh iyr r eim e r eT
. h s
- e.mcti rte t Ae ne pr r~r f
- o. ,e Sptoh t
dt eeethf
. ~. dtee n e ,t ee e,i . ,.
ys se yet neiew aHc
. t n ,= T lib
.t e,ple r pHDm.meyw
~rie.,d ee sMyrnea cnP hc.e
- e. er o n ,ed* ,ehebe.gn h
,e
~G t ,n gi
't r _
s en kn nmfo e,n h v
9 .e vo _
8 9
n~ r e s yw yd d bt e h o=e 3 hAs _
n, a
betne,r ut nec Gwsho 1
~
o e.fte. gt e ,em n y de r ,
n.i*wi,t e
~ n.. m, w .e . ec . m l 9 4. e
_ , em., n . n si eth a. _
Y
. yr r ameett r pu3et h ee s(
et r r kM.
, b ,J ehe _
A
- ._ha,emnonoemt ednn,t nmt u e r e
y egocr t
4 f n e t e ee a h tes v t e ~ dce m.n<me.s n art hr d
Y Y, .
,e n r mee, , . b e , d o.t e c. e h e
't w e ,,f r cT ce ee rM A n
s A
,r t
net ei,,
c e. ,, ht r.,t e , v e .s hi h
= ht pet ct e, tteos hl h e,hth e la h ee e,en e. pf o, ,i q f ,. ,e m y n . _
,nere a e l o,
o n s t it Y. = m ci,d.h1tM.d
. w e w (c eoe est mr .
A D
i t
t r
,t e n e m ,3 ere he,ed t.
,e n , t. e d e ,e t r c emh u
,rd e.hette,ets ieo r rf{
rcwt e tr wi,me-
, MsysCateoeDJ S r , i R e _
ery* - t Min to.t a ett e ji e s "tte- c - t ef _
-
- ml r
U Cheet _
e c
- a' e'
- r0 mer e t g rl it
, l t w* 0 he hnaem _
n t
s r ht eo t,
i e s a 0, wb t e
)T.
i a .n '
- c1 9 i m rtht heet me
. r e eh cs ~ e 9d?
r*t t r i
i n l. i * <a ee d yme fe cfestdnftbs iag i ee ,
~ co e O e i t
- *~ rtl.n h n weDd ti~
R n e S
et g4 te , _
o o nim t
e tt demrtniie n
WO Y v s e h
'~Pchr isypt e cn t v w r r*i-e ,-
latta* ~ n&=f0 rt u m n+h e %hmoatsde a
ar$e a _e g
fo n
t it me vet f -
c -
nwm0 e i e s i
u e np m,feo r eet ee .
a.e n cN
- a*
a - ewt t n e e* fir eS w 8 e n n s 6 e$ l "Mt
- n ePsa e ne u r ch- ifohf Y er uei ewtn h. - m _
- a ,,u
.h r t e' s
,ht r e ,e t eet s r nMe t s ie sn' t
r r ne g weee89 e -
s a- ~a as s me hvi atyhr e n m bN b d . t e eev w msa t ' t o r y .
ve r if re e a'Nneteea ah n .
l m M "* bet e' tnrlR'Mltui.nt hd s m h e t p -a B es* ght y t
iat' l c
c J ,
'a ee 9 enaa i is r .t dt8 . trh s re etemI e e, le t veh a
,~
e *y*i* P
- *s C I
n*enwnt e n t e u lvp l
t ad
" d" et ae*
r M' h 'r ee.o 7 Am g
t.
da
- g !etfe e M m .-
mmpo t
- 1) e eCe t h . -
8 d e ei s l,'
= .*-
e' tfole'mht8ma i
l p
t t r c
c
,&ipeiei a er nt t
" yd m o mreet 'R 9tn' e E" e pped t w
? I t
F i e a ,obm8 r ih '* M W n m a e p e n d ._.
W *e ~t ta 'w * ' m f
- cyyl ev
~6 m e v v n p l e r ov e r ew ir ht e 'g A e etalt e g dm+nd ae e c D a ee -yaW' n s "t efeelf ne n yet =
i a yi 3 tn+
lh ,aa dete n nmu Mee r.ht ig teWr e pppvolr p e h e.
- n. em - nirM:mtdyr
- r-e s mmo ce,o ** *rmT o e r
y e e M e. itodet? i n r tdt eC h, A -
foMtuv p A.
N n a n.c
,. i e nohe c v ti-i* eo t . e ni .bp r O s -
P > u.
f e,.,
ee n, u, M.te. e r
e C et ,c t
e v n h. h h re t
e s t
e rel ee -
- t. le tehMea t
sRtt e i
h T, s a Te.nh er e ot t n ir su h't timS er t
l yeee l
r r i be r toreehwmt a e keMn Mepet t f
e a
i V .
v.n.
t e
e yet
- v. e r am si e is m.t e . h
- bC deon
- t l B .J X o w s w tebe te gr ie er pt i
X e m.fd w s e,ef p 9ehr,enf cr et s o e e t s ,. n, h p s el r a X ft re,efeey y t e d, m e e etttp t es C .
ri.hn A e r o,rwglede cer te tdt ei p e, ,, j T. 4 et k L ,e9 ce -
0 C. Mtr .
imeede eer getericwt h dr ef e e , n m,1 lee 9
snee m r eP g e -
s ne yc v
R i t e.v y se le ,emtF . g e *.t.te e ,, e eh g .hc -
t f
e hpt .i,r9ten i e ,ltei y ht ts d ., *,t te ee N ;u , e, te, , oitf y Trerl g
n g,to i
,, SJtm _
If
_ - - eeo e u
o m"lehta h or h
- r s - - - g s ed ib nne n t
sa t nth a su s lo wfin "s, t
t ee nieri ept pv e d Fciot t ul el ativ lpt e yu n qcu me pd o iec me ,
yn e e lue eein "s, )a. hhah t t e kt r o u or r msL e e pt t o
n ef ce o
_ ef ee a
s os n
gt o c a "y bt m gr aeoD c s tf a oh ood f n ps at dm
/ t aa o d r( J t didn i i t sot wne t
my dl l ei s
iMucdmfiymt a
t
.h eegt t oiss n n h r f
nt emvr t np nu
.e eya a ad k pn e a ori emm x
unn .
s yea r
e a c e m
a ah e eg s
un t
s le a a r lt h a l i a e ts b l a r
r i nht t eWsi a h ohetce en u t
t s
t e o b r r lp pa o s e e e t p e to lu g1 1 c
.h k o e"s ii y
t n e".
r s r i b y
P n oh p aigs wtuo n ae t o
eoCst crt"oco yl m eo t eo s r vrn ht e a tl esdh i s lufa et eb ct f e us n e ep aJ r otiCsnia o t r sno yani n sa f sh de .mRdir sm cC k ei d rl o i st ir t
ur st nTt url nmNa s aRv a ta e pn nCoe mol ip a md a ist laavil ne" ec r nS c ou e o h io cmfrMNh m w et l sk ci0. e e a
- , d h -rn x
- r - -
mag dnat otd f o bheera oh e e ,en t
t naoa0t ect o 9
t kc cPb eep p 0. e T h ar l l a t b
yc 8 i t u
ailaht es w$ avh bd hwt rs us0 yu e a r
lak a mrco d ey Bb a2
^ 9 1 o Mt e yee vt ePt t s l f
tc da a egc nil s y s o e r e e o 4, - d t n .h sf a e sw ea pt ai na ets ea x Y
A l
es it n
o brf ymrk n
,foio t
sCtoa ok tea irt c r i e s g
nd. wo o 'l he f sc o
e e ai e nd msh nn ege isirt n
M, a cea t i t
s t e ret n e r m,s Mt aet s ua k fr e o amwta eh s mo t h t
Y s
t u e la 'e e t
qhe eyoi nis -
A f h rhi tvl l lp a Cnte ma D
S i y t mlir s lea get sd not ud wi e s
Em wo ht t .l ef o
R hf t e ot nnr e r ann rt t h s o c cc n i
.l r ta wumnbtoe io aj es t su U at eui iu s ca sl r 0l e a hi toae k s a r ps t b el c
l oa qn0 a m mt y c e gmh i e o Wd i
T eev eeI h r t
c ois a e sa ot hf e rh s oTmo gd s5 a
. 0, a e, C l c xMy on eciTe t t u n
.ee lptmh t
. h iw a r n a n a 1
$ M a, 3 pn t aq rt f i n f
o Cd monoc o
t t net n male re c
a c t
s ea c oa i
etteei
.l -
d ngPn e Rt t
nk eor
, - s s so non a m t
t e
)c I
i0, t
v udhi e nr s eee a w
e n" y
det ns0 s mmnwk i er rd gos o na cr5 r
0, tug n ca n n el iwaGRt hr nspe o c e nl C or g l
deu e3 mme st a o
s t
a a l t
a nw$uh uas neb n r o orNam nh c s nt r e luf ial o got n plb oloie edr to r c s e t cCa pr a enhe epu l
s "e.
s K
e e t l re Ree rd r al es
- f eynt t a e t h t r ab d s
P*
s a
ai r wnl set e n f
ce nv er ont, nk mSceoh ctntie oelet ah a r tpo C le a ao ci c uh s sge u e n toaa a c i mewmec e
CB c s nwin ea run ad lpSt ht a c t
y u a a ya s n e Nw to ha aytog abh na s
a togt i n R mraL n o t
n eg er ct f a I' c dh ee a sle c x erint r Ttecww eot ih a hi cs Tsjewu h g s h e i t o euec . s na "e B N
r ib moinb or ono ah gwbbt el h NTiwa t 6 i - !1
. i ,*
,' '